🚀12 Months of UPSC CSE Subscription for Just ₹29,999! 🚀 🔗 Subscribe Now: unacademy.com/goal/upsc-civil-services-examination-ias-preparation/KSCGY/subscribe?plan_type=plus&referral_code=worldaffairs
No under INC situations were much better,under Dr.Bidhan Chandra Roy(The best CM of WB till date) it was under congress,this CPIM and TMC ruined everything
@@promitray6921 I have this sense , you have this sense , infact a person who understands a bit of economics will have this sense. But alas most of the people of my state fail to realise it, they are happy by getting 500/- or 1000/- monthly.
In late 1960s Communists government forced Gujaratis to leave W Bengal. Took away their shops and houses. Made them refugees in their own country. They all were Bengali speaking! Many leftists! Most moved to Mumbai and Gujarat! Nehru congress, socialists had nothing to say!
It is so funny nowadays to see a bunch of gobar gaumutra tasters coming forward everyday and singing obituaries of West Bengal economy 😂😂😂....these pundits must see the status of their own economies first....in Gujarat when 50 jobs are announced 50000 people stand in line😅😅😅....in Delhi airport roofs come crashing down and minor rainfall causes waterlogging....I request these gaumutra experts to come to New town and Ecopark areas of Kolkata and see if WB is developing or not...the truth is that the BJPs gujju economic model is exposed today😂😂😂....investors are rushing to West Bengal for investment.... Bengalis have suffered in the last 20 years because of the gujju maru economic model....but now Gujju economy is suffering....Surat textile workers are running losses....West Bengal is rising🤘🤘🤘
@@Aditya88Chaturvedi Kolkataiyans are bengali hindus and there are many bengali hindus who are living in Bangladesh. Despite from the same society, the Kolkataiyans do not care about bangladeshi hindus, and this is shameful . This is the reason why bengal is poor .
@@MBNATH-oq6ifand.. What about bangladeshi ppl? Constantly poking Indians saying bad things in social media.. Other state of India doesn't know that only we know what kind of cheap mentality they are holding against Indians. How can you expect before talking nonsense take a look on your ppl. You started but we will finish for sure.. What was that slogan - jo jitna anti Indian wo utna Bangladeshi.. Apne bachho ko anti Indian banao.. 7 sis le lenge chicken neck le lenge wb k pp 3rd class h west Bengal ko azad karo.. Itna kuch bolne k Baad bhi tum bol rahe ho wb k ppl Bangladeshi k liye bolega wah bhai. Agar hindi me Bangladeshi log bolne lag jaye to baki Indians bhi bangladesh k liye chup ho jayega tum logo ka jo harkat h.
It is so difficult here in Bengal day by day it is becoming worse. There is no security no education, and no ample amount of medical facilities most of the village people are politically influenced and have no education therefore lots of educated families are planning to move out of Bengal "once the capital of India " It is so sad
I am Punjabi. Aksed my bengali friend why bengal is so poor. He said because we bengalis spend our money on education rather than investing in things like property etc as punjabis do. 🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡
@@debojyotighosh5423 at last stage. I think you don't know the case study. there are case studies about West Bengal politics(downfall). see those first..
Europe - Christians vs Muslims Israel - Jews vs Muslims Africa - Natives vs Muslims Russia - Russians vs Muslims China - Chinese vs Muslims India - Hindus vs Muslims Myanmar - Buddhists vs Muslims Pakistan - Muslims(Shia, Baloch) vs Muslims(Sunni) Turkey - Muslims(Kurds) vs Muslims(Sunni) Middle East - Muslims(Shia) vs Muslims(Sunni) Earth - Humans vs Muslims
@@malyajlikhar5605 Sandeshkhali bhool gaye kya? Bahut recent incident hai jisme mamata ke kareebi log shamil the.. RG Kar medical college ka kaand mein bhi mamata ke kareebi log the, isliye uss doctor ko bachaya jaa raha the...
Europe - Christians vs Muslims Israel - Jews vs Muslims Africa - Natives vs Muslims Russia - Russians vs Muslims China - Chinese vs Muslims India - Hindus vs Muslims Myanmar - Buddhists vs Muslims Pakistan - Muslims(Shia, Baloch) vs Muslims(Sunni) Turkey - Muslims(Kurds) vs Muslims(Sunni) Middle East - Muslims(Shia) vs Muslims(Sunni) Earth - Humans vs Muslims
They forced out TATA and now there is no major company. Only devlopment is in southern part North is neglected like a step child, No company no development.
@@Anushilan_Samiti2after the removal of cpim, govt did announce many SEZ's. Places around kolkata are being developed as SEZ's. 42 new companies signed MoU with bengal government in setting up their offices before 2026. Bengal government has already allocated land.
@@hiraksaha1386what's the point most of them lack practical knowledge because of which they end up becoming PhD scholars. Btw I am an IIT graduate myself.
Absolutely false remark.. Bengal always developed skilled intellectual and proficient English speaker. So check your facts before commenting. Bengal is incapacitated by dirty political game play but the talent pool is still way ahead in comparison to any other parts of state..
North Bengal should be bifurcated from south Bengal and it shoud be integrated with North Eastern council . So that North Bengal can get extra money from union for its development.
Central government should carve out Gorkhaland from Bengal, state government and their politics can't stray their focus away from the Kolkata Metropolitan.
