I've been waiting for you to review this one! Thank you for having an open mind and buying boots from all manufacturers. Allen Edmonds seems to get ignored in these online review spaces, but you are the exception! Thank you and keep them coming!
I have a pair of boots with the XL sole (Berwick 538 moc toes) and find the same issue as you regarding stability. I think it is because they have the cushioning of a soft running shoe but none of the support features that are built into running shoes nowadays like TPU plates and dual density foam.
You are so right about the sole. I have the Higgins Mill Barbour and it is so light, bouncy and squishy. It's almost sneaker like. Not a 'boot' feel at all. They are in my rotation because I spent $450 but I can't wait to get back into my Aldens or Grant Stones.
I love this shoes and great 👍 explanation too,thats a win win for me.im watching these days boots review channels in youtube, this channel one of the helpful and Im myself new to boots world, I order thursday boots as a starter so I'm going to see how it goes since everyone talks about thursday boots. Thanks for ur time sir.
I have a pair of these and agree 95% with your review. I was able to find mine for $199 USD! I bought them without even a review until after they arrived. The color is very versatile and the yare probably my favorite pair of boots.
Thank you for the video. I know this is a couple months old video though for anyone wanting to get a pair, righ now both the Allen Admond Amazon store and their website have most items at 30% discount. Picked up the same Loden suede pair from the review at Amazon for $200 (Thursday's price). Great video!!!
I have an old AE Caen cap toe boot in suede and the 11.5D fit me perfectly if anything a little roomy due to the blocky toe. I measure an 11.5D on brannock. However I found the Higgins Mill boot tight. When I tried on a normal brown chromexcel pair with black rubber sole, the 11.5D fit well. Snug, but felt right. However, I was buying the natural chromexcel “weatherproof” version with the red rubber sole. They had to order those in my size and mailed them to me. Unfortunately they were too snug and did not break in. I wore them on and off for almost 4 months before finally giving up and selling them.
Teik! Your videos are so good. I’ve interacted with you on the forums, and it’s great to finally be diving into your YT vids. I have these boots coming next week and am looking forward to seeing how it goes!
Another well made and interesting video. A bit of information that is maybe useful: „Loden“ is a type of wool fabric that is traditionally used in the southern parts of Germany / the alpine region by woodsmen, farmers and hunters. Very old type of fabric that has been used for hundreds of years. It is often in dark green or brown colors like you see in this boot.
I have the high top sneaker version and I had to size one whole size. When I first purchased the sneakers I was hesitant on it not jiving with my outfits but I’m glad I kept them. The color loden is a great third option when it comes to versatility when you want a break from brown or oxblood/burgundy.
I have the HM in burgundy lug sole & I have a love/hate thing for these boots. Comfortable but the quality could be better, got it on sale so the price was justifiable. Idk if I ever keeps them where they need a resole but want to get a vibram lug sole to keep that more rugged look mix with it dressy upper. AE is better making dress shoes than boots IMO.
I’m an 8.5D on Brannock too. But I have skinny feet and skinny ankles. I always have issues with lacings coming too close. Like you I like my fit to be snug in the heel and ball and a lot of room in the toes. The Trubalance last is my best fitting boot in this regard but like I said having low volume feet and skinny ankles makes lacings close.
Great review, as always! One question if you can help clarify. You mentioned the outsole is cemented and, therefore, is a throw-away shoes. Can cobbler just glue a replacement outsole? If not resolelable, it would defeate paying more for Goodyear welt boots.
I bought mine a few months ago. Yes, they are very versatile and can go with most colors. At the beginning of your video, you showed the different outfits but without showing the boots with them.
fantastic! i'm working on my first AE review and your AE videos have been an immense help as always Teik! i agree with the sizing, the ones i'm reviewing are 8.5D and they are definitely snug, they seem to use more traditionally lower volume/ dressy lasts
Nice review. I have the same pair in loden suede but I specified a dainties olive green outsole. I like the Vibram but I thought the green sole would be a nice touch.
Great review, as always! I have the exact same boots and it’s funny they’re my go-to airport shoes as well (like you I also have this model in a Dainite/CXL combo but I haven’t worn that pair on a plane yet, lol). Yes they’re a little squishy due to that sole but a nice comfy break in my regular rotation of (harder soled) GS Diesels and Chelseas.
Great video once again! Did you order your boots from amazon or from the actual website? Also did you pay full price? From Amazon do you think the quality drops or no? Also are the insoles removable? Thanks I love your channel!
