Joseph Stalin in English AI Reconstruction
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 сен 2024
- This is a remake of a speech by Joseph Stalin before WW2. He was speaking to the ECCI. In his second speech May 14, 1929. This was one year into his 5 year plan. In this plan he was collecting all resources in an attempt to quickly industrialize. An estimated 6-7 million would die from famine due to the this plan. It has been rebuilt in English as a historical reconstruction.
If you would like to contribute to our work consider joining us on patreon. / timeunveiled
or join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @timeunveiled_
(edit) For those keep asking what tools I used to make this video here are some links. Hope this helps.
Voice Cloning - Eleven Labs - (affiliate link) elevenlabs.io/?from=partnerchen742
Audio Cleanup - Adobe Podcast - (affiliate link) podcast.adobe....
Audio Editing/Leveling - Audacity - www.audacityte...
Speech recognition- Whisper - github.com/ope...
Video Editing - DaVinci resolve - www.blackmagic...
Photo Editing - Gimp - www.gimp.org
Video to audio - www.videolan.org
This is incredible. As a blind person, it's never really been possible for me to read subtitles, so I really never had any idea what these guys were saying unless I read the speech transcript somewhere online.
Dude just open your third eye
@@Whaddle31you would been long dead if we did.
My brain hurt reading this
@@KJ33- Mine too!
Plot twist: He's not even from this dimension.
My uncle was born 100% blind, he was an incredible man. Nothing stopped him. He helped us shingle roofs as a kid. Being 14-16 and watching him lump shingles up a ladder up onto a roof set me in motion to never let anything stop you. God bless. Glad you can hear these speeches finally.
Putin’s 2006 speech to the Munich Security Conference would be interesting
2007*
Ooh, that's a good one!
try to find it on the internet, it’s whiped out, not even a full transcript
@@alexsnow5092 it must be on Kremlin's official website, they have transcripts of all speeches by date
it was translated for the Netflix Documentary Series Turning Points from 2021
This idea for the use of AI is awesome. International history can grow in new ways
We already have their words on record. Historians and other experts no doubt picked their words every which way to where they want to go. No doubt they even have clues about their tone and style of speaking. Still, it is edifying for common people to hear their speech in their language and tones.
@@filrabat1965this ai reconstruction is a game changer. Lots of lies about historical figures but now we can hear them and make our own conclusions. The Austrian painter’s speech was especially shocking to me.
Do joe Biden. I have no clue what he’s saying.
LOL
😂😂
😂
Theres plenty of self help english learning videos here on youtube. English is my second language as well. This channel has been great so far, lets let him keep doing historical vids and use the already established language teach channels for help with english. Good luck with it, some word spellings and how the sentence structure goes still make no reason for me lol
😂
Stalin really did have zero charisma when he spoke
Ya. He was more of a mob boss than a politician. I still wanted to make it as authentic as I could.
Truth > Charisma. Stalin was smarter than every one of the other speakers on this channel and every nazi sympathizing dumbass in these comments combined
@JackSardonic To me it almost makes Stalin that much more scary.
@@captainlamp2.076😃 That is the correct response. I would say similar to Putin he is not a wild dog. He is actually very disciplined, but he will rip out your throat if you threaten him or his plans.😅
@@TimeUnveiled_ what's the difference?
Kruschev "We will bury you" speech at UN.
I don't subscribe to his point of view.
@@E4439Qv5 Thanks Gordon.
Thats a bit harsh
Well, they didn't manage it, but the Chinese ARE RIGHT NOW. How about that?
@@leonardpearlman4017 um. They're not gonna make it. :}
@timeunveiled KEEP THESE GOING! You have done excellent work thus far my friend. Ideological differences and political interests aside, everyone should have the opportunity to hear these speeches.
I completely agree. Only with free speech and listening to others opinions can we truly formulate our own opinions. 👍
Could you please do Dr Goebbel's total war speach.
That could be interesting. 🤔 I will take a look. Thanks for the suggestion. 👍
That is just the Interlude / Introduction to Hitlers Speech at the Sportpalast in 1943.
