A fair, frank, and intelligent discussion. I knew Mr. Sibal only as a politician and a senior Supreme Court advocate. But now he may be called a humanitarian activist. My respect for him increases after watching each of these discussion.
Sibhal has to decide to which party he belongs to. Congress has ousted him. He is creating a leftist Caucus of Delhi Lutyens in a AC 5 star hotel. Time is against this man at 75 he has only 5 years to become 80. His patience is running out as he wants to become a minister. Ha Ha...
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||●●●● *The Question from the Ruling Party & its Blind Followers about Islam & 20 crores Muslim?* *The Ruling Party and its Blind Followers stand against Islam & 20 crores Muslims by speeches, actions and expressing Hate & Anger against Islam & Muslims due to Misunderstood of Islam and its divine teachings and law.* *If you come forward with open mind & honestly to find-out, what is the Islam? through the book Quran & The life of Prophet MUHAMMAD peace be upon him, definitely you will love the Islam & Prophet MUHAMMAD pbuh.* *If you are weak in understanding & did not understand the subject Islam, how justice & peace will establish in our personal life and in our beautiful country India.* *Now choice is yours to accept the truth or mislead our life and our India.* Anwar Masih Uddin
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||●●●● *The Question from the Ruling Party & its Blind Followers about Islam & 20 crores Muslim?* *The Ruling Party and its Blind Followers stand against Islam & 20 crores Muslims by speeches, actions and expressing Hate & Anger against Islam & Muslims due to Misunderstood of Islam and its divine teachings and law.* *If you come forward with open mind & honestly to find-out, what is the Islam? through the book Quran & The life of Prophet MUHAMMAD peace be upon him, definitely you will love the Islam & Prophet MUHAMMAD pbuh.* *If you are weak in understanding & did not understand the subject Islam, how justice & peace will establish in our personal life and in our beautiful country India.* *Now choice is yours to accept the truth or mislead our life and our India.* Anwar Masih Uddin
A wonderful discussion. Mr. Kapil Sibal is a great personality and advocate. He showed us the serious problems that the Muslims are facing in India. I would like to say that the community instead of building so many mosques, why don't they build schools also. The Muslim community cannot only depend on the Government they too must build schools and educate the members of their community. Kapil, Sir have a discussion on the serious problems faced by the Christian community especially in the states ruled by the BJP. We Christians are being persecuted.
Today, the political focus is all about keep winning elections and its purpose is controlling tax payers money so that these funds assures win in next election. The sufferings of Indians is not the core issue. When we vote illetrate criminals to win power for our selfish prosperity then politicians spin the matter to their advantage.
Arfa ji ...excellent as always ❤ Heartfelt thanks for being our voice ❤️ Thanks to Kapil Sibal ji for initiating this free and frank discussion!! God bless you 🙏 ❤️
बिल्कुल सही राह पर है... इस विमर्श और गहरा किया जाना चाहिए... पार्ट -2, 3 या जितनी जरूरत हो, वर्तमान में मुस्तफा सर को जितना सुना जाए... उतना कम ! 👍❤️👍
Mr Kapil Sibal is a very gifted person , very eminent and highly intelligent lawyer. His programme is too good , his diction is impeccable , issues are well researched and a pleasure to watch. Thanks for yr excellent programmes.
Such a nice discussion. My huge respects to Prof Faizan Mustafa. If Muslims especially the talented Arfas listen to him carefully, India will be in a better place.
There is a scenario never witnessed in India before & I would know for am in my 8th decade of my Life . Have lived through every Prime Minister. The fault lies with With We the People, the silence of the onlookers is frightening, the intelligent the educated too have chosen willingly or under fear, changed.
The primary reason for not having Muslim leaders is due to not having enough liberal Hindus who can tolerate a practicing Muslim become a leader of Muslim community without compromising his / her religious indentity . Therefore deserving member of Muslim community doesn't enter into Indian politics. However, nowadays, Muslim can't hold even public position without being a hypocrite. Hence I sometimes tend to believe the word secularism itself gone changed to such an extent that become deficult to identify it .
That's not at all true. There are so many secular and liberal Hindus. But they are as fearful as Muslims. It's not that there aren't enough, it's just that they don't speak out loud and it should change. Also, tell me, do Muslims speak against Islam?
