I said this before in another reaction but who cares : "I'm almost 55, my mom is almost 86 and she's one of the biggest P.F fans I know, I started listening to P.F. from the cradle and I never thought I'd hear a band that could even play P.F. at the same level or even improve what is already perfect, when I showed this to my mother she went crazy and sang the whole song with marko, and this is the best compliment I can give, my mother loved it, greetings from Portugal 🤘🤘"
Metal Hammer magazine have put this into top100 best cover/tribute performances ever. NW has passion, talent and respect for PF, so it isn't surprise they nailed it.
Oh, I'd put this EASILY into the Top 10 for that, hands down. I'm a cover/tribute song fanatic and this is one of the most flawless one's I've ever heard.
You truly are amazing! Got a couple other Floyd related reaction coming this weekend. Ones that I love that I want to introduce you guys to, if you don't already know them.
One of the best things about new reactors is that they don't have a mile long list of songs to react to and will jump on things that catch their attention so good on you for checking this incredible tribute so quickly. New sub for more of that...and Nightwish of course! LOL As an old school PF fan, I was somewhat dismissive of High Hopes/Division Bell but this tribute is impossible to dismiss. I am almost 63 and Nightwish has been a revelation to me. They are filling a void in my musical soul that I didn't know existed before the pandemic. (thanks covid?) Looking forward to whichever NW song you react to my friend.
I was skeptical about listening to this version for quite a while (I hate covers in general, although this is more of a tribute) but after making my way through a sizeable chunk of Nightwish's live discography I thought "if anyone can pull off High Hopes, it's them"....... Mind blown!! I listened to it a further 10-15 times that same night, and without fail I have listened to it every single day since, at least once. It's the best tribute to any song I have ever heard. Great reaction. I saw you tearing up, and knew instantly "you get it"
Floyd is my favorite band. There's a very personal connection to their music due to a life event so yeah, sometimes, their music definitely gets me in the feels. LOL
OMGosh! I just now realized that I watched your video quite a while back. I haven't started watching this video yet, but I remember I loved your reaction to this cover by Nightwish.
This is actually a wonderful tribute. It's heavier and powerful, but maintains nicely the essence of the original. Glad you liked and approved, because I know that some PF fans don't. ⛄👍
Some Floyd fans are purist snobs. They miss the whole point of what Floyd was about: exploration of sound and experimenting with that could be done with it. I'm extremely open minded about music. I judge everything on it's own merits.
The only other two that I have heard that are close is Wrathchild America doing "Time" and RPWL doing this one: ruclips.net/video/0pHgnuhIgWg/видео.html
O.M.G. that performance was unbelievably good! I'm a massive PF fan and never thought anyone could do them justice, but Nightwise just did. Not only that, they created a menacing feel to it too that was scarily intense. I loved it, and I loved your reaction to it. Thank you!!
If David Gilmore likes it...you did a good job! So glad you jumped the list to check this out... this ismore a tribute than.a cover bc while they respected the original song...they also made this a Nightwish song...with class! Never seen one Pink Floyd fan watch this and not.like it! And lemme help you.out... Tampere is pron: TOHMM-Pehr-Ahh.
Thank you. I'm terrible at pronouncing stuff. And yes, they made this flawless. Any Floyd fan that doesn't like this, misses the point of what Floyd stands for.
@@MusicGodReacts I hear that! And Marko Hietala (pron:HEE-ah-Tallah) is a fantastic vocalist! His solo stuff is worth checking out. Especially the song Tides, by his band Tarot!
Part of what makes this performance so great is that it’s not a direct copy of the original, but it’s still very respectful of the original. That respect is what’s missing from most of the “weird stuff” that you referred to. It’s important.
And what exactly is the DIFFERENCE between a cover and a tribute, by your standards? Not asking rudely, just curious because I've always wondered how people differentiate the two?
@@MusicGodReacts It is hard to explain. Please go checkout The Wyldeside with Eric clark reacting to this song. He can explain better than I ever could. Btw sorry it took me so long to get back to you!
Greetings from Finland & thanks for your reaction to this amazing tribute to Pink Floyd by one of the best live bands in the world even if Marko was really sick, Jukka had a migraine attack behind his drum set & the guys were set to fire the band's lead vocalist Tarja Turunen after this show.
