Hereford or Rubia Gallega? Which steak tastes better?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 7 янв 2025

Комментарии • 171

  • @feartheduck6664
    @feartheduck6664 5 лет назад +16

    You should cook the rubia properly...

  • @MrFabianPeq
    @MrFabianPeq 6 лет назад +14

    The spanish one looks a lot more rare, maybe if the cuts were cooked to the same internal temp the decision would’ve been different

    • @frooskys22
      @frooskys22 2 года назад +3

      The spanish one has a lot of marble, is definitely better

    • @jothamolivero
      @jothamolivero 2 года назад +1

      Ye cooked the rubia wrong need to keep seeing it with salt as you go along with it’s fat

    • @flispifml7277
      @flispifml7277 2 года назад

      M8 not every meat is made the same way, CNT compare this beefs and and not at the y way you compare it, respect for your opinion but if some one sees this video as first for Rubia galega, you kill the options of Rubia gallega.

    • @MrFabianPeq
      @MrFabianPeq 2 года назад +2

      @@flispifml7277 how do you compare it correctly?

  • @augoldfinger
    @augoldfinger 6 лет назад +21

    I raise my own beef every year. If I have a choice, it always a Hereford. Mine are on pasture and grain fed until the last 3-4 months. Then they are heavily grain fed, by an all grain (no pellet), and high quality hay

    • @PITMASTERX
      @PITMASTERX  6 лет назад +3

      One day I will that as well... I love it

    • @JohnsCoC
      @JohnsCoC 5 лет назад

      you are wrong but its ok

  • @SmokedReb
    @SmokedReb 6 лет назад +1

    Your production quality is top notch, those steaks looked amazing!

  • @dennisvondenhoff4327
    @dennisvondenhoff4327 6 лет назад +2

    Wow! Amazing Roel! That must have been a taste explosion all together.
    Maybe the cuts were a little different and it migh explain the difference. The difference in texture is definitely due to the difference in rare vs medium rare.
    Awesome video and great idea those mushrooms!

  • @maorrotman3323
    @maorrotman3323 6 лет назад +14

    I didnt understand if you wanted to compare between cow strains or beef cuts because those are diffrent cuts of beef.

    • @PITMASTERX
      @PITMASTERX  6 лет назад

      Cow strains

    • @maorrotman3323
      @maorrotman3323 6 лет назад +16

      I think it would be better to use same cuts for more acurate compare other than that i realy liked the video

  • @kristy77a
    @kristy77a 4 года назад +1

    From where did you source your cuts of both steaks, Hereford and Rubia Gallega? Thanks.

  • @DenDenForever
    @DenDenForever 6 лет назад +2

    I appreciate your Hard Work. We get a video just about every few dayys. Thanks for the EYE Candy.

    • @PITMASTERX
      @PITMASTERX  6 лет назад

      I am glad you appreciate it👍 We try to make as much as possible. We also do 2 live streams

  • @lichithepelexa
    @lichithepelexa 3 года назад +1

    Only for the marbling I can tell rubia is better but you cook them different and is different thickness

  • @chads7796
    @chads7796 6 лет назад +2

    Awesome video Roel. Like you, I was surprised that you found the Rubia Gallega was not as good as the Hereford. The Rubia looked like it had the nicer Marbling. But, sometime you never know until you eat it.
    I did a tri-tip and flank steak comparison the other day (since I had a piece of each). While the flavor was excellent on both, we found the flank to be more tender, quicker to cook, easier to source, and a bit cheaper ($8 vs $10 per pound). Different cows, from different stores (Trader Joes vs. Costco), and of course a different cut.

    • @barbaraguy3491
      @barbaraguy3491 6 лет назад

      I think the comparison would have been more valid if the meats shared the same cook level (temperature). I go for medium-rare, but one was rare and one was medium. Definitely will affect the taste. Another quality video, nonetheless.

  • @raidazz1
    @raidazz1 6 лет назад +1

    What a great vid.. Had me salivating through from beginning to end

    • @PITMASTERX
      @PITMASTERX  6 лет назад +1

      Mission accomplished 😁

  • @rafapazos06
    @rafapazos06 4 года назад +2

    2 different cuts for a comparison? You should’ve used the same mate.

