I wasn't sure which of them to buy. You were so clear and detailed, yet so straight to the point. I'm going for the ML-CD15, which is also cheaper than the other one. I think this is the one-to-go option for the ones who think that the Magsphere is overpriced! Thank you very much!
I already owned these both, but I’m glad I saw this video. It’s good know about the split warmth of colors, but knowing that I can work around it in most cases. Thanks!!
It would be nice if there were different back options for the CS1625. The translucent, a black, a silver reflective, etc. An attachable grid would be useful too.
Thanks for these reviews! It seems the ML-CD15 could be a good replacement for the magsphere. Thinking of pairing it with the V1 and AD100 for events and on-the-fly portraits.
I returned the magsphere. This is 10c better. I tried wrapping the sphere around my V1 and it can be done but it was extremely tight. This is very nice on my 860iii. The flash and the cd15 together is a little heavy but the images look beautiful.
For Seniors, I'd take a look at what Magmod users tend to do. Prior to the release of the Magbox, many of them would use a small diffuser (the magsphere) on an off-camera key light, but then fill it in with an on-camera light. The small off camera light source will create hard shadows, however by filling the shadows in, the light pattern is not very dramatic. Alternatively, they would use a diffuser just out of frame, to get the softest light possible out of a tiny modifier. Some would go as far as to keep it in frame, then snap a second shot with the light pulled out to easily composite the light out in post production. Neither of these are my favorite, personally I'd rather just use a larger modifier in that scenario, which is why I tend to use compact diffusers most for bounce-fill indoors.
Very informative. and well-done Robert...I'm thinking the ML-CD15 might work well for location shoots on windy days when most light modifiers would get blown over . Im getting one to add to my location gear....
worst part is that if you lose any of the mount adapters, godox doesn't have them for sale individually anywhere. I'm learning that the hard way. so frustrating.
Exactly the video I was looking for - as always! Only question I have is: with the round head adapter on, is it still possible to use the AK-R1 magnetic accessory kit (say I wanted to use gels inside these, for example).
@Sharpen -- Robert, excellent overview! I hadn't thought about color temp. Speaking of which, is it possible to add color modification filters to the mounts?
Hi Robert, have you used the ML-CD15 with an on camera flash at events? Does it perform well and is it any better than say the magnetic frosted dome on the V1? Thanks mate, love your work.
Hey Trev. I have used it and you just get a more "full" bounce. The V1 + frosted dome sends most of the light up (upwards if your flash is pointed at the ceiling), whereas this one will send more light forward/down.
Hi, Robert. Yiu vids are excellent, esp when I kearned rhe godox flash system from you. I know rhe cd15 will fit my godox 860ii flash. Is there much difference in your mind between the 860ii, versus the 860iii? Ty, again.
I own a Godox V1 and was looking for a kind of magsphere modifier for event work (mostly weddings). Do you think the ML-CD15 or the AK-R22 makes more sense??
Thanks for the video, Robert. It seems like your audio is clipping through most of the video (or some weird distortion)??? Maybe it is just the way that the Rode wireless go handles reverb??? (It seems like you are in a very live room).
@@BeecherBandits unfortunately that is not the case with anything below the ad400 pro. The ad300 is their own mount but the modifier seems to come with several adapter mounts
Thanks for great video, Robert. I recently got this ML sphere with my ad300 because magmod only has softbox attachments for ad300. The problem is that I could no longer use magmod gel. I am using the flashpoint gel with the white rubber band, which is difficult to use. Do you have a better solution for fast gel on ad300?
@@VEGAFLICKS akr1 is for godox v1 or round head for ad200. I ended up using the old magmod gel holder without the gel and LEE otc sheet under it. The hardest part is getting the magmod base magnet on. Also, I realized I'm the only one who uses gel for corrections. I still prefer using gels. The struggle is worth it. Haha.
Interesting. I've seen versions of these in magnet forms. I agree in that the different sizes don't amount to much difference unless they are extremely different sizes.
Honestly this question is lost on me because I wouldn't ever use my bag to define the gear I choose to carry. The images I want or am paid to create determine the lighting I carry, then the lighting determines the bag necessary. If that's a restriction you have to impose on yourself then you'd have to determine the gear that closest meets YOUR goals while fitting in the bag. And in that case, my preferences are irrelevant.
@@robhallphoto The link you provided is for the extention flash head. I was asking for the ring ring adapter that you showed in the video. The base i can use to adapt the ML-CD15 to the AD200. Thank you.
