Noah Centineo and Lana Condor Chemistry Tape Read for To All The Boys I've Loved Before

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 314

  • @ingrowntoenail1420
    @ingrowntoenail1420 2 года назад +10621

    they literally look like the cutest high school couple ever

    • @understandment7032
      @understandment7032 18 дней назад +1

      Dude, I literally love your profile pic and username.😂😂😂💀💀That's it. I'm following you lol.

  • @NatalieZii
    @NatalieZii 2 года назад +15892

    Holly molly. This felt more raw and real than what appeared in the movie.

    • @spacebar9733
      @spacebar9733 2 года назад +124

      the microphone also this scene was in the book (sort of)

    • @OmfgHiii
      @OmfgHiii 2 года назад +184

      cause this is like the whole movie resumed in a conversation

    • @madametj
      @madametj 2 года назад +195

      It seems like they were improving here but they probably made them stick to the script for the movie

    • @MK79797
      @MK79797 2 года назад +125

      I thought the same thing!! I was wayy more intrigued than thw actail movie. I’m like we need more conversations like this in movies than just cliché happy ever after stuff.

    • @RiaG
      @RiaG 2 года назад +24

      I wish this was the movie

  • @leena5531
    @leena5531 2 года назад +6278

    lana condor has such an adorable, animated way of speaking shes almost like a disney princess

    • @aliciaaghata
      @aliciaaghata 2 года назад +37

      so true

    • @kounyia
      @kounyia 2 месяца назад +42

      omg i was like oh this comment??? then i saw 0:40 rofl. literal animated disney princess.

  • @MelissaNgai
    @MelissaNgai 2 года назад +7126

    Wtf why was this so much cuter and felt realer than what we saw in the movies?

  • @Sam-0827
    @Sam-0827 2 года назад +7393

    This didn’t feel like a chemistry read, this didn’t feel like 2 actors. So so cute wtf

  • @Hyelee6714
    @Hyelee6714 2 года назад +12118

    Honestly, I never though of Noah as "a good actor" I mostly thought they casted him because he's cute, but damn, the way he acts is really natural (at least that's how I perceive it) it feels like an a actual person just having a conversation. Lana is great too, sometimes it feels like they're just improvising and if that's what it is they did amazing, and if it's the script omg it feels SO natural.

    • @CookieCreamCrumble
      @CookieCreamCrumble 2 года назад +463

      i think he's just similar to the character irl and has trouble playing other roles tbh

    • @xiopaovid1215
      @xiopaovid1215 2 года назад +210

      I first saw him in the show The Fosters he's really good, sadly after this movie, (in my opinion) they gave him shitty roles.

    • @IshratJahan-dh3ev
      @IshratJahan-dh3ev 2 года назад +80

      @@CookieCreamCrumble geez, yall literally hating because he's cute. He did the role he got really good, even if his personality seems similar (which I don't think so, I might just keep getting roles in this theme by the industry), he still portrayed different emotions so naturally that you find it hard to admit his skills. Ppl like you... smh

    • @fatoumatacisse3796
      @fatoumatacisse3796 2 года назад +113

      @@IshratJahan-dh3ev people disliked him because Netflix kept putting him in shitty movies after TATBILB they put him as the same flirty character in every movie even though he’s a good actor

    • @helenmaghinay7304
      @helenmaghinay7304 2 года назад +76

      I love how Peter Kavinsky came alive because of his protrayal. The hand in the back pocket and the spin? He made it so effortlessly, and I imagined Peter being that smooth and confident in real life. I truly believe he and Lana have so much more range, but it's Netflix that boxes them in. Noah can be so much more than the token highschool popular guy, and Lana can be so much more than the token highschool shy girl.

  • @eleanorjones8613
    @eleanorjones8613 2 года назад +4873

    Honestly this just reminds me how much the movies changed between the first and second one.
    I understand that Lara Jean would grow out of her shell but the awkwardness felt so much more over played in second and third movies
    This feels so sweet and so genuine and I feel like only the first movie captured this

    • @bloopbloopbloopbloopbloop
      @bloopbloopbloopbloopbloop 2 года назад +246

      they also switched directors for some dumb reason

    • @mangomunchin
      @mangomunchin 2 года назад +96

      @@bloopbloopbloopbloopbloop so they pulled a twilight.

