A citizen of a democratic country should not have to justify why they are traveling overseas. That's a basic civil right of a citizen. It's also quite egregious that that she's being questionef for being young and traveling alone. Stopping human trafficking isn't an excuse.
The nation issuing the visa to the filipino takes care of the verification if it is really a legit visit or for illegal purposes, it is their nation after all. When she gets to israel she'll undergo through their screening process and be approved or approved by their customs on whether she is a legal visitor to their country. Ang trabaho lang dapat ng pilipinas diyan ay i-verify kung totoo ang visa at maayos lahat ng papel niya. The BI should only move if they had concrete suspicions that the traveler is not legit and it is up to them to work on proving their suspicion and not the filipina tourist work on proving her travel's legitimacy.
True, they keep on giving Filipinos going out of the country to travel a hard time but cant seem to identify pedophiles and scammers who enter the country. Power trip pa more
This is justifiable because Philippines is a hotbed of human trafficking. Kung naka-alis yan gawing slave maltratuhin sa ibang bansa pang Magpakailan man story na naman or Wish Ko Lang
Sue them in court. This will not end the misery of our countrymen. Let them pay all the expenses that caused your delay. Noli please help her to sue this guy.
Not just refund but pay for moral damages and loss of time. That BI should be fired from the job. Whoever is running the department should be questioned. Cases like this should never happen again.
Ano na kasi ginagawa ng civil service commission? Taga gawa na lang ba sila ng napahirap ng examination. One of the Philippine State Commission walang saya sa mga ginagawang kapalpakan ngayon ng mga nasa government service
Finally someone is addressing this issue. Yung mga immigration officers pinapapahirapan tayong mga pilipino. Exaggerated yung mga tanong nila. Only in the Philippines 😔
Who interrupted her travel should pay back her ticket. It's not fair what she went through and without any liable cause that she was left behind her flight for being interrupted with massive unnecessary questioning.
@@anniesimborios3751 sana nga po ganun..kaso parang wla namang konsensya mga taga NAIA...at kailanmay hindi kmi maiintindihan ng iba kasi hindi cla nka experience ng kagaya samin..Peace be with you all mga kabayan
This is not an isolated case. I experienced the same thing when I had to travel overseas to attend a conference. She was not targeted because she's alone. I was leaving with other women (we are all from the same company) and I suffered the same treatment. I was planning to file a case back then ( I even told my family that I'm willing to spend my life savings for lawsuit fees), but I considered the possible implications to the company that organized the conference. To be honest, being interrogated and treated like a criminal was the most degrading thing that happened to me. That experience was traumatic.
Not isolated po kasi 1% lang sa 32k na na hold yung my case na human trafficking o illegal so napaka bulok talaga ng sistema dpt kasuhan na yyng head kasi alam nila lahat to
Same experience last 2017. Daming irrelevant questions. The IO even asked for pictures of me and my bf as proof na bf ko daw ba talaga kasama ko. Hanggang sa na missed ko na lang flight ko to HK kaka scroll ng IO sa cp ko. Nakaka trauma sila.
In reality, it is the RIGHT of every Filipinos to travel as long as they have the money to support their expenses! And nobody has the right to prevent you from leaving your country UNLESS there’s a HOLD DEPARTURE ORDER filed against you!
I also experienced the same thing..and its not only one person involved, almost everyone inside NAIA conspired..somebody approached me just before I reach the BIO and even after passing the BIO, another guy ran after me accompanied by a security guard...im about 50meters away from the entrance of the plane when they ask me to go with them for interrogation..they ask me how much money do i have , i said not much,so they tried to stop me from boarding..as i had no choice, i told them i will ring my grandmother who happens to be an RTC Judge, when they heard me talking, they said some words to each other like saying "tagilid tayo" and they left...thanks God...after that incident, i talked with my friends abroad and many of them were victims of extortion..if they sense that you are gullible they will try their very best without hesitance..I just hope and pray that they will stop this.
All those who have experienced this issue must unite and file class administrative and criminal case to give examples for all corrupt personnel and officials in the airport..
Can we have all these abusive and arrogant immigrant officers get fired and no pension for their arrogant behavior all these years? Matagal na silang ganyan at ngayon lang sila na-exposed sa media. Let's clean up the Immigration office and get rid of these arrogant employees. It's time to put their foot back on the ground. Tingin nila immortal sila.
Meron pang nag comment sa isang video tungkol din dito na isang immigration officer din at sibrang yabang sabi nya they can offload passengers for any reasons daw. Sinagot ko yung comment nya na kahit power tripping lng ang reason? Dapat magkaroon man lng konsensya tong mga taong ito. Mga sobrang entitled sa position nila.
@@WENG4898 how do you know po na totoo syang immigration officer po at hindi isang troll lamang? Nagpakita ba sya ng ID? Kaya po maraming naloloko online at text message kasi po masyado kayong nagpapaniwala.
Go " GIRL" it happened to me in other way... The only word I said is . There u go u. Hear that ? Final BOARDING BOUNDTO....... IF I MISSED THAT FLIGHT AND I LOST MY JOB.. I WILL SUE THIS PLACE.". I M A FILIPINO CANADIAN.
I experienced the same with all the checking of emails, bank accounts both here in the Philippines and abroad. It was traumatic indeed. It felt like they’re so bitter that you’re traveling. I can still point out who is that man.
Opo. I was really devastated kasi it was my first time to travel as a tourist not as an OFW. Ung minamaliit ka kasi bbiyahe at ininsulto pa ako. My God talaga.
kabayan, pls follow up immigration as to their concrete steps to reimburse this woman for the unreasonable hassle they caused her. an apology is not enough.
Apology is not enough talaga paano yung magastos ng tao thank u na lang?Palitan lahat ng IO sa NAIA Kkung may visa at return ticket naman payagan na nila umalis dahil bago makakuha ng visa katakot takot na papers na ang naibigay ng traveller
There is only one reason why an immigration officer and all government employees in general are asking for the impossible and the ridiculous i.e. he is fishing for a bribe. In this particular case, another official seemed to be acting in collusion with Abdullah, selecting possible victims to induce bribery.
@ Marilyn Moreno, I think you are right, why would the Airport's,employees would asked personal questions,it has nothing to do with the passenger flights, they are surely hustling for money.
1:57 Israel is not a tourist destination? Then he proceeds to later ask if she already went to Israel after she explained that she booked another flight with another carrier using her money. De Castro is a talking head.
I missed my flight to a wedding of my brother. Cost me a total of 50.000 pesos and a lot of stress because of immigration. Filing an official complain does not exists. We are being treated as cockroaches.
It happened to me in 2010, I got offloaded because of long nonsense Immigration interrogation. I have no choice, but to rebook the ticket. Huh! I travelled to UAE, UK, France and Canada, but I never experience such terrible and traumatic interrogation from their Immigration officer. I heard so many stories like this, the government has to do some investigation.
You had not experienced Gestapo like interrogation in foreign airports because their personnel are not corrupt unlike Foolipinos who are extremely corrupt !
Well the govt itself is corrupt!! Don't expect help from them! They're all connected to criminal organizations, the difference is they have badges, uniforms & govt positions!!
6:09 Philippine Immigration apology is nothing without compensation. They should refund your rebooking expense. Not to mention compensation for violation of a human right to movement without harassment and delay.
