Classical Musicians React: Oh My Girl 'Windy Day'
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 13 дек 2017
- For the 21st reaction video of the 2nd year of this series, classical music majors react to Oh My Girl's 'Windy Day' MV.
Watch the original MV here: • [MV] OH MY GIRL(오마이걸) ...
~Reaction Schedule:
docs.google.com/document/d/1u...
~ Complete to-react list:
• Playlist
~ Will not react to list: • Will not be reacting to
---------------------
Send us things!
P.O. BOX 14933
ROCHESTER, NY 14614-1119
~Channel instagram: @reacttothek_official
~ Channel twitter: @reacttothek
~ Channel tumblr: / reacttothek
~Support us on patreon and get extra access to videos you’ll never see on YT: / reacttothek
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Video editing by Umu
Intro design by Alex Chen (website: www.acchen.com/)
Thumbnail credit goes to Nozomi Murayama (insta: @nonchanyuzuru)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(PD) Umu:
Instagram: @_emcha_
/ omg-horns
/ bangtan-fanart
/ funny-vixx
(kpop, mamamoo, bts, vixx) Amino app: Umu @ ReacttotheK
(channel manager & assistant editor) Eric:
Twitter: @ricekangaroo
Henry:
instagram: @zappa_yes_floyd_genesis
Twitter: @henry_carpender
Peyton:
Instagram and Twitter: @pjohnzzz
Tumblr: / pjohnzzz
Jarod:
Instagram: @JVLPhotographic
and @Jarod_lau
Katie:
Instagram: @katieknudsvig
Davis:
Instagram: @davisherndon9664
SC: dherndon96
Kevin:
Twitter: @nerdymusicks
RUclips: nerdymusicks
Gwen:
Instagram and Twitter: @gwenpakerr
RUclips: Gwen Paker
Hugo:
Instagram: @hugohumbility
Shimon:
Instagram: @shimonohi
Naoki:
Instagram: @naokitoyomura
Lindsey:
Instagram and twitter: @lamusicstudio
tumblrs: / punk-popsicle
/ double-horn
Fiona:
twitter: @fiona_stout
Insta: @fionaastout
Emiel:
Fb: Emiel De Jaegher
Insta: @trumpetoats
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
*DISCLAIMER: I do not own any of the songs or videos being reacted to in this video. All credits to the companies that own them.
Also, none of us are PROFESSIONAL musicians. So if you come here for a strict breakdown/analysis of the music, you won’t be getting that. This is strictly my conservatory musician friends taking time in their schedule to watch kpop for fun, and throw in any musical comments that come into their mind! Also please do not complain about any "boring" reactions...some of the musicians have blank faces since they are concentrating so deeply on analyzing the music. On top of that, if you think that they aren't commenting enough on the music, it's because /nothing/ is happening IN the music to comment on. It may be a great song/bop/huge hit that they're listening to, but that does not mean there are actual complicated musical things happening that they'd be able to talk about. 
Кино
Whenever Kevin gets on the piano you know its a good reaction
DarkAngelRin yeahhhh
i want his ears :D
oh my girl is SO underrated and windy day is one my favorite songs from them - so happy to finally see this reaction!!!!
ishipthatfishycouple I am curious to what couple your name is referring to.
multífαndσm trαѕh the ship in my profile picture - eunhae 💙
i'm glad they liked it. 😍 it's my fave too and closerrre~
Windy day&closer is their best song💕💕✨
ishipthatfishycouple exactly!!
One of my all-time favorite K-pop songs and music videos.
Oh My Girl is *SO* underrated.
4maybeso not really but yeah underrated,kpoo more know pristin than OMG
4maybeso samee
Yass 😍
not really??? they are SO underrated dude
When it comes to cute groups, OH MY GIRL is exceptional and it's rare for me to get into cute girl groups since I like sexy concepts or krnb / khiphop music genre. OMG have a lot of good music and also AMAZING CHOREOGRAPHY THAT NEVER TIRES ME. I just love watching them perform. I don't know, I find them unique. I can say they are underappreciated but then again not alot of people know them. So they are somewhat underrated too. 😭
I CLICKED AS FAST AS LIGHTNING THIS SONG AND MV ARE LEGENDARY
Clare Abbott OH MY GOD SAME
ikr!!!
Yeah, me too! Too excited for this tbh
Your fingers would have shattered continuing towards your arm. If it was that fast.
Clare Abbott BIG BIG BIG BIG BIG BIG MOOD
i love oh my girl, their concept and sound is always changing and trying out new things but you can still tell that its them
sooyoungfanclub yes that's why I love them so much.
Please also do reaction to ONF's On/Off~~~ (also from WM entertainment)
sooyoungfanclub ikrrr 😭💕
Ikr. They are so versatile. One of the main reasons I love them so much!