My younger brother is like you...a massive Pink Floyd Fan! He has everything they have ever put out...multiple copies of every album...and his wife is just as hooked on PF as he is!! When I sent him the link to this song on Facebook...when he played this same video...he said his wife cried because Nightwish didn't do a cover...they did a tribute to this legendary band! Oh...I am 65 years young! Still have my love for the bands I grew up listening to, and have added Nightwish and a few other newer bands to my play list! Oh....you're right...Emppu did a great job on his solos! He is a very underrated guitarist! I love watching his antics on stage! But...you can tell how much he loves being on stage! Well..you have a new subscriber!!! I enjoy your videos!!! We're about the same age...and have similar tastes in our music!
Thank you so much! Yeah, Emppu is amazing. I'm also a huge fan of his other band, Brother Firetribe. Floyd is definitely one of a kind. Hard to compare tehm to anyone else.
I played in a HS football game in Nov 1987 in the Pontiac Silverdome. I was starting for Erie Mason Eagles and we won Class C state championship in 1987 (there is actually a video on YT of our season and that game against Saginaw Novel Catholic Central). I also saw Great White & White Snake in the Silverdome during my senior year. Memories. The only time I heard Pink Floyd live in concert was 2010 sitting on the balcony of my 10th floor San Francisco apartment next to AT&T Ballpark off King St & 3rd. I had a big bowl of popcorn, listened to every song and enjoyed the fireworks and such as they shot out the top of the open baseball stadium.
That would have been amazing to see. I went to the Silverdome for tons of things back then, including Lions games, WMIII, concerts, and monster truck shows. it was a crazy place
Just sheer brilliance. Dave Gilmour gave this tribute his seal of approval and you can't really argue with him on matters of Pink Floyd. 78,000 - almost as many as at the Wacken 2013 Nightwish concert.....
@@NickBR57 I would be utterly star struck. I HAVE gotten to interview both Steve Hackett of Genesis and FISH from Marillion, so there's always hope, I guess. LOL
As a old rock and roller fan I have fallen in love, I have seen thru out my long life some of the best, and I have come to realize this is the best live performance band ever, there music, singing, instrumentals, is untouchable in talent I am so happy I found them before I pass they are a gift God bless
As other reactors have stated, this is not merely a cover; it is a tribute to Dave Gilmour and Pink Floyd. Like you, I get emotional listening to it. I don't know why, but it has that effect. All the band were on point. Tuomas with his moody keys, Yukka really laying into his drums, Emppu's sublime solos and Marko's astonishing vocals. Each single member puts in a virtuoso perfomance, but when they are taken as a whole....flawless, as you put it. Subbed.
they managed to catch the feeling, the athmosphere of the original, and kindly enhances it into a metal tribute to pink floyd. and fyi, this is a pause-song for wardrobe change of the female front woman ... try some Nightwish out, you will be amazed of what they have to offer ! oh, just realized that you know them already :) , and you are going on, see you in the "Weak Fantasy" reaction ! liked and subbed for more
@@MusicGodReacts hell yeah ! =) is it possible that you will do an old Nightwish song too ? from 2001, "The Pharaoh sails to Orion" live Tampere would be great
In my stoner days i loved listening to Pink Floyd they always taken me off on this journey and yet i feel the same now for Nightwish except they are a lot heavier. Tuomas doesn't just write lyrics and music he writes experiences and anyone that goes or has gone to a Nightwish concert would know this. My two favorite Pink Floyd albums are Dark side of the moon and The wall although Wish you we're here i love too.
Your honousty just bought you another subscriber...thank you for this Sir, really. Mind you, Nightwish don't do covers, they pay tribute...and although they do it very rarely, they never disappoint. Great Sunday to you Sir, and see you soon 😊.
I love this tribute to Pink Floyd. PF is an amazing band and this tribute to them was done by NW another amazing band in their own right. I'm looking forward to your reaction to Weak Fantasy which is one of my favorite songs. Both the subject as well as the lyrics and music are awesome. I have to stay off this in the car cause I will go way over the speed limit.
