What I fund hypocritical is that most of the media wanted his head and when it happens ( wether it’s right or wrong) the media jumps up and down and bags the club. North Melbourne are not the first and won’t be the last to go through this..Btw Robbo is a total flog.
@@taxads7791 Are you serious? No coach can survive 10 goal losses every week. No coach can survive when all the KPIs are getting worse and worse with time. Just in the 2 years with noble, KPIs have worsened by double. No coach can survive that. Noble is not a bad guy, he had a go but it didnt work for him. 2 years is enough when nothing is improving, and he couldnt even get effort from players.
Yes, that's exactly how it looks to me. There are so many other people in the club that need to be looked at, but it is always easy to just sack the coach.
Anyone who took on this role was destined for failure. I don't understand why every club needs instant success...it's clear north needs at least 3-4 trade periods to be able to bring in some talent and get rid of some dead talent. I feel sorry for David Noble...he seems like a respectable man who did what he could in the role..unfortunately he doesn't have the talent in the team at the moment...and it was shown in the last round vs Collingwood when they got run over in the last quarter...that's not a coaching error...it's a lack of talent, cohesion and experience. Unfortunately when you lose so many games in a row it's hard to break that momentum and win but I find it astounding the pressure that was on David Noble instead of the board and media taking accountability at where North is and that they aren't likely to be successful anytime soon because of a lack of talent and a rebuild is needed. You can bring in Alastair Clarkson or any other coach...but it's going to take several years and trade periods to get the side back into finals contention. Instant success isn't going to happen and it's not a structural issue of where players are playing...it's a simple lack of talent that cannot compete with teams such as the midfield of melbourne and the forward line of Geelong and Carlton.
I disagree. Yes its true that he wasnt the only problem or even the cause of the problem, but over his 2 years, all the KPIs have doubled in the worse direction. It doesnt matter what rabble you have on field, a good coach will get improvement. The worst thing is Noble couldnt get players to even show effort. Players were obviously not playing for the coach. Noble is not a bad guy, he had a go, but it didnt work for him, 2 years is enough time to see some improvement or competitiveness, but it was only getting worse.
@@slipperyblock9679 that’s the dumbest thing I’ve ever read the coach can only do so much it’s up to the players to take the chances presented to them do you watch the footy or just listen to these flogs North Melbourne should have won it was there lack of skill and lack of pressure the game plan he had in place stood up wile the players were competing at 100% but when a few players drop of it isn’t the coach it’s the list management and players 🤦🏼♂️🥜
Thousands of people will get sacked this year but will any of them be people that were so desperate for their business,(club), to succeed than David Noble? Well,maybe Leon Cameron who,despite losing great players year after year,almost got GWS to their first flag. As a Freo fan Ross Lyon almost took us to the promised land but I still feel awful about how we treated Mark Harvey,who was just wonderful for our club. Good money I know,but it's a brutal job that will throw you very publically on the scrapheap if you don't reach the promised land.
@@paulweston285 this is a board that rejected brad Scott’s review, fired him and is 18 months removed from a senior coach walking out the door and not calling anyone or responding to any calls from the board in Rhys Shaw. Clearly a rotten club.
Norths board was more interested in getting memberships than actually winning games . Amarfio needs to go and the board needs to change to a winning games board !!
What annoyed me about it is how they said for weeks 'David Noble is our man' only to turn around and sack him when the losses got too high. Ffs as Sam Newman said even when North were successful in the 70's and 90's they were never a 'sexy side', everyone's heard the stories of how Arden Street used to look, being paid out of brown paper bags etc. Not saying they didn't sack coaches then, Wayne Schimmelbusch getting sacked in 93 brought Denis Pagan to the club which in turn brought those two flags. But for North to act like just because Arden Street looks better and they've got little to no debt means they can all of a sudden expect instant success is laughable. Literally Sonia Hood saying 'just because we're in a rebuild doesn't mean we shouldn't be winning' or whatever she said, that is literally what happens when you rebuild don't expect to be anywhere near the top of the ladder. They made Brad Scott, arguably their most successful coach since Pagan, turf out players that could have probably gone another year or two. The most disrespectful of which being Boomer, the player most casuals knew North for. They replaced them with what you can only describe as a failed rebuild thus far, and Scott got the arse once Brayshaw wasn't there to back him in anymore and they didn't get instant success. They then brought in two untried coaches, one lasted a year the other two years. I said the same about Carlton when they sacked Teague after bringing him in on a few wins, at some point, especially with a record like Carlton has, the club has got too look at themselves and admit they're the problem.