    • @eleanorjones8613
      @eleanorjones8613 2 года назад +105

      @@bloopbloopbloopbloopbloop I know that, and its a flaw in the overall trilogy. The second one's lighting is so dark and the third is annoyingly bright.

    • @bloopbloopbloopbloopbloop
      @bloopbloopbloopbloopbloop 2 года назад +13

      @@mangomunchin yep exactly. I was so angry

    • @nottoomuch87
      @nottoomuch87 2 года назад +14

      @@bloopbloopbloopbloopbloop I knew then that those movies would suck lol. If it ain't broke..

  • @rachelzachariah
    @rachelzachariah 2 года назад +5090

    holy shit their chemistry is insane WHAT?? and i agree with so many people in the comments, like this was so much better than what the movie portrayed because it feels so much more real and raw than what we got in the end... it would've awesome to see them together in something more like the "before sunrise" movie series rather than something as highly stylized as the "to all the boys" movies

    • @lolafisher3453
      @lolafisher3453 2 года назад +34

      YES BEFORE SUNRISE.

    • @hay_bail1
      @hay_bail1 2 года назад +4

      @@lolafisher3453 literally what I was thinking!

    • @rocolas
      @rocolas 2 года назад +11

      I love the TATBILB style though if the director is reading this!

    • @linuseethat1micey
      @linuseethat1micey 2 года назад +3

      Yeah their chemistry is *astounding.

    • @jojotherapy008
      @jojotherapy008 Месяц назад

      O that’s why it’s called a chemistry read

  • @cirrusmacleod2628
    @cirrusmacleod2628 2 года назад +3089

    I feel like I’m eavesdropping. Like I’m in a public space, maybe at the park, and I’m sitting under a tree reading a book and I’m taking a break to people watch and I catch some of their conversation on a bench nearby. I’m like, ooo, this sounds good, and pretend to read but really I’m listening as hard as I can because they’re cute and they obviously have great chemistry, and by the end of the conversation I’m a little bummed they’re not together but I’m hopeful they’ll get there in time. And maybe every few weeks I’ll walk past the park and see the bench and think of them with a smile as I wonder what did happen between them in the end. And the thought that maybe I witnessed the beginnings of something beautiful is a treasure I’ll keep with me for a long time, and it is all the more precious because I’ll never know for sure.

    • @Atteindrelesetoile
      @Atteindrelesetoile 2 года назад +29

      Haha this was well written I love it

    • @maleiatremblay4642
      @maleiatremblay4642 Год назад +38

      I love how you painted this scene. It reminds me of how we are surrounded by so many lives, and in some ways we get to eavesdrop and listen into them

    • @totallynotaturtle._.5285
      @totallynotaturtle._.5285 Год назад +9

      This is the cutest comment I've ever read

    • @emilymeyers6069
      @emilymeyers6069 Год назад

      HAHAHAH smae

    • @SMya-xk3jr
      @SMya-xk3jr 2 месяца назад +3

      Are you a writer? This was beautiful

  • @glowynectarineslife
    @glowynectarineslife 2 года назад +5865

    the crew laughing makes this infinitely better omg

  • @tee-py3zx
    @tee-py3zx 2 года назад +2038

    They DEFINITELY should have done the scene like this in the movie. Just one shot, no fancy editing, mayyyybe some light music. Just seeing everything play out on their faces. Like everyone else is saying , this feels so much more raw and relatable, and you need to CONVEY THAT FEELING TO THE AUDIENCE in this snippet of them genuinely opening up for the first time, when the rest of the movie revolves around faking their relationship. im actually frustrated bc that would've been the perfect stylistic choice to highlight it as a memorable scene and to distinguish it from them pretending.

  • @adannayoutube4243
    @adannayoutube4243 2 года назад +2117

    this is one of comfort movies, but i wish i could watch it for the first time all over again

    • @itslala3076
      @itslala3076 2 года назад +3

      same:(

    • @dominiqueeden
      @dominiqueeden 2 года назад +11

      Have you read the books?! They are great - I read them first and watching the film felt like experiencing the story for the first time again might work for you :))

    • @adannayoutube4243
      @adannayoutube4243 2 года назад +8

      @@dominiqueeden i did actually! when the trailer first came out i ran to barnes & noble and binged the series before the film released lol

    • @SHEISJAI
      @SHEISJAI 2 года назад

      righttt this is one of my favorite movies

    • @jendowden
      @jendowden 2 года назад +1

      Right, it’s one of my favorite book and film series. It just gives me a warm comforting feeling.