@musicgodcj, I’ve been a lifelong Pink Floyd fan(since the beginning) but I must admit that this tribute version of High Hopes by Nightwish is my favorite by far, I must also recognize that since I discovered Nightwish with Floor Jansen around 7 years ago, Nightwish has become my all time favorite band and lead singer. 🤟🤟✌️✌️🇨🇦
Very nice reaction, thank you and new subscriber here! I'm old school Metal Fun and I love this version of “High Hopes”, what an amazing tribute to Pink Floyd! Greetings from Germany!
I love this. Marko can SANG. He's 5 months older than me. Marko's first band was called Tarot with his brother. The video you should react to is Wings of Darkness from 1986 and then the 20th Anniversary
I've seen Floyd twice love on the momentary lapse of reason and the division bell tours and nightwish are my favourite band so this song is a fantastic tribute that pays respect to the original without being a note for note copy.
I saw Floyd on the Momentary Tour as well. Brilliant show. Definitely a world class version. Easily Top 5 all time for this kind of song, whether you want to consider it a cover or a tribute.
Well, what can I say: my favourite band playing a song by my other favourite band. Good to see Nightwish can do an excellent performance of more conventional rock songs without their trademark female vocals.
Hey JC great reaction, I believe you have someting like a double track playing, the sound of the video seems a bit off. I suspect you have the track playing in your video capture software plus the sound of your mic picking the track from your speakers maybe, it make a weird sound with a delay. Other than this technical detail, well done. .
for me Marko is the best vocalist there ever is/was, learned of him at 90's with Tarot, thank's to my brother. Tarot has huge influence for my guitar playing.
I am also a huge Pink Floyd fan, although I never had the honor of seeing them live. I actually prefer this version of this song, blasphemy though it may be. I also highly disapprove of other artists changing Pink Floyd songs to suit their style, usually completely ruining the songs in the process. I always have to go and binge Dark Side of the Moon after one of those experiences. If you hadn't liked this one, you would have lost my subscription. In my opinion, you can't love both Nightwish and Pink Floyd without loving this amazing tribute. I think you understand the tribute Nightwish meant it to be. Thank you for reacting to this.
There's nothing wrong with liking this version better. It's flawlessly done. There's a version of Hey You done by the band Bobaflex that I prefer over Floyd's version. LOL
Coldplay - A Sky Full Of Stars (Official Video), Yellow (Official Video), Fix You (Official Video), Trouble (Official video), The Scientist (Official Video), What If, Talk (Official Video), Hypnotised (Official Lyric Video). P l E a S e .
I never understood the whole "covers" shit personally....But if others enjoy that is their right but I won't wast my time or money on a band that plays covers....But again that is just MY personal preference....AHIMSA!!!!
Personally, I love cover songs if done well. I've heard both good and bad. This one is definitely in the Top 5 for that category. Some of the greatest songs in Rock history have been covers.
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
Marko is the best male vocalist out there. Dare I say it? I love this version even more than the original.
I said this before in another reaction but who cares :
"I'm almost 55, my mom is almost 86 and she's one of the biggest P.F fans I know, I started listening to P.F. from the cradle and I never thought I'd hear a band that could even play P.F. at the same level or even improve what is already perfect, when I showed this to my mother she went crazy and sang the whole song with marko, and this is the best compliment I can give, my mother loved it, greetings from Portugal 🤘🤘"
Yes, It's perfectly done. In my Top 3 PF Tribute/Covers ever done.
Please tell your mother from me that she's fucking awesome!!!! That's so cool!!!!
For me First Led zeppelin,Pink Floyd.now from 2019 Nightwish .Best live band i have hearth
Nobody is better than Marko for these kinds of songs. Nobody.
Metal Hammer magazine have put this into top100 best cover/tribute performances ever.
NW has passion, talent and respect for PF, so it isn't surprise they nailed it.
Oh, I'd put this EASILY into the Top 10 for that, hands down. I'm a cover/tribute song fanatic and this is one of the most flawless one's I've ever heard.
@@MusicGodReacts is it considered a 'cover' if it's just a live rendition?
I'm glad I caught that glimpse of the Pink Floyd t-shirt earlier, so I could remind you of this wonderful tribute.
Way to go Martie....AKA The beautiful Martina. LOL
@@thomaslilly9558 😊
You truly are amazing! Got a couple other Floyd related reaction coming this weekend. Ones that I love that I want to introduce you guys to, if you don't already know them.