중간에 싸비에서 2,3할때 응? 저게뭐지했는데 다음 싸비에서 1,2,3,4하는데 소오름... 전문가는 저런게 바로 들리는구나.. 뭔가 신기하고 재밌넹
옛날엔 자막 없었는데 누가 자막 달아줬네 ㅠㅠㅠ 감사합니다 ㅠㅠ 긍데 이건 음악적 지식이 있어야 번역 가능할듯 ㅠㅠ 대단하십니다 ㅠㅠ 한국어로 읽어도 모르겜ㅅ음ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
소소한 덕후생활 자막 없이 보느라 힘들었는데 다시 들어오니 있네요!! 자막달아주신분 천사님ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
Yessssss, Oh My Girl is so talented and deserve so much more attention!
you know it’s good when kevin goes to the piano
The word "wind('baram 바람' in Korean)" has the symbolic allusion in the Korean culture to "sexual/sensual/romantic escapade." For example, when the Koreans say "She's arousing wind ('바람 피우다 baram piuda' in Korean), they're saying that "She's having an affair," the kind that's out of wedlock, illicit, and therefore usually immoral. It's a strong expression of condemnation usually. And here the song title is "Windy Day." What would that mean for a young girl, not married, in her teens probably, and innocent? The girls are using such a strong word "wind" of social connotation to express the kind of strong romantic arousal they're experiencing, perhaps for the first time in their lives, because of the presence of a heartthrob that they have the crush on. And you saw a glimpse of stag with magnificent horn in the forest. So the day is "windy"! The "Egyptian scale" is thrown in the song musically to express the kind of tingling flutters in your heart of expectation thinking about the guy the heartthrob.
That explains the deers tbh :0 I like that
Wow thanks for explaining the nuance. That's fascinating. It brings a new meaning to the song. Its more mature than i thought
I WAITED THE WHOLE YEAR FOR THIS REACTION!!!!
Rebeca Sally I alwas in your foot tho
thought i was the only boy i was wrong
I've been waiting since they reacted to coloring book, waiting for the Liar Liar M/V.
ME TOO
Rebeca Sally me too... finally!!!!!
They should react to Closer by omg too!!
Marta Monterrubio YES! I love that song too
Marta Monterrubio it was taken out of the reaction schedule and that’s most likely because it was deemed not interesting enough to make a whole video reacting to it.
Which sucks because it’s one of their more popular titles
jelly yeah, unfortunately but we understand how this channel works. so... i get how Umu has to be a little selective w the music.
I think it was taken out of the schedule because most of the reactors heared it on KCON.
I really don't think Closer has much musicality to it that they could react to. It's one of my favorite songs but I don't think they would have much to comment about.
oh my girl serving bops since april 2015
2019년에 보러오신 미라클 손👋🏻
This is my fave OMG song! It's just so musically interesting, plus the choreo is astounding! 😍
제발 closer 리액션해주라 ㅠㅅ ㅠ
Plz, react "closer"
OMG is a really good group. Wish them more success in Korea.
리액투더케이에 드디어 오마이걸이 나오다니 감동 ㅠㅠ
티슈박스 TissueBox 컬러링북도 했었어요!
This comments say something along the lines of “finally they reacted to oh my girl I’m thankful” and the person replied “they did coloring book too!”
티슈박스 TissueBox 영상 잘보고있어요 그나저나 러블리즈는 아무리 기다려도 안나오네 ㅠㅠ
thanks for translated dude :)
자막이 필요해요
4:20 how they just casually harmonized so beautifully
NEVER BEEN THIS EARLY. ANYTHING WHEN OHMYGIRL APPEARS.♥
Katherine Zavala OMG DUDE I FOUND YOU
HOLY CRAP I'VE WAITED SO LONG FOR THIS!
TintedRhythm i have waited for A YEAR!!
+TintedRhythm - I am waiting for them to react to CLOSER as its my favorite song from them and one of my best kpop songs of all time.
I miss JinE ;;
Same...
Same. 😢
me too 😭
I was so happy until i saw this comment 😢
:(
"I hate windy days, they are bad for the hair man"
I FEEL YAA
🤣😂🤣😂
OH MY GIRL MY BABIES I LOVE
일반인들은 뭔말하는지 모르겠는데 저기 영상에선 말이 통하는게 신기ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
내말이옄ㅋㅋㅋ
윈디데이가 갓띵곡인 이유를 잘 설명해주네.. 진짜로 사랑의 세기를 바람의 세기에 대입해서 표현한 노래라는 게 너무 잘 드러남..그리고 영상도 노래에 일치해서 만들어졌고,,윈디데이 진짜 띵곡
우리가 인도풍이라고 하는 후렴을 여기 사람들은 이집트풍이라고 말하네... 신기...
정확히는 인도풍이아니라 아라비안 풍이 맞는것 같아요.. 우리나라 사람들이 아라비안 풍을 인도영화 덕분에 인도풍이라 인식하고 있는것 같아요.
