Can we encourage migrants out of crowded cities? Australia 2050 (part 3) | 7.30
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 29 май 2024
- Population Minister, Alan Tudge, has signalled the intention to make migrants settle in regional areas for up to five years to try and reduce the squeeze in the cities.
It's not the first time these kind of settlement programs have been attempted.
There are some success stories, but also some vital history lessons for regional areas trying to boost their populations.
For Part 1, click here: • Australia's population...
For Part 2, click here: • Will Australia cope wi...
For more from ABC News, click here: www.abc.net.au/news/
Follow us on Twitter: / abcnews
Like us on Facebook: / abcnews.au
Subscribe to us on RUclips: ab.co/1svxLVE
Follow us on Instagram: / abcnews_au
What kind of jobs? Opening a coffee shop, McDonald's, Kmart in a new suburb won't create wealth. You need a real manufacturing industry that can export overseas.
The third part has been the best so far :).. nice wind farms..
You don't necessarily have to be an exporter to create wealth. You can create things that increase efficiency, and the examples you mentioned are all consumer products, which most certainly can increase the economy by increasing public spending and keeping money in circulation
Good luck getting manufacturers setting up in Australia for the export market. It's impossible to compete with China's lower wages and non existent workplace laws, or health and safety standards.
@@Jwalker76 one way to grow local manufacturing is through increased automation, which could then be exported. However, obviously automated manufacturing doesn't create the number of manufacturing jobs that people quite often want. As an example, the USA actually manufactures more products now than it did 20 or 30 years ago, but with far fewer manufacturing workers. That also doesn't mean automation is a bad thing, as it can reduce the cost of products for consumers, which can then spend more money in other sectors of the economy- growing the number of jobs in non manufacturing sectors
@Johnie2011 yes human rights abusing China is a massive problem for Australian manufacturing. There are other issues all having to do with foreign national monopolies within our market.
We either wait for the giant to be crushed under its own weight, or we topple it along with American and the rest of South East Asia in a New Pacific Theatre.
As well as making regional towns attractive for migrants, why not also make them attractive for existing citizens.
Peter Quinlan good point
cause they want the new money
@@theinventionsofmegsy3137 What new money. Most migrants don't arrive with much, that's why they are coming here, to GET money.
Stop thinking about how to encourage migrants out of crowded cities, think about how to encourage all people living in Australia, no matter local or migrants, out of crowded cities. All human beings want to pursue the same thing - A better life. If regional places are better, people will not hesitate to leave the city. STOP BLAMING MIGRANTS because of the GOVERNMENT'S INCOMPETENCE. We, migrants, are invited by the government. I want to say what is critical is WE NEED MORE PIONEERS. To do so we need more government stimulation. To simply cut the immigration number is not the solution because regional areas will still not be developed. The government always have the right to cut the immigration number, but after inviting all the immigration to Australia to fix the population problem and then blame migrants for the crowded city is irresponsible. Migrants have nothing to blame. They are just like local Australians. Blame your migration policy and please fix it if it went wrong.
Thumbs up
Yes, stop bringing in so many migrants. Get it down to the average that it was in the second half of the last century.
Obviously, the problem we are having now isn't immigration.
Even we stop any migrants coming in right now, major cities are still over crowded.
The plan of developing regional areas with details, announced by the government, should be our solution of over-glowing population. And just like the video said, even though we settle migrants into regional areas, they will still go to the cities. We need to develop those areas in order to make them stay.
I thought Australia is an open, multicultural country, and now look at the comments here. It is filled with white supremacism and patriotism.
The one question no one is asking. Why does our population need to " GROW" There is no shortage of people for jobs. Only a shortage of people willing to do low income jobs. So instead of eliminating these jobs , we import people from 3rd world countries willing to do them. Ain't that the truth!
This is actually a very good question.
Well an good example on why populations need to grow is Japan, they have a strict immigration and low birth rate, and it the government is predicting a huge toll on their economy in, as their economy has been stagnant since the 1990s when their population started to decline.
Aging population means someone needs to care for the elderly, and young people are needed to grow enough food for the existing population, and replace workers that are being aged out of the work force.
When a town needs 6 nurses, and no one is applying for the job, someone has to do it, assuming Australian don't want their government to tell them where to live and what to work, they will have to incentivize those 6 nurses to come in this town.
There is a need to immigrants to sustain economical stability, although it is not the only answer, but since we cannot force people to procreate, something has to give.
Sam Z - We can't overpopulate the Earth. Stagnant populations are inevitable.
I pray to God you never have Children.
Because our public benefits schemes are too costly and require an ever expanding population, or a pyramid shaped demographic structure (not the stable column shape that was naturally forming) to prevent it from collapsing. The real question to ask is; what do we do when the migrants age?? MORE immigration?? This is clearly unsustainable but the current people in power simply couldnt care less about what happens when theyre gone.
@@samz3542 No mate, there is absolutely no skills shortage, thats a pure myth spruiked by the pro migration lobbyists. Mass migration is to keep the property and pension ponzi afloat. See a large proportion of people nearing retirement dont have any retirement savings and there arnt enough tax payers to give them all pensions. So what they did was blow an historic property bubble using low rates, govt incentives and massive amounts of debt to put some money into the old home owners hands, so now theyre cash poor (like they always were) but asset rich, but they need someone to sell the historically overpriced houses too to unlock the equity for their retirements maate. Also mass influx of foreigners keeps wages and bargaining power low in the young workforce. The last thing they want is for all the power to fall into the hands of the young.
To be frank people don’t immigrate here to become farmers
That's because of the type of immigrant we select, which is university educated, qualified, etc. Most illegal Mexicans in America jump the border to become farmers and construction workers.
Australia has to build medium sized cities other than Sydney and Melbourne, and create jobs there so that people can work and live there for long term, which also contributes to the growth of our economy. There are 100 cities in the US and 10-20 cities in Canada, population spreads across different parts of the country rather than concentrating in one or two major cities like what happens here in Australia. Federal government encourages people to relocate to rural towns but where are the jobs and facilities there? Without all that even if you force people to live there for 3-5 years, they will go back to big cities after the period is over. The other way is to build high speed rail to connect small towns to the big cities so that people can cut down travel time by 80% while living 200-300 km away. Cutting down immigration intake is a very negative approach and it won't work for the long term. While Australia reduces immigration intake from 190k to 160k per year, Canada has increase theirs from 330k top 360k per year for the next 5 years.
U R wrong LA & NY (4-8 mill),then 7 other cities (1-3 mill) just like Australia on a smaller scale and Canada's going down the same shit pipe as Europe did! CLOSE THE BORDERS TO ALL UNSKILLED MIGRANTS!
Ice baby why? Just let the population dwindle. Our species is on the verge of eliminating most jobs with AI, why the hell would we want to keep importing people who are likely going to be an unemployed underclass in 15 years
max? The answer is to keep our Ponzi like economy going until the boomers peace out and leave millennials to deal with the horror.
Japan isn’t turning into some dystopian hell hole without immigration and a dropping population.
@Lee McDonald The Coalition getting elected again means a huge amount of lost potential revenue that Labor was going to get from cutting loopholes (the Clive Palmer $1 trillion scare campaign pretending tax RATES would increase to get this revenue).