Me and my daughter had a bad experience with the immigration officer/s…during pandemic, they are not allowing my daughter to enter the Philippines, my daughter presented a certificate to enter the country in lieu of a Philippine passport. According to the immigration officer there is no such thing as a late birth registry, and the the certificate issued by the Phil consulate is not acceptable. Then another officer went to the booth, until there were 3 including the supervisor…the supervisor even said that there is a new guidelines, but cannot explain to me what it is all about, I told the officer that the was issued the day after we left SFO, therefore that doesn’t apply to us. They keep asking for a Philippine passport, i keep telling them that they issue the certificate instead because of the furlough due to pandemic. I even told them that i even have an email from the immigration regarding the requirements for our trip. After 2 hours, they finally stamp the certificate. And 7:12 the lady in the airport told me that they just waiting for me to bribe them!!!! This is so sad!
The IOs at NAIA Terminal 2 also took pictures of my passport, bank details, credit cards, and laman ng bank ko po. I felt humiliated po, sana mabigyan to ng aksyon. Ang kapal pa ng dala kong docs, sana po mabigyan ng leksyon yang mga tao sa immigration!!!
If the name/names of this/these BI personnel is not published, if this/these people are not investigated, punished, given a lesson, then, i'll never believe in the sincerity of the BI in ensuring that this will not happen anymore. Pity the poor, ordinary human beings. One way to avoid this is to assign trusted observers in all their dealings.
They protect their own, dahil majority sa mga yan magnanakaw at corrupt! Hindi sila sincere sa apologies or whatever excuses nila. Mauulit lang yan. Mga patay gutom kasi employees ng BI, kaya matakaw sa pera at kapangyarihan!
Worst airport in the world.. My indonesian friend had similar experience last June 2022 when I invited him to visit the philipines. I am a phil-am living in Florida and I went ahead to the philippines and we agreed na susunduin ko sya sa NAIA. Hindi sya pinapasok at he was hold 2 days sa airport dahil lang hindi sya fluent sa english at gumagamit lang ng translator. Ako naman too stressed sa labas ng airport at walang magawa until such time sa third day isinakay pabalik sa Indonesia. So sad ang nangyayari dyan sa bansa natin. I travelled to many international countries like Canada, Europe, middle east at hindi ganyan kabubo ang mga immigration. Dapat ang mga yan palitan na!
Nangyayari sa amin yan ng bunso q nung 3 years old pal ng sya. now she’s 19 years old na . Pabalik na kmi ng Japan nun ng e hold aq ng immigration kc may mga tanong daw. Tinanong aq na kesyo saang parti ng Japan kmi pupunta etc… Talagang cnagot q sya na bkit tinatanong nyo aq ng mga question na ganyan e kumpleto aq sa papers at sa Japan kmi nka base. At talagang pnkta q na bweset na aq, buti nlang dumating ung babae na mas mataas sa knla,at tinanong anong nangyari at bkit nka hold kmi,kung may promlema daw ba sa papers..Nung cnb ng lalaki at babae na nag hold sa akin na wala nman tinatanong lang aq kung saang parti ng Japan pupunta,. Pinagalitan sila nung babae na mas mataas ang posisyon sa knla,na kumpleto nman daw pala aq sa papers bkit aq hinold, kya ayon ura urada aq na ni released .Gusto kc nilang mka kuha pera sa akin kc nkta nila sa papers q na military wife aq at ibang lahi asawa q.😡
It sounds like the immigration officer has a powerful relative,he didn't get suspended,just working out of sight.Its really time for Filipinos to put government workers in a higher standard,since they work for the Filipino tax payers.
A grave abuse of power and discretion was obviously committed by the IO. Also, it shows that IO lacks the skills to properly screen travelers who he suspects of a possible victim of human trafficking. Does the BI provide adequate training for IOs?
They’re skilled pero gnyan ang sistema nila kse dyan. Sadya ang mga gingwa nila kse my black market dyan sa loob gsto nila lagi under the table. 😂😂😂 kkhya satin! Hnde mwala ang corruption!
Naalala ko rin po ngyari sakin sa Clark Airport sa immigration same what happened to her, muntik na po ako naiwan ng aking flight sa sobrang haba ng tanong nila sakin, that was last year of July Ilan beses na tinawag ang pangalan pero dami paring tanong sa immigration about sa background ng education ko at saang bansa pa ako galing malaking pasasalamat ko sa Qatar Airlines talagang hinintay ako so I did not lost my flight, 3 silang ng interview sa akin at asking din Ilan ang dala kung pera nakakalungkot lng talaga sana po maayos na to. God bless po sa inyo Jan sa Clark immigration.
Violation of your human rights when your cell was taken from you then read the messages without a search warrant. And I can not believe this is happening a lot in the Philippines. She needs to file a criminal case. Too many syndicate is running your country.
Ang parusa lang sa officer na abusado, ilalagay lang sa back office. Dapat diyan tanggal na sa serbisyo. Sobrang humiliation, gastos ang inabot ng pasahero.
Here's the questions that IO should ask 1. In case of emergency alam mo ba Philippines Embassy na bansang pupuntahan mo? 2. Do you have the address/phone number? 3. Can I see the print copy of the address/phone no# These questions are basic, but critical questions. Pupusta ako karamihan sa Tourist/OFW walang contact information ng embassy.
This issue must be pursue to discuss in the senate. All questions is irrelevant and the immigration division is accountable to the troubled they made😡😡😡
ALL IMMIGRATION OFFICIALS TOP TO THE LOWEST PERSON NEED "FORMAL TRAINING" AND TESTED. SET STANDARDS ACROSS AND HOLD QUARTERLY ONLINE INSERVICE TRAINING WITH QUESTIONS AND ANSWER THEY NEED TO PASS. SHAMEFUL THAT THE PHILIPPINES IS BEHIND OTHER COUNTRIES IMMIGRATION STANDARDS. TIME FOR HIGHER UP OFFICIALS TO STEP UP AND BE ACCOUNTABLE AND FIX THIS MESS.
Yearbook? What a stupid question!!! Who carries their yearbook with them when they travel? Those idiots at immigration should know what a valid visa stamp looks like. Furthermore, such lengthy “interview” is tantamount to an interrogation and illegal detention which they have no right to do!!! It is imperative that they implement a time limit on these interviews or else reimburse their victim for their ineptitude. They need to update their questionnaire and training manual to properly catch possible human trafficking victims. First, the screeners and now this?!!! Is there anything that airport can do right? 😤😤😤🤬🤬🤬
@@melmel9571 Or they can ask us to bring our diploma. Schools will then have to publish grad pics for verification. Being in the immigration for 2 hours is simply ridiculous. They're also not willing to give their names. When you ask, they would ask why? When you say someone said this to you, they would then say, what's the name of the BI agent that told you to do so?
Senate and Congress shld make an inquiry and investigation on the rampant abuses of Bureau of Immigration for deliberately asking questions that are out of context resulting to off loading of passengers. Such maltreatment must stopped. PBBM should take action to revamp BI personnel from top to bottom.