  • @peetsnort
    @peetsnort 6 лет назад +1

    I am lucky to live in the UK Hereford and I have a good butcher that ages the beef for 6 weeks. I have yet to afford the tomahawk. I usually have the rump for 14 pounds per kilo. The fancy cuts will be 35.
    I have bought my tickets for the lottery in anticipation
    Good video

    • @PITMASTERX
      @PITMASTERX  6 лет назад +1

      Awesome ...I hope you win the lottery 👈🤩👉

    • @peetsnort
      @peetsnort 6 лет назад

      @@PITMASTERX
      Well would you believe. I won 140 pounds last night on the thunderball. So I am still on the rump. Got 40 pounds worth @17 per kilo

  • @Ifitfitz22
    @Ifitfitz22 6 лет назад +6

    Those steaks looked awesome! What part of the cow are those cuts? The Hereford looks like a bone in ribeye and the rubia looked like a really thick cut strip to me.

    • @chads7796
      @chads7796 6 лет назад +1

      Ya I am wondering the same and agree with your assessment. Care to verify Roel?

  • @marzo1979
    @marzo1979 6 лет назад +13

    Rubia Gallega es mejor.!!!!

    • @dess8808
      @dess8808 5 лет назад

      No it isn't. A hereford from the Pampas will make that look like a joke.

    • @sitohousemusic
      @sitohousemusic 3 месяца назад

      ​@@dess8808estas muy muy muy equivocado !

  • @mjwmontgomery
    @mjwmontgomery 6 месяцев назад

    Had a rubia steak today. It was brilliant. Irish steak is great too.

  • @patrickbeyer8909
    @patrickbeyer8909 6 лет назад

    when i search for those steakcuts on the Website it only shows me URUGUAYAANS GRAIN-FED MINI ; URUGUAYAN HANGING TENDER. URUGUAYAN GRAIN-FED WHOLE RIB ...
    do you get these to test them and they are for sale later ?

  • @ladamurni
    @ladamurni 6 лет назад +1

    Very nice video! You made me hungry. To me the Rubia was a little undercooked. I did however expect the Rubia to taste nicer than the Heroford because of the marbeling of the Rubia. But there you see looks aren't everything :)

  • @logic3686
    @logic3686 6 лет назад

    Just beautiful. You always deliver sensational steaks.

  • @vykeenb4707
    @vykeenb4707 6 лет назад

    Awesome yet again. Thanks

  • @grontelp77
    @grontelp77 5 лет назад +2

    that hereford looks overcooked, looks medium and parts are well done. Rubia is beautifully rare.

    • @abiamdanso3394
      @abiamdanso3394 2 года назад

      When the beef is almost medium rare is when it’s the best ❤️

  • @anthonyferguson7877
    @anthonyferguson7877 2 года назад

    What brand was the butter from

  • @owenn3885
    @owenn3885 6 лет назад

    Looks amazing!

  • @gero811
    @gero811 6 лет назад

    any idea which thermometer he uses? it's obviously not the one linked in the description.

  • @jacklamotta0015
    @jacklamotta0015 6 лет назад +5

    hi roel✌✌my favorite is 100% rubia gallega👍👍👍👉❤👈

  • @cyanide893
    @cyanide893 6 лет назад +1

    I like these episode of beef battle!! Why dont you make this a series?!

  • @yalcnergun8511
    @yalcnergun8511 4 года назад

    I liked which you made with Portobello man! But Rubia needs a little bit more heat, if you more liked the Hereford that’s why..

  • @denelektrieker6851
    @denelektrieker6851 2 года назад

    The rubia really shines when smoking it slowly

  • @leifdehio2151
    @leifdehio2151 6 лет назад

    Hey Roel, nice cuts of beef there! Was the Rubia Gallega cut the same as the Hereford one and was it aged the same way as the Hereford? The cuts looked somewhat different...
    The cheese you used in the Portobellos, was it a French „Reblochon“?
    In any case a mouthwatering video as usual...

  • @bigpapi3636
    @bigpapi3636 6 лет назад

    Mushrooms inside mushrooms, molten cheese and a Fred Flintstone steak. What's not to like! I've weighed in before by saying the particular breed has less to do with the final result than the up front quality of the beef. I still believe that's true and that diet is a factor as well. To me grass-fed has a more beefy, mineral taste than grain-fed and I prefer it although it's not for everyone.

