MYSTERY MONDAY Lizzie Borden: Guilty or Innocent? Part One

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 дек 2024

Комментарии •

  • @StephanieHarlowe
    @StephanieHarlowe  5 лет назад +584

    Guys I am going to be replying to your comments soon, I am just editing Part 2 so it's up by tomorrow!

    • @themoon-iy1kg
      @themoon-iy1kg 5 лет назад +18

      Stephanie Harlowe thanks for all your hard work ♥️

    • @jessicacorradini7644
      @jessicacorradini7644 5 лет назад +9

      woohoo! you keep me company during my days of university thesis work :) looking forward to watching part 2!

    • @eileenherkenham7775
      @eileenherkenham7775 5 лет назад +5

      You literally are the best!!!! I love history and true crime so them combined has me hooked!! I’ve always been so curious in this case. I was so so excited when I saw his was the video for today yayyyyy😘😘🤓

    • @MyvaniaTasram
      @MyvaniaTasram 5 лет назад +1

      Thank you so much❣️

    • @inannanightingale9718
      @inannanightingale9718 5 лет назад +8

      Amazing, I've heard a lot about Lizzy Borden before but never such an indepth look at the story. Poor Abby, I feel so bad for her. There's something kind of funny about you mysteriously changing clothes with a secret story behind it, and then going on to talk about Lizzy mysteriously changing her clothes haha

  • @sunburst3076
    @sunburst3076 5 лет назад +1388

    We don’t deserve you - I have never liked true crime videos where it’s a RUclipsr talking to the camera most of the time and actively avoid those thumbnails and videos. However - the amount of time, research, and detail you craft into every video makes me feel as if I’m stepping into the skins of the people involved in these stories. I can see everything so clearly! Thank you for all that you do!

    • @NANOUWITZify
      @NANOUWITZify 5 лет назад +44

      I agree, Stephanie's research is carried out with scrupulous attention to detail, I just enjoy listening and watching her videos.

    • @marylesueur868
      @marylesueur868 5 лет назад +11

      Totally agree!

    • @irenerodriguez3304
      @irenerodriguez3304 5 лет назад +29

      I agree her strory telling skills are unmatched from what i have seen. She really takes you to that place and paints a clear picture

    • @StephanieHarlowe
      @StephanieHarlowe  5 лет назад +52

      Aww thank you!!! The thumbnails are basically there just to catch attention, and some of the videos that have eye catching thumbs are more than click bait! I appreciate you being here!

    • @TracvM320
      @TracvM320 5 лет назад +22

      SUNBURST I love you said we don’t deserve her❤️people tend to forget how hard this stuff is- if anyone just clicks around, they can see tons of people attempting to do what comes naturally to Stephanie/ she’s personable- back in the day when there were true reporters- Stephanie could have been an anchorwoman on any news channel- she’s beautiful, and so engaging. I can’t believe I just found her channel

  • @criticalthot
    @criticalthot 2 года назад +98

    Fun fact, Lizzie was the second weird murder situation in her family tree. In 1673 one of her ancestors named Rebecca Cornell was found burned to death in her room, while her son and his family were allegedly downstairs. Eventually the son, Thomas, was found guilty of murder, mostly bc of the spectral evidence provided by Rebecca’s brother. Very weird, interesting case that helped shape Rhode Island law.

  • @beckieross9122
    @beckieross9122 5 лет назад +585

    OJ and Casey Anthony were found innocent too 🤷🏽‍♀️

    • @NageelaMom
      @NageelaMom 5 лет назад +48

      Found not guilty. That's not the same as innocent

    • @beckieross9122
      @beckieross9122 5 лет назад +5

      Same thing, they weren’t found guilty, so people obviously think they are innocent

    • @andreaturnquist4855
      @andreaturnquist4855 5 лет назад +10

      Actually not guilty. Innocent is not the same legally.

    • @andreaturnquist4855
      @andreaturnquist4855 5 лет назад

      @bonniewcarlson Agree.

    • @AdjustedCrown
      @AdjustedCrown 5 лет назад +4

      oJ is innocent, not his son though

  • @PixenBit
    @PixenBit 5 лет назад +283

    I love the parts where you forget to jump cut (or maybe you leave it in on purpose) and you're just sitting there reading your notes. Makes it feel like I'm sitting across from you and you're reading a story! 😂🥰

    • @amyy801
      @amyy801 3 года назад +4

      Haha I know right!

    • @moongds8269
      @moongds8269 3 года назад +51

      I though she was getting emotional. About to cry. But I read these comments to see about that.

    • @sugaroxo
      @sugaroxo 3 года назад +4

      @@moongds8269 I thought that too

    • @acatnamedjimmy8060
      @acatnamedjimmy8060 2 года назад +1

      I really like that too!

    • @opeltheartist
      @opeltheartist 11 месяцев назад +1

      I had to turn my phone screen on and see if she was pullin funny faces 😂😂😂

  • @KendallGreenEl
    @KendallGreenEl 5 лет назад +359

    lol, you're right women were always feeling faint or fainting in old stories. Maybe because of all of the undergarments and corsets? I tried to wear two layers of spanxx once and it was a really bad idea

    • @glitterlover3244
      @glitterlover3244 5 лет назад +38

      Kendall G yea, back then they even had a fainting room. Women had ro wear like 3-4 things under to ‘be respected’. And our corests now are so much different. We are more fitted, and not trying to force having a small waist, where as they had been trying to look smaller, and some were made of whale ribs. Its actually where the first viberator was made, a doctor made it to ‘relax’ his paitence in the fainting room. Im so happy we can just wear a tee shirt and some shorts.

    • @glitterlover3244
      @glitterlover3244 5 лет назад +31

      DismalTrix I dont blame them, hell they didnt think we could feel anything during sex. Might as well use those.

    • @grimtheghastly8878
      @grimtheghastly8878 5 лет назад +47

      By all historical accounts, corsets weren't that bad actually. Most women didn't wear them that tight since the boning would naturally shape the silhouette so there was no need to pull it tight.

    • @HelloMyNameIsAlli
      @HelloMyNameIsAlli 5 лет назад +4

      😂 amen!! I did that once at a wedding; could barely eat a thing

    • @AhNee
      @AhNee 5 лет назад +12

      @@glitterlover3244 "Whale bone" corsets weren't made with whale bones, let alone ribs. They were made with baleen, which the whales use to strain out krill and other edibles.

  • @betterwiththeirish
    @betterwiththeirish 5 лет назад +726

    I will say Lizzie correcting police on Abby not being her mother doesn’t seem out of the ordinary to me. I have a horrible stepmother and it triggers me when people call her my mother

    • @StephanieHarlowe
      @StephanieHarlowe  5 лет назад +82

      Better With The Irish if she was just murdered though!!? 😂 girl, you’re savage 😘

    • @aellabdevill
      @aellabdevill 5 лет назад +114

      I agree with you on this one. My father died when I was 8 and a half years old and I have the most wonderful stepfather. We get along reall well and since he's been my stepfather for over 20 years now, he has been longer in my life than my dad. But I call him by his name and I make it clear he is my stepfather if people get it wrong. It has nothing to do with how I feel about him (because I love him very much), but I feel it's disrespectful to my father to call anyone else "father". I do feel that my stepfather has always been like a father to me and he does feel like a father, but I remember my dad and I want to keep the title "father" as his, if that makes sense :)

    • @TimeForChange55585
      @TimeForChange55585 5 лет назад +56

      Better With The Irish, I completely agree with you!! I was only 5 when Mom died. My sister was only 9 months old. Dad claims he went into a deep depression that lasted 30 years, yeah right. He remarried when I was 7. She was the most vile person. My sis and I were subjected to physical, emotional and verbal abuse. I remember being beat with the heel of her high heels once because I refused to call her mom. Keep in mind that her 2 kids were treated very well.
      Happy ending when his mom and dad took us with them. Praise God they did!

    • @neuralmute
      @neuralmute 5 лет назад +58

      For what it's worth, a shitty bio-parent sometimes doesn't deserve the name either. If my abusive "father" were murdered tomorrow I'd still refer to him as The Sperm Donor, and I'd be breaking out the champagne because the world was less one vile, woman-abusing predator. My step-dad's been a far better parent than that creature ever was. Blood isn't always thicker than bullshit.

