🎹Yamaha P45 vs Roland FP10 Digital Piano Review, Comparison, & Demo🎹
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 17 июл 2024
- 🛒 Get the Yamaha P45 Digital Piano▸geni.us/Yamaha-P45
🛒 Get the Roland FP10 Digital Piano▸geni.us/Roland-FP10
0:00 - Intro
2:02 - Sound
15:56 - Action
22:54 - Features
🛒 Get the Yamaha P45 Digital Piano▸geni.us/Yamaha-P45
🛒 See More Yamaha Digital Pianos▸ geni.us/Yamaha-Digital-Pianos
🛒 See More Roland Digital Pianos▸ geni.us/Roland-Digital-Pianos
🍁For Canadian Customers Click Here for the Roland FP-10▸www.merriammusic.com/product/...
💕 Subscribe to Merriam Pianos HERE ▸ bit.ly/SubscribeMerriam
🔔 Click the 🔔 bell to be notified of all videos! ▸ bit.ly/SubscribeMerriam
Alternative Options - Comparable Digital Pianos
🛒 Korg B2▸geni.us/Korg-B2
🛒 Kawai ES110▸geni.us/Kawai-ES110
🛒 Casio PX-S1000▸geni.us/Casio-PX-S1000
🛒 Yamaha P-125▸geni.us/Yamaha-P125
🛒 Casio PX160▸geni.us/Casio-PX160
🛒 Yamaha P-115▸geni.us/Yamaha-P115
🛒 Roland FP-30▸geni.us/Roland-FP30
🛒 Roland Go▸geni.us/Roland-Go
#P45 #FP10 #Yamaha
Hello everyone and welcome to another comparison video here at Merriam Pianos. Today, we’re going to be comparing two titans of the entry level market, the Roland FP10 and the Yamaha P45. This video has been requested several times in the comment threads of our other videos, so we’re really excited to have this for you.
Given that these two instruments are priced almost exactly the same, and frankly look very similar, some people might assume that they’re essentially going to deliver the same experience. This is definitely not the case, and we’re going to outline exactly what sets these instruments apart in this video.
Tone Engine and Sound:
The Yamaha P45 uses Yamaha’s AWS synthesis which sounds reasonably full, albeit if a little bit on the brighter side, though this tends to be the case with Yamaha’s acoustic pianos as well. There are 2 speakers with 6 watts of power each, which should be enough for home use, especially given that the piano only weighs about 25 lbs. You will be able to get a better tone using a set of headphones, but the speakers should still be adequate for most solo playing. Polyphony on the P45 is 64, which is on the lower side of what is generally available among any digital piano available on the market.
The Roland FP10 uses Roland’s SuperNATURAL sound engine, and features 96 note polyphony. Despite the exact same power output with two 6 watt speakers, the FP10 sounds noticeably more complex than the P45. The FP10 is also fully compatible with Roland’s Piano Designer app via Bluetooth MIDI, which opens up a host of editable parameters, such as string resonance and lid opening position.
Piano Action:
The P45 features Yamaha’s GHS action. This is an action that Yamaha has been using on their instruments for a little while now. This action is on the simpler side in terms of what’s available on the market, and this is especially apparent when playing it against the FP10. A real positive about this action is there’s very little lateral motion, meaning the key doesn’t knock back and forth when depressed. This action does not feature escapement, which won’t matter to some, but may be a drawback to someone who is used to playing on a grand piano. Another thing to note is that the GHS uses a double sensor. For a lot of use this is sufficient, but if your intention was to say use the P45 as a controller to trigger MIDI samples, the double sensor won’t deliver a particularly accurate MIDI output for professional use.
Piano Features:
When it comes to the peripherals and accessories that these two pianos come with, there’s lots of similarities to be found. Both instruments come with a plastic music desk, essentially the same powered speakers, both are compatible with a matching wooden stand, and neither instrument is compatible with a triple pedal unit. The standard sustain pedals included with both instruments don’t really move the needle too much, so it’s definitely a good idea to upgrade to one of the better sustain pedal options each manufacturer offers.