Medicare and much much more (even further cuts to company tax for small businesses, most workers, newstart raises etc.) would be easily funded with that.
Instead we miss out on that and get a $70b hole in the budget to help very large (also typically foreign) companies to also get a company tax cut.
Cutting down on immigration is NOT a negative approach. Immigration is a negative approach and will not work in the long term. It will generate poverty and lower the quality of life of second and third generation Australians. Our high immigration levels are already ruining Australia.
'Look at all these migration success stories'
They're speaking English and they were explicitly told by their families to BE AUSTRALIAN.
The problem with current immigration is that they're not integrating, In south-west Victoria, its common to see road signs in Chinese, real estate agencies that specifically target the Chinese market (they dont advertise in English)
All Asian people live in overcrowded share houses unless they're the successful types, they work for less than minimum wage, which steals jobs from Australians.
Australia hasnt even started future proofing our existing populations employment situation, let alone millions of UNEDUCATED migrants.
FIX OUR ENERGY, WATER, WAGES, HEALTHCARE, HOUSING, LESS IMMIGRATION.
Booth what is going on ? !
Explain to me how a skilled migrant is delivering food to my house? Is driving taxis?
You want to goto china town in Melbourne? Where you can have a gluttonous feast for less than $20?, yeah im sure they're highly skilled, working legally and at or above minimum wage.
There are websites entirely in foreign languages for immigrants/visa holders to find share houses in Australia, where they cram people in to save on costs and hide on overstayed visas.
Booth i think theres a mix up between migrants and overseas students. Migrants would be skilled. The asians ddliverimg your food are probably overseas students. Those jobs should really be for locals
@@tonee4024 Well there's the problem. Too many temporary migrants (aka Visa students and workers) are in the major cities which are putting the locals at a disadvantage. I advocate for a cut to the temporary migrant rate or force them to move to regional cities.
they should start accepting convicts from the UK again. We got some great ones that'll fit right in.
I lived in Australia I returned back to Africa,
Lock&Load 77 lol
shon safri why
Too many indians in Australia
1976 was telling us something.
That there was enough of us.
The earth is struggling and we want more people?
Makes no sense.
The real problem is greedy businessman. Not immigrants.
@Chris Christian every soul shall taste death. Yet we still argue about how we can live in luxury and wealth..
@@adisyahirsupian8825 ....I agreed with you
I like how these immigrants were all speaking English, showing that they are fully integrated into their community and how the community has welcomed them. Very different to the US.
Blame Democrats
Don't be fooled! These regional settlement plans may encourage the learning of english, and integration but in the capital cities & suburbs integration efforts are much less. Many cities, suburbs & neighbourhoods have a majority of one nationality, culture or religion. And it's not a healthy or friendly way to live.
@@tracynelson7531 It's freedom of association
That's the ABC MISrepresenting things. Most do NOT speak English.
If there were diverse job opportunities in regional areas you wouldn't need to encourage migrants to go there, locals would go.
By the definition of insanity, Scott Morrison is continuing to do what has failed for 70 years - trying to keep new migrants in regional areas.
How about considering what other successful nations have done.
1. Make regional areas more attractive (sporting facilities, events, government offices, infrastructure, schools )
2. Provide employers with financial incentives for opening offices regionally (special economic zones)
3. Provide people with advantageous housing benefits for building houses regionally.
It’s not rocket science you know.
Yeah, it's called rocket surgery.
Skilled immigration takes from developing countries, if we invested in our own people we wouldn't need economic refugees.
Besides jobs, perception is everything. How can one compare Melbourne to Nhill? Beautiful parks, museums, places to go, the bay, the shops, and so on. Life is not just about earning money. We work on average 40 hours a week out of 168 hours. What can we do with the rest of our time? Large centres like Sydney support the regional towns and cities around it, like the Central Coast, Penrith, Wollongong. People travel to do things. The prestige of these centres cannot be underestimated. Government could set policies to encourage the private sector to develop regional centres like Bendigo, Traralgon, Bathurst/Orange, Toowoomba, Newcastle, Coffs Harbour to be more like the big cities - to bring the prestige. Marinas, landmarks, museums, sports, racing, water sports, things to do - to have the things the big cities have negates the divide. Focus industries in these centres. I would hazard the cost of proactively doing this would be less than the massive cost of infrastructure to keep unsustainably growing the large cities.
Growth is necessary because without it a city dies, look at historical Detroit. Decay brings many problems including crime. There is no equilibrium, that's just a tipping point waiting to happen. Sustainable growth, i.e. low rates of growth are far healthier, move the surplus growth to the regions, close to the current major centres (1-1.5 hours) by first providing prestige, then accessibility (roads and high speed trains), then jobs. Regional growth would follow a ripple effect as zones concentric to the major centres grow in waves.
Absolutely. As a skilled and experienced worker that lived 90% of my life in city with metropolitan population well over 20 million I would gladly go somewhere with population of several millions, if it had proper infrastructure and services. I do not even begin with job market. Melbourne, Sydney and Perth have high skilled jobs that attract young corporate professionals like me. We pay taxes, we know language and we play by the rules.
Want to shoehole me into Australian outback for 5 years? With a job that most likely not developing my professional expedience or even remotely connected to it? Well there is a lot of other countries that actually want skilled workers. You would end up just with low-payed uneducated mess. And I had seen this shit before. Here in Russia, HORECA sphere (and some other spheres as well) dumped huge chunk of quality workforce to pay less for TOTALLY unskilled and unprepared migrants. As result locals do not have deserved wages as businesses rely on low-cost migrants. And as the chain reaction it dumped wages all the way from waiter up to top management. And quality of services for that businesses tanked quite a lot and now resides on a permanent tipping point of catastrophe.
As the result most of skilled workers with higher education that I started to work with 8-9 years ago are gone. They are all over the globe - Dubai, Greece, Canada, New Zealand, you name it.
All I say that endeavor to cut city growth and reverse it to the low-skilled outback labor would most likely backfire in stagnation of currently existing job markets. You could not put migrants into the slave camps for the rest of their lives, they would find way back into cities.
There is not enough water in Australia to support a large population and the people are also leaving rural areas looking for job in the big cities because all the mines closing and the drought as well.
Desalination plants. Also there is actually a lot of work available in the country, however it usually doesn't pay well and the social prospects for families and young people is somewhat lacking
Agreed. There has be more than one or two reasons to stay in a town, desperation is not one of them. With the abundance of renewable energy that Australia can generate because of it's huge area of unproductive land, there's no reason we can't use that energy to power more desal plants and send it to the interior to where it's needed. Also capturing a portion of the water where it rains the most and sending it (canals, pipelines, pumps, dams) to the areas that need it would help too. Imagine the jobs that it would generate just to build it, and the job all that water could create? Large lakes in the interior would cool the continent just a little and make it more bearable and productive. Possibly even generate more rainfall. More jobs again ! Less hardship and more people happy instead of bickering over the little things.
@@tepidtuna7450 also we could do what China did and is doing by turning desert into reasonable agricultural land by utilising the Great Artesian Basin
Agreed, another good source of water if sustainably used. It's not being done because we The People argue too much over what is allowed. Our politicians are therefore too scared. We're constantly stalled by our bickering.
The Chinese got rich by reducing their fertility and avoiding taking migrants at all.