Supreme Court should act now to stop tte bureau of immigration from abusing the rights of Filipinos for decades to travel . We also encourage the UN and its commission on human rights to investigate all Philippine immigration officials for rights abuses. This will be a more popular move for Filipinos instead of going after Duterte
@@shamrock214 which makes the injustices of so many Filipinos being offloaded at the discretion of immigration officials tantamount to a wholesale violation of human rights. A class suit should be filed by thousands against Philippine immigration officials
This is not the only offloading case due to BIs over questioning and irrelevant documents asked. If you google and check youtubes, a lot of filipinos voiced out their offloading experienced. Philippines is becoming like North Korea. As long as a passenger has valid passport, plane ticket and no hold departure order the passenger should be able to leave country without questions. Only court can decide if one can travel or not. BI dont have power to stop someone from travelling if theres no hold departure order. Even on their website, nothing that says they have authority to stop someone from travelling if theres no hold departure order. They cant stop you just because of speculation. I hope BI is aware that if a passenger will carry so much documents irrelevant to the travel, the host or receiving country might not let them enter. Its already difficult to get a visa or to afford to travel and being oflfoaded without refund or reimbursement is very frustrating. Some people like to travel solo or meeting someone in other countries. Its none of BI’s business.
Actually nagugutom lang sila, kase kami dati nung katrabaho ko naOffload din dahil hindi kami nagbigay ng 14K. Pero nabook din kami ng company the following week
While those corrupt IO's are kept in their positions, NAIA will always be branded as one of the worst if not the worst airport in the world. What a shame. We will lose tourism thru the kind of discouragement and embarrassment such as this. Total revamp should be conducted within the BOI in the airport.
I have the same experience po during 2021 the immigration officer asked me to open my family group chat and even asked me to open my bank account. Which i feel violated, but couldnt do anything that time buti nlng pinayagan ako maka travel and im 5min closer bago lumipad ang plane.
Kabayan Noli, please investigate ASAP Tickets because so many Filipinos from US were not refunded by this travel agency during lockdown. They are so shrewd, dishonest and corrupt. Let them pay for what they did to the Filipinos in the US.
ang nakakasama ng loob dito hindi naman talaga naparusahan yung BI officer nilipat lang dapat maparusahan yung BI officer dapat din yung bi officer na nagkasala humingi ng sorry personal at bayaran nya yung nagastoa para sa rebook ng ticket ang nangyare parang tinatago sya ng BI parang malakas ang kapit sa loob ng departamento
Hindi sapat Ang parusang warning , reprimand, suspension, and retraining , tangal sa position dapat extermination of all corrupt BI personnel including their families . Ganitong corrupt attitude Ng sa lahat na Gagovernment offices ay rampant . Even a very lowly position stencil boys sa LTO Pasig acts a very authoritative voice , sa police station pag kumuha ka Ng police report Ang ibang police uses threat and intimidation para maglagay ka , Ang mga traffic enforcers sa Manila ganun din uses threat and intimidation para maglagay ka pag hindi ka maglagay lagyan nila Ng arrogant Ang ticket mo para may another penalty na 500 ganyan ka walang hiya Ang mga ibang Foolipino . Kaya if given satanic power I'll exterminate forty percent of Philippines population para mahinto na Ang mga corruption sa bansa natin !
My husband's phone was also checked in NAIA immigration desk when he was about to fly to Indonesia. A lot of questions! But thank God he was allowed to fly to Jakarta.
Matagal ng ganyan ang Immigration. Pati chat with the relative living abroad gusto nila basahin. Even with those with their Sponsor still ino-Offload nila! Then may mga pinapapasok sila at iniEscort pa nga ng Immigration Officer. Mga nagbayad mga yun pra makapasok. Yan ang totoong dahilan kung bakit maraming na oOffload.
Nakakatakot naman yung ang IO mismo humawak ng phone niya at tinignan laman ng email niya?! Dami nga sa atin ni ayaw ipahawak sa kapamilya natin phone natin tapos yung officer ganun2 lang?!
I had the same experience, way back in 2017, When i was interrogated by 2 BI officers at the back office where they even checked my phone including my emails, skype, messenger and txt messages. It took me about 15 minutes to answer all their questions. I was able to get in when the officer said to the other officer that he didn't see any trace. Perhaps any trace of illegal employment or whatsoever. Who knows what trace it is. My brother and I are bound to Singapore for a three day tour.
Been to SG many times Naman pero never experienced what you experienced. We were just asked about our hotel accommodation, our itinerary for our whole stay (I printed all the booked tickets of the places we plan to go to like USS etc), return ticket and the usual. The only personal question that the IO asked of me was like what is my job?.
Marami pa pong gnayang istoray sir Kabayan...kahit yung sa kanaya late na, sana sir, tulungan nyong maglahad pa yung marami nating mag kababayan na nakaranas ng di patas na mga interview at requirements sa Immigration Officers, salamat po.
Bureau of Immigration should be responsible for purchasing her ticket . This is totally unacceptable. Perhaps , the officer was waiting for a bribe. The Bureau of Immigration has so many corrupt personnel and this is common knowledge. Remember the Pastillas scandal. And this in only what was discovered and revealed. How about those that were never found out. The reason why so many illegal Chinese in the Philippines where they just remain in the country incognito running illegal businesses and other criminal activities.
ABS CBN, Please continue to bring up issues on BI and NAIA incompetence, unprofessionalism, ignorance, power-tripping, greed, disrepute, and the like, so that it gets the needed attention from lawmakers. They have the worse reputation of all government agencies.
Not all are travelling there (Israel) as tourist will plan to work. If there are already valid reasons for returning, why hold and be questioned irrelevantly? If you are that person being questioned, you might feel that it's not confirmation but interrogation.
They should provide a written cause of hold from flight so that may proof. And then if the BI staff abused his/her position then they should JAIL first then fired. ABUSADO KAU> from head to lowest staff. NAKAKAHIYA KAU MGA PI KAU sa BI
There is no such thing as a safe Rights for Filipinos in our country when our personal lives are being questioned and interfered, Discrimination is what we experience daily and the Rich and the Poor thing which is sad but true
Please they need to do something about this kasi nakakatakot na mag travel lalo na sa mga nag ipon talaga para mag enjoy sana tapos ganito gagawin nila…
Sasagutin ng immigration ang refund dapat. At bakit hindi sinibak? Parang ,something fishy. Naranasan ko rin medyo naharass as airport way back 1983. Galing ng Saudi.
I don't understand the Big News with her experience. This is Not New!! But good for her to bring it forward MAYBE things will change. In 2019 I missed a flight from Manila to Singapore after hours being interviewed with my friend. We were going for a 3-day weekend trip but missed the flight even though checked in at the airport 3 hours before departure and even hearing our flight being called they said too bad come earlier next time. I said we checked in as soon as we were allowed and we missed the flight and left the airport. Lost money because of missed flight:, Grab to airport, Grab back home, air ticket for 2 people and 1 night hotel (allowed to cancel the last 2 nights without penalty). I felt the Immigration Officer wanted cash to let us go to our flight but I refused to do that and as I said we were held with endless questions until our flight departed and we were still in immigration. Good for this lady for raising the issue hope they improve their outdated departure system/rules. They need to travel and see how professional it is in other countries and learn a better system. Checklist for next trip: 1. Passport 2. Cash 3. Credit Card 4. Vaccination Record 5. YEAR BOOK 😂
This is very obvious na may mga inside job yan sila jan. Akala nila, after nila kayong ma off-load,magre-rebook kau for another trip. At sa rebooking niyo na un magkakaroon sila ng commision from the airlines since they couldn't ask for lagay galing sainyo kc nga naman mahahalata?🤔
@@niccapasobillo2923 Wow I never thought of this reason Salamat after missing our flight and losing all that money (Grab fare 2x, our air tickets X 2, and one night hotel cost lost) I couldn't afford to rebook for awhile then never did again and have never been to Singapore - so too bad for airline and too bad for Singapore they got money out of me one time but not a second.