Its the most repeated and overly represented soeech there is
The war was basically over st that point but i see why theres such a big interest in it.
@@phnix6242 If I recall it was one of his most theatrical speeches. I might be interested in doing one on Goebbels. I think people might be interested to hear some of his speeches as well. 🤔
It is bewt knoen, and i guess many believe Afolf Hitler asked if the german people wanted the total war.
But it is still bot a real full soeech its about 5-7 mknutes and is him introducing the Führer.
And even if it sounds impressively aggressive, i dont think it is a soeech that was as significant as people believe.
It isusually not mentioned, that this was more at the end of the war. And ive come across ebough people who believed this was like at beginnin or before start of WW2 and oh the bazis were so open about their war efforts…..
I think hitlers declaration of war to roosevelt is more interesting.
But what really decided europes fate was what happened the decade before World War 2.
And the dears of 1919-1932, most people cant tell you a sibgle event of that time can theyy…. But everyones an expert of ww2 and „the nazis taking over“
Like it happened over night…..
thats faaaar from the truth and the Nazis were laughed at and made fun of for a decade. But their policies reallly improved many lifes. And they grew from 14 foubdkg members to 13million.
But just like Zeppels / Airships
People are so manipulated, they Think ih ya Hibdenburg Crash
(Where most people survived unharmed) and thats the end of Airships. But airships had global routes. Newyork London Tokyo.
But ofcourse german ptents, had to be ended.
The inventor Rudolf Diesel who invented Diesel notors and ended the dumping of it into waterways, was also killed but hey he was already most likely killed in 1913.
Also world war 1 did bot start because ferdinand was assassinated
It was because the ottomans and persia would have had complete control of new found Petrol in the arabian penibsula and the transport to europe vis the Berlin Bagdad railway
Nl one ever ever mentions thst and how british operatives sabotaged these traintracks under construction.
Berlin to Istanbul to Bagdad.
So much of history is available, but majority of people dont look it up, they are fed a false reality.
Wow youtube just deleted a long reply a did
The censorship is out of control
Comments saying "he's a boring speaker" as if he's talking to an average person and not party officials. He's chastising party officials, not rallying a crowd lol
Who cares man, communist party officials were often elevated commoners, especially in the 40s and 50s after the many "clean ups" at the top level. He just keeps on reqpeating himself over and over again.
well I can see why so many died under his rule. Boredom.
Yeah people missing the point lmao. They always want to be entertained. It's like they're mad that he didn't have subway surfers or family guy clips paired with his speech to keep them occupied.
@@Bramblebush5948You’d be writing your comment in German if it wasn’t for Stalin and the CPSU
@@Bramblebush5948 👶
After 4-5 minutes everybody in the room was sound asleep.
Ya… I must admit I found him boring too. He was a bland speaker sadly, but that was the man.
its like leftist memes really. Just huge blocks of text that noone cares about
@@TimeUnveiled_It's not just him, many communists were like this. It's not just rabble rousing, it's also a lot of boring theoretic nitpicking and wordsalads.
@@bromisovalum8417 ya I think your right. 😆
@@bromisovalum8417 Ideologues left & right are guilty of this.
Just for you who didn't know, and I didn't but I just looked it up, the ECCI is the Executive Committee of Communists international. So he is speaking to communists on a global scale. The first time I watched this I didn't know that, and I was thinking "what is the relevance of Stalin speaking to Americans in 1929?"but now I get it with that context.
A good summery. 🙂
So weird, they sound more palatable when you hear them in your own language. I just heard Hitler. Its kinda scary, we have people in our country that are every bit as extreme as Hitler or Stalin but they dont sound as bad because they're speaking in English and currently don't have the same power.
Neither of them were extreme and if they are then America is 10x more extreme
🤔Ya language is such a powerful barrier. Even just English to English with bad intonation can ruin it.
@@zRythemHD We have some problems, including some skeletons in our closets. However I would not go so far as to say neither of them was extreme. 😄
Yeah, I know. The left is awful. So bad, they're not nearly as cuddly and sensible as Hitler or Stalin in english.