Hmmm, your statement doesn't really tell the whole story. While the video link I provide below doesn't either, I think you might find it interesting based on your claim: m.ruclips.net/video/Fg7jIjmLyWs/видео.html
The question should be can we encourage migrants out of Australia?
Some yes,but not all.Denying welfare will stop many,but it won't deter any who's country owns Australian politicians and real estate,business,essential services ,food securities etc etc etc
Brettox Benzyme: Agree. Actually i believe the coastal centers will become predominantly migrant over time and its the white Australians who will head inland, I say this because i know of several families in SA who have already moved further inland and also know of two who left the country for the Visegrád region and my adult children are planning the same as are others they know. Sounds extreme yes but white flight from Au is building on the prediction in 20 years this country will be unrecognizable from today, not in any good way.
@@maxaman64 I've been considering whether I'll be staying coastal or heading inland myself,perhaps even migrating to a specific country/s where I find the politics more agreeable (Visegrád region),my age makes that very unlikely however,although I do offer at least one child for the future (still have one in the nest) .
The problem with "White Flight" is the government will eventually "diversify" wherever whites go in western democratic welfare enabled countries (inline with UN globalist agendas) ... even if whites build a new city or even small town from the foundation up completely of their own cost the hordes will be delivered unto thee eventually.
In my area currently,most low wage unskilled or low skilled work is being devoured by mostly immigrant workers,young non- immigrants can't get these jobs as the traditional step up to better jobs or higher schooling.Some local farmers openly discriminate by advertizing "Asian only" positions or "Euro only" in some cases,denying the most hard up locals seasonal work to get by.Looking into work around mining areas I was not desirable to hire due to wage cost. Subsidized work visa,fly in/fly out and immigration rules the roost.
"Gina Rinehart has used a rare video appearance to repeat her warning that Australians need to work harder to compete with Africans who will labour for less than $2 a day."
www.abc.net.au/news/2012-09-05/rinehart-says-aussie-workers-overpaid-unproductive/4243866
Aaron: Agree and though voicing such ideals is admiral it makes sense also to understand things in Australia will need to get a hole lot worse than they are now in order for people to wake up so the struggle in long and hard with personal self preservation being the key to eventual numbers. Remember Australia is a country where things like Holocaust denial carries a custodial offence and to voice too loudly can bring charges of hate crime. Yes bloodline is everything and we can only breed when free.
Aaron: I personally know of one who received 18 months served 10 months in Victoria. There is one case of a denial in South Australia that lead to arrest here then imprisonment in Germany. David Irving is and English denier who has a lot of factual evidence. If you do not know of him he is well worth the research. I was raised by National socialist and can assure you the ideal is alive and well and growing all the time but every body needs to understand its core is not hate of or for anybody but rather ruthless love of the nation, likewise nations and the people of the nation and self reliance.
We Definitely need to go back to this concept. We have too many ethnic enclaves Little China, Little Thailand, Little India in Parramatta etc - We need everyone to become Australians. Whites mixing with Indians Chinese Mixing with Indians Greeks etc. That's not happening in the Big Cities !
Australia has to build medium sized cities other than Sydney and Melbourne, and create jobs there so that people can work and live there for long term, which also contributes to the growth of our economy. There are 100 cities in the US and 10-20 cities in Canada, population spreads across different parts of the country rather than concentrating in one or two major cities like what happens here in Australia. Federal government encourages people to relocate to rural towns but where are the jobs and facilities there? Without all that even if you force people to live there for 3-5 years, they will go back to big cities after the period is over. The other way is to build high speed rail to connect small towns to the big cities so that people can cut down travel time by 80% while living 200-300 km away. Cutting down immigration intake is a very negative approach and it won't work for the long term. While Australia reduces immigration intake from 190k to 160k per year, Canada has increase theirs from 330k top 360k per year for the next 5 years.
This series was great to watch and to see that the country takes its immigration seriously. However, being a New Zealand whom lives here in Australia with my young family. I struggle to see why this push for immigration excludes Kiwi's. I came to Aussie with my young family 6 years ago with my job. I am a manager with Bunnings. One of the most iconic, true blue Aussie brands there is. I was in Bunnings NZ for nearly a decade before we opened up in Alice Springs. I took on an offer in Alice Springs when no Australians wanted it. My little girl was 8 months old and my wife was pregnant with my son. After a few years In was sent to a town in South Australia until earlier this year when I was placed in Adelaide. I love rural Aussie! I love it better than NZ, I really do. I fit in here and my kids are growing up Australians. Hell, most you blokes cannot even pick me having an accent. Yet, I cannot become an Australian like all other countries. My Granddad and his brothers fought and died next to Aussie soldiers in WWII. My dad did the same in Vietnam. It wasn't too long ago since NZ was part of NSW. We are the same people. Yet, being a kiwi, we are treated as second rate. Now, I am going to stay here until I die and my kids want to be Aussies for ever. It is all they will ever know. I do know that in NZ and Aussie is treated quite nice yet here the favor is not returned. If Aussie really cares about immigration then do a story on why the country does not accept its Kiwi brothers and sisters. There is a story worth looking at.
Haha I always knew kiwi's were soft
Nato Genocide kiwis are brown bro like the natives of Australia are 😂
i agree 100 percent my dads a kiwi been here longer then any thing yet like u said our gov dosnt see them as worthy ( unless there brown skined)
Covid-19 is going to be a game-changer for population distribution in Australia. From 2020 onwards, we're going to see significant growth in regional areas - one of the positives that will come from the virus.
No effort has been made to resettle or employ a generation of lost Australian youth.
We've doubled our immigration in the last decade. There's not a new job for every immigrant; so more jobs go wanting which forces down wages, which increases investor wealth. We don't increase government expenditure proportionally to the increase in population. And our infrastructure doesn't increase with the increase in population - with water being a prime example. Our roads aren't all now twice as wide as they were 2 decades ago when our population was half the current size. The population spike also raises the demand for everything including housing. So prices have shot up which again raises investor wealth and makes Gina Reinhardt happy. Shes says she hopes that the Australian poor will be happy with $2 a day wages. She, and many other investors, are the backers behind the Liberal Party in Australia. It's the Liberal Party who have increased the immigration intake dramatically. They don't care about the poor. Or the environment. They care about becoming wealthier. Australia is becoming a mini USA.
A lower immigration rate will also reduce tensions between immigrants and the rest of the population. I don't want to have a country where there's racial and religious vilification.
Steve RX4
Love your work mate
It wasn't really just population that spiked housing market, that was already planned for when the GFC hit and interest rates hit the deck, not just in oz but rest of the world also.
Our gov/banks capitalised on the cheap credit as an incentive to all Australians "own your dream home". That plus alleviating the purchasing of property in oz from overseas (China) we have had the largest housing bubble in history.
Of course gov reaps in the huge benefits of capital gains taxes, taxes from the enormous upswing in construction industry and commercial banks are kept happy that their needs for supply of loans and interest payments are satisfied.
Just about every country especially in the G20 have this same problem and its just one type of bubble thats been waiting to pop and is now slowly deflating..
Personally I think it’s not so much the people but the lack of facilities in the outback that’s the problem, people go where the schools, universities and jobs are.
