Spoiler Review of Aiyaary, Black Panther | Anupama Chopra, Rahul Desai, Sucharita Tyagi
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 18 фев 2018
- Our in house critics Anupama Chopra, Rahul Desai and Sucharita Tyagi discuss recently released films 'The Shape of Water', 'Black Panther', Love per Square Foot' and 'Kuch Bheege Alfaaz' in detail.
Have you subscribed to Film Companion yet? Join us here - bit.ly/FilmCompanion
Visit us at filmcompanion.in
Do Like, Share, Comment & Subscribe to our channel.
Subscribe: bit.ly/FCsubscribe
Follow Us On:
/ filmcompanion
/ filmcompanion
/ filmcompanion
The Film Companion is a web channel intended to promote Indian cinema through films review, interviews, discussions, video essays and analytical compilations. It is intended primarily for the purpose of encouraging informed discussions, criticism and review of cinema and towards such purpose the programs use short extracts of cinematograph films, sounds recording and photographic works. These clips and extracts are of a minimal nature and the use is not intended to interfere in any manner with their commercial exploitation of the compete work by the owners of the copyright. The use of works are in compliance with the fair dealing exception provided under Sec. 52 of the Copyright Act, and we asset our use of the works under the exception provided for criticism and review. 
Развлечения
You could time code each movie's review for people who wanna listen about particular movies
Very much agree!
Umm, can you please fix your sound set up? It's really hard to hear anything and the volume is on max. I'm glad you are creating more engaging content.
manali vasanth or maybe you try to fix your hearing problem.
Thank God there’s someone honest like Sucharita who actually pointed out all the faults “The Shape of Water” has!
Black panther was so overrated! Surprised no one pointed that out.
*someone who has your opinion
I love Guillermo Del Toro. But ya, imo, shape of water was disappointing.
If Sucharita ever makes a movie I would watch it just because it would be her vision of what a movie should be like.
YAYYY!!
Tried&Refused Productions. When will you post your next video jammy..
Tried&Refused Productions. Bro you have more subscribers than them 😂😂😂
Tried&Refused Productions. Thanks for watching man ! :-)
Sucharita Tyagi Are you the real Sucharita Tyagi??
ALWAYS :)
This is an amazing section. Please do not discontinue it!
For black panther (spoiler alert) - When the villain was dying.. he said the same thing that Padmavati said - 'Rather than becoming a slave, I would rather die' which eventually talked about self respect and choice. Same happened with Jauhar...wondering outrage is limited to Hindi cinema on such practice or thought process. When we say villain came from progressive mindset he chose death over a fight or may be a life later that could be a struggle but yet could have been a winning point. Just my thoughts :) The comparison sounds vague but was in similar zone. :)
Replying to a comment 3 years old. But anyway, the thing about Jauhar is completely different. Its about keeping up the Rajput pride. Her and other's contribution as Rajput female warriors is to burn themselves alive rather than getting sexually assaulted. The poem is very old, when women sexual pride was extremely sacred. The movie ends with the credit that "this was the biggest win for Chhitdaud". So it seen as a win. But its not a win, it something very tragic, but the Bhansali doesn't treats it like that, instead he glorifies it. Imagine, glorifying Sati in today's times. That a woman's life beyond a husband is nothing and people would see them with lust, so they burn themselves alive for the pride. And imagine glorifying it on the screen like Bhansali did with his epic choice of music in the end...
Other thing that is more important is, this jauhar thing is not woman's choice, it's as much a choice as Sati, or wearing Burkha... Many women say wearing Burkha is their choice... I don't agree... It's just within the patriarchal society that we live in... To rationalize let's say, why don't Muslim men wear Burkha, if it's a choice ???
I Kinda agree with Mr. rahul desai about Hostiles. It talks about cultural diversity and respecting other cultures as much as a back panther being praised about diverse casting in the film.
Does rahul desai ever REALLY LIKE a movie man?
Nabeel Pbx He just said he liked Black Panther and Hostiles.