  • @jasminemai9360
    @jasminemai9360 Месяц назад +174

    the fact they did this all in one take and it just flows and looks so natural. Like even if they have moments to look down to read (if they even are) they are so PERFECT GAWD

  • @anais9263
    @anais9263 2 года назад +1514

    If i could go back to watching this movie for the first time again I would. Nothing has ever compared to the comfort TATBILB gives me

    • @spacebar9733
      @spacebar9733 2 года назад +7

      fr

    • @werew3
      @werew3 2 года назад +21

      Omg right. It was everything & i loved how beautiful the first movie was!

    • @dominiqueeden
      @dominiqueeden 2 года назад +15

      Have you read the books?! They are great - I read them first and watching the film felt like experiencing the story for the first time again might work for you :))

    • @gigi2502
      @gigi2502 2 года назад +2

      frrr

    • @anais9263
      @anais9263 2 года назад

      @@dominiqueeden I haven't read the books! I have a friend that highly recommends them as well

  • @megurnngoh
    @megurnngoh 2 года назад +675

    the crew laughing in the background just goes to show how they were a perfect fit for this movie

  • @adelynebuchholz7920
    @adelynebuchholz7920 2 года назад +960

    this was the kind of acting the movie needed to have

    • @merry_christmas
      @merry_christmas 2 года назад +284

      I don't think it's the acting that's changed much. It's the directing/cut scenes/camera angles that make this very natural conversation all too stylized.

    • @any8574
      @any8574 2 года назад +39

      I love how natural it is. We need more movies that feel like real life

  • @Nonamegirl1
    @Nonamegirl1 2 года назад +666

    I usually avoid watching audition tapes, chemistry reads, and what not because they can be really cringe but I freaking loved this!! It was literally the coolest thing to watch them act out their lines in such a realistic way. This is damn great acting holy shit!

  • @shaesingson
    @shaesingson 2 года назад +949

    i loved this so much. I felt like it truly was the book being acted out because I was so immersed into this alternate reality, I forgot I was watching two actors and thought I was really watching the characters come alive. :') This felt so real - reminds me of my own Peter Kavinsky as a teen :)

    • @louisaamabel708
      @louisaamabel708 2 года назад +14

      exactly :’) i feel like us book-first girlies get it!!!

    • @bodilycoffee1368
      @bodilycoffee1368 2 года назад +2

      YES! I came to see just a few seconds and leave, but I just couldn't. Suddenly the scene was ending and it felt like I had the book in my hand

    • @pinkfrostedcwpcake
      @pinkfrostedcwpcake 3 месяца назад

      The way he looks at her❤❤😢

  • @lanielovespopculture
    @lanielovespopculture 2 года назад +609

    This felt so real. I was truly entranced

  • @meeniemoe
    @meeniemoe 2 года назад +1091

    I want them to reunite for a 500 days of summer type of movie in like 10 years a la Leo and Kate style 😭 Or a revolutionary road type. Ugh would be soo good.

    • @riverthoughts2400
      @riverthoughts2400 2 года назад +35

      Yessssss!!!! And like Keanu and Sandra Bullock, and Drew Barrymore & Adam Sandler! I love their chemistry too - I hope they do a movie again soon

    • @Ambereigh
      @Ambereigh 2 года назад +33

      500 days of summer is not a romantic movie lol

    • @gibeons
      @gibeons 2 года назад +7

      Or maybe a cameo on “the summer I turned pretty”

    • @galaxylucia1898
      @galaxylucia1898 2 года назад +5

      😮Revolutionary Toad was so depressing what?!?!?🤨

    • @meeniemoe
      @meeniemoe 2 года назад

      @@galaxylucia1898 😂😂😂

  • @hialyssah
    @hialyssah 2 года назад +428

    How is this 100x better than what we were given in the movie?!

