Unfortunate really is that only 5% people in India complaining about tax, remaining enjoying freebies. Unless driving factor who pay tax has only rights to vote or weightage could be 10x for each of us, no one would listen to us.
Very true.. and with this kind of setup.. who knows how many illegal Bangladeshis are enjoying our tax freebies and how many more would be coming.. And one day they might start massacaring us like the current minorities in Bangladeshis.
Only 5% make huge money like how they have been making for so many years 🤮 If 80% depend on freebies and food subsidy then understand that whatever growth is happening is lop sided😊. So at the end of the day should govt really think and improve the well being of 5% or the 80% who are forced to depend on benevolence and largesse is really the issue. 😠So stop cribbing 😂
I am following u since very very beginning, but mostly u always defended the government, today i think it's the first time u spoke like a professional and that's what suits you.. this is how u should run ur business fact n fact .. no masal to government
Quite an interesting discussion with so much data. It makes sense why FII are selling. The government seems to have lost the plot and focussing on trivial things instead of growth economy. There is lot of negative sentiment growing in the minds of the tax payers, middle class are squeezed out, crumbling infrastructure, increasing feebie culture and what not. The narrative being built up looks gloomy and not at all encouraging for markets also but also for concerned citizens like us.
Our respected Madam will do NOTHING, She will announce some sops to farmers, some nonsense around rural economy etc, I am confident this NDA-3 lost the plot on economy, if we don't remain attractive to foreign investors, our future is scary. I am sure this government will do NOTHING, the arrogance of our respected FM Mam will continue.
मोदीजी विवश हैं क्योंकि उन्हें 80 करोड़ गरीबों को बिना मेहनत किये एकदम फ़ोकट में भोजन देना है ,वो भी 5 वर्ष तक😢😢😢😢 वो क्या कर सकते हैं?? वो असहाय हैं।।।😂😂
मोदीजी विवश हैं क्योंकि उन्हें 80 करोड़ गरीबों को बिना मेहनत किये एकदम फ़ोकट में भोजन देना है ,वो भी 5 वर्ष तक😢😢😢😢 वो क्या कर सकते हैं?? वो असहाय हैं।।।😂😂
Government of India's outstanding debt - 180 lakh crore Interest payment - 10.8 lakh crore Direct & Indirect Taxes will keep on increasing to pay the interest.
Great insight Sir. But the same should be thought by the present Govt and they should do every thing that's good for increasing consumption and thereby giving boost to the economy. A change in mindset is required along with change in personnel.
I am of the firm view that scenario building is intellectual entertainment! But I'll keep quiet till two levels viz. 25200 and 23200 are breached! First will signify recovery the other more downfall! In this range, I'll not commit a single rupee! But analysis is fun and a good way to pass time while being in FDs! 😊
The government should consider some measures to stabilize the market and retain investor confidence. This might include revisiting tax policies or introducing new incentives to attract foreign investment. Thank you Alok!
I think the increased domestic flow of money justifies that the majority DO have a disposable income and hence justifies the tax policies. Good job Narendra Bhai. So People are consuming it is just that they have started consuming stocks and hence the increase in STCG,LTCG 😂
225 basis points Delta is way to less to make India favorable, after accounting for currency risk it may be negative... Expect FII to continue selling for about a quarter or two atleast
Very good content, my point is government will need huge money to finance the freebies plus the capital expenditure. Hence lowering of taxes is difficult. They will only increase taxes now also on corporates and the rich .
The kind of arrogant behavior we have seen, it looks nothing going to come on taxation. I feel they may use STT is a good tool to extract further. Looking into currency depreciation FII may further off load, unless RBI does some miracles to hold rupee. As usual your video narration is a class of its own. Thanks to you.
Domestic flow will also stop. People are investing their foreign ESOPs aboard only and not bringing the proceeds to India. Indians are sending money via LRS outside.