@@suchetachakraborty5988 that's correct. North Bengal faces discriminations and negligences . There is a huge gap of economic disparity between North Bengal and south Bengal. We should raise our demand unitedly for the separation of North Bengal from south Bengal and make our North Bengal a fascinating tourist place
We are too much dependent on kolkata ,west bengal doesn't have any major cities than kolkata .. it is impossible to grow as a strong economy ,we should start from the bottom. All districts should be equally developed . But political leader ,only focus on corruption in rural areas
Bengali hindus do not care about their brothers,the bangladeshi Bengali hindus, then how can you say the political leaders are main problem? It is the people itself who are responsible
Ever since Bengal has a provincial festival, corruption, crime, helpless law and order And since rape was made the biggest celebration, Bengal has gone into the abyss.
This is a huge misconception that 1947 to 1977 was a golden period under Congress rule. Yes Kolkata was the number 1 city in terms of industries and trade through 1950s but that was all because of the growth and development of the British era but by 1960, through freight equalization and other policies central govt killed heavy industry here. And due to plastic's use , the jute industry died a natural death by 1960.Also Nehru refused to dredge , desilt and clean the Ganga which killed Calcutta port. By 1960, Kolkata was behind Bombay. The rest of Bengal anyway was going through terrible famines and year round floods throughout the Congress rule in the (state + centre).
Political parties didn't allow big industrialists to set up manufacturing plants in Bengal, citing Bengal is not for outsiders. Corruption is greatest factor of such a state of economy.
Some economic mistakes had happened. But I really wish bangal become a major economy of India. Bangal has been giving livelihood to many poor people and now it's time that the successor of those people honestly contribute in the revival of the state.
Apart from the undeniable damage done by these political parties, we Bengalis never ventured into business and entrepreneurship. That's why we don't own any business in our own state today. Its a heart wrenching situation. If we, the Bengalis of West Bengal start acting today, we may see an 'of the Bengalis, by the Bengalis and for the Bengalis' business monopoly in West Bengal after eight decades or so.
Literally Bengalis were never competent in business. The community which actually monopolised whole west Bengal or united Bengal were marwaris. In past it used to jagat seth during 70s soorajmal jalan during 90s birlas bagri binanis during 2000s Rama prasad goenka in 2020s it's benu Gopal bangur Ravi modi Sanjiv goenka Madan mohanka and radheshyam Agarwal. Do you think the so called liberal communi and hateful mindset will compete with these screwed marwari Banias who were there in west Bengal since from Thier rags to rich journey. Impossible
@RijanKhanal-jh6t The last sixty years didn't go as per the likings of many Bengalis, including me. But that doesn't mean that the next sixty years will follow suit in that direction. Changing the order of the day may be difficult but not impossible. Here goes a clarion call to all the Bengalis of West Bengal to commence business and entrepreneurship on a war footing. Let's all herald an 'of the Bengalis, by the Bengalis and for the Bengalis' business situation in West Bengal. It may take four to five decades or even more. But there'll be sunshine at the end of the long tunnel.
@@jitamanyughose535 it will be of the bangladeshi muslim by the bangladeshi muslim For the bangladeshi muslim. Not the bengalis. Noklah was wake up call blasphemy against sujoy mondol in comilia was another wake up in Bangladesh. Now imagine what happens these bangladeshi muslim will form majority in west bengal done by mumtaz begum
The decline of Bengal is often linked to the increase of the Muslim workforce in the unskilled sector. The predominance of Muslims in this labor segment has been a factor in altering the political dynamics of West Bengal. Kerala and Kashmir also have dominant Muslim workforce hence you can notice down fall in growth here. Iran, Pakistan, Bangladesh and Afghanistan have large-scale Muslim workforce in unskilled sector, results, all are going to bankrupt. Saudi and UAE has Hindu workforce.
Yes you are right . WB govt to illegally entered Bangladeshi & Rohingas Ko jaga dete hai vote loot karne ke liye aur wo log destroy kar rahe hai WB Ko.
Europe - Christians vs Muslims Israel - Jews vs Muslims Africa - Natives vs Muslims Russia - Russians vs Muslims China - Chinese vs Muslims India - Hindus vs Muslims Myanmar - Buddhists vs Muslims Pakistan - Muslims(Shia, Baloch) vs Muslims(Sunni) Turkey - Muslims(Kurds) vs Muslims(Sunni) Middle East - Muslims(Shia) vs Muslims(Sunni) Earth - Humans vs Muslims
Another important reason is creation of Bangladesh. 1971 more than 1 crore hindu refugees compelled to come to bengal to save their lives without bringing any resources. Bengal has not recovered from that economic pressure till date as no economic package given to those refugees by Central government.
West bengal ka bahut bura lagta mujhe, jabki ye India ka prominent state hai. Itne badi bangali language population hai per bangladesh cinema ka pata he nhi. Immediately sochna padega government ko espe. Aise India develop nhi ho paayega.