Sadly, they're still doing it even after her viral video. The only difference is they would let you go for as long as they see that you have a stable job and you can afford it. It was my flight last Friday and I'm traveling alone too. I thought I would NOT make it after seeing the same stupid process they did to her like asking me about when I graduated, my job, the money I have, my manager, the kind of company I work for, etc then in the end they asked me to talk to the immigration head officer... 😮😮 Akala ko ma-ooffload ako. But luckily I made it. ❤ Tingin ko medyo niluwagan na nila kase napahiya na sila because of this brave girl. Pero pramis!!! Ganun parin mga tanong nila. Walang nagbago. Parehong-pareho parin kay Ate Girl. The only difference is mas malaki na yung chance mong hindi ma-offload if you have a stable job, have your legal documents ready, and if you show that you're financially capable.
i am really happy na pinapaulit ulit naten itong issue na to para mabuksan ang mga mata ng buong pilipinas sa kawalang hiyaan ng immigration officers naten (hndi lahat , pero meron talaga sadyang ganun)..
The Govt should do something sa Bureau of Immigration👍It happened to me & My Daughter before.. There's a lot of Questions like the B.Cert.of my Daughter..Our UK VISA..The Invitation of my Sister Who is a Nurse in London...& It took us almost 30 mins👍Glad that We didn't Missed our Flight..
I remember the time when my daughter was coming here to the US, the immigration interviewer was giving her a hard time inspite that all papers and documents are legal and in order. All she felt was that the immigration man wanted to extort money to let her go But she was from the University of the Philippines and with a strong sense of nationalism she would never give in to that. Finally, he let her go. Now they're doing the same tactics but the only difference is that it is worse today.
Mas mahigpit pa sila sa BI ng US & aside from that very irrelevant ang mga question about the passenger’s itinerary malinaw na abuse of authority. That BI has to meet the consequences of his actions. But I have a question, why do you have to pay to rebook a ticket? Kc it happened to me several times last 2021 from Canada to US, Canada to France and one time Canada to Philippines all I did is rebook without paying anything. The delay is not my fault it’s because of the very long lineup but the questions are brief. We know they are just following orders from their superiors but they have no knowledge to comply. Those BI should be replaced & should be reprimanded.
I had this kind of bad experienced way back 2019 on my first vacation in NAIA T1, hoping maturuan ng leksyon ang mga staff na gumagawa ng mali sa profession nila.
![Unang Balita sa Unang Hirit: DECEMBER 26, 2024 [HD]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/P0NRg0Pc7ho/mqdefault.jpg)
![Unang Balita sa Unang Hirit: DECEMBER 26, 2024 [HD]](/img/tr.png)
A citizen of a democratic country should not have to justify why they are traveling overseas. That's a basic civil right of a citizen. It's also quite egregious that that she's being questionef for being young and traveling alone. Stopping human trafficking isn't an excuse.
Discrimination...and power trippings
@@jonnamaerojero6992 💯agree
The nation issuing the visa to the filipino takes care of the verification if it is really a legit visit or for illegal purposes, it is their nation after all. When she gets to israel she'll undergo through their screening process and be approved or approved by their customs on whether she is a legal visitor to their country.
Ang trabaho lang dapat ng pilipinas diyan ay i-verify kung totoo ang visa at maayos lahat ng papel niya. The BI should only move if they had concrete suspicions that the traveler is not legit and it is up to them to work on proving their suspicion and not the filipina tourist work on proving her travel's legitimacy.
True, they keep on giving Filipinos going out of the country to travel a hard time but cant seem to identify pedophiles and scammers who enter the country. Power trip pa more
This is justifiable because Philippines is a hotbed of human trafficking. Kung naka-alis yan gawing slave maltratuhin sa ibang bansa pang Magpakailan man story na naman or Wish Ko Lang
Bring in the head of immigration to senate for a hearing. He/she is the one responsible for all the mess they created.
Basta ako ibubuto ko ang senador na dadalhin ang issue na ito sa senado.
Tama. Mabuti nag viral tong issue na to.
@@wynnercausing6157 kung hindi ay nako, hindi maka tarungan ang ginagawa nila.
may mga siraulo sa Naia tlga!!!😡😡😡😡😡
Naghahanap ng kurakot mga yan, immigration corrupt, Naia employees magnanakaw, yan ang news palagi
she's an eye opener and voice to everyone who suffered the same as her....
Marami naman nagvovoice out ng horrible experience nila sa mga IO hindi lang napapansin o nagtitrend. Tsaka di na yan bago alam na ng lahat yan.
Sue them in court. This will not end the misery of our countrymen. Let them pay all the expenses that caused your delay. Noli please help her to sue this guy.
Not just refund but pay for moral damages and loss of time. That BI should be fired from the job. Whoever is running the department should be questioned. Cases like this should never happen again.
Ano na kasi ginagawa ng civil service commission? Taga gawa na lang ba sila ng napahirap ng examination. One of the Philippine State Commission walang saya sa mga ginagawang kapalpakan ngayon ng mga nasa government service
dapat lng
Finally someone is addressing this issue. Yung mga immigration officers pinapapahirapan tayong mga pilipino. Exaggerated yung mga tanong nila. Only in the Philippines 😔
mali lng ang sistema, marami talaga nag di disguise na tourist but eventually mag wo work talaga.
Dapat yang mga immigration officer na nagpapahirap sa mga byahero na sobrang interview na wala nmang saysay ay dapat sibakin sa pwesto
Checking personal emails is a direct violation of privacy law
Who interrupted her travel should pay back her ticket. It's not fair what she went through and without any liable cause that she was left behind her flight for being interrupted with massive unnecessary questioning.
That's a good question need to be discuss in the Senate, Congress and High Court.
Yup, Cybercrime Prevention Act of 2012, RA No. 10175!
yes totoo yan, kailangan ng warrant pag ganyan, tipong criminal na inimbestigahan grabehan tong BI
@@anniesimborios3751 sana nga po ganun..kaso parang wla namang konsensya mga taga NAIA...at kailanmay hindi kmi maiintindihan ng iba kasi hindi cla nka experience ng kagaya samin..Peace be with you all mga kabayan
This is not an isolated case. I experienced the same thing when I had to travel overseas to attend a conference. She was not targeted because she's alone. I was leaving with other women (we are all from the same company) and I suffered the same treatment. I was planning to file a case back then ( I even told my family that I'm willing to spend my life savings for lawsuit fees), but I considered the possible implications to the company that organized the conference. To be honest, being interrogated and treated like a criminal was the most degrading thing that happened to me. That experience was traumatic.
Not isolated po kasi 1% lang sa 32k na na hold yung my case na human trafficking o illegal so napaka bulok talaga ng sistema dpt kasuhan na yyng head kasi alam nila lahat to
Same experience last 2017. Daming irrelevant questions. The IO even asked for pictures of me and my bf as proof na bf ko daw ba talaga kasama ko. Hanggang sa na missed ko na lang flight ko to HK kaka scroll ng IO sa cp ko. Nakaka trauma sila.
@@oddinary30 so kahit sa panahon ni FpPRD
Sino ka ba? sino ba kau? anong makukuha nila pag e hold?
Sya din kaya yun immig officer?
In reality, it is the RIGHT of every Filipinos to travel as long as they have the money to support their expenses! And nobody has the right to prevent you from leaving your country UNLESS there’s a HOLD DEPARTURE ORDER filed against you!
True.
True !!!big true
Tama....