Long daily commutes to where the jobs and educations is doesn’t only exist in the cities. Sooner or later it simply makes more sense to move or board rather then commuting all the time.
Basically people go where the work is but the work is only there if there is a big enough population to demand it. Which essentially means people are constantly being drawn towards larger populated areas.
Online work and education will likely counteract that a bit but there is still drawbacks to fully online education and work so in my experience generally at least some on campus study/work that is still needed or preferred.
Rural towns in Australia are so bland and boring every young person who stays becomes an alcoholic or hooked on methamphetamine.
In rural towns you have to make your own fun. The reality is, in a rural town YOU are bland and boring. Oh the irony.
Community and family is a dying aspect of Australian life. It's hard to do drugs and drink with other breathing down your neck the judging you :)
we are admitting we are overcrowded yet somehow we need more migrants..
overcrowded? isn't the outback a part of arse-tralia?
Overcrowded.$25M on a land mass of this size. Have you ever been outside of OZ?
Antarctica is a giant continent too with plenty of room. Has the Australian government considered settling migrants in polar regions?
Why are they allowing 60000 plus indians to settle in Australia each year. There population exceeds 5 millions. Soon they will be the 2nd population in Australia.
Why isn;t anyone talking about how many is enough?
They are happy to put limits on emissions which I agree with - why are there no targets for people in the world? Can the UK support 150 million? What is the goal for Australia? 50 million? 200 million? A billion?
Dick Smith has been trying to get people talking about it but no one seems to be listening.
No the UK can't accept anymore,we have untold thousands of our British born people,homeless, and unable to claim any state benefits,yet the immigrants, ,illegal ones too,can claim double our benefits and housing!
the goal is to eliminate euro australians
Deplorable D, Our current population is just over 25 Million, I think we should limit it to say..40 Million, and of the increase, we need to look long and hard at De-centralization, and build large infastructure, including Water resorces and large amounts of Jobs near to the new Rural developments.
Many 'refugees' & migrants were settled outside of Sydney, Melbourne & Brisbane, but as soon as they had the money, or a majority neighbourhood, they moved to those cities.
I dont mind immigration, but we nedd to cut back on overseas aid and spend that money on infrastructure to be able to accomodate and serve the new immigrants, we need water, transport as in roads , rail and we need local manufacturing to give them jobs.
russell, Exactly right, we need to spend the money here to help make Australia better than it is now. There needs to be a lot more De-centralization, and I mean big buildings where needed, for the local population to work in, No more driving all the way to Sydney or Melbourne to work each day, THAT is Crazy.
I am not interested in paying tax to provide infrastructure for newly arrived foreigners. I would prefer not the have the foreigners and spend our money on improving what we have, not just building more of it.
Tall buildings are more expensive per square metre of floor space, than small buildings, both to build and to run.
As I said in the previous video, create economic corridors across rural areas using high speed rail. This means big commercial can stay in the cities and everything else can stay spread out and connected.
Broccoli 24 why arent u running the cou try ? 👍
@@tonee4024 aha a university degree short of Law and International Relations. Maybe I'll move into politics, one day
Broccoli 24 one day ? We need u now ! 😆 thats the beauty of democracy, every persons voice should be heard. Thats alot of brains working ! Most complain, leaders think ! 😉 i would say u r a leader ! 😊
I can see by the comments here that most people don't get it. More people = More demand = More Jobs = More taxes to pay for those who can't or won't work. Getting more people to live in regional areas means there are more people spending money there. Schools need more teachers, hospitals need more nurses, supermarkets need more staff and so on. Australia has a LOT of liveable areas that we haven't even touched. We could easily double our population and it would benefit us greatly. Imagine if we had another Sydney or Melbourne somewhere half way up the west coast of Australia where currently there is bugger all population?
Don't agree sorry,we'll have to agree to disagree on your every point. hehehe =P
You'd be right if our government was competent enough to plan for this. Instead the higher population leads to some negative aspects of higher demand such as congestion and housing affordability issues. Sure if we had proper industries that didn't rely on the service sectors in Melbourne and Sydney then you could be right. Perhaps we could have free trade zones like Shenzhen or some things KSA is experimenting with.
The same old corporatist arguments about "growth", we got along just fine before 2003 with lower immigration, we can do it again. If farmers can't get workers then maybe they should move their labour intensive operations closer to large population centres (seasonal work isn't good enough) and in reality if food supply was a big issue, then we wouldn't be bringing in all these extra mouths to feed. The reality is that we all know where this is going, more high rise developments and crowded cities.
How can farmers move their operations closer to large population centers?
Just Because its not immigration.its globalism. Alot of foreigners can live here for 3 months now. Same for us . Its globalism
Market gardens, hydroponics, vertical farms, in any case where there is a demand the market is probably going to make it happen (or you just get less variety of produce).
I live in a town named junee which is almost the opposite to stwall as over the past 5-10 years our town has grown from 4000 to 5000 people and we have no signs of slowing
In the not too distant future.
Sydney will be renamed
New Shanghai.... Melbourne
New Mumbai and Brisbane..
New Beijing.
GO BACK TO INDIA!!!!!!
Shaw Leon isnt india suppodsed to be rich now ?
There are also millions of backpackers working on your farms every year and spending actually all of their money in Australia. That's some temporary migration for work, Australians wouldn't do.
Absolute garbage, it's not millions and they take out most money they earn AND pay little tax. You have no idea of anything.
Australians might do it if cheap immigrants weren't undercutting the wages all year long.
@@snorelax3908 idk about cheap migrants, but all backpackers I've met haven't been working for less than 22$au. Normal payment was nearly always 25$au an hour.
@@gortnewton4765 nah backpackers waste all their money they bring from home before they start working (they need $5000 to enter) and after working they spend it again on travelling inside Australia (and again and again)
I'm sorry but I thought I thought I heard the Queen's voice in 5:17.😂
As a Young American, I have become attracted to rural Australia.
Thank you for this news
Regional Australia the dumping ground for migration mismanagement
lol
It isn't "mismanagement" tho'....
The entire "migrant crisis" has been engineered from the very beginning.
@Lock&Load 77
I think the "true purpose" of the "refugee crisis" is chaos.
Displaced populations to displace the previously displaced populations, whom once displaced the currently displaced population in some other place.
Which is displeasing.
I wouldn't want to trade places.
Meanwhile Harvey Norman is laughing his way to the bank!
"Where is the sense of compatriotship, brother and sisterhood now?" - you mean like the Irish Catholic/protestant establishment divide we had for 150 years. Or the worker/squatter divide we had for 100 years?
>Pepe the Frog
Opinion disgarded
If you don't want migrants just don't take them!! Why do you show them the Australian dream and then rip them off ?? Lets be honest no one in their right mind would spend their life savings to come to an island like Australia if they dont have benefits. Just like our forefathers came here on boats for opportunities !!
If they held a vote on the issue, immigration would be stopped. The problem is the parties on the left are obsessed with ensuring the downfall of white Australia and on the right, they are obsessed with cheap labour.
4:29 that transition was awesome
Hmmm why are we not having babies??? EXPENSIVE Housing, Education, Day care, Tolls, Fuel, Insurance, Health Insurance. If you want to be permanently broke and struggling to pay bills have a family. NO THANKS.