हिंदू नेतृत्व,हिंदू राजनीती दल, हिंदू धार्मिक संस्था ,ट्रस्ट,धार्मिक गुरू इन्को हिंदू धर्म का प्रचार एवं प्रसार के बारे मे सोचना चाहिए...धर्म का simple न pure form हो जो बाकी धर्म के लोगो को आकृष्ट करे... भारतीय मुस्लिम को हिंदू बनने के बारे मे कूच action plan होन चाहिए
Europe - Christians vs Muslims Israel - Jews vs Muslims Africa - Natives vs Muslims Russia - Russians vs Muslims China - Chinese vs Muslims India - Hindus vs Muslims Myanmar - Buddhists vs Muslims Pakistan - Muslims(Shia, Baloch) vs Muslims(Sunni) Turkey - Muslims(Kurds) vs Muslims(Sunni) Middle East - Muslims(Shia) vs Muslims(Sunni) Earth - Humans vs Muslims
Kindly prepare one video of How the economy of Darjeeling District can grow? Why do hills people have to leave their home district for jobs and education? I shall be very grateful to you. Jai Hind
Freebies... Laxmi bhandar... This things are more important than education... Industry... All world is fool our west bangal is the best... No can blame our honorable cm . Joy bangla.
The thumbnail is significant. These two persons are single handedly responsible for the destruction of once flourished West Bengal. The sad part of the story is that they not only destroyed the economic progression of bengal but also bereft Bengal of her supremacy in cultural and intellectual sphere.
Europe - Christians vs Muslims Israel - Jews vs Muslims Africa - Natives vs Muslims Russia - Russians vs Muslims China - Chinese vs Muslims India - Hindus vs Muslims Myanmar - Buddhists vs Muslims Pakistan - Muslims(Shia, Baloch) vs Muslims(Sunni) Turkey - Muslims(Kurds) vs Muslims(Sunni) Middle East - Muslims(Shia) vs Muslims(Sunni) Earth - Humans vs Muslims
For today's situation only people of Bengal are responsible. Except for Dr Bidhan Ch Roy every CM in Bengal worked for either party or family interest. Party not allowing Lste Jyoti Basu to become PM of India in mid nineties was blessing in disguise. Imagine of the situation ehat would have happened to Indis then!
Jyoti Basu was Deng Xiaoping of West Bengal that he once transformed his State into one of richest & economic hub state of India until Mamata Banerjee ruined it after came to power 13 years ago
It was Congress that industrialized Bengal before CPM under Jyoti Basu stalled all development. Buddhodeb tried to revive industries in Bengal but did not succeed much. Mamata is a disaster for Bengal
Auuu Bengol ab Kangladesh ka dusra bhag ban raha hai Kangladeshi illegally andar reh rahe hai.. Ya mahare kuch political labh ke liye unko waha basa rahe hai..
TMC and JIHADIS are destroying WB. These TMC politicians have made WB a Jihadi Bangladesh state.What is RGKAR status? Bengali Hindus and others with INDIA please rise against this stupidity 🇮🇳👍🏻 else reap what you sow.Bengali brothers and sisters rise up for this in accordance and show your strength 🙏
Europe - Christians vs Muslims Israel - Jews vs Muslims Africa - Natives vs Muslims Russia - Russians vs Muslims China - Chinese vs Muslims India - Hindus vs Muslims Myanmar - Buddhists vs Muslims Pakistan - Muslims(Shia, Baloch) vs Muslims(Sunni) Turkey - Muslims(Kurds) vs Muslims(Sunni) Middle East - Muslims(Shia) vs Muslims(Sunni) Earth - Humans vs Muslims
🚀12 Months of UPSC CSE Subscription for Just ₹29,999! 🚀
🔗 Subscribe Now: unacademy.com/goal/upsc-civil-services-examination-ias-preparation/KSCGY/subscribe?plan_type=plus&referral_code=worldaffairs
Can you make a video about how Kashmir Sabotaged its prosperity with all of their fanatical religious stupidity/slavery....
Demographic change is also a big reason...
No 1. These are Allah provide people! Not at all interested in study,industry, civic sense! Loonghiwala!
Na ,, communist ko vote dena pap hai
plus congress ideology is also biggest issue and people is the main reason voted for radical communist govt
No bengali like you and your family voting TMC is the only reason😝😝😝😝😝😝😝
Hm Bangladesh, Bihar, Nepal , Jharkhand aur Eastern UP, sabne milkar Bangal ki demography ki dhajjiya uda di
Reason is very clear CPIM, TMC, INC & K2A specially Rohingyas
Bangladeshi
Right 👍
Also people who voted them to power
No under INC situations were much better,under Dr.Bidhan Chandra Roy(The best CM of WB till date) it was under congress,this CPIM and TMC ruined everything
Reason is only one - bengalis. 😂😂
It's very hard for me as a Bengali, as a boy from Bengal to see this vid. Each n every words are piercing through my heart....
Same, Poor Bengal. Amader Bangal ke Kharab rajneeti khokla kore diyeche
@@promitray6921 I have this sense , you have this sense , infact a person who understands a bit of economics will have this sense. But alas most of the people of my state fail to realise it, they are happy by getting 500/- or 1000/- monthly.