  • @chronostv2071
    @chronostv2071 2 года назад +529

    I just love their chemistry balance❤❤❤❤

  • @werew3
    @werew3 2 года назад +425

    Aw they were babies here. So cute. I love how authentic & real it felt! Definitely love that the crew laughed & felt the chemistry ❤

  • @littleseaturtle
    @littleseaturtle 2 года назад +109

    not me kicking my feet, cheeks hurting from smiling watching this 😭 the romcom genre was NEVER the same, i wish i could wipe it from my memory so i could experience it for the first time because at this point i have the whole movie memorized front to back smh..

  • @0104brit
    @0104brit 2 года назад +504

    The scene in the movie was already great, who knew that it could've been better. I promise I don't get giddy, but they are soo adorable like I can't...🤗

  • @mxxxn
    @mxxxn 2 года назад +207

    It's quite magical when actors have good chemistry, everything they're saying seems so natural 🥺

  • @joyajohnson2216
    @joyajohnson2216 2 года назад +261

    they’re both so natural and wonderful together. how beautiful.

  • @coffeeatmidnght
    @coffeeatmidnght 2 года назад +192

    The chemistry is insane!! Lana deserves better I want to see her in more movies. I think Noah needs to try things outside of the high school trope too, he seems like a good actor.

    • @coffeeatmidnght
      @coffeeatmidnght 2 года назад +15

      also, I genuinely think the first movie was amazing, the second and third didn’t do the books justice or their acting justice 😭 idk what went wrong

    • @nicholettetsungai
      @nicholettetsungai 2 года назад +6

      Noah acted in Black Adam and was great too!

    • @tireddaily
      @tireddaily 3 месяца назад +4

      i really liked him in the recruit

    • @neb.9489
      @neb.9489 Месяц назад

      @@coffeeatmidnghtA change of directors

    • @coffeeatmidnght
      @coffeeatmidnght Месяц назад

      @@neb.9489 im just seeing these replies lol but yes I found out shortly after my comment the switch of directors ☹️

  • @wdrh03
    @wdrh03 2 года назад +86

    Put them in a film like Before Sunrise. Natural dialogues with long takes, no heavy editing! They will nail it!

  • @blackbirdflyyx
    @blackbirdflyyx 2 года назад +136

    I really enjoyed the first movie but not enough to watch it a second time (though enough to follow through with the second and third), yet THIS chemistry read makes me want to re-watch. Their chemistry really was so pure and instantaneous. 🥺

  • @tintind7043
    @tintind7043 2 года назад +159

    Woooahhh.. this screen test.. is GOLD. Method acting. This was way more natural and felt soo real and raw compared to the film. Wow. Brava to both of them, they played out kavinsky and covey phenomenally well in just these 5 minutes alone

  • @jellybaebi
    @jellybaebi 2 года назад +210

    I didn’t even notice they had started playing background music until the very end. That’s how immersed I was in them and what they were saying even though I’ve already watched the movie.

    • @rishlyc
      @rishlyc 2 года назад +2

      I didn't notice till I saw this

  • @belensanchezs5526
    @belensanchezs5526 2 года назад +280

    And chemistry there was indeed ❤

  • @ailiaone
    @ailiaone 2 года назад +140

    Ughh raw and early reads are always the best, always so much better than the real thing

  • @alliegiaccone6883
    @alliegiaccone6883 2 года назад +41

    Why is this better than all 3 movies

  • @seabr33ze
    @seabr33ze 3 месяца назад +38

    THEY SHOULDVE KEPT THE SCENE LIKE THIS IN THE MOVIE ITS SO MUCH BETTER

  • @sarahroy6655
    @sarahroy6655 3 месяца назад +27

    3:23 Omg this part this literally is the book being played out, I cannot😭😭
    Also the way Peter looks at LJ, we all know hes alrdy in love 😭

  • @fairlysleepy
    @fairlysleepy 2 года назад +53

    The first TATBILB is genuinely a really good movie. It is a cute romantic movie about two kids just trying to find their way in HS. I love it so so so much. The second is a flop personally. The third one is okay but nothing can compare to the first movie. Noah is a good actor portraying roles similar to his irl character but netflix really gave him cartoonish roles to play. Man I’d do anything to watch TATBILB again

  • @yaren_
    @yaren_ 2 года назад +139

    wow they did really good

  • @jujufilmss
    @jujufilmss 2 года назад +73

    omgg wait lowkey best performance ive seen from him... just very real not sure how to explain

  • @helenmaghinay7304
    @helenmaghinay7304 2 года назад +19

    The first movie was as faithful as it could be from the source material. The second and third ones diverged more though so the first movie has a special place in my heart.

