39:18 I disagree with that point...breaking the Fourth Wall technique was used in Hindi cinema many times...Jaane Bhi Do Yaaron's last Shot, scenes in Kal Ho Na Ho, Kabhi Haan Kabhi Naa etc. and most of the films starring Kader Khan...kader Khan sort of pioneered this technique in mainstream Hindi cinema.
Thank you so much HoC for such quality content. This interview is truly inspiring for all aspiring filmmakers and film lovers in general. Keep spreading your love for cinema!
Phebe Walter bridge is obviously great. But try the movie "Interview" by Legendary director Mrinal Sen there is a great moment when the protagonist starts talking with the audience in a bus
Vishal sir is so so so good. I think my first interview of him I have seen and completely blow away with the way he talks. Thanks so much HoC. Please do more amazing stuff like this
Who said we did not break the fourth wall in hindi cinema? Addressing audience was there in mainstream films like Qurbaani Kal ho na ho, Student of the year, Sanju and so on and my favourite is when Legend Kader Khan does it in almost of his films.
Breaking the fourth wall can have two ways to think about it: 1. Talking to the audience - this is usually a one time execution (more looking out the window than breaking the fourth wall) 2. Including the audience as a character in the show - this is usually when done repeatedly and for more meaningful things to be said. Here the references to shows like Fleabag are to invoke the latter. Kal Ho Naa Ho, phenomenal as it may be, might do the 1st, certainly doesn't do the latter.
till 2 years ago I didn't know kieslowski has influence on Vardwaj , when I watched haider,it remainded me of White. And I searched about vardwaj and found he is hugely influenced by kieslowski. And yes Blind Chance is absolute masterpiece, only sad thing is he made it a little political . But that's okay.
I’d love to know what Vishal Bhardwaj thinks of Abbas Kiarostami’s films. I bet he loves or would love them as much as I do. 🥰 He seems to admire the same filmmakers that I do. Krzysztof Kieslowski is a major favorite of mine. 💟
@@HumansofCinema That is very kind, thank you so much my friend. I love these longer conversations with artists that I admire, so I loved watching this! Much love from the Netherlands. 😊
I appreciate that his work is unique in comparison to other hindi movies but the unfortunate thing is that his movoes are usually a hit or a miss, either its very good or very bad.
I like his films specially Omkara, Kaminey and Maqbool but Not At all "Haider" it's completely trash and Anti-Army film. Filmaker Ache hain Craft acha hai But Soch Ghatiya hai
Army afspa k naam par rape kare toh theek hai.. masoom logo ko maare unka ghar bomb se uda de theek hai.. film mai dikha diya toh galat ho gaya.. The Indian army is the most corrupt organisation. Police se bhi jyada corrupt hai. Bus deshbhakti k nama par kuch dikhaaya nahi jaata..
Lol Most thought the kashmir movies were those shown by Vishal until Kashmir Files exposed all of that brutally. Thats the best story on kashmir till now.
wow- so sorry to feel that you have beleived what a party wanted to project and what a careless 3rd grade x rated film maker made for his masters a literal HMV ( his masters voice). come on grow up. you are truly a velai illaada vetti paiyan.moolai illaada manithan. sorry to say but i didn't find any other apt word or phrase to compliment you.
There are ALWAYS more than one side to the truth (truth has as many faces as humans involved ) , Haider showed ONE SIDE and KF showed ONE side. Both are equally valid and true.
@@gayatrisrinivas6342 Karma. You get what you give. What they gave to Kashmiri hindus for ages, they are getting back. Kashmiri Hindus never started terror campls. Thats the difference. First you see the real truth.
@@thiruvetti I am NOT denying that Kashmiri Hindus suffered. Read my comment again. You are justifying the terrorism and counter-terrorism. Both cases ARE CAUSED by politicians. And common man suffers and then reacts, irrespective of their religion. Common man have been used and still being used as puppets in ALL conflicts, in ALL conflicted countries, and in ALL major religions. That is the ONLY ultimate truth, the rest of them ( as shown in Haider and KF) are truths that are personal to the people involved.