@@debasishdas8134 Alas we are ruled by the people of 50's 60's we need someone from our generation to rule us atleast
@RamkrushnaBag-g8v lol😂😂
But still, you and your family will vote for TMC 😝😝😝😝😝😝😝
5500 cr for madrasa education in WB......................🤣🤣
its only for TMC vote bank.. 😑
It's for tmc vote bank
Kichu bolar nai Bhai 😢,
5530 cr 😢😢😢
Bhoka log khud downfall kra rhe he dd dd bol ke😂
Islamikaran of Bengal is main cause
Islams other countries main bhi hai...but India main rehne wale muslim development se jyada majhab pe dhyan dete hai
@@pktech818 Bangladesh, Bihar, Up and Nepal also responsible for it
@@BajrayoginiUpadhay97 I don't think UP and Bihar has anything to do with it... Bangladesh yesss
@@magnificent_123Muslims are foolish they are voting for TMC due to some unknown fear 😂
@@gpatfwo log h hi nahi Indian.. Most of them are kanglu. Abhi bhi log nahi samjhe na to bhai smjh lo
As long as TMC is in power, West Bengal's condition will never improve.
Mamta Banerjee is curse for Bengal 😢
WB gsdp growth rate is projected to be 10.6% in 24-25
@@the_.shahil haha.. katuwa predicted it ya?
Bilkul sahi baat
Chased off Ratan Tata n their projects ,to come to power.n citizens supported her.
Atleast the women get 1000 rupees and free rice to vote for TMC. Hope they can live like queens in that amount.
In late 1960s Communists government forced Gujaratis to leave W Bengal. Took away their shops and houses. Made them refugees in their own country. They all were Bengali speaking! Many leftists! Most moved to Mumbai and Gujarat! Nehru congress, socialists had nothing to say!
Gujarati and Marwadi both…. We always forget that marwadi are always present in all indian states for small businesses with Gujaratis
They forced TATA too.. karma
@@DailyHacksAlpha Tumhari Karma tumko Mubarak😆
It is so funny nowadays to see a bunch of gobar gaumutra tasters coming forward everyday and singing obituaries of West Bengal economy 😂😂😂....these pundits must see the status of their own economies first....in Gujarat when 50 jobs are announced 50000 people stand in line😅😅😅....in Delhi airport roofs come crashing down and minor rainfall causes waterlogging....I request these gaumutra experts to come to New town and Ecopark areas of Kolkata and see if WB is developing or not...the truth is that the BJPs gujju economic model is exposed today😂😂😂....investors are rushing to West Bengal for investment.... Bengalis have suffered in the last 20 years because of the gujju maru economic model....but now Gujju economy is suffering....Surat textile workers are running losses....West Bengal is rising🤘🤘🤘
@@BajrayoginiUpadhay97 kkangluzze 😁 lunggi rikshah
Bengali leader before 1947 🗿 after 1947 🤡
Pakistan banane ki bajah se hua tha
All eyes on Bangladeshi minorities (Hindus, Buddhist & other minorities communities)
Kolkata er kono Banda kaneo dhykay na ei sob khobor
@@MBNATH-oq6if mujhe samajh nahin aya ki aph kya kah rahe hain.
@@Aditya88Chaturvedi Kolkataiyans are bengali hindus and there are many bengali hindus who are living in Bangladesh. Despite from the same society, the Kolkataiyans do not care about bangladeshi hindus, and this is shameful . This is the reason why bengal is poor .
@@MBNATH-oq6ifand.. What about bangladeshi ppl? Constantly poking Indians saying bad things in social media.. Other state of India doesn't know that only we know what kind of cheap mentality they are holding against Indians. How can you expect before talking nonsense take a look on your ppl. You started but we will finish for sure.. What was that slogan - jo jitna anti Indian wo utna Bangladeshi.. Apne bachho ko anti Indian banao.. 7 sis le lenge chicken neck le lenge wb k pp 3rd class h west Bengal ko azad karo.. Itna kuch bolne k Baad bhi tum bol rahe ho wb k ppl Bangladeshi k liye bolega wah bhai. Agar hindi me Bangladeshi log bolne lag jaye to baki Indians bhi bangladesh k liye chup ho jayega tum logo ka jo harkat h.
@@MBNATH-oq6if bhul kotha, amra Kolkata r manusrai UNA te kotha tulchi Bangladeshi hindu bhi der jonno.
TMCP destroy west bengal 😢
Bengal was the richest state of subcontinent when it was independent 😊😊
@@NazmulAlam-of9dj Holding onto past glory is what messed up WB.
@@NazmulAlam-of9djsorry kanglu, we dont care bout you
@@NazmulAlam-of9djfirst look at the mirror
TMC n CPM.both dnt blame only TMC ,CPM too responsible , basically Bengali are leftist minded ppl
বাংলা পুরোপুরি শেষ করে দিল বামফ্রন্ট এবং তৃনমূল মিলে😢😢😢😢
বিজেপি 'একটু একটু শুরু' করবে ?🤣🤣
@@atheistbanerjee008 এটা তো জানা কথা আজ যে বামফ্রন্ট কাল সে তৃনমূল পরশু সেই বিজেপি,,,,
বামফ্রন্ট ৩৫ বছরে যে ক্ষতি করেছিল, তার থেকে বেশি ক্ষতি তৃণমূল এই ১৭ বছরে করেছে। 😢
@@atheistbanerjee008choti chete churir takai apnar songsar chole se ta sobaike bola ta ki khub dorkar ache??😂😂😂
@@atheistbanerjee008yes because your didi can't do anything
It's the people of Bengal who brought this condition on to them because they elected their rulers.