Exactly 💯 mukhang May katangahan ang mamamahala ngaun sa immigration 😢
every FILIPINO. Singular not plural po. You’ll thank me later
I also experienced the same thing..and its not only one person involved, almost everyone inside NAIA conspired..somebody approached me just before I reach the BIO and even after passing the BIO, another guy ran after me accompanied by a security guard...im about 50meters away from the entrance of the plane when they ask me to go with them for interrogation..they ask me how much money do i have , i said not much,so they tried to stop me from boarding..as i had no choice, i told them i will ring my grandmother who happens to be an RTC Judge, when they heard me talking, they said some words to each other like saying "tagilid tayo" and they left...thanks God...after that incident, i talked with my friends abroad and many of them were victims of extortion..if they sense that you are gullible they will try their very best without hesitance..I just hope and pray that they will stop this.
If given satanic power I'll drop an atomic bomb sa NAIA para maubus na Ang mga corrupt na empleyado Dyan !
that was i thought . . .
Kawawa tayong mga karaniwang mamayang pilipino. Nakakasuklam tong gobyerno natin.
woah, even extortion?!
@@greyfortitude18 sinasadya nila yan lalo na si PBBM ang president ng Pilipinas
All those who have experienced this issue must unite and file class administrative and criminal case to give examples for all corrupt personnel and officials in the airport..
Yes, they really should do that. Kasi it will happen again and again. At walang katapusan Yan ginagawa nila. Unless mapalitan Ang mga namumuno.
😅
Tama po
This desk officer must not only put on the back office, he should be fired and not to be hired in any public position.
😅
Can we have all these abusive and arrogant immigrant officers get fired and no pension for their arrogant behavior all these years? Matagal na silang ganyan at ngayon lang sila na-exposed sa media. Let's clean up the Immigration office and get rid of these arrogant employees. It's time to put their foot back on the ground. Tingin nila immortal sila.
Meron pang nag comment sa isang video tungkol din dito na isang immigration officer din at sibrang yabang sabi nya they can offload passengers for any reasons daw. Sinagot ko yung comment nya na kahit power tripping lng ang reason? Dapat magkaroon man lng konsensya tong mga taong ito. Mga sobrang entitled sa position nila.
@@WENG4898 how do you know po na totoo syang immigration officer po at hindi isang troll lamang? Nagpakita ba sya ng ID? Kaya po maraming naloloko online at text message kasi po masyado kayong nagpapaniwala.
Anong fired dapat multahan at ikulong Ang mga walangyang Yan, abuse of power ginagawa nila
Sorry na lang kasi dito sa Pinas, RECYCLE ang nangyayari. "I-sususpinde MUNA" so babalik din yung IO na yon na parang walang nangyarj
@@Grumpzzz Parang ikaw troll
Girl don’t get them get away with what they did to you. I’m so mad just listening to your story
Go " GIRL" it happened to me in other way...
The only word I said is . There u go u. Hear that ? Final BOARDING BOUNDTO.......
IF I MISSED THAT FLIGHT AND I LOST MY JOB.. I WILL SUE THIS PLACE.". I M A FILIPINO CANADIAN.
Make the immigration officer pay for her ticket.
Not only to pay tanggalin sa work ang mga yan abusado sila
Tanggalin at walang benepisyo dapat. Masyadong perwisyo yang mga IOs eh.
And iblacklist from any frontline service work that deal with time sensitive situations.
Because tourist visa and sinabi nya na business purpose.
@@fordlynx334 true grave pahirap ginagawa ng mga yan pati privacy ng taong aalis kinakalkal nila
Salute and Respect for this Woman! ❤
I experienced the same with all the checking of emails, bank accounts both here in the Philippines and abroad. It was traumatic indeed. It felt like they’re so bitter that you’re traveling. I can still point out who is that man.
go girl time na para ilabas lahat ng kabulastugan ng mga BI minsan i offload pa talaga.
Opo. I was really devastated kasi it was my first time to travel as a tourist not as an OFW. Ung minamaliit ka kasi bbiyahe at ininsulto pa ako. My God talaga.
I salute you, ate for being cool & composed despite the hassle you experienced from the immigration officer.
kabayan, pls follow up immigration as to their concrete steps to reimburse this woman for the unreasonable hassle they caused her. an apology is not enough.
Apology is not enough talaga paano yung magastos ng tao thank u na lang?Palitan lahat ng IO sa NAIA Kkung may visa at return ticket naman payagan na nila umalis dahil bago makakuha ng visa katakot takot na papers na ang naibigay ng traveller
Not enough po di to isolated case dapat dalhin nato sa senado
There is only one reason why an immigration officer and all government employees in general are asking for the impossible and the ridiculous i.e. he is fishing for a bribe. In this particular case, another official seemed to be acting in collusion with Abdullah, selecting possible victims to induce bribery.
totoo to
Merong proof?
@@Grumpzzz kailangan ba ma CCTV ka?
In short waiting for an offer 🤦🏻♂️
@ Marilyn Moreno, I think you are right, why would the Airport's,employees would asked personal questions,it has nothing to do with the passenger flights, they are surely hustling for money.
BI - Bad Imigraration. pahirap sa Mga kababayan That officer should fired for wasting taxpayers, Money.
1:57 Israel is not a tourist destination?
Then he proceeds to later ask if she already went to Israel after she explained that she booked another flight with another carrier using her money. De Castro is a talking head.
She really Proffessional and calmed person.👏👏👏😍😍😍
I missed my flight to a wedding of my brother. Cost me a total of 50.000 pesos and a lot of stress because of immigration. Filing an official complain does not exists. We are being treated as cockroaches.
😢😢😢
:(
Grabe 50,000.😥😥😥😥
You should file a complaint too. P50k is a serious matter.
Masakit isipin pero tama ka. Naranasan ko din ma offload last year. The experience was very traumatizing, that everytime I approach BI, kabado na ako.
It happened to me in 2010, I got offloaded because of long nonsense Immigration interrogation. I have no choice, but to rebook the ticket. Huh! I travelled to UAE, UK, France and Canada, but I never experience such terrible and traumatic interrogation from their Immigration officer. I heard so many stories like this, the government has to do some investigation.
You had not experienced Gestapo like interrogation in foreign airports because their personnel are not corrupt unlike Foolipinos who are extremely corrupt !
Well the govt itself is corrupt!! Don't expect help from them! They're all connected to criminal organizations, the difference is they have badges, uniforms & govt positions!!
6:09 Philippine Immigration apology is nothing without compensation. They should refund your rebooking expense. Not to mention compensation for violation of a human right to movement without harassment and delay.
Me and my daughter had a bad experience with the immigration officer/s…during pandemic, they are not allowing my daughter to enter the Philippines, my daughter presented a certificate to enter the country in lieu of a Philippine passport. According to the immigration officer there is no such thing as a late birth registry, and the the certificate issued by the Phil consulate is not acceptable. Then another officer went to the booth, until there were 3 including the supervisor…the supervisor even said that there is a new guidelines, but cannot explain to me what it is all about, I told the officer that the was issued the day after we left SFO, therefore that doesn’t apply to us. They keep asking for a Philippine passport, i keep telling them that they issue the certificate instead because of the furlough due to pandemic. I even told them that i even have an email from the immigration regarding the requirements for our trip. After 2 hours, they finally stamp the certificate. And 7:12 the lady in the airport told me that they just waiting for me to bribe them!!!! This is so sad!
