If you are a deer 🦌 and think about not eating another animal... It doesn't mean tiger will show courtesy on you and 🐯 won't eat you... The mindset is the one that makes difference....
Lots of cases only boys could be cheated . generation will be changed.even girl why can't be cheated a boy? Is the best punishment to boys..for the god sake
@@Efforts_never_wentinvain. Dude what the hell is wrong with your mindset. Cheating is not a kind of progress. Cheating is cheating and it is cheap no matter it's a boy or girl
She is the same actor whose performance has mesmerised the audience in Bandish Bandits! Shows how much a good script and direction is important for an actor to succeed!
Saying cheating is ok, is not okay... If someone is scared of commitment or marriage , don't get comitted.. You can't hurt someone because of your selfish interest.. We are free to make choices , but hurting someone intentionally cannot be termed as freedom.
A beautiful film doesnt attempt to be didactic or entertaining....it is open to interpretation....it leaves you wondering,questioning,pondering and philosophising....this is what this film actually does...thank you so much imtiaz sir....
10:10 That Bhojpuri Song in the Haldi scene! ♥️ Finally Bhojpuri being represented in the not so stereotypical way.. Imtiaz Ali is my favourite director. 👍
Awesome work as expected.. The reason behind not understanding Imtiaz Ali Films is " People don't know themselves, they think about others rather than thinking about themselves, our mind and heart is created to create wonders and to experience a lot more things other than daily soaps and stupid romcom.. Once you get close to yourself, once you start to feel every little things about yourself, once you start giving some attention to every action and every good or bad feelings or emotions inside your heart you will feel more alive and then may be IF YOU ARE LUCKY YOU WILL UNDERSTAND HIS FILMS.
This needs part 2 , to know further story and how the decision by girl affected her life. An incomplete story without a proper msg can set bad example for society. Just to know the different views of people , and people liking the movie are not sufficient. Every movie doesnt need good ending like the real life but such incomplete movies are definitely not going to leave good impact on young minds. One of the main traits of a good character is trustworthiness.
"Freedom" is knowing that you are at ease with your conscience. How can you achieve that by cheating? Morally, what's portrayed in this movie does not make sense. Strange ideologies.
"confused and being complex" has always been imtiaz Ali's concept and he made a lot of stories based on this.. but now I think he should make something different. We are watching the same thing from "socha na tha" till "jab Harry met sejal" and I must tell you it's been very long time since then.
It's depressing for me when the girl says she has a boyfriend but she is still involved physically with this guy.... So hurting.... This is the reason I have decided not to get married.. Because I know in this generation most people cheat after marriage.. I have seen lots of people like this....
Vo insaan hi kya jo time ke saath badal jaaye.... I think this is imitiaz ali's answer to all those people who are saying that his style of filmmaking is now done for and should do something else... Well i think the story of a man/women discovering him/herself was very well portrait in tamasha and now anything that is remotely similar to discover-self movies reminds us of it.. Especially work of imitiaz sir... That is why it seems as if this short film is just a rendetion of that... Ps loved the screenplay.. Reminded me of memento.. 🙂
Can relate so much to scared of being bored by my interests. I've just completed 12th and have to finally choose which career line to pick. In a way I'm getting married to my career choice... it's a life long commitment and choosing another one is probably just as big a hassle as a divorce because the careers I'm confused between are polar opposites... I don't know what to do. Hoping for freedom after marriage? Risky hai.
It's not about independence, it's about inhibitions of a human mind. It's all her insecurity about marriage. She wants to be free without any such insecurities and that is why she's seeking that freedom from someone who is not afraid to accept his flaws unlike her.
Miss everyone is afraid. Even men are afraid about marriage but that does mean you cheat. If person is afraid, is cheating or having sexual experience is only way ? Is it justified to cheat on someone who your are going to spend your entire life ?
Reminded me of Tamasha. And I still wonder why Tamasha didn’t do well on box office! Perhaps because that movie in a way removes the viewer from the seat and places him/her in front of the whole audience on the screen, effectively making him/her feeling embarassed because of own weaknesses. After all, people go to cinema to escape, and not face “Real Talk”.What a gem Imtiaz Ali is!
Boss👏🏼🙌 you go where no director has ever gone .... you play with most sensitive thing in a human You hit on their fear And revolve the society boundaries completely around unveiling the true face of animal within Fabulous director and amazing story teller You make your audience ponder That’s the beauty of the stories
To me it is by far one of the finest films ever made. If you look at it, he's shown this girl who believes in her freedom. Freedom to do anything that she wants and gives her the contentment and lover her life. Happiness is what you want. Marriage, manogamy is all what we are bombarded with all these years. With time should your belief, your approach to such things change? Should you believe in TRUE freedom or just live with the fact that you have to behave in a way after a point of time(after getting married) Love the depth in it and the brilliant execution and the fantastic way of depicting such a beautiful approach in mere fourteen minutes. You are a STAR sir!