YOU ARE SOOOOOO WRONG about the ML-CS1625. I wish you would stop saying it’s not good for event photography. I have used it in over 100 events and it’s great. The shape allows for a more controlled light around a subject for portraits or a wide group shot. 3:55
I am going to try out my new ML-CS1625. Will be photographing rabbits at a rabbit show. Close ups will be nice with a larger diffusion surface. Glad to hear it will work for events too. But camera, flash, and diffuser is so bulky and heavy. It attracts so much attention as a photographer. Do you extend the box or leave it flatten?
You'd think they should have corrected the lights and not compensate with the modifier. Stupid Godox, you wouldn't see any sensible company do stupid work arounds like this.
I feel that the easiest resolution would have been to make corrected fresnel glass for each available to purchase. Then the AK-R22 could be the same material as ML-CD15!
I wasn't sure which of them to buy. You were so clear and detailed, yet so straight to the point. I'm going for the ML-CD15, which is also cheaper than the other one.
I think this is the one-to-go option for the ones who think that the Magsphere is overpriced!
Thank you very much!
I already owned these both, but I’m glad I saw this video. It’s good know about the split warmth of colors, but knowing that I can work around it in most cases. Thanks!!
thanks robert, I really like that you report on color temperature, slide shooting manias, but I like them
It would be nice if there were different back options for the CS1625. The translucent, a black, a silver reflective, etc. An attachable grid would be useful too.
I was just about to purchase these items... this video really gave me the information I needed... I am going to buy two CD15's... thanks!
Thanks for these reviews! It seems the ML-CD15 could be a good replacement for the magsphere. Thinking of pairing it with the V1 and AD100 for events and on-the-fly portraits.
I returned the magsphere. This is 10c better. I tried wrapping the sphere around my V1 and it can be done but it was extremely tight. This is very nice on my 860iii. The flash and the cd15 together is a little heavy but the images look beautiful.
Thanks for explaining the pink diffuser. I was confused between both duffuder models.
I’d love to see a video of how/when you’d use these most!!! I’m always trying to find ways to lighten my load for senior portraits
For Seniors, I'd take a look at what Magmod users tend to do. Prior to the release of the Magbox, many of them would use a small diffuser (the magsphere) on an off-camera key light, but then fill it in with an on-camera light. The small off camera light source will create hard shadows, however by filling the shadows in, the light pattern is not very dramatic.
Alternatively, they would use a diffuser just out of frame, to get the softest light possible out of a tiny modifier. Some would go as far as to keep it in frame, then snap a second shot with the light pulled out to easily composite the light out in post production.
Neither of these are my favorite, personally I'd rather just use a larger modifier in that scenario, which is why I tend to use compact diffusers most for bounce-fill indoors.
@@robhallphoto ok got it! Thanks so much
Very informative. and well-done Robert...I'm thinking the ML-CD15 might work well for location shoots on windy days when most light modifiers would get blown over . Im getting one to add to my location gear....
Thanks!! I've been waiting for one of my go-tos (like yourself :) to review these. CD15 it is!!
wish you had compared sample photos to traditional softboxes
Wonder full . Excellent defuser
worst part is that if you lose any of the mount adapters, godox doesn't have them for sale individually anywhere. I'm learning that the hard way. so frustrating.
Thanks for the Info, nice review
How much lights ML-CD15 eats?
Exactly the video I was looking for - as always!
Only question I have is: with the round head adapter on, is it still possible to use the AK-R1 magnetic accessory kit (say I wanted to use gels inside these, for example).
Thank you for the great detailed review. Robert, is the CD15 practical for wedding work? If not, what do you use for a compact diffuser? Thanks
great video. Do you prefer this to magsphere 2 and magbounce 2 and, why not, new magmod XL kit, soon with godox mount ?
could you please make a video using these diffuser on the Godox V1 pls
@Sharpen -- Robert, excellent overview! I hadn't thought about color temp.
Speaking of which, is it possible to add color modification filters to the mounts?
Hi Robert, have you used the ML-CD15 with an on camera flash at events? Does it perform well and is it any better than say the magnetic frosted dome on the V1? Thanks mate, love your work.
Hey Trev. I have used it and you just get a more "full" bounce. The V1 + frosted dome sends most of the light up (upwards if your flash is pointed at the ceiling), whereas this one will send more light forward/down.
@@robhallphoto sounds good, cheers.
Hi, Robert. Yiu vids are excellent, esp when I kearned rhe godox flash system from you. I know rhe cd15 will fit my godox 860ii flash. Is there much difference in your mind between the 860ii, versus the 860iii? Ty, again.
I own a Godox V1 and was looking for a kind of magsphere modifier for event work (mostly weddings). Do you think the ML-CD15 or the AK-R22 makes more sense??