They made him turf what ultimately were players who could probably have still gone on for at least a few more years and provided him with what ultimately thus far has been a failed rebuild. So yes I'd say they did let him down, same with Shaw & Noble. The fact that Brad Scott was the most successful coach North has had since Pagan is telling.
North is losing for 1 main reason. they do not have the talent on the park. You could give them the greatest coaches of all time and this season would be basically the same.
True. They should employ Don Scott or some Hawks from the 80's who had the best under the table player payment system with banks all around the world paying players.
I'm a hawk and I disagree! 😂🤣to the other comment about hawk's paying players under the table well I think everyone was doing it! But if you got Clarko this year the team would be way more competitive! It's all about vibe and belief! Bring in clarko that vibe and belief goes through the roof! I disagree with a lot of the comments saying roos don't have talent! It's true but not a big a issue as CONFIDENCE BELIEF AND QUALITY GAME PLAN THAT ALL PLAYERS UNDERSTAND! That's what roos lack! And that's what Clarko will fix instantly! You put Clarko in the box next week see if there not pumped and competitive! Yes they will loose a lot but it won't be thrashing every week I can guarantee you that! Roos need to refind CONFIDENCE AND BELIEF! And Clarko will coach them he is to loyal not to! See if I'm wrong!!! Sam won't win as many games this year as Clarko did last year! And Sam has more talent than Clarko did!! Best coach ever! That will turn roos around! King ringing Lyon first over Clarko are you kidding me! Each to there own opinion! The hardest thing to teach is CONFIDENCE end of discussion!!
2 years after 72 they made the Grand finale and a year after that they won their first premiership. And they where the coolest football team ever. All because of the ten year rule. They were great days for north. PS I don't follow the Roos .
How the hell can anyone be talking about North Melbourne hiring Buckley as coach ?? If they do so it will only continue the relationship with the bottom 3 on the ladder.
Ross Lyon didn't treat all players equally.but no coaches do. Lachie Neale left Fremantle because of Ross Lyon. Plenty of others improved after leaving Fremantle. He would be a disaster for North Melbourne.
I would look at development staff, recruitment of players at the club and also the overall running of the club, David seemed to have a good idea of relationships from the outside looking in but clearly when you are losing by 50 to 100 points every week something has to change and unfortunately they blame the coach
It's not a crisis when any coach is sacked! Clarko was sacked last year no crisis here!!!! Clarko will coach roos he is exstreemly loyal see if I'm wrong!!
Footy success is money, to get success it's money. So the problem is money, if you ain't got it, you don't get it. It's easy for "experts" on the outside to rip the piss out of people, and clubs! Unfortunately too much notice is given to the views of burned out has-beens and never where's, that sit around a desk in front of a camera!
I always feared that when Gold Coast came in it would be at the expense of a Victorian club. Don't rule out the Gold Coast Roos. Personally I hope North survives in their own right.
North isn't going anywhere, so the non-North supporters should give up repeating that BS. North is debt free despite not resorting to generating easy cash from pokies like the other clubs do. North has also built a $7m state of the art multi purpose facility at Arden Street, so we're not going anywhere.
Slobbo is just like that ranting incoherent drunk at the end of the bar that's talking about cricket when everyone else is talking about football. What is he babbling on about?
The beginning of a rebuild that actually begun in 2016 when we delisted a whole swag of experience. That is when North's problems really begun. Noble had to go because he can't coach, it's that simple. Yes the list isn't good, but it isn't as bad as what Noble has made it to look like. He hasn't been able to improve skill levels, there has been no game plans that are identifiable and the players are playing without spirit, so he isn't even able to motivate them. We've got worse this year when we should have been improving. We'd be winless but for playing against the COVID hit WAFL Eagles.
