When you think about it, everything Celestia says kinda makes sense. Because given that the blizzard caused by the Windigos was pretty much apocalyptic, it was only natural that ponykind would've experienced a plague of death at that time. because with all that cold weather they couldn't grow crops, and there's no telling how many ponies probably froze to death or died from disease. But anyway, as usual you guys did such a marvelous and outstanding job on this dub! Truly brilliant and masterful work and Happy Hearth's Warming!!!
Interesting to think about is the fact, that there might be a lot of ruins, under the polar ice sheet and that the Crystal empire might have been the only part of the pony ancestral lands to survive.
Gotta love Celestia's blunt honesty. Would expect nothing less of an immortal goddess of immense wisdom and experience. My favorite MLP character besides Rarity.
I love whenever Celestia is depicted as JUST a tiny bit off her rocker, nothing crazy like being a tyrant or a serial killer, just a twinge unhinged to help sell how unbelievably old she is.
More than likely the play is a massive oversimplification of events. It is highly unlikely that the leaders would travel alone, save for a single attendant, into unknown territory. It is far more likely that they marched out at the head of a large host with runners ready and waiting to return home and inform their peoples if they found a new land to settle.
When she puts it like that, I imagine Hearth’s Warming as the favorite holiday of Discord, Longface, Master Frown, and any other villain who loves sadness.
Finally! Someone who's asking the real questions! The idea that the few founders of Equestria were the first and only residents means that just about everyone born in Equestrian roots is related to one another in some way
@@thegoldenbrickstone yeah, I was waiting for the post-comic segment where they bring up how that would mean that Equestria is a MASSIVELY inbred population. That segment never came, but I knew in my heart it was true. Now my question would be: in this interpretation, how the heck are the ponies of modern-day not grotesquely deformed? Unless… those short muzzles…
Nothing screams "tidings of joy and goodwill" more than the suffering of thousands of people dying to a blizzard, Twilight! Everyone knows that! Even Pinkie Pie!
And I thought that hearing "Santa's not real" hurt childhoods enough. That is a *new level* of "childhood ruined". Celestia, we love you, but you can be a real jerk sometimes.
Twilly-Boo just got a dose of reality... 0~o dang the holidays can be both cruel as happy. Welp! Twilight will be in therapy for the foreseeable future... Is Dr. Wolf available??
That sounds like maybe Hearth's Warming Eve in a way is like both Veterans day and Christmas. Also I think there was a comic book series that showed that there was a fourth pony tribe that was forgotten or abandon during the time of the first Hearth's Warming Eve.
I’ll say Merry Christmas here then! … unless there’s some macabre undertones I don’t know about! 😂 Ignorance is bliss I always say! Merry Christmas all, and a happy and healthy 2025!
Well, it the Bible does talk about how after the wise men came to Herod had all male children under the age of about three killed to prevent a threat to his throne. Then there is that whole Krampus tradition......
I've given you the 169th like on this video, Scribbly. Kinkly nice, huh? Oh, and I'd said Celestia's lines along with the comics, and let me tell ya; they're pretty funny to read.
Now remember, the reason why all of ponydom needs to be friendly towards each other is not because it's the right thing to do. We aren't being kind, generous, compassionate, loving, reasonable and wholesome for its own sake. We aren't holding back on racism and prejudice because of ideological reasons to be good towards each other. No, the reason we have to behave with tolerance and understanding towards each other is because if we don't, then evil spirit creatures will appear and freeze the land.
You're not celebrating the suffering of the ponies but rather celebrating the end of the suffering. Because after all hart's warming eve didn't start until the end of the blizzard.
And that's why when it comes to MLP, I pretend that they use "Chistmas", "Halloween", and "Valentine's Day". Instead of "Hearth's Warming Eve", "Nightmare Night" and "Hearts and Hooves Day". Especially because of their connections to Christianity. Being a Christian myself.
![[MLP Hearth's Warming Special] Mistletoe Mourning (GRIMDARK / TRAGEDY / INFECTION AU / ROMANCE)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/xSc98ZXC61M/mqdefault.jpg)
![[MLP Hearth's Warming Special] Mistletoe Mourning (GRIMDARK / TRAGEDY / INFECTION AU / ROMANCE)](/img/tr.png)
![[MLP Halloween Comic Dub] UNIT 002 (DARK SAUCY COMEDY)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/pxsJ3Q1R7Z8/mqdefault.jpg)
When you think about it, everything Celestia says kinda makes sense. Because given that the blizzard caused by the Windigos was pretty much apocalyptic, it was only natural that ponykind would've experienced a plague of death at that time. because with all that cold weather they couldn't grow crops, and there's no telling how many ponies probably froze to death or died from disease.
But anyway, as usual you guys did such a marvelous and outstanding job on this dub! Truly brilliant and masterful work and Happy Hearth's Warming!!!
Interesting to think about is the fact, that there might be a lot of ruins, under the polar ice sheet and that the Crystal empire might have been the only part of the pony ancestral lands to survive.
Gotta love Celestia's blunt honesty. Would expect nothing less of an immortal goddess of immense wisdom and experience. My favorite MLP character besides Rarity.