This guy who made the movie Haider is a total fraud. He made a movie on Kashmir which is totally false and far away from reality. INDIA should ban and boycot this fraud and an enemy of India.
Never miss interviews of Vishal bharadwaj, Anurag kashyap , vetrimaran, Mani ratnam( though man of few words and very few )
Vishal is one of the most important voices in world cinema. He’s immensely creative and brave filmmaker.
Always something to learn from Vishal Bhardwaj's interviews.. Small correction, Kieślowski died at 54.
The most honest genuine unique Director Music composer Story writer Producer
39:18 I disagree with that point...breaking the Fourth Wall technique was used in Hindi cinema many times...Jaane Bhi Do Yaaron's last Shot, scenes in Kal Ho Na Ho, Kabhi Haan Kabhi Naa etc. and most of the films starring Kader Khan...kader Khan sort of pioneered this technique in mainstream Hindi cinema.
Salaam hai .....kamaal hai ....yeh Aadmi ♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️respect....respect.....respect for Vishal Bhardwaj ♥️♥️
Vishal sir is great craftsman. I am always up to listen him. So much knowledge about life and cinema
Ver few interviewers who ask interesting qs, make the speaker speak his mind…
Great work bro!
Thank you so much HoC for such quality content. This interview is truly inspiring for all aspiring filmmakers and film lovers in general. Keep spreading your love for cinema!
Thank you so much! ❤❤
Phebe Walter bridge is obviously great. But try the movie "Interview" by Legendary director Mrinal Sen there is a great moment when the protagonist starts talking with the audience in a bus
Vishal sir is so so so good. I think my first interview of him I have seen and completely blow away with the way he talks.
Thanks so much HoC. Please do more amazing stuff like this
4th wall has been broken by Paresh Rawal in Mr and Mrs Khiladi and also by Kader Khan in a few movies. I'm sure there are other instances also.
Haider my fav movie from Vishal sir.
He is such a legend!!
So nice to see him on the channel! 👏🏽
❤❤❤
Bahut badiya kaam. Kudos to the Guest and Host both.
Legend. Thanks for interviewing him.
Who said we did not break the fourth wall in hindi cinema? Addressing audience was there in mainstream films like Qurbaani Kal ho na ho, Student of the year, Sanju and so on and my favourite is when Legend Kader Khan does it in almost of his films.
He said usually they don't do that!! Its not he is doing something like this for the first time..
@@drprathamprakash1408 He said “humne hindi cinema mai fourth wall break hi nahi kiya aaj tak” 39:20
Breaking the fourth wall can have two ways to think about it:
1. Talking to the audience - this is usually a one time execution (more looking out the window than breaking the fourth wall)
2. Including the audience as a character in the show - this is usually when done repeatedly and for more meaningful things to be said.
Here the references to shows like Fleabag are to invoke the latter. Kal Ho Naa Ho, phenomenal as it may be, might do the 1st, certainly doesn't do the latter.
Brilliant interview. So inspiring !
Haider is just up and above 🔥❤
VB OP
Such an iconic interview
why have you used Abode audio enhancer?? it is not sounding good, it was good with bg noise
I love Vishal Bharadwaj's movies. But Kadar Khan and Asrani did break 4th walls in a lot of their movies.
I LOVEEE BLIND CHANCE
4th wall
How about
"Pyar ke side effects"
Thank you❤it was pleasure listening to Vishal sir
till 2 years ago I didn't know kieslowski has influence on Vardwaj , when I watched haider,it remainded me of White. And I searched about vardwaj and found he is hugely influenced by kieslowski. And yes Blind Chance is absolute masterpiece, only sad thing is he made it a little political . But that's okay.
I’d love to know what Vishal Bhardwaj thinks of Abbas Kiarostami’s films. I bet he loves or would love them as much as I do. 🥰 He seems to admire the same filmmakers that I do. Krzysztof Kieslowski is a major favorite of mine. 💟
Same ❤ will ask him about Kiarostami whenever I see him next 🥺
@@HumansofCinema That is very kind, thank you so much my friend. I love these longer conversations with artists that I admire, so I loved watching this! Much love from the Netherlands. 😊
I think the coolest thing I've found is you're approaching this interview like a learner.
