Can I please ask everyone to keep a respectful tone? While I think it is important to keep pressure on Rothfuss to deliver I think it is important we try and address this as respectfully as possible.
It's hard seeing so many people go way overboard on this. I get that people like his work, but turning to an angry mob like this is why authors like him stop writing. If he underdelivers people rip him apart anyways. He's just a dude like any of us, and it sucks to see people lose interest in why his books are great. It's regretful that he didn't honor his commitment, but the goal of the donations was not his book anyways, it was for the charity. If he had pocketed that money it would be different, and while I understand that his chapter was the reason people donated, I still think that people lost sight of the whole charity work. They should be saying his response was disappointing, not completely villifying him for this. We are not entitled to a third book, that's his art and if he never publishes the third one then oh well. There are plenty of other stories if you want your fill. I'd rather look at why his books are great.
@@KMFWR I feel like even acknowledging that, the response is still extreme. I understand people don't like not getting what they paid for, but this kind of fan entitlement is what ends up in creators recieving death threats. I was aware of this kind of response in the gaming community but seeing it in readers too is incredibly disheartening.
@@KMFWR Claims about someone having had a ghost writer for twenty years are not oppinions. I never said you needed to give your justification. My oppinion is that people feel entitled, and need to check themselves. Pat never intended this to take off as it did, and while I get people voicing their frustration, they have also begun to take it too far. That doesn't mean I can stop people, you can do whatever you want. That is merely my oppinion. I find it ironic for you to imply that my voicing this concern infringes upon that somehow. Also my comment was not personally directed at you, though your need to defend yourself is indeed telling. The creator of the video is asking for people to be respectful, I merely wanted to add on to it.
His charity is actually rated extremely low on Charity Navigator, which says the organization isnt even remotely transparant with Financial Statements, Tax Documents and has a 57% expense ratio. I does not look good.
He is literally a scammer. People wouldn't have given him this much money if he hadn't said he would give them a chapter. And he knew that very well, else there was no reason to promise something you're never going to give
He did it as a bet, and kept trying to double down when he lost. I think he thought he couldn't lose, so didn't have to worry about paying up till it was too late, like all gambmers who lose big.
You’re being more gracious towards Rothfuss than I am. The man committed fraud, never apologized (I feel bad is not the same as I’m sorry, and here is how I will fix it), and uses his mental health as an excuse for terrible behavior. I mean, I struggle with severe anxiety, and have ADD, but I have obligations and responsibilities, and promises that I make and need to fulfill. What if I just stopped taking my kids to school, or refused to pay my bills, or any number of things? And then on top of that I refused to give any explanation for my behavior? And then 2.5 years later I did a general announcement saying I kinda feel bad about it, but those people who bothered me about the situation were d***s? TBH, those fans should have pressed charges against Rothfuss, and I can tell you I won’t have anything to do with his work until he fixes this.
Geez, who even cares about this guy anymore? This is a guy that said his entire story was complete when he was signed. I love his first book, the second was good but not great, but his shitty attitude around fans asking about his third book has completely lost me, the guy is a prick.
I mostly just want to see him held accountable for scamming donors of charity. I've done a lot of charity work in my life, and I donated to Worldbuilders multiple times. Pat is a gaslighting narcissist who uses mental health as a scapegoat. It makes us who actually suffer from those issues look bad. We don't go around stealing and refusing to write 10 pages in 13+ years.
I think part of it is his attitude, and part is his popularity. He seems to be very arrogant, he likes to shit on Tolkien as if his own style of fantasy is superior and that doesn't get you really anywhere. The other aspect is like George R. R. Martin (perhaps to a lesser degree) he has achieved a ton of popularity without having finished his magnum opus. Some people lose motivation when they achieve their goals before they finish working towards them. If you give someone the gold medal before the race is over, they're probably not going to finish. Martin doesn't have the same attitude as Rothfuss but there's no chance he's finishing his series either.
I am not a fan of Kingkiller, but I take a great interest in how Rothfuss has treated his fans. As an aspiring author, I have an excellent example of what NOT to do as an author.
And a good example of what TO do as one, oh Ruin-profile-pic (Even if you can’t crank out material at the rate of the Brandotron 9000, he’s a pretty good role model with regards to how he treats his fans.)
I mean yeah,Martin and his fans know that he has a ton of hats he has his hands on and he is aged too I feel like lynch and Martin are way more vocal (even though song of ice and fire has shit ton of things going on other than just a book)
And Martin dropped multiple chapters. I think he is actually working on it, just having a lot of trouble. Rothfuss appereantly have not wrote a single chapter.
At least with G.R.R.M. I get the impression that he is trying to write the book (at a snail's pace but trying), Patrick on the other hand I'm pretty sure that the dude hasn't been doing nothing other than sitting around and scratching his balls for over 10 years.
@@AkaSora96 I got the opposite impression. I cant help but notice how much of a far left extremist Martin became, im not sure how his Marxist views can sit well with his old writing style. If his dreamed color revolution ever happens hes going up the wall first thats for sure, maybe hes making sure it dosnt happen and wont write again.
10:15 When did he apologize? He just said he feels bad that's not an apology, by saying he feels bad he makes it about himself when he is not the victim here, a proper apology is taking accountability and it's main focus is always towards the real victim not yourself, I don't care how you feel, an apology is not about knowing that you feel bad an apology is saying "I'm sorry, I acted wrong" every reason as to how you feel or why it happened should come second to that.
@@NatalieNox600 yeah, it's a classic tactic to make you feel bad, like "and now I AM the asshole" they do it so people take pity on them and stop trying to make them take responsibility, I should know I used to do it, it's not like some evil thing you do to manipulate, it's more like self-pity and feeling like you are the victim and try to make people see you as that when deep down you know you are not the one who was screwed over, no matter how much you want to believe it.