Hath to Central Government ka bhi hai Bangal ko pichhe dhakel ne mai
@@BajrayoginiUpadhay97don’t blame others for everything . Blame yourself for the fall of WB
@@BajrayoginiUpadhay97 har chiz me tume central dikhta he 😂.. kitne andhe ho tum
It's their so called bengali pride which doomed them
Things that ruined bengal
1) Communism
2) Bangladeshis/muslims
3) TMC
ममता इस्तीफा दो।ममता को बर्खास्त करो, ममता का बहिष्कार करो, ममता की तानाशाही बंद करो। बहुत हो गया,
RSS Andhbhakti will revive Bengal ? 🤣🤣
@@sambak4173 Tab toh Yogi ji usse bade tanashah hai. 😆😆😆😆😆
Brahman abar atheist 🥴🥴🥴@@atheistbanerjee008
Bengali communist 😂@@atheistbanerjee008
It is so difficult here in Bengal day by day it is becoming worse. There is no security no education, and no ample amount of medical facilities most of the village people are politically influenced and have no education therefore lots of educated families are planning to move out of Bengal "once the capital of India " It is so sad
Oh really
@@BajrayoginiUpadhay97don’t you know?
Bengal is Doomed
Correct. Almost every private and government hospitals in Cuttack and Bhubaneswar are flooded with bengali speaking patients.
@biswajitbehera7977 I thinks it's good for Odisha's economy. Is it not Mr Behera😆 Nahi shayad apke state ke 50% GDP gayab ho jayenge .....
communism and sanctimonious nature of Bengolis.
Yes it is true.
Main reason is, 35% vote share of the Criminal Community. State can't progress with 35% of Criminals vote, never ever 🙏.
I am Punjabi. Aksed my bengali friend why bengal is so poor. He said because we bengalis spend our money on education rather than investing in things like property etc as punjabis do.
🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡
fantasy world.
Fir bhi achchha hai dusre state ke tarah awaz toh dabayi nahi jati na.
Thankgod you are back sir, where were you, I was so worried.
I am from West Bengal. This happened because cpm(communism) & now tmc(tola baaz, gunda raj).
Wasn't Mr Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee trying to bring TATA in West Bengal for Nano car factory?
@@debojyotighosh5423 at last stage. I think you don't know the case study. there are case studies about West Bengal politics(downfall). see those first..
@@debojyotighosh5423true he was the second best CM of wb. But he couldn't control the goon culture
Shashank sir, मैं तो स्टूडेंट भी नहीं हूँ, लेकिन आपके सारे वीडियो बहुत पसंद हैं। प्लीज वीडियो बनाना बंद मत करना, ये ज्ञान बहुत अच्छे हैं
डरो मत नही करेंगे रोजी रोटी का सवाल हैं। वैसे मैं भी विद्यार्थी नही हूं पर ज्ञान और संज्ञान पाने के लिए इधर आ जाता हूं। बहुत बढ़िया काम करते हैं सर।
@@Vinvonerfan Itana gyan dete hai ki mere dimag se ab gyan ki nadiya behne lagi hai, Aur mere ghar mai gyan ki flood (barh) aa chuki hai 🥹🥹🥹
😮😮😮😮😮जबसे प बंगाल का मुल्लीकरण हुआ तब से तबाह हो गया😮😮😮😮😮
Ye log apne sath curse leke ghumte hai..
@@DailyHacksAlpha Bhai wahi toh seekh leni hai tumko Gujarat se. Remember 2002 💥🔥
Europe - Christians vs Muslims
Israel - Jews vs Muslims
Africa - Natives vs Muslims
Russia - Russians vs Muslims
China - Chinese vs Muslims
India - Hindus vs Muslims
Myanmar - Buddhists vs Muslims
Pakistan - Muslims(Shia, Baloch) vs Muslims(Sunni)
Turkey - Muslims(Kurds) vs Muslims(Sunni)
Middle East - Muslims(Shia) vs Muslims(Sunni)
Earth - Humans vs Muslims
Bengal ke loge ayiyash bhi hote hain, mehnat karne se ya sangharsh se durte hain, daru, cigrette, dance ,chhokri ki taref jaldi bhagte hain.
@@malyajlikhar5605
Sandeshkhali bhool gaye kya? Bahut recent incident hai jisme mamata ke kareebi log shamil the..
RG Kar medical college ka kaand mein bhi mamata ke kareebi log the, isliye uss doctor ko bachaya jaa raha the...
Surpanakha ki Lanka jal rahi hai
🤔🤔
😂
Badhiya reply
@@vijaysinghchandel5450 Jaise Madhya Pradesh ke Hari zameen ko woha ki sarkar aur industrialist milkar ujra chaman banzar bana rahe hai 😆😆😆😆
Mainly Communism and then appeasmet politics
muslims vote for RELIGION ,Mamta is master of RELIGION POLITICS
Europe - Christians vs Muslims
Israel - Jews vs Muslims
Africa - Natives vs Muslims
Russia - Russians vs Muslims
China - Chinese vs Muslims
India - Hindus vs Muslims
Myanmar - Buddhists vs Muslims
Pakistan - Muslims(Shia, Baloch) vs Muslims(Sunni)
Turkey - Muslims(Kurds) vs Muslims(Sunni)
Middle East - Muslims(Shia) vs Muslims(Sunni)
Earth - Humans vs Muslims
Answer is Mamta Banerjee.. and majorly voters..