Conclusions:
First of all, there’s going to be some subjective preference for one piano’s sound versus the other. Beyond that, if you’re someone who has traditionally gone with Yamaha due to past experience or the general perception that they make great products, the P45 probably won’t disappoint. With that being said, if you’re open to other options, for about the same price, the FP10 is going to provide a superior action, more complex tone, and the convenience of a Bluetooth radio.
Connect with Merriam Music:
● Website ▸ www.merriammusic.com/
● Contact Us ▸ www.merriammusic.com/contact/
● Instagram ▸ / merriammusic
● Facebook ▸ / merriammusic
● Twitter ▸ / merriammusicinc 
Видеоклипы
This review is on point. I am just starting to make my dreams come true by learning how to play the piano and looking into these two specific brands. I would definitely go for Roland, I’ve worked so hard over the years to save for this and I will not let this pandemic stop me from making my way into a pianist someday. Thank you, Sir!
Best of luck, and thanks for sharing your journey to your piano!
I agree. I’ve been looking at the two pianos for about a month now and this video helped me finally make a decision. Going with the Roland.
@@Gundam-bruh did you get the Roland FP10? how its been?
@@morF1ni sure did. I can’t say anything that was already said in the video other than I don’t regret buying it at all. It’s a great piano for me, as a beginner that is taking my learning seriously.
Yo, 2yrs later how are you getting on?
This channel is underrated. I bought a FP10 a few months ago, and I am completely in love with it. I've seen so many videos from other reviewers, comparisons, etc. and they are nowhere near as complete as this one.
We really appreciate that incredible review! Thanks so much for the kind words and for supporting our channel! Enjoy your new Roland FP10! :)
Is the action noisy? How it holding up after a year? Thanks.
@@scarsstitches636After almost two years using it, I can confidently say it's an amazing product for the price range. The action is quite good (it's not perfect, obviously) and doesn't make too much noise (although you can hear the keys a little after some use). If you just started playing, I wouldn't second guess it and buy it. If you're used to an acoustic however, I would suggest looking into something like the FP-90X or similar, which has better action and overall quality.
Coming from a Thoman DP Arranger, the Roland FP-10 is a beast. Doubt you'll find anything better at this price.
Hope it helps!
I am very impressed with this man’s analysis an explanations with great examples. I am not a pianist, but hope to learn soon in retirement. As a guitarist, knowing your instruments can bring a great deal of confidence and encouragement. This review is excellent from my vantage point. Thank you sir, it is clear that you know your instruments intimately.
This is the best review I have seen so far on these keyboards. You answered every question I had and more. Having worked with many of the best keyboard players in the business since the late 70's, I must say you have some really good chops. Thanks for a great review.
Best.comparaison. Review. Ever.
THX a lot. Hope to see more of these reviews =)
As usual, informative and comprehensive. Great content Stu!
I also appreciate that you spend the time writing a summary in the video description.
One of the best reviews I've ever seen on literally ANY product.
Outstanding
Subbed just for this guy. Best review I have ever seen of anything.
Excellent thorough comparison, with description and links. Thank you very much! Subscribed!
A pleasure to listen to this very well structured, to the point review! Thank you!
Absolutely fantastic review. Amazingly comprehensive! Thank you for the video!!
A perfect review without any unanswered questions. Great!
Thank you, Stu Harrison! Always excellent, unbiased presentation and superb playing. Love your reviews. 👍
This is one of the best reviews / comparisons I have ever seen. I really appreciate how thorough you were, and I like that there was a mix of honest objectivity and subjectivity. This video made up my mind for me. Thanks again!
Nice thanks Ive been waiting for this review from you.
An excellent review. Helps so much. Thank you & Happy New Year!
I loved your playing more than the review itself, with your talent you could make any instruments sounds like heaven.
I thinks it good example to just start learn with whatever instrument available to you..
