Her singing isn't impressive but she gives the song a somber and heart broken feeling that makes you remember her. She conveyed the lyrics better than anyone. You can fix technique but you just can't teach emotion. For me a good song isn't one necessarily sang perfectly but one that moves you.
+Rimu N Isn't that what the song should convey: somber and heart broken? It is a sad song. Both adjectives that show emotion. How old is the girl? She looks young. Give the girl a few years.
This girl sang on tune and sang how she would have told a story, with felling and emotion, like the judges wanted. I thought she was great, and I hope she continues to sing since I believe she is very good at it. Very underrated singer. Would love to see more from her.
All these people saying it was shaky because they don't understand that the song isn't about a man repenting anymore but a heartbroken woman singing about how he should have treated her better when he could. That's why it's shaky people, because the song changed its meaning.
Are you more qualified than the judges on the show? She was pitchy in parts of the song and you can clearly hear her instability. They commended her performance based on the emotional aspect and said her technical skills need work.
So good so emotional... She's only 14 years old. Don't ask too much. She may be short of technique, but I think she has a heart how to express her feeling. Isn't it enough for a 14 year old girl??? I really love her singing.
She is a diamond in the rough ! She never learn how to sing, does not know how to read music... but she has that quality of great singer. Just imagine, after one year of professional training.... she will be awesome !!!
even tho her voice was kinda shaky and she kinda cut the notes a little short but the way she sang the song was like she was talking about her ex so i cant wait for her to improve on technique. Very Excited for her
with training of course considering she had no experience in music what so ever and she she said so herself before the performance and after she said "i think i got off tune"
For gods sake her voice isn't shaky and she isn't emotionless. The level of music appreciation of some of the kpopstar fans apall me. If you don't know music don't criticise.
What I know is ... She puts all of her heart along with a meaning of a song and sang it out. Even her voices and anything else are still lack or really lack but ... I just cannot to stop her from singing because of she just touches my heart with a song.
Let's assume she was shaky due to the emotion for the song, even then she overdid it imo and if we assume she didn't she should work on that haha.. I really like her voice, but she needs to work on her technique honestly even if you dont take the shakiness in account. Her emotion is intense though, really beautiful.
She never had any technique training or knowledge before this so i'm confident that with the training she's gonna be really great in the ranking auditions!!
Ahh she has a good voice, and yes, her voice is shakes a lot. But it seemed like she was going to cry at the end. Like she was telling her story. I mean she's still young, but still. The way the lyrics's switch around, it was sad.
WTF? Some actually think she was "shaky"??? Let's see if YOUR VOICE won't shake with YG & JYP staring you down RIGHT IN FRONT OF YOU (while YHY giving you his perverted 변태 a-juh-see smile beside them), NOT to mention a nationally televised tv audience!! In that very setting, THIS GIRL ROCKED IT!! (can u? ;)
JYP did say that her technique was unrefined. It's only natural since she's never received any instruction and can't even read sheet music. She did rock it, but she is kinda shaky.
Asena Karadag Shes in JYP, she competed in JYP Sixteen...but, unfortunately she didn't get into Twice..I'm not sure if she's still a trainee in JYP though...heard she left or something...
I don't think she was shaky; the only thing that bothered me a bit was when each line of the song ended, her voice faltered and the words didn't sound like she was singing but just saying the words. anyone understand? but otherwise, it was great.
no this is Ada Wong from New Zealand also she is kick ass in Karate search You Tube for WKF Jr World 2015 Ada Wong (New Zealand) 2nd round vs Maria Pereira (Portugal)
She came back to her country - New Zealand and her taewondo competitions. Her voice is âmzing but she doesn't know about the melody, notes or any instruments :) She sings beautifully, but it's hard to survive as a singer if you don't know much enough but just singing. :)
+Bts_got7_ Seventeen she's not korean but she wants to be a kpop idol. she came to showcase her talent in order to show the judges what she's got; and in order to do that she has to show them her best and singing in a foreign language probably wont do any justice. languages can be learned later
The judges were totally shocked by how much emotion she showed though. She even changed the lyrics to a woman point of view so they were really shocked because she hasn't ever learnt music nor she knows how to read notes, they didn't expect anything and she showed everything she had.