You are speaking about the wrong questions . "How" is a starting point, but "why" is a better one.
Bruh you a straight up dawg for making these. Please keep making them. You should do stalins “not one more step back” Stalingrad speech. I don’t know if that’s what it’s called but the speech he gave when the nazis made it to Stalingrad.
nazis didn't make it to Stalingrad, Wehrmacht did
@@marcwinfield1541 you know what I mean, nerd
@@roccos2311 only meant as constructive criticism. Nazi doesn't mean anything.
@@marcwinfield1541NAZI Germany was in a war against Hitler and they were trying to escape the political problem in Berlin by scattering all over Europe and North Africa. Maybe this will work on the yt crowd. It's a flawless evasion.
Charles de Gaulle would be cool
🤔 ya that is a good one I will definitely do that one at some point. 👍
Do these historical speeches from beginning to end. Lots of light to be placed on the real history of the world. Thanks for doing these speeches in English. I look forward to more!
These are super interesting. I have always wondered what these people were saying.
Thank you for putting these up.
can you do some Israeli hebrew commentary in english? like all the speeches inciting violence towards the palestinians?
Watching this after Hitlers final speech transcribed into English speech; this is incredible work and can revolutionize not only the way we receive different world representatives but can also greatly expand and challenge the narratives and caricatures we may have been sold on much of historical figures and events. Thank you for sharing 🙏🏻
C'mon guy, it's the Will of the Collective.
😂
Might have to throw this one out mid convo when I’m drinking with the boys
Wacka wacka wacka! Man, you'd almost think he was a Communist, eh? What dopey comments we get from the Libertarians! He's mentioning you-all in that speech! As "Anarchists".
Could you please do Stalin's 1941 October revolution parade at red square ?
Thanks for the suggestion. That could be a good one. I will add it to the list. Thanks for watching.👍
@@TimeUnveiled_ seconded.
When you hear the translation it doesn't even sound like anything more extreme than someone like Trudeau says.
Very well-spoken, plain and direct and he appeals to reason
Appeal to reason is very different from reason.
@@tabuculusromulus I didn't conflate those two things, I said he appeals to one's ability to reason rather than to hate or fear or whatever. But listening to the content of the speech, the argument Stalin makes to his audience is reasonable in its explanation and advocacy of democratic centralism
@@hsjshdhsjshsh958
You leftists are cringe
A brilliant concept for a channel.....subscribed.
It seems that all leaders, no matter which country they represent, speak of stopping world imperialism.
I'm glad I stumbled upon these. Very fascinating
The fact that you feel it necessary to start with that disclaimer says a lot about how deeply degenerate Western society has become.
Really ? How does it bother you ?
@@diego6849 "These reproductions may contain controversial, sensitive, or outdated wviewpoints and language. The content is presented in its historical context and does not reflect the views or values of this channel. Viewer discetion is advised, particularly for younger audiences".
Honestly, it's beyond stupid that it's apparently felt that such a disclaimer is needed. No one except a moron (whose opinion doesn't matter to intelligent people) will expect that posting an intelligible translation of a politician's speeches - be that politician Hitler, Stalin, Obama, Trump, Biden, etc - would indicate support for that politician, unless support was indicated otherwise. Especially not from this kind of channel.
Yeah, sure, if a known tankie posted this, or a known nazi (ACTUAL Nazi, not just "Slightly right of Bernie Sanders" like what the term has come to mean apparently) posted a speech from Hitler, that'd be a different matter.
It's like if the Borg had elected a spokesman...
He sounds like the vaccine pushers. They must submit to the collective.
By Presidium he actually meant himself, he was the greatest control freak and if you did not agree then you got the chop.
That's not how it actually was
Are you retarded? Stalin wasn't even the member of the Presidium of the Executive Committee of the Communist International.
@@kindlingking These guys really think they fully understand the complexity of the workings of the Soviet political system because they read in a pamphlet that the man killed 100 million people.