You forgot 'no blame' divorce, compulsory superannuation and the increased cost of housing. Immigration pushes up the cost of every square metre of land in the cities. And don't the wealthy just love that!
Even the migrants send their kids back to China because they can't afford child care.
@@chriswatson1698 Yes it's the landlord's lie.
we built the cities and they came
"if you build it they will come"
How can a country with such a huge landmass and such a small population have crowded cities? Why do Anglo-Europeans design their cities to be so narrow sized, congested but people of North Africa, Middle East and South Asia have such spread out cities with accessible parking slots, open sidewalks and wide roads? It's beyond me. As a North African once told me "and they call us third world". I couldn't agree more.
You could always go back where it’s more comfortable for you??? نادر الی راحمان
And why do all the rich Arab states with all their space not accept refugees?
@@ALA-uv7jq According to Nabil Othman, the UNHCR regional representative to the Gulf region, there were 500,000 Syrian refugees in Saudi Arabia at the time of his statement. The government itself of Saudi Arabia has stated that it has, over the past five years since the start of the conflict hosted 2.5 million refugees.
Because people want to live in the large cities near the coast and few want to live in a desert, right? But you're missing the point and you're wrong about the details. Australian cities not exceptionally crowded in terms of population density. Melbourne metro is around 80 Km end to end and about as wide, so its not exactly small, right? Do you actually know anything about Australia?
@@ALA-uv7jq rich arab states has more immigrants than western countries, i visited UAE i saw more immigration 90% people live UAE doesn't Emirates majority they come from indian subcontinent
what the song intro of the video, please
2:21 at least she can speak English, unlike many other migrant nurses
or the ones going to uni.....
Yah lol
I was at the local University Hospital the other day,and a young Indian couple were talking in their native tongue,no biggie I guess they didn't want anyone else knowing what they were talking about (despite talking so loud we could hear down the end of an adjoining hall.When arriving at the end of that hall there was a small group of Asian folk speaking in their native language .... so I keep on walking to find a Muslim couple with small tribe of their own in tow . and I'm not even sure what language they were talking.
The moral of the story is,I originally thought of this as an opportunity to learn a fourth language (I know shitty French, and average German,am native English) but soon realized that there are so many different languages being used and so frequently in AU that I literally didn't have a chance in hell of ever understanding what a large portion of "my fellow countrymen" were communicating.
In the end I've decided I better pat the dust of my Mandarin because China appears to be the dominate foreign force in acquiring Australia as it's asset.
You cannot obtain a degree if you do not know english lmao
Yes … you can .. and people do … one only need ask to utilize the language options available.
If you can pipe oil and gas...you can pipe water from deltas back to the desert.
And who is going to pay for that? The foreigners at present living overseas?
I have no interest in being taxed to pay for a water supply for foreigners. Or any other infrastructure that we wouldn't need, if our government hadn't flooded the country with foreigners.
It’s simple, govt needs tax payers to fund the services to all Australian. Ageing population increases cost for govt so easy solution without cost is to bring in immigrants. No child care cost, no schooling etc.. Young and ready to work. Best is bring in students, make them pay on average 80 k for their degree.. and give them residency.. Young , Australian educated, don’t have to fund UNI so much...
So win win.. Good policy as a government but comes with consequences..
Nope.
Big lose-lose. Nothing like you imagine it.
Gort Newton Stating the fact, it’s upto an individual how one wants to consume and digest it.. 🤘
Good for the migrants. Bad for the incumbents. Keeps wages flat and house prices high. Only the elderly are the winners. AGAIN.
@@deepak1764 A worthless opinion has no value - consumption of it will give indigestion, hahahahah
Where's all the jobs housing hospitals infrastructure roads transport !! THEY are all over loaded now?? Our own people are on the street's home less and they should have government housing first priority not Welfare immigration bleeding our Welfare System for Australian people !!
We are hooked on migration... In other words, migration is so good for Australia, that we must endure its horrors.
Mostyn Gale there are no horrors you xenophobe
@@marcozolo3536 It was tongue in cheek. If something is so good overall that we can't give it up, then it can't be bad.
Mostyn Gale understood, I think Australia will keep immigration high until the end of the century taking the nation well and above 100 million population.
But good luck being able to recognise Australia by then. It will be nothing like what you see today.
@@marcozolo3536 Exactly... If you got in a time machine and went back a hundred years, abducted one of the Anzacs and brought them back, they wouldn't recognise Australia today.
Mostyn Gale in 30 more years parts of Australia, like Sydney and Melbourne will be like present day New York City. In 50 more years Australia will be like Singapore. Give it a hundred more years and Australia will be like downtown Manilla or Mumbai with numbers reaching over 200 mill😂
I drive uber in Melbourne. Around 9am I enter in the city and until 4 pm I hardly get any rides. At airport we have to wait for almost 2 hours to get the ride. I have a friend who drive uber in New York and whatever the time is they always get riders all the time. If Melbourne really have that much population than why people are not out all the time. I do not agree with this report because the reason is not immigrants are increasing the population, the reason is lack of infrastructure. What we call CBD is too small in comparison to other international cities. You need to give reason to spread. Housing sprawled because they were attracted by the builders. I have so many friends who moved from alice springs, Bunbury, New Castle to Melbourne in 2 years because on the name of entertainment they had nothing over their. Banks will give loan for houses but not to start a business. Banking system need to focus and encourage small businesses to setup in regional areas. One business can open job option for at least 4 people. Government need to give open details about what business is required in which regional.area and go phase by phase. Encourage people for rain water harvesting, produce cheap electricity thru wind and ocean and solar power with batteries should be subsidize. Govt shud invest money in better medical facilities in regional areas. Immigrants are not responsible to shut down industries here. Empowerment can bring change. Empower every person who is living n paying taxes here n then see the magic.
This video is propoganda, the government needs a large influx of immigrants because population growth is meant to be a main driver of economic development, being that the more people = more demand = more means of production (jobs). One such reason was to prop up demand for housing and the only reason they want that is because after '08 GFC other than the mining industry Australia didn't really have any major industry taking off, so, basically, governments/banks pushed for more people to take out loans / invest in the property market which is why interest rates are so ridiculously low and why there has been such an enormous boom in prices and dwellings over the past decade.
Of course for the big commercial banks and governments this means more loans and more INTEREST repayments as well as more TAX being generated through Capital gains on housing.
You need to understand that all of this is a ponzi scheme to help a broke ass government which is by the way in a TRILLION dollars of foreign debt.
Banks will not help out smaller businesses for the simple fact that it doesn't meet their criteria of a SOLID SUPPLY OF INTEREST REPAYMENTS. Unfortunately for regional areas with dwindling populations they won't receive the same opportunities as larger, more stable companys and governments - including overseas.
Because the banks know, that the interest payments will not only be higher but will most likely never stop trickling through the doors as governments and corporations continue to borrow and borrow, driving themselves deeper and deeper into debt.
All of the things you are stating in your comment are only going to prolong our government into more debt than their already in, and guess what happens when too much credit is constantly borrowed? Supply of money inevitably increases which is what drives inflation of prices of everything. No no no no!
