Nice list. The only thing off the top of my head is that I would replace Mind Grind with Sygg, River Cutthroat. Other Dimir favorites that I think would be very close to the 10 spot would be Evil Twin, Lazav, Dimir Mastermind, Sire of Stagnation and Dragonlord Silumgar.
I mostly agree with this list but I would knock down drown in the loch a bit because the floor of the card is nobody has a graveyard and it does nothing. I personally love the card but I wouldn’t rank it as high objectively.
It has a terrible floor but basically an unlimited ceiling and has 2 modes to choose from and it only casts 2 to cast.It's only really dead in hand the first turn or two.If everyone is playing on curve it should be fine.
@@vasylpark2149 I know what you mean though,my main deck is Rhys so the only searching I do is for ramp.The only tutors I could use are eladamris call to grab Craterhoof or enlightened to grab a token doubler.
@@SJamesGill88 I have a sissay weatherlight captain shrine deck. But I'm going to take it apart because it's so boring. It's just go get Sanctum of all, then fetch up all other shrines, then protect those shrines until you win.
@@vasylpark2149 My brother is building Shrine tribal now for EDH and I play a version on Arena,and you're right,it's just a very repetitive play style.
mnemonic betrayal not deluge...but when you play it late game, it can seem like a deluge
Nice list.
The only thing off the top of my head is that I would replace Mind Grind with Sygg, River Cutthroat.
Other Dimir favorites that I think would be very close to the 10 spot would be Evil Twin, Lazav, Dimir Mastermind, Sire of Stagnation and Dragonlord Silumgar.
Are you going to do all of the three colors too
I really hope he does. Hopefully starting with Grixis and Esper lol.
Love these lists. Keep it up bud
I mostly agree with this list but I would knock down drown in the loch a bit because the floor of the card is nobody has a graveyard and it does nothing. I personally love the card but I wouldn’t rank it as high objectively.
It has a terrible floor but basically an unlimited ceiling and has 2 modes to choose from and it only casts 2 to cast.It's only really dead in hand the first turn or two.If everyone is playing on curve it should be fine.
Of course it has no place in this top 10, but in the right deck a Consuming Aberration can do some quite interesting stuff :)
I think consumer aberration Should definitely be on the list particularly if you have clones
I casted it with reflection of littjara in play and created two 40/40 and then all the other opponents killed me in two turns
Good list.
Also you said deluge instead of betrayal
I'm not hurt by ashiok very much all I do is land fetch. I don't do tutors. I think it goes against the spirit of EDH.
To each their own,but combo decks use tutors as a cornerstone of strategy.
@@SJamesGill88 that's true.
@@vasylpark2149 I know what you mean though,my main deck is Rhys so the only searching I do is for ramp.The only tutors I could use are eladamris call to grab Craterhoof or enlightened to grab a token doubler.
@@SJamesGill88 I have a sissay weatherlight captain shrine deck. But I'm going to take it apart because it's so boring. It's just go get Sanctum of all, then fetch up all other shrines, then protect those shrines until you win.
@@vasylpark2149 My brother is building Shrine tribal now for EDH and I play a version on Arena,and you're right,it's just a very repetitive play style.
Circu is the dimir combo king.
I mean I play Stranglehold lol