How does this not have millions of views
Too busy not knowing which bathroom to use
Uhh, the dead can't do much of anything in the Here and Now. But if Stalin WAS in power, then yeah--It might get TWO MILLION views? Three???🙄😶
Because he isn’t a nazi/advocating for the death of jews. People unfortunately seem to prefer those
It would have been much more accurate if a heavy accent was applied since Stalin spoke with a heavy Georgian accent and was immediately recognizable as foreign by the Russian people.
Let's be honest this channel has three problems: I bias towards you know who, a hate of communism and the voices sound similar. Still excellent stuff though.
@@JohnKobaRuddyfourth one is commenters who usually lack any nuance and deal only with boundaries of their ideology.
He spoke with a Georgian accent in Russian. It's weird to hear him speak so clearly
he never mentions anyone by name. there are just labels for groups and organizations, and only these have intentions and agency. it's chilling that people have existed, even at large scale, who thought this way.
Bro sounds like a Mr. Burns version of the Borg.
My eyes glazed over about a minute into this bore of a man. He was a big deal? Everybody fell asleep listening to him.
One thing this doesn’t capture at all is his heavy Georgian accent. Imagine if the president of the U.S had a stupidly heavy deep Appalachian accent, that’s basically the rough equivalent.
Stalin probably wouldn't be where he was had it not been for Lenin.
100% agree.👍 Those that win revolutions rarely stay in power long. Even if the first new ruler is kind and benevolent it is rare to keep that going for long. Succession has always been a pain point in history.
Yes, obviously
@@TimeUnveiled_Lenin was nothing even approaching kind and benevolent.
if there was no Lenin - there would be still Russian Empire, lol.
No shit, dumbass, literally nobody would've ascended to their positions without Lenin
I LOVE THESE AI VOICE RECONSTRUCTION VIDEOS!!!!!
90% of the comments showing that practically no one really listens to what the man is actually saying 😂
Stalin would make a great spokesman for the Borg.
Uncle Joe speaks to us in English! The man had talent. He writes his speeches and sign death warrants with great zeal.
Could you please do stalin's speech "No armies are invincible", june 1941?
I might be able to circle back to it after I do some others on the list. Thanks for the suggestion. 👍
How are you making these videos? They are a great learning tool for regular people and students of politics and history.
I use a number of different tools. 🙂I use eleven labs for the AI voice cloning, adobe podcast for AI audio cleanup, audacity for manual audio cleanup and leveling, and davinci resolve for video editing. I hope that helps. 👍
@@TimeUnveiled_ You are probably being actively repressed by RUclips’s algorithm and search criteria. I had to search very specific terms to get your videos to come up again. I strongly believe you will be popular anyways and would be willing to give a bit of money for a longer video.
@@purple-headedyogurtslinger2683 🤔I don’t think I am being suppressed. I am a young channel and probably just obscure. Still I appreciate the love. 🙏
@@TimeUnveiled_ You didn’t want to follow up on the money part?
I found your channel through a random website 🤷♂️ glarity.app/youtube-summary/education/adolf-hitler-in-english-ai-reconstruction-16428834_894519
He really like to use the word “collective” a lot
Ya… I wonder if that was intentional or just lazy writing?🤔
@@TimeUnveiled_ Maybe that was on their mind a lot! It was what they needed, maybe their only hope! The Soviet Union was "born in to a house on fire", they lacked everything, were in the utmost desperation. President Putin talked about this in a discussion once, we used to be able to hear this! Basically saying things were so desperate then, and communication and education were poor, they had so many disadvantages. Now (he seemed to be saying) we can take more thought, discuss things more. On the day after the Revolution, maybe it's most important to have propaganda and a simple ideology just to get everyone sort of vaguely oriented, have some function in society, be able to make some progress.