That was an awesome review! Directly to the point and with the musician in mind. Thank you so much for helping me make my decision :)
Thank you that’s what i’ve been looking for ❤️
Excellent reviews (and playing!), many thanks.
Very well done comparison video, well done and thank you!
Thank you so much for this review! I am a classical pianist who is accustomed to Yamaha Clavinovas for digital practice and MIDI use. I have to rent a keyboard for a few months due to a temporary move, and if it wasn’t for this video I would have gone with the Yamaha purely out of brand bias. Thanks for opening my eyes and making the differences between these instruments easier to understand!
Such a fantastic objectively done review and comparison.
I do you know it was objective? You don't know this guy.
Excellent review! I myself have a Casio PX560, and would not have needed to watch this video were it not for a friend of mine wanting to buy a more or less entry level digital piano. Anyway, I'm glad I watched it. I've seen other of your reviews and you always do a thorough and apparently unbiased job, imho. So, thanks for posting stuff! Thumbs up and subscribed!
I'm hanging around waiting for my Roland FP-10 order to be fulfilled from my local music shop (in the UK). You've actively helped me not just buckle and ask them to swap it for the P-45 I know they have. Such a well-planned, thought-through and excellently presented video. Thanks :)
You're very welcome Jacob! We're happy to hear that the video was helpful in your decision making process. The Roland FP10 offers an excellent playing experience, especially considering its attractive price. I am quite confident that you will find it to be well worth the wait! Enjoy the FP10 once it arrives! :)
This review is outstanding. You really know what you're talking about. And I love how you consider more professional usage. Bought the FP10, and I'm really looking forward to practice again after 6 years of abstinence .
Thanks so much! We appreciate you taking the time to check out our video and share your very kind words! All the best and happy playing! :)
exactly the man is a specialist for real.
Thank you so much for this! I had a grand piano for for 20 years living with my parents but I’ve moved out and I now live in a smaller apartment so I can’t house a massive grand piano anymore. But I am looking into one of these guys to give me a similar grand piano feel so thank you for this!
Im in the same situation ! Which piano did you finaly Get ?
really appreciate such an honest review - thank you!!
That was so brutally honest. Loved it.
Thanks for this video - was going to go P45 but as a result of seeing this got the FP30X today. Thanks for the advice! 👍
Great comparison! Thank you 🙏🏻
Yamaha P-45 Piano test : 3:27 4:00 5:30 7:24 7:45 11:30 18:06 18:58 19:49
Yamaha P-45 E Piano sound test : 7:57 8:10
Roland FP-10 Piano test : 0:45 11:18 11:45 13:01 14:00 21:19 22:25
Roland FP-10 E Piano sound test : 14:43
Thank you 👍🏼
Thank you very much
👍👍
If anyone is looking for so more sound tests, I have a blind test of the Yamaha P45 vs. Roland FP10 on my channel to help people decide :).
Great review...loved it.
I saw the one, Roland at Costco and I was amazed. And it felt liking playing a piano. I used rent Baldwin pianos to practice. The feel is as important as the sound.
Great review on these 2 products! Have been looking around for digital pianos and it has been quite challenged to decide on which is better when comparing one over the other. This review finally sealed the deal. Thanks!
You're very welcome! We're glad to hear that the comparison helped you through your decision making process. :)
Thankyou for this review! It is very helpful.
FINALLY! A genuine, authentic, unbiased review from an authentic professional!
Thanks a lot for this wonderful video!
Thank you so much this is really helpful to me. Much appreciated 💜
Thank you for your excellent review 😎
This is an excellent comparison & contrast. Thank you for the clarity & demonstration.
You're very welcome! Thank you for taking the time to tune in! :)
Thank you for this. Long time Roland fan and I think you've helped me decide on my next piano.
Excellent review. Thanks very much.