He liked siddharth gentleman
Obviously these people have a certain type of movie they like ... not really critics but bunch of people who like a certain type of movie who cant seem to give every movie fair review by looking at them as they.. n they on that black panther bandwagon...
He is an idiot as far as I know
He liked action jackson...u can watch that review..
So this has becoome a weekly event now ?
love love love this - can listen to you guys talk for hours!
LOVING THIS FORMAT!
KEEP EM COMING!
FAN SINCE THE BEGINNING
Thanks for another great discussion. Looking forward to more.
It’s always pleasure to watch you all together discussing movies. You all have a very distinctive personalities yourself. So it makes quite fun to see how different people perceive the same movie.
I love this....plzz don't stop doing thiss
I'm just loving these cosy filmy conversations 💜☕
I've a question which is bugging me from quite a long time...
I really like movie Vicky Christina Barcelona but because of the director woody allen ..now am I not supposed to like the movie or it's still OK to like it as lots of people must have worked hard to get the job done.
Help help help
aryan tiwari Taj mahal was made by the moughals. Now we might hate those atrocious rulers for things that they did, but we surely pride ourselves over the monument right. You can appreciate the art even when you chose to hate the artist. No worries :)
pankaj B :)
dude like whatever you want to like... why are you pressured by others. I liked to watch the apprentice many years ago doesn't mean i think Trump is a good human but doesn't make me like the show less.
The incessant conviction to slow/fast walking montages have been going on since A Wednesday Rahul.
there are so many problems with the sound set up..can u fix it please ?
where can you see foreign movies without cuts in india?
Awesome! Love this segment. 3 different minds with their different opinion. That's what I needed.
Neeraj Pandey is an overrated filmmaker! Yes, he has made some good movies in the past, but they were good because of the decent stories and great performances. But purely judging him as a moviemaker, he is well below the mark. Things like background score, CGI (remember the atrocious young Sushant in Dhoni), posters, branding, makeup (Sidharth's bad guises in Aiyaary), editing, cinematography etc. in his movies is mediocre at best. Everything seems hastily done without any attention to detail.
Siddhartha Verma im short 95% filmamakers in india are mediocre
agree with sucharita on the shape of water thing ! There were pieces of sloppy writing in that movie
Guys.. keep doing this..It's good to dissect movies we watch !
Continue with these spoiler reviews!
Fun to watch!
Dooooo moreee like this stufff..
Its amazing
Would love a 'Let's Talk Movies' segment on the Oscars as well! Pretty Please?
i absolutely loved how they talk about black panther like they know everything about it , but as a person who has read black panther's story even before marvel made iron man i would suggest they research a bit more. And also love per square foot is not the first indian movie by netflix it's brahman naman 2015
i think you are missing the point, which was first indian movie on netflix and please lol, seriously what are you 11?
well clearly pot head they are talking about 1st movie by netflix that released on netflix and i think you haven't been following netflix otherwise u would know that sometimes netflix releases it's content in theaters too like in the case of inhumans show so go back and watch chotaa bheem cause that's your mental age
ok bhai just accept yr mistake i understand everybody is not well versed with netflix it's a new thing i understand
Their job is to review the movie. It doesn't matter what was the original story.
Just great imagination doesn't help the movie it needs great execution and screenplay which was missing in shape of water. Anupama please help think about again, and remember just because it's nominated it doesn't need to be good movie. Three billboards is better than shape of water anyday.
You just missed the jist of what Killmonger stands for. The last dialogue where he says he'd rather die defines him. Also, they may bring him back with all the reality stone stuff.
I guess Rahul is a bad audience.....
I agree..
I agree with sucharita..the shape of water was a mediocre movie...The plot was tight but it was nothing memorable
Sucharita's ta-tas have really come a long way. Much impressed!
Brahman Naman was also a Netflix film.