    • @maggiekarabel123
      @maggiekarabel123 5 лет назад +17

      neuralmute This is very true. My husband doesn’t speak to his mother because she’s an abusive, mentally unstable alcoholic. As far as we’re concerned, his stepmom is my real mother-in-law and my daughter’s real grandmother. She doesn’t even care enough about her only grandchild to try and mend fences.

  • @kittywolford7768
    @kittywolford7768 5 лет назад +719

    When I was young my Nanna did ancestry and found out I was related to Lizzie Borden on my mothers side. Now me and my boyfriend joke around about keeping hatchets away from me. Lol

    • @StephanieHarlowe
      @StephanieHarlowe  5 лет назад +95

      Ooooh, how are you related to her? That is so interesting!

    • @Brea890
      @Brea890 5 лет назад +8

      That is AWESOME

    • @MiguelMaxMusic
      @MiguelMaxMusic 5 лет назад +4

      Thats pretty cool

    • @giabarrone7422
      @giabarrone7422 5 лет назад +8

      I knew some Bordens in a city about 15-20 min away from Fall River, but I never thought to ask if they were related.......

    • @nataliereb4902
      @nataliereb4902 5 лет назад +44

      Ha, wow...I am related to her too, so does that mean you and I are related to each other?
      Oh, and the movie made in the '70s about Lizzie Borden starring Elizabeth Montgomery (really good
      movie btw) : after Ms. Montgomery passed away, it was discovered that she was actually related to Lizzie Borden. Sidenote: Elizabeth Montgomery started in the very popular TV series "Bewitched".

  • @kelly19364
    @kelly19364 5 лет назад +115

    My wife and I listened to this case a bunch of times with various RUclipsrs. Your video included a lot of details neither of us had heard before. Great job. Eagerly waiting for part 2

  • @Howl_atTheMoon
    @Howl_atTheMoon Год назад +18

    I love coming back to these older videos. Stephanie, you continue to be an amazing creator. I will always recommend your channel to anyone who loves history/crime. Your level of research and ethics is unparalleled. Love you girl!

  • @womensarmycorpsveteran2904
    @womensarmycorpsveteran2904 3 года назад +38

    My mom cured me of shoplifting at an early age. I had stolen a packet of lifesavers candy and when my mom found out, she marched my little butt right back to the store and made me go to the shop owner and apologise and pay for what I had stolen. I thought I was gonna die of shame and enbarassment.

    • @comet1227
      @comet1227 3 года назад +1

      Mine was chapstick. Took a week. I was bawling and snotty they couldn't understand and thought I was eating it😂

  • @LittleRecordGirl
    @LittleRecordGirl 5 лет назад +892

    "Rosie, you're drinking incredibly loudly."
    *Me watching this video, drinking my green tea.*
    WELL I NEVER
    (My name is Rosalie/Rose/Rosie. Just realised it doesn't show up... haha)

  • @maggiebonnet7695
    @maggiebonnet7695 5 лет назад +192

    I was born and raised in Fall River, right down the street from Lizzie Borden's house. I remember when I was in high school, we had a mock trial of this case in our law class, and because I was so adamant she was guilty, I got to be her defense attorney. As I researched the case, I don't believe she did it, but I believe she knows who did. I am so glad you decided to choose this case!

    • @nesadcruz7840
      @nesadcruz7840 5 лет назад +4

      catadhernandez her Uncle perhaps? Or could she have had help? Either from her Uncle or Bridget

    • @maggiebonnet7695
      @maggiebonnet7695 5 лет назад +28

      I don't want to ruin anything if it's mentioned in Part 2, but Lizzie and Emma had a half-brother who Andrew had written out of the will - someone who would be angry enough to murder if Lizzie might have offered part of the inheritance....

    • @ericaallen3540
      @ericaallen3540 5 лет назад +6

      I don't understand why the maid ( Bridget ) isn't looked at more..

    • @TheSpasticAvenger
      @TheSpasticAvenger 5 лет назад +4

      @Lily Slipcast She stood to inherit NOTHING. Their father hadn't provided for them, if Andrew had died first everything would have gone to Abbie's family.

    • @otma2011
      @otma2011 5 лет назад +6

      There was absolutely no evidence that anyone else did it...

  • @frondsbenefits
    @frondsbenefits 5 лет назад +354

    That 1 dislike is Lizzie Borden

  • @SugaStarr
    @SugaStarr 5 лет назад +39

    My boyfriend and I have been to the house numerous times as it’s just a few minutes from us in Fall River. The house itself is demonic. It has such a heavy, ominous feel (especially in the attic.) The land and the home have a lot of dark history prior to the deaths at the Borden home. If you’re ever in the area it’s worth stopping by, the tour guides are so dedicated to their job. And if you have the time and money you can spend the night since it’s a bed and breakfast. The owners of the home have worked hard to keep the house looking almost identical to when the murders took place.

  • @quesarahsarah5026
    @quesarahsarah5026 5 лет назад +34

    Another thought: marriages of convenience rather than love were so common back then. Andrew probably remarried simply to have someone to take care of the children and home. I'm sure Abbie was part of that decision making process.
    My great grandmother passed away giving birth to my grandfather and his twin brother on a ship in the middle of the Atlantic. My great grandfather married her sister after they got to the U.S. because he knew he couldn't take care of his boys by himself. She took good care of the family and homestead, but it was common knowledge that their relationship was a business relationship rather than romantic.

  • @watchinvidzwatchinvidz7691
    @watchinvidzwatchinvidz7691 5 лет назад +325

    You remind me of Velma in the Scooby - Doo movie, she's always solving mysteries. Just like you.💕

    • @carsoncrouch7895
      @carsoncrouch7895 5 лет назад +7

      thatbeingsaid thatbeingsaid never knew it was spelled like that! Always just thought it was Velma😂

    • @DR053
      @DR053 5 лет назад +3

      Carson Crouch You’re right, it’s Velma lol

    • @HippieNikkiTheTopeteTribe
      @HippieNikkiTheTopeteTribe 5 лет назад +1

      thatbeingsaid thatbeingsaid 😂🥰

    • @watchinvidzwatchinvidz7691
      @watchinvidzwatchinvidz7691 5 лет назад +7

      @@carsoncrouch7895 whatever or however it's spelled I'm not in a spelling bee. Lol 🤓😌

    • @serenanorris6129
      @serenanorris6129 4 года назад +1

      WOW never thought of it, but your right.

  • @crochetomania
    @crochetomania 5 лет назад +182

    I think sleeping with dead bodies in the house would not shock them in those days in the way it shocks us now. I think it was common to leave a dead person in the house till funeral. I might be wrong though. Same about sleeping in a bed that belonged to a dead couple. People used to inherit beds, so a few generations would be born and would die in the same bed.

    • @Meredith471
      @Meredith471 5 лет назад +34

      Yes, you are correct. The bodies would be placed in the casket in the sitting room and visitors would come to pay their respects. Typically, in many families, someone would sit with the body throughout the night and pray. The body was never "left alone" up until the time of the funeral. Some counties/towns still allow this practice, especially if the burial will take place in the family cemetery (typically farms or places in the country).

    • @NageelaMom
      @NageelaMom 5 лет назад +9

      @@Meredith471 Jewish practice is still to never leave the body alone. But not in the home

    • @EGMADH
      @EGMADH 5 лет назад +1

      MK Lonestar Handcrafted in my country we still have this costume.

    • @Meredith471
      @Meredith471 5 лет назад +18

      @@NageelaMom yes, my father stayed with the body of his friend for the night until the funeral the next day. My cousin is a mortician and makes certain that anytime he has a Jewish client, there is always someone available to remain with the family overnight until the funeral the next day (he also does not charge them extra for this service. My father made sure my cousin understood this custom since my father's friend had been a Rabbi and even though we are Christian we respect and recognize the Jewish customs and holidays).

    • @Meredith471
      @Meredith471 5 лет назад +5

      @@EGMADH I think it is a great tradition. I wish more countries would follow this custom.

