Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.
English Medium Blessing or Curse? Sonam Wangchuk on New Education Policy
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 4 авг 2020
- One of the biggest transformational features of the recently announced New Education Policy of India is the use of mother tongue as a Medium of Instruction at the Primary level. Unfortunately not many seem to understand the significance of this step as we are still reeling under the influence of our colonial past. In this video Sonam Wangchuk shows that the top 20 countries in the world (in GDP terms) all use their mother tongue as the medium of education and the bottom 20 countries in the world, most of them in Africa, use English or a European colonial language as the medium of instruction.
For those who still have doubts about the performance of children who study in non-English languages as the medium, he presents two examples that will change their perceptions forever.
Follow Sonam Wangchuk on Social Media:
Instagram: @wangchuksworld
/ wangchuksworld
Facebook: @wangchuksworld
/ wangchuksworld
LinkedIn: @wangchuksworld
/ wangchuksworld
Twitter: @Wangchuk66
/ wangchuk66
I am Tibetan. Thank you all the Indian and Indian government for supporting and caring Tibetan people. Now we try our best to give it back to Indian people.
Proud of you brother
🥺
I'm proud of you. Keep spreading love
We together fight Chinese regime
Wow brother..so overwhelmed by tibetans' love towards Indians
Tibet culture m baare mai pdhaya jaye
Lucky to have an intellectual who is a good teacher with best intentions, Namaskara Guruji.
🙏🙏🙏
I was Tibetan refugee from India, we are so great full to India. India is the greatest country in the world. I love India, and always wishing everything best for India. Indians should be proud and acknowledge their true beautiful self. 🙏☀️
sarve bhavantu sukhinaḥ sarve santu nirāmayāḥ...
Don't tell refugee you are part our indian people god bless you
u r our brother. This country is yours too
Tibet must be free and get back it's independence. Dalai Lama must not accept Chinese occupation of Tibet. Chinese communist party will destroy Tibetan culture forever if Tibetan don't fight at national and international level against China occupation of Tibet
Free tibet...
अंग्रेजी मात्र एक भाषा है और हिंदी हमारी मातृभाषा है 🙏🙏
सोनम वांगचुक जी को प्रणाम 🙏🙏
Hindi sabki matribhaasha nahi hai gawaarrr
I wish out of the nominated people for rajya sabha includes him too so that we have a voice
JK mein L join krde wahi bahot hain
Fully agree wd the idea Mr Modi
Badnami hogiiiii
@@fmyfavouritesongs A guy asked a girl in a library: Do you mind if I sit beside you? The girl replied with a loud voice: I DON'T WANT TO SPEND THE NIGHT WITH YOU! All the students in the library started staring at the guy, he was embarrassed. After a couple of minutes, the girl walked quietly to the guy's table and said: I study psychology and I know what a man is thinking, I guess you felt embarrassed right? The guy responded with a loud voice: $500 FOR ONE NIGHT? THAT'S TOO MUCH! All the people in the library looked at the girl in shock. The guy whispered in her ears: I study Law and I know how to make someone feel guilty.
Please check out my youtube channel ruclips.net/video/Aq_327jFGhM/видео.html
Start a campaign on change.org?
You must come and meet some students here in Pune studying in simple local marathi medium schools ... They are so sharp.. be it science or mathematics .. they are just there !!
Ya i think government school students are more creative and confident,if they are given proper education they will definitely excel
Yes true
THEY HARASSED PREGNANT LADY!! ruclips.net/video/RbeUBP5AoCE/видео.html
I'm from Pune. And I totally agree with you Sumedha.
@@harshithababukumuda490 that if will be constant till we get a young man leading the country
Don't expect young a Rahul Gandhi
He is a noob
If a child is learning in his mother tongue he can express his thoughts and ideas ...bcz we need to express not impress
Kisme app lilhe ho woh to dekho phele language dekho
Watch this and know about ruclips.net/video/BWi0vwlDs5o/видео.html
@@rishabhpandey8782 और आपने कौनसी भाषा में लिखा है?
Absolutely right ❤️
Bhai lekin English global language hai. Aap medium of instruction matrbhasha rakh sakte ho, par English aaj ke zamane mein seekhna zaruri h.
I myself had my primary education in marathi, my mother tongue, and now I realize..it helped me a lot
Jai Maharashtra
How did it help if I may ask?
@@DH12UV it helped me too. I learnt in Marathi school till 5th standard. When I got admitted to English school in 6th , I learnt English very quickly. Those who came from English medium school performed less than me in Science and Maths.
How? And do you think it would be difficult if you studied in English..
English is just a language not the parameters of intelligency.
Hain bhai jitna achha english bologe utne hi tez ho
Says the guy who writes his own comment in english...irony
@@therandomreacherचलो किसी को तो समझ मे आया।😂😂
But coporate wale nahi mante. Mohoday bolne se budhdhu bolte hai.
Especially in india
U will definitely be the education minister of India.
Edit - next p.m.
Sonam sir SHOULD be our EDUCATION MINISTER... 🙏🇮🇳
Sonam sir should be in minister
@@raazsingh1364 THEY HARASSED PREGNANT LADY!! ruclips.net/video/RbeUBP5AoCE/видео.html
@@harveyspecter1795 and u are promoting it here ?
Wow, such an amazing video, really eye opener. Pls President bring him to RAJYA SABHA.
Rather he should be the next President of India India
@@muraliparameswaran4182 that would be too much !!