Absolutely off the mark ! It’s the Muslim community which does not accept broad minded liberal thinkers and true believers amongst them. A true believer is one who believes in God and not in a particular God ! Whereas practising Islam according to most intolerant Muslims is believing the mullah . The true Islamic scholars are not accepted. Look at what happened to Maulana Wahiddudeen saheb . Muslims by and large , think that introspection is not permitted in Islam so they remain in the cesspool of their beliefs forever and are led by this Mullah or that Maulavi !
Have you seen a muslim leader in secular America or UK - let alone China or Russia. No politician can be a leader of the masses if they do not feel, address and take ahead what the masses want - if that sounds like a compromise to you, be it. Or be an uncompromised ghetto leader like Owaisi - live as a Pakistani in India.
And why should you expect otherwise - Hindus wanted a Hindu nation and muslims an Islamic nation. Nehru and some leftists forced Hindus to be secular after breaking India on communal lines. The muslims in India should just make themselves useful to the nation while earning a livelihood.
This is so true. My learned friends and relatives are thinking the way this system is saying. Their minds have been corrupted with these hate thoughts.
This panel didn't represent minority although 20 crore people didn't fall in minority by any definition . Most of the Muslims in India didn't believe in secularism, socialism and neither in constitution. They value constitution only as it protect their right. I meet 100 of Muslims on daily basis barely anyone who values secularism all they want is a sharia .
Muslim community leaders are also equally responsible for marginalisation similar to Hindurashtra vadi. About 45-50 years back when I was in college, Muslim girls were wearing dress like others. They were mingling with non-muslims and having friendly relation with others. Now Muslim leaders want seperate identity. The girls are wearing Burkha and restrict their interaction with others.
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||●●●● *The Question from the Ruling Party & its Blind Followers about Islam & 20 crores Muslim?* *The Ruling Party and its Blind Followers stand against Islam & 20 crores Muslims by speeches, actions and expressing Hate & Anger against Islam & Muslims due to Misunderstood of Islam and its divine teachings and law.* *If you come forward with open mind & honestly to find-out, what is the Islam? through the book Quran & The life of Prophet MUHAMMAD peace be upon him, definitely you will love the Islam & Prophet MUHAMMAD pbuh.* *If you are weak in understanding & did not understand the subject Islam, how justice & peace will establish in our personal life and in our beautiful country India.* *Now choice is yours to accept the truth or mislead our life and our India.* Anwar Masih Uddin
🔴🔵‼ कृपया हमारे संविधान को बचाने के लिए अपनी आवाज़ उठाएँ ‼ ➡‼ अब केवल मतदाता (आम जनता) ही हमारे संविधान और भारत के लोकतंत्र को बचा सकते हैं, अगर हम सच्चे भारतीय नागरिक हैं, धन्यवाद
In a secular country , like the students like the teacher In a religious country , like the teacher like the students Faizan Mustafa and Muslim teachers across India are the ideal example of teacher's condition in a secular country
Respected, I can say TRUE human being Kapil Sibbel sir. I thank you that you have given a title to your channel as " DIL SE ". It is a SYMBOL of your thought a Higher a Human than identity of your Religion. Sir I noticed that Unless. & Until a person who is holding a Higher position with powers linked to his status will Live his life to Work without feeling of his HEART than your WISDOM. You will be a Danger & your actions will destroy the Sorroundings . I therefore greet you to introduce the name " DIL SE". SIR JI I am senior citizen of this my Mother land aged 84 + a retired Pensioner a post equal to the Dy. Collector. I am sure you have been Blessed by the Almighty to do something for the topic " JUSTICE ". You have pointed one question to three participants about " LEADER" in this community. Sir with due respect i can recommend you to please you go through a book of MICHLE HART titled " 100 INFLUENCIAL PERSONS OF THE WORLD ".
I think dear Kapil Sibal and other dear participants should understand that there is another minority in India, the linguistic minorities. How can a malayalee understand what you are talking if you suddenly slip to Hindi. I want to follow the very important topic you are discussing but couldn't, because of this. Atleast think of subtitles if you want to slip to Hindi in between.