At this point, i feel the best move for him and his fans would be for him to admit something like, "I'm facing the world's worst case of writer's block. I've been trying to get this book out for a decade, and it's just not happening. I'm sorry the book probably won't be coming out." That way, if he wants to keep working on it behind the scenes, it's a bonus, but he's not carrying all those expectations anymore.
@neiltaylor513 I think that's what is costing him sympathy. Lots of people have big problems, but only the well off can afford to not work while they solve those problems.
Here’s my opinion. Rothfuss never intended to deliver. He released an already released prologue with a couple of changes. And he didn’t apologize. He said he felt bad, and that he could have done it a year and a half ago, and called everyone who even questioned him d***s. At this point he’s a thief. To release a book and still have not delivered on a $1million promise. His mental health is, as you say, no excuse. He’s a thief, and I would need itemized receipts to even believe it went to charity. As for his work, I don’t believe anymore that he wrote it. I think he had a really great ghost writer and they’ve either parted on bad terms, or the ghost writer has died. He also seems to feel entitled to collect money and provide nothing. One chapter could have been written in less time than it took him gaslight his way through that “apology.” Nobody asked for perfection. Just got a chapter. Which he couldn’t manage even though he managed to expand a short story into a $26 novella.
Based on what I've seen, I think he has not learned the skill in life to force yourself to do something, is excellent at making excuses, and is mentally too immature to analyse this aspect of himself.
Book 3 does not exist. All he needed was to pick just one chapter and read it, and since he didn't, it can only mean that not a single chapter for book 3 exist. More and more, this looks like a scam.
Not trying to sound like I'm defending Rothfuss, because I'm not - but the deal was for a stand-alone chapter that wouldn't contain any spoilers, not just any old chapter. That doesn't mean I believe he's written anything - I don't, and it pisses me off, but that he had no chapter ready to release that met that description doesn't mean he didn't have anything at all.
I'd put money on it that he doesn't have a single chapter completed yet. It wouldn't surprise me if he hasn't even put together an outline of the book. Every time I see one of these videos I'm thankful I never started his books because he isn't finishing it.
I've given up on Rothfuss and already got rid of his books I purchased. I don't bother promoting his books either. Such a scammer and jerk, depression or not. I have depression and anxiety, but I take medication and I'm so much better for it.
Sorry, but I won't watch that video. I've decided to let bygones be bygones, but this said, Mr. Rothfuss will never ever get a single penny from me, even when I absolutely love the books he has written. But I just don't want to waste my time waiting for the next book, when there's so many other talented authors out that write at a consistent pace and get their work done. I much prefer to give my money to those authors and reward their work ethics.And to be honest, I'd much rather have you spend your time talking about those authors as well, because contrary to Mr. Rothfuss, they would deserve it.
100% this. "I feel bad" is what narcissists say when they are cornered instead of apologizing. I grew up with a parent who was later diagnosed with narcissistic personality disorder. I'm very familiar with this phrase.
The problem is the word, donation.......when ones donates....they lose most ways to get something back. If his promise was contractual then he would have to pay but it wasn't
@@PageTurnersbooktube523 Charities and donations receive far more scrutiny over donation incentives especially when directly offered by the Charity itself (Pat is the only Board member of Worldbuilders). If Pat wasn't The Founder and active board member this would be true. Pat being a mouthpiece of the charity makes this an official action of the charity. Which turns this into defrauding donors of a charitable organization. I have reason to believe his charity is currently under investigation.
3 series likely never to be finished: 1: king killer Chronicles 2: A Song of Ice and Fire 3: Gentleman Bastards. To me it’s an absolute tragedy that these literary works of art may never be completed. I hope I’m wrong and all of them get finished.
I still think that Kingkiller Chronicles and Gentleman Bastards will finish one day. Both authors still write and are relatively young (or, at least, have a decent lifespawn).
At least with Gentlemen Bastards, each book has enough of a sense of resolution that (at least for me) the series could end at that point and still be satisfying. All questions answered, every stone turned? No. But I’ve never been angry to close a book at the end of reading it, and if any others are published, it’ll just be a pleasant surprise.
@@oohshiny1366 I personally thought that Republic of Thieves ended on a cliffhanger in that we get a huge reveal and it’s said that many things will come to pass in some fashion or another. It left me chomping at the bit for more lol. IMO
@@hawk66100 That’s fair! I took it much more as “and the adventure could continue!” without really feeling the need for answers. It would be great to read more about these characters and setting, but I’m also satisfied with the story as-is. It’s way more comparable to something like The Last Unicorn, or Sabriel in that way. It is wildly untrue for the other ASoIaF, and KKC.
Given Rothfuss's political beliefs-- or at least what he's happy to shout about-- I think the whole thing was a troll on people-- his fans-- who have disposable income: people who haven't already given all of their money to charity. He's just another hypocrite who likes to say money "doesn't matter" while he has plenty of it. Also, I don't think the money was ever real to him. He wanted to go "double or nothing" at one point until his mods talked him out of it I shudder to think what kind of damage he could do to himself in front of a slot machine.
At this point I feel he should just admit he cannot complete it, he should gather his notes and ask Brandon Sanderson, Steven Erikson, or Joe Abercrombie to finish his work so the fans can have closure.
@@MaiaGothmog Moreso than that - they're opposites in prose, too. Sanderson says he tries to make his prose invisible, and as a result its very basic. makes his books fast reads and easy to read (which is important for a story with ten thousand made up words) but it makes for mediocre prose. Rothfuss has less of that high-fantasy stuff, and his prose is significantly better.