Amazing it is... !! Woh Insaan hi Kya Jo time ke Saath badal jaaye!! Aur agar badal bhi jaaye aur time pe sudhar bhi jaaye.. usse woh Insaan kharab nahi ho jaate!! After all we are all humans... She wanted something... She got it..and wasn't content and sure...!! She tried and took the step and realized!! It's the like the two edged sword...!! Dono taraf lagegi...
Huge fan of the masterpieces Imtiaz created in the form of Tamasha and Rockstar, but this short film is seriously bullshit. So damn shallow man. This is damn cruel from the perspective of the Boy whom the girl is marrying, he didn't even force her to. The girl is cheating on just because she is afraid she will be bored ? What bullshit ? This shit is cancer. So was Jab Harry Met Sejal. Don't know what has happened to Imtiaz. Maybe he has lost his clarity of thought.
Four Minute Films Zara dimag khol kr sochie jnab insan galtiyon ki hi katputli h.... We are allowed to make mistakes to regret or be proud of them is our choice... It is a story and every story doesn't have a happy ending or an honest raja harishchadra in it... -love
+Four Minute Films - I agree with you. But the fact is that this world is filled with confused idiots who aren't sure what they are doing but do it anyway. Obviously, because they are coward and then all of a sudden realise they need to fix this and after screwing everything they feel proud of taking a stand for what they feel. Morons don't realise that they have screwed somebody's life and that somebody is definitely not proud of you being their choice. Sorry for using foul words but without the words, real emotions wouldn't have come out. lol. :P
What if I told you, he's a abusive drunk. And she hides all her pain behind the smile. See, it's a matter of perspective. It's a story of rewa, and the guy doesn't matter so he's no where in the film. :)
the title can be interpreted in 3 ways - 1) the movie reflects the time in reverse 2) the stereotyped gender roles are reversed 3) the photographer was always 'the other', not the 'way'. i feel the concept is a little too progressive for most, so it ends up confusing or hitting them! very imtiaz ali, this short :)
This film only reiterates my views on the dying institution called marriage... I have always held that homo sapiens were never meant to marry and spend the entire life with the same person...food for thought....thank you imtiaz sir.
very few filmmakers understand the nuances of life and relationships like Imtiaz Ali does. Although many will say it is the same old story and he must change his ways but that is what we as an audience lack and fail to comprehend. First of all its not a mainstream platform so why to make a film if a storyteller wont event experiment a little and go out of his ways ( however Imtiaz experiments in mainstream mediums as well ) and secondly it is about changing times which might not be completely reflective of todays society but does breathe somewhere in some places in some minds. In my opinion it is the detailed and non serious( at several places ) voice over that brings down the film.
What a concept Imtiaz sir. Master Piece if you understand. And punchline: Voh Insan hi kya jo time ke saath badal jaye. Then Camera rolls all the major events.
what nonsense. Why is cheating shown so normal in films these days? Why is it being promoted everywhere? With great powers come great responsibilities, when will the filmmakers and media understand this simple thing. Being Independent and being so selfish and ignorant of others feelings are very different things.
Manisha Shrivastava True. These characters lacked depth of any kind and giving them a mouthful of heavy dialogues at the end doesn’t change the fact that the bride is an ass and going to screw up lot of unsuspecting lives in her search of ‘freedom’. To make matters worse they didn’t bother to show the background of her relationship with her fiancé for her to think this way. Pathetic story line and dialogues and stupid voice over. Sorry not buying this piece of thrash!
How blatantly a cheating girl has been glorified here. I'm in long distance with my girlfriend back in India. I hate that i stumbled upon this short film. Paap lagega aise soul shattering deed ko glorify karne walo ko. Hell is a luxury for you people, you deserve worse. Whoever thought this film was a good idea.