Getting rid of most of that experience was probably a good thing in 2016. It was letting 13 players walk a few years back and trading Ben Brown and then last pre season losing Tarrant. I don't get how David Noble gets any of the blame for bad management and very poor list management.
@@richardbehan8118 Some of the delistings in 2016 were warranted, but I'd argue that the likes of Boomer and Del Santo should have been retained. My main point was that the rebuild didn't begin a few years ago but has in fact been happening since 2016. They have just managed to screw it up even more as time passed since then.
![Gunna - HIM ALL ALONG [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/w7Wf0h1Q8a4/mqdefault.jpg)
What I fund hypocritical is that most of the media wanted his head and when it happens ( wether it’s right or wrong) the media jumps up and down and bags the club. North Melbourne are not the first and won’t be the last to go through this..Btw Robbo is a total flog.
It's a strange decision, a development coach would normally get
longer than what he was given. Would have thought he would get 3 years.
@@taxads7791 Are you serious? No coach can survive 10 goal losses every week. No coach can survive when all the KPIs are getting worse and worse with time. Just in the 2 years with noble, KPIs have worsened by double. No coach can survive that. Noble is not a bad guy, he had a go but it didnt work for him. 2 years is enough when nothing is improving, and he couldnt even get effort from players.
Spot on.
That’s the media for you. And agree that Robbo is a flog 👍🏻👍🏻
What amazes me is people think the media has some moral or societal accountability. There a business that needs to make a profit. That simple.
please get robbo do a straight line walking test.
thank god somone else hears his slurring. Poor Gerrad
Just talks rot to
He wasn’t given the troops to work with
He chose to take on the role, nobody forced him to. He was very well paid to coach his team to many losses. No sympathy.
This feels so wrong. Anyone who has been in a toxic corporate work place knows that David Noble is a scapegoat
Yes, that's exactly how it looks to me. There are so many other people in the club that need to be looked at, but it is always easy to just sack the coach.
“We made the mutual decision to part ways with our senior coach”. Huh?
I think she means the board.
@@richardbehan8118 so..the Board made the mutual decision? My ‘Huh’ still stands.
@@waynesworld7804 I can only assume.
That's what every club says when they sack a coach
Anyone who took on this role was destined for failure. I don't understand why every club needs instant success...it's clear north needs at least 3-4 trade periods to be able to bring in some talent and get rid of some dead talent. I feel sorry for David Noble...he seems like a respectable man who did what he could in the role..unfortunately he doesn't have the talent in the team at the moment...and it was shown in the last round vs Collingwood when they got run over in the last quarter...that's not a coaching error...it's a lack of talent, cohesion and experience.
Unfortunately when you lose so many games in a row it's hard to break that momentum and win but I find it astounding the pressure that was on David Noble instead of the board and media taking accountability at where North is and that they aren't likely to be successful anytime soon because of a lack of talent and a rebuild is needed.
You can bring in Alastair Clarkson or any other coach...but it's going to take several years and trade periods to get the side back into finals contention. Instant success isn't going to happen and it's not a structural issue of where players are playing...it's a simple lack of talent that cannot compete with teams such as the midfield of melbourne and the forward line of Geelong and Carlton.
I disagree. Yes its true that he wasnt the only problem or even the cause of the problem, but over his 2 years, all the KPIs have doubled in the worse direction. It doesnt matter what rabble you have on field, a good coach will get improvement. The worst thing is Noble couldnt get players to even show effort. Players were obviously not playing for the coach.
Noble is not a bad guy, he had a go, but it didnt work for him, 2 years is enough time to see some improvement or competitiveness, but it was only getting worse.
The fact the team was up for 3 quarters and fell off in the 4th is the coach and leadership not pushing the standards
@@slipperyblock9679 that’s the dumbest thing I’ve ever read the coach can only do so much it’s up to the players to take the chances presented to them do you watch the footy or just listen to these flogs North Melbourne should have won it was there lack of skill and lack of pressure the game plan he had in place stood up wile the players were competing at 100% but when a few players drop of it isn’t the coach it’s the list management and players 🤦🏼♂️🥜
@@slipperyblock9679 that is hardly a fact.
new world order..everyone should get a medal..what a load of horse poo
More drama than a Glenn Archer BBQ !