  • @SarahBarah.99
    @SarahBarah.99 5 лет назад +193

    I know this is a little different than your normal murder mysteries, but have you ever thought about covering Bonnie and Clyde ?? I LOVE all things historical as well, and just would love to hear your take and perspective on a case like that! ❤

    • @carsoncrouch7895
      @carsoncrouch7895 5 лет назад +11

      YES!!

    • @StephanieHarlowe
      @StephanieHarlowe  5 лет назад +41

      I love the Bonnie and Clyde story!

    • @SuzieQuzie0773
      @SuzieQuzie0773 5 лет назад +12

      Not sure for how long but at one point my grand father drove for them...well so he told me lol

    • @boomersoonerbaby3466
      @boomersoonerbaby3466 5 лет назад +15

      Clyde Barrow was a cousin of my grandmas lol. It’s interesting to see information about him in our family book.

    • @LupieHousewife
      @LupieHousewife 5 лет назад +1

      OMG Yes!!!

  • @victoriadiesattheend.8478
    @victoriadiesattheend.8478 3 года назад +24

    I personally subscribe to the theory that Lizzie's sister, Emma, is the killer. Her whereabouts on the morning of the murders (supposedly visiting friends) was never officially verified beyond her friends saying she stayed there. She had cause to want Abby & her father dead. She also had cause to need them to die in the very order they did, even if just by a few minutes. Had Andrew died first, his estate would have passed to Abby and that possibility might actually have entitled her family (that slightly impoverished sister you mentioned) to some money, as her beneficiaries. In order for that not to even be a possibility, she had to pre decease him, which she did. Later in life, Emma was known to keep an axe in a glass case, by a staircase, with a light always shining on it. "One night," she told the maiden sisters she lived with as an elderly woman, "they will come for me." Who could she have been referring to?

    • @cassielong6617
      @cassielong6617 2 года назад +1

      If you read how Lizzie was treated you can see how that can cause Lizzie to act out, she wasn’t favored in the family because her father didn’t really treat her right I kinda wonder why mr Borden didn’t treat her nicely and love her like he should’ve like why did Lizzie get left out of things? There’s a reason why but I don’t know what it could be

    • @javiermori1710
      @javiermori1710 Год назад +2

      So the friends she visited were in on it? Knew Emma killed them? Idk bout that. Many theories. Emma did it,the maid and Abby,the uncle,Lizzy herself. The less ppl know the better.

    • @TammyM36
      @TammyM36 Год назад +5

      Yeah im not buying that. She had a pretty good alibi. Lizzie has virtually none and had access to both murder victims at time of crimes and so much contradictory answers she gave in testimonies. Lizzie did it

  • @cadydenning-kras2907
    @cadydenning-kras2907 5 лет назад +29

    I thought I’d be bored of this story bc I’ve heard it a thousand times. But you reminded me how fascinating this case is!!! And how thorough you were!! Good job!!

  • @kaylalovescoffee
    @kaylalovescoffee 5 лет назад +851

    LO L at the comment about being women being the weaker sex. Have people who actually think that ever seen a man with a common cold???? 😂

    • @teralla9973
      @teralla9973 5 лет назад +93

      kaylalovescoffee tell me about it 😂
      It’s like they are almost at heavens door .

    • @jasonmack2569
      @jasonmack2569 5 лет назад +82

      I'm a man and even I know this to be true LOL.

    • @neuralmute
      @neuralmute 5 лет назад +82

      I worked in a piercing and tattoo shop for a while when I was in school, and I have the (informal and observational) goods. Dudes act more macho and some girls will show more fear, but overall women complain less and guys whine more. FACTS.

    • @CCMaya-ze3sj
      @CCMaya-ze3sj 5 лет назад +4

      Preach!

    • @karenmccann8644
      @karenmccann8644 5 лет назад +3

      @kaylalovescoffee Yeah I know really!.😂😂

  • @chloer1310
    @chloer1310 5 лет назад +181

    Even if I’ve heard a case a million times before I still can’t wait to hear you talk about it! Love you, girl 🤩

    • @kimballlynn2123
      @kimballlynn2123 5 лет назад +3

      So true. Stephanie always adds in a lot of information that other people don't put into their videos. The people become very humanized.

    • @krystaj944
      @krystaj944 5 лет назад

      Chloe Rhodes same here!

    • @sarahtelford9601
      @sarahtelford9601 4 года назад

      Yes omg

  • @KR-ue1gd
    @KR-ue1gd 5 лет назад +168

    Re: the mysterious behavior of Lizzie in the cellar, I can see one way it could be benign. Playing the devil's advocate: what if she DIDN'T kill her dad and stepmom, and the stuff in the toilet bucket downstairs WAS menstrual rags? How embarrassing for a woman of any time, but perhaps especially of that time, to know that her dirty private things were lying around for a bunch of strange men to see! If I'm having my period and forget to flush the toilet, I'm horrified to think of housemates of guests seeing it. And people in shock DO have a tendency to obsess about the mundane, as a kind of anchor. So if she were innocent, she could have been humiliated by this literal dirty laundry lying around, and she wouldn't want anyone else but her to take care of it.
    For the record, I don't think she was innocent, but I wouldn't want people to assume that her behavior in that one instance was sure proof of guilt, since I could easily imagine any woman, innocent or guilty, behaving the same.

    • @valpars
      @valpars 4 года назад

      Yo fiatsdgg hitdwj

    • @angiebear8727
      @angiebear8727 4 года назад +15

      Good point. Never thought of that but it does make sense from a woman’s perspective; which men, especially at that time, wouldn’t have considered.

    • @TheT151
      @TheT151 4 года назад +4

      @@angiebear8727 Me being a woman if I'm on my period I don't wear light blue or pink for fears of a accident and Lizzie used rags I just wouldn't take that chance and I don't think she would either.

    • @angiebear8727
      @angiebear8727 4 года назад +11

      @@TheT151 I get what you are saying and yup I do the same. No light colors on my bottom half for about a week a month, lol, but can’t speak for every woman.

    • @TheT151
      @TheT151 4 года назад +1

      @@angiebear8727 I hear you but this was Victorian time a blood stain would have been like a knife to the throat no pun intended 😉

  • @jasminetravisreyes9603
    @jasminetravisreyes9603 4 года назад +138

    “Lizzie Borden would never have killed her stepmother’s cat. She liked animals more than humans, which I can relate to some days.” 🐈🤎🐕 SAAAAME 👌🏻

    • @courtneymidyett9451
      @courtneymidyett9451 3 года назад +11

      Animals are amazing and a gift. They only know unconditional love. Yes they are better than some humans

    • @queenlk198
      @queenlk198 3 года назад +2

      Yeah I agree that’s a bit far fetched she loves animals

    • @jennyclark6183
      @jennyclark6183 3 года назад +1

      Lizzie made have hated cats because she was a bird lover and knew that cats kill birds. Yes, she loved dogs and birds but the stories about her killing cats could be true. A lot of people who love dogs hate cats.

    • @roccocatalano1773
      @roccocatalano1773 3 года назад +2

      Animals are pure & innocent, they do nothing with willful intent to harm innocence w. Premeditation , the only monsters that exist are HUMAN

    • @jennyclark6183
      @jennyclark6183 3 года назад +1

      @@roccocatalano1773 That is correct.

  • @elisamastromarino7123
    @elisamastromarino7123 5 лет назад +72

    Greed is the number one reason for murder. Lizzie did it. After dear old dad died she lived out her life in one of those houses on the hill that she coveted so much. She tried to set the stage for murder with all the stomach problems. Yes she was close to her dad but it's estimated that 1 in 11 of us are sociopathic. If she wanted it bad enough, I can see her doing it no problem.
    In the end, it's like Jack The Ripper - we'll never really know. But I strongly believe Lizzie did it. If not her, then who? She and Emma were never really that close anymore because of Lizzie's spending habits with Arthur's money.

    • @johndoe-wv3nu
      @johndoe-wv3nu 4 года назад +3

      Who's Arther?
      No, Lizzie had no motive.

    • @victoriadiesattheend.8478
      @victoriadiesattheend.8478 3 года назад +8

      Emma and Lizzie do not fall out over her spending habits until much later in life.

    • @julianakleijn9254
      @julianakleijn9254 3 года назад

      I really dont think I blame her

    • @Galen-864
      @Galen-864 3 года назад +3

      Greed, yes, Lizzie, no. The uncle did it, maybe with her help.