@@kamalchakraborti1353 read the news of Cnbc two days back. Industry has recommended to fin minister and it is being considered. Laughing at it means you don’t watch news🤡
For NRIs, indexation is removed from properties which is a tax loot now, besides that, we can't do intraday, brokerage is high, we have to face Re. depreciation of 3% on an average, nothing left in Thali
Your views are spot on . But so long as you have an illiterate electorate and the entire state apparatus helping you get reelected without real economic performance why bother listening to anyone? Investors are less than 5%. Tax payers even less, so everyone else is enjoying at their expense. People who agitated against UPA regime are worse than it. Most commentators have been sugar coating the distasteful truths.Glad finally you chose to speak out.
The increasing trend of freebies ( both by opposition AND ruling govt) as seen in recent state elections shows the increasing socialist mindset of rural india and lower middle class in urban areas. Every party is under constant fear of not doling out enough freebies. So logically the only choice left is to TAX every aspect of our lives to fund these freebies! It has already started for the upcoming delhi elections. FIIs have realized this . The coming months will be a true test of the mantra 'SIP sahi hai ' !!
I think still there is a lot of money as still I am standing 107% on my portfolio and sitting on 70% profit cash.. finally market rewarded me after 10 years.. thanks sir..
Sir, with due respect to you, India is going down hill with a terrifying momentum. Not just the stock market or the Rupee, but everywhere I see. Even the commercial disputes in Patiala House Courts are not being decided. Orders are not being passed unless you Grease the Judiciary. Who in his right mind will invest in a Banana Republic like India.
If govt keep giving cash to people, high inflation will be there. For middle class, they got shock in Covid which burnt their savings, salary is stagnant for last few years, Rent has doubled in Tier 1, 2 cities. Food inflation is high. Disposable income and Savings are falling rapidly. Govt will give 500rs per month relief to middle class in budget and will expect turnaround in economy.
The investment opportunities in India has certainly taken a beating in view of the global situation. The stance of the present political dispensation is also not helping the stock markets. It appears the Govt is hell bent upon squeezing the tax payers and extending freebies to a majority of the population which is nothing but bribing them for votes. In fact the bribery is to be redefined since the Governments are directly involved in it. We have seen Governments fade away because of their lack of vision.
The rich people always want less tax, thats how income inequality will keep increasing. If anything, equity gains taxation should be same as that of salaried with maybe some discount.
Need a new FM who is upto the JOB and dosen't just just go by BABU's advise on finance.......still could not understand what good done by removing indexation and bringing in Grand fathering clauses for every thing......
Our dear PM is busy in making A1, A2 richer...and rest are busy in searching temples below mosques....who the hell is worried about economy......i dont own/ trade any shares - FM will say on budget day 😅
I think. Mother Taxesa is being arrogant now. When you listen too much to the babus and very little to the outside world you end up in this kind of a situation. You should balance views on both sides!
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
Unfortunate really is that only 5% people in India complaining about tax, remaining enjoying freebies. Unless driving factor who pay tax has only rights to vote or weightage could be 10x for each of us, no one would listen to us.
Do you know anyone who gets freebies . Stop believing what politicians tell you on the TV .
Very true.. and with this kind of setup.. who knows how many illegal Bangladeshis are enjoying our tax freebies and how many more would be coming..
And one day they might start massacaring us like the current minorities in Bangladeshis.
Unless the 5% quits the jobs and govt now needs to listen
Only 5% make huge money like how they have been making for so many years 🤮 If 80% depend on freebies and food subsidy then understand that whatever growth is happening is lop sided😊. So at the end of the day should govt really think and improve the well being of 5% or the 80% who are forced to depend on benevolence and largesse is really the issue. 😠So stop cribbing 😂
100% Indians are paying taxes. Probably you thought that only income tax payers are paying taxes but the burden of indirect taxes are borne by all.
after a long long time, we have got a clear view wrt to reasons for FII and FDI pulling out of India
😂😂 you're so visionary
I am following u since very very beginning, but mostly u always defended the government, today i think it's the first time u spoke like a professional and that's what suits you.. this is how u should run ur business fact n fact .. no masal to government
Quite an interesting discussion with so much data. It makes sense why FII are selling. The government seems to have lost the plot and focussing on trivial things instead of growth economy. There is lot of negative sentiment growing in the minds of the tax payers, middle class are squeezed out, crumbling infrastructure, increasing feebie culture and what not. The narrative being built up looks gloomy and not at all encouraging for markets also but also for concerned citizens like us.