@@MusicGodReacts I'm not too familiar with Pink Floyd (apart from a few very well known songs), so I'll have a listen for sure.
Welcome aboard friend. You have an amazing road ahead of you.
Thank you!
This is not a cover but a tribute too Pink Floyd .
.
One of the best things about new reactors is that they don't have a mile long list of songs to react to and will jump on things that catch their attention so good on you for checking this incredible tribute so quickly. New sub for more of that...and Nightwish of course! LOL As an old school PF fan, I was somewhat dismissive of High Hopes/Division Bell but this tribute is impossible to dismiss. I am almost 63 and Nightwish has been a revelation to me. They are filling a void in my musical soul that I didn't know existed before the pandemic. (thanks covid?) Looking forward to whichever NW song you react to my friend.
Tons more coming along with some other goodies that I love. You veer listen to RPWL or Ray Wilson?
@@MusicGodReacts New to me but I'll check them out, thx.
@@brewswillis9783 gonna be doing some Ray reactions tomorrow. And RPWL as well.
@@brewswillis9783 RAy WIlson is something- not our NW allday known, i like it also. great Comment Brew, btw
@@alexandersteinmetz6857 I've actually interviewed Ray on my podcast. Briulliant songwriter and a super nice guy with a genuine love of all music.
It's something of a tribute to Pink Floyd. Nightwish have made it with respect and still made it their own.
I was skeptical about listening to this version for quite a while (I hate covers in general, although this is more of a tribute) but after making my way through a sizeable chunk of Nightwish's live discography I thought "if anyone can pull off High Hopes, it's them"....... Mind blown!! I listened to it a further 10-15 times that same night, and without fail I have listened to it every single day since, at least once. It's the best tribute to any song I have ever heard.
Great reaction. I saw you tearing up, and knew instantly "you get it"
Floyd is my favorite band. There's a very personal connection to their music due to a life event so yeah, sometimes, their music definitely gets me in the feels. LOL
This was live over 20 years ago in Helsinki Finland
OMGosh! I just now realized that I watched your video quite a while back. I haven't started watching this video yet, but I remember I loved your reaction to this cover by Nightwish.
Nightwish Army UK popping in for a great reaction.
Welcome
This is actually a wonderful tribute. It's heavier and powerful, but maintains nicely the essence of the original. Glad you liked and approved, because I know that some PF fans don't. ⛄👍
Some Floyd fans are purist snobs. They miss the whole point of what Floyd was about: exploration of sound and experimenting with that could be done with it. I'm extremely open minded about music. I judge everything on it's own merits.
@@MusicGodReacts Yeah. Good music is good music, no matter where it comes. 👍
@@pekkakarppinen1608 And that's TESTIMONY!
I have seen around ten reactors on this cover/tribute and they all loved it. You said it very well, quite different but true to the original🤟
Yes this i happens when Master Toumas became a fame Song in his Hand and make the best Homage to Pink Floyd .
This Nightwish tribute to Pink Floyd is the best I have ever heard. Awesome.
The only other two that I have heard that are close is Wrathchild America doing "Time" and RPWL doing this one: ruclips.net/video/0pHgnuhIgWg/видео.html
O.M.G. that performance was unbelievably good!
I'm a massive PF fan and never thought anyone could do them justice, but Nightwise just did. Not only that, they created a menacing feel to it too that was scarily intense. I loved it, and I loved your reaction to it. Thank you!!
A spiritual experience... every single time!
Youlove music. I applaud you. Beyond that i wonder.
A awesome Band do a Tribute to another awesome Band. 🤘
Marco can sound like anything he wants. Amazing!
If David Gilmore likes it...you did a good job!
So glad you jumped the list to check this out... this ismore a tribute than.a cover bc while they respected the original song...they also made this a Nightwish song...with class!
Never seen one Pink Floyd fan watch this and not.like it!
And lemme help you.out... Tampere is pron: TOHMM-Pehr-Ahh.
Thank you. I'm terrible at pronouncing stuff. And yes, they made this flawless. Any Floyd fan that doesn't like this, misses the point of what Floyd stands for.
