UK Should Take “As Many” Asylum Seekers “As Is Necessary”
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 20 сен 2024
- Talk’s Peter Cardwell is joined by Asylum Matters director Louise Calvey to debate the UK’s migration crisis.
It comes after Speaking Sir Keir Starmer said a Labour government would expand counter-terror powers to cover people-smuggling gangs and create a new Border Security Command to co-ordinate efforts to halt the crossings.
His comments came as figures showed more than 9,000 migrants have arrived in the UK after crossing the Channel so far this year.
In a message to smuggling gangs, he said: “These shores will become hostile territory for you - we will find you. We will stop you. We will protect your victims with the Border Security Command. We will secure Britain’s borders.”
Peter Cardwell asks: “What level of migration do you think is acceptable?:
Louise: “We’ve embraced migration and it’s made us stronger, it’s made us richer - it’s an inextricable part of our country’s history.”
Click here for more from Talk talk.tv
If you need any help visit: talk.tv/helplines
#migration #immigration #immigrants #asylum #labour
we dont want them here
They did not want you in the Colonies either, you had to be forcibly evicted!
@@floro7687 Those same colonies that were thriving under Euro-rule, you mean?
Or those same colonies we handed back for their service to us in WW2?
@@floro7687 funny how faux liberals ONLY have a problem with the British empire, don't care about any other empire in history. Piss off ya clown, it's 2024.😂😂
@@floro7687yawn …. Years and years ago and your still blaming now
@@floro7687 so You were witness to that person being there, grow up.
Most are not seeking asylum they are after an easy life with everything handed to them for free whilst the rest of us struggle to get by week to week.
This woman is talking utter rubbish.
Well said...
There has been no upward mobility in the UK since Blair came to power. Each generation is now getting poorer.
The tories could have ended Blair but just made things worse over last 14 years.
@@robertcreighton4635 All the same.
You mean since Thatch came to power.
True, more billionaires then ever and even less millionaires then in recent years.
Then every labour politician should house an illegal immigrant
They're not "illegal", they're fellow human beings, you fascist dolt.
If their asylum claims are LEGALLY and FAIRLY processed in the UK then their eligibility can be properly assessed according to UK Law. Anything short of that is in fact ILLEGAL and ANTI-BRITISH.
Only one!?
Well said.
Caldwell should house 10, absolute idiot. NHS is crashing, can't get doctors for weeks, crime up, no social housing and millions a day spent keeping them. Fool.
Heck, give them a hundred to look after and support.
This woman is mad and out of touch !!! Loony left at its best !
She does this to make her self feel good, there are a lot of people who find a purpose in life, it's just that some are misguided.
It's the Tory righties backing them up at every turn and protest..Real lefties can't afford to live, let alone keep paying high taxes to keep em in Hotels..
This lump is what this country does not need
if she wasnt earning money from it she would be against it
She? Are you sure .....
Lumps a polite word.😉
You are a person. Future people will read your posts and be appalled. I wonder want collective noun they will choose for your ilk
@@seanoconnor8843 Many people will also agree with the ops comments.
Blair created this mess,he has been very mysteriously quiet and out of the spotlight recently 🤔Come to think of it,where has Mr Cleverly been hiding since he became the Home Secretary?.Louise Calvey-do not give her any more airtime to spout absolute nonsense.
There is an International Arrest Warrant on him For War Crimes and the English would like to do a Citizens Arrest
1997mmmmm things can Only get better? most of you mugs voted for this the best is yet to come
@@knoxyishCharming!.Very narrow minded of you to call most of us mugs and assume that most of us voted for this 🤔
Blair is a war criminal, thousands of deaths due to that cretin.
I am afraid this is a bigger coup. This comes from that small group minority in the world who controls the money and the financial system. That is where this kelargi plan roots. Research, kelargi.plan and melting.pot. That is what this is.
We need to look after our own , fuck the rest of the world til we get our own house in order
...yes.. and the rest of the world should put their houses in order. The inflatable boats are just theatre, suggesting 'plight'. They might as well lay on ferry boats and quit the kidology..it's wearing a bit thin now..
With you 1000 per cent
Absolutely spot on.
❤❤
sorry, but she talks utter rubbish. banged on about deaths of illegal immigrants trying to get here on boats like it is all our fault.
and then she had the cheek to say why should they stay in France? because we are only a tiny country and we are full up already.
what she dont get is we dont want them here why do they not get that? no access no entrance why do you not get it ? it is not our problem
She looks like she has eaten a few.
The question should have been why NOT stay in France!
