finally there's a sensible kpop commentary channel that actually give reason why its shit you comment about sheesh and clik clak spot on ngl, i just grimace every time i hear it sad about pinata tho :(( because ace songs are usually so cool and out of the kpop noise box, same like touch been binging your vids lately, keep up the good work my guy
As a Choice, honestly - fair. I don’t think “Piñata” is a complete failure but it was certainly a disappointment to hear A.C.E chase a trend rather than carve their own path. I think a certain other boy group embarrassed themselves far worse that same month, but it’s not my list I would always rather hear a negative review from someone who presents consistent good faith criticism rather than yet another hollow reaction channel. We need more of this sort of content in K-pop discourse.
I love how you use beautiful and meaningful vocabulary to describe!!! It seems like I'm listening to Mariah's songs, which is so attractive to watch! 😂😂❤❤
Surprised APT by Rose wan't tops on your list. This is the most obnoxious irritating song I've heard in a decade. It blows my mind that it got so popular.
It's kinda interesting how some of yall genuinely can't seem to dislike a song without sounding miserable lol I personally can't possibly imagine being that upset over a song. If I dislike it I just move on
only gonna comment songs i know - i lowkey enjoyed freak, i don't understand korean so maybe that's why - mona lisa was fun for me, especially the last part of the song (though i do like her other solo song more) - at first i was meh with meow, but i kind of enjoyed it after a while. i kept wanting to dance everytime it plays - gold at first i was confused and reminded me of sneakers or cake (which i don't like that much), but relistening, i enjoy it a bit more now (also that ryujin part you showed was one of my fave parts too lol) - zombie i thought was a nice change of pace for everglow. i can admit it may sound a bit boring as the rest, but i prefer this over adios or slay honestly, which i were not my faves. they went a bit on the creepy side (which reminded me of a purple kiss song) and i dig it. i do think they could have pushed a bit harder with the concept - touch was catchy and simple. at first was hesitant to like it cause it's everywhere, but admittedly it's quite addicting and has a nice tune - roll up, sadly is to me kinda meh and i am still stuck with cat and mouse and close to me lol - wait mantra slays for me, like this and new woman, nonstop back to back - oh yeah, done, i want that gone
I love Freak and Mantra 🥲 but Yuqi has better songs in her album and definitely Jennie would have better songs too like ZEN it's already way more cooler.
I am surprised not to see Who by Jimin, Rockstar and Moonlight floor by Lisa, Superlady by G-idle, and so on, especially all the collabs with western artists.
Wow, am I supposed to feel stupid for being obsessed with Mantra? Watching this video made me think I probably shouldn't watch any of your other videos, since I probably would just be upset by something you had to say. I was on board with everything in this one until you slammed Mantra. I think I'll watch it again right now, and then watch Zen afterward.
Sitting and watching the small clips of each song reminds me why I don't listen to tiktok or yt short popular songs unless suggested by a trusted friend
FINALLY SOMEONE WHO HATES TOUCH (and clik clak and gold and sheesh)! obviously i also disagreed with a few of these but i also 100% understand why from a musical and less personal standpoint they're bad songs
Well after all it's just one person opinion, so yeah why bother. Every person have their own taste. And don't forget some song are designated for live performance, most YG song are designated for that, it's so fire when performed live.
I'm sorry for your comments section, but I'm here agreeing with you in every song , I can't even understand how ppl like gold but ye i love Imaginary Friend too so ye at least we got that
Sorry about what? He's very condescending himself lol telling people they should have their head examined if they think a song is good. Just be an adult and say you don't like it lmao
I also don't like "my idol" by x:in even though I'm a ready 😂❤ and honestly I don't like mantra but i love Jennie and then dheesh I don't know about the lyrics 😅 i mean what? Sheesh !?