@@MusicGodReacts I hear that! And Marko Hietala (pron:HEE-ah-Tallah) is a fantastic vocalist! His solo stuff is worth checking out. Especially the song Tides, by his band Tarot!
@@amygoodson-catlady Tarot is actually my favorite thing that Marko does. There's something about those songs that really resonate with me.
@@MusicGodReacts Me too! I've got Crows Fly Black in my car rt now!
Tears are falling...are they yours, are they mine?
Greetings from the Netherlands, I onley got to see Nightwish live and Floor Jansen Solo live.
Part of what makes this performance so great is that it’s not a direct copy of the original, but it’s still very respectful of the original. That respect is what’s missing from most of the “weird stuff” that you referred to. It’s important.
Agreed. You can tell that there is great reverence paid here.
This is not a cover. This is a Tribute!!!
And what exactly is the DIFFERENCE between a cover and a tribute, by your standards? Not asking rudely, just curious because I've always wondered how people differentiate the two?
@@MusicGodReacts It is hard to explain. Please go checkout The Wyldeside with Eric clark reacting to this song. He can explain better than I ever could. Btw sorry it took me so long to get back to you!
Greetings from Finland & thanks for your reaction to this amazing tribute to Pink Floyd by one of the best live bands in the world even if Marko was really sick, Jukka had a migraine attack behind his drum set & the guys were set to fire the band's lead vocalist Tarja Turunen after this show.
All that aside, they STILL performed flawlessly!
My younger brother is like you...a massive Pink Floyd Fan! He has everything they have ever put out...multiple copies of every album...and his wife is just as hooked on PF as he is!!
When I sent him the link to this song on Facebook...when he played this same video...he said his wife cried because Nightwish didn't do a cover...they did a tribute to this legendary band!
Oh...I am 65 years young! Still have my love for the bands I grew up listening to, and have added Nightwish and a few other newer bands to my play list!
Oh....you're right...Emppu did a great job on his solos! He is a very underrated guitarist! I love watching his antics on stage! But...you can tell how much he loves being on stage!
Well..you have a new subscriber!!! I enjoy your videos!!! We're about the same age...and have similar tastes in our music!
Thank you so much! Yeah, Emppu is amazing. I'm also a huge fan of his other band, Brother Firetribe. Floyd is definitely one of a kind. Hard to compare tehm to anyone else.
Pink Floyd gave me birth to music. And 30 years later, Nightwish, my favourite band, tribute a song of my genuine band 👌Tx from Québec Canada 🇨🇦 🤟
I got to see Floyd live in 1987. This is a true tribute to everything Floyd is.
Its a tribute to them and David Gilmore approved it
I played in a HS football game in Nov 1987 in the Pontiac Silverdome. I was starting for Erie Mason Eagles and we won Class C state championship in 1987 (there is actually a video on YT of our season and that game against Saginaw Novel Catholic Central). I also saw Great White & White Snake in the Silverdome during my senior year. Memories. The only time I heard Pink Floyd live in concert was 2010 sitting on the balcony of my 10th floor San Francisco apartment next to AT&T Ballpark off King St & 3rd. I had a big bowl of popcorn, listened to every song and enjoyed the fireworks and such as they shot out the top of the open baseball stadium.
That would have been amazing to see. I went to the Silverdome for tons of things back then, including Lions games, WMIII, concerts, and monster truck shows. it was a crazy place
50 here, PF fan, but Nightwish is what got me here! Great reaction, more NW! 🤘
Yep, got more coming! Just working through the requests list. Also still learning the editing thing so streamlining that process to make it faster.
Nightwish took a Pink Floyd song and made a tribute for them. Great!
Just sheer brilliance. Dave Gilmour gave this tribute his seal of approval and you can't really argue with him on matters of Pink Floyd.
78,000 - almost as many as at the Wacken 2013 Nightwish concert.....
You simply can NOT question the approval of David. #1 on my dream list to interview!
@The Music God CJ Plain That would be fun if you ever get to do it. Here's hoping 🙏
@@NickBR57 I would be utterly star struck. I HAVE gotten to interview both Steve Hackett of Genesis and FISH from Marillion, so there's always hope, I guess. LOL
@@MusicGodReacts Respect!!!