  • @dodgeviper1372
    @dodgeviper1372 6 лет назад +2

    May I come and live with you I so need some of them steaks lol wicked vid Hereford deffo only coz I’ve never had the other one lol

    • @PITMASTERX
      @PITMASTERX  6 лет назад +1

      hahahahha.. give the Rubia Gallega a try.. it is also good

  • @craig3205
    @craig3205 6 лет назад

    When you take the steaks off from indirect, do they lose much heat whilst waiting for the cast iron pan to warm? Does this impact the meat?

    • @PITMASTERX
      @PITMASTERX  6 лет назад

      It does, but these cuts were so thick you hardly notice

  • @christophervanbrackle8808
    @christophervanbrackle8808 6 лет назад

    I work across the street from Smith & Wolenski. They're getting a visit today!

  • @salt262
    @salt262 6 лет назад

    I was wondering why you dont season your steaks before grilling them ?

  • @Isac86
    @Isac86 6 лет назад +1

    Tomahawk steak!!! I'm drooling right now. Awesome job Roel.

  • @JETLFC
    @JETLFC 6 лет назад

    What weights are these cuts of beautiful steaks ???

    • @PITMASTERX
      @PITMASTERX  6 лет назад

      North of 1 kg.. my guess is 1,2 kg

  • @ibr80
    @ibr80 3 года назад

    You turned the Rubia gallega into a roast beef. Where are the pieces of lovely far the rubia is known for ? Thank you very much for making and sharing the video but it’s not apples to apples.

  • @bcwolters
    @bcwolters 6 лет назад

    Hi Roel, I love your channel, and the only question I have for this episode is, why didn't you cook / grill the Portobello? Then I am even getting bold with a request, a nice bone marrow recipe, could you do one please? Then the British - Irish Hereford breed discussion, It's quite simple, the breed originated in Herefordshire, England. But has been exported to over 50 countries. The species you got your hands on, clearly was bred in Ireland.

  • @foxxx555666
    @foxxx555666 6 лет назад +1

    Yes please, another steak video :D well done sir.

  • @yarith9764
    @yarith9764 6 лет назад

    I live in the Netherlands as well if I may ask, where did you get the hereford steak ? I already know beef&steak quite well ^^

    • @PITMASTERX
      @PITMASTERX  6 лет назад

      That's where I got it... if they dont have ot at the moment call the they will keep you informed

  • @evilreddog
    @evilreddog 6 лет назад

    How about locally sourced meat battle? different cattle, different farm location. Highland, lowland, coastal?

    • @PITMASTERX
      @PITMASTERX  6 лет назад

      Great suggestion.. might give it a try

  • @NLJeffEU
    @NLJeffEU 4 года назад

    Die intro muziek is echt al jaren veeeeelste hard 😂

  • @robmetzger9955
    @robmetzger9955 6 лет назад

    Looks sooo goood

  • @Eder418
    @Eder418 6 лет назад

    Oh man oh man richtig geil!!!

  • @hiramfeliciano2667
    @hiramfeliciano2667 6 лет назад

    You have a Great job!!!!!!!

  • @dwaynewladyka577
    @dwaynewladyka577 6 лет назад

    I think both looked great. That's my opinion. Cheers Roel!

  • @eliaschefpenamartinez
    @eliaschefpenamartinez 6 лет назад

    Both were beautiful. But the temperatures on both were completely different because of the thickness. Maybe next time you should ask for cuts that are equally cut in thickness or do the cutting yourself. That could make a change. I saw more dry meat on the Hereford for that reason and more red on the other. But good job on both cuts. I like Medium rare and almost rare. God bless.

    • @PITMASTERX
      @PITMASTERX  6 лет назад

      Thanks Elias. These cuts are imported like this I wish I could order it to specification

  • @21hazza
    @21hazza 2 года назад

    I can almost smell those steaks through the screen 😋

  • @RoyalViking465
    @RoyalViking465 5 лет назад +1

    Rubia Gallega is better

  • @TheMayhem15
    @TheMayhem15 6 лет назад

    Great Looking steaks PX. Nice one.

