Paige’s elimination was very much deserved (I think that Against All Odds is one of the worst I’ve ever seen), but it was still quite brutal watching Simon basically “don’t bother singing, we won’t consider saving you.”
I got some nominations for part 3 of both least shocking and shocking eliminations. These are my picks and I trust you have your own. Shocking Part 3: 1. Asiah Epperson 2. Paris Bennett 3. Sabrina Sloan 4. Amanda Overmyer Least Shocking Part 3: 1. Antonella Barba - I thought she should have gone way sooner. 2. Kellie Pickler - with two consecutive weeks that were bad, she was bound to go. 3. Scott Savol 4. Lisa Tucker - I like her and I thought she could have made it further but her times in the bottom 3 three times in a row killed her chances. 5. Mikalah Gordon 6. Josh Gracin 7. Bucky Covington 8. Ace Young 9. Megan Joy - She should have left when Jasmine did. These are just my suggestions.
It's fucked up that people cheered when Sanjaya got eliminated. Like I get he WAY overstayed his welcome, but damn, he just got eliminated, and his family is in the audience, and he was also only 17. Cheering like that was fucked up.
When you get to making a part 3 of this, I think Scott Savol, Kellie Pickler (after 2 back to back bad weeks, I kinda expected it), Lisa Tucker (same reasons as Hollie, she could have made it further but three times in a row in the bottom 3 killed her chances), Antonella Barba and Josh Gracin. Aaron Kelly, Lakisha Jones, Chris Sligh, Chris Richardson and Phil Stacey are other options.
I disagree with kristy completely, at the time she was picking up a lot of momentum and most people actually predicted one of Carly Syesha or Brooke to leave this week (and for those 3 to be the b3) her elimination was a bit of a shocker that specific week
I can understand that. I liked her last performance and her other few were also good. But she’s been in the bottom so much she was bound to go soon. We all knew she wouldn’t win.
and Kristy was improving throughout the competition and getting better she had a couple bad performances but when she picked the right song she was good and she was overhated
10. I heard he received death threats. 9. Didn't care for her but yikes, Simon! 8. Yeah. Vote for talent, not your crushes! 7. About time! She should have gone sooner! 6. All I can say is, Good Riddance. 5. Again, she should have gone way sooner! 4. Looking back at this, she really didn't stand a chance. At least David Cook won. 3. This was inevitable and at least he outlasted Antonella Barba and Haley Scarnato. I wish they were booted out sooner. 2. I think Allison Iraheta was in the same situation. She could have made it further had it not been for her times in the bottom 3. 1. Again, no comment
LOVE IT! Hahaha. I gotta say season 9 was absolutely terrible and killed the show for a lot of people. I mean compare it to season 4. Paige was told she had the strongest voice when the live shows started. I think she hurt from not being a trained vocalist and being sick the entire time. I feel she was destined to make the top 3 but there was not saving those terrible vocals.
I personally don't think Paige was even that good of a singer before she got sick but then again all I remember from her was that bad romance group battle between her group vs Siobhan and Todrick's group.
Do you by chance have unedited seasons of 1-8 that can be uploaded somewhere? I'm looking to have copies and don't want them with RUclips channel watermarks. I do have content I can trade.
Personally Rayvon benefited by both Daniel and Qaasim still being around cause neither of them had any business staying as long as they did and the judges had no business giving one of them (Qaasim) the judges save during top freaking 11.
Keep in mind he wasn't originally supposed to be in the semifinals a guy name Chris Golightly got DQ and the producers for some reason gave Tim his spot instead of (in my opinion of course) the more talented Thaddeus Johnson.
Kady Malloy was another that was not shocking. I'm glad she was voted off after butchering a Queen song. Will Malkar also should have gone sooner. Sorry about the many comments but I think I now rest my case.
I felt bad for haley scarnato because all her critiques were always about her looks and you could tell it was really getting to her. I liked her voice but she went at the right time
she’s gorgeous but she definitely overstayed her welcome and she was so generic she had pretty white girl privilege I think that’s why she stayed as long as she did
@@machoman1016 Sanjaya & Haley both overstayed their welcome and with that week it wasn’t surprising that Haley got voted off she was in the bottom 2 a few times and it was time for her to go
I wouldve liked to see hollie in the finale with phillip. I think she was most improved from her previous season and was interesting to watch, i think the issue with her though was musically she didnt really have an identity and it was hard for people to connect, even though she had a good voice
She grew on me as the season progressed just like Elise which is why they made it so far. My favorite performance of hollies was river deep mountain high
Paige’s elimination was very much deserved (I think that Against All Odds is one of the worst I’ve ever seen), but it was still quite brutal watching Simon basically “don’t bother singing, we won’t consider saving you.”
Not to hate on Lazaro but man he was killing me all season long!
I got some nominations for part 3 of both least shocking and shocking eliminations. These are my picks and I trust you have your own.
Shocking Part 3:
1. Asiah Epperson
2. Paris Bennett
3. Sabrina Sloan
4. Amanda Overmyer
Least Shocking Part 3:
1. Antonella Barba - I thought she should have gone way sooner.
2. Kellie Pickler - with two consecutive weeks that were bad, she was bound to go.
3. Scott Savol
4. Lisa Tucker - I like her and I thought she could have made it further but her times in the bottom 3 three times in a row killed her chances.
5. Mikalah Gordon
6. Josh Gracin
7. Bucky Covington
8. Ace Young
9. Megan Joy - She should have left when Jasmine did.
These are just my suggestions.
I just now realized Kevin Covais was on Good Luck Charlie. Back then I thought he looked familiar, but I forgot he was on American Idol until now
Oh yeah, he played Victor! I didn't even know he was on Idol
It's fucked up that people cheered when Sanjaya got eliminated. Like I get he WAY overstayed his welcome, but damn, he just got eliminated, and his family is in the audience, and he was also only 17. Cheering like that was fucked up.