Also Central Government ka dogla vyavahar Bangal ke prati bhi jimmedar hai.
Bengal was gone before TMC. TMC made it worse
Amra Bengali apna bura bhalla sochne mein asmarth hain.
Since last 50 years Bengal has seen great political leaders in the art of winning elections after elections at the cost of development and neglect
Well said
They forced out TATA and now there is no major company. Only devlopment is in southern part North is neglected like a step child, No company no development.
No development in southern part. Just kolkata is getting developed due to private efforts. Government literally did nothing.
@@Anushilan_Samiti2after the removal of cpim, govt did announce many SEZ's. Places around kolkata are being developed as SEZ's. 42 new companies signed MoU with bengal government in setting up their offices before 2026. Bengal government has already allocated land.
Bengalis of Kolkata will say the data is wrong. They are too proud of themselves to admit they can go wrong.
Absolutely.
The best reason.
Bengali people did very bad with Aditya Birla in 1990s this was biggest reason to downfall of kolkatta stock exchange hardly people talk about it.
Scam toh Gujarat walo ne ki thi, Isme Bangal ki kya dosh hai
Demographic change is also a big reason
Bengal Will Rise Again, They Must Rise Again ❤ Bengal need Reforms to be a part of Better India
For that Mamta must go. Else it will be another afghanistan.
It will rise but it's too late ...50 years pichhe chala gya
Haha.. 100 saal aur lelo..
@@nilaydutta335 Aage aayega ek din
People of West Bengal first need to elect a right government
Bengali students now lack English proficiency. Well educated Mukharjee Banerji Chetarjis are mostly come from other states!
Jaise baki state ke 90% population RP accent mai baat karte hai!
@@BajrayoginiUpadhay97 👍
English is just a language brother. If you see the IITs or IIMs, 40% students are bangali.
@@hiraksaha1386what's the point most of them lack practical knowledge because of which they end up becoming PhD scholars. Btw I am an IIT graduate myself.
Absolutely false remark.. Bengal always developed skilled intellectual and proficient English speaker. So check your facts before commenting.
Bengal is incapacitated by dirty political game play but the talent pool is still way ahead in comparison to any other parts of state..
North Bengal should be bifurcated from south Bengal and it shoud be integrated with North Eastern council . So that North Bengal can get extra money from union for its development.
Central government should carve out Gorkhaland from Bengal, state government and their politics can't stray their focus away from the Kolkata Metropolitan.
Is reason se toh Pehle Gujarat, Maharashtra, Rajasthan aur Up Bihar ka batwara hona chahiye
@@BajrayoginiUpadhay97 parliament can do that all at the same time.
WB govt Ko pata hi nehi hai ki north Bengal mei bhi log rehte hai kuch infrastructure chahiye. Sift ghumne ki time pe yaad aata hai north Bengal ka
@@suchetachakraborty5988 that's correct. North Bengal faces discriminations and negligences . There is a huge gap of economic disparity between North Bengal and south Bengal. We should raise our demand unitedly for the separation of North Bengal from south Bengal and make our North Bengal a fascinating tourist place
We are too much dependent on kolkata ,west bengal doesn't have any major cities than kolkata .. it is impossible to grow as a strong economy ,we should start from the bottom. All districts should be equally developed . But political leader ,only focus on corruption in rural areas
Most of the Indian state dependent on their Capital.
@@BajrayoginiUpadhay97 No actually!
Our political leaders are main culprits for the current situation. In Bengal politics are main industry. So don't expect industry.
Bengali hindus do not care about their brothers,the bangladeshi Bengali hindus, then how can you say the political leaders are main problem? It is the people itself who are responsible
We bengali destroyed WB . Only we are to be blamed not any party because party comes and goes but people remain. Hope that sink in.
Ever since Bengal has a provincial festival, corruption, crime, helpless law and order
And since rape was made the biggest celebration, Bengal has gone into the abyss.
This is a huge misconception that 1947 to 1977 was a golden period under Congress rule. Yes Kolkata was the number 1 city in terms of industries and trade through 1950s but that was all because of the growth and development of the British era but by 1960, through freight equalization and other policies central govt killed heavy industry here. And due to plastic's use , the jute industry died a natural death by 1960.Also Nehru refused to dredge , desilt and clean the Ganga which killed Calcutta port. By 1960, Kolkata was behind Bombay. The rest of Bengal anyway was going through terrible famines and year round floods throughout the Congress rule in the (state + centre).
Political parties didn't allow big industrialists to set up manufacturing plants in Bengal, citing Bengal is not for outsiders. Corruption is greatest factor of such a state of economy.
Some economic mistakes had happened. But I really wish bangal become a major economy of India. Bangal has been giving livelihood to many poor people and now it's time that the successor of those people honestly contribute in the revival of the state.
Its really heart breaking for us! Our neighborhood are not like wealthy or progressive anymore!
Sad to be a Bengalis 🥺
Apart from the undeniable damage done by these political parties, we Bengalis never ventured into business and entrepreneurship. That's why we don't own any business in our own state today. Its a heart wrenching situation.
If we, the Bengalis of West Bengal start acting today, we may see an 'of the Bengalis, by the Bengalis and for the Bengalis' business monopoly in West Bengal after eight decades or so.