  • @Natasha_-_
    @Natasha_-_ 5 лет назад +66

    😂 That part with Rosie drinking water is priceless! I laughed out loud! Then you just see her pop up in the background with her cute little self 😂❤

    • @4usprosperity
      @4usprosperity 2 года назад

      H H H best buy for a new place to work with you and I miss u too much so I can get you to find out what

  • @TheChihuahuaLady
    @TheChihuahuaLady 5 лет назад +138

    When Stephanie drops a new vid.........The world comes to halt, gotta sit down with a cuppa tea, and enjoy.

    • @jamiewarren1222
      @jamiewarren1222 4 года назад +1

      Expecially while I am watching this March 23rd 2020. The world IS AT A STANDSTILL

  • @valtoton2982
    @valtoton2982 5 лет назад +30

    It doesn't matter how much I think I know about the content..Nobody tells it like you do! I appreciate the details and the hard work that you put into our stories.
    Also love how your family life gets peppered into the videos...btw your hair looks amazing today

    • @StephanieHarlowe
      @StephanieHarlowe  5 лет назад +4

      Aww thank you! I thought my hair was being very uncooperative, lol

  • @aprilwycherley
    @aprilwycherley 3 года назад +4

    Speaking as someone with hydrocephalus, who had it brought on as a result of having had a brain tumor, and having scar tissue building up in my brain, I hate hearing about any child dealing with hydrocephalus!!! I haven’t had a headache-free day in what will be 10 years in November, and I have a shunt, which helps with the pressure. I can’t imagine what that poor baby went through, most likely without a shunt!

  • @margiejcupcakeprincess4711
    @margiejcupcakeprincess4711 4 года назад +38

    The shoplifting triggered a memory, I was about 8 years old and took a pack of Hostess cupcakes from the corner store, my mum found out WELL LET ME TELL YOU she didn’t pay for them she took me to the store and I had to confess to the owner and pay for them. I never took anything again, I’m 70 years old and still never took anything

    • @karentucker2161
      @karentucker2161 2 года назад +2

      That's how my mom is..she is definitely old school. She would make me do the same thing your mom made you do. She is close to your age...just 3 years younger.

    • @laurenturner3578
      @laurenturner3578 Год назад +3

      My mom did something similar, though in my case I took pieces of pretty cloth from a quilt store. I'm only forty, but I am very careful to this day to even avoid LOOKING like I might be taking something!😊

    • @thesincitymama
      @thesincitymama Год назад +2

      I have the same story from when I was four but I stole pretty buttons

    • @TheBerkeleyBeauty
      @TheBerkeleyBeauty Год назад +1

      Similar. I took a pack of gum. My gramma found out and took me back to the corner store to confess. She didn’t pay for it, and since I was only 8 and obviously had no money, the store owner had me sweep the back room for and hour to pay my debt. My gramma taught me a valuable lesson on the way home. She told me that when you take something that doesn’t belong to you, it doesn’t make it yours, it just makes it stolen. And for as long as you have it, it will never be yours. It will never be ANYTHING but stolen. 56 and I still think about that.

  • @jasonmack2569
    @jasonmack2569 5 лет назад +114

    Fun fact regarding the maids name. It was very common in the Victorian Era for the lady of the house to rename the maid. Either because like Stephanie said she could not be bothered to learn a new name; or because she thought the maid's given name was not appropriate for a domestic to have. For example if you had the given name of Margot, your employer may have thought that sounded "too French" and would have called you Maggie. Margot would just have had to put up with it if she wanted to keep her job.

    • @walruslatte6080
      @walruslatte6080 4 года назад +20

      I also thought it might have been some kind of slight against her being Irish as there was still prejudice toward the Irish at the time. Sort of like if they had a black servant, calling him Toby or something. The Borden sisters seemed like they'd be into bitchy jokes.

    • @hdtwal1den
      @hdtwal1den 4 года назад +24

      "Maggie" was a frequent generic nickname given to female Irish servants particularly in the Boston area. People frequently referred to their Irish servant girls as "our Maggie."

    • @jasonmack2569
      @jasonmack2569 4 года назад +8

      ​@@walruslatte6080 Then says,"we have Irish friends. Why some are even Protestant."

    • @walruslatte6080
      @walruslatte6080 4 года назад

      @@jasonmack2569 😂 Exactly

    • @lexiwexiwoo
      @lexiwexiwoo 4 года назад +7

      It's little facts like these that make you wonder how we ended up with the society we know today and it's just never going to stop amazing me to find these little tidbits about what craziness people endured. I wonder what the version of our time's weird quirks.

  • @eliapace6810
    @eliapace6810 5 лет назад +21

    I'm walking to school while listening to this. It's great how you can learn things even when you aren't in history class. Thank you, Stephanie. 😊

  • @reneenayfabnaynay5679
    @reneenayfabnaynay5679 5 лет назад +90

    Stephanie, I agree with you that Lizzie was probably just setting the stage, with her eerie feelings about something happening to her father. However, some people do have premonitions and feelings about things. My late sister Pam was like that.
    Back in the early 80s she lived next door to a married couple. One night, in the middle of the night the police came knocking, waking her and her family up, wanting to know if they'd heard anything, because the man next door had just murdered his wife with what they thought was an axe! They found out later that it was actually the claw end of a hammer. My sister told the cops that this must be why she'd had such bad forebodings all day. But, none of them, her and her family, had heard anything.
    The officer mentioned they hadn't been able to find the weapon. My sister asked him, "Don't they have a refrigerator in their garage?" When told they did, my sister said for them to look in or around the refrigerator. She just had a "feeling" that that's where he'd hide it. Guess where they found it??? The garage had a drop ceiling, where the ceiling is a bunch of squares, that you can push on and they open up and you can see inside, above the ceiling.
    Anyway, the square, right above the fridge had the hammer sitting on the inside of it! My mom warned my sister to stop talking to them or they might think she was involved! Lol! Of course, she wasn't! That was just Pam! She was eleven years older than me, and I was always more worried about not being able to fool her than ever I was of my mother! Lol! It was like having two moms!
    Sorry for the rant, but I thought you might enjoy that story! Great vid, BTW!

  • @davidrice7969
    @davidrice7969 5 лет назад +30

    I would love to hear more historical cases. They're always so more mysterious.

    • @4usprosperity
      @4usprosperity 2 года назад

      You ko love to see how you love love and care and you

  • @ladyjaysindeore1113
    @ladyjaysindeore1113 5 лет назад +52

    That jump-rope rhyme was a song the local children used to sing to taunt Lizzie. My great-grandmother was one of those children.

    • @4usprosperity
      @4usprosperity 2 года назад

      T T to the world of America to the world of the world is not a good idea for a good idea for a good idea 😀😊😉🙂I know how to get the best deal 😉😀❤😊and I will see 😉😀

    • @PattyMarshall-l8v
      @PattyMarshall-l8v 9 месяцев назад +2

      I remember jumping rope to the Lizzie rhyme in 1st grade (1964).

  • @frondsbenefits
    @frondsbenefits 5 лет назад +19

    This is gripping, hate to have to pause this to go out!
    P.S. Hope everything is okay, saw your message at 26 minutes in and I'm sending love and best wishes xo

  • @thepeopleslast2579
    @thepeopleslast2579 5 лет назад +263

    The struggle of being early is the lack of comments lol

  • @Heath450
    @Heath450 5 лет назад +61

    This is so weird. Another case that is literally 15mins away from where I live. I have always been so fascinated with this case. I have gone on the tour they turned the house into. Super interesting. What a great case.

    • @Heath450
      @Heath450 5 лет назад

      @@kaytee4262 I live 15 minutes from Fallriver so I would say about 1hr to Boston.

    • @Heath450
      @Heath450 5 лет назад

      @@kaytee4262 sorry just realized I repeated myself about the 15mins

    • @Heath450
      @Heath450 5 лет назад

      I loved that series. I was bummed out when it ended. I know it seemed far fetched a bit but I think Christina Ricci did a great job.

    • @KarensKorner
      @KarensKorner 5 лет назад +3

      Hey, I live close by fall river too. I went on a ghost hunt and sleepover at the Lizzie Bordon B&B

    • @Heath450
      @Heath450 5 лет назад +2

      @@KarensKorner You are much braver than me. Lol... I would be so scared to sleep there.