You don't get many uber jobs between 9am and 4pm because 1) most people are working, and 2) almost every man and his dog is driving an uber or taxi. Its become many people's side hustle, if they have a day off their full-time job, they drive to earn some extra pocket money. New York is a different kettle of fish to Melbourne, very few people want Melbourne to end up like New York.
Oh get down and dirty..... says a white privileged millionaire who's clearly lost touch with the reality of low wages, high power and food prices and housing prices out of reach for regular Aussies.
Great work on the story abc
I'm Australian born, in outer suburbs of sydney, definately not attracted to the cities, i would like to move very far out NSW, where house prices are still remotely affordable, and i can go to the shops and actually find a parking space, get out of my car, and buy my groceries without being tucked in a sardine can with people breathing all over me.
If i can get better than the 350sqm for 1.2mil that the cities offer me, i can grow fruit and veg, that actually has taste to it because i grew it myself, not grown in Vietnamese human shit like the produce we get from the supermarkets.
Absolutely right
You have to understand that the migrants of post WW2 and the migrants of today are VASTLY different. The former integrates and assimilate while the tens of thousands of coming in from India and China today will pack up their bags and leave as soon as anything goes wrong. They’re economic migrants, they’re here for economic reasons not because they want to start a new life and make Australia truly their home. Generations of these people still live in their own “community” while never really being part of the wider Australian community, even the ones born here. They value their own culture over what it means to be Australian and to live here. What kind of place will our country be in the future when there’s no societal unity and a sense of community? Australia, it’s culture and way of life was built by these European migrants, which is not the reality of those coming in today.
Skilled Migration yes, unskilled no. Western values yes, extremists no.
Man is created equal. Do you understand that? So stingy.
Those Asian girls looked very extremist indeed! We no want em.
This is not a Chinese mass production factory. People NOT equal at born, men and women NOT equal.
If the carrot to get migrants out of the cities is work in the country, WELL I want to be the 1st offered work in the countryside, I cannot find work in country Australia, nor anyone else I know of in these small country towns, there is NO work, good bye fulltime employment, its quite a competitive struggle to find part time employment.Australians born here need employment, if govt taxes rules, regulations were not so expensive there would be more businesses setting up,l NO way if I were a millionaire would I set up a business in Australia these days, paying for some one else's retirement, what a joke, when superannuation became mandatory, that was the collapse of Australia as we knew it, collapse of businesses suddenly.
Very hard for Aussies to get jobs.
Modern day people suffer from ADD and thus lack the objectiveness to truly understand the history of man. As a species, we have always migrated from one place to the other. We started in Africa and populated the entire world in a sequence that can easily be traced. This idea that we should stop a pattern that has preexisted for tens of thousands of years is really myopic. I understand that some people do not enjoy the diversity they see when they go to the mall thus feel irritated by the change of demographics. The larger share of immigrants(not to be mistaken for refugees) have worked extremely hard to migrate here to Australia and have brought with them a very strong workforce. One of the key reason Australia thrived through the economic crisis of 2008 was due to immigrants. Immigrants created a strong enough consumer market..e.g Housinf..etc that allowdd for Australia to continue humming when nost western societies were crumbling. Most Australians work in construction and are benefiting from the work provided by a growing demand(by immigrants) for new houses.
Now for those speaking of "white genocide", i would urge you to first research on geneology. Genes have been in constant change since the cromagnons walked the earth, thus this idea of maintaining pure "genes" is simply a cultural assertion. If you are to speak of genocide then do not leave out the Aboriginal,Jewish or native American genocides, which were perpetrated using brutality and violence. A person chosing to be in an interracial relationship is definitely not "genocide"
Wow,textual Diarrhea of the most absurd kind.
@@brettanthonypalmer2956 Explain why you came to this conclusion?
@@vforvendetta60 Because the whole pile of words is a eyesore of wrong.
Different ethnicity belong to different parts of the world through NOT constantly migrating ....... Asians didn't become Asian through a breeding bastardization of genes. The segregation and location of ethnicity is what makes them unique and cherished ... Before the Euro push of Empire/colonialism, there was so little world migration that it is in fact utterly miserable as an excuse for immigration at all.
The Jewish,Native Americans,Aboriginals and Africans actively and quite gleefully took part in Genocide themselves,they are just as guilty as any other ethnicity or nation .... the Jews were quite happy to stand by the white convict settlers in Australia,Jews are recorded on the first fleet as fellow convicts,the 250 odd Aboriginal tribes themselves were at war with each other and were inhumane not just to their enemies but their own women and children. As an aside,to the best of my knowledge Aboriginals couldn't own land as it's against their religiion,it's also partly why they couldn't grow crop or herd live animals. My brother in law (RIP) taught me much about his culture as he wanted to share. There never was an Aboriginal Nation and the latest round of Aboriginal unrest is being lead with a Jewish based lobby.... go figure,as they too had a hand in this so called genocide.
The native Americans,both north and south had absolutely no issue with wiping out entire regions and taking slaves.The African tribes,particularly the Zulu from the north of the continent cut swathes of tribes down to rivers of blood,wiping some out entirely on their tribal rampage to the southern lands,lands which whites had built up form unusable arid crap into sustainable farming land . And if we'd like to seriously discuss Communism/socialism/bolshivik/Islamic expansion hand in genocide then you'll be sorely upset on just how few deaths WW2 had caused statistically OVERALL.
The immigration policy of successive Australian governments has been nothing but harmful to the already established western Euro/Christian based and built society of Australia.All this rampant immigration has provided is working poor wages for labor,unaffordable housing for our children,huge welfare burden on already existing taxpayers who's own children and their future have been compromised for a quick buck,Unacceptable education of our youth and a debt slavery to pay for this third rate education,an unacceptable crime rate which includes obscene violent crimes that were mostly so rare to be outliers in past crimes statistics before successive Government harmful immigration policies.
Most of all it's provided Australia with "New Australians" who don't give two bob about the history,culture or defense of the host country they're leeching from ..... The vast majority of them would/will never take up arms for Australia's or Australians defense and would rather exercise their right to invoke their dual citizenship for escape back to their "motherland".....where a vast majority of their the cash they earn in Australia ends up anyway.
Your narrative,it's fantasy.
Japan=Don't want "diversity"
Israel= Don't want "diversity"
South Africa = Don't want "diversity"
China= Don't want "diversity"
Saudi Arabia = Don't want "diversity
Visegrád Group =Don't want "diversity"
Pakistan = Don't want "diversity"
India = Don't want diversity
Etc,Etc,Etc
Diversity = white genocide pure and simple.Mass immigration of non like religion and culture is a sham for globalist human trafficking debt and sex slavery. It's vile
@@brettanthonypalmer2956 Now to speak on your assertion that immigration has been detrimental to Australia. Firstly you have no idea of the struggles that immigrants have to go through to get a job here in Australia. A survey showed that if a person applied for a job with a foreign sounding name they are highly unlikely to get called in for an interview. They had to make writing one real name on a resume non-compulsory just to curb that handicap. For an immigrant to get a job they have to be exceptional and work twice as hard to earn the respect that is given freely to caucasian Australians. These immigrants you speak of are taxpayers as well and are entitled to the benefits as they are paying for them just like any other Australian. Jobs have been declining in the west not because of population increase but globalization,that has seen a lot of manufacturing jobs being outsourced to asian countries. Immigration has actually helped boost construction jobs as most immigrants tend to buy houses. Immigrants have been starting their own businesses here in Australia, further increasing employment figures. If you go on the Australia Bureau of Statistics, you will find that crime over the decades has actually gone down. The only reason most caucasian Australians are assume crime has gone up is because the perpetrators look different to them. In Victoria for example, Africans make up 1% of the crime in that region whilst approximately 80% of crime is committed by Australian born people,but the media and general public "assume" Africans are ramping up crime.Look at the statistics for a more objective take on these matters.