The IOs at NAIA Terminal 2 also took pictures of my passport, bank details, credit cards, and laman ng bank ko po. I felt humiliated po, sana mabigyan to ng aksyon. Ang kapal pa ng dala kong docs, sana po mabigyan ng leksyon yang mga tao sa immigration!!!
hindi na po tama un. kasi may data privacy act na ang PH. I think that’s beyond their scope na.
You need to lock and replace your credit cards. Yari ka na niyan, mag shopping na yan. ID theft mangyayari sa iyo.
Sayang yung username na monster. 😂😂😂
If that was done to me. Naku! Good luck yan BI. Sa bonga2x ko. Hindi nila pwede tingnan ang credit card at picturan. Dapat pumalag ka
reklamo mo na yan lalo na kung wala permission.
This was intentional in nature for the indirect solicitation for bribe. They should be liable for paying the plane ticket and immediate termination.
If the name/names of this/these BI personnel is not published, if this/these people are not investigated, punished, given a lesson, then, i'll never believe in the sincerity of the BI in ensuring that this will not happen anymore. Pity the poor, ordinary human beings. One way to avoid this is to assign trusted observers in all their dealings.
They protect their own, dahil majority sa mga yan magnanakaw at corrupt! Hindi sila sincere sa apologies or whatever excuses nila. Mauulit lang yan. Mga patay gutom kasi employees ng BI, kaya matakaw sa pera at kapangyarihan!
Worst airport in the world.. My indonesian friend had similar experience last June 2022 when I invited him to visit the philipines. I am a phil-am living in Florida and I went ahead to the philippines and we agreed na susunduin ko sya sa NAIA. Hindi sya pinapasok at he was hold 2 days sa airport dahil lang hindi sya fluent sa english at gumagamit lang ng translator. Ako naman too stressed sa labas ng airport at walang magawa until such time sa third day isinakay pabalik sa Indonesia. So sad ang nangyayari dyan sa bansa natin. I travelled to many international countries like Canada, Europe, middle east at hindi ganyan kabubo ang mga immigration. Dapat ang mga yan palitan na!
Nangyayari sa amin yan ng bunso q nung 3 years old pal ng sya. now she’s 19 years old na . Pabalik na kmi ng Japan nun ng e hold aq ng immigration kc may mga tanong daw. Tinanong aq na kesyo saang parti ng Japan kmi pupunta etc… Talagang cnagot q sya na bkit tinatanong nyo aq ng mga question na ganyan e kumpleto aq sa papers at sa Japan kmi nka base. At talagang pnkta q na bweset na aq, buti nlang dumating ung babae na mas mataas sa knla,at tinanong anong nangyari at bkit nka hold kmi,kung may promlema daw ba sa papers..Nung cnb ng lalaki at babae na nag hold sa akin na wala nman tinatanong lang aq kung saang parti ng Japan pupunta,. Pinagalitan sila nung babae na mas mataas ang posisyon sa knla,na kumpleto nman daw pala aq sa papers bkit aq hinold, kya ayon ura urada aq na ni released .Gusto kc nilang mka kuha pera sa akin kc nkta nila sa papers q na military wife aq at ibang lahi asawa q.😡
It sounds like the immigration officer has a powerful relative,he didn't get suspended,just working out of sight.Its really time for Filipinos to put government workers in a higher standard,since they work for the Filipino tax payers.
They should pay for your ticket! Makarma sana sila!
A grave abuse of power and discretion was obviously committed by the IO. Also, it shows that IO lacks the skills to properly screen travelers who he suspects of a possible victim of human trafficking. Does the BI provide adequate training for IOs?
putso putso ang tawag jan sa mga ganyan hahahhaha, malamang minana lang nila ang mga trabaho na yan.
They’re skilled pero gnyan ang sistema nila kse dyan. Sadya ang mga gingwa nila kse my black market dyan sa loob gsto nila lagi under the table. 😂😂😂 kkhya satin! Hnde mwala ang corruption!
lol out of 33k na na offload, 3% lang nga sila tumama.
@@authority_ryan2102 tumpak
Naalala ko rin po ngyari sakin sa Clark Airport sa immigration same what happened to her, muntik na po ako naiwan ng aking flight sa sobrang haba ng tanong nila sakin, that was last year of July Ilan beses na tinawag ang pangalan pero dami paring tanong sa immigration about sa background ng education ko at saang bansa pa ako galing malaking pasasalamat ko sa Qatar Airlines talagang hinintay ako so I did not lost my flight, 3 silang ng interview sa akin at asking din Ilan ang dala kung pera nakakalungkot lng talaga sana po maayos na to. God bless po sa inyo Jan sa Clark immigration.
Violation of your human rights when your cell was taken from you then read the messages without a search warrant. And I can not believe this is happening a lot in the Philippines. She needs to file a criminal case. Too many syndicate is running your country.
Sa Privacy Act bawal yong pag scroll ng email... What a shame..
Kaya nga e dpat kasuhan nya
Kasuhan lang tapos di naman makukulong.. 😂😂😂
Violation of privacy data act.. bawal po pakialaman ang celphone ng passenger
Nah pina open pa nga at gichecked pa ang history ng online banking ko ng officer.
Who ever caused your troubles they should responsible for your expenses. That's the right things to do for you.
Ang parusa lang sa officer na abusado, ilalagay lang sa back office. Dapat diyan tanggal na sa serbisyo. Sobrang humiliation, gastos ang inabot ng pasahero.
Dapat kulong at least 5 years for harassment and extortion!
Ridiculous
Here's the questions that IO should ask
1. In case of emergency alam mo ba Philippines Embassy na bansang pupuntahan mo?
2. Do you have the address/phone number?
3. Can I see the print copy of the address/phone no#
These questions are basic, but critical questions. Pupusta ako karamihan sa Tourist/OFW walang contact information ng embassy.
This issue must be pursue to discuss in the senate. All questions is irrelevant and the immigration division is accountable to the troubled they made😡😡😡
ALL IMMIGRATION OFFICIALS TOP TO THE LOWEST PERSON NEED "FORMAL TRAINING" AND TESTED. SET STANDARDS ACROSS AND HOLD QUARTERLY ONLINE INSERVICE TRAINING WITH QUESTIONS AND ANSWER THEY NEED TO PASS. SHAMEFUL THAT THE PHILIPPINES IS BEHIND OTHER COUNTRIES IMMIGRATION STANDARDS. TIME FOR HIGHER UP OFFICIALS TO STEP UP AND BE ACCOUNTABLE AND FIX THIS MESS.
Yearbook? What a stupid question!!! Who carries their yearbook with them when they travel? Those idiots at immigration should know what a valid visa stamp looks like. Furthermore, such lengthy “interview” is tantamount to an interrogation and illegal detention which they have no right to do!!! It is imperative that they implement a time limit on these interviews or else reimburse their victim for their ineptitude. They need to update their questionnaire and training manual to properly catch possible human trafficking victims.
First, the screeners and now this?!!! Is there anything that airport can do right? 😤😤😤🤬🤬🤬
Ganyan po ka stupid marami kababayan ntin at kapwa pinoy pa inaagrabrayado,isama pa pagiging buwaya at corrupt na iba.
exactly! this really pist me 😡😡😡😡😡
Paano ako year book ko di ko nakuha it's long time ago na din
Ako nga graduate di ko nakuha yearbook ko
@@DOI_ARTS kawawa tau kahit may experience working abroad di basta makapag travel dahil sa year book
Ano ba ang ngyayari sa BI natin? Sobrang maurirat. Dyan lang sa Pinas meron niyan. Unbelievable!