  • @tammyblack2747
    @tammyblack2747 5 лет назад +8

    What preceded Lizzie not calling Abby mother any more was Andrew let some relative of Abby's live in a house he owned. He apparently would not let his daughters do that. When he allowed that, was when Lizzie stopped calling Abby "Mother."

  • @JenniferMcMahonhawaii78
    @JenniferMcMahonhawaii78 4 года назад +27

    Police:: ”Miss. Borden, what’s your alibi?...”
    Lizzie:: “Eating pears and looking for lead in a barn.”

    • @anthonymartino9917
      @anthonymartino9917 3 года назад +4

      The thing that keeps coming back to me is how did she have ZERO blood on her? think about these murders and HOW MUCH blood will go like hell everywhere!

    • @despinacharalambous1728
      @despinacharalambous1728 3 года назад +1

      @@anthonymartino9917 maybe she had someone do it for her.

  • @marah6755
    @marah6755 5 лет назад +21

    I cut away from a video I was in the middle of watching to get over here and check this out! Out of everyone I watch you are the one I look forward most to getting the new video notification. And since I’ve seen so many renditions if the story about Lizzie already, that’s saying something. I really can’t wait to see your take on it!

    • @marah6755
      @marah6755 5 лет назад +2

      Also, the way you speak is seriously so relaxing. If I wasn’t so interested in hearing what you have to say I could fall asleep to your vids.

    • @StephanieHarlowe
      @StephanieHarlowe  5 лет назад +2

      Did you like it?

    • @marah6755
      @marah6755 5 лет назад +3

      @@StephanieHarlowe I really did. One of the biggest reasons I enjoy your videos is that you put so much more detail in them. I feel like I'm back in time when I listen to period pieces from you. It's plainly obvious how much effort and work you put into these videos, with the details and facts. And they also have your own distinct flair to them, with your characteristics and comments. I'm so excited to see Part 2! As always, thank you for all of your hard work! You are the absolute best

  • @celestenevermissashot8883
    @celestenevermissashot8883 5 лет назад +16

    Omg I just love you dude. You do so well. I would never be able to research all of this interesting stuff with my current situation and lack of concentration. I love that you cover basically ALL of the lil thangs people don't think matter. You keep me updated to boot.

    • @StephanieHarlowe
      @StephanieHarlowe  5 лет назад +5

      I often suffer from a lack of concentration, I feel ya

  • @courtneylovesmaccompact9047
    @courtneylovesmaccompact9047 5 лет назад +78

    I can see her killing the step moms cat to hurt her. Not bc she wanted to kill a cat but bc she didnt want the mom to have something she loved

    • @StephanieHarlowe
      @StephanieHarlowe  5 лет назад +3

      courtneylove's MACcompact a very good point!

    • @nataliereb4902
      @nataliereb4902 5 лет назад +7

      Fortunately there is the thought that she didn't kill a cat. And she left her money to a humane society, I think it was the American Humane Society but I am not sure if that's the one.

    • @ScarletImp
      @ScarletImp 4 года назад +10

      @@nataliereb4902 Yeah, I don't think she would've killed the cat for any reason She had other ways of hurting Abby (other than axe to head, of course) if she really wanted to cause the woman pain. Animal lovers just don't go, 'I love all animals, but you, cat who is loved by someone I hate, I'm putting your furry ass in the ground.'

    • @nataliereb4902
      @nataliereb4902 4 года назад +9

      @@ScarletImp tragically, some sick POS's have done detestable things to animals to "get back" at humans. But then, as you implied, they probably weren't animal lovers to begin with.

    • @johndoe-wv3nu
      @johndoe-wv3nu 4 года назад

      @@nataliereb4902 Fall River Animal Rescue League.

  • @kkheflin3
    @kkheflin3 5 лет назад +1

    Stephanie....your voice is so soothing to listen to! The upside is when I put one of your episodes on at night and lie down to listen to your great episodes I enjoy it so much! The downside is I almost always fall asleep listening because of your voice! So I have to finish the episode in the morning! Fascinating case. I'm a history teacher and this story has always interested me. Thanks for your great research as always!!!

  • @Joslinemk171
    @Joslinemk171 3 года назад +1

    What I love most about Stephanie and this channel is no matter how many times I hear about a case or watch a documentary about one of these cases, I can watch you go through it and its like I hear it all for the first time! The details, the work and time you put into these is amazing. So happy I found this channel! I guess the best thing about finding it so late is I can now binge all these one after the other without waiting! Thank you for being amazing and sharing all of this with us ! 🧡🧡🧡

  • @elmoiswatchingyou
    @elmoiswatchingyou 5 лет назад +30

    Quick note on Ring Around the Rosie, or Ring-a Ring-o Roses, it's not about the Great Plague. The theory was put out there in the mid-20th century that it was about the Great Plague of London in the 1660's, but folklore experts have found it to be baseless because it doesn't describe the symptoms of the plague and they've classified it as an urban legend. Like, the line about "they all fall down" the theory states is they all die, but experts say that would have been in reference to curtsying or bowing as part of the dance kids do with it. No need to fear, it's not about death. They think it's just an old silly rhyme that has changed a lot over time, since the tune was first documented in the 18th century and the closest thing to the rhyme we know wasn't penned until a century later. Even then, the rhyme has changed a lot since that first semi-recognizable rhyme.

    • @StephanieHarlowe
      @StephanieHarlowe  5 лет назад +5

      good to know!

    • @t.l.1610
      @t.l.1610 5 лет назад +13

      elmoiswatchingyou
      See, I’ve heard differently. I took a course which touched largely on flower/herb medicinal uses and lore. We were taught the “Ring around the roses” part was in reference to the flowers and herbs they would pile on/around plague victims, also how they were burned in big piles in the street in hard hit areas (“ashes, ashes”) - both bc of smell but also bc they believed it purified the area. Perfumers would often escape plague effects, led to many of these beliefs. Now we know many of these plants have antiseptic properties.
      Nor that we’ll ever really know 100% where these rhymes come from, but it’s always interesting to talk about. ☺️

    • @thedativecase9733
      @thedativecase9733 5 лет назад +6

      You are right I have been pointing this out to people for years. The Ring a Ring O' Roses / Great Plague story was invented by an Oxford University academic in 1956 in a spoof article for the Oxford magazine. I think the English newspapers picked up on it and printed it as if it was true. Probably during the summer "silly season" when there is a lack of political news thus is an urban legend born. It persists because some Nursery Rhymes do refer to actual events - Goosey Goosey Gander is almost certainly about the persecution of Catholics in 17th century England.

    • @t.l.1610
      @t.l.1610 5 лет назад +4

      TheDativeCase
      Right but how much is spoof, making things up - and how much is taking mythology and expounding on it? Turning it into an article? B/c many legends have a kernel of truth. We see that with a lot of the medieval chroniclers repeating stories that were passed down, like the mythos around King Arthur. I’ll dig up some of my old textbooks & see what I can find on this. Interesting stuff.

    • @paranormalsoulcircle3176
      @paranormalsoulcircle3176 4 года назад

      It's about the plague

  • @divamisse7
    @divamisse7 5 лет назад +103

    Mystery Mondays have me actually loving Monday! ❤️

    • @christiegroves
      @christiegroves 5 лет назад +1

      Thats great news, you won't be "shooting the day down" Boomtown Rats after the case of Breda Spencer ;)

    • @Nance-th5hw
      @Nance-th5hw 5 лет назад +1

      PeaceLove&Misse same 😂😂I used to hate mondays

    • @jazzinlight1245
      @jazzinlight1245 5 лет назад

      Same

  • @AmericanGadfly
    @AmericanGadfly 5 лет назад +321

    Im just gonna put it like this. Oj was found Not Guilty too...😂

    • @sobbos8975
      @sobbos8975 5 лет назад +2

      American Gadfly 😂😂

    • @leamartin8392
      @leamartin8392 5 лет назад +17

      And Casey Anthony

    • @elizzybec
      @elizzybec 5 лет назад +4

      wasn't he acquitted? that's not the same as not guilty it just means the case was too messed up and had to be let go or thrown out
      no? do I remember this wrong?