I’m really glad you caught that. It’s something that’s very important to the way I conduct this podcast :)
Let's go HOC
🎉🎉🎉
wonderful interview.....nice conversation...nice anchoring.
Thank you 💝
Every Indian Director is limited only 4 good movies in their lifetime, you made 3, 4th is yet to come.
when is the part where he talks about fleabag?
Puri video dekhiye naa..
@@sushmitachakraborty5477 zindagi me patience ki badi shortage hai
21:44 what happened to the sound here ?
Ek Vishal B - SRK movie toh ham bhi deserve karte hai? 🥺
Pls find that movie for me in which a boy drowned in Frozen lake.
44:44 44:20
Beautiful mere bhai keep it going🙌🙌
NO SUbS? I thought this id Humans of Cinema not Humans of Bombay and Delhi :(
❤❤❤
Harshit………yes sir…..ji sir bolte hai…….correct and right bolna..??
Charlie Chopra as a movie is ok ... may be just above average. Nothing more.
v good interview
I appreciate that his work is unique in comparison to other hindi movies but the unfortunate thing is that his movoes are usually a hit or a miss, either its very good or very bad.
Vivek Agnihotri > Vishal Bharadwaj!
The Kashmir Files > Haider!
I am sorry to say but but bridge ruined indiana jones and james bond for us😢
Me to the host - say 'Matlab' again... I dare you... I double dare you... Say 'matlab' again
Edit 💯
Mehdi hasan saheb ke naam ke pehle ustad lagta hai Ji.
Bhai film bna rhe ho toh btao saath btane hai yrr...host bhai tumse kehra hu..
😅 hutiya host
❤❤❤❤❤❤
I like his films specially Omkara, Kaminey and Maqbool but Not At all "Haider" it's completely trash and Anti-Army film. Filmaker Ache hain Craft acha hai But Soch Ghatiya hai
Army afspa k naam par rape kare toh theek hai.. masoom logo ko maare unka ghar bomb se uda de theek hai.. film mai dikha diya toh galat ho gaya.. The Indian army is the most corrupt organisation. Police se bhi jyada corrupt hai. Bus deshbhakti k nama par kuch dikhaaya nahi jaata..
Add subs! Would reach more
Don't drink more tea/coffee than the guest. looks awkward 😂
Lol Most thought the kashmir movies were those shown by Vishal until Kashmir Files exposed all of that brutally. Thats the best story on kashmir till now.
wow- so sorry to feel that you have beleived what a party wanted to project and what a careless 3rd grade x rated film maker made for his masters a literal HMV ( his masters voice). come on grow up. you are truly a velai illaada vetti paiyan.moolai illaada manithan. sorry to say but i didn't find any other apt word or phrase to compliment you.
There are ALWAYS more than one side to the truth (truth has as many faces as humans involved ) , Haider showed ONE SIDE and KF showed ONE side. Both are equally valid and true.
@@gayatrisrinivas6342 Karma. You get what you give. What they gave to Kashmiri hindus for ages, they are getting back. Kashmiri Hindus never started terror campls. Thats the difference. First you see the real truth.
@@thiruvetti I am NOT denying that Kashmiri Hindus suffered. Read my comment again. You are justifying the terrorism and counter-terrorism. Both cases ARE CAUSED by politicians. And common man suffers and then reacts, irrespective of their religion. Common man have been used and still being used as puppets in ALL conflicts, in ALL conflicted countries, and in ALL major religions. That is the ONLY ultimate truth, the rest of them ( as shown in Haider and KF) are truths that are personal to the people involved.
Too many 'matlab's
This guy who made the movie Haider is a total fraud. He made a movie on Kashmir which is totally false and far away from reality. INDIA should ban and boycot this fraud and an enemy of India.
Two upper caste men talking about cinema and trying to sound intellectual 😅😅😅😅😅😅
Am I missing out on something big if I don’t know kieslowoski 😢
Yes.