Some cemented boots are re-soleable in the same way that a glued on sole on a welted shoe is re-soleable. I have had cemented boots re-soled myself and in many cases a cobbler would do the same as a cobbler would do for this boot. Where it gets trickier is when there is a foam midsole integrated into the outsole which is how most modern hiking and athletic boots are constructed. Even so, there are a couple of specialised repairers in the UK (and I'm sure elsewhere) who can rebuild many of these and are authorised agents. Typically the all leather boots are ones that are more likely to be included. Zamberlan, Scarpa, Lowa and Meindl (and possibly other brands ?) also offer a resole service at their factories for many of their heavier, all leather hiking and mountaineering boots though it usually makes sense to use an authorised repairer unless you live in that country.
I'll just add that the most well known specialist UK repairer, Lancashire Shoe Repairs, have a much larger list of brands on their website than I included above but also claim they can repair "ALL makes and models of walking, hiking and trekking boots" .
Nice video! I have the same pair and not only are they squishy but they wear out super fast. I walk a lot. Any suggestions on what to resolve them with to make them less squishy and get more miles?
Hey Teik, I have a question that's unrelated to this video. I'm considering of buying Truman boots, but also want the best quality possible, which is Nicks or Whites. Since you have both, if Thursday boots are a 1 and Nicks and White's are a 10, where do you think Truman is positioned? (the only reason I'm asking is because Rose Anvil didn't yet cut open a pair of Truman, and we can't see what's inside) Thanks
Apparently after watching a cobbler take a few Truman boots apart, they are filled with a fiberglass shank and foam filler, which I don't think it warrants the price. So personally I will stay away from Truman until their quality improves.
IMO Truman are up there, maybe 8.5 to 9 just for the solidity of the construction and the fit and comfort. They do have boots with fibreglass shanks - but fibreglass can make solid vessels and body armour and help me go through airport security, so what? But all of my Truman boots are steel shanked. Not all of them have a foam infill, some of them are cork, and some even leather. But my score is on the wearing of them, not on the materials, and for ruggedness for stitching etc
Have you reviewed the Wolverine BLVD? Seems the mainstream reviewers are purposely avoiding these due to perhaps some perceived competition with Thursday and maybe who is paying for reviews.
I cannot quite understand why you lovers and reviewers of quality boots don't also love quality leather jackets, Aero, Goodwear and so on. Nothing beats good boots, jeans and a leather jacket!
I bought these not realizing the outsole was so dang soft. Maybe it's all in my head but sometimes I think I can feel pressure points in my foot where the different lugs are. The website should be more clear on how soft it is. At $249 I kept the boot but if I had paid full price then absolutely would not have been happy.
I would exchange these if you haven't worn them outside. They are too small for your feet. The 1157 has a wide toe box, it is not a hipster boot. I had to go 1/2 size above TTS for my feet with the AE Park City. Maybe the Higgins Mill runs narrow, and you need an E, not a D width. Try TTS and E.
@@ADyess086 😀Happens sometimes. I have four pairs of AE boots. My feet on Brannock are just wider than 11E. But I have thick feet, and need EEE. For a comparison, 10.5EEE is ok on my first pair, but I went 11 EEE on the next three pairs, which is better. I would say never go below Brannock on length, width will depend on thickness of the foot. I originally thought I was 10.5 on the Brannock, which is why I advised going a half size larger. Then I bought my own Brannock scale. TTS is best for size on AE boots.
Here's hoping but my store said that if there's such a deep discount that usually means they're just trying to clear out inventory. Weirdly they still make the cap toe with dainite in loden. But the plain toe lug sole just feels more appropriate.
@@graefx hello, there is a loden version of the ae landon boot available on the allen edmonds shoebank website currently for $250. i believe it has a vibram sole, which is firm, not squishy like the hm in this video.
I've been waiting for you to review this one! Thank you for having an open mind and buying boots from all manufacturers. Allen Edmonds seems to get ignored in these online review spaces, but you are the exception! Thank you and keep them coming!
I have a pair of boots with the XL sole (Berwick 538 moc toes) and find the same issue as you regarding stability. I think it is because they have the cushioning of a soft running shoe but none of the support features that are built into running shoes nowadays like TPU plates and dual density foam.
You are so right about the sole. I have the Higgins Mill Barbour and it is so light, bouncy and squishy. It's almost sneaker like. Not a 'boot' feel at all. They are in my rotation because I spent $450 but I can't wait to get back into my Aldens or Grant Stones.
I was looking at the Barbour because of the sole. I’m on my feet all day.
