For us, Pantheon is pretty much a must have expansion. Both because it allows to break the flow of having to pick up a card from the pyramid, and because placing the gods and using their powers adds a lot of depth. It's an awesome game either way.
Appreciating the effort you put into those 12x12 Reviews. Of course some games you would have played in all variants anyways, but I guess in reality this is a lot of additional effort to be able to come up with such a complete review with all perspectives. Just wanted to highlight that!
These 12x12 reviews are absolutely great as many other reviews are not as in depth and reflect just a couple of plays. This series is super nice to assess the longevity of a game
I think Agora handled the extra win condition really well. They understood that adding another way to end the game early would further disincentivize the points game ao they tied the politician's strength to the number of blue cards you have. This was brilliant because it makes sense thematically (the more civilian infrastructure you have, the more popular/powerful the politicians) and it made blue cards really important in a way that isn't just about their VP or linking symbols. In the base game, blue cards are actually really undervalued as gathering resources and building an engine is far more important in Age 1 than getting blue cards which may or may not be counted in the end. Age 3 blue cards were always pretty important because if you're already in Age 3 you are more likely to end on points but those age 1 blues are more useful as coins than in my city. But in Agora, I find actually wanting to get those blue cards in order to maximize value from the politicians, something that would never happen in vase game. To me Agora is also a mandatory expansion just like Pantheon once you've played a handful of games because of just how much intrigue and opportunities it gives players. You can be way more clever with Agora and I actually prefer it over Pantheon. But Pantheon actually addressed some issues with base game like the crazy-swingy Guild cards and the inability to affect the rhythm of the draft which sometimes led to predictable outcames that the players could do nothing to change. Agreed that Pantheon is mandatory ASAP but Agora is mandatory if you really want to sink your teeth into it.
I love those in-depth reviews done after many many plays and with everything there is for those games! It is really nice to have a global opinion on the game itself and its expansion. Keep making more of those videos! They are very helpful.
Sometimes I wonder if I need new board game friends. Played this with my friend, and we enjoyed it so much we played it 10 times in the one day. The Next week I asked him to play again and he didn't even know what game I was talking about.....
7WD is 10/10 for me. I love the victory conditions (instant victories vs accruing points), the zero sum economy (I may be best served to block you from a move rather than help myself), and the choice about when to buy gods cards or build a go agaib wonder in order to scoop on a burried card. Bruno Cathala is a genius. This is one of those near perfect games which i recommend to everyone!
Alex, I couldn't agree more with your consensus. One more rhing I would add is game length. Agora adds quite a lot more time to a quite short game as Pantheon is o ly adding a minute or 5-10 in my experience. Agora would be more close to 20 min. It also brings a lot more complexity, so I would never use it with first time players. Pantheon gives that much needed flexibility to skip a draw step which is a true gamechanger. I would never play without Pantheon if possible.
Really a great game that is even better when you are playing against someone who knows how to play. I have been surprised how much I enjoyed playing with both expansions.
I play this a lot on Board Game Arena with both expansions. Some people have this mathematically figured out and there’s also the rare age one political victory which is nearly impossible to stop if the cards play out right and you have the right wonders.
There is a solo variant that was put out as well. I think it's worth trying. It's easy to manage, and there is an app to make it even more streamlined. I still feel like I haven't "played it out" after about 150 games. One of the easier games to play on BGA as well, so that's helpful toward exploring the variations.
Algorithm and topic related comment 😜🐦 For me it felt a bit too random, because you could have several bad available cards in a row and lag behind. The expansions does mediate this a bit. I do like the game though, but will choose something different if I got the choice.
"7 Wonders Duel" basegame is really good on its own. I always found the expansions too expensive for what they are, especially the Pantheon expansion. Now that the Agora expansion is here, I'd like to try the 'complete' game but for the time being the high prices of the expansions will prevent that.
the player that has more replay wonders can easily force science especially in pantheon with green gods and most of the time is unstoppable
For us, Pantheon is pretty much a must have expansion. Both because it allows to break the flow of having to pick up a card from the pyramid, and because placing the gods and using their powers adds a lot of depth. It's an awesome game either way.
Appreciating the effort you put into those 12x12 Reviews. Of course some games you would have played in all variants anyways, but I guess in reality this is a lot of additional effort to be able to come up with such a complete review with all perspectives. Just wanted to highlight that!