As a old rock and roller fan I have fallen in love, I have seen thru out my long life some of the best, and I have come to realize this is the best live performance band ever, there music, singing, instrumentals, is untouchable in talent I am so happy I found them before I pass they are a gift God bless
They are fabulous. Check out Evergrey. They are in the same vein and another flawless live band with massive passion for their music.
I found this to be such a special performance as well. Great reaction.
Thank you.
Kiitos! Thank you! It started with Dark side of the moon In 70's. It has never ended. Nightwish makes awesome tribute to PF. Missing Marco so much. ❤
Welcome to the channel!
Great reaction...Nightwish amazing band ...the best band our time..Higher level..this is amazing Tribute ..🤘❤
Thank you!
As other reactors have stated, this is not merely a cover; it is a tribute to Dave Gilmour and Pink Floyd. Like you, I get emotional listening to it. I don't know why, but it has that effect. All the band were on point. Tuomas with his moody keys, Yukka really laying into his drums, Emppu's sublime solos and Marko's astonishing vocals. Each single member puts in a virtuoso perfomance, but when they are taken as a whole....flawless, as you put it. Subbed.
Welcome to the Noize!
Nightwish one never get tired of. Everything they do is different and all extremely good 🙂
Favourite tribute/cover. Love it! ❤️
Jukka, the drummer is a good part of this to. He is just amazing :)
they managed to catch the feeling, the athmosphere of the original, and kindly enhances it into a metal tribute to pink floyd. and fyi, this is a pause-song for wardrobe change of the female front woman ...
try some Nightwish out, you will be amazed of what they have to offer !
oh, just realized that you know them already :) , and you are going on, see you in the "Weak Fantasy" reaction !
liked and subbed for more
Yep! That one and more coming later today!
@@MusicGodReacts hell yeah ! =)
is it possible that you will do an old Nightwish song too ? from 2001, "The Pharaoh sails to Orion" live Tampere would be great
@@helli0n824 I can make that happen. Give me a day or two and I will get it done up!
@@MusicGodReacts Anticipation is the greatest joy
with one listen to this tribute version I converted my friend, a life-long Pink Floyd fan (since Syd Barrett daze), into a Nightwish fan too!
Great reaction dude!
Best wishes from Namibia
Thank you!
Hello from Denmark..When Nightwish hit you...They HIT you.....
You have among the best sound quality playbacks of any reactor I've seen. Kudos to you sir! Great reaction.
Wow! Thank you. Lots more on the channel and tons to comes, as well.
In my stoner days i loved listening to Pink Floyd they always taken me off on this journey and yet i feel the same now for Nightwish except they are a lot heavier. Tuomas doesn't just write lyrics and music he writes experiences and anyone that goes or has gone to a Nightwish concert would know this. My two favorite Pink Floyd albums are Dark side of the moon and The wall although Wish you we're here i love too.
Your honousty just bought you another subscriber...thank you for this Sir, really. Mind you, Nightwish don't do covers, they pay tribute...and although they do it very rarely, they never disappoint. Great Sunday to you Sir, and see you soon 😊.
From Finland with Love
I love this tribute to Pink Floyd. PF is an amazing band and this tribute to them was done by NW another amazing band in their own right. I'm looking forward to your reaction to Weak Fantasy which is one of my favorite songs. Both the subject as well as the lyrics and music are awesome. I have to stay off this in the car cause I will go way over the speed limit.
Just posted the Weak Fantasy reaction.
@musicgodcj, I’ve been a lifelong Pink Floyd fan(since the beginning) but I must admit that this tribute version of High Hopes by Nightwish is my favorite by far, I must also recognize that since I discovered Nightwish with Floor Jansen around 7 years ago, Nightwish has become my all time favorite band and lead singer. 🤟🤟✌️✌️🇨🇦
Always great to meet another Floyd fan! NW truly are a marvel!
Enjoyed your reaction as much as the music, thank you. Hope you noticed the light. This as much of a tribute as it is a cover. Miss you Syd. Be well.
Thank you! Floyd is so special to me!
Tuomas (the Metall Mozart) would never try to cover PF. It's a tribute song and a tribute to P.F and DG
Playing someone else's song on an album or in public is, by definition, a cover. Call it what you want. But a tribute can be done in the heart.