I love this shoes and great 👍 explanation too,thats a win win for me.im watching these days boots review channels in youtube, this channel one of the helpful and Im myself new to boots world, I order thursday boots as a starter so I'm going to see how it goes since everyone talks about thursday boots. Thanks for ur time sir.
I have a pair of these and agree 95% with your review. I was able to find mine for $199 USD! I bought them without even a review until after they arrived. The color is very versatile and the yare probably my favorite pair of boots.
Thank you for the video. I know this is a couple months old video though for anyone wanting to get a pair, righ now both the Allen Admond Amazon store and their website have most items at 30% discount. Picked up the same Loden suede pair from the review at Amazon for $200 (Thursday's price). Great video!!!
I completely understand your comments on having an ultra soft / flexible sole. Thanks for the review.
Great job on this review, Teik! I’ve already been interested in these particular Allen Edmonds boots! The colorway is extremely versatile. 👍🏾
I have an old AE Caen cap toe boot in suede and the 11.5D fit me perfectly if anything a little roomy due to the blocky toe. I measure an 11.5D on brannock. However I found the Higgins Mill boot tight. When I tried on a normal brown chromexcel pair with black rubber sole, the 11.5D fit well. Snug, but felt right. However, I was buying the natural chromexcel “weatherproof” version with the red rubber sole. They had to order those in my size and mailed them to me. Unfortunately they were too snug and did not break in. I wore them on and off for almost 4 months before finally giving up and selling them.
Teik! Your videos are so good. I’ve interacted with you on the forums, and it’s great to finally be diving into your YT vids. I have these boots coming next week and am looking forward to seeing how it goes!
Another well made and interesting video. A bit of information that is maybe useful: „Loden“ is a type of wool fabric that is traditionally used in the southern parts of Germany / the alpine region by woodsmen, farmers and hunters. Very old type of fabric that has been used for hundreds of years. It is often in dark green or brown colors like you see in this boot.
Very useful, thanks!
I have the high top sneaker version and I had to size one whole size. When I first purchased the sneakers I was hesitant on it not jiving with my outfits but I’m glad I kept them. The color loden is a great third option when it comes to versatility when you want a break from brown or oxblood/burgundy.
I have the HM in burgundy lug sole & I have a love/hate thing for these boots. Comfortable but the quality could be better, got it on sale so the price was justifiable. Idk if I ever keeps them where they need a resole but want to get a vibram lug sole to keep that more rugged look mix with it dressy upper. AE is better making dress shoes than boots IMO.
I’m an 8.5D on Brannock too. But I have skinny feet and skinny ankles.
I always have issues with lacings coming too close.
Like you I like my fit to be snug in the heel and ball and a lot of room in the toes. The Trubalance last is my best fitting boot in this regard but like I said having low volume feet and skinny ankles makes lacings close.
Great and detailed video. I always enjoy your stylings and product choices.
Great review, as always! One question if you can help clarify. You mentioned the outsole is cemented and, therefore, is a throw-away shoes. Can cobbler just glue a replacement outsole? If not resolelable, it would defeate paying more for Goodyear welt boots.
You can resole. The outsole is on a midsole and can be replaced
Great review Teik. I never thought of getting a pair of green boots before, but you have changed my mind sir. Well done.
I have these, they are amazing. Very lightweight squishy soles, great looking, and go with everything except olive pants.
i like these boots; they are the best i have seen in a while
I bought mine a few months ago. Yes, they are very versatile and can go with most colors. At the beginning of your video, you showed the different outfits but without showing the boots with them.
The editor needs a kick 😂😂😂
fantastic! i'm working on my first AE review and your AE videos have been an immense help as always Teik! i agree with the sizing, the ones i'm reviewing are 8.5D and they are definitely snug, they seem to use more traditionally lower volume/ dressy lasts
Look forward to your review!
Nice review. I have the same pair in loden suede but I specified a dainties olive green outsole. I like the Vibram but I thought the green sole would be a nice touch.
Great review, as always! I have the exact same boots and it’s funny they’re my go-to airport shoes as well (like you I also have this model in a Dainite/CXL combo but I haven’t worn that pair on a plane yet, lol). Yes they’re a little squishy due to that sole but a nice comfy break in my regular rotation of (harder soled) GS Diesels and Chelseas.
Great video once again! Did you order your boots from amazon or from the actual website? Also did you pay full price? From Amazon do you think the quality drops or no? Also are the insoles removable? Thanks I love your channel!
The insoles aren't removable.
They were eBay
excellent review, well done again
just in time i was looking to get a pair of these or the whites mp
Very good looking boot! I love the color and texture! 🔥
Some cemented boots are re-soleable in the same way that a glued on sole on a welted shoe is re-soleable. I have had cemented boots re-soled myself and in many cases a cobbler would do the same as a cobbler would do for this boot.