@@brettanthonypalmer2956 Furthermore one of the reasons you see people migrating to western societies is because they were colonized by them. Due to colonization,people from developing countries tend to share some cultural similarities and familiarity with the west, so they go there instead of Japan..etc.So you will find people from former British colonies will tend to migrant largely to Britain than anywhere else.
You stop the baby bonus that's why it didn't. Increase
That only encouraged bogans to breed lol
Yeah because it didn't give other people the benefits just them it doesn't work like that
Why should migrants leave? it doesn t matter who was "here first". A citizen of Australia is an Australian citizen.
They could Just make new city as well like come on
no they don t what
because my ancestors built this country, migrants ran from what their ancestors built. they can run back there, we owe the 3rd world NOTHING.
thank you for all 3 videos as great watching as the show grow big over the time
the Australian government and state government here look better build up towns living out side main city of Australia want further and plus keep Australian jobs here in Australia
I wonder if the ABC makes advertising revenue from this, or whether youtube makes its own revenue by throwing in ads where there is content. Guess it really is a brave new world out there
multiculturalism is good but not at the cost of national identity
Too many Indians in Australia
What is good about multiculturalism? And don't say 'food'. Migrants aren't responsible for the wide range of cuisines on offer in Australia. We have had few Japanese migrants, yet Sushi bars abound.
I left Australia 20 years ago and when I visit now it doesn't feel like the same country, mostly because of overpopulation. It might seem like the economy gets boosted by immigration, but there is also a cost in lower quality of life for all, a cost which is almost never considered.
Hi Peter, you did the right thing. I want to leave too.. I don't like what has been happening for years and years. Very sad living here now.
@@lynneleighton5482 Where would you go though?
If I had plenty of money Singapore would be my choice...Cleaner...Safer...location.
@@youngtravels9948 The cost of living might be high, but the salaries there are also high, so as long as you're working there it's not a problem.
theuglykwan ironically he probably moved to Asia
Betteridge's law of headlines applies.
"Any headline that ends in a question mark can be answered by the word no."
The answer is no, the migrants will move away from regional Australia for the same reason the young do. Although I remember we had this project which would have provided affordable ubiquitous low latency high bandwidth communication nation wide which could have mitigated many of the disadvantages of living small remote communities. Despite screwing all that up I'm sure our genius right wing government can solve the issues around integration requiring foresight and planning over multi-generational time scales...
Wow.. cant believe im watching this after 16 yrs living in Sydney..people in Australia are paranoid of their future.
God forbid we be like everyone else.
the problem is Lack of proper urban planning and Lack of infrastructure
So you think that Australians should be taxed more, and forced to pay for facilities for foreigners? The people who own construction companies are rubbing their hands in glee at the big profits that they are making at the expense of Australian taxpayers. And all that taxpayer expenditure counts as the GDP which the Federal government can brag about.
Chris Watson Cmon...... infrastructure for everyone, for the next generation, for the future, for your daughters and sons
@@hanhan2360 cmon. The infrastructure that my taxes, my parents' taxes and my grandparents' taxes paid for, was intended for our children and grandchildren. But our government has been giving it away to foreigners who have clogged it up. Migrants are foreigners who move here with the intention of using the infrastructure, health care and free education that we have built for our own descendants.
Easy... just develop several Bali like beach cities. Don’t wait for politicians to fix your problems, they will take advantage of every situation.
Politicians have created most of our problems.
We can't create Bali like beach cities because of planning regulations and the like.
How about you stop encouraging them into the country in the first place with record immigration
@Lee McDonald Does it not seems self evident that the same media and groùps that campaign for higher and higher immigration turn around and complain that those immigrants have difficulty fitting in? Sustainable levels of immigration means considering all such factors.
@Lee McDonaldSo you support unsustainable migration? Because the current rate is in no way sustainable. You are anti sustainable future? Wanker.
If only the new migrants were willing to join in on Australian society like the old ones were. Ray put it best.
There's not water on country cities no jobs...travel long distances ., you must travel on the road 100km hits too fast roads are slippery with snow.... dangerous food is more expensive on country side at Coles or other shops petrol is more expensive and the pay is low country side is good f our rich people
Why don't we try and invest in areas outside of Sydney and Melbourne so people have incentive to leave these cities where the jobs are. Australia doesn't have a population problem, it has a distribution problem that is driven by an incompetent government.
Good story definetly something to think about, moving back to Australia next year guess I better get a wiggle on before they stop letting people in.
full HD but quality is still subpar
i love how they dont have any australian point of views its all from the imagrents
The title question should not be asked, even not refered. I know you guys do not let immigrants go out from the big cities, but the point is one of the rasied solution for overpopulation problem is get them out from cities. I know most aussie are racist, because i suffered many racist conduct when i traveled australia. But this is way to wrong. You guys are solving problems in racist ways and covering even in formal broadcast media. This is totally discriminative.
Also talks about newstart...dont you think these jobs are the solution......instead they leave them with low self etseem and help the migrants....
Also talks about newstart...dont you think these jobs are the solution......instead they leave them with low self etseem and help the migrants....
Yeah in Canadian and in shocked at this title . Lol Australian need immigrants but want then to work away from the cities . How disgusting
Hey dont forget that we're that special people that give everybody a fair go..... Unless you're seeking asylum.
The only reason that we think that discrimination on the basis of race is wrong, is because none of us can choose our race, or change it. To discriminate on the basis of gender or age is just as wrong.
But we have no obligation to share our heritage with anyone at all. And if we do share our birthright, we have no obligation to be fair in who we choose to share with. We are entitled to act in our own interests, not in the interests of people who have stuffed up their own countries..
You ask international students go to rural area? They are paying money to get educated. Not paying money for suffering. They are going to other countries. But the government can settle refugees to rural area.
Their children will leave for the cities, same as everybody else.
S, Lianis what I can tell is that we understand you are using a racist language. So stoping being racist and grow up. I agree some students have insufficient English skills. However, this is not the reason they should be sent to rural area. Neoliberalism policy allows them to go to other countries to get educated.
To save the community , you must offer more money to keep your workers or find new workers that will accept your tiny little wages from 3rd world countries to immigrate here.
The second choice was made & it's sold to us as a "GOOD IDEA"
Once these workers realize better oportunity lies elsewhere , they will move to a city. After all they moved to australia for that same reason.
Multicultural immigration is good if you bring the right people who can contribute to our country and be law abiding citizen's and be social !!👍😉
Man is created equal. So mean.
This is not a Chinese mass production factory. People NOT equal at born, men and women NOT equal.
The title should be, can we encourage immigrants to stop coming here so the Australian lifestyle remains half decent!
A population cap is in order before we start eating each other!
Can we encourage residents to stop migrating to the coast?????
