Within Temptation - Forgiven (Live) (First Time Reaction)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 10 сен 2024

Комментарии • 25

  • @saulmagal5734
    @saulmagal5734 2 года назад +13

    That’s the big difference between a “trying-my-best-to-show-how-good-I-can-sing” and a real and urgent need to sing what you are feeling. That’s Sharon and Within Temptation. While other bands are so full of themselves, WT are always true about what they’re doing and all they want is you to join them and feel the experience

  • @rvb2986
    @rvb2986 2 года назад +13

    She sung this song a short time after she had lost her father from a horrible disease. He was her biggest fan. He died a few months earlier and this was one of the first times she performed again. There is a video from two days earlier in which she really breaks and has to stop singing here is the link to that ruclips.net/video/ICDJ2v8JGnQ/видео.html The song is actually about suicide. I cannot listen to this song without crying, because my sister in law commited suicide. We raised her two daughters. It took a while but i forgive her. I just want to thank Sharon for singing this with all of her heart. She really is one of the nicest persons i know. Thank you for your beautiful reaction.

    • @mauijttewaal
      @mauijttewaal 2 года назад +1

      Pale is about suicide too, first person perspective;)

  • @emma8295
    @emma8295 2 года назад +11

    I was lucky enough to be at one of these concerts in 2018. It was a lifetime experience, beyond any words. She is just incredible. Nothing can describe how perfect her voice is live.
    As far as I know, this song was so emotional for her because she recently lost her beloved father.

  • @cristinamateescu5049
    @cristinamateescu5049 2 года назад +9

    She can do so much with just her voice and all emotion she puts in it... Probably one of their saddest songs (the others explained better than I would have, probably).

    • @mauijttewaal
      @mauijttewaal 2 года назад

      Pale is sad too, and very underrated...

    • @JudaGoethe
      @JudaGoethe 2 года назад

      @@mauijttewaal Uff and the Pale version from their acoustic album ''An Acoustic Night At The Theatre'' is just pure gold. The voice of Sharon in that song is incredibly softer and more fragile (in a good way) than this song Forgiven

  • @RoseForEverafter
    @RoseForEverafter 2 года назад +6

    I so admire Sharon’s ability to put emotion into songs, in both the lyrics she writes and the way she sings. Knowing the context behind this performance makes it all the more both heartbreaking and impressive that she was able to channel everything she was feeling into her voice. Jeez, I’m gonna need a minute to recover from this one 😂 the only other time I think I’ve seen her this emotional is when she sings Say My Name, a song she wrote about her grandmother having Alzheimer’s. I know Forgiven wasn’t written about her father, but so many of the lyrics clearly hit home.

    • @mauijttewaal
      @mauijttewaal 2 года назад +1

      she really songs from her soul:-)

  • @mandje2002
    @mandje2002 2 года назад +4

    Fun Ayreon fact: Sharon plays the part of the Indian on The Electric Castle

  • @rickrack4812
    @rickrack4812 2 года назад +2

    No one sings the feeling of despair like Sharon does.

  • @marks5451
    @marks5451 2 года назад +2

    I believe its about her relationship with her father before he died. I saw WT 6 times on that 2018 Resist tour and each time the audience held their collective breath during Forgiven. Most knew of her loss of her father and that she was fighting her emotions whilst singing this song. At one of the 6 shows she did break towards the end and the feeling of support from the crowd was palpable. I find it very hard to watch this performance now. Her face gives away her pain.

  • @rickrack4812
    @rickrack4812 2 года назад +2

    I don't have Patriot money donation money to request songs but you have to do more ballads of hers because everybody seems to skip them and they're so beautiful.... Pale, Bittersweet, Relentless, Is memories... Aquarius

  • @johnveerkamp1501
    @johnveerkamp1501 2 года назад +2

    THIS ARE REAL EMOTIONS. HARD TO FIND IN THE U.S.

  • @rickrack4812
    @rickrack4812 2 года назад +1

    For better live audio although it's probably been processed somewhat, Her performance from the black Symphony concert It is so good... But you must do the song also done with that set is set called THE SWAN SONG ... It was only released on the European and Japanese C d's when the silent force album came out.... It's all emotional so beautiful so perfect.
    You can find the perfect studio version on RUclips in a lyric video for video or to Gothic art sequences... So beautiful it is... Or you can get a perfect live version from the black Symphony concert

  • @rickrack4812
    @rickrack4812 2 года назад

    I think it's just the way she sings and puts herself into a song.. Need not be about anybody from her past. She is just that great at emoting

  • @Bunny99s
    @Bunny99s 9 месяцев назад

    Thanks for the reaction. There are almost no reactions to this song on YT.

  • @simonoussoren8316
    @simonoussoren8316 2 года назад +2

    The most beautiful song
    Check also our farewell

  • @andresbanoy6008
    @andresbanoy6008 2 года назад +2

    Rhapsody again, dude! come on!

  • @malmkwaks
    @malmkwaks 2 года назад +2

    It ain't much if it ain't Dutch 🙂😉

  • @mauijttewaal
    @mauijttewaal 2 года назад +3

    Great! Pale next plz:-) sorry don't have a credit card...

    • @mauijttewaal
      @mauijttewaal 2 года назад

      that's an emotional song too;)

  • @rickrack4812
    @rickrack4812 2 года назад

    I missed this one from you, but now I have to see if you have missed "don't pray for me"

  • @Man-gh1gh
    @Man-gh1gh 4 месяца назад

    Ik ga er zelf stuk van, man.