Thank's to Merriam Music, for the details of these digital pianos. We just released a video about the difference between an acoustic piano and a digital piano: ruclips.net/video/Iq0o1agqUxY/видео.html
Hopefully useful for those of you who are starting to learn the piano :)
Such comprehensive and professional demo on these two digital pianos. It's really helpful for parents shopping for beginners level pianos for children. Thanks!
It is so refreshing to finally hear someone with a good touch that can actually play well do this.
Great review!
Thank you for your thorough review. I've always been a Yamaha user, but you convinced me to seriously look into Roland also. (piano teacher)
Great work!
Amazing review, thank you so much!
Glad it was helpful!
So helpful, thank you!
Thanks a lot!!! Best review!!!
Such a nice review!!! Thanks in deed.... new subscriber here!!
Great comparison 👏👏👏
Excellent review ! Both very informative and pleasant to watch (and listen to). Thank you so much.
You're very welcome! Thank you for tuning in! We're glad you enjoyed the comparison! :)
Thank you for making this video. Truly appreciate your expertise and value how you played for 20-30 seconds at a time to hear the tones. Very good analysis from a true professional. Much much appreciated this review. Thanks again!
You're very welcome! We're very happy to hear that you enjoyed the video and found it helpful! :)
A very good review of both these pianos. Much appreciated.
Thank you for tuning in! We're glad that you enjoyed it! :)
got an fp-10 about a year ago after trying both models. definitely very happy with the product
That's awesome! It's a fantastic digital piano and one of the best cost-to-value ratios on the market. :)
Many thanks for making my mind up regarding which of these to get my son as he starts lessons. Loved your playing by the way.
Thanks for tuning in! You're very welcome! We're happy to hear that the comparison was helpful. :)
I am one of those looking to use a digital piano with a DAW so the reference to the double sensor of the yamaha was very useful, I think I am sold on getting an Fp-10, interesting to see the apparent difference between an x stand and the cabinet style stand with the roland. I may not have the piano out all the time and so the cabinet style stands wouldn't suit that but the stability difference is really clear. Thanks for the in-depth review.
Great video and a great review. THanks!! I was set on the P45 but your review pushed me to the Roland. As others have noted, too bad its unavailable (at least as far as I can tell). :-(
Love the video! Great class in explaining the differences. I was about to buy Yamaha but three additional extras in Roland are much more convincing. I am glad that you also recommend doing further research.
Thanks so much! We're glad you enjoyed it. The Roland FP10 is a spectacular piano with, arguably, the very best touch available at this price point. I think you will be very happy with the choice. :)
Thank you for the video.
The shaking of the whole unit itself would drive me crazy
they're only shaking cause of his keyboard stands.
This channel is amazing. Your reviews are amazing. When I came across one of the first videos I watched I looked down to the subscribers counter expecting something near the figure of 500k. You deserve so much more than you have. Great video, great content overall, hope you keep it up
Just realised because of you that he 'just' got 9k of subscribers.
But massive clicks.
I mean that's possibly normal when you do product reviews and people just want to see test 1 or 2 products
buuuuut
I really think he deserves muuuch more c:
also expected like 300k or something...
So good luck @Merrian Music
sorry if I got some grammatic wrong
I think my english is okay but really not the best c:
Also realised I haven't subscribed yet soooo
You also got a new sub.
Thanks for you detailed and informative review :) I ended up purchasing Roland FP10 and I'm really excited to get back into playing the piano :)
Jennifer Noye how’s it coming along?
@jennifer how its going?
thanks, excellent review
About P45 lack of bluetooth, there are a some USB to Bluetooth adapters you can connect to it so you smartphone/tablet will also be free of any cable.
Thanks.. Your a good and plesant speaker. Sharp mind speaking well.. Thanks it was a joy to listen.. Pro 👍
Thank you very much for sharing your thoughts on these two keyboards. It's been very useful.
We're glad to hear that you found the video helpful! Thanks for tuning in! :)
Superb comparison and review! Thank you very much!