Minorities will need to rise from a point of strength and not weakness...we know that victimization is a fact and we can keep crying about it...but what about the attitude adjustment which is alao much needed, it really on us to change our plight....Lastly we the muslims of India should stop idolizing Pakistan or the Arab states....we need to hold on steadfastly to the ideals of secularism even in our private spaces.
Not sure if Sibal could manage to take political advantage from this discussion. However, these three smart and eminant Muslim personalities have certainly opened up people’s mind if not more for Kapil Sibal. Mr.Sibal… try hard next time.
Discussion on the Contradictions of Society inherent in the Contemporary Bharat 2b Progressively corrected 4Constitutional Objectives engraved inThe PREAMBLE of Our Constitution of INDIA*
Thanks to Sibal Sahib and all praise for his wisdom, knowledge and objectively in holding great discussion among distinguished intellectuals concerned on the relevant and delicate issue. His style of conducting the discussion is of immense value to the well meaning viewers. Thanks to Sibal Sahib again for sparing time out of his awfully scarce schedule for holding DIL SE. It is sorts of national service. Jai Hind !
I am a Citizen of India. But I will not stand up for Anthem, I will not show respect for Rama Navami procession, I will not respect Tiranga, I will not respect Ram, I will respect SC and courts only when they listen to me,. My foot Citizen of India..
A fair, frank, and intelligent discussion. I knew Mr. Sibal only as a politician and a senior Supreme Court advocate. But now he may be called a humanitarian activist. My respect for him increases after watching each of these discussion.
Mr.Kapil Sibal is a wonderful personality and excellent subject talking and he is a real son of mother India
Wow he is real only for a particular party
@@sujityadav8971tumhara bhi number aayega bus manusmriti implementation ka intezaar karo
Sibhal has to decide to which party he belongs to. Congress has ousted him.
He is creating a leftist Caucus of Delhi Lutyens in a AC 5 star hotel. Time is against this man at 75 he has only 5 years to become 80. His patience is running out as he wants to become a minister. Ha Ha...
yes and Kapil Sibal sir is very well read and open analytical minded....
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||●●●●
*The Question from the Ruling Party & its Blind Followers about Islam & 20 crores Muslim?*
*The Ruling Party and its Blind Followers stand against Islam & 20 crores Muslims by speeches, actions and expressing Hate & Anger against Islam & Muslims due to Misunderstood of Islam and its divine teachings and law.*
*If you come forward with open mind & honestly to find-out, what is the Islam? through the book Quran & The life of Prophet MUHAMMAD peace be upon him, definitely you will love the Islam & Prophet MUHAMMAD pbuh.*
*If you are weak in understanding & did not understand the subject Islam, how justice & peace will establish in our personal life and in our beautiful country India.*
*Now choice is yours to accept the truth or mislead our life and our India.*
Anwar Masih Uddin
we need a india like this. Decent, Secular and Happy India.
Your efforts are far better than so called todays media channels...
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||●●●●
*The Question from the Ruling Party & its Blind Followers about Islam & 20 crores Muslim?*
*The Ruling Party and its Blind Followers stand against Islam & 20 crores Muslims by speeches, actions and expressing Hate & Anger against Islam & Muslims due to Misunderstood of Islam and its divine teachings and law.*
*If you come forward with open mind & honestly to find-out, what is the Islam? through the book Quran & The life of Prophet MUHAMMAD peace be upon him, definitely you will love the Islam & Prophet MUHAMMAD pbuh.*
*If you are weak in understanding & did not understand the subject Islam, how justice & peace will establish in our personal life and in our beautiful country India.*
*Now choice is yours to accept the truth or mislead our life and our India.*
Anwar Masih Uddin
Faizan Mustafa sir was fabulous 🫡
Hats off to you Kapil Sibal Sir
Kapıl Sibel sir
You n Mr. P bushan are the pillars of honesty in Indian Justice
Wish you both good health and long life
Why they go to court to protect terrorists and anti nationals?
I am Vijay Avasthi ( Hindu Brahmin) agree with each and every word by Arfa Ma'am ( My most favorite woman generalist)
I AM A HINDU
I DON'T AGREE WITH ANYTHING ARFA SAYS WHO ÌS A JIHADI DIHADI
I am also a Hindu Brahmin , she is a traitor , always on wrong side. You are misguided
@@fellowgoodie
U demolished 300 mosque and madarsa and u said traitor to her u urself a traitor
@@SAFFRONINFERNO
I know only 0.00001% hindus are non racist being a hindu is itself a racism person
Very sincere and absolutely transparent conversation.