She didn't sing the song very well, as in, it didn't sound good. Her voice is good, from what i just heard, but they way she changed the song wasn't pleasant to hear, and I just don't think she knows how to use her voice yet.
+Julia Chang 장은영 Dont think you know how to use your voice yet. I never heard this song, so hearing someone sing it , this way, was the first way I heard it. Maybe thats your predudice. Should someone copy the way the song is originally recorded and performed? Or make it personal and sing it the way they feel inside?
![[직캠] 브루노 마스 - When I Was Your Man (2023 Bruno Mars Seoul Tour)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Xvm9OvptJDo/mqdefault.jpg)
Her singing isn't impressive but she gives the song a somber and heart broken feeling that makes you remember her. She conveyed the lyrics better than anyone. You can fix technique but you just can't teach emotion. For me a good song isn't one necessarily sang perfectly but one that moves you.
+Rimu N
Isn't that what the song should convey: somber and heart broken? It is a sad song. Both adjectives that show emotion. How old is the girl? She looks young. Give the girl a few years.
Tori Chang Ah, my mistake. Thanks
Well said
The little tweak in the lyrics makes the entire song much more personal.
I love the clarity in her voice :)
This girl sang on tune and sang how she would have told a story, with felling and emotion, like the judges wanted. I thought she was great, and I hope she continues to sing since I believe she is very good at it. Very underrated singer. Would love to see more from her.
This girl just put everyone in the shoes of the song story and it just made me tear up and cry completely
All these people saying it was shaky because they don't understand that the song isn't about a man repenting anymore but a heartbroken woman singing about how he should have treated her better when he could. That's why it's shaky people, because the song changed its meaning.
i agree
Are you more qualified than the judges on the show? She was pitchy in parts of the song and you can clearly hear her instability. They commended her performance based on the emotional aspect and said her technical skills need work.
she has just sung a song, the shakiness could be her expressing the feelings in the song, you don't know, I don't know, nobody knows.
So good so emotional... She's only 14 years old. Don't ask too much. She may be short of technique, but I think she has a heart how to express her feeling. Isn't it enough for a 14 year old girl??? I really love her singing.
13 in New Zealand tho haha:)
She is a diamond in the rough !
She never learn how to sing, does not know how to read music...
but she has that quality of great singer.
Just imagine, after one year of professional training.... she will be awesome !!!
even tho her voice was kinda shaky and she kinda cut the notes a little short but the way she sang the song was like she was talking about her ex so i cant wait for her to improve on technique. Very Excited for her
with training of course considering she had no experience in music what so ever and she she said so herself before the performance and after she said "i think i got off tune"
the best cover ever.
This girl have a great voice maybe better than kpop
agree
***** رسميه عشان نتكلم بالانقلش! مو كذا الرسميه فاهمه غلط
+Dana Lay لاي تعبير مزاجي مااقصد رسميه رسميه .
***** اوكيي.. بس وين الرسميه؟
***** نو كومنت
For gods sake her voice isn't shaky and she isn't emotionless. The level of music appreciation of some of the kpopstar fans apall me. If you don't know music don't criticise.
You have an amazing voice girl, don't be afraid to show it ! Fighting !! :)
The emotiona in her voice! The facial expressions.
저 오디션프로에서 본지 여러해가 지났는데도 지금
까지 가끔 들어와서 노래를 듣는다 기교도 없고 노래를 완전히 끝까지 다부른것도 아닌데 듣고있노라면 내마음이 힐링이되는 이유는 뭘까 가수로서 언젠가 성공했으면 좋겠다
What I know is ... She puts all of her heart along with a meaning of a song and sang it out. Even her voices and anything else are still lack or really lack but ... I just cannot to stop her from singing because of she just touches my heart with a song.