आप एक सच्चे भारतीय हैं 🙏🙏🙏
I have learned from Marathi medium... And I can relate to this Sir... Whatever you are saying is right and important..
If a child learn in his mother tongue, his grasping power increases tremendously.
Now my English is better than my friends, who went to English medium schools.
Can you little elaborate the matter brother?
In which class did you switch your medium from Marathi to English?
I agree with you dear
Same as me...I went to English medium after 6th class from Hindi Medium school..!!
@@kuntalghosh. I switched to English after 10th standard.. My neighbors told me, you won't be able to study further as all your books will be in English language. But today, I am MBA in Finance, working as Senior Software Analyst.
@@pranaykargutkar Great brother.
मैं पांच (5) भाषाएं बोलता हूं।
और मैं विदेशियों को हिंदी सिखा रहा हूं।
हिंदी की अहमियत और खूबसूरती भारत के लोगों से ज्यादा विदेशी जानते हैं।
अंग्रेजी बस एक भाषा है ( #Easy)
एक बार उनसे पूछ कर देखो जो हिंदी बाद में सीखते हैं ।
Many Congratulations on 1 million subscribers.🙏🎁🌹🌻.
Jiyo Sacche Deshbhakt.
आदरणीय सोनम wangchuk जी आपको हृदय से नमन : आपका यह वीडियो देखकर मेरा भ्रम भी दूर हो गया है। और बहुत जानकारियां भी मिली है। हमें आप पर गर्व है. बस आप ऐसे ही नेक काम करते रहिये. प्रभु आपके साथ है। और प्रार्थना करती हूँ की सदा आप पर कृपा बनाये रखें।
I am the guy who studied in Gujarati upto 10+2, then I joined Bachelor's of Mathematics with English medium, I toped in my college. Then I joined Master's of Mathematics with English medium, I ranked 2nd In University.
Now I am better at English than of my friends Who studied In English medium, also they didn't get any rank in college and University as me. Mother tongue is very important for primary level. I support #NEP2020
Kem cho????kai University ma cho???
You topped class anyway what about the normal folks
THEY HARASSED PREGNANT LADY!! ruclips.net/video/RbeUBP5AoCE/видео.html
@@vvksailor THEY HARASSED PREGNANT LADY!! ruclips.net/video/RbeUBP5AoCE/видео.html
@@harveyspecter1795 tha nks for sharing in general interest
I remember my when I was in ukg class teacher showed me picture of Insect and told me what is this I told her it's Keeda and she slapped me on face I wept bitterly as my mother used called it as Keeda
Pehele ke teacher maarte toh the, aajkal toh students ke saath he yaari dosti chalti h teachers ki
Engrezzi ki ghulam hogi
Same condition
The teacher probably took out her personal frustration on you.Our teachers don't realize how much power they hold.my love for any subject was because of great teachers .
Bhai yahi dikkat h....India ki
Totally love him.....❤️❤️❤️.... Such a treasure to the nation....😀😀
Watch this and know NEP ruclips.net/video/BWi0vwlDs5o/видео.html
🇮🇳🙏Vangchuk sir🙏🇮🇳
भाषा एक विचारो, भावनाओं को बताने का बस जरिया है।
, हमारी 'मातृभाषाएं' इसमे अधिक विकसित है। सबको समाए रखने की क्षमता, और समझ उसका गुण है।
तथ्य के आधारपर, जो कहा आपने, बिलकुल ये revolution होना ही चाहिए, भारत मे....
देश की खुशहाली और भविष्य(happiness n future) इस चीज को अपनानें से ही संभव हो पाएगी..... historical... must have thing....
हमारे प्यारे देश को जगाना, आगे बढ़ना जरुरी है🇮🇳😍
Right now,I'm in 10th class but I feel like, I wanted to start my schooling from start 😂😂 because english was somewhere imposed on us and now also.
I hope things will get better for the little student!!!!
जय हिंद 🇮🇳🇮🇳
THEY HARASSED PREGNANT LADY!! ruclips.net/video/RbeUBP5AoCE/видео.html
Abe chodu board ke exam pe dhyan de. Jyade you tube mt dekh. Maths sahi se padiyo .. gand phad degi math's
I am a bengali and I live in kerala, will keralites teach my kid in bengali?????
@@nemosdiary8271 so in Kerala your kid speaks Bengali outside or Malayalam?? Or English or Hindi??
@@beginner6715 I'm a girl 😂😂
I have a friend from UP...he studied in Hindi medium n he met me in engineering class...n his understanding was much better than any of us 🙏🙏
Okay....then from where u belong?
Share this video everywhere.