@@duckndive.😂 was just about to post that 😂
@@allanstack7016 Because they all speak English. Don't you watch Novare Media?😤
Richer in sectarianism and violence.
Saying it's made us stronger and richer just shows how detached from reality and in denial some people are
Bloody bonkers isn't it.
She should of been asked in what way has it made us stronger and richer.
@@tetraquark2402 She wouldn't have had and intelligent answer for that
@@172louis yep, they try to convince us of it by repeating it but they don't live in the real world like us they live in their elite bubble
So what she is saying is the government should build homes , more hospital schools for the immigrants. Put the rest of us to one side as long as they are ok.
How do people who contribute nothing make a country richer and stronger 🤔
Labour will be the final nail in the coffin for Britain
I will vote for anyone if it means bye bye Tories even Starmer!
@@thegoat11111 same destination, different speeds
That '' final nail '' was hammered home years ago I'm afraid , , , next is worse to come . 🤔
@@thegoat11111 then you're just as dangerous as the abduls and muhammeds
@@Maggie_n_Mitch23 conflict is inevitable.. thankfully
This woman is a major part of the problem.
she is THE problem
Correct. Expel the NGOs of all kind!!
Woman!?🤔
@@johncroucher9918you made my evening I rolling over with laughter,
Woman ?he definitely has issues ,I thought his head was going to blow 😂
Starmer is Tony Blair’s mouthpiece. Blair is the power behind the throne and Starmer is his puppet
And who decides how many we should have ? Who ever asked the British Public if they wanted to live in a multicultural society ? I haven’t been asked, have you ?
And who's going to pay to keep them seriously a stupid thing to say.
Don't forget the 750,000 legal migrants, only 120,000 of them have work visa's who do you think is keeping the other 630,000?
would not be the uk taxpayer would it?
@@edwinchaffin3154 You guessed it
Forget about the war, the pettiness, the reuniting with family....all that is rubbish!!!
This is a coup to end the white civilisation in Europe. ALL THE MIGRANTS HAVE TO BE DEPORTED. GET THEM ALL OUT! THERE IS A SINISTER AGENDA BENEATH THIS LIBERAL HIGHLY EDUCATED KNUCKLEHEADS!!! expel all the NGOs.
We are an island and half the world is on its ways & guess what religion they are
France is twice the size of the Uk but the UK has a larger population .
I think it three times the size. We owe these people nothing. The bring nothing but trouble.
Conveniently these lunatics forget that! Like saying an English village should take the same number of immigrants as a major city!
We've had 💩from the Tories now we're going to get it from Labour.
She wants the whole world to come here .safe and legal routes in English open borders
She? Thought it was a bloke 😂😂
She never said that.
@@SeanRoberts-c4oMe too 😂
Lab is out of date and out of touch with the UK 🇬🇧. We are full. Also these boats should be turned back. The other thing those losing there lives, its theyre fault not ours. We didn't force them to get on the boat's. Those who are already here. Should be sent back to the EU.
Sorry, how has it made us stronger and richer?
Imo it has made us poorer and more divided than ever.
It has united the country in believing our politicians are useless.
She want's a balanced discussion about immigration yet she is as un balanced as they come with her wild claims .
She is telling the truth.
UK has taken less than 1%( I think she said that or have taken 1%) Britain is much smaller than France or Germany! She omits to discuss overcrowding?their filthy habits which are turning many parts of Britain I to hellholes. Their refusal to attempt to assimilate, their demands(!!! ), their complaints 😠 The list is endless .
When are we going to be full? Will 100 million say enough is enough? This country is broke we are trillions in debt.
100m is actually cited in one of the UN documents. (maybe relating to the migration compact).
How many as she put up in her house 🏡 that’s right zero 🙄
Her?
@@leahashley9330I thought it was a bloke too.
Should be called Lewis.
She shouldn't be expected to do the governments job.
The Tories and Labour have no idea 😅😅😅
We need to vote in independents who will look after our interests,
25 years of complete chaos I wouldn't vote for this red/blue shower EVER
This is above you politician puppets. This is a deep well organised plan from an small elite that controls the financial sector. Please research deeper. EXPEL THE NGOs NOW;
So true, they are two of the same, the both fail every single time and yet the public keep voting them in.
Without the boat people she has no job
What a load of rubbish, we don’t have enough homes for family’s already here. We should be like Australia, no benefits or housing for 10 years u til they have paid into the system
Why should Britain take in The MiddleEast toilet..
she needs to get real job
Who'd employ her?
@@ProudtobeEnglish the alphabet lot
burger bars@@ProudtobeEnglish
@@ProudtobeEnglish the alphabet people
Litter picking
Refugees are in a safe country in France .