Love this performance! I feel her voice came out well and really clear sounding
Ada 완전 엄청잘했엉! 추카추카 👍 so proud of u ❤️❤️ ill be ur no.1 fan forever 💓
anybody else crying because how amazing her voice is and i`m getting chills
좋다..
I really love her voice
I was about to cry
노래를 하는데 진짜로 진심을 다해 가사 전달을 하려고 한다...마치 내 얘기좀 들어봐 하고 말을 건네려고 하는 것 같음..와
I was so so so close to tears.. :(
Common she got a nice and powerful voice she s going to be between the good contestants I liked how she sang it
This girl is good👏❤️
She is really a good singer Bravo
wow this is really touching
awesome job :)
Beautiful voice! Great audition!
Well done, ADA!
SHES FROM NEW ZEALAND! WOOHOO~~ NZ REPRESENT!
why they are so fucking goood🔥🔥
LOVEEEEED HER RENDITION
make her a star,please!
Let's assume she was shaky due to the emotion for the song, even then she overdid it imo and if we assume she didn't she should work on that haha.. I really like her voice, but she needs to work on her technique honestly even if you dont take the shakiness in account. Her emotion is intense though, really beautiful.
She never had any technique training or knowledge before this so i'm confident that with the training she's gonna be really great in the ranking auditions!!
I honestly cant wait to hear her after training dankoya
+Natasja Ai Lin I would cuddle her, just like JYP and YP would.
She sings like she's in church.
I felt the pain...
Ahh she has a good voice, and yes, her voice is shakes a lot. But it seemed like she was going to cry at the end. Like she was telling her story. I mean she's still young, but still. The way the lyrics's switch around, it was sad.
Waaaa~
she was sooo good omfg :3 sure her voice was shaky, but she was nervous ^_^
I cry, your voice is amazing
WTF? Some actually think she was "shaky"???
Let's see if YOUR VOICE won't shake with YG & JYP staring you down RIGHT IN FRONT OF YOU (while YHY giving you his perverted 변태 a-juh-see smile beside them), NOT to mention a nationally televised tv audience!!
In that very setting, THIS GIRL ROCKED IT!! (can u? ;)
It's the internet. Everybody is a music expert. Did you not receive the memo?
JYP did say that her technique was unrefined. It's only natural since she's never received any instruction and can't even read sheet music. She did rock it, but she is kinda shaky.
yea its not she did awful she was amazing XD
actually that was her style of singing
Edmon Lacsa No it isn't. Her voice is shaky because she is nervous. And because she is my friend, I know that she can sing better than that!
i looooove her *^*
WoW !!!!!😘😍
Love love love love it!!
I love her :) Good job girl!!! Good luck in the next rounds :3
good job :))
This girl sounds better than Madilyn bailey for me I cant resist listening this
very good voice
I really like how she put this song into the girlfriend's perspective! ;o;
waw so beautiful voice :)
PARABÉNS LINDA VOZ.................
This is awesome!
she gives me chills, DO YOU KNOW EHERE SHE is now? Like where does she train etc
+Stefanie Dimitrovska
She went back to New Zealand where she is come from.
I think this one is better the original one
She is so good 😄😄
Do not know how she did not win ?
Me encanta
Hi! Can you also upload a video of Esther Kim with Almost is never enough.. Thanks!
브루노마스보다 울림이 훨 좋네요.
I love it, it just she have to sing it with confidence
she was nervous. but i still liked the singing^^
yg! jyp! i blame you for that!
WHEN I SAW SOOHYUN I STARTED SCREAMING AND MY SISTER CAME IN AND ASKED ME IF I WAS ALRIGHT
she good :)
oh crap..... the song from a woman's point of view, my god, it's really sad, she did great!
que linda
who cutting the onions. 😢😢😢😢
damnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn
Can someone tell me how long did she go? Is she still singing now? Thank you.
canta muito
Wow, she reversed the original song to narrated her side of the story.