@@ritatiwari8843 Jammu Kashmir
I have many classmate from hindi medium and most of them are dumb. What it prooves ? Andhabhakti
@@war.champscoc8935 exactly... 😂🙌
सर आप बहुत अच्छा काम कर रहे हैं लोगो को जागरूक कर रहे हैं आपका प्रयास सरहनीय है NCP की बहुत जरूरत थी लगता है हमारे समय क्यूँ नहीं आईं हम इन्तज़ार रह गये ।
मुजे और मेरे जेसे लाखों parents को भी current सिस्टम से समस्या है हमें भी आप जेसे लोगो से उमीद है की आप हमारी आवाज़ बनेगे और सरकार तक हमारी बात पहुंचायेंगे ।
मेरी सम्स्या शिक्षा सिस्टम से है covid में जो पेसे वसूली के लिए स्कूल बेहद गंदे तरीके से गुँडो की तरह माफिया की तरह parents को परेशान कर रहा है उसके लिए हम parents अकेले लड़ रहे हैं ।आप जेसे किसी भी शक्सियत का साथ हमे अभी तक नहीं मिल पाया है ।मुजे पता है आपने सोशल मीडिया पर parents के साथ जो अभद्र व्यव्हार किया गया ऐसे बहुत से वीडियो अलग अलग parents द्वारा डाले गये हैं आपने जरूर देखें होंगे ।
मीडिया ने हमारी बात रखी लेकिन बहुत strongly नही रख रहे हैं ।हमे सहयोग की आवश्यकता है ऐसे स्कूलों पर लगाम लगाने के लिए
इस सत्र की पूरी फीस माफ की जाये और
इस 2020-21 को 0 academic ईयर घोषित किया जाये
बोर्ड में 2021 के पेपर ना लेकर अन्य विकल्प से बच्चों कौ पास किया जाये
वहुत से संघटन कार्य कर रहे हैं आप एजुकेशन के लिए आवाज़ उठा रहे हैं इसलिये आप से आशा है आप सहयोग करे गे इसकी पूरी आशा हैं हमे 🙏🏻
आपके जो भी विचार हो जरूर बताईयेगा
हमें सहयोग की बहुत आवश्यकता है सरकार तक अपनी बात पहुंचाने के लिए
फेसबुक ट्विटर पर बहुत से ग्रुप कार्य कर रहे हैं parents के लिए आशा है आप हमारी आवाज़ बनेगे 🙏🏻
When most of the so called intellectuals have forgotten or chosen to ignore this basic issue, you are still standing tall doing what you have been preaching all your life i.e teaching and learning. Heartfelt regards,
Sir Wangchuk lay
Carry can get 20 million plus subscribers but this legend have only 1 million.
These things do need to change
Carry Minati do cyber shaming and bullying, with lot of gaali...youngsters love it.
You çan help gain more followers by sharing it to your friends.
I used to share this type of videos. But no one is interested. They don't understand that we are a developing nation. We can't blindly follow western and their joyful life. They are interested in comedy and roasting etc.
Hindi me likho samjme nai aaya 😂😂😜😜😜
@@rajbhogayta455 tum pachvi kaksha se uper hi hoge to tumhe jaroorat nahi.😜
This is so true. Me and my husband studied in Gujarati Medium till 12th std. My husband is an IITian and scored AIR 16 in GATE. We both were in US working in Google and eBay.
Amazing
@Dipal Mam it is good that both u And ur Husband are highly Qualified but on other side if both of u use your knowledge, skills etc. to boost our country in all dept. Then it will be more Appreciable........😇🙏
Nice
@@iron_man1038 she said they WERE working . ALSO it's her choice
A sad case of brain drain. Common let's wake up.
OM
Sonam Wangchuk ji, this eye-opener is so beautifully and tactfully presented by you. Hope the 'still-I-am-an-Angrezi-slave' Indians see the light of truth, and, as you say, without losing this golden opportunity - of PRESERVING ourselves!
You yourself stand as an example of what you speak - such knowledge, such diction and clarity of thought, as well as command over multiple languages - as you are established well in your mother tongue.
Studying his basic Mathematics, and general science in his mother tongue Tamil, at the Rameshwaram Elementary School, a little boy rose to be an ace Space Scientist (with exclusively Indian Degrees!), and the most beloved President of India - Abdul Kalam ji's life and achievements speak more eloquently than 'slavery-ridden' counter-arguments!
May you continue to inspire Indian minds to glory!
Jai Hind!
Very nice talk sir. I am an educationist and always thought of starting an institution like Sardar Patel. Now my dream will come true. Jai Hind
निज भाषा उन्नति अहे , सब उन्नति को मूल
बिनुनिज भाषा ज्ञान के मिटे न हिय के शूल।
As a teacher I can say it's curse because my Bihari student got so many problem because of English..
They don't understand English but they are forced to learn in missionary school
For a Hindi medium student who studied in Hindi upto 10 or 12 then it might be difficult for them to learn English ... But Studying in local language upto 5th is good descision
@@Sauravme exactly
@@Sauravme Well, Then There should Be English As A Language Subject Bt Shouldn't Be A Medium of Our Whole Education system.
@@nightfurygame-hub4619 English should be Stay As Language Subject along with Hindi in Schools Bt Medium of Education shouldn't be English.
@@Sauravme my brother has done 10+2 in Hindi medium and he's now done his UG and PG from IIT in aerospace engineering.
इस पहल से पूरे भारतवर्ष को बहुत लाभ होगा. हमें अपनी मात्रभाषा पर गर्व होना चाहिए. इस मुद्दे को सभी के सामने इतने अच्छे से प्रदर्शित करने के लिए आपका धन्यवाद.