@@stephengrant4841 I think “significantly better” is a very subjective term. Sando does an incredible job with what he’s trying to do. And I prefer a simpler, more fast-paced writing style to “beautiful” prose. Then again, I read mainly for escapism and so I like my stories to move fast. For example, I just read Red Rising and the prose in that book is simply masterful in my opinion. And I think Pierce Brown handles that style better than Sanderson. I write my own stories that way.
Have to agree. As an author myself, if I promised a chapter, I would release "anything" even if it isn't done and say look, this is something special for you, it may change in the final book....but for now, this is the chapter. Can't even do that? $1 million? holy shit dude, figure yourself out. Personally I never even got through book 2, but out of curiosity I'm following up on this debacle and I'm stunned.
Him and RR Martin…. I think they both simply made so much money and got so much praise that it affected their work ethic. They don’t need money, so there’s no financial reason to write another book. And they got so much critical praise that they are afraid to write something that isn’t perfect. I wish them well.
Why would you think there is no financial gain by releasing the book? His fans literally paid him over a million dollars to release one chapter. Don’t you think these fans would not buy the book when it’s released 😂 What praise is he getting by doing this?
Great timing, I just started the audiobook for Name of the Wind. Put it off for years because this guy is not reliable. I found a free version somewhere so I'm listening to it before it get's taken down. Get to listen to the book without supporting this scammer at the same time. Win win 👍
I loved the first two books. But it's been a fucking decade since book two came out. At this point in time I assume he will literally never finish book three and the story will never have an ending. Some authors need to realize that perfection isn't worth letting your readers grow into completely different people. Since book 2 released I've completed a master and a PhD, moved to not one but two different countries, and went from being single to married with two kids with one starting school this Fall.
Fine. I won't purchase his works. I will get pirated PDFs of his works. I was excited to order his 2 books if i ever want to read kingkiller chronicles. I'm sorry but his attitude is disappointing.
i dont understand the reasoning behind him not communicating. Just tell us where the books at in terms of progress. people are already pissed. you cant make fans more angry by just being open.
The reason he isn't honest is probably because there *is* no progress being made. "Sorry guys but I gave up a while ago" is about the worst possible thing he could say.
He should have shoved whatever out the door, learned form his mistakes, and started his next series. His first book was really good, but not perfect. Can't get over himself. Writing is not a mystical art, it's sitting there and thinking and getting words on the page as best you can. Afraid to fail = afraid to move.
I undertand being too depressed or mentally ill to write. I struggle the same so i get it. But setting up fund raisers and getting money from fans for doing nothing at all is a complete different story. Atleast make an effort to give fans what they want.
Screw him. There’s a whole galaxy of stories made by writers who are CONSISTENT with their work. Read the Hanuvar novels by Howard Andrew Jones. He already released two books in the series and the third one will be out later this year.
I really think he is struggling with this book. I have been a fan for a long time and I remember the wait for the 2nd book and I was so excited when it finally came. But there’s definitely a huge change in him since then. The Pat from 15 years ago would never have done something like that. I don’t know, but I am actually a little afraid of book 3 finally being released because I fear the tone and feel will be so vastly different from books one and two that it will almost ruin it for me.
When I read (and absolutely LOVED) Books 1 and 2 of the series, I had no idea that I may die of old age before the conclusion of the trilogy. Patrick is no scammer, he’s simply one in a long line of tortured artist using their fragile mental health as a crutch. (READ: another whiny Primadonna’s fear of success)
I gave up on waiting for Rothfuss book long time ago. He said once on his blog joking that Steven Erickson sold his soul to the devil and that is why he write so much books so fast (Malazan Series) . Maybe Rothfuss should sell his too...
IMO, it was pretty obvious he wrote a Bast chapter for charity, and he decided he could sell another book if he weaved that new story into The Lightning Tree.
Even still its not that hard to write another chapter to release a novel with no controversy, thus making MORE money instead of releasing a novel after a huge backlash with his own fanbase 😂
@@adoniscreed4031 oh, I'm 100% there with you. Honestly, the idiot could have given everyone half of The Narrow Road between Desires for free, and it would have increased goodwill and boosted sales. The dude is just lazy. I get it. Mental disorders are a b*tch, but if he wanted to get it done he would have.
Dear Patrick Rothfuss: please invite Brandon Sanderson and other authors to a write out adventure! Brainstorming with other Authors might get you out of whatever spot you are stuck in. Or you can even sell them your project so they can finish it! We won’t mind! And you can still be on the credits with a finished storyline
God that ‘apology’ just made me ill when I first saw it. Like man your fans donated over 1 million dollars to your charity that, I guarantee you, wouldn’t have come anywhere near even half of what it made if you didn’t promise a chapter from Doors of Stone. Then you go on with these excuses “Oh it’s not edited the way I want it to be, I want to do a big thing with professional VO’s. Then it turned into a mess.” Like dude stop using your mental issues as a crutch here, pick a chapter from the book, preferably one that doesn’t need a ton of context from other chapters, and literally copy and paste that to your blog. You can literally say “Hey guys, this is a rough draft of the chapter _It will likely be different in the final manuscript_ but this is it so far. Thank you once again for donating your hard earned money to my charity.” Fans would be over the moon for new kingkiller content in a decade, and they would understand it’s a rough draft of the chapter. The fact it’s been nearly 2 and a half years is making me think he hasn’t written ANYTHING of Doors of Stone.
thanks for covering this! i think about it every month probably, lol. i was gifted the name of the wind a couple christmases ago, but i won't start the series until all this drama is resolved. just say something, dude (rothfuss)!
