Chris Chibnall Was Bad for Doctor Who: #2, #3, #5 and #4 He Doesn't Like Doctor Who

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 5 янв 2025

Комментарии • 42

  • @Mor0se-g9b
    @Mor0se-g9b 13 дней назад +1

    *whole video about how bad the chibnall era was*
    "i swore not to watch it"

    • @innfahrgeek
      @innfahrgeek  13 дней назад

      @@Mor0se-g9b Yes, we found out from lots of online reviews and articles.
      We didn't watch a single episode.

    • @Goodsoldiersfolleworders99
      @Goodsoldiersfolleworders99 8 дней назад

      @@innfahrgeek I did, not bad, people don't like it because the doctor has tits, must be single fans with no sex life

  • @andrewbyrne2173
    @andrewbyrne2173 14 дней назад +2

    That title is the master of understatement.

  • @Goodsoldiersfolleworders99
    @Goodsoldiersfolleworders99 8 дней назад +2

    Canon never made sense in doctor who just like time travel, so get over it

    • @innfahrgeek
      @innfahrgeek  8 дней назад +1

      @@Goodsoldiersfolleworders99 Canon always made sense in Doctor Who.
      The Doctor (Sigma Theta) who is a member of the Time Lord Society, stole a Type 40 Tardis to take his granddaughter out to see the universe.
      That is very simple.
      The Doctor was part of a big family but his brother stepped forward to fill a very important role as family head.
      The Doctor was in the house called the Prydonian Chapter at the academy. The same house as his teacher Borusa and the Time Lord president Rassillon.
      The Doctor had terrible grades in school and even failed his final exams more than once.
      You see, Doctor Who canon makes lots of sense, one only just has to look deeper for it.
      Each race of being has their origins.
      You are most welcome.

    • @Goodsoldiersfolleworders99
      @Goodsoldiersfolleworders99 8 дней назад

      @innfahrgeek I didn't need a long backstory 💤💤💤💤💤

  • @timmyhipbird7543
    @timmyhipbird7543 16 дней назад +2

    so he is one of the ones that killed dr who.

    • @RegianOne
      @RegianOne 16 дней назад +2

      Yes, it started with him

    • @innfahrgeek
      @innfahrgeek  16 дней назад +1

      @@timmyhipbird7543 He is indeed the new version of John Nathan Turner.
      Turner came during the 4th Doctor's era and not only cause a rift between him and Tom Baker, he also punished the people playing companions if they didn't fall inline with his decisions.
      Peri Brown was killed off the show because Nicola Bryant refused to do pantomime doctor who stage shows for 6 hours after spending all day shooting episodes.

  • @aidenshigaraki1998
    @aidenshigaraki1998 8 дней назад

    canon was not that good in Doctor Who, but I don't watch doctor who for that, I watch it for the aliens and monster, but i think in my opinion that Chibnall did do a better job with the Cybermen inhis season of doctor who better then torchwood with the Cyberwoman

    • @innfahrgeek
      @innfahrgeek  8 дней назад

      @aidenshigaraki1998 Canon is very good for Doctor Who. It is a common misconception that it isn't.
      It is a show thats been on for 60 years and it has a long and deep and complex canon.
      Russell T Davies 1.0 and Steven Moffat respected and knew canon.
      Steven Moffat especially knew canon well as he talked about it behind the scenes.
      For the episodes World Enough and Time and The Doctor Falls he showed the origins of the Cybermen, making it the first time it was shown on TV.
      I have been a fan since 1984.

    • @aidenshigaraki1998
      @aidenshigaraki1998 8 дней назад

      @@innfahrgeek I grow up with the 2005 seasons

    • @innfahrgeek
      @innfahrgeek  7 дней назад

      @aidenshigaraki1998 yes and they hold true Canon.
      Even the Cybermen who they use in series 2 aren't the original variant but they act a lot like the original

  • @friendlyotaku9525
    @friendlyotaku9525 13 дней назад

    "He Doesn't Like Doctor Who"
    Literally a lifelong Doctor Who fan but okay.
    Also it was the BBC's decision to change from Christmas to New Year, not Chibnall's as he himself confirmed.

    • @innfahrgeek
      @innfahrgeek  13 дней назад +1

      @@friendlyotaku9525 If he liked it, he would not have tried to change the origin story.
      Russell T Davies, big fan of the show, brought it back to the air waves, didn't change the show. He created the Cybus Cybermen but kept them very close to the original Mondasian Cybermen.
      Steven Moffat also a big fan, didn't change the origin story. In fact he found a way to keep the show on because the 11th Doctor was on his last regeneration cycle.