मातृभाषा, मात्रभाषा नहीं।
सोनम वांगचुक जी धन्यवाद आप के सटीक आकलन और सुंदर विचारों के लिए । आप ने जो भी कहा है वो सही है विशेष कर अंत में आपने कहा की यदि आप एक भाषा को अच्छी तरह से जाने ले तो दूसरी किसी भी भाषा को आप बहुत हीं आसानी से सीख सकते हैं ।
अभी हमारे पास एक बेहतरीन मौका है अपने ऐतिहासिक गलतियों को सुधारने का और शिक्षा में सुधार करने का । बेहतर होगा की हम नई शिक्षा नीति को बेहतर ढंग से लागू करें और कमियों को दूर करे । .. जय हिंद ।
Thnq so much Sir. Mujhe aap ki bate pasand toh bohot phle se hain. But aapke videos se aapko dekh or smjh pana or bhi simple ho gya hai. Aapki bato se mujhe ghoda bohot seekhne ko mila hai. Or me phle thoda depression me rhta tha but aapki bato se mujhe sochne ko milta hai. Ki har cheez ko theek kiya ja skta hai. Or as always aaj bhi aap ki baate khi na khi mujhe bohot related thi. Meri local language Hindi hi rhi hai +2 tak. Or fir colg me jane par seedhe hi English ho gyi. Koi option hi nhi tha. Mere pass puchne ko bohot kuch tha but faculties mujhe smjhna hi nhi chahte the. Wo sbhi acchi English bol pate the. Or +90% students bhi. Jo 10 % the unhe jyada tar faculties na smjhne ki koshish karte the na hi management. Unme se kafiyone colg hi chor diya. Me middle class se tha toh na tlh chor skta tha na koi smjhne ko tyyar tha. Isi sab ke karn mere Graduation me percentage bhi kafi kam rhe. Or ye jyadatar colleges ke haal hain. Toh aap hi ki trh me bhi aap ki baat se bohot had tak sehmat hun sir.
I'm from Hindi medium, Ironically I used to explain questions to my English medium friends during early college days because they can only read questions in English but I could also understand the questions. English is a just language, a language is a tool to exchange thoughts, if we are able to exchange thoughts then language, its grammar, spellings and accuracy don't matter.
Felt very nice to read this.
Bhai mai tumhari baat se bilku sehmat hu aaj hindi bolne walo desi, uneducated aur gav ka ya gawar kaha jata h whi aap 2 line english me bol de to aap ko sabse padha likha society me bataya jaega aur aapko amir aur high class bhi samjha jata h jabki hindi ya english sirf ek bhasha h aur ye bakwas narrative ko bollywood bhut badhawa deta h....
Share this video everywhere.
Yeah medium don't matter.. But real knowledge and deep understanding of its language too
Same with me.....plus students from cbsc are very weak in maths and reasoning. Subjects that require iq ...
Congratulations to achieve 1 million subscribers. You have been motivating us always. Thank you sir.
ruclips.net/channel/UCP8qfln2FH2JMeol_od7PqA
Those who are advocating regional languages over English medium , I have a few questions for them.
1. Has proper Science textbooks been written upto even 10+2, let even undergraduate level in any regional language? Until we do that , how can we even think of junking English ?
2. JEE Mains is conducted in English , Hindi and Gujarati and JEE Advanced in English and Hindi. India has 22 scheduled languages and no national language and as per census 2011 data India has 53 crore Hindi speakers. What about the rest of the 57 crore people? In an apparent effort to ' Indianise' the exams , are you not doing injustice to the majority and biasing it towards Hindi speakers? This is one of the possible reasons that some science students (especially , state boards) are not getting their due.Same thing is true for the CSIR UGC NET exams( for Phd entrance).
3.The great edge that we have in the IT industries is because of our English language educated workforce and possibly this is one area where we are truly global leaders. The coming era is going to be of AI, ML and Big Data. Other than scientific innovation and technological prowess , English will help us to be a true leader in this upcoming age.
4. When you produce world -class research ,you have to place it before the world in English.All papers in science and technology are written in English. All your research, presentations before the global experts of the field are in English. Like it or not, this is the way things are and things are likely to remain. Even German ,Russian and Japanese researchers ,who otherwise have their entire education in mother tongue have to do it and for that purpose English is emphasized in their universities.
The real solution is not attacking English for some narrow jingoisitic nationalism or trying to circumvent it , but to develop ,polish and fortify the English language skills of our working age-group as well as children from the youngest possible age. At the same time, giving due importance to the mother tongue and exposure to literature in it is essential for the child to know about his country, past and surroundings.
The best solution is to give an English language education right from 6 years of age for all Science and humanities subjects while incorporating a strong component in mother tongue and its literature at least till class 10th and preferably till class 12th.
Can't agree more 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
True that. Especially d Hindi speakers point. D govt should first start improving d govt schools.
@Space Cowboy perfect my brother 😄😄😄👍
Salute to u
I studied upto 10th class in my mother tongue and now I am an engineer. My wife also studied in her mother tongue and now she is a doctor. I feel proud that I learned most of concepts by my mother tongue only.
This is truly interesting to note about Tibetan students performance; means we do have a tested model already...
Actually, China also doesn’t teach in the English medium atleast in the initial formative years. And we already know how well they are economically as a country..
I am good at English but I feel we are losing our originality and our languages.
So I like this move.
But more than that I love that we are developing in the right direction and PM Modi and Sonam Wangchuk agree on this development
For all those who think removal of english is BAD!!
You are a mental Slave of English !! It is scientific fact (unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/pf0000146632
) that children learn in a better way/good comprehension skills, when they are taught in their Mother Language. Take example of France,Germany,Japan,China etc all these countries are developed nations and their education is in mother language. English should be taught only as "language" not as a medium of education.
"ENGLISH DOES"NT DEFINE YOUR INTELLIGENCE, IT IS JUST A LANGUAGE" For Eg- In japan if u want to do Job, then it is compulsary for you to learn Japanese, otherwise u wont get a single Job, not even in a Petrol Station. Japan has'nt taught english , is it not a advanced nation?