  • @Lord_Fenrir
    @Lord_Fenrir 2 года назад +146

    I swear, those two feel like acting soulmates. DAMN!! they're so good at their jobs

  • @savannalee
    @savannalee 2 года назад +251

    they’re so fucking cute wtf

  • @skholiwezondi986
    @skholiwezondi986 2 года назад +35

    "Carlos Meyer? CARlos? carLOS?" 😂😂 I'm going to watch this movie again

  • @stefw46
    @stefw46 2 года назад +58

    Lana Condor looks like a Disney princess here.

  • @rice2462
    @rice2462 2 года назад +60

    Lana is so charming 😭 chemistry indeed

  • @juliabassham4864
    @juliabassham4864 Год назад +31

    3:25 the way he looks at her 🥺

  • @aqsa629
    @aqsa629 2 года назад +15

    why didnt i watched it before. it is amazing, their chemistry and expressions are so on point, mindblowing. these extra dialogues are good too.

  • @anniem.7482
    @anniem.7482 2 года назад +25

    They had so much chemistry!! It was so cool to see how much they acted so well when they have barley known each other at this point.

  • @seekingthelight2029
    @seekingthelight2029 2 года назад +44

    How are they so natural?! I wanna act like this 😱

  • @genevawelsh9133
    @genevawelsh9133 2 года назад +45

    I truly could not stop watching this they really did a great job with it. Loved it even more with the crew laughing in the background

  • @ClaireIsabellaa
    @ClaireIsabellaa 3 месяца назад +16

    even in the movie, their lines felt so natural. one of the best romcom leads this past decade

  • @bijanlove8000
    @bijanlove8000 2 года назад +69

    They did amazing!

  • @bea4793
    @bea4793 2 месяца назад +6

    this is defrosting the teenage girl in me and I love it

  • @andriamihajaannick403
    @andriamihajaannick403 2 года назад +54

    The chemestry since day one

  • @lillianle6805
    @lillianle6805 2 года назад +60

    3:09 when he says “Covey” and looks at her like that AHHH 🥹

  • @nviah
    @nviah 2 месяца назад +8

    yall i got chills

    • @nviah
      @nviah 2 месяца назад +3

      this felt too natural

  • @owlsareeverything4152
    @owlsareeverything4152 2 года назад +26

    I was so obsessed with this movie when it first came out. And that was from me only watching clips of it.😭

  • @sahiil_17
    @sahiil_17 2 года назад +53

    Noahhh i love him how cute he is ❤🥺

  • @sangiguite6843
    @sangiguite6843 2 месяца назад +5

    I could watch the entire movie like this

    • @starrr432
      @starrr432 2 месяца назад

      right. it's more natural this way

  • @sherleyordonneau3608
    @sherleyordonneau3608 Год назад +4

    It already feels very natural and genuine between them. They are great !

  • @eliannebororing8971
    @eliannebororing8971 2 года назад +60

    damn that was soo good omg

  • @maeve6004
    @maeve6004 2 года назад +20

    I’m obsessed with how he calls her covey 😭

  • @dianeyoung8130
    @dianeyoung8130 2 года назад +52

    noah in every movie: woah woah woah woah

  • @mylifehasbeentakenover
    @mylifehasbeentakenover 2 года назад +15

    oh my god? this was actually so cute. very natural!

  • @riathezeita
    @riathezeita 20 дней назад +2

    fine I'll just go and watch the movie AGAIN

  • @anns8370
    @anns8370 2 года назад +5

    Crazzzy good. And I always knew acting was hard but how they pull this off, mind blowing.

  • @glitterflyy
    @glitterflyy 2 года назад +15

    Yes want to see this pair get to be serious!!! Noah’s acting here is incredible, and Lana shines without trying, they def pushed the “youth” in TATB

  • @aprilsheehan1
    @aprilsheehan1 6 месяцев назад +3

    love noah 🫶 the way he’s acting in this, especially for the first minute or two actually reminds me more of the way he acted jesus in the fosters than peter. he’s such a great actor i love all of his characters

  • @littlemissjazz13
    @littlemissjazz13 2 года назад +4

    Ughhhh they still make me blush :’)

  • @a.dgirlstar4721
    @a.dgirlstar4721 2 года назад +6

    This has become my new favorite thing on the internet

  • @ellyzhaastudillo
    @ellyzhaastudillo 2 года назад +55

    omg the chemistry

  • @osaa3912
    @osaa3912 2 года назад +40

    they are so cute !!!