Aaaand there's the conspiracy theorist for the day... Remember: Things are never simple, there's ALWAYS something sinister going on, always a dark secret, always a scheme
I feel like a lot of ppl forgot this was during the pandemic timeframe, which can EASILY change someone's life, let alone their plans. He's a human first and foremost. Those who assume anything about someone who writes so in-depth and layered, are more than likely incorrect.
Sure could have, but that doesn't free you, him, or me from responsibilities or promises made. Recovery requires doing hard things. Anything except expecting one to do what is right is enabling what is wrong. More so, it's fraud to misrepresent intentions, even with charity, and I'm surprised nobody has sued and that consumer protection hasn't stepped in.
@@schlurrpy9790 Screw him, sure the pandemic was bad sure, but that was 2 years ago, the release of book 2 was 2011 he had 9 years to produce something, but at every corner, instead of writing he was doing charity and going to pax to play DnD and at every moment and at every moment he was abrasive to his own fans, GRR Martin is the same but at least Martin has interviews where he says that writing a chap for him is like giving birth, Rothuss just complain about his own fans.
@@DaviHorner I guess. Yes and no? I want to assume that he has the right thing to do in his mind, ready to go, but Occam's razor suggests otherwise. The simplest answer is he screwed up, and something will not allow him to fix the problem. Nobody else knows what that something is. Is it pride? Is it fear? Ghost writer part ways? Whatever it is, that's his demon to fight. Most would probably help him fight it, if he were willing to be straightforward on what it is. The reactions say it all... He's likely never wanted to fight fans, but it's a hell of a lot easier to ban angry Joe on a forum than it is to admit failure in a public space.
I am truly shocked that people have not sued him at this point. Legit. There's a lot of bosh going around whether or not it was a scam or not. Don't get me wrong, I loved his books, or anything he's written so far. He's one of the best fantasy authors in the 21st century. I think why it's so good is not just that the world is beautiful and full of well developed characters, it's how it is written. It is truly remarkable. But. Since the charity, my respect for him died. He is a jerk to his fans, he's an ass to anyone who asks about the third novel. Because he didn't deliver the chapter, is it considered scamming? I think so. Why has no one come after him for that? I don't know the details but couldn't he go to jail or something scamming people out of that money? I don't think in his heart he's a truly bad person. His behavior has made it hard to believe that sometimes. I don't get it at all. Why wouldn't you want to release it? It'll be good for him, good for the series, good for the fans, and everyone will be better off for it. It does take time to write a book. It should not be rushed. I am an author myself and have written five books in eight years. I am not saying I'm better than him by doing that. Just making a point. It's unfathomable that it's been 13 YEARS! Jesus man. He's barely breathed about it for like two years, really since 2021. At this point does it even exist? I doubt it.
Surprised he hasn't be sued because not holding up on his side is illegal right? Btw, he didn't apologise. He's irresponsible, immature, unprofessional, uses his mental health as an excuse, and lazy at this point. Nothing is stopping him from hiring people to do all the non-writing parts that he wants to do for that chapter, but he makes it a clear point "I want to do a, b, and c for it" bruh, hire people for the parts that are not part of your job as a WRITER. In the past he's been rude af to fans too and AGAIN used his mental health as an excuse. He's just a man child at the end of the day.
I might be a garbage person but when I donated I did it not for charity, I did it to get a piece of my favorite story and that was stolen from all of us.
I agree with everything you're saying but Brandon Sanderson was the worst choice of examples when talking about Rothfuss. Sanderson is one of the most prolific authors in the genre, he's like the Stephen King of fantasy. Rothfuss clearly has a more serious mental health issue than I think anyone realizes and his situation isn't anything Sanderson has ever experienced. Sanderson's special release is a whole different thing, he didn't do that because he had gone 13 years without being able to release any books. If Rothfuss did the same, fans would not "love it" like when Sanderson did it. They would be seething because all they want is a new book and it would come off as a money grab. I feel for Rothfuss more than most because I know how crushing writer's block is. No, clearly he CAN'T write a chapter in a "day, week, or at the most a month" or the book would have been here already, obviously... His problem is that he keeps making promises that he can't keep, as much as I know he wishes he could. All of his excuses sound like different ways to say he can't handle the pressure and expectations. I sometimes think if the first two books weren't so successful, the third would have been written a decade ago. I think fans should just quietly back off at this point. The fact he said "when I 'accidentally' Google my name" says a lot. The increasing ire over the years has only served to worsen his mental health. He is not getting the help he needs or he would know not to Google his name but he's doing it and if people want to EVER want to see the book they would do well to just leave it be, don't donate, don't hate, just wait or forget him.
He didn't apologize, he said "I feel bad." Yeah well good, it's good to feel bad when you do something bad. It shows you're not a psychopath, just a normal bad person.
You do book news very well, Viking. Content like this is sure to help your channel grow. Very tactfully done the way you addressed this author. Watching further, he could have written a decent standalone short story and his fans would have been happy.
If you really want to lose faith google, when his charity last filed their reported income. And how much money rothfuss makes renting space to his charity.
Yeah but the prose will be far more prosaic and perfunctory. And when it came to Rothfuss half the appeal at least for me was the music in his words. Book 3's not gonna happen anyway, so moot point.
Mental health would be an awesome excuse IF he hadn't continued to blog and join "so many other projects" he always refers. And those apologies he posted are a complete mess of excuses. Lost my respect for some time now and if he writes the last book, i will read it but on my terms: i will borrow it from the public library as soon as it is avaiable. I will not give a cent for it although i strongly believe that he will never write it...