Exactly. I feel embarrassed that even though I am fluent in Hindi and English. I can’t write in my mother tongue because it was never thought in my school. This is definitely a right move
THEY HARASSED PREGNANT LADY!! ruclips.net/video/RbeUBP5AoCE/видео.html
@@vibhas.g2399 THEY HARASSED PREGNANT LADY!! ruclips.net/video/RbeUBP5AoCE/видео.html
@@harveyspecter1795 tha ks for sharing in general interest
आपके जैसा मै कोई Famous नही हूँ . गयी १८ बरस से मै प्रयास कर रहा हूँ लोगो को समझाने का लेकीन अग्रेजी का प्रभाव मुंबई इतना है की लोग मातृभाषा मे शिक्षा लेना Means अपने आपको पिछडा कहलाना. अभी आपका व्हिडीओ लोगो के दिमाग मे नया नजरिया सेट करेगा. धन्यवाद सोनम वांगचुक जी
When we learn something in our mother tongue then we just learn but when we learn in a foreign language than we first interpret it into our mother tongue only than we understand
This education policy will Increase the skills, exquisite & literacy rate in quality term in India🇮🇳.
In 25 years
NEP 2020 is still years too late. We are years behind the level we should be in. The previous NEP was decades too late or nothing much significantly ever changed from the matriculation system. Even NEP 2020 makes ideal assumptions and expectations about everything. For the positive changes given there's also negative loopholes that can be exploited. Keep in mind that even previous system had positives that were not implemented thanks to corruption.
.
.
Why not .. I mean why not give a try to study in our own mother tongue? This will be a game changer for India’s future.
Study in mother tounge is my dream. This new modified education, make me very happy.
It is regret that i was not part of this education system
feel same way
Me2
थैंक्यू सर,। नई शिक्षा नीति को इतने बेहतरीन तरीके से समझाने के लिए। जबरदस्ती इंग्लिश सिखाने के चक्कर में बच्चा ना घर का रहता है ना घाट का। मेरा देश सच में बदल रहा है।🙏🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳🙏🙏
It's worth watching, Sonam Wangchuk la, completely agree with you whatever you said. Never forget your roots. Jai Hind, 🇮🇳🙏 keep inspiring us.
@Qetuo 047 as a respect, like Indian words Ji जी
Sir i was a english medium student but i sent my son in a marathi medium school and he is in his final year of degree
Our nation needs more sonam wangchuk 🙏
I will become next sonam wangchuk
@@roasted_boy6213 i am waiting for that . All the best
My blessings r with u
Yes bro
@ all the best
Lets build a better new india
If we make our mind we can give birth to a company much bigger that Google etc
Aryan your dreams is your first step to your achievements
@ i will also try my best to give india as much as i can i also wanna become a software engineer and work for isro and benefit india in my success
Very inspiring videos for those parents who have blind faith in English medium!!
చాలా బాగుంది సార్ , మీ అనుభవం మీ ఆవిష్కరణలు భారత దేశానికి చాలా ఉపయోగకరమైనవి , మీరు ఇలాంటి మరెన్నో అవిష్కరణలు చేయాలని ఆకాంక్షిస్తున్నాను
I am a example of it
I studed upto 3rd in odia only
Then come english that too very elementary only
Then in class 6
We had options of Hindi/sanskrit
Today I can write 4 language & speak 7,i am working as a engineer in a MNC
& The most important part is
I am able to talk, manage my work force easily
An*
absolutely. great to know your example. at the age where our minds is able to grasp concepts very easily, if we waste it on learning language (learning language isn't as cognitively complex) instead of channel and broadening natural curiosity to learn, then we lose a lot.
@MH 12 Proud Punekar true. but that can be gained in a diploma or even a degree later on.
imagine if the curiosity was allowed to expand at the age 5-8yrs, if children were allowed to grasp simple concepts simply instead of making it more complex by putting it in a different language.
would you have Tagore write Gitanjali in english? or even Harivanshrai Bachchan write Madhushala in english?
@MH 12 Proud Punekar well i really don't have any problems with giving English language the importance it deserves. however I think there's something more important, that is taking pride in who we are and what we do and doing it to the best of our ability.
these days when google can translate languages, the gap of not understanding has been bridged so much.
with the same example as above - Tagore got the Nobel for literature which he wrote in his own mother tongue. meaning, if it is impactful enough, original enough, if it makes us proud of having created something, it doesn't really matter.
My point is English is not so difficult or important in our life that we should start with it. Of course we can go for it but should not start with it.
Moreover Stop glorifying it
No questions remained unanswered. Coz when he doesn't just speak his words are backed by facts and findings.
Bahut bahut dhanyawad is Sundar video ke liye
The swirling wind when hits the sturdy and strong mountains - I love that sound
Respect and Gratitude 🙏🙏🙏 from Tibetans guy 🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦
SONAM , YOUR THEORY IS FROM PRACTICALS
AND WHAT YOU PRACTICE IS NATURE.
SADHUWAD
No sir genuine honest intrest and creative passion
Absolutely Right Sir. This movement must be led by you only in our country. We will play our role in this movement to the best of our knowledge.
ये बात बहुत सही कही आपने शिक्षा अपने मातृभाषा में होगी तभी देश आगे उन्नति करेगा
Sir, you deserve a NOBEL prize & Bharat Ratna for the work which you do!! JAI Hind 🇮🇳
I know Hindi, Malayalam, Tamil, and Kannada. But I am using English for my work. As sir told it's a key, the more keys you have the more doors you can open.