Collective as in (Majority of People or People that work for the Collective, the People) That's the meaning of the phrase if you didn't know, Workers to this day have the Collective mindset, well.. In Australia at least, that the work we put ourselves through doesn't go to the CEO (Individual) but goes to the Communities regardless of what job you have, and even equal wages for workers in the same workspace, as opposed to wage declines, gender pay gap, physical labor going to projects that benefit Certain Individuals, Empowering the Private Cooperates in attempt to steal assets that were owned by the state or Governments that the People (The Collective) may have elected, weaking their Tolerance and Democracy in not just only their workplaces, but in overall society in which the Individual will empower themselves to the extent of overruling court cases, dictate to the masses for their own Individual Purposes, in fact, there are many Individualist Factionalist Perpetrators in Communist Movements around the world that claim to fight for a Collective cause but in realistic terms they are only fighting for Individualist Anarchism which is nothing but a Parasitical disease that it's only objective is to suck the fresh blood from the True Communist and infect it with Reactionary Ideas through the blood streams across the body politic, in which would cause such harm within the Movements around the world and destroy the Theories of Marx and Lenin in practice, the word Collective must not be taken for granted unless you were born from a specimen that may have been infected with such diseases and it's brain smothered with dirty Cockroaches, then the Word Collective would not seem so Ideal to its nature, and it's therefore important to ensure the mass antidote for the Individual and the Cockroaches residing in him/her, get eliminated in order for a new Revolutionary World View that will seek Collective efforts to ensure that the Inequalities of Capitalism, Fascism, Imperialism, Feudalism and Liberalism don't fuel the conspiracy of such greed for self interest and that the Workers of the World will Prevail!
Ideological knowledge for the Uneducated.
I’m surprised how calm And composed he was, I really expected ranting and raving
And I’m impressed with how well his English was 😊
what a lunatic. Scary stuff.
Scary Stalin killed people even in his speeches , many died of boredom RIP
But you must clap with vigour
Fascinating. Great work on all these
Stalin was the physical manifestation of bureaucracy.
To the boring bastard who took Berlin
You are very kind. 😊 I’m glad you like it, and no worries I will do my best to keep it coming. 👍
And Stalin's mother tongue was not Russian but Georgian. He apparently had a heavy Georgian accent.
His speech sounds dry and tasteless. How many times is he going to repeat the word "collective" is beyond me.
Thank for that . Even if I’m fluent in Russian I appreciate that you do this work for us. Don’t leave this job .
Can you translate 1914 Wilhelm II speech?
0:28 wait only now have I realised I’ve never heard Stalin
"The American Communist Party lives and continues to live."
>*Becomes revisionist*
>Thanks Earl Browder fkin traitor
Who gave this idiot a thumbs up?.
They’re called Democrats.
Unfortunately and only bc they don't realize that communism has always and will always fail.
What a beautiful channel. I find it very educational that you can now see what impact a speech has on you when you understand it. Often when you hear these leaders from history, it's unintelligible, and you wonder how people could be swept away.
Here’s the true villain
If you’re a Nazi
I like it. I feel it would have a little.more character if the speaker had a slight accent from their native language. But thats not a complaint, just an observation. Well done.
This is amazing how close these reconstructions can get. Maybe try a Lenin speech?
Thanks for the suggestion. I tried his gramophone recordings. They didn't work very well, but maybe with a little more practice. 😄
6-7 millon, more like 30 million when you include the Ukraine and how disposable they were
Ukrainians were never the victims and always the perpetrators.
Truly diabolical
He spoke with a Georgian accent, which I imagine to the Russian ear would be akin to an English speakers appraisal of rural Appalachian American... so just imagine this speech with about 1000% yes haw and git-r-done
If you take a shot for every time he says the word collective you will be drunk before you make it halfway through the video.
What was Vladimir Lenin like? Would you please do an AI recreation of that figurehead in the history of Russia? Just like the warning said at the beginning of the video, the opinions expressed by the leaders of the Soviet Union or any time in Russian history do not reflect the views of myself and are only a re-creation used for informative and educational purposes.
he spoke english and also his speeches are recorded. he was very , very smart, and a fireplug, and most stuff he said in public was reasonable. however he was very willful and intolerant
There is a post like this of Lenin speaking on YT.
"higher collective" That's their replacement for god and it sounds sermon like when he says it. Scary stuff.