And all the other European countries they pass through.
Many of the Africans speak French and don't speak English. Yet, they still choose to risk their life in a dinghy to achieve their dream.
She has many sob stories
cause she is making money
Well lady what are you saying. 🏴 England lose your culture. Next step lose our monarchy. King Charles you are being threatened. Surely you can speak to your government. Our country is under threat we have a Navy Army and Airforce. Why not act
then people who pay tax, should be allowed to carry guns!
There are 50 Muslim countries they could easily go to instead. She is dodgy.
The law is that a refugee has to claim asylum in the first safe country he or she comes to.
Untrue. There is no law that dictates that a refugee must claim asylum in the first safe country they come to. First, if a country determines what is considered to be a 'safe county', it innately isn't taking into consideration the asylum seeker's individual circumstances and negates THEIR safety concerns. Secondly, you can only return an asylum seeker to another country IF THAT COUNTRY AGREES TO ACCEPT THEM. There has to be a treaty / agreement between the two countries before such a return can happen; otherwise, the return is prohibited by international and EU law (refoulement). .
@dorianissock732 how convenient
It makes perfect sense. A government can't send someone to a country that won't accept them, bas it would then make that person 'stateless' (a human rights violation) and has been prohibited by the Geneva Convention which was established 75 years ago.
Government expect us to follow the law. But Allow and encourage illegal migrants.Then reward them with housing ,food, medical, mobile phones ,bikes weekly spending money. And protection. They should be stopped and returned Before they get into our waters. What have we got an army/navy/and airforce for if not to protect Britain and its people.
"A few people" and they are all children. Hell, no. They are arriving in their thousands and they are single adult males.
Politicians should housed their invited guests. Not us.
I agree. Louise Calvey can house a dozen, and then we can house the rest within a mile of her house. When we run out of room, we can start housing them in Oxford and Cambridge Uni's, Winchester College, Eton and Harrow. Portakabins in the grounds of Chequers, Balmoral, Sandringham, Windsor, Buckingham Palace and Waddesdon Manor. Then in Keir Stammer's constituency, preferably in his back garden. Richmond, Chiswick and Islington in London, York, Chester, Bath, Bristol and any other hot bed of white middle class Guardian reading BBC gawping liberal fascism would then take their fair share.
or just build more units and houses. simple
We need to slash net migration (of all sorts) from 745,000 to at most 10,000 a year. The UK is inflicting self harm by allowing unfettered mass migration.
Absolutely insane. We have to take our country back from the crazy people.
should take 0
Take as many as necessary . . .? There’s something missing, it should read, ‘take as many as possible, straight to the airport, onto a plane back to their own country’
Starmer's solution to the migrant problem is to just let everybody in regardless of their status, whether they are here legally or not and to grant them asylum, residency whatever. What that will mean is a horrendous increase in the pressures on all services which are already at crisis point or beyond. Where will thousands of people who arrive every week live, how are we going to pay for them. Our hospitals, health services will get immensely worse through the pressure of sheer numbers demanding attention. Schools will be swamped with children who have little or no education and cannot speak English and will thus take up nearly all the time of the teachers. We already have terrible problems with the knife culture which has invaded this country, we are seeing a re-emergence of many serious illnesses that were previously eradicated in this country now sweeping the population because of the huge numbers of immigrants who have had no vaccinations and many refuse to be vaccinated because of a culture of fear in their own country.
I don't think Starmer will let everyone in. I hope he will fix the asylum system which the Tories broke.
@@MrRailjunkie it was Labour who created the problem in the first place with Blair and Campbell wanting to rub the rights noses in diversity. It was Starmer who has repeatedly opposed and fought against every measure to curb immigration. It is the civil service and leftie immigration lawyers who have thwarted and grown fat off the back of delaying repeatedly dealing with immigration applications or appealing against every rejection. Nothing to do with the Tories.
@Goldenlion148 sure let's just ignore the fact the Tories have been in power for 14 years & have broken every promise they made.
@@MrRailjunkie The whole problem was started by TonyBlair/Alistair Campbell. Starmer will let everyone in and grant them asylum just so he can say he has fixed the system and there are no backlogs. It is was not for the Labour Party fighting everything the Tories have tried to do to control immigration. The leftie civil service and House of Lords also put up barriers and obstacles to implementing all asylum controls. The system is broken by left wing opposition to any controls on immigration because it is against their mantra to destroy this country.
He wants these people in and stopping deporting by plane, Labour do what they want NOT what the public want.
Louise, you mean?
All of her/his points are irrelevnt because we do not want them here
because they are not skinfolks?