Sorry to hear
Why cant things just be standard? Tell us what we need to bring. If complete, then let us through
If they’re gonna standardize bringing our yearbooks with us then we’re totally fkcd. Airlines better give additional weight allowance for yearbooks😂😂😂
@@melmel9571 Or they can ask us to bring our diploma. Schools will then have to publish grad pics for verification. Being in the immigration for 2 hours is simply ridiculous. They're also not willing to give their names. When you ask, they would ask why? When you say someone said this to you, they would then say, what's the name of the BI agent that told you to do so?
Meron kasi sa huli na ... "and other relevant documents." Boom! Shoot ang pasahero 😅 Lahat ng maisip ng IO pwede nya ipasok sa phrase na un.
2:01 What’s wrong with traveling alone? Also, Israel is a popular destination for religious people. Besides, her ticket was a round trip ticket.
Senate and Congress shld make an inquiry and investigation on the rampant abuses of Bureau of Immigration for deliberately asking questions that are out of context resulting to off loading of passengers. Such maltreatment must stopped. PBBM should take action to revamp BI personnel from top to bottom.
Ooohhh Yan kasi😊
Omg, sino naman kaya magdadala ng yearbook sa flight.
Supreme Court should act now to stop tte bureau of immigration from abusing the rights of Filipinos for decades to travel . We also encourage the UN and its commission on human rights to investigate all Philippine immigration officials for rights abuses. This will be a more popular move for Filipinos instead of going after Duterte
agree...hehehe...tantanan na si duterte..yang mga abusive na yan ang unahin...
@@okatravel7978 o di ba
@@rodneyd9921 may ruling na yung supreme court dati na nagsabi na hold departure order lang pwede humarang sa Pilipino sa pag alis sa Pilipinas.
@@shamrock214 which makes the injustices of so many Filipinos being offloaded at the discretion of immigration officials tantamount to a wholesale violation of human rights. A class suit should be filed by thousands against Philippine immigration officials
sue them....
Walang pag asa yung sue dito. Mauubos lang ang pera at malay natin protektado "sila"
This is not the only offloading case due to BIs over questioning and irrelevant documents asked. If you google and check youtubes, a lot of filipinos voiced out their offloading experienced. Philippines is becoming like North Korea. As long as a passenger has valid passport, plane ticket and no hold departure order the passenger should be able to leave country without questions. Only court can decide if one can travel or not. BI dont have power to stop someone from travelling if theres no hold departure order. Even on their website, nothing that says they have authority to stop someone from travelling if theres no hold departure order. They cant stop you just because of speculation. I hope BI is aware that if a passenger will carry so much documents irrelevant to the travel, the host or receiving country might not let them enter. Its already difficult to get a visa or to afford to travel and being oflfoaded without refund or reimbursement is very frustrating. Some people like to travel solo or meeting someone in other countries. Its none of BI’s business.
A lot of stupid filipino immigration agent there in Manila.
Trueee
They can’t even tell what a valid visa looks like!!! 🤬🤬🤬
Baka kasi ngpapalagay si Abdula
Actually nagugutom lang sila, kase kami dati nung katrabaho ko naOffload din dahil hindi kami nagbigay ng 14K. Pero nabook din kami ng company the following week
Ang daming violations ng IO..pati cp ng traveller pinkalieman nya..pati ung about her parents tinanong p kng hiwalay..ano b yan?
Sa Back Office lang...... What a SHAME!
While those corrupt IO's are kept in their positions, NAIA will always be branded as one of the worst if not the worst airport in the world. What a shame. We will lose tourism thru the kind of discouragement and embarrassment such as this. Total revamp should be conducted within the BOI in the airport.
I have the same experience po during 2021 the immigration officer asked me to open my family group chat and even asked me to open my bank account. Which i feel violated, but couldnt do anything that time buti nlng pinayagan ako maka travel and im 5min closer bago lumipad ang plane.
OMG! How infuriating! They have NO RIGHT at all to do that!!
This insane, incredible immigration officers. Nakakahiya ang tatanga san ba kinuha mga yan. Mali lahat ng ginawa.
sa kalye
Kabayan Noli, please investigate ASAP Tickets because so many Filipinos from US were not refunded by this travel agency during lockdown. They are so shrewd, dishonest and corrupt. Let them pay for what they did to the Filipinos in the US.
The BI and custom in any country(Even in the US) can check all your belongings even your wallet and phone/emails, etc. This is nothing new.
custom can do that but NOT immigration, not in the US.
Same here, my emails and group chats were checked.
ang nakakasama ng loob dito hindi naman talaga naparusahan yung BI officer nilipat lang dapat maparusahan yung BI officer dapat din yung bi officer na nagkasala humingi ng sorry personal at bayaran nya yung nagastoa para sa rebook ng ticket ang nangyare parang tinatago sya ng BI parang malakas ang kapit sa loob ng departamento
Hindi sapat Ang parusang warning , reprimand, suspension, and retraining , tangal sa position dapat extermination of all corrupt BI personnel including their families . Ganitong corrupt attitude Ng sa lahat na Gagovernment offices ay rampant . Even a very lowly position stencil boys sa LTO Pasig acts a very authoritative voice , sa police station pag kumuha ka Ng police report Ang ibang police uses threat and intimidation para maglagay ka , Ang mga traffic enforcers sa Manila ganun din uses threat and intimidation para maglagay ka pag hindi ka maglagay lagyan nila Ng arrogant Ang ticket mo para may another penalty na 500 ganyan ka walang hiya Ang mga ibang Foolipino . Kaya if given satanic power I'll exterminate forty percent of Philippines population para mahinto na Ang mga corruption sa bansa natin !
My husband's phone was also checked in NAIA immigration desk when he was about to fly to Indonesia. A lot of questions! But thank God he was allowed to fly to Jakarta.
Matagal ng ganyan ang Immigration. Pati chat with the relative living abroad gusto nila basahin. Even with those with their Sponsor still ino-Offload nila! Then may mga pinapapasok sila at iniEscort pa nga ng Immigration Officer. Mga nagbayad mga yun pra makapasok. Yan ang totoong dahilan kung bakit maraming na oOffload.
That BI officer should be sacked and penalized accordingly.
Nakakatakot naman yung ang IO mismo humawak ng phone niya at tinignan laman ng email niya?! Dami nga sa atin ni ayaw ipahawak sa kapamilya natin phone natin tapos yung officer ganun2 lang?!
Ganun sila pakialemera/o
baka trip si maam nung officer kaya ganun ginawa.. TSK!
Power trip at its best! Kaya hindi umuunlad ang pinas dahil s mga ganyang tao.
I love the way you presented this dra ... I have been a patient of the pain rehab for almost 2decadea already
Omg ano klase questions yan. My goodness! Grabe na complaints sa immigration ha.
Kailangan maging matapang din tayo sa mga immigration officers lalo na kng alam nman ntin n hindi na dapat pinagtatanong stin!
I had the same experience, way back in 2017, When i was interrogated by 2 BI officers at the back office where they even checked my phone including my emails, skype, messenger and txt messages. It took me about 15 minutes to answer all their questions. I was able to get in when the officer said to the other officer that he didn't see any trace. Perhaps any trace of illegal employment or whatsoever. Who knows what trace it is. My brother and I are bound to Singapore for a three day tour.