I think the ML-CD15 makes the most sense.
@@robhallphoto Thank you 🙏
Thanks for the video, Robert. It seems like your audio is clipping through most of the video (or some weird distortion)??? Maybe it is just the way that the Rode wireless go handles reverb??? (It seems like you are in a very live room).
Any attachment available for Bowens mount?
Godox mount is the same as a Bowens mount.
@@BeecherBandits unfortunately that is not the case with anything below the ad400 pro. The ad300 is their own mount but the modifier seems to come with several adapter mounts
Is this better than an umbrella?
Thanks for great video, Robert. I recently got this ML sphere with my ad300 because magmod only has softbox attachments for ad300. The problem is that I could no longer use magmod gel. I am using the flashpoint gel with the white rubber band, which is difficult to use.
Do you have a better solution for fast gel on ad300?
Not exactly sure if this is what you need, but check out the Godox AK-R1 Accessory kit .
@@VEGAFLICKS akr1 is for godox v1 or round head for ad200. I ended up using the old magmod gel holder without the gel and LEE otc sheet under it. The hardest part is getting the magmod base magnet on.
Also, I realized I'm the only one who uses gel for corrections. I still prefer using gels. The struggle is worth it. Haha.
tks. can you make a video shooting model in-outdoor w/ this 3 diffusers
Sam Merrill
A lot of that plastic mount for the AD200 Pro is covering the flash. How does that affect output? (the ML-CD 15)
Nice video. Thanks. Can you tell me what flash meter you were using, please.
Not a flash meter. Its a Sekonic C-800 Color Temperature Meter
Off topic but It’d be nice to have a twin mount for the AD300.
highly unlikely since the AD300 Pro doesn't have an encased flash tube. Would require clean gloves every time you wanted to assemble it.
Have you tried the ring light head for the AD200?
Yes I have
hi
is it possible to connect the big rectangle to the V1?
I NEEEDDDDDD THISSSSSS
Interesting product. Is it compatible with a Bowens mount?
Looking at the diameter I assume it’s not. Bowens Mount is a lot bigger than the Godox..
No bowens mount, the opening is much smaller than Bowens.
Esto es luz continúa difusora o es flash disculpa ???
Interesting. I've seen versions of these in magnet forms. I agree in that the different sizes don't amount to much difference unless they are extremely different sizes.
What flash and modifier would you use if you only have 1 30L backpack to hold all your camera gear?
Honestly this question is lost on me because I wouldn't ever use my bag to define the gear I choose to carry. The images I want or am paid to create determine the lighting I carry, then the lighting determines the bag necessary.
If that's a restriction you have to impose on yourself then you'd have to determine the gear that closest meets YOUR goals while fitting in the bag. And in that case, my preferences are irrelevant.
can i mount this on my Godox Ad200Pro?
Do you have a link to the AD200 adapter? I can't find that item within Adorama or B&H. The rectangular speed light adapter. Please and Thank you.
adorama.rfvk.net/BYaGy
@@robhallphoto The link you provided is for the extention flash head. I was asking for the ring ring adapter that you showed in the video. The base i can use to adapt the ML-CD15 to the AD200. Thank you.
@@camphoto oh, no I don't know of a listing for that separately, just as a piece included with the MLCD-15
@@robhallphoto Thank you for taking the time to reply. I appreciate and enjoy your channel. You do a great job.
Can it work with A10 profoto or A2 ?
New in the US?
Examples ????
Will they fit on flash point Xplore 600 Bowen’s mount?
no.
@@robhallphoto so it’s not a Bowen’s mount?
@@peterb.8875 no.
Which one would be best for the ad200?
You got any info on this?
YOU ARE SOOOOOO WRONG about the ML-CS1625. I wish you would stop saying it’s not good for event photography. I have used it in over 100 events and it’s great. The shape allows for a more controlled light around a subject for portraits or a wide group shot. 3:55
I am going to try out my new ML-CS1625.
Will be photographing rabbits at a rabbit show. Close ups will be nice with a larger diffusion surface.
Glad to hear it will work for events too. But camera, flash, and diffuser is so bulky and heavy. It attracts so much attention as a photographer.
Do you extend the box or leave it flatten?
Cool
on v1 give magenta tint , dont buy it
You'd think they should have corrected the lights and not compensate with the modifier. Stupid Godox, you wouldn't see any sensible company do stupid work arounds like this.
I feel that the easiest resolution would have been to make corrected fresnel glass for each available to purchase. Then the AK-R22 could be the same material as ML-CD15!