@Shlok Chitnis dude am specifically talking about this short film , don't escalate things and generalise , humans are complicated so was the relationship there is always no sense in it . Get over it
Get some insights , if someone leaves you it is for a reason . Am no god to forgive , but i will move on . I know its hard but there is no other way . We must have mutual respect in relationship and if it meant to be it will be forever , or let it go
@@pri14724 who are you to say I can't.... Dumbass....... If you can judge me I can do the same.... Don't try to pick on me.... I'll screw you here itself...... Take a hike
@@randomindianguy7734 awww u got offended?? 😆 Anyway thank you for proving my point that no one has the right to judge others.you do you boy. Peace out ✌️
@@pri14724 got amused as how dumb people have become.... My statements weren't self explanatory to begin with so that it may support your logic...... Anyway....... I'm not at all keen on talking to a self-hypothetical selfmusing dim witted dumb fu*k like you
@@sunnshine....8713 pyr ka koi rule nhi hota koi insaan kisi ek saath khus reh skta kisi k multiple partner ho skte hain iska matlb yeh ni koi galt hai sab apni jagah sai hain
Am I the only one who actually liked the film? I think its not at all wrong. Psychology, precisely psychoanalytical theory says that there is a term called as 'superego'. It includes the moral ideas that a person learns within the family and society. It is the internal representation of parental and societal values. Nothing if we look in the broadest dimension is wrong. It is what we have been told. We have been told if a girl sleeps with 4-5 men she's wrong or a slut. Who decides that barrier? Anything and everything that gives you happiness, makes your life better and enjoy a moment is NOT WRONG. But what's more important is not living w a guilt. In the film later if she feels she is not contended and doesn't feel good then that's different. That is absolute freedom to do what makes you love your existence without having a guilt. Love this film! Imtiaz never lets down❤️
Actually I was experimenting with people who said wow or good on this video. If I hurt you then It's my freedom according to this video. :D Don't mind.
Ayyo ! To be honest I couldn't get the head or tail of this story. May be I am very unfit for today's world..the cheating world. One thing but I am sure is that whether it is man or woman whoever cheats it is not OK in a marriage or even in a relationship. If you're that much fascinated in cheating go for open marriage. Why destroy the life of an unsuspecting partner ? -- Preethi
I think the point was totally missed. This short does not encourage infidelity. As the girl says "I can do anything, anytime. No one can give me freedom", which summarises how the marriage should be. Just because she is married, she doen't need to seek freedom from anyone. She is free to do what she wants irrespective of whether she is married or not. And that realization takes her fear away from the marriage and she goes back to get married. However, if a person actually chooses to indulge in a post marital relationship or not is left to the person's consciousness and it is his/her responsibility to deal with the consequences. But marriage can not be a deterrant to those thoughts/actions irrespective of the accepted moral standards of the society.
It's extremely good that online platforms like youtube give even established filmmakers an opportunity and freedom to experiment.. it is kind of an R&D before investing huge amount in making films with new concepts and technicalities. So glad to see that the future of indian cinema is the hands of filmmakers like Mr. Imtiaz Ali , who r taking progressive efforts and using the resources aptly to experiment and evolve.
Thanks a lot for such kind words. We want to give absolute freedom to creative thinkers to bring alive their imagination. And at the same time, all feedback from the amazing viewers is more than welcome:-). Continue engaging with us at #BarrelSelect #LargeShortFilms
marvellous..! I think the most here are talking about the girl cheating on her fiancé is because they have not been able to decode the underlined point that the story is making. personal freedom and individualism is a big thing. it is natural to have second thoughts about marriage when you are afraid to lead a monotonous and banal life style after getting knotted. Imtiaz Ali may sound misogamist but he's got a point.
Well, who doesn't enjoy freedom . Freedom is give and take. Trust their is freedom in responsibilities, too.. nothing is impossible. Cheers to life.... Live life king size 😉
Yes it's Shreya Choudhary from Bandish Bandits! But did anyone notice Arushi Sharma who played Leena in Love Aaj Kal 2? I think they should mention the entire cast here.
There is difference between freedom and cheating. Marriage is a big commitment, why to spoil someone's life.
If you are a deer 🦌 and think about not eating another animal... It doesn't mean tiger will show courtesy on you and 🐯 won't eat you... The mindset is the one that makes difference....
Correct
sadi ka concept hi galat h, ek galat commitment se puri jindagi kharab ho sakti h.
@Vandana Pareek are you alright?
@Vandana Pareek oh great 🙌💫
When a guy cheats it ends up being in an episode of Crime Petrol .. But when a girl cheats it ends up as an Imtiaz Ali's sophisticated short film ..
Comment of the decade 😂🔥
Well said
Underrated comment 😂
Lots of cases only boys could be cheated . generation will be changed.even girl why can't be cheated a boy? Is the best punishment to boys..for the god sake
@@Efforts_never_wentinvain. Dude what the hell is wrong with your mindset. Cheating is not a kind of progress. Cheating is cheating and it is cheap no matter it's a boy or girl
She is the same actor whose performance has mesmerised the audience in Bandish Bandits! Shows how much a good script and direction is important for an actor to succeed!
Actress✌️
Good script? Promoting cheating in the form of freedom .