I was seeing your points for most of your choices till you came for Touch. That's a BOP sorry. I don't think you're gay enough for it tbh cause it's for the girls and gays
half of the songs he dont like are literally a few of the best songs 2024 and some of them won many awards. i should give this video a disslike but i wont cuz its not worth it
just because they won awards doesnt mean theyre good. if the only argument you can make is "but they performed well!!!" then...well...it's quite a weak argument if I do say so myself. edited cuz grammar
@Bewweekly no one should be arguing about this in the first place, including you, because it all comes down to personal opinions anyway lol no one is right or wrong in this, there's no point
@@cami_triz83 Is music one of the most subjective things out there? Yes. Does that mean you can't argue about it? No. My opinion is that a song performing well isn't a great measurement of how good it is. They're allowed to have their own opinion, and I'm allowed to have my own.
Finally someone who agrees that mantra isnt the most special thing in the world like everyone points it out to be.
I've literally never seen anyone say it's the most special thing in the world lmao
Same@@resrevr
Who tap this vid because of the thumbnail like me 😭✋
Me 😭
Me af ☠️
finally there's a sensible kpop commentary channel that actually give reason why its shit
you comment about sheesh and clik clak spot on ngl, i just grimace every time i hear it
sad about pinata tho :(( because ace songs are usually so cool and out of the kpop noise box, same like touch
been binging your vids lately, keep up the good work my guy
is Clik Clak a song I would take with me to a deserted island? No, but putting it in the vincinity of earrape like Smoothie or My Idol is criminal
Putting clik clak in this list is criminal. But I guess it's just my taste after all
Babymonster is a talented group but the lyrics and repetitive theme is killing their potential, I'm so tired of this concept.
Nah bruh roll up is one of the songs that made them more popular and touch is a banger 😢
I don't know.. But i love Mantra🥰
noooo
Same I love mantra sm
Bruh Mantra, Sheesh and Clik Clak in this list seriously bruh??
You're a blink what do we expect
Damn we match in almost all the songs!!! They were surely a miss or one time song!!
Nah i love mantra but yes you are so damn right about other songs
also touch!
As a Choice, honestly - fair. I don’t think “Piñata” is a complete failure but it was certainly a disappointment to hear A.C.E chase a trend rather than carve their own path. I think a certain other boy group embarrassed themselves far worse that same month, but it’s not my list
I would always rather hear a negative review from someone who presents consistent good faith criticism rather than yet another hollow reaction channel. We need more of this sort of content in K-pop discourse.
NAHHH WHEN I SAW CLIK CLAK I WAS JUST LIKE WHAT THE HELL
i love this channel you do not hold back lmao
The only songs i disagree with are mantra and gold.
I'd replace them with klaxon and supernova love.
I love how you use beautiful and meaningful vocabulary to describe!!! It seems like I'm listening to Mariah's songs, which is so attractive to watch! 😂😂❤❤
Surprised APT by Rose wan't tops on your list. This is the most obnoxious irritating song I've heard in a decade. It blows my mind that it got so popular.
It's kinda interesting how some of yall genuinely can't seem to dislike a song without sounding miserable lol I personally can't possibly imagine being that upset over a song. If I dislike it I just move on
Still better than mantra and jisoo lisa songs combined tho, but yeah it's overplayed
Nah, when I saw Meow, Freak, gold, clik clak, Ggum and sheesh, I was about to throw hands 😭💀🙏
only gonna comment songs i know
- i lowkey enjoyed freak, i don't understand korean so maybe that's why
- mona lisa was fun for me, especially the last part of the song (though i do like her other solo song more)
- at first i was meh with meow, but i kind of enjoyed it after a while. i kept wanting to dance everytime it plays
- gold at first i was confused and reminded me of sneakers or cake (which i don't like that much), but relistening, i enjoy it a bit more now (also that ryujin part you showed was one of my fave parts too lol)
- zombie i thought was a nice change of pace for everglow. i can admit it may sound a bit boring as the rest, but i prefer this over adios or slay honestly, which i were not my faves. they went a bit on the creepy side (which reminded me of a purple kiss song) and i dig it. i do think they could have pushed a bit harder with the concept
- touch was catchy and simple. at first was hesitant to like it cause it's everywhere, but admittedly it's quite addicting and has a nice tune
- roll up, sadly is to me kinda meh and i am still stuck with cat and mouse and close to me lol
- wait mantra slays for me, like this and new woman, nonstop back to back
- oh yeah, done, i want that gone
Agree with you 100%, I have not a single disagreement in this video.