I looped this for several time, it was nice but the ending was a bit rush, wasn't she crying?
where is she now
Asena Karadag Shes in JYP, she competed in JYP Sixteen...but, unfortunately she didn't get into Twice..I'm not sure if she's still a trainee in JYP though...heard she left or something...
Jessica Menya she didn 't compete in jyp sixteen but she went back to new zealand
she is competing under the Korean flag in Karate
I don't think she was shaky; the only thing that bothered me a bit was when each line of the song ended, her voice faltered and the words didn't sound like she was singing but just saying the words. anyone understand? but otherwise, it was great.
Crush: ...
Me: 1:17
A bit shaky, but otherwise it was good!
It give the emotion of being heart broken, so it works
Is she Minyoung from Sixteen reality show??
no this is Ada Wong from New Zealand also she is kick ass in Karate search You Tube for WKF Jr World 2015 Ada Wong (New Zealand) 2nd round vs Maria Pereira (Portugal)
gj ! (:
2:04 good
A bit shaky in falseto, but great voice!! Brunno mars' songs is a hard to sing though..
I remember JYP said she made him feel guilty as if he was the one who broke her heart. Lol
Can someone who can read korean telle me the name of this singer!!!!!????? PLEASE!!!!
Her dad is from Hong Kong (or just Canton in general) judging by the last name...correct me if I'm wrong
Esther Kim should have sung it:(
She was maybe nervous, i can see it she was nervous
the judges are JYP YG And who ???
A cover by a cover by boyceavenue "inception"
I actually thought JPY and that guy in black were the same person
what Is her name.
Ada Wong
bit shaky voice and a very stiff posture... otherwise her voice is good!
It give the emotion of being heart broken, so it works.
she kinda looks like L.E (EXID)
Version by Abigail Kim from season 3 liked more than this.
ruclips.net/video/-x_L8faJSfI/видео.html
What's her name???
Ada Wong
Found the full version of "Because of you" and also "Talking to the moon" that she prepared for the battle round on Soundcloud
Where is she now?
She came back to her country - New Zealand and her taewondo competitions. Her voice is âmzing but she doesn't know about the melody, notes or any instruments :) She sings beautifully, but it's hard to survive as a singer if you don't know much enough but just singing. :)
I thought she was Jessica Koh haha but when I watched she's really not Jessica XD
who's her name?
Rookies Airin Eida Wong
Why do they always sing in English??
+Bts_got7_ Seventeen she's not korean but she wants to be a kpop idol. she came to showcase her talent in order to show the judges what she's got; and in order to do that she has to show them her best and singing in a foreign language probably wont do any justice. languages can be learned later
I dont mean to be rude, but her voice is like every other girl, nice sung, but she doesnt shine over the others.
she pretty good considering she had no training what so ever...just my opinion...
She can sing but she doesn't show her emotion towards the song its like she is reading the lyrics in front of her
Not at all the emotion was there. Hence why the judges reacted the way they did.
The judges were totally shocked by how much emotion she showed though. She even changed the lyrics to a woman point of view so they were really shocked because she hasn't ever learnt music nor she knows how to read notes, they didn't expect anything and she showed everything she had.
were you not listening to her? she showed a lot of emotion, especially more towards the end. i thought she was going to break into tears.
Funny, because the actual judges told her she lacked singing ability but showed so much emotion in the song. I'll listen to the pro judges instead :P
Are we listening to the same clip??? That was full of emotion!!!!
She didn't sing the song very well, as in, it didn't sound good. Her voice is good, from what i just heard, but they way she changed the song wasn't pleasant to hear, and I just don't think she knows how to use her voice yet.
+Julia Chang 장은영 Dont think you know how to use your voice yet. I never heard this song, so hearing someone sing it , this way, was the first way I heard it. Maybe thats your predudice. Should someone copy the way the song is originally recorded and performed? Or make it personal and sing it the way they feel inside?