I commented this on the 2nd mov. video but thank you for the comprehensive and interesting viola part!! we appreciate that from modern composers so much
Incredible piece, love the harmonic evolution in each movement. Especially the second movement, wow - all those chromatic melodies that emerge and get passed around different instruments, overlaid over the piano chords. The cross-instrument phrasing marks are so cute, not sure how that would look in their parts, but it's a cool concept. Also really love the cadenzas in the outer movements!
Really well structured and that is very difficult for something this big so really my congratulation❤ its an impressive work. I would though love (and take it as a criticism but more of a personal struggle i am experiencing with my music too) to see more modern aspect. I am just know you can really do great stuff you just need a step further. Keep up the hard work❤ , and as a composer myself in love with late romantisim and impressionism, i can completely understand.
Actually, the original drafts of the third movement had a LOT of straight up atonal moments. There was also extended techniques and very complicated harmonies. I removed all of that because it was too advanced compared to the first movements. The result is very watered down music that I think is more romantic era than contemporary.
Me encanta que hayan compositores contemporáneos,que honran y crean musica,esa que está plena y exhuberante de melodía,y armonías agradables al oído,y rinden culto al puro arte de las sonoridades excelsas,cuando hay tanto masacrador de chirridos,y sonidos cacofónicos que se creen genios...
J'aime beaucoup les allusions que vous faîtes à des œuvres d'autres compositeurs tout en vous les appropriant. Il faut maintenant qu'un pianiste nous le joue avec orchestre ! Ce ne sera pas du gâteau pour lui, ce n'est pas de la fausse virtuosité comme on en voit parfois, c'est ici très difficile, tant techniquement qye musicalement. Bravo 🎉
@@majrn1000lol😂 hey is it possible for you to publish a piano only score for this concerto on musescore, I really want to see what exactly is the piano is doing.
@@majrn1000 I love it, too! Only that the first subject in the first movement of that piece feels as if Bortkiewicz had cut it off too abruptly. It should really goes on longer!
More Neo-romantic mush. When will people like you get out of your 1903 bubble, and realize that no one with any degree of respect or pedigree writes music like this? The effort you put in to this piece is commendable, and there was some moments that were genuinely beautiful. However, I hope that after this piece, you can escape from your nostalgic fantasies, and try writing something that has anything unique to say texturally and emotionally. You have potential, now do something about it!
To be honest I think this piece is much more basic than what I usually make (or even listen to). Even so, I don't write music for attention or "respect and pedigree." I don't care for modernity or uniqueness if I like what I'm putting out. I love Penderecki and Xenakis as much as Rachmaninoff and Feinberg. There's enough progressive composers out there, I will make music I want to make. I will have to be commissioned to make music of your satisfaction and not mine. I do appreciate your comment.
This is definitely one of the compositions of all time
bruh
It is... It is hard to describe,It absolute beauty.
Thank you so much!
I commented this on the 2nd mov. video but thank you for the comprehensive and interesting viola part!! we appreciate that from modern composers so much
Thank you! I wish I could use viola more but typical orchestral viola sections are quite small. The viola melody at 35:16 is my favorite ❤️
THIS 👏 DESERVES 👏 A 👏 LIVE 👏 PERFORMANCE
Thank you!!
This is amazing!
Thank you!
Incredible piece, love the harmonic evolution in each movement. Especially the second movement, wow - all those chromatic melodies that emerge and get passed around different instruments, overlaid over the piano chords. The cross-instrument phrasing marks are so cute, not sure how that would look in their parts, but it's a cool concept. Also really love the cadenzas in the outer movements!
@@symphwind Thank you so much!! ❤️❤️
I cannot believe what im hearing..... the fact that something like this is being composed in 2024....
@@aeroslothy not sure if this is a good thing but thank you anyway
@@majrn1000it’s amazing
Grand and exciting...with delicious echoes of Rautavaara....BRAVO MAESTRO....from Acapulco!
The piano makes great texture during the music, I love it!
wow this is one of the compositions I actually like
Great job bro!
woah :O
As a fellow composer I'm amazed
Thank you 😍❤️
masterpiece
Very interesting. Congratulations.
Really well structured and that is very difficult for something this big so really my congratulation❤ its an impressive work.
I would though love (and take it as a criticism but more of a personal struggle i am experiencing with my music too) to see more modern aspect.
I am just know you can really do great stuff you just need a step further. Keep up the hard work❤ , and as a composer myself in love with late romantisim and impressionism, i can completely understand.
Actually, the original drafts of the third movement had a LOT of straight up atonal moments. There was also extended techniques and very complicated harmonies. I removed all of that because it was too advanced compared to the first movements. The result is very watered down music that I think is more romantic era than contemporary.
Me encanta que hayan compositores contemporáneos,que honran y crean musica,esa que está plena y exhuberante de melodía,y armonías agradables al oído,y rinden culto al puro arte de las sonoridades excelsas,cuando hay tanto masacrador de chirridos,y sonidos cacofónicos que se creen genios...
It is fantastic!! 😍👏🏻👏🏻 I'm pianist and compouser too
J'aime beaucoup les allusions que vous faîtes à des œuvres d'autres compositeurs tout en vous les appropriant. Il faut maintenant qu'un pianiste nous le joue avec orchestre ! Ce ne sera pas du gâteau pour lui, ce n'est pas de la fausse virtuosité comme on en voit parfois, c'est ici très difficile, tant techniquement qye musicalement. Bravo 🎉
Thank you so much! ❤️❤️
Honestly the best piano concerto I’ve heard from a living composer
@@jerrysun2380 gonna make me cry fr 🥺
@@majrn1000lol😂 hey is it possible for you to publish a piano only score for this concerto on musescore, I really want to see what exactly is the piano is doing.
Can’t wait
nice
Which software do you use? As a fellow composer, I believe this is a very nice composition!
probably musescore
@@acusado8381 nice
do you put this pieces on any music platform like spotify?
One day maybe!
Instantly recognized Bortkiewicz 1 vibes at the beginning😜
One of my favorites of all time!
@@majrn1000 I love it, too!
Only that the first subject in the first movement of that piece feels as if Bortkiewicz had cut it off too abruptly. It should really goes on longer!
More Neo-romantic mush. When will people like you get out of your 1903 bubble, and realize that no one with any degree of respect or pedigree writes music like this? The effort you put in to this piece is commendable, and there was some moments that were genuinely beautiful. However, I hope that after this piece, you can escape from your nostalgic fantasies, and try writing something that has anything unique to say texturally and emotionally. You have potential, now do something about it!
To be honest I think this piece is much more basic than what I usually make (or even listen to). Even so, I don't write music for attention or "respect and pedigree." I don't care for modernity or uniqueness if I like what I'm putting out. I love Penderecki and Xenakis as much as Rachmaninoff and Feinberg. There's enough progressive composers out there, I will make music I want to make. I will have to be commissioned to make music of your satisfaction and not mine. I do appreciate your comment.
@@majrn1000 I totally respect that. Art is subjective, ignore my stupid comment. Enjoy making music, it’s fun!
Rachmaninoff