How ironic. They played there first very good game against the Magpies and then he gets sacked. That's North Melbourne.
THEIR, spazz. not over there 😐
King was behind the , Get rid of Brad Scott group , and things have gone downhill since ???
King switches sides more than anyone
Exactly, his job is not on the line.
Has he ever coached before? His basically a administrator.. who the the hell employed him?
The board
Thousands of people will get sacked this year but will any of them be people that were so desperate for their business,(club), to succeed than David Noble? Well,maybe Leon Cameron who,despite losing great players year after year,almost got GWS to their first flag. As a Freo fan Ross Lyon almost took us to the promised land but I still feel awful about how we treated Mark Harvey,who was just wonderful for our club. Good money I know,but it's a brutal job that will throw you very publically on the scrapheap if you don't reach the promised land.
Anyone who says this is the right decision is blind, the board needs to go. Upper management is the issue. End of discussion.
Your right Jack and Noble is the scape goat for their mess.
@@paulweston285 this is a board that rejected brad Scott’s review, fired him and is 18 months removed from a senior coach walking out the door and not calling anyone or responding to any calls from the board in Rhys Shaw. Clearly a rotten club.
@@jackwaite4035 What about you fire David Noble but also replace the board too.
@@outlawrip-offartist4161 that won’t happen, the board is self serving and delusional. Just look at there history.
@@jackwaite4035 One commentator labelled the team as " Witches Hats " i think that was the straw
Always the Coach and thanks to the players for supporting him 🏉🏉
Why is it that the coach gets the sack when a team is not performing. some players should be getting the sack too as they are just as much to blame .
Norths board was more interested in getting memberships than actually winning games . Amarfio needs to go and the board needs to change to a winning games board !!
What annoyed me about it is how they said for weeks 'David Noble is our man' only to turn around and sack him when the losses got too high. Ffs as Sam Newman said even when North were successful in the 70's and 90's they were never a 'sexy side', everyone's heard the stories of how Arden Street used to look, being paid out of brown paper bags etc. Not saying they didn't sack coaches then, Wayne Schimmelbusch getting sacked in 93 brought Denis Pagan to the club which in turn brought those two flags. But for North to act like just because Arden Street looks better and they've got little to no debt means they can all of a sudden expect instant success is laughable. Literally Sonia Hood saying 'just because we're in a rebuild doesn't mean we shouldn't be winning' or whatever she said, that is literally what happens when you rebuild don't expect to be anywhere near the top of the ladder. They made Brad Scott, arguably their most successful coach since Pagan, turf out players that could have probably gone another year or two. The most disrespectful of which being Boomer, the player most casuals knew North for. They replaced them with what you can only describe as a failed rebuild thus far, and Scott got the arse once Brayshaw wasn't there to back him in anymore and they didn't get instant success. They then brought in two untried coaches, one lasted a year the other two years. I said the same about Carlton when they sacked Teague after bringing him in on a few wins, at some point, especially with a record like Carlton has, the club has got too look at themselves and admit they're the problem.
I was shocked when Brad Scott left. He had the potential. But the club I felt let him down.
They made him turf what ultimately were players who could probably have still gone on for at least a few more years and provided him with what ultimately thus far has been a failed rebuild. So yes I'd say they did let him down, same with Shaw & Noble. The fact that Brad Scott was the most successful coach North has had since Pagan is telling.
North is losing for 1 main reason. they do not have the talent on the park. You could give them the greatest coaches of all time and this season would be basically the same.
True. They should employ Don Scott or some Hawks from the 80's who had the best under the table player payment system with banks all around the world paying players.
I'm a hawk and I disagree! 😂🤣to the other comment about hawk's paying players under the table well I think everyone was doing it! But if you got Clarko this year the team would be way more competitive! It's all about vibe and belief! Bring in clarko that vibe and belief goes through the roof! I disagree with a lot of the comments saying roos don't have talent! It's true but not a big a issue as CONFIDENCE BELIEF AND QUALITY GAME PLAN THAT ALL PLAYERS UNDERSTAND! That's what roos lack! And that's what Clarko will fix instantly! You put Clarko in the box next week see if there not pumped and competitive! Yes they will loose a lot but it won't be thrashing every week I can guarantee you that! Roos need to refind CONFIDENCE AND BELIEF! And Clarko will coach them he is to loyal not to! See if I'm wrong!!! Sam won't win as many games this year as Clarko did last year! And Sam has more talent than Clarko did!! Best coach ever! That will turn roos around! King ringing Lyon first over Clarko are you kidding me! Each to there own opinion! The hardest thing to teach is CONFIDENCE end of discussion!!