I'm guessing the cheers were more for Lakisha staying than him going but then again the way that people were acting at him I wouldn't be surprised.
Syesha is a great singer! I wouldnt mind if she made it into finale
3.How he survived is beyond me his sister should’ve been the one moving on not him
When you get to making a part 3 of this, I think Scott Savol, Kellie Pickler (after 2 back to back bad weeks, I kinda expected it), Lisa Tucker (same reasons as Hollie, she could have made it further but three times in a row in the bottom 3 killed her chances), Antonella Barba and Josh Gracin. Aaron Kelly, Lakisha Jones, Chris Sligh, Chris Richardson and Phil Stacey are other options.
Yay so glad you are making these again!
I disagree with kristy completely, at the time she was picking up a lot of momentum and most people actually predicted one of Carly Syesha or Brooke to leave this week (and for those 3 to be the b3) her elimination was a bit of a shocker that specific week
I can understand that. I liked her last performance and her other few were also good. But she’s been in the bottom so much she was bound to go soon. We all knew she wouldn’t win.
and Kristy was improving throughout the competition and getting better she had a couple bad performances but when she picked the right song she was good and she was overhated
@@azzz7279 she was getting better at the end but unfortunately it was too little too late everyone else had more momentum.
This video is finally here after such a long wait! Enjoy and let me know what you think!
Can you upload some Haley Scarnato season 6 performances please? I can't find like half of her performances with the judges comments :(
Not gonna lie I kinda wanted to throw a party when John Stevens was voted off.
i would also add casey james and scott savol here too
10. I heard he received death threats.
9. Didn't care for her but yikes, Simon!
8. Yeah. Vote for talent, not your crushes!
7. About time! She should have gone sooner!
6. All I can say is, Good Riddance.
5. Again, she should have gone way sooner!
4. Looking back at this, she really didn't stand a chance. At least David Cook won.
3. This was inevitable and at least he outlasted Antonella Barba and Haley Scarnato. I wish they were booted out sooner.
2. I think Allison Iraheta was in the same situation. She could have made it further had it not been for her times in the bottom 3.
1. Again, no comment
I didn't even know there was a Paige Miles! Also, is it just me or does Tim Urban look like Louis Tomlinson?
I thought Kristy outperformed Brooke that night, but overall Brooke probably had a stronger “body of work” and therefore she stayed.
Looking at the bottom 3 and knowing who will leave is damn funny. Especially when they overstayed.
i was so happy when sanjaya left
The Davids season was my favorite! Left handed people are awesome!
I’m such a fan of your channel! I’m uploading all seasons 🥰
i mean ...Syesha was in the bottom 3 ot 2 *SIX TIMES* .....
LOVE IT! Hahaha. I gotta say season 9 was absolutely terrible and killed the show for a lot of people. I mean compare it to season 4. Paige was told she had the strongest voice when the live shows started. I think she hurt from not being a trained vocalist and being sick the entire time. I feel she was destined to make the top 3 but there was not saving those terrible vocals.
I personally don't think Paige was even that good of a singer before she got sick but then again all I remember from her was that bad romance group battle between her group vs Siobhan and Todrick's group.
6. Bucky should’ve went home
Do you by chance have unedited seasons of 1-8 that can be uploaded somewhere? I'm looking to have copies and don't want them with RUclips channel watermarks. I do have content I can trade.
Personally Rayvon benefited by both Daniel and Qaasim still being around cause neither of them had any business staying as long as they did and the judges had no business giving one of them (Qaasim) the judges save during top freaking 11.
8.hallelujah
casey james elimination should be here
Paige versus Tim really couldve been either. They were both terrible and honestly Tim shouldnt even have made the top 12
Keep in mind he wasn't originally supposed to be in the semifinals a guy name Chris Golightly got DQ and the producers for some reason gave Tim his spot instead of (in my opinion of course) the more talented Thaddeus Johnson.
I agree with everythinh
JAX THE PIANIST AND SINGER WAS WAY BETTER THAN NICK FRADIANI WHO HAS BEEN FORGOTTEN,
6.Bucky should’ve went
1.she should’ve went home
Kady Malloy was another that was not shocking. I'm glad she was voted off after butchering a Queen song. Will Malkar also should have gone sooner. Sorry about the many comments but I think I now rest my case.
I felt bad for haley scarnato because all her critiques were always about her looks and you could tell it was really getting to her. I liked her voice but she went at the right time
She got unlucky that Sanjaya gave a good or at least passable performance that week.
@@machoman1016 Sanjaya also lasted way longer than he should have
@@rmusic08 yes he did but I also felt that the hated he got was very undeserved it went pass his singing ability and went personal.
she’s gorgeous but she definitely overstayed her welcome and she was so generic she had pretty white girl privilege I think that’s why she stayed as long as she did
@@machoman1016 Sanjaya & Haley both overstayed their welcome and with that week it wasn’t surprising that Haley got voted off she was in the bottom 2 a few times and it was time for her to go
5.duh
how did Paige make it to the top 12 ? Katelyn Epperly should’ve been in the top 12 instead
7.who
Hayley scarnato
4.pointless
Rayvon was the best singer out of the 4 of them though. Nick was the weakest singer and he won
Nah he wasn’t he was the worst.
I wouldve liked to see hollie in the finale with phillip. I think she was most improved from her previous season and was interesting to watch, i think the issue with her though was musically she didnt really have an identity and it was hard for people to connect, even though she had a good voice
She grew on me as the season progressed just like Elise which is why they made it so far. My favorite performance of hollies was river deep mountain high
My top 5 was Jessica, Colton, Joshua, Hollie and Skylar/Elise. I don't like Phillips.