Next please do The Secret Speech by Nikita Khrushchev. This was his De Stalinization speech.
It has been done on YT.
Sounds like Dr. Breen speech from Half life 2
😆 I suspect he was based on Stalin. That or maybe just Orwells works.
@@TimeUnveiled_ Interesting theory. Half life 2 does take place in Eastern Europe which makes sense for the setting as well as the similarities in characters such as a charismatic and manipulative figure.
@@DonnyKing1 🤔some game developers can be really deep thinkers. It would not surprise me if they made these as conscious choices.
Reminds me even more of the speeches from the HL2 Beta, like dead on.
Breen had more charisma
Ah yes, Stalin the. GEORGIAN bankrobber :)
🤣I believe Yeonmi Park once said “communism works until you run out of someone else's money” 💰
I have wuite some doibts about her story. But that one is a good quote.
But seriously, Stalin with others did a full on Bankrobbery, or rather a cash-transporter heist
Usibg guns and bombs
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1907_Tiflis_bank_robbery
He was also in hulag i believe 2 or 3 times in siveria, each time convincing multiple others to break out and flee
He was definetely a hard ass Mfer
@@phnix6242 🤔 I knew he had a criminal background, but I guess I didn't know the details. History has so many gifts to give. 😄 Thanks for sharing. 👍
Yeonmi Park also said that they had to push trains in NK. Do you also believe this is true? She's a liar and a hack.
@@connorhall9326 🤔 I admit I don't know her work that well, but it is a great quote. 😂 Even if you don't trust someone we should still consider. For the most effective lies are half truths. For example you mentioned pushing trails. I could see them using handcarts.
Who are the Jews in the American delegation
The work of your AI implementation team us great. Can you possibly do a translation of Putin referencing the Ukraine invasion, or is this strictly historical?...if you can do it. That would be great. If not. Please continue the good work. Thanks
Please do some Abraham Lincoln and Washington’s farewell address. It would be cool to hear their voices recreated based on first hand accounts
Sadly I would need some form of sample audio. I could use a substitute audio, but on that one I am afraid we may never know.
@@TimeUnveiled_ Lincoln actually does have some very brief audio recordings taken of him.
How could Lincoln possibly have audio recordings?
IT IS REALLY VALUABLE WORK . TO LEARN AND SEE HOW THINGS DEVELOP AND IT IS ALSO FACINATING TO SEE HOW OUR WORLD DEVELOP FROM ONE STAGE TO ANOTHER . THANK YOU .
We're drifting back to this. Everyone submit to the common interests or whatever our global commitees decide our common interests are.
🤓I find there is a trend in history. When things get chaotic we rush to dictatorship. When things get too strict and brutal we rush to anarchy. It is difficult to keep that fine balance between the two extreme states. ⚖
What zero historical analysis does to a mf'er. They will see capitalism, corporate interests and think "wow this is communism".
It's nice to see someone else actually say this, thank you 😂
Fallen angels controls are nations. Seriously history makes sense when you reason cherub was prideful and got kicked out of heaven but was DESTROYED by Yeshua! Accept Yeshua as your savior
@@danielcamacho4166 I hate to say it, but I thought it was an original thought. 🤣
Significant historical figure, obscure speech
What are you using to do these?
I use a few different tools. I use eleven labs for AI voice cloning. I use adobe podcast for audio cleanup, audacity for manual audio cleanup and leveling, and davinci for video editing.
In summary: "just stfu and go along with it"...
And actually that's the summary of many speeches on this channel😂
🤣hard to argue with that. 🤣
Wow. This sounds like what happens when the pathetic middle manager gets power
There was nothing pathetic about Stalin. Maxim Gorky once said that if a flea had been magnified a thousand times, then you would have an accurate depiction of Stalin; a monster thirsty for the blood of humanity.
@@praetor9822sounds not unlike a xenomorph
@@E4439Qv5 Yes indeed.
This is absolutely crazy.
so many logical fallacies and circular reasoning... the message basically is "obey or else..." some people still consider Stalin to be a genius.