Why not build city’s in the middle of the desert of room out there , keep the green belt green instead of covering it with concrete and tin roofs
Because the land would be cheap and immobilia Tycoon don't get their share !!
Who is going to pay for the water supply? I am not interested in being taxed to pay for water for foreigners. Desalinated water is four times more expensive than water from dams. The more immigrants we take, the more our cost of living will increase.
Try just not letting more than we need, I know racist racist for saying sane and common sense things but yeah, common sense hasn't died off yet so lets continue to be choosy in who we allow in
Brazilians and Australians get along?
I don't se why not!
@@Ragnar6000 Are you Australian?
I know a bunch of South American's, all of which are wonderful people. Short as hell, but great and wonderful people.
@Johnny Irenchi why mate?? I'm Brazilian living in Ireland for 5 years. I think we get along over here! I think
@Manoel de Jesus Ribeiro......yes
Why is this question being asked? Australia, protectionism is not a long term answer.
We aren't talking the encouragement but our government needs to have stern wrist to set firm POLICY request to all immigranting applicants to settle allotted areas of remote states with explicit written explanation prior to lodge immigrating application by LAW. And let those qualified immigrants settling down the allotted sites for 5 yrs then start to be qualify to live in any major organs of metropolitans in the nation that simply the mechanism of controling the number of the city exactly the same principle to control the highway flow on the road. Or again, if we don't and won't apply the STERN HARD WAY now, the future will be the congestion in the city and the vacuum status in the outskirts of the major city. We need to change at this point..........STF.......
We have seen this happen in our isolated area of the country. There is almost no support for immigrants, those with poor English struggle to find jobs or understand how to cope with every day life. For example one family of six arrived and not one person in town spoke their language. They have a very difficult, lonely life.
They didn't even speak a word about the aborigines as if they don't exist or never did, and never wanted them to exist.
They hadn't even invented the wheel, aboriginals are the dumbest race of people on the planet, name one smart abo lol.
Look at your 50 dollar bill, if you have one. See that guy on it? Smarter than you'll ever be.
The ignorence is real in these comments, haha, or they didn't watch it and just comment stupid shit because of the title. people are trying to fit in you saw it, controlled migration is still a benefit to us it's just we need to think about slowing but guess what we will still have to take refugees no option on that one and we have shit tonnes coming when the pacific islands start going under.
by the indigenous ethos it is no ones land which i agree with but we are also a democracy which is extremely important and requires a majority to do shit so good luck with that one and we still live on earth and are all citizens of earth we need to realize we are all on the same team. and how the fuck do you know i'm not indigenous... how do i know your indigenous oh wait lets show our paper of aboriginality to each other. Fucking hypocrite calls me a moral supremacist while shouting their morals at me like i know nothing . which could be the case youtube comments after all...
Just look after what we have. The damage has been done. We just have get along with each other. We have look after Mother Nature.
Migration has no place in Australia where in a drought you student think this far ahead of yourself did use!!!!!!
Decentralization was mentioned here, the Idea of three CITY areas in Sydney is a good one., but someone has to MAKE it happen. For the people who want to live and work in the CBD, then I believe we need to Build Huuge... 100 plus Story Scyscrapers where you LIVE and WORK in the same building, It would have Big Buisiness, Shops, Doctors, Schools, fitness centres, etc. and all the Appartments needed to house the workers. I don't think we have to Import too many people into Australia, and the ones that come here, (legally) need to be anything except Islamic, because Islam want to take over every country they move to, have a look around the world where they have moved into and you will see Destruction of the natural order of those societies, and this CANNOT be allowed. Here in Australia we follow the Judeao Christian Laws and Governance, like the UK, and Fundamentalist Islam is DESTROYING that country. We can't afford people to come here who do not WANT or WON'T Integrate. That means to learn English, Respect the indemic Australian way of life and Classify Australia as their new HOME, and abide by the Australian Laws ONLY. ( NO Sharia). Yes we are a Nation of Immigrants, BUT we should all now come together as AUSTRALIANS.
Demonrats trying to decide where people want to live. I have to watch this stupidity over and over again.
Unofficial 3 million Indians in Australia !!!!!!!
You can thank John Howard for starting it all.
Peter Laustra and African Australian’s 😡
They come from the land of bride-burnings, slums, high birth rates and the oppression of untouchables. It took British colonialists to stop the Indians from persuading widows to burn themselves alive. And we are going to let them participate in the choice of our lawmakers.
@@chriswatson1698 UK , AUSTRALIA AND CANADA WERE BUILT ON MONEY STOLEN FROM INDIA.
@@ketangarg2419 What utter rubbish. Without the British, the people of India would still be being exploited by the Maharajahs; and the Muslims and Hindus would still be fighting each other. Oh, wait, they still are fighting each other, 60 years after the British left.
What the British left behind was worth far more than any of the profits that they made from trading in India.
Our skills shortage is a lack of investment in TAFEs.
i agree and disagree, people need to be invested into as well, there needs to be trust for society to work, and im sure youll find if you go asking people on the street that trust comes few and far between
even loyalty is fleeting...
brand loyalty is pretty big though, most people dont care about anything other than if they can get that gucci and how they're perceived by others
@@PhunkBustA some good point mate, poor governance and trust is partly responsible for the current state of affairs, no vision or plan to energise the people of our country.
@jon jon There isn't a skills shortage. If we stopped migration tomorrow, the employers wouldn't even notice. What they would notice would be paying higher wages. It is cheap labour they want, not skills.
The capital to develop a Silicon Valley in Australia is not there, never was, just look at the fail programs from various governments ... we can't attract capital, nor give chance of capable people ability to Start their own business with ease. Australia need to rethink their own tax system also, how about lower tax rate for companies outside of cities cap at a certain turn over and employees gets to pay less tax per dollar and has no cap?
No, because city environments are perfect for commercial use and the corporations are doing quite well in Australia. What you need is temporary less tax for having property along a corridor connecting up major cities. Fill this corridor with a high speed train network and you basically have a more advanced California
"hooked on migration" sums up the issue imo.
James Blackler so what if Australia was originally a penal colony!?
@@kayseek1248 maybe you should because little less high and mighty and racist. Considering your heritage ain't that great
James Blackler hahahahahahahahahahahahaha
My ancestors were both immigrants from Scottland and England and i am half Asian/White, what does my comment have to do with hookers and criminals? This is not a race issue but one of Sustainability for the Aus way of life.
The fact you went straight to the race card is a clue to who the real racist is here.
MrSweetness1983 he’s just one of these left-wingers addicted to the drug known as “Tolerence”.
you need a balance of migration, infrastructure and economy. Increase migration speed up the economy, if you reduce migration then Australian economy is on its knees. Dosnt matter the red party or the blue party is in power, they wont touch that subject, they may reduce migration, but every change of government they would revert the policy.
It just means endless debt.
@@mikespearwood3914 Thats how politicians make their $$$, living in luxury house, drive expensive cars, holidays and finance their lifestyle.
greed is so deep in this society from govt to banks to businesses , to corporates ...its making its citizens life miserable
The pollies are bloody hopeless
With immigration. Need to have
More general labour immigrants
For the shortages of staff for
Small business. They need to
Give visas only if they go to
Regional areas.
Then bloody build fast rail there then