These 12x12 reviews are absolutely great as many other reviews are not as in depth and reflect just a couple of plays. This series is super nice to assess the longevity of a game
Thanks for this Alex
I think Agora handled the extra win condition really well. They understood that adding another way to end the game early would further disincentivize the points game ao they tied the politician's strength to the number of blue cards you have. This was brilliant because it makes sense thematically (the more civilian infrastructure you have, the more popular/powerful the politicians) and it made blue cards really important in a way that isn't just about their VP or linking symbols. In the base game, blue cards are actually really undervalued as gathering resources and building an engine is far more important in Age 1 than getting blue cards which may or may not be counted in the end. Age 3 blue cards were always pretty important because if you're already in Age 3 you are more likely to end on points but those age 1 blues are more useful as coins than in my city. But in Agora, I find actually wanting to get those blue cards in order to maximize value from the politicians, something that would never happen in vase game.
To me Agora is also a mandatory expansion just like Pantheon once you've played a handful of games because of just how much intrigue and opportunities it gives players. You can be way more clever with Agora and I actually prefer it over Pantheon. But Pantheon actually addressed some issues with base game like the crazy-swingy Guild cards and the inability to affect the rhythm of the draft which sometimes led to predictable outcames that the players could do nothing to change. Agreed that Pantheon is mandatory ASAP but Agora is mandatory if you really want to sink your teeth into it.
Very well said (I love your channel by the way)!
@martino1571 thanks!
Excellent review, very informative! Time for me to get the expansions!!
I love those in-depth reviews done after many many plays and with everything there is for those games! It is really nice to have a global opinion on the game itself and its expansion. Keep making more of those videos! They are very helpful.
Sometimes I wonder if I need new board game friends. Played this with my friend, and we enjoyed it so much we played it 10 times in the one day. The Next week I asked him to play again and he didn't even know what game I was talking about.....
Thanks for in-depth review, 12 plays + expansions + digital. Wish other channels make the same effort eh! 🎉
Enjoying the deep dive reviews into games. Keep up the great work
7WD is 10/10 for me. I love the victory conditions (instant victories vs accruing points), the zero sum economy (I may be best served to block you from a move rather than help myself), and the choice about when to buy gods cards or build a go agaib wonder in order to scoop on a burried card. Bruno Cathala is a genius. This is one of those near perfect games which i recommend to everyone!
It's sooo good :) It so rarely ends in points for us...but the points matter a lot :)
Really informed review, nice one!
How often do you play with both expansions?
At this point most of the time
Do you think we will have a third expansion? I really hope so
I almost feel it would have been here by now
Off topic of the game but have to say... That is a hilariously awesome shirt! 🤣
Cool - Pantheon is a no brained every time but when we tried Agora we felt the Conspiracy cards were too uneven. Did you feel this way?
Alex, I couldn't agree more with your consensus. One more rhing I would add is game length. Agora adds quite a lot more time to a quite short game as Pantheon is o ly adding a minute or 5-10 in my experience. Agora would be more close to 20 min. It also brings a lot more complexity, so I would never use it with first time players. Pantheon gives that much needed flexibility to skip a draw step which is a true gamechanger. I would never play without Pantheon if possible.
Ty for this video!!
Really a great game that is even better when you are playing against someone who knows how to play. I have been surprised how much I enjoyed playing with both expansions.
I play this a lot on Board Game Arena with both expansions. Some people have this mathematically figured out and there’s also the rare age one political victory which is nearly impossible to stop if the cards play out right and you have the right wonders.
Agora is by far the better expansion but it does make it cutthroat as you said
Yes it does!
There is a solo variant that was put out as well. I think it's worth trying. It's easy to manage, and there is an app to make it even more streamlined.
I still feel like I haven't "played it out" after about 150 games. One of the easier games to play on BGA as well, so that's helpful toward exploring the variations.
Algorithm and topic related comment 😜🐦
For me it felt a bit too random, because you could have several bad available cards in a row and lag behind. The expansions does mediate this a bit.
I do like the game though, but will choose something different if I got the choice.
"7 Wonders Duel" basegame is really good on its own. I always found the expansions too expensive for what they are, especially the Pantheon expansion. Now that the Agora expansion is here, I'd like to try the 'complete' game but for the time being the high prices of the expansions will prevent that.