Also, fantastic playing! 👍
Thanks Stu! That was Awesome 👌
Thanks so much for tuning in! Glad you enjoyed it! :)
Great review. It helped a lot
You're very welcome! We're glad that you found it helpful! :)
Thanks for your review you actually helped me choose.
You're very welcome! We're happy to hear that you found the video helpful. :)
Superb review, no stand-up comedy, just useful facts, great playing and informed opinion, with a decisive conclusion. Perfect! Thanks for the care and attention!
Thank you for the kind words and thank you so much for tuning in! It is very much appreciated! :)
@@MerriamPianos You might like to know that I bought an FP10 as a result of the review, very pleased so far, no unnecessary complications, sounds great, job done. I wish I had been able to buy from your company but I am In Turkiye now and it would have been complicated! Thanks again for a great contribution to the keyboard world!
I should you that I very thankfull for your review, they are so honest and objety. Because of you I often for a FP10 and I have no regrets, its perfect for me! Thanl you!!
been looking for yamaha p45 the whole week and couldn’t find one online in my region, I think people start to find piano as hobby during quarantine (n I’m sooo late 😂). n now after watching this I’m starting to eye on Roland 😶🤷♀️
Yeah they all skyrocketed in price
I just found a Roland fp10 for retail but it was back ordered so I won’t get it for 3 weeks 🙁
If you wait a year or so, a lot of ppl will be selling them, those who quit. :-)
Yamaha p45 instead of roland, you will love the yamaha because of the touch of the keys and better quality sounds
@@bryanromoleroux3531 Dude.... please.
If we're talking about p125 we can argue (barely, as PHA4 is far better than GHS), but P45 sound? really?
Context: A year ago I've buyed a P515 with NWX and CFX+Boesendorfer... and just can't leave my old FP-30.
P45 is option only if cheaper, even Casio Privias are better options in sound and mechanics.
The Roland FP 10 is the one I will get. Thanks for your advice
very helpful!!! thanks so much
You're very welcome! We're happy to hear that it was helpful! :)
A very professional review, thank you very much, it was very useful, congratulations.
You're very welcome! Thank you kindly for taking the time to check it as well as the kind words! :)
Thankyou for doing this review. I'm looking to getting back into playing after a very long absence of about 30yrs. I'm interested in the Yamaha but now i'm thinking about the Roland instead. Thankyou for opening my eyes to the Roland. Great review :-)
Same situation here of 20 years. I tried both at the music store and would agree the FP10 feels closer to playing a acoustic piano. I ended up choosing a higher end Yamaha for its authentic sounding guitar voice haha! Whatever you decide, hope you find a piano you are happy with and able to get back to practicing!
As an aged beginner, I just enjoy your presentation of styles. (Love the ragtime!)
Thank you kindly! We're glad you enjoyed. Thanks for watching! (We love the ragtime bits as well :) -LP
This video was very helpful in making my choice of digital pianos (candidates were Roland FP10 and Yamaha P125A, which is on sale for almost the same price as P45 in Sept 2023). I took my piano teacher to the local music store and we both played both pianos before deciding on the Roland FP10. Great job on recording the sound so that I could really (with my good studio headphones) hear the differences.
Hi! Thanks so much for your kind words! We're glad to hear that the video was helpful. Congrats on deciding on the amazing Roland FP10! It is a fantastic instrument with a great touch and tone. I know you will be pleased with what it offers musically. :)
Usefull, thanks!
I really want to start in a few weeks with learning to play the e-piano and I’ve researched which e-piano I should buy as a total beginner. Thank you so much for this insightful and objective review. Thumbs up
You're very welcome! Thank you for tuning in! We're very glad to hear that you found the reviews helpful in your process. Thanks again and happy playing! :)
As soon as I get the money together I will be going with the Roland.
There's a used P-45 in the classifieds for just over $300, but I'm going to hold out for the Roland thanks to this video.