I love whenever Celestia is depicted as JUST a tiny bit off her rocker, nothing crazy like being a tyrant or a serial killer, just a twinge unhinged to help sell how unbelievably old she is.
Give hugs to Twilight. Her foalhood has been shattered.
Twilight: "That's pretty messed up, Celestia."
Celestia: "Pretty messed up indeed, Twilight."
Great job Celestia, you scarred Twilight.... and me too 😭 How are we suppose to have a Happy Hearts-warming now?
More than likely the play is a massive oversimplification of events. It is highly unlikely that the leaders would travel alone, save for a single attendant, into unknown territory. It is far more likely that they marched out at the head of a large host with runners ready and waiting to return home and inform their peoples if they found a new land to settle.
Trollestia strikes again.
That was dark move, Celestia. Poor Twilight
🖤✨💙💜
When she puts it like that, I imagine Hearth’s Warming as the favorite holiday of Discord, Longface, Master Frown, and any other villain who loves sadness.
Well this sort makes the Apple Family Tree much bigger don't it?
Finally! Someone who's asking the real questions! The idea that the few founders of Equestria were the first and only residents means that just about everyone born in Equestrian roots is related to one another in some way
@@thegoldenbrickstone yeah, I was waiting for the post-comic segment where they bring up how that would mean that Equestria is a MASSIVELY inbred population.
That segment never came, but I knew in my heart it was true.
Now my question would be: in this interpretation, how the heck are the ponies of modern-day not grotesquely deformed? Unless… those short muzzles…
Nothing screams "tidings of joy and goodwill" more than the suffering of thousands of people dying to a blizzard, Twilight! Everyone knows that! Even Pinkie Pie!
That was great! Hahahaha I love the reality of it all-It's like Twilight was just told that there's no Santa or something
This screams Trollestia, and I am here for it. Nice job, guys. Twilight's holiday is officially ruined
Wow, Celestia. You've scarred Twilight now with that brutal honest truth!
Many holidays and traditions have a background of suffering and tragedy buried within their history... Happy Holidays,,, /)
Yeah, I love how almost unhinged she sounded, in how bluntly honest she was
This is what we call, Insan-stia
The cousin to Molestia
Hearth's warming eve - a joyous occasion
And I thought that hearing "Santa's not real" hurt childhoods enough. That is a *new level* of "childhood ruined".
Celestia, we love you, but you can be a real jerk sometimes.
You’re a mean one~ 🎶
Celestia~ 🎶
This is why we dont ask questions we cant stand the answer of. You can never unknow Twilight
We celebrate Heart’s Warming because somepony else’s wasn’t lucky enough to get the same thing 😂
Well that makes the holiday very depressing. It was probably just a scouting mission for the leaders who would then order their ponies to migrate
Vladi Voices & Scribbler you both did a fantastic job. Keep up the good work. Have a wonderful day.
celestia knows exactly what shes doing....
It gets even crazier when you realize there are 6 ponies, 3 male and 3 female, 2 ponies from each gender from each tribe, to bring back the pony race
Every child's face when you tell them their parents leave their presents 😂
Twilly-Boo just got a dose of reality... 0~o dang the holidays can be both cruel as happy. Welp! Twilight will be in therapy for the foreseeable future... Is Dr. Wolf available??
Trollestia Strikes Again
Celestia, Fluttershy would not like to hear that. She'd break down into a big cry fest... 😢
That sounds like maybe Hearth's Warming Eve in a way is like both Veterans day and Christmas. Also I think there was a comic book series that showed that there was a fourth pony tribe that was forgotten or abandon during the time of the first Hearth's Warming Eve.
“Is it not obvious? They died!” wow Celestia that was dark
Good job Celestia now Twilight will never see heart's warming eve the same way again
This is the first time I've ever heard the phrase "tissue of lies" before
Can you make episode 11 of Friendship Is Tragic 2?
well its kinda better then becoming like the donner party story
trollestia strikes again
I’ll say Merry Christmas here then! … unless there’s some macabre undertones I don’t know about! 😂 Ignorance is bliss I always say!
Merry Christmas all, and a happy and healthy 2025!
Well, it the Bible does talk about how after the wise men came to Herod had all male children under the age of about three killed to prevent a threat to his throne. Then there is that whole Krampus tradition......
That's a small gene pool to restart from...
No wonder so many ponies look alike.
Celly is just telling it like it is, just like there's no such thing as competent royal guards. :p
Poor poor Twilight
It seems Celestia is proud to scaring her greatest student for life.
Are you ok Twilight.
It’s gonna be hard celebrating the holidays when you drop the bomb like that😓
Chalk up another to the list of topics to NOT talk about around Hearth's Warming. Especially around Twilight.
Gotta love good old shower thoughts
I think Twilight Sparkle is going to have a good hearth's warming eve 😔
Poor Twilight XD I Love this comic!
"My government needs me!" 🤣
Poor Twilight I want to hug her
I looked at the description before the video and it said Scribbler all voices and then... I hear a Vladi Jumpscare🤣
Brutal cruel honesty
Honestly that makes sense
*hug twilight*
I've given you the 169th like on this video, Scribbly.