Shreya chaudhary
@@yashxgx its gender neutral now buddy
Very relaxed to see the comments.. thankfully people are still good.. and stick around good value system
I agree with you on this
Nice shika ji
Me also
i thought it would be a good film but it was fucking time waste
Yeah
I had the same thought
First 1 minute is the best part of this story😂😂😂😂😂
Saying cheating is ok, is not okay... If someone is scared of commitment or marriage , don't get comitted.. You can't hurt someone because of your selfish interest..
We are free to make choices , but hurting someone intentionally cannot be termed as freedom.
Exactly
absolutely
Bst cmnt ever.....
Fucking bakwas movie
Totally agree with u! What rubbish is this movie!
When a guy cheats it ends up being in an episode of Crime Petrol .. But when a girl cheats it ends up as an Imtiaz Ali's sophisticated short film .. 👍
Aayush Chopra awesome 👌😂😂😂
Hahahah correct bro
lol
Seriously what kind of concept is this
Aayush Chopra haha... true 😂
Imtiaz ali will never ever come out of his formula of Running, Journey & Philosophical love
Way too overrated as a director.
@@dhananjaymalhotra7854bro nhi, overrated to ni hai, love ki philosophy ko out itna acha smjhata hai
Wrong philosophy ****
The story was something about time..and wasted all my time😑
Really
Hahaha so true
🤣🤣
Useless story ..they are nothing else but cheaters
Yeah right. Total time waste
A beautiful film doesnt attempt to be didactic or entertaining....it is open to interpretation....it leaves you wondering,questioning,pondering and philosophising....this is what this film actually does...thank you so much imtiaz sir....
10:10 That Bhojpuri Song in the Haldi scene! ♥️
Finally Bhojpuri being represented in the not so stereotypical way..
Imtiaz Ali is my favourite director. 👍
Exactly !! That bhojpuri song... Great to hear that...
Feeling proud ❤❤
That extra auto-tune was missing
Awesome work as expected.. The reason behind not understanding Imtiaz Ali Films is " People don't know themselves, they think about others rather than thinking about themselves, our mind and heart is created to create wonders and to experience a lot more things other than daily soaps and stupid romcom.. Once you get close to yourself, once you start to feel every little things about yourself, once you start giving some attention to every action and every good or bad feelings or emotions inside your heart you will feel more alive and then may be IF YOU ARE LUCKY YOU WILL UNDERSTAND HIS FILMS.
This needs part 2 , to know further story and how the decision by girl affected her life. An incomplete story without a proper msg can set bad example for society. Just to know the different views of people , and people liking the movie are not sufficient. Every movie doesnt need good ending like the real life but such incomplete movies are definitely not going to leave good impact on young minds. One of the main traits of a good character is trustworthiness.
Flim Gheharayiya.... Part 2
This is what neha dhupia said"its her choice "..
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Ashi Sharma & that was so disgusting of her to address it the way she did ! She might be doing the same to her husband cheating on him 😏
@@chaitalisalian1820 as if you know it all
Haha moti bhais neha bhesh
"Freedom" is knowing that you are at ease with your conscience. How can you achieve that by cheating? Morally, what's portrayed in this movie does not make sense. Strange ideologies.
"FREEDOM" is good but not when hurting someone else!!!
And not when one loses one's moral values and dignity.
Exactly 🙌
Why Imtiaz Ali's brides are always running from the shaadi....
jab log ethics ke bubble ke bahar ate hai na...that makes good stories
His own wife would have left him in his wedding
He is paid to write so.
Bcz of his fake feminism.
May be his bride run from her wedding 😂
"confused and being complex" has always been imtiaz Ali's concept and he made a lot of stories based on this.. but now I think he should make something different. We are watching the same thing from "socha na tha" till "jab Harry met sejal" and I must tell you it's been very long time since then.
It's depressing for me when the girl says she has a boyfriend but she is still involved physically with this guy.... So hurting.... This is the reason I have decided not to get married.. Because I know in this generation most people cheat after marriage.. I have seen lots of people like this....
There r many guys who do this too. Blaming all girls is dumb.
@nishakanchan7682 I am a male and logically I can marry a female and that's why I am talking about the females... 🙏
@@yashwarke5712 even then ots not rote coz not all r the same, men or women
I liked this video only for Shreya , what a great acting of Shreya❤️
That's such a great lesson. But unfortunately a few could understand. Imtiaz rocks❤
Bhai samjha do yaar, meko to bas itna hi samjh aaya ki ladki cheat kar rahi hai.
Vo insaan hi kya jo time ke saath badal jaaye.... I think this is imitiaz ali's answer to all those people who are saying that his style of filmmaking is now done for and should do something else...