😍🥰 I also started learn Malayalam love from Bihar
Niu kannadadavra
@@sagarrudnoor4823 Nanu kanadiga, malayali, tamilian, hindi wala and paka Indian.
@@kabeerdas8149 bhai it's odia....not orriya 😊😊😊
I'm a kannadiga from Karnataka
My mother tongue is Kannada
I know hindi,English,marathi,telugu,tamil,Malayalam,sanskrit & hindi
Now I m learning 😊👍🏻tulu & konkani
@Faisal Hubdar for now m learning tulu & konkani ...after their completion ,urdu is next on my list
Later some Punjabi ,haryanvi ,maithli,beary
So 😅its a long process
Anyways thanks for suggestion
Wow...
But aren't you a little dead to do that 😬
@@burhanlakdawala8091 He is the kannadiga version og is Bihari lol😬
@@mohitshetty2862 🤣
Sir awakening ...THANK YOU VERY MUCH ..jai BHARAT Jai JAGAT
Sir, you are right. I am Sandeep Singh from Gurgaon Haryana. My medium of primary education was Hindi. Which is my mother tongue. I was very interested in science. Being a Hindi medium, I could easily understand the thoughts of others and convey my ideas easily to others. But when I went to class 11, I took up non-medical because I was interested in science from the beginning. From 11th grade, my medium of instruction changed from Hindi to English. The English language impeded my thinking, understanding and expression. I was hesitant to ask questions because I could not speak English. Due to a lack of knowledge of the English language, I could not write my thoughts properly in the exam. As a result, I failed twice in 12th grade. If this kind of education policy comes in which the medium of instruction is your mother tongue, many children will be able to get themselves out of the cycle of language and learn the importance of education more than learning rote.
Ur wrong,how can hindi become mother tongue,hindi is the youngest language in India,did ur fore fathers speak hindi,this is what happens to regional language when hindi is imposed over regional language.
8:30 चलिए मैं भी आपको एक उदाहरण देता हूं । मैं IIT gradutute हूँ। हिंदी मीडिया में पड़ने से मुझे JEE clear करने में कोई दिक्कत नही। बल्कि मैं ज्यादा असनी से exm क्लियर किया। पर जब college में class start हुए तो जो अच्छे चपर चपर English बोल रहे थे उन्हें proud feel होता था पर मैं और मेरे हिंदी बोलने वाले अपने आपको अलग कर लेते थे और गिल्ट होता था। बाद में फिर जब industry join किया तो फिर से देखा कि सारा काम तो हिंदी में ही हो रहा है तो फिर बीच मे हम English medium में पढ़कर और Demotivated क्यों रह रहे थे?😢
Ur correctly said😔
Maine v same prlm face kiya
Ha ye baat to sahi h India mein sirf bolne k liye English official language h bt koi English bolta bhi nhi h...aur main bhi yahi maanti hu ki koi bhi baat humlog apni mother tongue mein jyada achhe se explain kr skte h
Aur mother tongue mein padhai ki h toh iska matlab ye nhi ki hume English nhi aati ...and Japan ko hi dekho itni developed country h...bt unko English nhi aati and agar aap unke saath kaam krna chahte ho to hume japanese sikhni padti h ya phir iterpreter ki jarurat padti h
Also there is no language of science and mathematics. Both the subject can be taught in any medium. These subjects are just based on ur common sense of understanding the things. For the students who r adopting PCM/PCB, there is no need to be good in languages. As JEE/NEET {PCM/B} are the most competitive exm for students they r just based on logic al approach.
I studied my whole life in English
But I can hardly read n write my mother tongue Telugu
I feel illiterate when I have to read something on board or write instructions in Telugu.
Here in Andhra Pradesh the government passed a bill recently that even in government schools English will be mode of instructions.
Which will erase our mother tongue slowly.
I'm vv happy with this new education policy which will protect our mother tongue. My kids are luckier than me.
I m really excited to learn with them wht I lost my yrs ago
Thanks to central government... Sanskrit should be revived
My husband is born and brought up in Bangalore, he also can't read Kannada despite speaking it fluently.
I too separated out my way from non technical reading/writing of books because after i got into job i lost the interest and confidence of knowing and understanding either of my mother tongue(Hindi) or English fluently. Though my mother is hindi teacher i can't distinguish btw बड़ी इ की मात्रा and छोटी इ की मात्रा (PS: Thanks to translator)
@@ravindramandal6207 Sanskrit may never have been the mother tongue of the larger population of ancient India. Language is used to discriminate between highly learned and wannabe learned. In the olden times it was SAnskrit. After transfer of power in 1947 it has been English. In between it was Urdu, pharsi. Let language evolve on its own. Personally, I think Hindi /Indian languages are easier to use and communicate while speaking, but english is easier to write. So what do we do?.
Sam My and GG : Up to the age of 5 yrs I could speak only Bhojpuri language. There after medium of instruction in English. From the age of 8yrs I had a bengali friend and with him I learned to speak and understand Bengali. I loved S.D. Burman songs in Bengali. As for hindi it came naturally to me.
But your problem is writing. So every morning after early bath and during prayers make it a point to write one of the MANTRA of hinduism 3 times in your pooja room in your script. Keep changing the mantra every week, till you can write them perfectly.
I too studied in Hindi medium school till class 3rd and easily switched to cbse English medium , both were confortable but I noticed many of the Student which were in cbse from play weren't quit familiar to hindi and sanskrit words, they didnt knew Hindi numbers and counting , mantras , folk tales , panchtantra stories etc but i became comfortable with both Hindi and English.