Literally Bengalis were never competent in business. The community which actually monopolised whole west Bengal or united Bengal were marwaris. In past it used to jagat seth during 70s soorajmal jalan during 90s birlas bagri binanis during 2000s Rama prasad goenka in 2020s it's benu Gopal bangur Ravi modi Sanjiv goenka Madan mohanka and radheshyam Agarwal. Do you think the so called liberal communi and hateful mindset will compete with these screwed marwari Banias who were there in west Bengal since from Thier rags to rich journey. Impossible
@RijanKhanal-jh6t The last sixty years didn't go as per the likings of many Bengalis, including me. But that doesn't mean that the next sixty years will follow suit in that direction. Changing the order of the day may be difficult but not impossible. Here goes a clarion call to all the Bengalis of West Bengal to commence business and entrepreneurship on a war footing. Let's all herald an 'of the Bengalis, by the Bengalis and for the Bengalis' business situation in West Bengal. It may take four to five decades or even more. But there'll be sunshine at the end of the long tunnel.
@@jitamanyughose535 it will be of the bangladeshi muslim by the bangladeshi muslim For the bangladeshi muslim. Not the bengalis. Noklah was wake up call blasphemy against sujoy mondol in comilia was another wake up in Bangladesh. Now imagine what happens these bangladeshi muslim will form majority in west bengal done by mumtaz begum
Its very simple - Cheap politics has destroyed Bengal😢
The decline of Bengal is often linked to the increase of the Muslim workforce in the unskilled sector. The predominance of Muslims in this labor segment has been a factor in altering the political dynamics of West Bengal. Kerala and Kashmir also have dominant Muslim workforce hence you can notice down fall in growth here. Iran, Pakistan, Bangladesh and Afghanistan have large-scale Muslim workforce in unskilled sector, results, all are going to bankrupt. Saudi and UAE has Hindu workforce.
Yes you are right . WB govt to illegally entered Bangladeshi & Rohingas Ko jaga dete hai vote loot karne ke liye aur wo log destroy kar rahe hai WB Ko.
Europe - Christians vs Muslims
Israel - Jews vs Muslims
Africa - Natives vs Muslims
Russia - Russians vs Muslims
China - Chinese vs Muslims
India - Hindus vs Muslims
Myanmar - Buddhists vs Muslims
Pakistan - Muslims(Shia, Baloch) vs Muslims(Sunni)
Turkey - Muslims(Kurds) vs Muslims(Sunni)
Middle East - Muslims(Shia) vs Muslims(Sunni)
Earth - Humans vs Muslims
Bengal in deeper problems as of today. You have explained it very well.
Thank you sir 😊 Bengali or west bengal ke leke time or video bana ne keliye ❤
Another important reason is creation of Bangladesh. 1971 more than 1 crore hindu refugees compelled to come to bengal to save their lives without bringing any resources. Bengal has not recovered from that economic pressure till date as no economic package given to those refugees by Central government.
Ai industry kno ase ni service sector growth hoi ni kno
Mamata begum is the main problem of WB
Politics of appeasement is also a major factor which diverts the mindset from growth
Problem happened due to labour strikes.... Not favouring industrialists.... Best example is TATA
Bidhanchandra Roy was the last good chief minister of west bengal.
TMCP Destroy our Bengal 😔😔😔
CHUP LAAL PARTYR MAAL
Maharashtra always rock 🎉🎉 wven after 5 year of unstable government Maharashtra still on top but now Maharashtra also need stable government 😊😊
The leader that you vote and bring to power plays crucial role so vote with responsibility
Politics, Politicians and the People who Voted for them. 👍
Beautiful insight and analysis. Not sure who worked on the content and script. Well done. I am happy that it was aligned with economics and timeline
The wrong that went was mamata banarjee and her TMC
Aay Gaya Political Burbak
@@joydebsinghasarkar5768if it's not politics then what? Can you explain
Good analysis and extremely educative!
West bengal ka bahut bura lagta mujhe, jabki ye India ka prominent state hai. Itne badi bangali language population hai per bangladesh cinema ka pata he nhi. Immediately sochna padega government ko espe. Aise India develop nhi ho paayega.
काफी अच्छी तरह से व्याख्या किया आपने
Thank you Sir
Im from odisha 😢 its sad reality
Odisha 🗿🥰🛕🚩🕉🇮🇳✅
Don't say, "what destroyed Bengal's economy." Ask "WHO destroyed Bengal's economy".
हिंदू नेतृत्व,हिंदू राजनीती दल, हिंदू धार्मिक संस्था ,ट्रस्ट,धार्मिक गुरू इन्को हिंदू धर्म का प्रचार एवं प्रसार के बारे मे सोचना चाहिए...धर्म का simple न pure form हो जो बाकी धर्म के लोगो को आकृष्ट करे... भारतीय मुस्लिम को हिंदू बनने के बारे मे कूच action plan होन चाहिए
Uske liye pese bhi lagte hai aur temple ke saate pese to government le leti hai na
Europe - Christians vs Muslims
Israel - Jews vs Muslims
Africa - Natives vs Muslims
Russia - Russians vs Muslims
China - Chinese vs Muslims
India - Hindus vs Muslims
Myanmar - Buddhists vs Muslims
Pakistan - Muslims(Shia, Baloch) vs Muslims(Sunni)
Turkey - Muslims(Kurds) vs Muslims(Sunni)
Middle East - Muslims(Shia) vs Muslims(Sunni)
Earth - Humans vs Muslims
Very interesting. But demographic change needs to considered as well
Goa ka mazagon? Mazagon is in Mumbai. The goa one is called GSL
This is partially true , there is no talk about Central government negligence. All successive government has decreased investment in Bengal
Your Mamta Banerjee rejects most of the scheme and development introduced by Centre 😂😂
Best example is AB-PMJAY
Lalu destroy bihar and didi destroy bengol both are my mother land😢😢
But odisha poor state to rich state🗿 🛕🇮🇳🚩🥰✅
Bahut acha aur informative presentation
vote for next video on kerala economic situation
Kindly prepare one video of How the economy of Darjeeling District can grow? Why do hills people have to leave their home district for jobs and education? I shall be very grateful to you. Jai Hind
Freebies... Laxmi bhandar... This things are more important than education... Industry... All world is fool our west bangal is the best... No can blame our honorable cm . Joy bangla.
