Atlas Shrugged by Ayn Rand Summarised
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 25 апр 2024
- Support the channel
► Donate A coffee: ko-fi.com/fictionbeast
► Join my Patreon: / fictionbeast
WHERE TO FIND ME:
► Website: fictionbeast.com
►Instagram: / fiction_philosophy
► E-mail: fictionbeastofficial {at} gmail.com
► Audio Podcast: redcircle.com/shows/c101a9a1-...
#fictionbeast
#philosophy
#literature
Loved learning about Ayn Rand 🎉🎉🎉🎉
She is wack
Love your videos bro
He does a great job.
There's people talking about a decline of the west and how Rand predicted it. I'm curious: what do they mean by decline, what are they actually talking about?
I'm aware the world is not perfect or even great by any means, and neither are the western countries we (probably) live in, but I don't see how things have ever been "better" if we want to speak in a general and qualitative way, though I'm not a fan of this manner of speaking. Just the fact that I can read and write, and in more than one language, without being noble or even wealthy, is something that wasn't possible for most people even 70 or 80 years ago. If the west is declining what is it declining from? When has the life of the average man ever been easier and relatively full of opportunities?
It's declining philosophically which will translate into decline in material terms. But the effect is not immediate.
I think the west is declining because many people don’t feel the way you do-most people aren’t in search of all of the knowledge that is available to them. The western mind is closing.
I have to admit, your taste in literature is insanely similar to mine😮
Actually these are pretty common literary choices...
@@damn7637 not in the social circles I am around
So what if all the businesses shut down tomorrow? That would be a devaluing of assets if they were not to reopen. Essentially Scenario a) the government would go to middle managers give them loans to restart the businesses and confiscate the assets of the business leaders who closed down the old businesses for political pressures. Scenario B) Quid pro quo bargin with them. Subsidise for contributions. The old fashioned way to embezzle.
Did u not read the book? That's literally somewhat part of it, sort of.
If you like laughing at poorly done movies, I highly recommend the trilogy that was made
I say that as someone who really enjoyed the novel. They screw up even the best parts of the novel
Got to be honest, I do not think that is a book I would enjoy but as always, it was discussed well.
Why are you here if you haven't even bothered trying to read it?
I think that people who are against rand should try to live in a third world country where effort and vision are overshadowed by monetary interests and envy
You mean like America?
Business hippies! Great use of language
I feel sorry for people who need to justify their lack of empathy. Ayn Rand was a very superficial "philospher".
Have to resoectfully disagree. Nobody has as clear a vision as AynRand. If you are in any way a Statist then you will not like her vision and that is OK. But surely you can see the sharp decline in the West both economically and morally is a result of the Statist mindset not the objectivist mindset?
@@joepaluka9031 what moral decline?
true...@@joepaluka9031
@@joepaluka9031 Honestly, no I cannot. First of all, morals are SUBJECTIVE....not objective. So I am at a loss in understanding your subjective opinion that there has been a "sharp decline in the West both economically and morally". Also, I have no idea what a Statist is. Do you mean Stalinist? Like a Communist? Since I'm going for honesty here, I consider myself a Democratic Solialist Progressive fucking punk rocker. I don't want to live anywhere near Ayn Rand's "Utopia"...so I also disagree with your opinion that "Nobody has as clear a vision as Ayn Rand". Ayn Rand was a total C U Next Tuesday.
I've typed this out before on this channel, and will do so again: Rand was a loathsome human being, a callow thinker, and a hack writer. Her "philosophy" (essentially a rationalization of selfishness and greed) hardly deserves to be called such.
This is a really bad summary of Atlas and you read stuff into it that isn't there. That's the problem with most people who review Rand they bring their pre conceived notions into a book that are not there.
One of the most important novels of the 20th Century, and beyond …
Such a ridiculous plot lmao
Not only the plot, the ideology it exhibits is equally ridiculous.
For the most part, I thought the plot was one of the highlights of the book - some the logistics are questionable, but it's certainly an original idea (I literally just re-read it, and the downside is the plot only has small windows to properly get going between all the ceaseless monologuing). On the surface, the plot is best enjoyed as a piece of pulp mystery adventure.
The sky is falling, fear mongering view of the world--very difficult to take seriously.
With respect, do you still not see how the West is declining along the exact lines aynRand predicted inthis book?
@@joepaluka9031 Yes and no. I see it and certainly hope for a better future. Perhaps that is a delusional, even contrary stance, but as rational as I can be at this time.
🤮🤮🤮🤮
I'm so glad I was never forced to read her books in school.
But did you read them ever, period? If not, seems odd flat-out dismissing her whole-sale if you haven't even read a single page, and are just going off of what other people told you.
If you have, and disliked her, that's well and all. I've read most of her major work, and I'm not so much a 'fan' exactly (I agree on some points, but disagree on a lot others) as much as I find her morbidly fascinating.