Sonam wangchuk sir !!
You are such a great inspiration 🙏🏻
101% real facts
Our indian government should think like you for people of india 🙏🏻🙏🏻
People who say that starting with mother tongue makes your English weak... I studied in Bengali (my mother tongue) from class 1-12... Then when I went to college, I had no problem with English. It's just an another language. It's not a subject. Learn to see a language as a language. Then everything becomes easy.
I am a successful researcher now with 20+ publications.. my mother tongue never stopped me from achieving my goal. Rather I was able to learn smoothly.
Regional languages
In my opinion, a problem can come by teaching in regional languages that if a student is belongs to state like Tamilnadu, Kerala and Gujarat and his father is doing a job in Delhi and he also started living with his father so when Delhi schools will teach him in regional language which is Hindi. the student will definitely face the problem in learning or understanding because his regional is Tamil, Malayalam and Gujarati not Hindi.
Aditya you know what? They'll learn a new Indian language. Not English.
But you tell me one question when a average student who learned Bengali medium school then he/she shifts English medium for higher education then he/she survives easily? You are a good student so you can do easily..
@@sumantakumarsaha7756 no student is average. Every student is a human and has 3.6 kg brain made exactly as same as mine. There is no difference.. I am not a good student as well.. I got 70% in 10th board and 66% is 12th. So if you see.. I am also an "AVERAGE STUDENT" as quoted by the society..
@@sagnikacharjee3148 bro, still hindi is foreign to him,the core is,it will burden the students,where his fellow dudes don't go through.fair chance is better option,, language is just a tool,not knowledge.
Yes ,we have to give more and more focus on our mother tongue as the language of instruction in education...
जय हिन्द सर🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🙏🙏🙏🙏
आपने मर्म बताया वास्तविक भारतीय परिवेश में शिक्षा का माध्यम मातृभाषा में ही होना चाहिए।
Watch this and know about NEP ruclips.net/video/BWi0vwlDs5o/видео.html
Sir, you are absolutely right, if children start studying English in class one itself and they are not taught about their mother tongue, then they will not have any knowledge about their mother tongue.😮😮
I am from Bihar I have studied till 10+2 in Hindi medium after that I have done my graduation from PATNA University and got 80% and also done my masters from central university I haven't faced any problem. Very awesome #NEP2020
I am a Bengali medium student and Primary School Teacher ...
I found no problem in Bengali language .... it's a pleasure to know your views in mother tongue
what would you do if you have to move to mumbai and study there. how will you study bengali there as there is marathi in there
Dada Tomar Kotha theek, kintu bhabo, Jodi ekta cheler ma Baba Jodi kajer sutre kono non Bengali statey jete hoto, oikhane hotat kore medium of instruction change, to o kibhabe cope korbe??
@@iamdc21 bro we have English as a subject(language) but we mainly take instructions in Bengali it mean not that we can not understand English
If your own child want to go or wish to go Abroad, what will you do? He or She at least should know International language (English), unfortunately we are still lucky that in our country we have this chance.
Please think properly, don't think what others say.
@@Sumit_random setai bolchi. english ta na rakhle sudhu regional language a ei jhamela ta hobe j onno state r chele mey der osubidje hobe. amar to south indian bondhu o chilo school a. ebar sekhane jodi bangla te porano hoto, or osubidhe hoto
Wah....thanks for making video on importance of mother tongue.....superb video.....gr8 efforts
I think that,such good revolutionary changes will be really helpful for the bright future of our country
One of the problem of teaching students basic education in english is that most of the students are not fluent in english as well as their mother tongue ..
Good Education Policy 👍👍👍
After listening this and analysed some data, my mind is changed ... Mother's tounge should be medium of instruction. 😊
Which mother tongue
In India there are various languages according to various states in india... Like in Uttar Pradesh mostly peoples use hindi ,in Karnataka State - Kannad , Maharashtra - Marthi , Andhra Pradesh - Telugu ,Kerla - Malyalam ... etc. So in starting classes at least class 4 - 5 the medium of instruction should be regional language after that switch to another language.
@@vatsala900 its very easy to say theoretically but ground reality is very different
@@jamesharden9082 I know Sir, Implementation is difficult everytime ,than Ideas. But ...
Hats off for Tibetain people who have history with China but are helping our nation 🇮🇳👍👍
@Yuvraj Sharma Poudyal here 10:04
@@sumanmahato7914 Tibet was a country. They didnt have any connection with china.
@@ellowowers4731 once Tibet was rules by chin ,I have heard that for sure.
Tibet was a vassal of the Qing Empire but it was not a direct rule. More like an alliance.
@@sumanmahato7914 Tibet is under chinese rule today also. I m saying tibetian and chinese are not same by history.
Great explanation sir🥰🥰! Satisfied😊😊 👍👍
Even while living in London, I was taught my Mother Tounge, Gujarati, since the age of 8, all the way to the age of 15. I could not forget, the knowledge they gave me.
They put me at such a point in Gujarati, that I can understand and could possibly translate even the hard Gujarati Scriptures.
You won't believe it, I am only 17 years old!
And it will be your soul duty to teach your children in Gujarati/HINDi language...!!
@@SHUBHAMSHARMA-uh7yp Yes of course.
@@SHUBHAMSHARMA-uh7yp Also, you won't believe it, I am now an assistant teacher in the School aswell!
@Karan Kapoor London
@Karan Kapoor In UK, Education and Healthcare is FREE. We are very lucky.