An epitome of law and justice Sibal has to engage more with the populace of India.
Hats of you all ❤. Kapil sir we need more conversations with people like these intellectuals !
Dil se Kapil sibal sar ji
I am a Christian and a proud Indian.
Loved the conversation...finally educated muslims talking about muslim problems.... looking forward for more such discussions
I was born in a brahmin family. Thats good but I am superior only if I do good actions
You will be Superior if u stick to your ancestral job that is begging
Meaningful conversation is held in Dil Se.Thank you,Sibal Saheb.
A wonderful discussion. Mr. Kapil Sibal is a great personality and advocate. He showed us the serious problems that the Muslims are facing in India. I would like to say that the community instead of building so many mosques, why don't they build schools also. The Muslim community cannot only depend on the Government they too must build schools and educate the members of their community. Kapil, Sir have a discussion on the serious problems faced by the Christian community especially in the states ruled by the BJP. We Christians are being persecuted.
Today, the political focus is all about keep winning elections and its purpose is controlling tax payers money so that these funds assures win in next election. The sufferings of Indians is not the core issue. When we vote illetrate criminals to win power for our selfish prosperity then politicians spin the matter to their advantage.
No doubt, Sibal is intellectual par excellence... Very good discussion.
Really a wonderful conversation, in true sense!!!
Nobody can hate APJ Abdul Kalam sir. Your contribution to country decide the respect to your community.
Wah! Kya logic lagaaya Bhai. Waise tho saare gareeb waalon ko maar de? Chu logic by a Chu.
Thanks Kapil Sir for bringing such an important issue.
Arfa ji ...excellent as always ❤ Heartfelt thanks for being our voice ❤️ Thanks to Kapil Sibal ji for initiating this free and frank discussion!! God bless you 🙏 ❤️
Faizan Mustafa sir far better than others three penal members, he is real secular,
बिल्कुल सही राह पर है... इस विमर्श और गहरा किया जाना चाहिए... पार्ट -2, 3 या जितनी जरूरत हो, वर्तमान में मुस्तफा सर को जितना सुना जाए... उतना कम ! 👍❤️👍
Mr Sibbal is playing this new role very well, excellent discussion. 👍🏻
Mr Kapil Sibal is a very gifted person , very eminent and highly intelligent lawyer. His programme is too good , his diction is impeccable , issues are well researched and a pleasure to watch. Thanks for yr excellent programmes.
Madam,
As a muslim do not be afraid. I am a hindu and I am with you for your fearless journalism. Keep it up. God bless you.
Nice discussion 👌 ❤
Absolutely agree with Najeeb sahab
Constructive conversation. Thank you Sibal Sir
Sir thanks for that's wonderful conversation.
People should unite to save our democracy
Such a nice discussion. My huge respects to Prof Faizan Mustafa. If Muslims especially the talented Arfas listen to him carefully, India will be in a better place.
Sensitive & Genuine concern ...My Identity as Citizen of the Country under the provision of our Constitution
I very heartedly salute mr kabil sibal sir for. Strong humanitarian approach
Very good conversation.
The best thing Kapil Sibal has done is "COMING ON RUclips" with very important topics. This will create great awareness about Constitutional law.
Illuminating. Great journalism.
Meaningful discussion
Kudos to Mustafa Sir. ❤
He is the true voice of Secularism.
The Other Two are Talking like Radical Orthodox Islamist.
Kudos to najeeb sir for speaking with honesty without sugercoating.
Time to come together all our intellectuals raise your voice to save our democracy save our country.
LOL There is no democracy in 57 Islamic hell Holes.
There is a scenario never witnessed in India before & I would know for am in my 8th decade of my Life . Have lived through every Prime Minister.
The fault lies with With We the People, the silence of the onlookers is frightening, the intelligent the educated too have chosen willingly or under fear, changed.
Arfa is absolutely correct. It's a reality.
Thank you Mr.Sibal for this insightful and thought-provoking discussion. Excellent!!
He is full of energy...
Great discussion
Kapil Sir Thank you for this initiative. This was much needed.