No one has the courage to stay the course. David Noble is gone because the media wanted him gone and the club executives are cowards.
No one would be talking about North moving to tassie if North had a player like Wayne Carey, that’s what they need, a few star players.
It's only outsiders and the media who keep regurgitating it anyway. Nobody at North Melbourne is. That was put to bed when Buckley was the president.
New blood please! Celebrating 50 years when we won the wooden spoon 1972, but the 1972 side never lost by huge margins like 2022! 🎂
Not even the Essendon replacement team played as bad as NM.
2 years after 72 they made the Grand finale and a year after that they won their first premiership. And they where the coolest football team ever. All because of the ten year rule. They were great days for north. PS I don't follow the Roos .
I would be very interested in what Boomer Harvey has to say about this.
I would be interested in knowing what Boomer Harvey has to say about his son considering he should be in prison
What did he do
@@The_Schmelter he’s a rapist
Tbf he got turfed by Brad Scott not Noble
After watching Pav and Justin Longmuir on Face ti face, Id would ring Clarko asking if he could start tomorrow if was head Kahuna
How the hell can anyone be talking about North Melbourne hiring Buckley as coach ??
If they do so it will only continue the relationship with the bottom 3 on the ladder.
Come to the pies Nobes we’ve got a spot for ya in your preferred position in upper management
Ross Lyon didn't treat all players equally.but no coaches do. Lachie Neale left Fremantle because of Ross Lyon. Plenty of others improved after leaving Fremantle. He would be a disaster for North Melbourne.
I want Brent Harvey as coach! He is a premiership player! 👍👍 The coaching candidate list has a few duds! Ross Lyon and Choco, Williams
How are Ross Lyon and Mark Williams duds?
This is beginning to smell like Fitzroy
You sack a coach in a rebuild,
The people who sacked him are trying to save their own jobs ,
Bastards 😐☹️
david king..in life , Like footy has speed humps..you must be living in dreamland ..
Can we get a headphone warning for Robbo’s wild volume regulation?
Gerrard.... I JUST WANT TO KNOW WHY MATE
That's Footy
Noble Is In The Same Group As Neeld, Rhode, Bolton, Bailey, R.Shaw, McCartney & Judge.
So is Brent Harvey the new coach? Should be!
I would look at development staff, recruitment of players at the club and also the overall running of the club, David seemed to have a good idea of relationships from the outside looking in but clearly when you are losing by 50 to 100 points every week something has to change and unfortunately they blame the coach
It's not a crisis when any coach is sacked! Clarko was sacked last year no crisis here!!!! Clarko will coach roos he is exstreemly loyal see if I'm wrong!!
The next great coach
Hopefully Nicks isn’t too far behind.
Noble should be a football manager in administration, he is talented but coaching is not the right role!
He got way more games than he should have. AFL is too matey matey & not brutal enough.
Recruit top players, choose them on their commitment with that, or go away! Too many anchor players not given it a go! Player review next!,
Look at norths list 🤣 good luck to any coach with having them players on your side 🤣
North needs true ex player to coach or a "Alistair Clarkson"
Simpson to North. Clarkson to the Eagles.
I'd be happy with Simo for the next 3+
I wonder which team we'll be going through this BS with next year? 🤔
norf again
Essendon.
Norf. It's always norf. It's been norf for 20 years with a year break here and there
The board need to put there heads on the chopping black and have a reality check the fish rots from the top
THEIR, spastic. not over there 😐
It’s not the coach
How is Robbo still getting a gig on this show...it's all dribble
Lol he's hard to understand.
Agreed
You can't expect people to go to work sober.
Is Robbo on the sauce?
Either that or he's been going through a stroke for the last couple of years.