@@monomonomo 맞아요 오마이걸 카레 커버 영상 댓글보면 인도분들 화내고 있음
11:01 the joy on Kevin's face from his "four"eign joke was especially amazing for me because that was the exact moment I realized what his shirt said.
Emiel in that black suit tho! Thanks for react to my precious girls! Its 00.11 a.m here still iam waiting you upload this reaction
I’ve been waiting for this so long!!! Oh My Girl has so much amazing music they deserve all the cred they can get
THEY SHOULD REACT TO ALL OH MY GIRL SONGS
nershheyy 😂i agree
Yessss
뭐야...? 평소에 해외반응 많이봐서 이 채널도 보는데 여기 한국인 댓글 이렇게 많은거 처음임... 낯설다 이게 퀸덤의 효과야...??
I LOVE OH MY GIRL!!!! 💖💖💖
좋아하는 노래인데 확실히 이 노래가 왜 좋은지 설명을 들으니 좋네요.
After waiting the best part of a year for this review (as said below, this song really is /legendary/), it was absolutely worth it. They were so interested and bemused by the chords and passage of the song and I'm so happy. It's one of my absolute favourites and clearly for good reasons. It's catchy, musically interesting, fun... I don't agree that it goes on too long though. I'd need a cut-down version first to test the theory, but it feels fine to me. The bridge and the silence help a lot.
I WANTED THIS AS SOON AS IT CAME OUT IM SO HAPPY RN 😍😍😍❤️❤️❤️🤧😭
Windy Day is the best OMG song. Would rather watch the live performance tho
Yesssssss finally the mv is react worthy that I want 💜💜💜
one of my favorite reaction videos. god knows how many times ive watched this haha. windy day is legendary
FINALLY I'VE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS LIKE FOREVER YOU HAVE NO IDEA
난 팬이면서 진짜 저런것까진 신경 안쓰고 있었는디 오히려 저분들한테 배워간다는...
I've been waiting for this! The first time I heard this song I was like "Cool, this is nice--Wait, what? What just happened?". It had been a while since that happened to me, LOL. I call it the DBSK reaction. I hope ya'll know what I mean XD.
Also, AHHH Gugudan at the end! It's coming!
This a 100x better than other songs of Korea's famous girl group now.
퀸덤보고 흘러흘러 여기까지 왔다;;
I finally get Oh My Girl here again and they don't do Closer? come on now.
I think they won't react to Closer because musically, it is quite basic. There isn't a lot of technical stuff to react to. I don't mean this in a bad way. Closer is, by far, my absolute favourite Oh My Girl song and choreography, but the song itself, however epic, is not musically interesting.
yet they did Taeyeon's I and that is super straightforward and not at all musically complex. They even did all 3 Dreamcatcher songs. They can react to the song itself and how it works, not how much 7th diminished chords or whatever it needs to have.
I know they have a list of requests that are all scheduled. I think they try to stick to that as much as they can. I'm sure a lot more people are requesting though so I'm not sure if they are prioritizing certain reactions, but if Closer was requested a while ago I have a feeling they will get around to it eventually.
The Enygma ikr
Might have been taken off the list because some of reactors saw OMG live at KCON this summer and it would no longer be a reaction from them.
oh my girl is so underrated still internationally but famous in korea now. omg is not your typical gg! their discography is so DIVERSE! the girls versatility is also INSANE! they are on another level! concepts queens indeed!
I love this channel because it makes me go out my comfort zone (musically speaking), I dont think I would have checked this group out if it wasn't for this channel, and I am in love with this song now 😍😍😍
Please do vocalists react to sohyang arirang alone and any other sohyang stuff!
Clare Abbott YESSSS
4:18 That singing of "oooonnneee, twwooooo thrreeee" took me by surprise but it really sounded awesome. o_o You can tell these guys really like music.
으와 완전 분석적이시넹ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 근데 그래서 화음을 더 자세히 듣게되고 좋네욤
ahhhh I have been waiting for more oh my girl for so long!!
Loved the reaction you guys are doing great work keep it up!
oh my girl seriously did such a great job with this song, and the choreo makes it even more amazing!!! i’m so happy my girls got a positive reaction from you guys!! thank you from all us miracles!!!!!
oooh! one of my favourite songs + mvs ever! thank you for this!!!
Yay!! Was waiting for you to show them this! Adore this song.and mv 💕💕
*Please react to OMG closer. Is a winter with strong vocal concept*
this is my most favorite oh my girl’s song. it’s just refreshing to me. ughh 💕 stan them yall! thank you for the reaction!
FINALLY YOU DID THIS. IVE BEEN WAITING LIKE A WHOLE YEAR FOR THIS. THANKYOU SO MUCH. YOU GUYS ARE AWESOME.