Our respected Madam will do NOTHING, She will announce some sops to farmers, some nonsense around rural economy etc, I am confident this NDA-3 lost the plot on economy, if we don't remain attractive to foreign investors, our future is scary. I am sure this government will do NOTHING, the arrogance of our respected FM Mam will continue.
मोदीजी विवश हैं क्योंकि उन्हें 80 करोड़ गरीबों को बिना मेहनत किये एकदम फ़ोकट में भोजन देना है ,वो भी 5 वर्ष तक😢😢😢😢
वो क्या कर सकते हैं??
वो असहाय हैं।।।😂😂
Great, a very bold statement on the current taxation.
मोदीजी विवश हैं क्योंकि उन्हें 80 करोड़ गरीबों को बिना मेहनत किये एकदम फ़ोकट में भोजन देना है ,वो भी 5 वर्ष तक😢😢😢😢
वो क्या कर सकते हैं??
वो असहाय हैं।।।😂😂
I totally agree with your views. This Govt doesn't listen to anyone. Total failure & disappointment
Thank you for sharing your point of view. This was long time coming. Appreciate the content and the efforts put into the videos generally. Thanks!
Thank you.
Govt doesn't seem to be listening to anybody, is icing on the cake. True
One of the most impactful and detailed in depth video on basic macro economics....thanks for this.. will watch this again & again
Glad it was helpful!
I get to learn from every video. Appreciate your team's work.
Thanks for going beyond typical market, sector and stock analysis .
Our pleasure!
I don't think they have empathy towards investor and people of India. No cut in budget
Thanks for posting such a great view
Government of India's outstanding debt - 180 lakh crore
Interest payment - 10.8 lakh crore
Direct & Indirect Taxes will keep on increasing to pay the interest.
So you mean govt is taking loan on a interest of approx 6% per annumm. Are you serious?
Great insight Sir. But the same should be thought by the present Govt and they should do every thing that's good for increasing consumption and thereby giving boost to the economy. A change in mindset is required along with change in personnel.
I really like the data and knowledge you bring in for the video content. Very informative and straight to the point 😊
Thank you.
Merry Christmas 🎁
I am of the firm view that scenario building is intellectual entertainment! But I'll keep quiet till two levels viz. 25200 and 23200 are breached! First will signify recovery the other more downfall! In this range, I'll not commit a single rupee! But analysis is fun and a good way to pass time while being in FDs! 😊
Sir the knowledge you share is amazing
Thanks.
Clear analysis 👌
Thanks.
The government should consider some measures to stabilize the market and retain investor confidence.
This might include revisiting tax policies or introducing new incentives to attract foreign investment.
Thank you Alok!
Thanks for the point by point analysis sir. Maza agaya samajh k.
Spot on. Worth watching
I think the increased domestic flow of money justifies that the majority DO have a disposable income and hence justifies the tax policies.
Good job Narendra Bhai.
So People are consuming it is just that they have started consuming stocks and hence the increase in STCG,LTCG 😂
The truth is just the opposite. People are coming to market to make both ends meet.
225 basis points Delta is way to less to make India favorable, after accounting for currency risk it may be negative... Expect FII to continue selling for about a quarter or two atleast
Very good content, my point is government will need huge money to finance the freebies plus the capital expenditure. Hence lowering of taxes is difficult. They will only increase taxes now also on corporates and the rich .