Well i think the story of a man/women discovering him/herself was very well portrait in tamasha and now anything that is remotely similar to discover-self movies reminds us of it.. Especially work of imitiaz sir... That is why it seems as if this short film is just a rendetion of that... Ps loved the screenplay.. Reminded me of memento.. 🙂
"tum karo toh chamatkar, hum kare toh balatkhar" 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
When a boy cheats it ends up being in an episode of Crime Petrol .. but when a girl cheats it ends up just sophisticated short film...
Dont copy others comments
@@pallabimaitralifestyle3489 truth is truth!!!
When a guy cheats he blames the girl when a girl cheats society blames her
Imtiaz your voice over was spectacular Bro
O:-P:-P-)-)-)-)-);)
A
Ssty stbrmstt
Can relate so much to scared of being bored by my interests. I've just completed 12th and have to finally choose which career line to pick. In a way I'm getting married to my career choice... it's a life long commitment and choosing another one is probably just as big a hassle as a divorce because the careers I'm confused between are polar opposites... I don't know what to do.
Hoping for freedom after marriage? Risky hai.
Hey,
So its about 1 year u to type this comment M sure u had pick any career for u Soo what was that??
Don't worry, everything will be fine , okay
Bhai padhai kar lo. Sab samajh aa jaiga konsa stream lena hai.
MUJY MERI LIFE K 14:14 MINUTES WAPIS LOTA DO...
Tu dabang 3 dekh. Tere liy wahi sab bana hai 😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Mary leya bhi mangwaly
Ho sakey toh un mein se kuch mujhe bhi de dena. Kuch bhi chalega thoda sa bhi
Hahahahaha
Best line I have ever heard, "Saaley, mazaa aya na use ho kay"......Lol
Independence. I think iss word ka bht zada misuse hora h aajkal.
🛎 logo ko pata he nhii sahi se independence ko use kaha kare or tum boll rahe hoo misuse hoo raha hii
Yup, I think if boy done it something like that they will judge us as cheater but for girls, it is freedon
It's not about independence, it's about inhibitions of a human mind. It's all her insecurity about marriage. She wants to be free without any such insecurities and that is why she's seeking that freedom from someone who is not afraid to accept his flaws unlike her.
abuse
Miss everyone is afraid. Even men are afraid about marriage but that does mean you cheat. If person is afraid, is cheating or having sexual experience is only way ? Is it justified to cheat on someone who your are going to spend your entire life ?
Reminded me of Tamasha. And I still wonder why Tamasha didn’t do well on box office! Perhaps because that movie in a way removes the viewer from the seat and places him/her in front of the whole audience on the screen, effectively making him/her feeling embarassed because of own weaknesses. After all, people go to cinema to escape, and not face “Real Talk”.What a gem Imtiaz Ali is!
Nicely put @Ravi. Thanks for sharing.
And rockstar also
Indeed!!
absolutely
😂😂😂
Last Master Piece of Imtiaz Ali Was Socha Na Tha :)
You forgot Jab we met, Rockstar, Tamasha, Highway and Love aaj kal
Wasted my 14 minutes.. Shud have watched the video from end to start... But wait... There is no gain in doing so also........
Better to watch momento movie
Yes
And at the end she marries Ajinkya Rahane :)
Heyy u r saying this bcz u watched it 1 year ago....now during quarantine u can watch it if u wish!!!😂😂😂
@@aishwaryashetty4837 i watched it now "in quarantine" yet it sucks big time, i mean there are expectations from Imtiaz.
Film making is beautiful😍
Hai na 😍 I too want to make movies I have so many stories
Boss👏🏼🙌 you go where no director has ever gone .... you play with most sensitive thing in a human
You hit on their fear
And revolve the society boundaries completely around unveiling the true face of animal within
Fabulous director and amazing story teller
You make your audience ponder
That’s the beauty of the stories
To me it is by far one of the finest films ever made. If you look at it, he's shown this girl who believes in her freedom. Freedom to do anything that she wants and gives her the contentment and lover her life. Happiness is what you want. Marriage, manogamy is all what we are bombarded with all these years. With time should your belief, your approach to such things change? Should you believe in TRUE freedom or just live with the fact that you have to behave in a way after a point of time(after getting married) Love the depth in it and the brilliant execution and the fantastic way of depicting such a beautiful approach in mere fourteen minutes. You are a STAR sir!
Come back to this video when your partner cheats on you in the name of his freedom.
Imtiaz Sir is already in 2050, hats off to story Sir!!
What a script! ...after all it's Imtiyaz Ali film! Spend a nice TIME !
Lol I knew I saw her somewhere before when I was watching Bandish Bandits. Regardless of this story, she's a very good actress.