Millions of people go to work everyday with mental health issues. He has the luxury to use mental health as an excuse not to work because royalties from his other books and the checks he likely receives for generating donations for Worldbuilders keep him financially salient.
@@jamescaldwell2357 I don't follow this drama closely enough. I know his mom died, but what are his mental health issues that allow him to keep writing other things and participating in so many events, doing some preliminary work on TV shows (even if cancelled) but prevent him from fulfilling the obligation to his fans to f#@king finish his story? Oh, sorry Neil Gaiman.... did I say "obligation?" Yes, I did - perhaps not a legal one, but an ethical one where the story is a trilogy and people invested time and money into the first two. Who would buy the first two books of a trilogy, and invest all that time into reading them, knowing they would not get the conclusion of the story? No one.
I have tried to be patient. But holy crap. It’s been 13 years! In a road riddled with broken promises, silence, and blaming the fans that made him what he is. While also streaming on twitch. JFC. At what point are fans allowed to say he’s spitting in their face?
I took KKC off my to-read list sometime around 2018 (it was coming up quickly on it, but I was paring down my list) and told my friends I would read them once DoS got a release date. So I, as a fantasy fan, have not read KKC, and at this rate I might never do so.
I always thought his father wrote them. His father died in 2017 after a 10 year battle with lung cancer and an 8 month fight with leukemia. He just got too sick to finish them. Why let your son publish them? Because at that time Pat was basically a professional student and didnt have any prospects of ever being an adult. If you've know those kinds of people you know what I mean. The charity by the way is a grift. They take the money rake off admin fees and give the leftovers to the actual charity which also takes its cut. Pat even bought a building himself and has the charity pay him 'rent'. Family is employed there as well.
Is there any breakdown for distribution of funds from the charity - who specifically the money is going to and how much? It would also be interesting to know who is authorized to distribute funds on the charity account. In other words, is he in control of how the funds are used?
Why is the possibility that Rothfuss simply found someone else's unfinished manuscript in some attic that was written by his deceased relative, or some-such, is not being discussed? This would explain why he's not written a single chapter as of yet - he has no idea how to write such quality stuff by himself!
Yeah. Even IF he didn't have the chapter he promised to deliver, how hard is it to just make something up and deliver it as he said he would? It wouldn't even have to be a super legitimate chapter. Just give SOMETHING...
Fans are waiting, publishers are waiting. It’s obvious the author is stuck. With the following he has, he’s under incredible pressure to produce a masterpiece, and it has apparently shackled him-for thirteen years and counting. As far as the ‘promised’ chapter, could be that it doesn’t exist, or if it does, maybe he feels like it subceeds everyone’s colossal expectations? In any event, my prediction is that the book will never be published, in his lifetime. I’d gladly be proved wrong. I wouldn’t trade places with Patrick Rothfuss, not even for that mil+ in charity money 😁 George R.R. Martin is in the same boat, his fans are still clamoring for that sixth book, that may or may not ever happen.
It's simple, it's because Rothfuss has no respect for anybody. And if you don't like being constantly lied to, jerked around and taken advantage of, you are just a hater and a terrible person. He doesn't owe his fans anything as he constantly reminds them.
The other projects take priority because it brings in more money… my assumption is that the donations went to where they were intended and so to finish the chapter and upload it brings him no income
So, I am going to toss a theory out there... What if he isn't the writer..... Hear me out. What if he was working with the actual writer, convinced them of the difficulties involved in getting published or manipulated it in another way that he would simply publish it under his name. Then, as the books popularity grew, he and said writer had a falling out, leaving him without a means to replicate the work for the last book.
Rothfuss is honestly fascinating. I cant believe he hasnt been able to release book 3 yet. He must have made some world breaking misstakes in the first books that he simply isnt able to solve and still keep his original story going. I wonder what he makes a living off? He cant still be living off the first 2 books surely!
I feel like you're screaming into the void. He's a twitch streamer who used to write. And he's counting his money for each new special edition that is released, and is obviously doing well enough that for whatever reasons he's not writing, he really doesn't have any incentive to write.
Name of the wind was a book i almost dnf. Then, about halfway way through, it just clicked. He writes beautifully. I dont really get this guy and martin. They obviously have talent. If i was them id just release it already. I highly suspect especially in the case of martin, that the book is done. They just got too popular and feel too much pressure. So they go over it again and again and again trying to make sometbing unperfectable ..perfect. Just wrap it up release the damn thing and what will be will be.
You know why? 'Cause the theory that Rothfuss has found someone's unfinished script on some garage sale, or some attic and published it as his own work, hoping he could finish that work of fiction. But he can't. 'Cause it ain't his.
I'll play devil's advocate here. Some people are extremely sensitive to the opinion of others and writers are often rather sensitive people on the whole. Imagine him writing a few successful books, enjoying the public's admiration, but then this happens. He wants to make his fans happy, he wants to not "just" release a chapter but make it a special thing but it falls to pieces, fans turn angry & against him at the same time as real life throws some spanners in the works (been there myself, a lot of people seem to never have had real problems in their life since they don't realize how it can mess you up) and suddenly you lose all motivation, all drive. For a writer that's a death sentence. Writing is not an office job, it's not a "let's crank out 8 hours a day" job. It's not "I'll sit down and type for 8 hours". No, good writing requires creativity, a sharpness of mind, focus, passion, a drive to keep going. Loads of writers get stuck - look at George R R Martin as the most obvious example (and I bet there's similar reasons there too). I can well see how a fan base that suddenly turned sour, feeling like the Internet is against you and no-one having any sympathy for what you're going through in your private life can kill all of that. And for what? A single chapter. Not a final product, nothing tangible. A TEASER. And instead of the "fans" going "Oh it's fine, just work on the book itself" they turn against him and increase the chance of there never been a third book at ALL now! As someone who has gone through several years of some very nasty stuff which led to a major burn out, I find it insulting how the Internet treats people. "We paid for something so you owe us now regardless" is such a cold hearted thing to say. Yes, it's true but if you're really a fan and really love something, you do NOT behave in such a toxic way, ESPECIALLY since it was a charity drive.