  • @carcrash9768
    @carcrash9768 2 года назад +57

    i feel like nobody talks about how big these actors were and all the hype the first movie had in 2018 but the second and third were just kinda there

    • @Neoragyu
      @Neoragyu 6 месяцев назад +6

      The 2nd and 3rd were big as well and they have this cult following too, but ofc anything thay comes first will hit different.

  • @laurathepoet
    @laurathepoet 2 года назад +3

    this scene made me cry in the movie and made me cry here. i think they have great chemistry. so many longing looks!

  • @thisbrightlight4047
    @thisbrightlight4047 2 года назад +46

    Woah... I think I forgot how good Noah is.

  • @taliw7736
    @taliw7736 2 года назад +12

    Love that whole scene great emotions and they have good chemistry

  • @kyradenisealston2796
    @kyradenisealston2796 2 года назад +11

    I miss them so much

  • @coralbleaching
    @coralbleaching Год назад +3

    I need more of this. I don’t care write the books. 4. 5. 6. Do it!

  • @raynanisbett1436
    @raynanisbett1436 2 года назад +106

    Everyone thinks Noah is bad but he’s so good in the fosters lol

    • @issygzmn8161
      @issygzmn8161 2 года назад +38

      YES! Noah is such a good actor he just gets type cast. Can’t blame him for sticking with what he’s good at tho

    • @fatoumatacisse3796
      @fatoumatacisse3796 2 года назад +7

      It’s cause Netflix kept putting him in shit movies when he can do so much better

  • @hellokottyy
    @hellokottyy 7 месяцев назад +16

    2:13 the awkward stare

  • @wendyschwarz9811
    @wendyschwarz9811 2 года назад +4

    Wow this is so good I watched the whole show and I loved it but goodness the chemistry and the acting is perfect. It felt really real..

  • @esther.sandoval
    @esther.sandoval 2 года назад +8

    This makes me want to re read this series again

  • @srtamagdiel6683
    @srtamagdiel6683 2 года назад +19

    THE BEST TEENAGE COUPLE EVER

  • @parisalena
    @parisalena 2 месяца назад +10

    WHY DO I HAVE TEARS IN MY EYS

  • @noemiesroses
    @noemiesroses 21 день назад +1

    Made me want to rewatch it again, second time this year

  • @marinasilva1228
    @marinasilva1228 2 года назад +4

    Wow I actually teared up that was amazing

  • @CA-ig3ne
    @CA-ig3ne 2 месяца назад +1

    THIS IS SO MUCH BETTER AGGHHHHHHH

  • @breeisjustababy
    @breeisjustababy 2 месяца назад +3

    This was so good. I'm cheesing so hard rn. 😊

  • @XoeNatalia
    @XoeNatalia 2 года назад +17

    Now I got to watch all three movies. 😅 dang it

  • @mm-jy8vy
    @mm-jy8vy 2 месяца назад +2

    I felt like I was eavesdropping on a real couple’s conversation 😱❤

  • @Diisycorner
    @Diisycorner Месяц назад

    There chemistry wow it’s so on point ❤ and I need to rewatch these movies.

  • @haylslou8943
    @haylslou8943 2 года назад +6

    The chemistry is 🔥

  • @AmaraEmme
    @AmaraEmme 2 года назад +1

    This was some of the best acting I’ve ever seen

  • @tonigolmayo
    @tonigolmayo 2 месяца назад +3

    they have me giggling and kicking my feet omg

  • @kikisdayy
    @kikisdayy 2 года назад +10

    4:45 the way he looks down at her lips 😭

  • @nviah
    @nviah 2 месяца назад +2

    yall the chills yall the chills!!

  • @riveroverland5902
    @riveroverland5902 2 года назад +6

    Lana is so beautiful here!

  • @blossumnouci
    @blossumnouci Месяц назад +2

    Love this. Great chemistry

  • @nihanikanoel
    @nihanikanoel 2 года назад +8

    It felt more real because their was a lot more improve it seems, they killed that