Amazing it is... !! Woh Insaan hi Kya Jo time ke Saath badal jaaye!! Aur agar badal bhi jaaye aur time pe sudhar bhi jaaye.. usse woh Insaan kharab nahi ho jaate!!
After all we are all humans... She wanted something... She got it..and wasn't content and sure...!! She tried and took the step and realized!!
It's the like the two edged sword...!! Dono taraf lagegi...
Huge fan of the masterpieces Imtiaz created in the form of Tamasha and Rockstar, but this short film is seriously bullshit. So damn shallow man. This is damn cruel from the perspective of the Boy whom the girl is marrying, he didn't even force her to. The girl is cheating on just because she is afraid she will be bored ? What bullshit ? This shit is cancer. So was Jab Harry Met Sejal. Don't know what has happened to Imtiaz. Maybe he has lost his clarity of thought.
Jab Harry met sejal was still better dude, a lot of people failed to understand the depth of it..
Four Minute Films Zara dimag khol kr sochie jnab insan galtiyon ki hi katputli h.... We are allowed to make mistakes to regret or be proud of them is our choice... It is a story and every story doesn't have a happy ending or an honest raja harishchadra in it...
-love
+Four Minute Films - I agree with you. But the fact is that this world is filled with confused idiots who aren't sure what they are doing but do it anyway. Obviously, because they are coward and then all of a sudden realise they need to fix this and after screwing everything they feel proud of taking a stand for what they feel. Morons don't realise that they have screwed somebody's life and that somebody is definitely not proud of you being their choice. Sorry for using foul words but without the words, real emotions wouldn't have come out. lol. :P
What if I told you, he's a abusive drunk. And she hides all her pain behind the smile. See, it's a matter of perspective. It's a story of rewa, and the guy doesn't matter so he's no where in the film. :)
Agreed
the title can be interpreted in 3 ways -
1) the movie reflects the time in reverse
2) the stereotyped gender roles are reversed
3) the photographer was always 'the other', not the 'way'.
i feel the concept is a little too progressive for most, so it ends up confusing or hitting them! very imtiaz ali, this short :)
Can u pls explain d conversations in English? I admire his works..so would be helpful if someone could translate..
Nicely said Sohini
i think the title the other way signifies something else.. living a daring life.. just the other way..
Imtiaz Ali always make sure that what he makes is the best.
This film only reiterates my views on the dying institution called marriage... I have always held that homo sapiens were never meant to marry and spend the entire life with the same person...food for thought....thank you imtiaz sir.
I think you're a few of them who liked it ..!!
@@suyashsaumya1899 you too it seems...like-mindedness never fails to delight
@@tousifmehdi3707 yess !!❤️
Uff! Imtiaz and his stories (revolving around confused love), I think it's the time when he should choose some other topics as well.
As a Imtitaz Ali's super-fan, I am getting worried after 'Jab Harry Met Sejal', That worry continues with this short.
very few filmmakers understand the nuances of life and relationships like Imtiaz Ali does. Although many will say it is the same old story and he must change his ways but that is what we as an audience lack and fail to comprehend. First of all its not a mainstream platform so why to make a film if a storyteller wont event experiment a little and go out of his ways ( however Imtiaz experiments in mainstream mediums as well ) and secondly it is about changing times which might not be completely reflective of todays society but does breathe somewhere in some places in some minds.
In my opinion it is the detailed and non serious( at several places ) voice over that brings down the film.
I think, he tried to project the reality of affluent families in some cities of india. Though it indicated as an encouragement to cheating behaviour.
What a concept Imtiaz sir. Master Piece if you understand. And punchline: Voh Insan hi kya jo time ke saath badal jaye. Then Camera rolls all the major events.
isn't this the same guy from the LIFT by ida ali??
yes
Yaa
Yes pavail gulati
YAAA U R CORRECT
One word: Reality !!
Great work 👍🏻
Means ur going to do the same
So boys who want to stay loyal should stop
Will u be happy if ur husband do it on marriage day
Really engaging...beautifully handled and nice timing (editing )😉👌👌👍👍
Thanks
Only Imtiaz Ali can make this type of twisted film
👍like all of imtiyaz's work💎💎✌
I love the way you went into the Time Factor with shooting it in reverse. She actually didn't cheat on her husband. Brilliant!
I would love to hear your explanation on why you think that the female protagonist did not cheat on her husband (to be)?
Can you please explain
Yes pls explain?
yes plzz
what nonsense. Why is cheating shown so normal in films these days? Why is it being promoted everywhere? With great powers come great responsibilities, when will the filmmakers and media understand this simple thing. Being Independent and being so selfish and ignorant of others feelings are very different things.