The internet can be wonderful and utterly horrible in matter of nanoseconds. This is the exact reason why i dont have any social accounts besides a youtube. For Pat to not just copy/paste text from a screenshot that was leaked years ago with multiple chapters is mind-boggling. Then just say, this isnt a final draft and is subject to changes. Yes, I understand he wanted to make super awesome with special readers and what not, but quite literally, all his fans wanted was a few pages. Everyone needs to be a bit nicer, but it doesn't help when you first off don't really make a sincere apology about a massive Goof up.
If the third instalment ever comes out, I will not bother with it. I enjoyed the first 2 books when they first came out but after thirteen years of crickets, the interest is nonexistent on my part. Why reread door-stoppers to reacquaint with the story and reward a disingenuous individual by giving him gas? No thanks.
I’m late to the party, but I have waited for this third book. Here’s an idea screw him copyright everything and let’s creative community to make the book.
I see a lot of comments saying people are straight up done with him for the simple reason that he hasn’t finished the series yet (unrelated to this charity issue)…and I wonder if Stephen King would have gotten this same amount of hate if there’d been social media in all the years between his Dark tower novels.
At this point I don't much care whether he finishes it or not. The material he's produced so far wasn't bad but my own experience reading it was a slowly growing belief that this just wasn't going anywhere. The story just seemed to wander and I lost interest in it. Same thing happened to GRRM and his never concluding story.
It's almost like Patrick can't move ahead with the final book at all. Something in his head just can't let him do it. Maybe it's just such a big part of his life that he can't bare to be done with it. He doesn't know what his life will be without it. What will be his purpose? The man clearly needs to work on himself first.
@amandapelland It is what it is, I guess. His antics definitely won't help him. I'd really like to read the last book, but fortunately, there are plenty of other good series to read.
You did a good job with the video. Reading is supposed to build compassion and empathy, an understanding that people can make mistakes, can do bad things, and still be good people. It seems that far too many of Rothfuss' "fans?" will acknowledge and appreciate moral complexity in fiction but not in real life. This is sad.
The real issue with Pat is that it's not that he hasn't written anything it's that he is still benefiting from the idea that he's an active writer. Which demonstrably isn't true so I don't know if he was just honest I don't think he'd get as much hate
At this point he has basically scammed people out of more than $1 million dollars. That million came from fans. Fans who are now realizing that he’s basically walked away with their money without delivering the product they gave the money for. He’s a con man, like so many who have promised and not delivered once the money was in their hands. People have been rooking other people out of their money for hundreds of years. Rothfuss is no different than any other crook at this point. He can’t write ONE chapter, but he can expand a short story and sell it for $26 a pop. He, like other con artists, took advantage of people’s desperation and walked off with a large amount of money going to a charity that he owns, I believe, which means it went into his pocket. Whether he used it for charity or not, I can’t say. But he certainly didn’t write a chapter with it. He’s banking on the continued sympathy and support of good and kind people like yourself, so that he can keep making excuses. He wouldn’t be the first person to take advantage of the kindness and generosity of good people.
Well, that second sentence is clearly an erroneous notion. I’ve been an avid reader for most of my life and people constantly tell me that I lack empathy. LOL
Rothfuss is a perfectionist, and is caught in a doom loop. He not the type of person to release what he see as unready. For bad or ill that just how he is. Success only put more pressure on him.
I don’t care for the chapter, I just want the book. It’s been far too long. I think he made a mistake by saying at the start he’d made a trilogy and then didn’t deliver on all three books.
I loved the first two books, and recently reread them. But I hate Rothfuss with a passion. Even if Doors of Stones did get released, I fear the book would just be a rushed, poorly written book. Causing me to rather have made the ending up in my mind. Than ruining the story for myself
Can I please ask everyone to keep a respectful tone? While I think it is important to keep pressure on Rothfuss to deliver I think it is important we try and address this as respectfully as possible.
It's hard seeing so many people go way overboard on this. I get that people like his work, but turning to an angry mob like this is why authors like him stop writing. If he underdelivers people rip him apart anyways. He's just a dude like any of us, and it sucks to see people lose interest in why his books are great. It's regretful that he didn't honor his commitment, but the goal of the donations was not his book anyways, it was for the charity. If he had pocketed that money it would be different, and while I understand that his chapter was the reason people donated, I still think that people lost sight of the whole charity work. They should be saying his response was disappointing, not completely villifying him for this. We are not entitled to a third book, that's his art and if he never publishes the third one then oh well. There are plenty of other stories if you want your fill. I'd rather look at why his books are great.
@@KMFWR I feel like even acknowledging that, the response is still extreme. I understand people don't like not getting what they paid for, but this kind of fan entitlement is what ends up in creators recieving death threats. I was aware of this kind of response in the gaming community but seeing it in readers too is incredibly disheartening.
@@KMFWR Claims about someone having had a ghost writer for twenty years are not oppinions. I never said you needed to give your justification. My oppinion is that people feel entitled, and need to check themselves. Pat never intended this to take off as it did, and while I get people voicing their frustration, they have also begun to take it too far. That doesn't mean I can stop people, you can do whatever you want. That is merely my oppinion. I find it ironic for you to imply that my voicing this concern infringes upon that somehow.