    • @AmericanGadfly
      @AmericanGadfly 5 лет назад

      @@elizzybec i could be wrong, Im pretty sure he was found not guilty though

    • @marylisedean4207
      @marylisedean4207 5 лет назад

      Yesssss!!!

  • @pocketninja9919
    @pocketninja9919 4 года назад +4

    I have only just discovered your channel and I've got to say you're one of the only true crime channels I can watch. I love that you go into so much detail and humanize the victims of the stories you cover x good job!

  • @bloodyneptune
    @bloodyneptune 4 года назад +33

    Anyone else picturing two cops standing next to a violently mutilated corpse, looking scandalized and horrified that period blood had been mentioned? "Good lord, Charles, Ive never been more shocked in my life".

  • @alexandracaldas5629
    @alexandracaldas5629 5 лет назад +40

    The house is a bed and breakfast, which is so so cool. I have stayed there! The tour is a delight, and it’s really neat to hear what the staff thinks what happened.

    • @StephanieHarlowe
      @StephanieHarlowe  5 лет назад +6

      did you see any ghosts?

    • @alexandracaldas5629
      @alexandracaldas5629 5 лет назад +8

      Admittedly I opted for a room way upstairs near Bridget’s because it was cheaper, and thus ultimately known for not having any spooks. The barn in the back (unsure if it’s THE pigeon barn or something remodeled) is the gift shop, where I got some hatchet earrings and a magnet of Papa Borden’s autopsy photo. 10/10
      At the least, I can confirm you were correct about which staircases led to which bedrooms. 😂
      Rachida, you can pay for a guided tour during the day or you can stay overnight and do the guided tour before going to bed. There’s something really cool about doing the tour at night and then inspecting copies of old files in their sitting room after.

    • @MiguelMaxMusic
      @MiguelMaxMusic 5 лет назад

      Does it feel like a scary place at night?

    • @alexandracaldas5629
      @alexandracaldas5629 5 лет назад +5

      MiguelMaxOficial, I don’t want to say it doesn’t feel scary at night just because it wasn’t for me. I imagine it is much scarier for folks sleeping in rooms where people had been killed. The tour guides also talk about sort of other worldly experiences reported by previous guests per room, so that makes laying your head down at night in one of those rooms a little tougher. It was a spooky old house with a notorious history, but I can say I slept really soundly on the third floor away from any reported crime or ghost drama.

    • @nesadcruz7840
      @nesadcruz7840 5 лет назад +1

      What do the staff think happened?

  • @alys4570
    @alys4570 5 лет назад +18

    You should look at the kidnapping and escape (after 7 years) of Steven Stayner . Then his brother (Cary Stayner) became a serial killer in Yosemite park. Ive always wondered how Steven stayner’s kidnapping had an affect on his brother Cary Stayner. It’s such an interesting case. I remember watching the coverage on tv with my mother when I was young. We watched that famous movie together “ I know my first name is Steven” . She has since passed away but she was always my true crime buddy even when I was young.☺️

    • @aprilsunflower7440
      @aprilsunflower7440 3 года назад +3

      I remember that show and than to hear that about his brother was just crazy. The young man ( steven) who was kidnapped died in a car accident in his his early 20's I believe

  • @sheffieldamanda
    @sheffieldamanda 3 года назад +38

    Andrew feels unwell: comes home early, reads his newspaper, goes for a nap.
    Bridget feels unwell: Ordered to clean every window in the house, inside and out!

    • @maryjocassell48
      @maryjocassell48 2 года назад +11

      I caught that too, and to top off having to clean windows, all the while being ill, it was also a really hot day. Unfathomable to me. ☮️💜

    • @aprilsunflower7440
      @aprilsunflower7440 Год назад +8

      @@maryjocassell48 I've always thought that to. Abby may have been nice but that wasn't.

  • @laurapeloquin159
    @laurapeloquin159 4 года назад +24

    My mother is a tour guide at the Lizzie Borden house! If you and Nev ever want to spend a night at the house or Maplecroft before it’s sold please let us know! We would love to have you.

    • @user-hz3pe7dh5j
      @user-hz3pe7dh5j 3 года назад +3

      Omg I hope she sees your comment! You can email or write to her too. What an amazing offer

  • @BB-pt9hv
    @BB-pt9hv 5 лет назад +68

    You should talk about the Laurena Bobbit case, id love to hear your opinion on it and see the facts layed out :)

    • @HippieNikkiTheTopeteTribe
      @HippieNikkiTheTopeteTribe 5 лет назад +2

      B B yes please!!!

    • @maggiekarabel123
      @maggiekarabel123 5 лет назад +16

      OMG yes. She was so horribly abused but all anyone remembers is that she cut off her husband’s penis.

    • @BB-pt9hv
      @BB-pt9hv 5 лет назад +4

      @@maggiekarabel123 yes! Theres so much debate over if she was abused but I believe her,

    • @AskColez
      @AskColez 5 лет назад +1

      Oooh that would be really interesting from Stephs research!

    • @b56gght
      @b56gght 5 лет назад +1

      She's a legend perioud

  • @tressaevans6813
    @tressaevans6813 5 лет назад +4

    SO EXCITED about this video!! I'm a huge history buff too. Stephanie, you should totally do a video someday on the Princes in the Tower murder mystery, it's super old (it's medieval!!) and I don't think the main suspect actually did it, but maybe you'll feel differently! It's spooky and fun though, it's almost folklore at this point!

  • @xxnekonekox
    @xxnekonekox 5 лет назад +57

    I literally never clicked so fast

  • @StephanieLeigh83
    @StephanieLeigh83 5 лет назад +5

    I live about 10 minutes away from the Borden and I’ve done the tour a couple of times. It’s actually pretty cool, they have it set up like it looked the day of the murders with period furniture and the table set up like it would have been for that days lunch. It’s like you’re going back in time.

  • @Jess1cah
    @Jess1cah 8 месяцев назад

    I’ve been listening to your channel for a long time. But I’m slowly working my way through the older videos and binge watching. Thank you so much for the time that you put into these videos. They are my saving grace during difficult times.

    • @StephanieHarlowe
      @StephanieHarlowe  8 месяцев назад +1

      Welcome back!

    • @Jess1cah
      @Jess1cah 8 месяцев назад

      @@StephanieHarlowe this reply made my day! 🙈 you remind me so much of myself in so many ways- you immerse yourself in these deep dives and I’m so grateful. Plus I’m an AP US history and AP Psychology teacher and an adjunct professor and I’m SO appreciative of your love for history and how you make it such an important aspect of the story you’re covering. I often find myself thinking how you incorporate both history and psych whenever you can and I think that is sooo crucially important to so many of these stories. Thank you for all you do, even when you’re facing what you’ve mentioned recently as some tough personal struggles. I’ve been there. Keep fighting the good fight. What you’re doing for these people and their stories is amazing. ❤️❤️❤️

  • @thestoryteller8486
    @thestoryteller8486 5 лет назад +16

    I honestly believe she did this. I am excited to hear your take on it.

  • @blueditto
    @blueditto 5 лет назад +16

    The first shirt that I ordered from you came today.
    I ordered another one last week, and I just ordered the one you’re wearing in this video. 😊
    I love your videos, happy to support. 💕

    • @StephanieHarlowe
      @StephanieHarlowe  5 лет назад +7

      Awwww thank you so much, Rose!!! That is so awesome and heart warming!

    • @daddysgirl5049
      @daddysgirl5049 4 года назад

      @StephanieHardlowe: How do I order a shirt from you?

  • @jnmwtkns
    @jnmwtkns 3 года назад +3

    I loved your take on this mystery.
    A few things I learned over my 48 years that I always thought were true were that her father wasnt a scrooge matter of fact he was very generous and spent most on daughters to have best boks , tailored clothes , sent lizzie on a very long trip , bought and converted a home for his family and also purchased most of the street they lived on and moved some friends and family into houses he purchased.
    Anyway I look forward to hearing more of your stories. Your voice is perceived for listening .