Rakul Preet does not go to flipkart to shop. In fact they are trying to show to way a hacker can attack and destroy money indirectly. Most of these sites have our details saved and we need only the cvv or some opcode. Anyway carry on.
looks they have their own stereotypical chick mentality that they are accusing others of.. who lets these dumbass critics discuss movies that they dont understand at all?
Ankit Das aiyaary was still shit! There were lot of logical flaws! Like look at baby or a Wednesday! They were good films but Neeraj just lost with last two films...
I am not sure if they have put out Creed-2 poster or not but Michael B. Jordan confirmed it on Ellen's show that they are going ahead with the movie.
Rahul Desai's observation on Ryan Coogler is spot on. Good Stuff Rahul.
Please come out with the oscar predictions soon. Will be eagerly waiting for them
echo in sound is too much and shot very casually not keeping any tech spec in mind
12:04 Don't wait too long to make your movie, if you already have a concept on your mind. You will probably give other people courage to make their own movie. You can start with a short film. All the Best.
why didn't rahul desai review The shape of water ??
In LOVe with Su4rita's way of expressing herself.😍
Nabeel Pbx :-D
Sucharita Tyagi Yessssss...the "Not a reviewer" herself replied. Small admirer of you and film companion from MAURITIUS.🤗😊
whats the point of having 3 people in a movie discussion when none of them are on the same page ???
Did anyone faced problem on settling the volume ..Kam karta Hoon toh ladke ka awaz nahi sunai deta Hai and if I increase it sucharita voice just explodes my ears #amen
From next time please repeat the question that is asked by the lady in background. Please remember you three have the mic, she doesnt. Not all of us are wearing headfones.
Brahman Naman was the first Indian movie to be made by Netflix and not Love per sq.feet.
absolutly agree...Anupama!!!!! 10.16
Yep sucharita shape of water was bizzare🙄🙄
Hey..I feel that the villain in shape of water wasn't just one tone..
You see him fighting to survive in this America. Him doing what he can do best to justify his 20 year struggle and live a good retired life. His emotions were so humanized.
Why are you guys not addressing the big elephant in the room while talking about Biopics? Arguably the biggest movie in the last decade or so 'The Dutt Biopic' is releasing this year. Im guessing it has to do something with Vidhu Chopra being a part of it.
Expression of Anupama Chopra when both of them tell how shape of water didn't work ....agree with both of them .the film just didn't work in so many levels .
Shape of water didn't work for me too
I didn't connect to me emotionally and screenplay was weak.
Please fix the sound.
Anupama Chopra you were the best part of this video
I think a critic is a human and not a computer but one thing I’d recommend the young critics is to keep opinions out of their mind while watching it and not color their minds. It’s hard but it’s required in that profession.
any examples of movie that you loved as an audience but dispised as a critic?
Tbh I didn't really like Black Panther. The plot points were a bit cliche and predictable.
@sucharita, criticism is not about how it works for you, it's all about whether the film should be watched or not.
I LOVED The Shape of Water. It was magical, hopeful and beautifully romantic.
Don't be such a cynic, Sucharita.
Michael Shannon was not cartoonish, I completely disagree with you on that. I thought he was pretty fleshed out.
It was deeply poignant.
Mam I like ur discussion .plzz interview aamir khan atlest . Atlest any of his movie.
Hi. Just flew into Mumbai with an amazing script. Unfortunately got a call from Canada and have to leave Wednesday. Ive been a subscriber for a while and feel you guys could definitely help. Please believe me it's amazing.
Wasn't Brahman Naman by Q produced by Netflix?
Medhajit Choudhury nope.they bought it.
In the comics Black Panther saves Killmonger. So MCU will bring him back plus they have a very good actor to play that role.
\
Please consider Telugu movie "Awe"
Why discuss all releases in one video? If a viewer has watched only one movie out of the ones you guys are discussing, how can he decide to watch this? Please make different spoiler reviews for each movie and let viewer decide which one to watch.
Seriously guys! Do something about sound quality. It seriously sucks.