I'd think James Hird would be a good choice
Maybe even Leon Cameron?
Sad
Any chance Robbo could not drink a whole bottle of Makers Mark before going on air?
Holy sheesh
Footy success is money, to get success it's money. So the problem is money, if you ain't got it, you don't get it.
It's easy for "experts" on the outside to rip the piss out of people, and clubs! Unfortunately too much notice is given to the views of burned out has-beens and never where's, that sit around a desk in front of a camera!
What about john wolsford
Or Danni Laidley
@@paulweston285 you seem really obsessed with that person, maybe you're harbouring some of your own internal conflicts..
I think Woosha is done with coaching a Melbourne team.
@@lunch2102 The players could learn a lot from a woman like that
@@donna25871 they could even get Worsfold in as an assistant.
What a circus of a club.
Get woke go broke
@@paulweston285 did they really get woke? I missed that
@@TheGunmanChannel he thinks because Dean Laidley is now Danni, North is woke, he's clearly an idiot
@@paulweston285 cool rhyme. Doesn't apply here though.
Merge with Carlton
A Noble sacrifice!!!!!
Sack Robbo go north
he is like mark neeldt ... very old fashioned, stern, close minded, authoritarian.
That's an opinion.
@@richardbehan8118 I was going to say clubs shouldn't hire coaches like that. That would have been an opinion.
@@themaninawhitecoatandhat7503 well to say that someone is "stern, close minded and authoritarian" without facts to back it up is an opinion.
@@richardbehan8118 it's a character assassination maybe.
save north Melbourne from Geelong fan
I always feared that when Gold Coast came in it would be at the expense of a Victorian club. Don't rule out the Gold Coast Roos. Personally I hope North survives in their own right.
robbo less coherent than my dementia ridden grandma
Norfs slow death brings my soul joy
Good evening, Mr Slobbinson. Can you please walk straightly along the line, or recite the alphabet backwards.
Why is everyone taking about clarkson and etc. What about the man who has done it 2 already, proven track record. Paul Roos
Mate, Paul roos is one of the most overatted premiership coaches of all time. Geezer is in it for the money
Paul Roos 4 KangaRoos 😁🙂
Send north to Tassie ASAP and give them 5 years they’ll win a premiership call them the north Tasie Devils
Just, Taz Devils, with blue and white colours.
Never a north video without the customary assclown comments..
We don't want em, we won't have em.
@@jamiekelly6851 it's funny that you think you have a say in what happens
North isn't going anywhere, so the non-North supporters should give up repeating that BS. North is debt free despite not resorting to generating easy cash from pokies like the other clubs do. North has also built a $7m state of the art multi purpose facility at Arden Street, so we're not going anywhere.
Slobbo is just like that ranting incoherent drunk at the end of the bar that's talking about cricket when everyone else is talking about football. What is he babbling on about?
Robbo a dinosaur, needs to go, get a young ex AFL guy in to replace him.
Agreed, but an ex coach would be better.
The beginning of a rebuild that actually begun in 2016 when we delisted a whole swag of experience. That is when North's problems really begun. Noble had to go because he can't coach, it's that simple. Yes the list isn't good, but it isn't as bad as what Noble has made it to look like. He hasn't been able to improve skill levels, there has been no game plans that are identifiable and the players are playing without spirit, so he isn't even able to motivate them. We've got worse this year when we should have been improving. We'd be winless but for playing against the COVID hit WAFL Eagles.
Getting rid of most of that experience was probably a good thing in 2016. It was letting 13 players walk a few years back and trading Ben Brown and then last pre season losing Tarrant.
I don't get how David Noble gets any of the blame for bad management and very poor list management.
@@richardbehan8118 Some of the delistings in 2016 were warranted, but I'd argue that the likes of Boomer and Del Santo should have been retained. My main point was that the rebuild didn't begin a few years ago but has in fact been happening since 2016. They have just managed to screw it up even more as time passed since then.
Bring back Danielle Laidley I say she did awesome things for that club.
Norf
Melbin.
Lol
Norf
Robo is so hard to listen too
TO, spastic 😐
robo should retire from tv
Pure raving drunk,all gibberish,did he play any football?