Ya I never much cared for communism. Every time I talk to a communism I ask them what would communism do when the titanic is sinking and there are not enough life boats for everyone. I always get the answer, but if we had communism there would bee enough. I am willing to listen, but it needs fault tolerance.
Knowing what we know now, these speeches are fascinating to listen to... Some of the most dangerous leaders of all time speaking to us from the past...
Could you do Degaulle’s address to the French in may 1940
🤔Probably. Let me look into it and thanks for the suggestion. 👍
It’s a speech for officials, not for a public rally. It’s like listening a speech in congress
hey can you do one of these about biden so we can understand what he is saying
🤣
HHAAHAHHAAHAH
Behind every good Socialist / Communist is a greedy Financier Capitalist. The League of Just Men were neither. The were Capitalist Strategists. Please go read "None Dare Call it Conspiracy" by Larry Abraham.
Sounds like don corleone
This channel is amazing
Austrian painter and friends sound more passionate than this mustache
That's because the channel owner admits he decided to make the video boring plus he used a video from the 19th October 1952 as his source, when the speech itself is from 1929.
@@JohnKobaRuddy be fair, the ai hugely improved his voice, he sounds like some critter in the original clip
He makes a lot of sense. I have listened to him in Russian and to me this is a pretty good rendering
One of the greatest scholars of famine (O'Grada) has stated that the famine was driven by weather, not by the communists. Sad that you can't translate the speech without repeating Nazi and Cold War propaganda. One year later the Soviet Union had a bumper harvest, and there was never famine again during the rest of the USSR. Famine had been a repeated experience prior to this period.
I'll have to watch this again with coffee on hand.
😆 Ya he can be a little dry. Still thanks for trying.
Hiding a small groups desires behind the notion of the "collective" seems pretty transparent, but without the freedom to speak, who could call out the obvious farce.
Can you translate a Biden speech next so I can understand wtf he’s saying plz
I am getting a lot of those requests. 🤣
@@TimeUnveiled_ I'm not sure that would be technically possible. -;)
Funny how they chose the most boring and legalistic Stalin's speech about inner bureaucratic proceedings of the Party instead of something relevant.
And of course the inescapable 🐮in the description about fictional "millions".
Well done. And kind of frightening when heard in English, the openness of calling for people to abandon individualism (freedom) and be subordinate to the "collective."
Ya… the idea of abandon your personal morality and just do what the party says is a scary notion.
He's talking about democratic centralism. It's an essential part of effective party behavior. There's debate and disagreement in deciding what the party should do, but once a majority opinion has prevailed, the entire party must adhere to what was agreed upon.
Without it, you get nonsense like what happens in the US where parties are ineffective because individual members can obstruct party goals.
This is a discussion purely about how the party works and achieves is goals. It's real democracy. It has nothing to do with people's personal lives.
@@ThomasTarrantsWell, by that logic, I would surrender my critical faculties, my faith, my moral edifice, my values and everything I believe in to someone else. Pass =)
@@pwrofrob why are you in the minority with your beliefs? why do you fail to persuade others? why should the majority submit to the will of the minority?
@@ThomasTarrants I agree that is what he was saying. not that I agree with it. still jarring for most people to hear. Western values place a large amount on individualism. 🤔
This Chennal is heavily underrated
Wow very interesting. Thanks
You’re welcome.🤗 and thank you for watching. 👍 I am glad you enjoyed. Ho Chi Minh next week if you’re interested. So be sure to keep checking back.
It really is diffrent in the language you speak. I would really like to hear what Saddam hussein was saying before they executed him.
well i could see why Stalin was not known for his oratory
I feel you but it's the words that matter, remember this man was in power until the day he died.Also Remember that he led the first nation to successfully resist the Nazis-all this while he sounded dull in his speeches.Actions speak louder than words
@@faraimusodza7641
You're talking Bad about Nazis
@@faraimusodza7641
You are talking bad about stalin
He had the 5 year plan, AND he cleaned not only his room, but the entire house! 😅