I really disagree with Sucharita on The Shape of Water. The creature was looking much more realistic than it would ever look if it was a Cgi character.
And maybe the villan character was one tone but he was by no means one dimensional he had a distinct personality.
You go girl sucharita!
Be our own Jean Luc Goddard
How come no one is talking about 3 billboards??? Get over Shape of Water man. Such an overrated, unrealistic movie
Chris Nolan sparked off the trend of a critically-acclaimed indie filmmaker delving into big-budget superhero franchises?
That's such a stupid explanation by Sucharita to hate the shape of water.
Narendra Sharma She is being highly cynical here. You need to have some romanticism in you to get swept away by the beauty of the movie.
I loved the ending...😂😂😂
Can we please get Baradwaj Rangarajan for a discussion instead of Sucharita & Rahul!
He's too busy
Having BRangan in your payroll and not having him speak about Hindi movie is crime.
I am totally agree with Suchatria about the Shape of water
half of the commentors here are better than Suchitra....She does not deserve to be here
Why same panel again?
Shahid was a good biopic though ..
please make questioner sound audible
I love you suo
I do not agree with your review on Black panther. I like Anupama ma'am but as for Rahul, you need to update yourself on comics.
Let's talk movies is better than your reviews.
Girl hacks and account and shops and its cliche and derogatory but if we see around in films male hackers are either gamers or porn addicts always ....but the point is that is it really necessary for a girl to hate or be disinterested in shopping to be a hacker and same for boys regarding gaming...we need to stop judging everything that looks girly in the slight bit...some things are called girly just because majority of girls like those activities and shopping is one of them...i know from my experience with my wife, mother aunts sisters and friends...and majority are working women with lots of other interests like writing, singing, guitar playing ,dancing, playing cricket but still they all love shopping!!!!!
And by all means aiyaary is a bad film overall but it hurts to see intellectual people like you guys pass judgement on such things...trash the story and director , even siddharth malhotra who is working hard to be the next rahul roy , vivek mushran , kumar gaurav but not such a inconsequential thing to rate the movie....loved your other points and rest of the review
Sucharita you are a writer use words to describe your opinion than sounds...
doesn't Hirani making Sanjay Dutt movie end up as the same thing?
How can you mix Hollywood and Bollywood movies.you had do do spoiler reviews seperately. Some of the people don't watch Hollywood movies and what about them.and how can you talk about 5 movies in 30 minutes. I mean it looks like you were discussing the movies because you have to discuss.
Mat Dekho bhai
I think sucharita is better than Anupama
"THE FLORIDA PROJECT" NOT NOMINATED
jami0070 ya it is a good movie . Entertaining!
jugal chakma And nobody is even talking about it.
It was one of the best films of last year.
Did u just called "sucharita" "suchita" ?
Vaishali Patil call*
Please talk about bafta winners
Personally, I think that Black panther is a pretty average movie, it's not great in any way. Although, I agree that it's action is really epic and fun, but the movie doesn't show any thing that is closer to cooglers style. It didn't take any great risks and I don't think that the second half was half as good as the first half.
IRON MAN IS STILL BETTER.
ishan bajpai Woah....and most people think it gets better after the first half... I didn't think it was epic because of "cool action"....it won't even be remembered for it. It is something else, something different. Lots of things. But that, if you mature and realise. Killmonger killed it, the racial, social and political commentary was subtle and beautiful, the supporting actors were awesome, the themes of this film were exceptionally handled, and last but not the least, its music was so goooood. Didn't shy away from using classical African songs. It depicted African culture in such an unbiased and beautiful way. These things are above the head of the usual cinemagoer, though.....
P.S - I too think Iron Man was better, but both are practically on the same level for me.....
I don't really know why you and the supposed " MOST PEOPLE" think that it gets better after the first half, but I have my real reasons for how I think, I know what something different you are referring to and to me that is surface level stuff for such a movie. No one needs to be actually mature to know it. The media shoves it to your face anyway about how a movie about a pretend nation is important for Africans and other shit related to that. IT'S REALLY NOT THAT BIG DEAL FOR ANYONE.