@@Tayl-top Because they are illegal economic chancers.
the necessary number is ZERO
Less than zero as we should be evicting!
@@lal2300 I was including the ones here, but lets agree and also include Windrush
Why don't they stay in France?..... BENEFITS
Most come from Albania, iran. Turkey, Sudan. Somalia etc etc theyre not 'refugees'
she is earning money that is all she is bothered about
She should take them all in her house..if she wants them stupid woman..
That sorry excuse for a human is one reason why we are in this mess,, 77million people in England/wales/scotland all the houses/hotls are full where are they soposed to live
She wants to encourage this crap, that's how she makes a living. Asylum matters advertised for a deputy director last September, salary £42,750 !!!!!
She's lucky she didn't lose out to a diversity hire 🤷🏻♂️
How about looking after the British people for a change because our country is so lost our people are lost ...our culture is very lost...we are declining fast....
This bog monster is the embodiment of everything that has ruined this once great nation. Make exile great again.
why do they all throw there passports in to the channel
CUS THEY DONT WANT TO BE IDENTIFIED AND THEY HAVE SOMETHING TO HIDE.
We should stop making it so comfortable for them. Simon Harris in Ireland is moving them out of tents and into some facility somewhere. WHY?!!?!?!?! that just leaves room for the next batch. Stop giving them money! They come here ILLEGALLY and we give them money!!
Nice bait. But nah, there’s no automatic right to stay here.
she forget to mention the size of the uk compared to germany and france
Put it to The British people in a referendum and find the answer.
Yeah while there's some of us left....much more and grimigrants will be voting for themselves
Illegal Immigrants not Asylum seekers, this country is full.
The issue is the social integration when they’re here, most of them don’t want to assimilate into British society. London is the perfect example.
I'll take a guess that the They/Them doesn't have any children to worry about.
I don’t care what this lady says we live in a democracy and not many people want them here FACT. Thirteen Million pound a day and counting.
I think it's 7 million a day now...
Let the Labour MP's take 2 or 3 in to show an example...
And go to jail when the first crime is committed!
@@lal2300 Love it!
Then all those politicians who agree this should take them into their homes and save the ta payer’s money.
The only thing that will stop the boats is more visas, hmmm I can think of a couple things that would stop them.
I am voting reform uk 🇬🇧🇬🇧
Labour -disaster
Conservative -weak
Reform-strong& loves uk plus has a plan
The English will continue to whine and complain but won't lift a finger to stop this policy....only the Irish have to balls to stand up against it, and they always have done.
oh please the Irish have welcomed their servitude for the last 20 years
Blue steel..totally agree, why aren't there thousands or tens of thousands blockading the ports where these illegals are brought in when picked up by boarder force / RNLI, block the routes so no one can leave, but the Brits would sooner get on their computers and whine, but never actually do something..
There is already 3x the number of immigrants to houses built. It just doesn’t work. Start with net zero migration. Vote reform.
So what exactly can the English do to stop them without breaking any International Laws ?
Nonsense. The Irish are doing it NOW because they think it has come via ENGLAND. So they are ONLY FIGHTING because they think that it will “feck the English” if they make a fuss and they will return the recent arrivals to ENGLAND.
If the Irish said we have done a deal to send them to France.
The Irish would say “nah we will keep them…it was only because we hate the English more than anything”.
It’s exactly the same as the Palestine situation.
If Japan, America, Egypt or Brazil started BOMBING the crap out of Gaza and killed 99.99999999 percent of population of Gaza.
There wouldn’t be ONE March.
Not ONE flag. NOT one person would say a thing. Just like Sudan, Afghanistan, Syria, Yemen. NOTHING
It’s because it’s the Jews.
The Irish have done nothing for years and have been sending their millions of people (not products, just Irish people) to England and Europe for decades.
Irish ARE the invasion and immigrants into England and the rest of Europe.
They’ve been doing it for centuries.
No one has whines about it. They have been welcomed in every country on earth. The English, Americans and most other immigrants are NOT welcomed.
Ireland has never had waves of immigrants - they have had waves of emigrants.
I can't even get a council flat why i work i am British i am single in other words i don't count
You make a good point, I hope you get the help you deserve and soon
Its a fucking disgrace
She lost her mind , come to London and have a look. It's like Rwanda
I think anyone that signs up to be legally and financially responsible for an asylum seeker should be on a list so we can drop people off to them. I wonder how many Louise Calvey will sign up for?