Manisha Shrivastava True. These characters lacked depth of any kind and giving them a mouthful of heavy dialogues at the end doesn’t change the fact that the bride is an ass and going to screw up lot of unsuspecting lives in her search of ‘freedom’. To make matters worse they didn’t bother to show the background of her relationship with her fiancé for her to think this way. Pathetic story line and dialogues and stupid voice over. Sorry not buying this piece of thrash!
True
But nowadays no one cares abt love ones feelings
And I hate it.
Sad but true story of today's youths. And those who keep their dignity they are treated like a old generation person.
Manisha Shrivastava 8
Literally awesome story .. The content and story scripting was amazing and offcourse the storyteller was superb..😉♥️
I thoroughly enjoyed this film frankly speaking awesome 14minutes cool film....😇😘😘
In just 15 min this much creativity
Imtiaz Ali Great Work ! ❤
just loved it.........
How blatantly a cheating girl has been glorified here. I'm in long distance with my girlfriend back in India. I hate that i stumbled upon this short film. Paap lagega aise soul shattering deed ko glorify karne walo ko. Hell is a luxury for you people, you deserve worse. Whoever thought this film was a good idea.
Timeless! Also, I am reminded of shahrukh's role as a junior artist in om shanti om and how he had to die first to achieve life.
Awesome.........representation..,,kahani Jaise v thi..,..dhikhaya bahut ache se h.......
Anyone after Bandish Bandits😍
Wtf was this!??? Is cheating on someone considered as freedom!??? Hurting someone who is innocent for ones selfishness is not freedom!!!
Sharanya Bhat Watch this beautiful short film based on child abuse ......ruclips.net/video/S5LaMyw4kmk/видео.html
Freedom is defined for person to person ... May b u r way is not okay for some others , "other way"
@Shlok Chitnis dude am specifically talking about this short film , don't escalate things and generalise , humans are complicated so was the relationship there is always no sense in it . Get over it
Get some insights , if someone leaves you it is for a reason . Am no god to forgive , but i will move on . I know its hard but there is no other way . We must have mutual respect in relationship and if it meant to be it will be forever , or let it go
@Shlok Chitnis 😊
I thought it was JIM SARBH in the thumbnail! LOL🤣🤣
Me too
ME TOO.
I know, this is why I started seeing it in the first place
Yes. Even the voice in first line.
Same here.
Nice 🌷 line freedom koi le Sakta hai na koi de Sakta hai, i like the story plot👣👣👣
I just got to know that,the attender with arjun at 10:47 is actually the heroine of Love aaj kal 2
The dialogue " fir me buri kab banungi" , someone gets me, I can so relate. Lovely film!
Then your human values need to be examined and will be
@@randomindianguy7734 lol who are you to examine someone elses values bro?? Get a life
@@pri14724 who are you to say I can't.... Dumbass....... If you can judge me I can do the same.... Don't try to pick on me.... I'll screw you here itself...... Take a hike
@@randomindianguy7734 awww u got offended?? 😆 Anyway thank you for proving my point that no one has the right to judge others.you do you boy. Peace out ✌️
@@pri14724 got amused as how dumb people have become.... My statements weren't self explanatory to begin with so that it may support your logic...... Anyway....... I'm not at all keen on talking to a self-hypothetical selfmusing dim witted dumb fu*k like you
10:40 No one's gonna talk about Aarushi Sharma!?😍
After 2 years watching again this movie now i understand this movie
I can't understand, explain me please 🙃🙂
@@sunnshine....8713 pyr ka koi rule nhi hota koi insaan kisi ek saath khus reh skta kisi k multiple partner ho skte hain iska matlb yeh ni koi galt hai sab apni jagah sai hain
@@palwidersinghtiwana2877Bina batye kaise reh skte h
The song during mehndi was so real.
Am I the only one who actually liked the film? I think its not at all wrong. Psychology, precisely psychoanalytical theory says that there is a term called as 'superego'. It includes the moral ideas that a person learns within the family and society. It is the internal representation of parental and societal values. Nothing if we look in the broadest dimension is wrong. It is what we have been told. We have been told if a girl sleeps with 4-5 men she's wrong or a slut. Who decides that barrier? Anything and everything that gives you happiness, makes your life better and enjoy a moment is NOT WRONG. But what's more important is not living w a guilt. In the film later if she feels she is not contended and doesn't feel good then that's different. That is absolute freedom to do what makes you love your existence without having a guilt. Love this film! Imtiaz never lets down❤️
Did not expect this from Imtiaz Ali!! What the hell was this!?