Thank u sir for providing very helpful perspective ❤
So nice of you
Great Video Alok Ji, I expect the government to reduce taxes as situation on the ground is not good
I agree with u totally 💯
Thank u very much sir 🙏 🙏 ❤❤❤❤
thanks a lot for the insight sir
My pleasure
Good Evening Sir ❤
Adani port 5.2, green 3.2, Sol 2.8, power 2.24, ENT 1.23% up in my portfolio Sir.
I do agree with you sir!!
Good analysis of FII outflow, Sir
Thanks for liking
Appreciate your straight forward and honest approach Boss... completely agree with you 🙏🙏
Thank you.
Thank You Sir...
The kind of arrogant behavior we have seen, it looks nothing going to come on taxation. I feel they may use STT is a good tool to extract further. Looking into currency depreciation FII may further off load, unless RBI does some miracles to hold rupee.
As usual your video narration is a class of its own. Thanks to you.
I think India intentially does this to cool down markets and will revise policies to hike the markets in the next year.
I agreed ❤❤
I don't eat taxes
Why advisors are pushing me to reduce taxes
Plz add fii dii data as well
Domestic flow will also stop. People are investing their foreign ESOPs aboard only and not bringing the proceeds to India. Indians are sending money via LRS outside.
News of tax slab increase is already out. no tax (with rebate) upto 15L is being considered []
Do you believe?
@Ak20231 I said it’s being considered. Read again;;
😂😂😂
@@kamalchakraborti1353 read the news of Cnbc two days back. Industry has recommended to fin minister and it is being considered. Laughing at it means you don’t watch news🤡
@@kamalchakraborti1353 it’s in news. Stop laughing and get educated about news. I said it’s being considered. That’s all 🤡
For NRIs, indexation is removed from properties which is a tax loot now, besides that, we can't do intraday, brokerage is high, we have to face Re. depreciation of 3% on an average,
nothing left in Thali
Your views are spot on . But so long as you have an illiterate electorate and the entire state apparatus helping you get reelected without real economic performance why bother listening to anyone? Investors are less than 5%. Tax payers even less, so everyone else is enjoying at their expense. People who agitated against UPA regime are worse than it. Most commentators have been sugar coating the distasteful truths.Glad finally you chose to speak out.
Sir, it was not your rant. You spoke truth.
Our tax policy makers are busy eating popcorn
The increasing trend of freebies ( both by opposition AND ruling govt) as seen in recent state elections shows the increasing socialist mindset of rural india and lower middle class in urban areas.
Every party is under constant fear of not doling out enough freebies.
So logically the only choice left is to TAX every aspect of our lives to fund these freebies!
It has already started for the upcoming delhi elections.
FIIs have realized this .
The coming months will be a true test of the mantra 'SIP sahi hai ' !!
Alok ji a new only smallcaps basket of concentrated 15-17 stocks is need of the hour... Mi35 ka consolidated version... Looking forward....
Smallcapa shs always be more diversified. Returns is not everything
Govt needs to make long term policies and this govt certainly lacks the vision.
great
Winter मे popcorn tax.
Come summer, there is going to be icecream tax.
I can find many business people enjoying govt subsidy as they don't show much income. For them those tax increase have no impact
Totally agree
High officials advising the CG for more tax are indeed killing indian economy 😊
I think still there is a lot of money as still I am standing 107% on my portfolio and sitting on 70% profit cash.. finally market rewarded me after 10 years.. thanks sir..
SME stocks?
@gauravgoel8092 no sir... Only midcap and small cap stocks. No largecap, micro, sme or penny stocks..
@@vimaljoshi6512 that's great
SIP de registration data shows Indian growth dreams getting shattered. Next 2-3 years slow down unavoidable now.
Aligned to your rant :-)
Sir, disposable income will be left only after getting relief from the tax terrorism.