Very nice reaction, thank you and new subscriber here! I'm old school Metal Fun and I love this version of “High Hopes”, what an amazing tribute to Pink Floyd! Greetings from Germany!
Greetings! Welcome to the channel! And thank your country for so many of my favorite metal bands!!
I love this. Marko can SANG. He's 5 months older than me. Marko's first band was called Tarot with his brother. The video you should react to is Wings of Darkness from 1986 and then the 20th Anniversary
I've seen Floyd twice love on the momentary lapse of reason and the division bell tours and nightwish are my favourite band so this song is a fantastic tribute that pays respect to the original without being a note for note copy.
I saw Floyd on the Momentary Tour as well. Brilliant show. Definitely a world class version. Easily Top 5 all time for this kind of song, whether you want to consider it a cover or a tribute.
Well, what can I say: my favourite band playing a song by my other favourite band. Good to see Nightwish can do an excellent performance of more conventional rock songs without their trademark female vocals.
Hey JC great reaction,
I believe you have someting like a double track playing, the sound of the video seems a bit off. I suspect you have the track playing in your video capture software plus the sound of your mic picking the track from your speakers maybe, it make a weird sound with a delay. Other than this technical detail, well done. .
ahh damn. that didn't show up in the edit. Will definitely double check for that and correct it in the future ones. Thank you!
for me Marko is the best vocalist there ever is/was, learned of him at 90's with Tarot, thank's to my brother. Tarot has huge influence for my guitar playing.
Yeah, truthfully, I like Nightwish but I TRULY LOVE Tarot. I do hope that Marko continues with that now.
I am also a huge Pink Floyd fan, although I never had the honor of seeing them live. I actually prefer this version of this song, blasphemy though it may be. I also highly disapprove of other artists changing Pink Floyd songs to suit their style, usually completely ruining the songs in the process. I always have to go and binge Dark Side of the Moon after one of those experiences. If you hadn't liked this one, you would have lost my subscription. In my opinion, you can't love both Nightwish and Pink Floyd without loving this amazing tribute. I think you understand the tribute Nightwish meant it to be. Thank you for reacting to this.
There's nothing wrong with liking this version better. It's flawlessly done. There's a version of Hey You done by the band Bobaflex that I prefer over Floyd's version. LOL
This will never be beat for me lol
Only 2-3 others I can think of come remotely close. Easily Top 5 all-time though for Tribute/Cover songs
@@MusicGodReacts now for some more Nightwish!!! Lol the army is already piling in I see :)
@@sarabanas1447 The Army has been brilliant! And lots more coming! Just posted Weak Fantasy reaction
yukka is fantastic
🤘
74 year old PF fan and this song brought me to tears, along with chills and goosebumps. It is true, it was a tribute, not a cover.
Born 66....Thats my STUFF 😁🤟
Born in 71 here and been a fan since a young child.
been there since almost of you have......
I love pink Floyd to,but this isBetter version!
Your camera angle was your first reaction
👍👍👍🇳🇱✌✌✌
its .tribut!!
😊🇫🇮❤️🎶🎹🎸🥁✨🤘
Coldplay - A Sky Full Of Stars (Official Video), Yellow (Official Video), Fix You (Official Video), Trouble (Official video),
The Scientist (Official Video), What If, Talk (Official Video), Hypnotised (Official Lyric Video).
P l E a S e .
Love this !!! But nowhere close to being as good as the real thing..!!!
Remember Syd......
Sorry for destroying the 666 likes.😂
LOL, all good! Didn't even notice.
WHERE'S YOUR HEADPHONES???? How are you going to react properly when you're not hearing it as their well done music sounds!!
Stop yelling......no one cares. Cheers!
Some people still have high quality sound systems and prefer to feel the air move...
@@randominc.2251 preach!
I have a 7 speaker, 200 watt, 5.1 surround sound by JBL for my computer. Everyone on my street can hear it! lol
I never understood the whole "covers" shit personally....But if others enjoy that is their right but I won't wast my time or money on a band that plays covers....But again that is just MY personal preference....AHIMSA!!!!
Personally, I love cover songs if done well. I've heard both good and bad. This one is definitely in the Top 5 for that category. Some of the greatest songs in Rock history have been covers.
PS.rumpalilla oli paskatauti!