VERY INFORMATIVE , TOUCHED SOME REALISTIC ASPECTS
The literacy rate has gone down due to leftist policy and present day govt
The thumbnail is significant. These two persons are single handedly responsible for the destruction of once flourished West Bengal. The sad part of the story is that they not only destroyed the economic progression of bengal but also bereft Bengal of her supremacy in cultural and intellectual sphere.
CPIM, TMCP destroyed West Bengal.
1:06 mazgaon shipbuilding is in Mumbai not in goa.
Avi tak eye nahi khula. Laxmi vandar 2000 kar diya
Mamta ko bahut soch samajh kar hamara bangal ko age le ja sakta hai
You're absolutely right
😂 Mamta Raando ne Bangal ko Bhikaristan bana diya hain 😂😂❤❤
Great report ❤
TMC and CPM destroy bengal
Jyoti Basu great leader of all time ❤
Muslim population increases progress declined 😢😢😢
👍🏻
Totally agree 👌👌
😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Europe - Christians vs Muslims
Israel - Jews vs Muslims
Africa - Natives vs Muslims
Russia - Russians vs Muslims
China - Chinese vs Muslims
India - Hindus vs Muslims
Myanmar - Buddhists vs Muslims
Pakistan - Muslims(Shia, Baloch) vs Muslims(Sunni)
Turkey - Muslims(Kurds) vs Muslims(Sunni)
Middle East - Muslims(Shia) vs Muslims(Sunni)
Earth - Humans vs Muslims
For today's situation only people of Bengal are responsible.
Except for Dr Bidhan Ch Roy every CM in Bengal worked for either party or family interest.
Party not allowing Lste Jyoti Basu to become PM of India in mid nineties was blessing in disguise. Imagine of the situation ehat would have happened to Indis then!
Jyoti Basu was Deng Xiaoping of West Bengal that he once transformed his State into one of richest & economic hub state of India until Mamata Banerjee ruined it after came to power 13 years ago
Exactly 😢😢 but not a single Bengali will understand that 😢
It was Congress that industrialized Bengal before CPM under Jyoti Basu stalled all development. Buddhodeb tried to revive industries in Bengal but did not succeed much. Mamata is a disaster for Bengal
He was the one who started ruining Western Bengal. Killing of upper cast people and anti communist people were starting of ruining of Western Bengal
No not at all. Leftists and TMC destroyed Bengal.
During communist regime wb started to decline ...read data then comment
Prior 1947 mirzafars were loyal to East India Company , today's mirzafars are loyal to IMF , WEF and UN
Bangal se thank you
Excellent analysis
Mamata begum destroyer of WB
Bengal is ruined only for the culprit Mamta bannerjee.
Auuu Bengol ab Kangladesh ka dusra bhag ban raha hai Kangladeshi illegally andar reh rahe hai.. Ya mahare kuch political labh ke liye unko waha basa rahe hai..
Tumhare sapno Mai.
Richest state before and after Independence 🇮🇳
Was the golden state of India 🇮🇳
Bad politics 😞
❤ Beautiful work.
TMC and JIHADIS are destroying WB. These TMC politicians have made WB a Jihadi Bangladesh state.What is RGKAR status? Bengali Hindus and others with INDIA please rise against this stupidity 🇮🇳👍🏻 else reap what you sow.Bengali brothers and sisters rise up for this in accordance and show your strength 🙏
Europe - Christians vs Muslims
Israel - Jews vs Muslims
Africa - Natives vs Muslims
Russia - Russians vs Muslims
China - Chinese vs Muslims
India - Hindus vs Muslims
Myanmar - Buddhists vs Muslims
Pakistan - Muslims(Shia, Baloch) vs Muslims(Sunni)
Turkey - Muslims(Kurds) vs Muslims(Sunni)
Middle East - Muslims(Shia) vs Muslims(Sunni)
Earth - Humans vs Muslims
W. Bengal CM is happy with the economic disaster in the state. It suits her voters.ßs
Bengali ❌ kangali ✔️
This is sad.. BD ki bimari WB ko bhi lagg gyi..
2 paise mile tumko
बिलकुल बंगाली लोग खुद जिम्मेदार हैं इसके लिए
Bisu or Bimaru! 😂
Bangal has becom Kangal..
Very much good explanation. But is it goes to the heads to our political leaders of West Bengal.??
Thnx for sharing ❤🎉