I am not trying to be harsh but it's true, the movie didn't feel organic, the gadgets that were shown were interesting and fun but many of the other things in Wakanda didn't feel organic even for a comic book movie. Any movie can do political commentary and many of them do better commentary than this one, For a comic book movie it was taking itself too seriously, the Marvel movies are fun because they know that they are comic book movies, I liked the depiction and respect for the African culture and the soundtrack was fresh too. The problems I mentioned remained, the ideas that were shown in the movie were not fulfilled, it was just like a mention and nothing else,
RAYN COOGLER HAS A STYLE OF FILMMAKING LIKE THE HANDHELD CAMERA OR THE FIGHTS WHICH ARE MORE ORGANIC AND LESS C.G.I, BUT THE STUDIO DIDN'T LET HIM DO THAT, INSTEAD, THERE WERE A GROUP PEOPLE MAKING UNREAL SHEILDS OUT OF A SHAWL, BUT WHAT DOES A USUAL CINEMAGOER LIKE ME KNOWS, RIGHT.
THE BEST PART IS THAT THERE ARE A BUNCH OF RICH PEOPLE AT DISNEY LAUGHING THEIR ASSESS OF AT PEOPLE WHO THINK THAT THIS MOVIE IS SOCIALLY IMPORTANT BECAUSE IT SHOW THAT THEIR IS A FICTIONAL COUNTRY IN AFRIKA WHICH IS SO RICH AND ADVANCED THAT IT'S KING CAN ROAM AROUND IN THE SUIT OF A BLACK PANTHER.
P.S.- BUT, I WILL SAY THAT THE LAST SECOND END CREDIT OF BLACK PANTHER WAS ACTUALLY GREAT.
Whenever I hear sucha tyagi talks abt movies, I think she talks shit. Fast forward. Rahul's review is honest & no nautanki.
Sucharita could get it!
I’ll come back later!😂
Aaaj chai pehle hi aagyi😂😂😂😂
Actually watched black panther because of its reviews .. it was soooo overrated..
Firstly, this is going to be a long post. So, if you have some time, please bear with me.Mrs Chopra, while I agree with some of the comments that Rahul and you make, what is Sucharita upto? I come to your channel for some serious movie discussions. Why is Sucharita trying to make it a stand up show. I could have still handled it only if she was any good at it. This feels like you are sitting with a flunky (only she is not called Roger). In my opinion, the Shape of Water is a hugely relevant film, especially in today's mileau (intolerance, et al)
Do you guys can ever make a movie? It's too easy to to be biased by western movies after reading their movie reviews and all(e.g. shape of water because we already already knew that it was nominated and all). I myself like Hollywood movies. But reviewing and dissecting our movies when you guys are not good for anything (except Anupama who has written and closely associated with bollywood projects). Common get a life and do something on your own rather than criticizing
Asit Kar being critic is a job itself. anylyzing movies in own perspective. wen u say indian cricket team is playing badly does any1 ask u if u can play better than virat and rohit.
go n watch u tube video tht will suit ur iq level.
Praise the Hanuman 🚩
Difficult to understand whether these guys are trying to review films or highlighting mistakes and making fun of films.
Maybe aiyaary is not a good film.
But neeraj pandey has 3 8+IMDb rated films out of 5 films . and 4 have been successful and critically acclaimed .
that doesn't give him the privilege to receive criticism over a movie which he made and it turned out to be bad. Lots of respect to Neerej Pandey but aiyaary kharaab hai.
mohd anas Qureshi not saying it wasnt bad but i agree with the comment above that these people more than reviewing a movie start talking about why this movie is bad n why i dont like this movie.
The whole point of the movie is to empathize a little with Killmonger; That's why the villain resonates with so many people in this film; His rage against the "colonizers" is reflected in many marginalized communities. Its this emotion and perspective in the film that elevates Black Panther to one of the best Superhero films.