OH SHUT IT ALREADY. Im a immigrant.. and i had to jumps through hoops and pay fees and go send my paperwork in order with forms every 2years if not every year.. im from Africa and ulive managed to find a route..sure it took me a long time and i had to work 80 + hours a week for years and years but im a women and i did it.
If they died in the channel ..that was there CHOICE.. their action, their consequences
What's your point?
Should there not be a safer passage for people to get the proper visa entry?
Or do you agree to have strict measures in place which will leave no other choice for others to take huge risks attempting to enter?
@AtTaulibah there are ways to get here legally, safely..so there is no need to put themselves at risk. They can apply from elsewhere.. and I wonder..maybe they do it like this because they know they don't qualify and have criminal records. The should all apply fro. Outside tge countey.
Starmer will grant amnesty to illegal immigrants if he wins election
@@AtTaulibahThere are safe and legal routes you idiot. We take several hundred thousands in by legal safe routes every year! Stop lying and learn some facts!
what planet does she live on whatever she is smoking is certainly working.
She’s a man hater
Maybe if we didn't spend £8 Million a week or more housing and paying for migrants, we COULD improve our infrastructure and hospitals, or is that just me?
That figure apparently is now around ten million PER DAY!!!! Previous lower figures were always quoting per day, never per week.
£ 8m per day
She talks a load of s**t we dont want or need them I'm sick of been screwed by the tax man and have nothing
This woman is nuts😮
That's easily done... none are necessary so take NONE!!
Why do these young men flee here from danger, but abandon their women and children to be persecuted at home alone ?
Because either there is no danger or they are cowards! We all know it is the former which is why they destroy their passports a they know they are not in any danger and would not qualify for assylum! Strange how they come with no money, clothes etc.but found several thousands to pay the traffickers! Or are the Iranians funding their invasion army and the boats?
We took as many as necessary 50 years ago.
Please, God, help us 🙏
Well with people like her we do really do need Gods help…
So it’s not about safety it is about being in the same country as a relative
That woman talks utter bollocks.
she is encouraging people to risk the channel . They won't come if they know they cant stay . Simple
france is 2.3x the land mass of the uk with a lower population. is this not a massive point ?
This is the problem and no one is bringing this up we are a small island
This women is stupid we are a small island with small land mass and lack of infrastructure here
"Immigration has made us stronger and richer" and yet there is more division than ever in the UK.
We have had mass immigration for 20 years and yet the growth in the economy , which we were told it would bring, has flatlined in that period so how are we "richer".
She should be a politician as she can give replies but point blankly refuses to give any answers
Mainly because it’s made homeowners richer and they then spend more money.
@@Lifelongloser So why has economic growth has been so poor.
Where are all these people going to live? Where are all these people going to work? Where are the school places for all these people? What will happen to the rates of pay when all these people need jobs. The poor will suffer. Anyone voting Labour is a traitor.
This woman never answers why these people have the right to come here FROM FRANCE, which is a safe country. She can pay these people to stay at her house if she wants to.
These people aren't affected by mass migration it's the normal working classes in the UK both the legal migrant workers and settled or indigenous nationals.thatvare affected .they haven't a clue as they don't live in our world. Labour have abandoned the working class
She needs to get her maths right We have taken more than any other Country in the EU up to now
Hope labour dont get in
Why should we take as many as necessary for what purpose ?
The UK has a land area of about 300,000 km2, which is about the size of an average US state, and one of the largest countries in Europe by area. The UK has a population of about 70 million people, which is about twice as much as the most populous US state and bigger than most of the 50 countries in Europe.15 Oct 2023
As necessary. Equals zero.
but the doctors and teachers lol
His record as Attorney General shows how good he is at stopping things from happening
Why don't theae people fight for the rights they want like our ancestors did
No one sorted out our country for us, we fought to get where we are. All these migrant men never fight for their country to improve things, they just run away and leave the women and children behind because they are weak cowards and only care about themselves!
That woman is obviously lying and she knows she is lying and we know she is lying and she knows we know she is lying but she keeps on lying anyway
What did she lie about? What is the truth?
Every thing she said was a lie
@@MrRailjunkie everything she said was a lie so nothing she said was the truth
You tell me what the truth is that she spoke and that would be the lie
@russellwilliams1163 tell me why she was wrong.
Keir Starmer! What a Pratt!
I actually think ONE is TOO MANY!!!
You can't apply for asylum while you're already in the country, they can go back to france and apply from there
We have no homes , no services , no money , full stop keep them out. Send to other Muslim countries who have the same thoughts and beliefs
Bet shes never walked around luton, Bradford, Birmingham, Leicester, london etc we are certainly losing oir culture and soon the whole country
I left Oldham because I wanted to live in England.