Been to SG many times Naman pero never experienced what you experienced. We were just asked about our hotel accommodation, our itinerary for our whole stay (I printed all the booked tickets of the places we plan to go to like USS etc), return ticket and the usual. The only personal question that the IO asked of me was like what is my job?.
Worse experience too with the BI as a foreigner they almost made me miss my very expensive flight due to ACR Card pending
Marami pa pong gnayang istoray sir Kabayan...kahit yung sa kanaya late na, sana sir, tulungan nyong maglahad pa yung marami nating mag kababayan na nakaranas ng di patas na mga interview at requirements sa Immigration Officers, salamat po.
Bureau of Immigration should be responsible for purchasing her ticket . This is totally unacceptable. Perhaps , the officer was waiting for a bribe.
The Bureau of Immigration has so many corrupt personnel and this is common knowledge. Remember the Pastillas scandal. And this in only what was discovered and revealed. How about those that were never found out. The reason why so many illegal Chinese in the Philippines where they just remain in the country incognito running illegal businesses and other criminal activities.
ABS CBN, Please continue to bring up issues on BI and NAIA incompetence, unprofessionalism, ignorance, power-tripping, greed, disrepute, and the like, so that it gets the needed attention from lawmakers. They have the worse reputation of all government agencies.
corruption at the airport...what the " F"
Dapat tlagang seryoso nilang icheck yung mga taong nagtatrabaho sa airport…maraming mayabang..pati hindi dapat itanong,tinatanong..
Power-tripping.
Not all are travelling there (Israel) as tourist will plan to work. If there are already valid reasons for returning, why hold and be questioned irrelevantly? If you are that person being questioned, you might feel that it's not confirmation but interrogation.
They should provide a written cause of hold from flight so that may proof. And then if the BI staff abused his/her position then they should JAIL first then fired. ABUSADO KAU> from head to lowest staff. NAKAKAHIYA KAU MGA PI KAU sa BI
There is no such thing as a safe Rights for Filipinos in our country when our personal lives are being questioned and interfered, Discrimination is what we experience daily and the Rich and the Poor thing which is sad but true
Pakiramdam ng BI officers ay dios sila.
next sila kat lord whahaha
Please they need to do something about this kasi nakakatakot na mag travel lalo na sa mga nag ipon talaga para mag enjoy sana tapos ganito gagawin nila…
InAustralian when your going out of the country they don’t ask you were you are going. They have no right to know your destination. Too much B…S.
Sasagutin ng immigration ang refund dapat. At bakit hindi sinibak? Parang ,something fishy. Naranasan ko rin medyo naharass as airport way back 1983. Galing ng Saudi.
Tama ka kabayan.
Bawal ying kinuha nya yun cellphone at scroll nya yun emails nya.
Violation of DPA.
Same thing happened to my daughter..she missed her flight because of long interviews of BI..
This girl should get a reimbursement from the BI. This case is so unjust.
Wala bang line of questioning ang mga IO? Or gawa gawa Lang yan ng kung Ano ang gustong maisip na itanong? Like yong sa yearbook and diploma?
Whoever that person should get fired. Does not know what he was doing. Does not know what kind of question to ask. Year book? Stuoid
I don't understand the Big News with her experience. This is Not New!! But good for her to bring it forward MAYBE things will change.
In 2019 I missed a flight from Manila to Singapore after hours being interviewed with my friend. We were going for a 3-day weekend trip but missed the flight even though checked in at the airport 3 hours before departure and even hearing our flight being called they said too bad come earlier next time.
I said we checked in as soon as we were allowed and we missed the flight and left the airport.
Lost money because of missed flight:, Grab to airport, Grab back home, air ticket for 2 people and 1 night hotel (allowed to cancel the last 2 nights without penalty).
I felt the Immigration Officer wanted cash to let us go to our flight but I refused to do that and as I said we were held with endless questions until our flight departed and we were still in immigration.
Good for this lady for raising the issue hope they improve their outdated departure system/rules. They need to travel and see how professional it is in other countries and learn a better system.
Checklist for next trip:
1. Passport
2. Cash
3. Credit Card
4. Vaccination Record
5. YEAR BOOK 😂
This is very obvious na may mga inside job yan sila jan. Akala nila, after nila kayong ma off-load,magre-rebook kau for another trip. At sa rebooking niyo na un magkakaroon sila ng commision from the airlines since they couldn't ask for lagay galing sainyo kc nga naman mahahalata?🤔
@@niccapasobillo2923 Wow I never thought of this reason Salamat after missing our flight and losing all that money (Grab fare 2x, our air tickets X 2, and one night hotel cost lost) I couldn't afford to rebook for awhile then never did again and have never been to Singapore - so too bad for airline and too bad for Singapore they got money out of me one time but not a second.
@@CanadianInPhilippinesex XD❤❤
Sadly, they're still doing it even after her viral video. The only difference is they would let you go for as long as they see that you have a stable job and you can afford it. It was my flight last Friday and I'm traveling alone too. I thought I would NOT make it after seeing the same stupid process they did to her like asking me about when I graduated, my job, the money I have, my manager, the kind of company I work for, etc then in the end they asked me to talk to the immigration head officer... 😮😮
Akala ko ma-ooffload ako. But luckily I made it. ❤ Tingin ko medyo niluwagan na nila kase napahiya na sila because of this brave girl. Pero pramis!!! Ganun parin mga tanong nila. Walang nagbago. Parehong-pareho parin kay Ate Girl. The only difference is mas malaki na yung chance mong hindi ma-offload if you have a stable job, have your legal documents ready, and if you show that you're financially capable.
i am really happy na pinapaulit ulit naten itong issue na to para mabuksan ang mga mata ng buong pilipinas sa kawalang hiyaan ng immigration officers naten (hndi lahat , pero meron talaga sadyang ganun)..
Dapat sa senado ito investigahan malaking issue ito
Ok.. di muna ako uwi. Nakakatakot maka expierience ng ganito.
Sana mabigyan ng pansin ang ganitong problema..
The Govt should do something sa Bureau of Immigration👍It happened to me & My Daughter before.. There's a lot of Questions like the B.Cert.of my Daughter..Our UK VISA..The Invitation of my Sister Who is a Nurse in London...& It took us almost 30 mins👍Glad that We didn't Missed our Flight..
I remember the time when my daughter was coming here to the US, the immigration interviewer was giving her a hard time inspite that all papers and documents are legal and in order. All she felt was that the immigration man wanted to extort money to let her go
But she was from the University of the Philippines and with a
strong sense of nationalism she would never give in to that. Finally, he let her go. Now they're doing the same tactics but the only difference is that it is worse today.
Ganyan din ginawa sa akin ng BI officer dati, pati cellphone ko binasa ang message...
Grabe wala ng privacy
illegal search
Mas mahigpit pa sila sa BI ng US & aside from that very irrelevant ang mga question about the passenger’s itinerary malinaw na abuse of authority. That BI has to meet the consequences of his actions. But I have a question, why do you have to pay to rebook a ticket? Kc it happened to me several times last 2021 from Canada to US, Canada to France and one time Canada to Philippines all I did is rebook without paying anything. The delay is not my fault it’s because of the very long lineup but the questions are brief. We know they are just following orders from their superiors but they have no knowledge to comply. Those BI should be replaced & should be reprimanded.
I had this kind of bad experienced way back 2019 on my first vacation in NAIA T1, hoping maturuan ng leksyon ang mga staff na gumagawa ng mali sa profession nila.