    • @PITMASTERX
      @PITMASTERX  6 лет назад

      Thanks bro.. glad you like them

  • @lordelectron6591
    @lordelectron6591 6 лет назад +2

    Next bbq white sause pasta

  • @quackgarage9551
    @quackgarage9551 5 лет назад

    As someone who grew up eating Hereford/Bradford from the Pampas region pasture everyday i'm definitely a bit biased ;)
    Any Hereford is one of the best experiences you can have when it comes to beef, it's a very underrated and somewhat unknown breed, it's so tender, so smooth and almost has no smell to it. The crossbreds between Hereford/Bradford/Nelore/Angus are even better.

    Rubia Gallega on the other hand is kinda similar but has a stronger smell to it, not rarely it's less tender and more tough to chew, just like a Nelore.

  • @SizzleBrothers
    @SizzleBrothers 6 лет назад

    Awesome Steaks, awesome Video, handsome guy! 🤤😍🤤😍😁🤘🏻

  • @NoOne-nx7en
    @NoOne-nx7en 6 лет назад

    I'm sorry but you're comparing a cut from the sir loin to a cut from the rib eye, obviously the rib eye will have more flavour because it has the fat in between the meat, it's also more tender. You should've pick the same cut if you really wanted to compare.

  • @gytisnavakauskas8588
    @gytisnavakauskas8588 6 лет назад

    Did I missed it or Portobello mushroom is RAW ? I always thought that You can`t eat raw mushrooms ..

    • @pietateip
      @pietateip 6 лет назад

      yeah i rewinded it 3 times to check if I missed sth. If he cooked them, he didnt show it. If he didnt cook them, well doesnt matter, he always gives the same reaction, if it's burned, dry,... ''it's always good'' :-/
      You can eat a small amout of raw mushrooms bit it contains a certain poison.

  • @RussMEagle
    @RussMEagle 6 лет назад

    Portobello’s not cooked?

  • @jasonbean1176
    @jasonbean1176 6 лет назад

    The second "e" in Hereford is silent, thus it's pronounced "herford". It seems goofy, but there's a lot of goofy stuff in the English language.:)

  • @gert-jandevries9729
    @gert-jandevries9729 6 лет назад +1

    Roel..... Wow!!!!!!

  • @sammygg21
    @sammygg21 6 лет назад +4

    Hey Pitmasters! Beautiful steaks!
    The mushroom! That was the cherry on the top for me!

    • @PITMASTERX
      @PITMASTERX  6 лет назад

      He sammy thanks bro

    • @wege85
      @wege85 6 лет назад

      Can't be happy more. World is out there with great mushrooms. He did good job this time with the sauce and steaks. Great inspiration.

  • @RichardBirdsall
    @RichardBirdsall 4 года назад

    Who the hell takes the time to watch the whole video and then downvote like an
    a$$hole? Either don't watch, or grow a brain and understand the content just isn't for you. This was my first video on this channel and got my vote!

  • @aitornavarro6597
    @aitornavarro6597 5 лет назад

    Rubia Gallega! 1000%!

  • @christophervanbrackle8808
    @christophervanbrackle8808 6 лет назад

    Man those are ROASTS...lol

  • @gabrieljordacernuda9011
    @gabrieljordacernuda9011 5 лет назад +1

    Maybe Hereford grow up in your country and the Galician Blonde does not. If it cost the same.
    I think you're pulling for the cows of your country.
    Watch how the cows are raised in Spain to assess their price.

  • @cashuma5010
    @cashuma5010 6 лет назад

    . . . couldn't spot you biting into this beautiful French bread :-) - I know: too much is too much . . .

  • @jonathanh2605
    @jonathanh2605 2 года назад

    Hereford every time!!

  • @jamesmckinney3311
    @jamesmckinney3311 6 лет назад

    I’ll take one! Lo.

  • @blech71
    @blech71 6 лет назад +1

    Damn I want steak 🥩 so bad now lol

    • @PITMASTERX
      @PITMASTERX  6 лет назад

      ... I got do another one 👉🤩

  • @shorylo3586
    @shorylo3586 5 лет назад

    Rubia galllllleeeggaaaa !!!!!!!!

  • @johnknapp6328
    @johnknapp6328 6 лет назад

    Rubia gallega looks like much better steak a lot more marbeling what is the cost of each. I'm curios
    What is native language in Netherlands, how many languages do you speak. With all the different European countries with many different languages. 👍

    • @JR-mv7uz
      @JR-mv7uz 6 лет назад +1

      Dutch/Frisian are the two official language. Most people know English/German or French.