I love Freak and Mantra 🥲 but Yuqi has better songs in her album and definitely Jennie would have better songs too like ZEN it's already way more cooler.
I just heard this song "my idol" is just too much the lyrics😂😸
I am surprised not to see Who by Jimin, Rockstar and Moonlight floor by Lisa, Superlady by G-idle, and so on, especially all the collabs with western artists.
I literally hate who by jimin
@@HorrorDooryeah bcoz you're used to tiktok music
Here is not moonlit floor
@@Miniblossom. yes
Realest
Wow, am I supposed to feel stupid for being obsessed with Mantra? Watching this video made me think I probably shouldn't watch any of your other videos, since I probably would just be upset by something you had to say. I was on board with everything in this one until you slammed Mantra. I think I'll watch it again right now, and then watch Zen afterward.
Sitting and watching the small clips of each song reminds me why I don't listen to tiktok or yt short popular songs unless suggested by a trusted friend
FINALLY SOMEONE WHO HATES TOUCH (and clik clak and gold and sheesh)! obviously i also disagreed with a few of these but i also 100% understand why from a musical and less personal standpoint they're bad songs
Well after all it's just one person opinion, so yeah why bother.
Every person have their own taste.
And don't forget some song are designated for live performance, most YG song are designated for that, it's so fire when performed live.
Mantra was so dull and predictable. And the MV did it no favours IMO.
I'm sorry for your comments section, but I'm here agreeing with you in every song , I can't even understand how ppl like gold but ye i love Imaginary Friend too so ye at least we got that
What if someone say they doesn't like Imaginary friend but liked Gold ?
Sorry about what? He's very condescending himself lol telling people they should have their head examined if they think a song is good. Just be an adult and say you don't like it lmao
WHO?
MOONLIT FLOOR?
SUPER LADY?
I also don't like "my idol" by x:in even though I'm a ready 😂❤ and honestly I don't like mantra but i love Jennie and then dheesh I don't know about the lyrics 😅 i mean what? Sheesh !?
I dunno but listening to tick-tack by illit made me dizzy comparing to clik-clak by babymonster
Agree with most of them... But I actually kinda love Pinata
Meh. Agree with most of them except gold and touch. They were BOPS
9:55 i'm literally crying
I was seeing your points for most of your choices till you came for Touch. That's a BOP sorry. I don't think you're gay enough for it tbh cause it's for the girls and gays
ooh yea no it was good till gays came, its just music??
This video is just about your liking tho
Well, it is is his opinion...
Username checks out
Instant subscribe
so basically hated all major combacks this year? okay
p.s: not liking mona lisa is a crime but its your opinion so😭😭😭😭😭
also im not hating, just saying because music is subjective to everyone
My Top 50 list would beg to differ...
half of the songs he dont like are literally a few of the best songs 2024 and some of them won many awards. i should give this video a disslike but i wont cuz its not worth it
What kind of awards? Korean awards? South Korea, who?
just because they won awards doesnt mean theyre good. if the only argument you can make is "but they performed well!!!" then...well...it's quite a weak argument if I do say so myself.
edited cuz grammar
@Bewweekly no one should be arguing about this in the first place, including you, because it all comes down to personal opinions anyway lol no one is right or wrong in this, there's no point
@@cami_triz83 Is music one of the most subjective things out there? Yes. Does that mean you can't argue about it? No. My opinion is that a song performing well isn't a great measurement of how good it is. They're allowed to have their own opinion, and I'm allowed to have my own.
Best songs voted by 12 years old kiddos.
Dude mantra pls not mantra
Naur not GGUM
GGUM is so good bro 😭😭😭
Ik right