Also my comment was not personally directed at you, though your need to defend yourself is indeed telling. The creator of the video is asking for people to be respectful, I merely wanted to add on to it.
His charity is actually rated extremely low on Charity Navigator, which says the organization isnt even remotely transparant with Financial Statements, Tax Documents and has a 57% expense ratio. I does not look good.
@@TheJollySoviet he’s a fraudster that’s why. Unlike many here, I’m not bothered by not having a 3rd book, I didn’t think much of the story
the fact that he doesn't even has ONE chapter of a new book says everything. The book is not getting released.
He is literally a scammer. People wouldn't have given him this much money if he hadn't said he would give them a chapter. And he knew that very well, else there was no reason to promise something you're never going to give
He did it as a bet, and kept trying to double down when he lost. I think he thought he couldn't lose, so didn't have to worry about paying up till it was too late, like all gambmers who lose big.
“It’s not a lot of fun being on the internet anymore” -Rothfuss
“It’s not a lot of fun being a king killer chronicles fan anymore” -the fans
You’re being more gracious towards Rothfuss than I am. The man committed fraud, never apologized (I feel bad is not the same as I’m sorry, and here is how I will fix it), and uses his mental health as an excuse for terrible behavior.
I mean, I struggle with severe anxiety, and have ADD, but I have obligations and responsibilities, and promises that I make and need to fulfill. What if I just stopped taking my kids to school, or refused to pay my bills, or any number of things? And then on top of that I refused to give any explanation for my behavior? And then 2.5 years later I did a general announcement saying I kinda feel bad about it, but those people who bothered me about the situation were d***s?
TBH, those fans should have pressed charges against Rothfuss, and I can tell you I won’t have anything to do with his work until he fixes this.
Geez, who even cares about this guy anymore? This is a guy that said his entire story was complete when he was signed. I love his first book, the second was good but not great, but his shitty attitude around fans asking about his third book has completely lost me, the guy is a prick.
THIS. He does not deserve people reading his books.
I didn’t think much of the books
I mostly just want to see him held accountable for scamming donors of charity. I've done a lot of charity work in my life, and I donated to Worldbuilders multiple times. Pat is a gaslighting narcissist who uses mental health as a scapegoat. It makes us who actually suffer from those issues look bad. We don't go around stealing and refusing to write 10 pages in 13+ years.
He seems mentally very immature, like a child stuck in an adult's body. "Meanies asking questions get banned!" Pretty tragic, actually.
I think part of it is his attitude, and part is his popularity. He seems to be very arrogant, he likes to shit on Tolkien as if his own style of fantasy is superior and that doesn't get you really anywhere. The other aspect is like George R. R. Martin (perhaps to a lesser degree) he has achieved a ton of popularity without having finished his magnum opus. Some people lose motivation when they achieve their goals before they finish working towards them. If you give someone the gold medal before the race is over, they're probably not going to finish. Martin doesn't have the same attitude as Rothfuss but there's no chance he's finishing his series either.
I am not a fan of Kingkiller, but I take a great interest in how Rothfuss has treated his fans. As an aspiring author, I have an excellent example of what NOT to do as an author.
And a good example of what TO do as one, oh Ruin-profile-pic
(Even if you can’t crank out material at the rate of the Brandotron 9000, he’s a pretty good role model with regards to how he treats his fans.)
I'm so done with him.
I gave up on Martin also, but at least R.R. Martin isn't a douche!
I mean yeah,Martin and his fans know that he has a ton of hats he has his hands on and he is aged too I feel like lynch and Martin are way more vocal (even though song of ice and fire has shit ton of things going on other than just a book)
And Martin dropped multiple chapters. I think he is actually working on it, just having a lot of trouble. Rothfuss appereantly have not wrote a single chapter.
At least with G.R.R.M. I get the impression that he is trying to write the book (at a snail's pace but trying), Patrick on the other hand I'm pretty sure that the dude hasn't been doing nothing other than sitting around and scratching his balls for over 10 years.
@@AkaSora96
I got the opposite impression. I cant help but notice how much of a far left extremist Martin became, im not sure how his Marxist views can sit well with his old writing style. If his dreamed color revolution ever happens hes going up the wall first thats for sure, maybe hes making sure it dosnt happen and wont write again.
10:15 When did he apologize? He just said he feels bad that's not an apology, by saying he feels bad he makes it about himself when he is not the victim here, a proper apology is taking accountability and it's main focus is always towards the real victim not yourself, I don't care how you feel, an apology is not about knowing that you feel bad an apology is saying "I'm sorry, I acted wrong" every reason as to how you feel or why it happened should come second to that.
This. Feeling bad isn't an apology. That is literally what narcissists say to not have to apologize when they are backed into corners.
Jesus forgave him so now everything is fine. Right? That’s how it works… apparently.
@@NatalieNox600 yeah, it's a classic tactic to make you feel bad, like "and now I AM the asshole" they do it so people take pity on them and stop trying to make them take responsibility, I should know I used to do it, it's not like some evil thing you do to manipulate, it's more like self-pity and feeling like you are the victim and try to make people see you as that when deep down you know you are not the one who was screwed over, no matter how much you want to believe it.
Jesus won't lose 1 of His sheep. John Chapter 10
At this point, i feel the best move for him and his fans would be for him to admit something like, "I'm facing the world's worst case of writer's block. I've been trying to get this book out for a decade, and it's just not happening. I'm sorry the book probably won't be coming out." That way, if he wants to keep working on it behind the scenes, it's a bonus, but he's not carrying all those expectations anymore.