Fully agree with you
Sir, with due respect to you, India is going down hill with a terrifying momentum. Not just the stock market or the Rupee, but everywhere I see. Even the commercial disputes in Patiala House Courts are not being decided. Orders are not being passed unless you Grease the Judiciary.
Who in his right mind will invest in a Banana Republic like India.
We need a new FM and completely new GST council to begin with
Continuing sip.. Waiting for budget.. Probably fii comes back.. Then 27k by end of April 2025☺️
Fully agree sir
Fully agree with your sentiment. taxpayer has become a cash cow for this gov to fund freebies.
Freebies for mass, high taxation for working ones, with skyrocketing inflammation.
If govt keep giving cash to people, high inflation will be there.
For middle class, they got shock in Covid which burnt their savings, salary is stagnant for last few years, Rent has doubled in Tier 1, 2 cities. Food inflation is high.
Disposable income and Savings are falling rapidly.
Govt will give 500rs per month relief to middle class in budget and will expect turnaround in economy.
Year 2024 will be remembered for One of the worst FM in the history of India who just killed the golden goose.
we agree 100% sir . Tax Terrorism is what we are leading to
Undue taxation has dampened spirit of middle class to earn. Govt is motivating people to be poor and enjoy freebies.
Creation of entitlement class by doling out freebies
Trust me ltgc is bound to increase to 15% in march
I dont have hope in budget they won't all Forex trading also but they put many conditions on Indian market 😕
One year to be completed in the 3rd term of present govt. So in next 4 Yrs what will be done in which was not done in past 11 Yrs.... 🤔.
The investment opportunities in India has certainly taken a beating in view of the global situation. The stance of the present political dispensation is also not helping the stock markets. It appears the Govt is hell bent upon squeezing the tax payers and extending freebies to a majority of the population which is nothing but bribing them for votes. In fact the bribery is to be redefined since the Governments are directly involved in it. We have seen Governments fade away because of their lack of vision.
Just wait nifty going to fall more 10% from here , in 2-3 months
FII will again sell heavy when slightly upmove will be there .
High time the finance minister and the whole MoF bureaucracy is changed...
The rich people always want less tax, thats how income inequality will keep increasing. If anything, equity gains taxation should be same as that of salaried with maybe some discount.
Equity giana are same for lal
FM has lost the grip on the economy. No solution in place. Hope they hear the economists who have a vision.
pls discuss only popcorn - the most important thing in economy is popcorn
Sir now news is that they are going to cut income tax
Continuous tinkering with some type of tax or the other is ongoing. Beyond rates this itself is irritating.
Couldn't agree more
Need a new FM who is upto the JOB and dosen't just just go by BABU's advise on finance.......still could not understand what good done by removing indexation and bringing in Grand fathering clauses for every thing......
16 % not 60
Our dear PM is busy in making A1, A2 richer...and rest are busy in searching temples below mosques....who the hell is worried about economy......i dont own/ trade any shares - FM will say on budget day 😅
India share of global manufacturing exports 3%, while China 40%. Make in India, really?!
I think something is getting cooked inside. A big announcement is pending leading the market to new ATH.
Baki to FII DII ye baate chalti rehengi
Nothing will change in Taxation. FM will only tax more and more.
Nirmala Tai will take Capital gain tax on Loss in the Share market soon. Just wait and watch ...
Moneycontrol has started publishing article that upto 15 lk income.. Zero tax... 😅
do subscribe...this is also in your best interest😁😜
government comes on sreeram , then why they prioritize other thing , government is giving what people vote for
Is Nirmala watching this?
10 years of Big slogans, but no action to match by the Gov.
Hope India is not too late to leverage the demographic dividend.
❤
Ladli behan ke liye paisa kaise ayega fer 😂😂
And ladla bhai also.
This Government has lost direction. They know they will not get voted again.
Please send this video to Seetha Aunty & keep hoping she quits.
I think. Mother Taxesa is being arrogant now. When you listen too much to the babus and very little to the outside world you end up in this kind of a situation. You should balance views on both sides!