Omg.... I love you guys reaction, so technical and a lot of details about actual music theory.
Very unique :D
I'm actually really thankful someone react to the music instead of the Music Video. I just found this page today and I already love your reactions guys.
YES I LOVE SEEING MY GIRLS GETTING LOVED AND APPRECIATED!!!
I'VE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS REACTION!! THANK YOU!!
I love how you mentioned different types of wind were expressed in the song. That's why I appreciate this song so much. The lyrics is also well written
Thankyou so much to react and remember Oh my girl!!
I was waiting for this one as soon as I saw it on your list! So happy that you reacted to Oh My Girl again and I'm looking forward to their comeback in January. Great comments from all the reactors. I didn't realize that the song was so musically complex, so that was really interesting to learn. I also loved that someone else thought of the Harry Potter maze... that box should have totally been a portkey ;)
Oh My Girl is that girl that girl group that I like but haven’t gotten around to stanning them - but I do appreciate them a lot and listen to quite a few of their songs. What am I doing? I should check their variety
PurpleSwils theyre quite active on vlive nowadays, so you can also check them out there. some fans have been subbing their content 😊
PurpleSwils there's this one song that the main vocalist Seunghee did with Sandeul from B1A4 and it sounded absolutely incredible - Companion(?) on Girl Spirit
their vlives are the best
This song makes me so happy every time istg the entire composition is a magical journey~
This was amazing!!! Ive always loved this song and found it so interesting and I love hearing people break it down in terms. I loved the guys who got way into breaking down the music and got on the piano!!!! Are they in other videos? I don't understand all the terms they used but they were so into it I loved watching them.
YES I’ve been waiting for this since I found your channel so long ago!!💜💜💜
STAN TALENT, STAN OH MY GIRL. THEY DESERVE EVERYTHING IN THIS WORLD & THEY’RE NOT RECEIVING WHAT THEY DESERVE. PLEASE LOOK INTO THEM, YOU WON’T REGRET IT 🙏🏻
Windy day is so classically beautiful, it has a special place in my heart
Seing these people really jam to the song makes me so happy. I love you all 😭💘
OHMYGIRL!! Love them. So glad you guys reacted to them ❤❤
These reactions are so intelligent. I feel blessed watching what they say.
this song is a masterpiece im so glad they noticed the amazing chords in this!!
I wish I'm a musician so I can hear what they hear and be so amazed and impressed 😂😂
i love all of your videos. i love the reactors reaction too!! i love all things about this youtube channel. keep making good and fun video!!❤
I've been waiting!! Thanks 🙏🏼
FINALLY IVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS FOR A WHOLE FREAKING YEAR
STAN OH MY GIRL STAN LEGENDS
Oh my girl 🙌
I LOVE THIS SONG AND THESE GIRLS SO MUCH IVE BEEN WAITING FOR SO LONG 😭😭😭😭
This makes me want to see them react to "Love Cherry Motion".
IIgoru1 yeah loona I wish they react to them also.loona song is amazing too
that chordal movement in katie and jarod noticed during the chorus repeated itself during the four lines prior to the "Windy day~ windy day~" portion of the chorus going in A major do, re, mi, fa (instead of fi) and ending on sol into flat 6 for "Windy Day" which i thought was really good modal mixture.
FINALLY YOU GUYS REACTED TO THIS
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR REACTING TO OH MY GIRL!!! This is one of my favorite Kpop songs (and Oh My Girl is my fav girl group)
YES THANK YOU I HAVE WAITED FOR THIS REACTION AND I WAS NOT DISAPPOINTED THANK YOU UMU
Yey, super happy for this reaction! thanks
I WAITED MY WHOLE LIFE FOR THIS OMG I NEVER THOUGHT YOUD DO THIS YES GES YES
I love finding content about Oh My Girl! I really like this song and video :D it’s so interesting watching these videos since I know nothing about music lol
thank you so much for this ;-; oh my girl is really underrated but they're actually my ult group!! 💖
Thanks a lot TT
OH MY GRIL is love ❤
This is the song that got me into Kpop. I’m so happy you guys reacted!
OMG! thank you for reacting to Oh My Girls - Windy Day 😭💓
Kevin is my fav!!! his reactions were totally my reactions to everything!
I LOVE THIS SONG thank you!!
Great reaction guys. Love Kevin's T-shirt. Cheers from the UK.
never heard of this song before. Now I'm a fan!!!
I MISS OH MY GIRL 😭 PLEASE REACT TO THEIR JANUARY COMEBACK TOO. THEY DESERVES TO BE MORE POPULAR
one of my favorite song !!!!!!!! love oh my girl !!!
Dude this song has so many unexpected parts
바람은 살랑살랑거릴수도 난폭할수도 있으니 그런 다양한 장치를 음악에 넣은게 아닐까싶음