    • @johnknapp6328
      @johnknapp6328 6 лет назад +1

      @@JR-mv7uz Thanks

  • @iraAlbucher
    @iraAlbucher 6 лет назад

    Great job! Both steaks looked good, but the portabellas looked like the star

  • @tofty21
    @tofty21 3 года назад

    Not an accurate comparison with different thicknesses and degrees of cooking. Having said that I would imagine the Hereford would be a better steak.

  • @ecyout
    @ecyout 3 года назад

    Dude, both steaks are overcooked, and you don't try the same part: one with fat and one from the heart of the steak. I don't have any opinion about your conclusion, and not saying it is right or wrong, just talking about the method ;)

  • @cdf2885
    @cdf2885 Год назад

    rubia gallega is far superior

  • @armangan-he8iy
    @armangan-he8iy 6 лет назад

    Крутые кусманы, супер, лайк, жду новых чудес.

  • @wickeddragon694
    @wickeddragon694 3 года назад

    Herefords are the best

  • @jccalvente
    @jccalvente 6 лет назад +4

    Bad cut on the rubia gallega wich is the best meat in the world,

  • @golfnutintib1
    @golfnutintib1 6 лет назад

    Poor comparison as it uses different cuts

  • @avednicomateo5181
    @avednicomateo5181 6 лет назад +1

    😍😋😋😍

  • @neighborhoodbbq3253
    @neighborhoodbbq3253 6 лет назад

    Perfect.👍👍👍. Greetings from us

  • @josheggers8499
    @josheggers8499 6 лет назад

    Did u learn from watching or from someone teaching you

  • @derfiesefriese1
    @derfiesefriese1 Год назад

    nice psilos

  • @MsGeoffh
    @MsGeoffh 4 года назад

    so impeach him because he's popular? lmao

  • @chris9937a
    @chris9937a 6 лет назад +2

    Did you just call that “Irish Hereford”?
    Hereford is very definitely not in Ireland if so. It’s an English city. Not Welsh (see history) and really really not Irish.
    Love your work - can you clarify please?

    • @PITMASTERX
      @PITMASTERX  6 лет назад +2

      Thanks Chris! The packaging said ..land of origin Ireland

    • @quelaag3829
      @quelaag3829 6 лет назад +7

      Well Irish Hereford is a breed of cattle that's breed in the midlands of Ireland. I dont know if it has anything to do with the English city though.

    • @jossfitzsimons
      @jossfitzsimons 6 лет назад +1

      I grew up in Tipperary and Waterford counties. My father and grandfather in Co Meath. Hereford were always the first choice for Irish beef farmers but my grandfather who soldiered in London in WW1 (trying to shoot down Zephlins and partying) always maintained a direct market in top London butchers for his smaller Aberdeen Angus, a more specialised breed. A typical Hereford is I guess about twice the weight of an Aberdeen Angus. Newer breeds.. Charolea Limousines etc I cannot comment except that say a milking cow like an Ayrshire I milked in Waterford and a Kerry Blue (like a dwarf Angus) could be found.... Well probably just in Kerry. They live out door all year round. The biggest milkers are Friesian from the Friesian Islands North of Scotland. I hope this clarifies? Now I'll move on to cross-breeds.....!

    • @jonnyt8056
      @jonnyt8056 6 лет назад +1

      It’s a name for the cattle breed and ALSO a place in England... irishhereford.com. Great Vid, hungry now though...

    • @peetsnort
      @peetsnort 6 лет назад

      I'm spartacas. I live in Hereford and its the original beef /dairy beef that you used to see in the western movie

  • @bigkahona8444
    @bigkahona8444 6 лет назад

    Wow you lost weight .. nice

  • @Sandor159
    @Sandor159 6 лет назад +1

    I once had Rubia Gallega picanha, I did not like the texture at all. The taste was great but extremely "chewy". Probably the most unpleasant steak I had.