Where it’s 500 everywhere right now
Nvm just found a Roland at b and h
Would it be better me getting rid of my yamaha grand, for roland piano
great in-depth review
Thank you! We're glad you enjoyed it! :)
I was just deciding between these two pianos. Because of your video I'm going for the Roland FP10. Thanks for the excellent review! :)
You're very welcome! We're very happy to hear that you found our video helpful in your decision making process! :)
Thank you for those reviews. Great video and super informative. I did not realize how nice the Roland is. Buying it now.
Glad it was helpful!
How is it? Has the piano broken down somehow?
I was dabbling with these and couldn't find a good comparison for tones and such. This video helped tremendously, and I'll definitely buy the Roland :)
You won't love the action.
Can you give me a small review on it? I plan on buying it as well.
@@DanyaalShaozab Don't buy it!
@@Pe6ek Why mate?..., please be more detailed in your warning alert!. Thanks!.
Best review of a well matched pair; either one of which I'd be happy to own and play. Had to sub'
Thank you so much! We appreciate you subscribing to our channel. :)
Thank you so much! I am a piano teacher helping several adult student purchase and this was so informative. I have a Yamaha Clavinova next to my Kawai grand in the studio though I'm very keen to test out the RolandFP10. Great and informative video. Thank you!
You're very welcome! Thank you for tuning in! We really appreciate it. The Roland FP10 is a wonderful instrument for the money. The touch is fantastic, but, the only limitation to consider for teaching purposes is the fact that it does not have triple pedal capabilities.
@@MerriamPianos Totally. I noticed that though for a beginner I would far rather the 88 weighted keys with decent piano action to a subpar instrument. A good "starter" piano, right(o; Do you ship across Canada by chance?
I have an accoustic piano at home, but I just ordered this from Amazon after months' of deliberation. I live in a townhouse, and my neighbor has been working from home in this pandemic and rarely leaves home. This keyboard is scheduled to arrive in a few days, and I'm super excited to be able to practice any time of the day/night!!
Grace Lee Which of the two did you buy? Still happy with it?
Thank you for your super comprehensive review. I would have definitely purchased the instrument from you had I been based in Canada.
Thank you so much! We sincerely appreciate that! :)
Can't thank you enough for this awesome review. I was looking for an upgrade from my M-Audio semi-weighted MIDI controller to something that feels closer to an actual piano so that I can take my piano playing more seriously. You've sold me on the FP10 and it's on its way now! ;)
You're very welcome! Thank you so much for taking the time to tune in! We appreciate it. We're also happy to hear that our reviews/comparisons helped you narrow things down to the FP10. It is a wonderful piano and I know you will be thrilled with its excellent touch and tone. It is one of the best values on the market considering the fantastic action is provides. :)
😅😅😅😅😅
Excellent review thanks! Unfortunately I don't have a music shop nearby that sells both, but I've tried the P-145 which was pretty good. After seeing this I'd be tempted to go straight for the FP-10, but I'll see if I can try one somewhere before I commit! Thanks again.
Thank you kindly! You're very welcome! The Roland FP10 is a wonderful instrument and certainly worth some serious consideration if you're shopping in this price category. The combination of the PHA4 action and SuperNATURAL tone engine is quite difficult to compete with. :)
What a great review! I am not sure I have ever seen a more thorough, detailed and to the point! Nice job Stew! I do have to wonder how long phone manufactures stop supporting the software. It could render the Roland useless if you can no longer access the app.
Great review, thanks. I’m going for the FP-10
Were you able to get one? I can't find them available anywhere in North America
@@livinlikelarry6314 I’m in the UK. I bought online very easily and really cheaply with a package which included stand, stool, pedal and cover. It got delivered within 24 hours. I was more than impressed. I don’t understand why you can’t find one in the US.
this is such a wholesome review !
So glad you enjoyed it, and thanks for the comment!
Thanks! Very helpful
You're very welcome! We're glad you found it helpful! :)
great, help me a lot... thank you
26:15 Small mistake: the P45 headphone 1/4" jack was written in the FP10 column on the second slide, the P45 is always shown with no audio jack on both slides.