You are the one who is standing and taking all that pain for the country.
Love You ❤
Najeeb sir also speak as good and experienced person
Now Sikhs are not called 'terrorists. So, hopefully, things will change for our Muslim brethren
Excellent conversation sir
Very very good and true discussion 👍👍
Kapil saheb nice program ❤❤❤❤
The primary reason for not having Muslim leaders is due to not having enough liberal Hindus who can tolerate a practicing Muslim become a leader of Muslim community without compromising his / her religious indentity . Therefore deserving member of Muslim community doesn't enter into Indian politics. However, nowadays, Muslim can't hold even public position without being a hypocrite. Hence I sometimes tend to believe the word secularism itself gone changed to such an extent that become deficult to identify it .
That's not at all true. There are so many secular and liberal Hindus. But they are as fearful as Muslims. It's not that there aren't enough, it's just that they don't speak out loud and it should change. Also, tell me, do Muslims speak against Islam?
Absolutely off the mark ! It’s the Muslim community which does not accept broad minded liberal thinkers and true believers amongst them. A true believer is one who believes in God and not in a particular God ! Whereas practising Islam according to most intolerant Muslims is believing the mullah . The true Islamic scholars are not accepted.
Look at what happened to Maulana Wahiddudeen saheb .
Muslims by and large , think that introspection is not permitted in Islam so they remain in the cesspool of their beliefs forever and are led by this Mullah or that Maulavi !
Have you seen a muslim leader in secular America or UK - let alone China or Russia. No politician can be a leader of the masses if they do not feel, address and take ahead what the masses want - if that sounds like a compromise to you, be it. Or be an uncompromised ghetto leader like Owaisi - live as a Pakistani in India.
😢😢
And why should you expect otherwise - Hindus wanted a Hindu nation and muslims an Islamic nation. Nehru and some leftists forced Hindus to be secular after breaking India on communal lines. The muslims in India should just make themselves useful to the nation while earning a livelihood.
Wonderful Conversation ❤❤❤
Excellent topic, guests and discussion 👍
Arfa gave a befitting reply on shahabuddin as leader 👍👍👍
This is so true. My learned friends and relatives are thinking the way this system is saying. Their minds have been corrupted with these hate thoughts.
Lucky to hear a person like Mr Sibal in my lifetime
Very fruitful discussion
All being said, had muslims in India joined the mainstream 75 years back, we would not have had this kind of a situation.
THAT IS PART OF OUR HISTORY AS WELL
Very excellent ,naa jaana,issa loog,kahan hai,May ,God give our country,peacefulness
This panel didn't represent minority although 20 crore people didn't fall in minority by any definition . Most of the Muslims in India didn't believe in secularism, socialism and neither in constitution. They value constitution only as it protect their right. I meet 100 of Muslims on daily basis barely anyone who values secularism all they want is a sharia .
I wish more and more people get inspired by all of them and become kind human beings, thank you #KapilSibal
Well spoken sir. Keep it up.
Sensitive issues should be talked about. Handle it delicately
Muslim community leaders are also equally responsible for marginalisation similar to Hindurashtra vadi. About 45-50 years back when I was in college, Muslim girls were wearing dress like others. They were mingling with non-muslims and having friendly relation with others. Now Muslim leaders want seperate identity. The girls are wearing Burkha and restrict their interaction with others.
Constitution has to be saved at any cost to the country
Kapil sibal aapko superincourt ka jaz hona chahiye brileant sir salute he aapko aur aapki koshisho ko keep it up thank
All of you are good orator ❤
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||●●●●
*The Question from the Ruling Party & its Blind Followers about Islam & 20 crores Muslim?*
*The Ruling Party and its Blind Followers stand against Islam & 20 crores Muslims by speeches, actions and expressing Hate & Anger against Islam & Muslims due to Misunderstood of Islam and its divine teachings and law.*
*If you come forward with open mind & honestly to find-out, what is the Islam? through the book Quran & The life of Prophet MUHAMMAD peace be upon him, definitely you will love the Islam & Prophet MUHAMMAD pbuh.*
*If you are weak in understanding & did not understand the subject Islam, how justice & peace will establish in our personal life and in our beautiful country India.*
*Now choice is yours to accept the truth or mislead our life and our India.*
Anwar Masih Uddin
An amazing discourse and certainly very enlightening.