  • @1066Kitchen
    @1066Kitchen 6 лет назад

    You don’t say Hereford like that, Americans can’t say Worcestershire either

    • @PITMASTERX
      @PITMASTERX  6 лет назад +1

      Hahaha.. I am Dutch... glad you will got the point

    • @1066Kitchen
      @1066Kitchen 6 лет назад

      Pitmaster X 😂😂😂 you must of smoked to much then, great cooked steaks tho

  • @tibbeatjshm
    @tibbeatjshm 6 лет назад

    😍🤩😋🤤🧟‍♂️🧟‍♂️🧟‍♂️🧟‍♂️🧟‍♂️🧟‍♂️meat!!

  • @fakenarutouzumaki3348
    @fakenarutouzumaki3348 6 лет назад +1

    These steak omg 😍😍😍

  • @mattdunn2582
    @mattdunn2582 6 лет назад

    I have never had the Rubia, but we raise Hereford. I am biased but I think they are the second best breed in the world.

    • @PITMASTERX
      @PITMASTERX  6 лет назад

      They awesome... where are you located?

    • @mattdunn2582
      @mattdunn2582 6 лет назад

      Pitmaster X, I am located in Southeast Alabama.

  • @pabloponti406
    @pabloponti406 3 года назад

    YOu cook the meat in a very bad way!!!! the size of Rubia is wrong no more the 4cm and no-cook more than 5 minutes for size, and for cooperation, you must cut almost the same size !!!

  • @joshasw240
    @joshasw240 6 лет назад

    Yay 100 :V

  • @zimzimma5688
    @zimzimma5688 3 года назад

    I'm Irish but living in Spain and I've tried the Rubia Gallega beef a few times here and for me personally at least, I'd take a run of the mill, bog standard Irish supermarket steak any day of the week. While the Rubia Gallega is definitely the best Spanish beef I've eaten here (I've had better Argentinian) I found it very underwhelming and quite frankly lacking in flavor in comparison to the Irish beef I grew up eating. Maybe it's what you're accustomed to, I don't know, but that's my honest feelings. Spanish pork however, well that's a different story. The best I've ever had by a long distance.

    • @j.b.2263
      @j.b.2263 3 года назад +1

      Are you sure it was rubia galega or ternera gallega? The second in veil and has a much blander taste.

    • @zimzimma5688
      @zimzimma5688 3 года назад

      @@j.b.2263 Well I'll put it this way, I hope it was Rubia Gallega because it was pretty expensive! As I say it is good beef, but personally I just think that the Irish Angus or Hereford beef I grew up on, which is for the most part exclusivley grass fed, given our year round rainy but mild climate, just has a much different taste to me, richer and beefier for lack of better word, but that might just be my personal palate.

    • @j.b.2263
      @j.b.2263 3 года назад

      @@zimzimma5688
      Rubia Galega is grass fed or it should be atleast.

    • @j.b.2263
      @j.b.2263 3 года назад +1

      @@zimzimma5688
      Galician avg summer temp is around 24-25 Celsius except Ourense and it rains more or less like in Ireland.
      Edit: lol. Looked it up and it rains double ammount per year in Santiago de Compostela than in Dublin it even rains more than in Glasgow for example. People need to forget about sunny Spain when talking about the North, lol.

    • @zimzimma5688
      @zimzimma5688 3 года назад

      @@j.b.2263 Thanks for the information, very interesting, I obviously knew it was much cooler in Galicia than say Andalucia for instance, but I didn't know it rained as much as in Ireland. I don't know what to tell you pal, I can only give my honest opinion. Again as I said, it's my personal preference so I wouldn't take it as a declaration of fact. Are you Spanish yourself?

  • @lordelectron6591
    @lordelectron6591 6 лет назад +2

    Loll first

    • @PITMASTERX
      @PITMASTERX  6 лет назад +1

      🥁🎶🏆🤸‍♂️🤩

  • @RussMEagle
    @RussMEagle 6 лет назад

    Hereford is British not Irish

    • @leifdehio2151
      @leifdehio2151 6 лет назад

      Russ Eagle: Hereford cattle raised in Ireland is actually Irish and also widely available throughout Europe - I purchase dry aged Hereford bred and grown up in Ireland regularly over here in Germany. Just as there is Black Angus from all parts of the planet, there is also Irish Hereford, even if it originally came from Herefordshire.

  • @debasplays6730
    @debasplays6730 6 лет назад

    Second

  • @roowasan5541
    @roowasan5541 4 года назад

    simple bs fake fake pitmater forgot the most important thing