    • @4usprosperity
      @4usprosperity 2 года назад

      F is a great idea for a new job in the world and I am sure you are not the one who has the best of the time you have to do it for a few days now and then I was going on a cruise with a friend of yours who was a great idea and we will see if you are available to see you and I will have you in the office and I am not sure what I want to be done to help with this one for you to

  • @stacypachecopacheco8261
    @stacypachecopacheco8261 3 года назад +9

    I live 20 minutes from the house where the murder happened and my husband and I have toured the house. It definitely has an eerie feel and we are very big Lizzie Borden history buffs and we even have Lizzie Borden memorabilia including a letter post marked from back then that was sent to her with her photo on it. You definitely did this story justice with the amount of knowledge you have told.

  • @tunaynamahal82
    @tunaynamahal82 Год назад +1

    This was most well done video on Lizzie Borden I've ever seen! I know so much history about this case, usually videos fall short of my expectations, but you were spot on! I spent a night at the Borden House in 2015 with my husband. We stayed in Lizzie's parents room!

  • @XoXoSmallsXoXo
    @XoXoSmallsXoXo 5 лет назад +25

    Omg yay!!! I just wore my “don’t come for me” shirt yesterday 🖤🖤

    • @ginganinja93
      @ginganinja93 5 лет назад +1

      Krystal Schatzle I wore mine today!!! :D

  • @ThatGirlWithTheCoffee
    @ThatGirlWithTheCoffee 5 лет назад +32

    About the maid's name- Brigid is a very common Irish name, and it could have been that there were multiple Brigids in the same family, so some of them were called by other names, such as Maggie or Mary. It doesn't always relate to the base name- I know a woman next door called Peg by her friends and family, but her christened name is May, and another beside my Grandfather called Cora, whose actual name is Aileen.

    • @DeadPretty138
      @DeadPretty138 3 года назад +2

      my grandma was called celine and some people called her barb (which is a regional term in lancashire where she came from) and others called her jill. I have no idea where jill came from at all. I grew up calling her grandma jill xxx

    • @denisedarnell1641
      @denisedarnell1641 Год назад

      It has been said somewhere that Lizzie and Emma called her Maggie because that was a maid before Briget and they simply were being rude calling her Maggie ...meaning she wasn't even allowed respect of her own name ..only the father and step mother called her Brigid

  • @maracuja320
    @maracuja320 4 года назад +4

    This is such an interesting case! The reason why the Borden family was so strict with keeping all the doors locked, is because of the "burglary" a couple of years before the murders would eventually happen. That's when they started to keep all their doors locked all the time because Andrew did not want any more things taken frol him.

  • @Gooosblabla
    @Gooosblabla 5 лет назад +1

    I just had to come back to this video to comment on how phenomenally you reported this story!!! I recently got going with Audible (ironically after your raving about the sponsor). I just finished the Lizzie Borden chapters in "The Cases That Haunt Us" from author and FBI profiler John Douglas. Your work has again superseded with great accuracy!!!
    So glad we found your channel!!!

  • @katieolson4292
    @katieolson4292 2 года назад

    Ive been on the true crime side of RUclips for a long time and somehow just recently found your channel. I almost always skip these stories I've seen or heard so many times but then I remember how much new, detailed information you bring to light about the people involved with the crimes and the crimes themselves and I have not regretted once listening to a video or series of yours that I feel like lve heard "too much about." You're incredible, Stephanie!!

  • @miahoneymoon
    @miahoneymoon 5 лет назад +47

    You should do the case on Juliet Holme and Pauline Parker. They were two young girls from new zealand who killed one of their mothers. It’s really interesting there’s also a movie on with Kate Winslet called Heavenly Creatures

    • @severianna9
      @severianna9 4 года назад +3

      Carlie Im new to this video but she did do a 3 parter on those girls and it’s to this day my favorite videos I’ve watched of Stephanie’s! I hope you’ve watched or will soon!!!!

  • @gabbyhogan2336
    @gabbyhogan2336 5 лет назад +5

    yay! A new Mystery Monday! I've been throwing up all night (we're working on diagnosing why I can't stop vomitting) and this is the perfect distraction to help me feel better. Plus I get to see stephanie's beautiful face

    • @themoon-iy1kg
      @themoon-iy1kg 5 лет назад +2

      Gabby Hogan hope you feel better soon! ♥️♥️♥️I’ve been sick as well so this is great timing :)

    • @StephanieHarlowe
      @StephanieHarlowe  5 лет назад +3

      I've been throwing up for four days now. There is something really wicked going around. I think I'm dying

    • @themoon-iy1kg
      @themoon-iy1kg 5 лет назад +1

      Stephanie Harlowe oh no Stephanie!!! Hoping you’re all better soon ♥️Youve got such dedication 💪🔥Yes there seems to be two different bugs going around in my area.🖤 (changed my screen name, i was flea)

    • @gabbyhogan2336
      @gabbyhogan2336 5 лет назад

      @@StephanieHarlowe oh no stephanie! There must be something going around trying to make us all sick

  • @beastkid1524
    @beastkid1524 5 лет назад +48

    Paul Bernardo and Karla Homolka would love to see you cover that one

    • @skinnypigs1
      @skinnypigs1 5 лет назад

      Yes

    • @CatrionaCharles
      @CatrionaCharles 5 лет назад

      That one is absolutely brutal!

    • @Uhhhok_i_guess
      @Uhhhok_i_guess 4 года назад

      1000% this one

    • @severianna9
      @severianna9 4 года назад +1

      Im new to this video but if you haven’t found it yet, she did cover it!! One of my favorites and it’s a mini series

  • @donnaatteberry3640
    @donnaatteberry3640 Год назад

    I almost didn't watch this segment because I thought I knew most of what there was to know about the Lizzie Borden case. But you proved me wrong. You're one of the best true-crime reporters and storytellers on RUclips. Bravo.

  • @wanderingbelle7
    @wanderingbelle7 3 года назад +10

    I feel so sad for Abbie. She seems like a kind woman who just wanted to be a good mother, and all her best efforts were crushed. I can’t imagine the pain Abbie must have felt in later years looking back at the good times she had with Lizzie while Emma was away at school. 😓

  • @mariem2029
    @mariem2029 5 лет назад +8

    omg your voice is so calm and soothing! I love it

  • @Rainbowofthefallen
    @Rainbowofthefallen 5 лет назад +37

    You are one of my favourite RUclipsrs ❤️

  • @gallygrovle2160
    @gallygrovle2160 5 лет назад +6

    Oh hell yes. You keep delivering what we need! Praise be!

  • @CeltycSparrow
    @CeltycSparrow Год назад +4

    So I have a couple of questions. When Lizzie discovered her father hacked to death, she calls for the maid, she calls for the doctor and she calls for a friend....but notice who she DOESN'T call. NOT ONCE do I hear you say Lizzie summoned the police (which would seem a logical thing to do, if you found your parents murdered with an ax, no? Call the police to have them investigate the murder and protect YOU, just in case the murderer comes back to finish the job or do a thorough search of the house and property to make sure the killer is gone) Also, they postulate that Abby was murdered first, and it was an hour and a half to two hours later that Lizzie's father was murdered. They keep asking LIZZIE why she didn't hear anything....so if her father was still alive when the murderer killed Abby, why didn't HE hear this and come to investigate? How is it that the maid, Maggie, was also upstairs (resting, but NOT fully asleep) and SHE doesn't hear the parents being murdered or any suspicious noises? Wouldn't Abby have been crying out in pain or screaming when she was hacked to death? Wouldn't she have heard the body fall to the floor?

  • @Addie3107
    @Addie3107 3 года назад +26

    Did you ever tell the “long story” about your wardrobe change? I’m so curious 😆

    • @k.embers
      @k.embers 3 года назад +3

      6 months after this comment, and I’m new to this channel, and I’m also curious.

    • @dijanavukovic2494
      @dijanavukovic2494 3 года назад +2

      me too

  • @rebeccaturner9394
    @rebeccaturner9394 5 лет назад +4

    Hey Stephanie! A man Andre McDonald a Air Force major was just arrested after his wife disappeared on Friday. Police took him into custody after finding evidence that he could of been involved in her disappearance and possibly murder. they found an ax, shovel, heavy duty trash bags and two five-gallon jugs of gasoline inside their Texas home. Police also think he destroyed the receipt I was hoping you could cover the case like the Watts case. This is turning to be really sad and hits hard sense I live in Texas so it hits home. I really enjoy your channel and love true crime thanks!