Kinkly nice, huh?
Oh, and I'd said Celestia's lines along with the comics, and let me tell ya; they're pretty funny to read.
Damn you Celestia. I'll take you down if it's the very last thing I'll do.😊😅😮😢🎉😂❤or not. But. I just got to try.
Awwwwww how dare you celestia do this to poor twily!!!
1:40 poor Twilight.
I blame discord disguised as Celestia
Can you make episode 5 of History Repeats?
So this was Ponykind's Toba Eruption.
Now remember, the reason why all of ponydom needs to be friendly towards each other is not because it's the right thing to do. We aren't being kind, generous, compassionate, loving, reasonable and wholesome for its own sake. We aren't holding back on racism and prejudice because of ideological reasons to be good towards each other. No, the reason we have to behave with tolerance and understanding towards each other is because if we don't, then evil spirit creatures will appear and freeze the land.
I love that that's 100% canon. It's like how you can't go in the woods; Why? *Because the woods are wolves, and will eat you.*
Sprout Cloverleaf says hello.
You're not celebrating the suffering of the ponies but rather celebrating the end of the suffering. Because after all hart's warming eve didn't start until the end of the blizzard.
Poor Twilight, I think I feel what she feel too 😢
Aaaaaa Christmas is hereeee U Wish u a merry Christmas ❤❤❤
I know what I’m watching Christmas Eve
Ah, the pony deaths of the holidays...
Tia please stop before i Drop a boxcar on you...
Look you're being mean ok?
...thanks
Hug?
Pony kombat
Liu kang:Twilight sparkle
Johnny Cage:pinkie pie
Sonya blade:spitfire
Raiden:princess celestia
Kano:dr caballeron
Sub Zero:rainbow dash
Scorpion:fluttershy
Reptile:spike
Shang tsung:queen chrysalis
Kung lao:applejack
Kitana:rarity
Jax:big macintosh
Baraka:Rover/diamond dog
Mileena:pinkamena diane pie
Jade:daring do
Smoke:sweetie belle
Noob saibot:nightmare
Shao kahn:queen opaline
Sindel:mane-iac
Stryker:soarin
Cyrax:applebloom
Sektor:scootaloo
Sheeva:iron will
Nightwolf:zecora
Kabal:Gilda
Rain:derpy hooves
Ermac:trixie lulamoon
Chameleon:sunburst
Khameleon:autumn blaze
Kai:Marble pie
Tanya:strawberry sunrise
Reiko:lighting dust
Fujin:princess luna
Quan chi:Starlight glimmer
Jarek:Marble pie
Shinnok:grogar
No face:Zephyr breeze
Tasia:Shining armor
Bo rai cho:Berry punch
Li mei:flash Sentry
Kenshi:snowdrop
Mavado:lord tirek
Frost:strongheart
Hsu hao:carrot top
Nitara:daybreaker
Moloch:troubleshoes
Mokap:button mash
Blaze:sunset shimmer
Sareena:princess cadance
Shujinko:Luster Dawn
Havik:discord
Ashrah:moon dancer
Kobra:lyra heartstring
Hotaru:Octavia melody
Dairou:prince rutherford
Kira:bon bon
Darrius:Vinyl scratch
Onaga:princess ember
Taven:pound cake
Daegon:pumpkin cake
Skarlet:babs seed
Erron black:braeburn
Kotal kahn:king thorax
Ferra/torr:cloud chaser/flitter
Tremor:maud pie
Triborg:diamond tiara
Kollector:cheese sandwich
Geras:dr whooves
Okay but then how did they repopulate the new Equestria?
Reproduction?
poor baby omg! 😭
poor twilight, lol.
Can you make episode 5 of My Little Pony History Repeats?
Ok... that was ... much O_O
What do you think Spike and the rest of the group along with the CMC and the Alicorns would say if they saw this?
Trollestia ffs
My Little Pony Horse History is Dark
This Comic Dub is funny
The Re-population problem alone...
As they say, "Ignorance is bliss," Twilight.
Basically why we don’t celebrate Columbus Day anymore
Nightmare fuel
Hey Scribbler I think you should read The Strength Of Our Bond by Nailah.
That got dark fast😅
how did only 6 ponies repopulate an entire nation?
This is a very dark truth about what happened to all the ponies when their leaders founded Equestria. I don't understand what type of logic this is
And that's why when it comes to MLP, I pretend that they use "Chistmas", "Halloween", and "Valentine's Day". Instead of "Hearth's Warming Eve", "Nightmare Night" and "Hearts and Hooves Day". Especially because of their connections to Christianity. Being a Christian myself.
Is that similar to the matches story?!
Oh?
It was a trap
Le dijo que santa no existe
Dark Celestia is best Celestia
🎭
You asked.
❤️🩹🥹wowwwww
Cruel
Wtf is wrong with celestia
Sorry, but I can't hear "A tissue of lies" without thinking of this.
ruclips.net/video/uO569fBzUO8/видео.html
That didn’t actually happen. They didn’t die. Please delete this video now.