🔴🔵‼ कृपया हमारे संविधान को बचाने के लिए अपनी आवाज़ उठाएँ ‼
➡‼ अब केवल मतदाता (आम जनता) ही हमारे संविधान और भारत के लोकतंत्र को बचा सकते हैं, अगर हम सच्चे भारतीय नागरिक हैं, धन्यवाद
🇮🇳 ❤ #proudcitizenfirst
Excellent discussion
In a secular country , like the students like the teacher
In a religious country , like the teacher like the students
Faizan Mustafa and Muslim teachers across India are the ideal example of teacher's condition in a secular country
If Hindu personal law can be abolished why not Muslim personal law ?
Very good .
You want to be righteous , but when unrighteousness is a law , you have to apply your wisdom
Very true.What can u do when the judiciary is not following the spirit of our country's constitution
Every Indian has right to wear and eat of his choice
Love you sir
Great sir
Modi disqualified for 6 years
Respected, I can say TRUE human being Kapil Sibbel sir. I thank you that you have given a title to your channel as " DIL SE ". It is a SYMBOL of your thought a Higher a Human than identity of your Religion.
Sir I noticed that Unless. & Until a person who is holding a Higher position with powers linked to his status will Live his life to Work without feeling of his HEART than your WISDOM. You will be a Danger & your actions will destroy the Sorroundings .
I therefore greet you to introduce the name " DIL SE".
SIR JI I am senior citizen of this my Mother land aged 84 + a retired Pensioner a post equal to the Dy. Collector.
I am sure you have been Blessed by the Almighty to do something for the topic " JUSTICE ".
You have pointed one question to three participants about " LEADER" in this community.
Sir with due respect i can recommend you to please you go through a book of MICHLE HART titled " 100 INFLUENCIAL PERSONS OF THE WORLD ".
I Really enjoyed the conversation and learn a lot of things
3 points
1. Govt opens school, all students go there. Hindu, Muslim, Sikh, Christian etc have ro right yo primary education.
A totally wellcome changed jung sahab
Great 💯😊 very good ❤
I think dear Kapil Sibal and other dear participants should understand that there is another minority in India, the linguistic minorities. How can a malayalee understand what you are talking if you suddenly slip to Hindi. I want to follow the very important topic you are discussing but couldn't, because of this. Atleast think of subtitles if you want to slip to Hindi in between.
Agree 100%. Pls use subtitles in yr videos Mr. Sibal especially in your Hindi videos. We love to watch them
Barvo sir.. being Muslim it gave me another (wise) perspective of looking at the things
We need like Mr. H. N. Bahuguna like leader to India.
Salute Sir
Excellent work keep it going
Minorities will need to rise from a point of strength and not weakness...we know that victimization is a fact and we can keep crying about it...but what about the attitude adjustment which is alao much needed, it really on us to change our plight....Lastly we the muslims of India should stop idolizing Pakistan or the Arab states....we need to hold on steadfastly to the ideals of secularism even in our private spaces.
Very Good Show ❤❤
Well said jung sahab
Not sure if Sibal could manage to take political advantage from this discussion. However, these three smart and eminant Muslim personalities have certainly opened up people’s mind if not more for Kapil Sibal. Mr.Sibal… try hard next time.
It matters!
Discussion on the Contradictions of
Society inherent in the Contemporary Bharat 2b Progressively corrected 4Constitutional Objectives engraved inThe PREAMBLE of Our Constitution of INDIA*
Thanks to Sibal Sahib and all praise for his wisdom, knowledge and objectively in holding great discussion among distinguished intellectuals concerned on the relevant and delicate issue. His style of conducting the discussion is of immense value to the well meaning viewers. Thanks to Sibal Sahib again for sparing time out of his awfully scarce schedule for holding DIL SE. It is sorts of national service.
Jai Hind !
I am a Citizen of India. But I will not stand up for Anthem, I will not show respect for Rama Navami procession, I will not respect Tiranga, I will not respect Ram, I will respect SC and courts only when they listen to me,. My foot Citizen of India..
Thank you Religion? First we are citizens of India is best concept to prosperity -primary education -beyond religion -is faith