  • @Ordinary_1
    @Ordinary_1 5 лет назад +15

    I thought I knew everything about this case but you provided new details😊

  • @simchi5611
    @simchi5611 5 лет назад +5

    I just LOVE her demeanor in court. One word answers, answering with questions, limiting information, she hardly ever slipped up and let out something personal. The girl was well trained, or a genius.

    • @sarahholland2600
      @sarahholland2600 3 года назад +3

      She was also off her face on morphine, her Dr gave her twice the normal dose "for her nerves".

  • @JTScott1988
    @JTScott1988 5 лет назад +17

    We didnt have places for autopsies then. Autopsies were done on location of death or at the individuals home.
    Lincolns autopsy was actuslly done in the white house.

    • @severianna9
      @severianna9 4 года назад

      Laquinton Wagner interesting!!!

    • @JTScott1988
      @JTScott1988 4 года назад

      @@severianna9 ikr.

    • @JTScott1988
      @JTScott1988 4 года назад +1

      @@severianna9 lizzie bordens folks autopsies were done in their loving room.

  • @cassieblack1776
    @cassieblack1776 10 месяцев назад +1

    this also reminded me of the movie " the others " because of the old timey feel and the constant door locking plus the bizarre awkwardness that's always in the atmosphere and the curiousness of never knowing what's really happened.

    • @juno2399
      @juno2399 7 месяцев назад +1

      Yes! Especially the part about the doors

  • @MrBibi86
    @MrBibi86 5 лет назад +24

    *yay! I'm early for once. can't wait to watch :)*

  • @MyvaniaTasram
    @MyvaniaTasram 5 лет назад +13

    There are more important things in life than material things. Family and friends are priceless. It’s nice to buy things but you don’t have to just because you can.

  • @Shyrden1
    @Shyrden1 4 года назад +7

    I may be wrong but during that time period I think "maggie" was sort of a slang term used for all irish women - the irish weren't well liked in America in the old days lol there was a lot of snobbery going on! Awesome show as usual, keep em coming Stephanie!!!

    • @4usprosperity
      @4usprosperity 2 года назад

      F is a great idea for a new place to work with you and I miss u so much and I will be in love with you and I miss u so much and I will be in a good way and I am not sure if you remember the best place to go to the next one is a great place to start and then we can go over it and if so how much it will take to see you 😊😀☺😄😉❤😊😀

  • @homebodycassidyofficial
    @homebodycassidyofficial 2 года назад +2

    Does anyone else feel like Bridgette is lying? She was told to clean the windows when she was sick, and she happened to not hear anything while two people were murdered and Lizzie was outside? It’s also super convenient to blame a juvenile who’s already known to steal.

  • @Koalaaahh
    @Koalaaahh 5 лет назад +1

    You're my new fav Crime-Tuber! Always feels like I'm listening to an audio book.

  • @LadyBlueAzure
    @LadyBlueAzure 5 лет назад +55

    Nice, something to chill and listen to while I play the Sims.

    • @lial2143
      @lial2143 5 лет назад +8

      Lol, same!? I thought I was the only one haha!

    • @PixelPenguin87212
      @PixelPenguin87212 5 лет назад +3

      Omg I always listen to Stephanie while I play Sims!!

    • @StephanieHarlowe
      @StephanieHarlowe  5 лет назад +12

      Now I need to play the Sims

    • @LadyBlueAzure
      @LadyBlueAzure 5 лет назад

      You're not the only one guys, haha. ❤ And yes Stephanie, listening to you while gaming is one of my favorite ways to chill out.

    • @kaylinLangevin
      @kaylinLangevin 5 лет назад

      Lol me too. She's become a part of my routines for my day off. Sims, sushi, wine, and Stephanie. Recipe for a great day off.

  • @x_carmy
    @x_carmy 5 лет назад +3

    Chills chills chills. Again, I've heard most of these true crime stories multiple times but you are such a great story teller and so detailed! I learn something new every time!

    • @4usprosperity
      @4usprosperity 2 года назад

      B is a good idea for a new place to work with you and I miss u too baby and I hope you can help me to make the most sense if I am able to get to know each of the United States 🇺🇸🇺🇲😊

  • @wrathchild8920
    @wrathchild8920 5 лет назад +34

    Awesome job as usual!! Please consider doing DREW PETERSON.

    • @themindylynn4927
      @themindylynn4927 5 лет назад +3

      I second that motion!!!

    • @angelcitygirl
      @angelcitygirl 5 лет назад +1

      That guy is straight up evil. And a cop too. Shudder.

    • @MsDoctorWhoFan1
      @MsDoctorWhoFan1 4 года назад

      I knew Staceys sister. Stacey I only saw at her sisters funeral.

  • @flazada
    @flazada 4 года назад +2

    Stephanie! You need to come to Fall River! I lived there for nearly 20 years! The bed and breakfast is fascinating, so is the historical society. It's really something to be in the actual rooms the murders too place in. The guides have so much knowledge too. It's great.

  • @scottadcock550
    @scottadcock550 5 лет назад +2

    ....who else is spoiled by stephanie's depth of knowledge, commitment to the facts and length of each video? litterally no one else comes close to the amount of effort she puts in.

  • @SuperToybox123
    @SuperToybox123 5 лет назад +18

    Did her mom have miscarriages I ask because it took my parents 4 or 5 years to have me after they married and they started from the word go but they just had dead babies for a while till me?

    • @StephanieHarlowe
      @StephanieHarlowe  5 лет назад +7

      I don't know, there is no record of it, but possible

    • @neuralmute
      @neuralmute 5 лет назад +10

      @@StephanieHarlowe They didn't always record events like miscarriages in the 19th c. because they would have been "improper" to mention, especially in the American middle classes, where propriety was extremely important! But even the description of her cause of death ("congestion of the womb?") sounds like a historical euphamism for death during a miscarriage to me. I'd guess that she had more than just that one.

    • @Meredith471
      @Meredith471 5 лет назад +8

      @@neuralmute I was thinking the same thing. I do believe "congestion of the womb" actually was a reference to a hemorrhage secondary to miscarriage, if I remember correctly. They did not do D&C's after miscarriages in those days, so it was quite common for this to be an issue after multiple miscarriages. So many years between each child has to lead one to wonder.

    • @NageelaMom
      @NageelaMom 5 лет назад +4

      @@neuralmute I thought it was a euphemism for uterine cancer...

    • @undergroundlady5892
      @undergroundlady5892 5 лет назад +1

      @@Meredith471 what does D&C mean?

  • @faithhammonds6025
    @faithhammonds6025 5 лет назад +5

    I love how early you start in the story and not just when the murder occurs

  • @trishhudson151
    @trishhudson151 5 лет назад +15

    I hope you have one day a week when you just chill. It will give you more energy for all you are doing the rest of the week. Just a thought..........

    • @StephanieHarlowe
      @StephanieHarlowe  5 лет назад +8

      Trish Hudson thanks, Trish!! That sounds fantastic and a really good point about storing up on some energy!

    • @rapitup45
      @rapitup45 5 лет назад +1

      Absolutely.

  • @Malcolmblacc
    @Malcolmblacc 3 года назад +1

    Stephanie tells these stories so well I literally can picture it in detail in my head , even when it’s in the 1800s . Her breakdowns are what gets me through work . One day I spent majority of my day listening to the Casey Anthony story. And now I’ve watched it about 5 times and I still find out something new each time. She’s the only RUclips I can sit down and watch literally every video whether it’s an like 3 hours long without even having to see pictures and stuff and stuff, usually I have to see pictures to pictures it more . She should really start writing books

    • @4usprosperity
      @4usprosperity 2 года назад

      T T to the world of America and to the hotel and got love in a hurry for a new job and that is a great place for the world to me is to be able to get a good feel for the way you look for the next two weeks and we are going on vacation to the office today to take care of our house for a few days and

  • @bethb4432
    @bethb4432 5 лет назад +1

    Wow! I’m only a few minutes in but I can tell I am going to love this. I’ve heard and read about Lizzie Borden probably for more years than you’ve been alive (I’m old) but already you have given me so much new and interesting information about this case. A+++ research!!