Bachhe sa direction story is shit too
More aptly put ' what gutter sewerage' was this?
those who are ok with cheating just say the same thing when you will get cheated, life can never satisfy you have to adjust it
Best part of this video was the wedding song.. it's bihari local wedding geet . Loved it 😍😍
Excellent movie. Imtaz bhai
Yr comments pdh k LG rha h aajkl BHI bhut ache log Han duniya me. Wah. That's great. 😍
The Imtiaz's Voice❤️
Gaurav Jaiswal imtiaz or kunal kapoor?
bhai in chutiyo ko kya farak padta hai. Bheed ke sath chalte hai jo horaha hai woh sahi.
I see Imtiaz Ali then I hit like
Kuch bhi
Ha yar ye Maine video dekhne se pehle likh Diya tha - big mistake
Actually I was experimenting with people who said wow or good on this video. If I hurt you then It's my freedom according to this video. :D Don't mind.
Ayyo ! To be honest I couldn't get the head or tail of this story. May be I am very unfit for today's world..the cheating world. One thing but I am sure is that whether it is man or woman whoever cheats it is not OK in a marriage or even in a relationship. If you're that much fascinated in cheating go for open marriage. Why destroy the life of an unsuspecting partner ? -- Preethi
I think the point was totally missed. This short does not encourage infidelity. As the girl says "I can do anything, anytime. No one can give me freedom", which summarises how the marriage should be. Just because she is married, she doen't need to seek freedom from anyone. She is free to do what she wants irrespective of whether she is married or not. And that realization takes her fear away from the marriage and she goes back to get married. However, if a person actually chooses to indulge in a post marital relationship or not is left to the person's consciousness and it is his/her responsibility to deal with the consequences. But marriage can not be a deterrant to those thoughts/actions irrespective of the accepted moral standards of the society.
Can anyone please tell me where this background score was used before because it really sounds familiar! At 3:30
Hey did you find??? I am searching for it 😭
Got it.... Song name Hangover!
Started watching with such high hopes and now regretting it. Extremely cringey, senseless and useless. Na sar na pair.
It's extremely good that online platforms like youtube give even established filmmakers an opportunity and freedom to experiment.. it is kind of an R&D before investing huge amount in making films with new concepts and technicalities.
So glad to see that the future of indian cinema is the hands of filmmakers like Mr. Imtiaz Ali , who r taking progressive efforts and using the resources aptly to experiment and evolve.
Thanks a lot for such kind words. We want to give absolute freedom to creative thinkers to bring alive their imagination. And at the same time, all feedback from the amazing viewers is more than welcome:-). Continue engaging with us at #BarrelSelect #LargeShortFilms
*Teenage love story short film | Joshya*
ruclips.net/video/oXNztI9CeMA/видео.html
Choice is a choice unless and until it affects some body. What message u want to give through this film?
Jab we met was such a beautiful masterpiece of relationship
2:56 to 3:58 is just what I liked
Heart touching story 🌟👍⭐👍💐👍💐💮👍🌺👍
I left after 3.5 minutes. All that cheese I can't eat, and y'all expect me to sit here and endure it? 😬 Nah.
Don't entertain this type of films, thoughts, scripts etc... if you only want freedom don't get married, marriage is all about responsibilities
marvellous..!
I think the most here are talking about the girl cheating on her fiancé is because they have not been able to decode the underlined point that the story is making.
personal freedom and individualism is a big thing. it is natural to have second thoughts about marriage when you are afraid to lead a monotonous and banal life style after getting knotted. Imtiaz Ali may sound misogamist but he's got a point.
*Its not fair to cheat someone like that*
Watched full video to find sonething sensible but couldn't find!😑
3:40 plays the tune of Kick ❤️
Omg yes ! Tune of Hangover. Glad that someone else noticed it too
@@KimayaKakde hehe.. yes. ❤️
Tune of 'tu hi tu har jagah', still remains the best 🤭
@@KimayaKakde hey saw your playlist, 'nindiya re' is really a gem. It used to help me sleep. 💓
@@rvrishav7 it really is !
@@KimayaKakde you can try anuv jain sometime
Well, who doesn't enjoy freedom . Freedom is give and take. Trust their is freedom in responsibilities, too.. nothing is impossible. Cheers to life.... Live life king size 😉
Gora culture Desi Log!!
Narrated by kunal kapoor.. he is so underrated actor... but brilliant
I thought it was Imtiaz himself who was narrating :p
Yes it's Shreya Choudhary from Bandish Bandits! But did anyone notice Arushi Sharma who played Leena in Love Aaj Kal 2?
I think they should mention the entire cast here.
Nd also in Dear Maya
Demotivating to youngsters
Yeah