I have been pointing on the same data from last 10-12 years. People used to laugh on my logic.
Hats off to Sonam ji to take up this issue so nicely and wisely..... infact I also started my primary education in Hindi language but a civil engineer from a reputed institution in Mumbai.... doing so well in my life... thanks a lot...
जुले सोनम भाई आपके मुंह से जुले सुनकर सदा ह्रदय आनंद से भर जाता है
You have played a significant role in educating the children in ladak
Your contribution is ossom in education sir
I love your work sir
Jai hind
Watch this and know about NEP ruclips.net/video/BWi0vwlDs5o/видео.html
I studied in Gujarati till 12th class and then did B.E. from leading Gujarat college. I believe I am doing good with my life. Not only me, my all classmates are going better with their life. There's no detail data but my experience suggest studying in mother tongue will improve common sense...
Haha and you typing in English
@@gomesgomes6635 as he also told English use as tool to communicate
Sachi vat
good ! तो फिर हिन्दी या गुजराती मे बात करें!
Kai college thi kryu b.e.
Hats off to all your efforts. You are truly inspiring 🙏🏻🙏🏻
How beautifully you have explained this.
Yes, I agree.. English is just a language.. which can be learnt later.. but mother tongue language is essential for children to learn concepts and other things in schools
Sir you are a real gem of our country 🙏
Very nice explained the importance of mother tongue in education👌👌🙏💐
बहुत ही अच्छी जानकारी महोदय👍🙏🏼सबसे पहले तो पालक को समझना चाहिए कि हम बच्चों को सभी विषय का अध्यापन कराने के लिए शाला भेज रहे है न कि केवल अंग्रेजी भाषा। जो हमारी भाषा ही नही रही है उस भाषा से बच्चे कैसे पढ़ेंगे। अंग्रेजी माध्यम को हौवा बनाकर रख दिए है। सब एक दूसरे को देख बस भेड़ चाल चल रहे है। दूरगामी सोच कोई नही रखता। फला फला के बच्चे अंग्रेजी माध्यम में पढ़ रहे है तो मैं भी अपने बच्चों को उसी माध्यम में पढ़ाऊंगा या पढ़ाऊंगी बस यही सोच रख रहे है। बच्चो की शिक्षा बोझिल और उबाऊ बनाते जा रहे है।
I have a Tibetan children homeschool in my neighbourhood , in Raiwala uttrakhand. It is very huge well built . And the students are awesome . They know a little Hindi .
Same I studied in Hindi Medium, today giving lectures on How to Improve English 😜
👏👏👏👍
Wow mind blowing.
Even i also don't know how to speak in English till Class 9or 10 but afterwards i used to saw movies &videos .So, now i can speak in English 😂😂😜😆
@@BrockLesnar3323 same here bro I also don't now english before 10th class now I'm in 12th and I can speak English but not properly
You did a grammatical mistake.
In English medium schools teachers teaches something but the students till class 5 fail to understand.
In government schools, the students can understand well in their mother tongue, but the teacher doesn't teaches anything 🤣
This system should be changed first. Then only people would prefer govt schools.
Are bhai sharam kro kis lqnguage me likhe ho comment
I have experienced it studying in English medium
@@rishabhpandey8782 why he have feel shy, if he writes in his mother tongue other region people in India will not understand. Hindi should me made official language for government records.
@@praveenkumar105 abe dyan se dekh english me pura likha hai uska comment...andhe
@Malay Ghosh kyu be yahi study karo kya jaroorat he foreign jake randapa krne ki kyu apna desh ghumne k liya sqhi nahi hai hatt chutya. laudu
I am iitian I can say .language don't matter in getting to IITs and studying IIT 👍.I like the new education policy
Share this video everywhere.
Please create more awareness about this people will listen your voice
@@adrrpa168 but why? Everyone knows the simple things🤷♂️
Your views matters a lot bro, thanks 👍👍🇮🇳
Why are you typing in English then
सर आप विस्तार से बताते हैं और काफी अच्छे तरीके से समझ आता है हमे. इसके लिए आपका बहुत-बहुत धन्यवाद.
This is welcome change in the way we perceive education! Curiosity and questioning makes children learn better and as these qualities are inherent in their mother tongues (languages they use at home from birth), I am sure they will understand and learn better! These children will grow up to become strong nervous system of a new INDIA!
Amazing sir, you have presented the facts perfectly. Thank you for us to make this understand. You opened my eyes.
Sir your analysis is "Great ".........
THEY HARASSED PREGNANT LADY!! ruclips.net/video/RbeUBP5AoCE/видео.html
@@harveyspecter1795 Thanks for sharing in general interest
@@harveyspecter1795 thanks for sharing in general interest
मुझे अपके विचार बहुत अच्छे लगे है सर
आप हमेशा अपणे मातृभूमी के लिय आगे आते है और सुधारणा करणे के लिय अपने विचार साझा करते हो सर
मै महाराष्ट्र राज्य से हू जय हिंद सर
Exactly my thoughts Sir. Very well explained. This new policy is indeed a blessing.
Yes, Sir I want Ashrama System back, atleast till 5th std.
I wanted to told this matters to my friends circle but unfortunately everyone rejected my ideas. I have got support of my thinking from your comments it's really a pleasure for me. I admitted my daughter into a Bengali medium Government school in that time some of my friends and family members against me. Now I fees that I have taken a correct decision.
Thank you Sir.
Watch this and know about NEP ruclips.net/video/BWi0vwlDs5o/видео.html
Good job
I wanted to tell not told