    • @friendlyotaku9525
      @friendlyotaku9525 13 дней назад

      @@innfahrgeek No, the origin story was not "changed", it was expanded upon and makes sense within the context of the show, it ENRICHES the history.

    • @innfahrgeek
      @innfahrgeek  12 дней назад +1

      @friendlyotaku9525 He did try to change it.
      According to Chibnall, the Timeless Child is the origin of Regeneration power, not the time Vortex.
      If that was the case the River Song couldn't have been able to get any regeneration power. Power of which she used to save the Doctor's life.
      Secondly Chibnall tries to say that the Doctor has unlimited regeneration cycles, which is not accurate.
      Canon states firmly that it was Lord High President Rassillon that limited all other Time Lords to 12 cycles of regeneration only.
      That was why on the Time of the Doctor, Clara begged the time Lords through the crack in time to gift the Doctor with a new set of regeneration cycles because he had no more. He was getting old and was going to die on Trenzalore because he could no longer regenerate.
      So the 12th Doctor was the start of a brand new set of regeneration cycles.
      Rassillon limited regeneration because he is a paranoid megalomaniac, scared of being overthrown.

    • @friendlyotaku9525
      @friendlyotaku9525 12 дней назад

      @innfahrgeek so like others i've seen you completely misunderstand this story on a fundamental level?

    • @innfahrgeek
      @innfahrgeek  12 дней назад +1

      @friendlyotaku9525 what story is that, might I ask?

  • @Goodsoldiersfolleworders99
    @Goodsoldiersfolleworders99 8 дней назад

    Also the cyber time lords looked awesome, so you cant talk shit about them

    • @innfahrgeek
      @innfahrgeek  7 дней назад

      @@Goodsoldiersfolleworders99 They look good yet Cyber technology is incompatible with Time Lord biology. It was only designed for human beings.
      But Chibnall doesn't properly explain how it suddenly became compatible with Time Lords

    • @Goodsoldiersfolleworders99
      @Goodsoldiersfolleworders99 7 дней назад

      @innfahrgeek then watch the season

    • @innfahrgeek
      @innfahrgeek  7 дней назад

      @Goodsoldiersfolleworders99
      I couldn't enjoy it because of the many mistakes.
      I don't eat food that I won't enjoy either and neither would you.
      I was watching a Simpsons episode about 8 years ago that was already barely funny, then something happened that took me right out of the story.
      Apparently the Chinese were trying to kidnap Homer Simpson so he could give them the secrets to nuclear energy.
      The problem with that writing is that China tested their first nuke around 1953/1954.
      So why would they need those secrets from Homer when they already have nuclear weapons for 50 years?
      I won't watch something that I don't enjoy and neither would you.

    • @Goodsoldiersfolleworders99
      @Goodsoldiersfolleworders99 7 дней назад

      @innfahrgeek well your lost, but that means you can't have an opinion if you haven't seen it, your worst then critical drinker who didn't watch season 4 of the boys, so he went to rotten tomato for reviews, one of the worst websites of all time

    • @innfahrgeek
      @innfahrgeek  7 дней назад

      @Goodsoldiersfolleworders99
      Lol I have been a Doctor Who fan since 1984.
      Canon is not opinion, it is fact.
      I will leave operating in opinion for you.

  • @tonyc9481
    @tonyc9481 14 дней назад

    Watch the episodes before you can comment !!! there are some great episodes .

    • @innfahrgeek
      @innfahrgeek  14 дней назад

      @@tonyc9481 I am afraid that I cannot watch them. It is fine for those who haven't watched the show for as long as I have (1984). However I know too much about the canon and continuity therefore it would be an insult to my intelligence and I wouldn't enjoy it.
      It is like that Simpsons episode when the Chinese kidnap Homer Simpson in order to get the secrets of nuclear energy.
      I couldn't focus on anything else in the show because the Chinese detonated their first nuclear bomb in 1954. So why would they need Homer for the secret of nuclear energy???

    • @joesomers3949
      @joesomers3949 14 дней назад

      ​@innfahrgeek Don't worry, you don't have any intelligence to insult.

    • @Mor0se-g9b
      @Mor0se-g9b 13 дней назад

      @@innfahrgeek 🤓

    • @friendlyotaku9525
      @friendlyotaku9525 13 дней назад

      @@innfahrgeek ...so you're complaining about an era you haven't even watched?

    • @innfahrgeek
      @innfahrgeek  13 дней назад

      @@friendlyotaku9525 There are lots of reviews online with videos to explain what happens in each episode. Behind the scenes videos articles and ratings