Where it gets trickier is when there is a foam midsole integrated into the outsole which is how most modern hiking and athletic boots are constructed. Even so, there are a couple of specialised repairers in the UK (and I'm sure elsewhere) who can rebuild many of these and are authorised agents. Typically the all leather boots are ones that are more likely to be included.
Zamberlan, Scarpa, Lowa and Meindl (and possibly other brands ?) also offer a resole service at their factories for many of their heavier, all leather hiking and mountaineering boots though it usually makes sense to use an authorised repairer unless you live in that country.
I'll just add that the most well known specialist UK repairer, Lancashire Shoe Repairs, have a much larger list of brands on their website than I included above but also claim they can repair "ALL makes and models of walking, hiking and trekking boots" .
Great review as always Teik! I'm based in Perth too. Any recommendations regarding good cobblers in Perth?
I use Wembley Shoe Repair. Floreat Forum also has a knowledgeable cobbler with a stock of JR soles.
Nice video. Does the weatherproofing, the membrane in particular, make the boot a little warm?
Yeah I feel it does
Nice video! I have the same pair and not only are they squishy but they wear out super fast. I walk a lot. Any suggestions on what to resolve them with to make them less squishy and get more miles?
I’m planning on going Dainite!
These are marked down right now from 450 to 200 US!
Hey Teik, I have a question that's unrelated to this video. I'm considering of buying Truman boots, but also want the best quality possible, which is Nicks or Whites. Since you have both, if Thursday boots are a 1 and Nicks and White's are a 10, where do you think Truman is positioned?
(the only reason I'm asking is because Rose Anvil didn't yet cut open a pair of Truman, and we can't see what's inside)
Thanks
Apparently after watching a cobbler take a few Truman boots apart, they are filled with a fiberglass shank and foam filler, which I don't think it warrants the price. So personally I will stay away from Truman until their quality improves.
IMO Truman are up there, maybe 8.5 to 9 just for the solidity of the construction and the fit and comfort. They do have boots with fibreglass shanks - but fibreglass can make solid vessels and body armour and help me go through airport security, so what? But all of my Truman boots are steel shanked. Not all of them have a foam infill, some of them are cork, and some even leather. But my score is on the wearing of them, not on the materials, and for ruggedness for stitching etc
Hey do you have a number to Truman? I need to change my boot size
Have you reviewed the Wolverine BLVD? Seems the mainstream reviewers are purposely avoiding these due to perhaps some perceived competition with Thursday and maybe who is paying for reviews.
No I haven’t - not easy to buy in Australia
Snagged these for 150 on Cyber Monday!
Great price!
For $200 US, these or Thursdays?
50/50
I cannot quite understand why you lovers and reviewers of quality boots don't also love quality leather jackets, Aero, Goodwear and so on. Nothing beats good boots, jeans and a leather jacket!
I bought these not realizing the outsole was so dang soft. Maybe it's all in my head but sometimes I think I can feel pressure points in my foot where the different lugs are. The website should be more clear on how soft it is. At $249 I kept the boot but if I had paid full price then absolutely would not have been happy.
I would exchange these if you haven't worn them outside. They are too small for your feet. The 1157 has a wide toe box, it is not a hipster boot. I had to go 1/2 size above TTS for my feet with the AE Park City. Maybe the Higgins Mill runs narrow, and you need an E, not a D width. Try TTS and E.
Allen Edmonds advised me completely opposite
@@ADyess086 😀Happens sometimes. I have four pairs of AE boots. My feet on Brannock are just wider than 11E. But I have thick feet, and need EEE. For a comparison, 10.5EEE is ok on my first pair, but I went 11 EEE on the next three pairs, which is better. I would say never go below Brannock on length, width will depend on thickness of the foot. I originally thought I was 10.5 on the Brannock, which is why I advised going a half size larger. Then I bought my own Brannock scale. TTS is best for size on AE boots.
They say " It got a wooden shank"
Are they made in China ?
It seems that this color is discontinued. Really disappointing with how versatile it is.
It seems to come and go. I think there are supply chain issues
Here's hoping but my store said that if there's such a deep discount that usually means they're just trying to clear out inventory. Weirdly they still make the cap toe with dainite in loden. But the plain toe lug sole just feels more appropriate.
@@graefx hello, there is a loden version of the ae landon boot available on the allen edmonds shoebank website currently for $250. i believe it has a vibram sole, which is firm, not squishy like the hm in this video.