But something about Pat's personality tells me that he will never do that because he likes the limelight even if it does make him look pathetic.
Probably would be best for his mental health I still love all of his writings dispite it all!
Must be great to just not work, sadly everyday people can’t afford to do that
@neiltaylor513 I think that's what is costing him sympathy. Lots of people have big problems, but only the well off can afford to not work while they solve those problems.
he said, that he has to story ready - if it‘s a writers block, then he should work together with a ghostwriter
Here’s my opinion. Rothfuss never intended to deliver. He released an already released prologue with a couple of changes. And he didn’t apologize. He said he felt bad, and that he could have done it a year and a half ago, and called everyone who even questioned him d***s. At this point he’s a thief. To release a book and still have not delivered on a $1million promise. His mental health is, as you say, no excuse. He’s a thief, and I would need itemized receipts to even believe it went to charity. As for his work, I don’t believe anymore that he wrote it. I think he had a really great ghost writer and they’ve either parted on bad terms, or the ghost writer has died. He also seems to feel entitled to collect money and provide nothing. One chapter could have been written in less time than it took him gaslight his way through that “apology.” Nobody asked for perfection. Just got a chapter. Which he couldn’t manage even though he managed to expand a short story into a $26 novella.
He didn’t have a ghost writer, he just has writers block. It took him 16 years to finish the first book.
Based on what I've seen, I think he has not learned the skill in life to force yourself to do something, is excellent at making excuses, and is mentally too immature to analyse this aspect of himself.
What year did Terry pratchett die?🤔😂😭
@@Transformers217
I wonder how many bank robbers can say they have "writer block" in front of a judge.
His editor has publicly said she has never seen a single word of DoS in 13 years. She believes he hasn’t written a single word since WMF came out.
His third book should be called
‘Pissed into the wind’
lol
Book 3 does not exist. All he needed was to pick just one chapter and read it, and since he didn't, it can only mean that not a single chapter for book 3 exist. More and more, this looks like a scam.
Not trying to sound like I'm defending Rothfuss, because I'm not - but the deal was for a stand-alone chapter that wouldn't contain any spoilers, not just any old chapter. That doesn't mean I believe he's written anything - I don't, and it pisses me off, but that he had no chapter ready to release that met that description doesn't mean he didn't have anything at all.
His ghostwriter perished, for sure.
Wonder if him and George RR Martin used the same guy.
@@RampageRich no.
@@RampageRichthe same hitman to punish their respective ghostwriters for attempting to extort them.
@@RampageRichMartin has written much more books than Rothfuss, they are not comparable.
@@CnoacdeTara It was a joke
I'd put money on it that he doesn't have a single chapter completed yet. It wouldn't surprise me if he hasn't even put together an outline of the book. Every time I see one of these videos I'm thankful I never started his books because he isn't finishing it.
I've given up on Rothfuss and already got rid of his books I purchased. I don't bother promoting his books either. Such a scammer and jerk, depression or not. I have depression and anxiety, but I take medication and I'm so much better for it.
Sorry, but I won't watch that video. I've decided to let bygones be bygones, but this said, Mr. Rothfuss will never ever get a single penny from me, even when I absolutely love the books he has written. But I just don't want to waste my time waiting for the next book, when there's so many other talented authors out that write at a consistent pace and get their work done. I much prefer to give my money to those authors and reward their work ethics.And to be honest, I'd much rather have you spend your time talking about those authors as well, because contrary to Mr. Rothfuss, they would deserve it.
Was that the apology? Cause i didnt hear him appologize.
He didn't.
100% this. "I feel bad" is what narcissists say when they are cornered instead of apologizing. I grew up with a parent who was later diagnosed with narcissistic personality disorder. I'm very familiar with this phrase.
I'm surprised there have been no lawsuits. If I had donated I would have launched a lawsuit.
The problem is the word, donation.......when ones donates....they lose most ways to get something back. If his promise was contractual then he would have to pay but it wasn't
@@PageTurnersbooktube523 Charities and donations receive far more scrutiny over donation incentives especially when directly offered by the Charity itself (Pat is the only Board member of Worldbuilders).
If Pat wasn't The Founder and active board member this would be true. Pat being a mouthpiece of the charity makes this an official action of the charity. Which turns this into defrauding donors of a charitable organization. I have reason to believe his charity is currently under investigation.
@NatalieNox600 understood thanks for clarifying
@@NatalieNox600feels like amber heard all over again
3 series likely never to be finished:
1: king killer Chronicles
2: A Song of Ice and Fire
3: Gentleman Bastards.
To me it’s an absolute tragedy that these literary works of art may never be completed. I hope I’m wrong and all of them get finished.
I still think that Kingkiller Chronicles and Gentleman Bastards will finish one day. Both authors still write and are relatively young (or, at least, have a decent lifespawn).
@@henriqueAMC I hope so.
At least with Gentlemen Bastards, each book has enough of a sense of resolution that (at least for me) the series could end at that point and still be satisfying. All questions answered, every stone turned? No. But I’ve never been angry to close a book at the end of reading it, and if any others are published, it’ll just be a pleasant surprise.
@@oohshiny1366 I personally thought that Republic of Thieves ended on a cliffhanger in that we get a huge reveal and it’s said that many things will come to pass in some fashion or another. It left me chomping at the bit for more lol. IMO
@@hawk66100 That’s fair! I took it much more as “and the adventure could continue!” without really feeling the need for answers. It would be great to read more about these characters and setting, but I’m also satisfied with the story as-is. It’s way more comparable to something like The Last Unicorn, or Sabriel in that way. It is wildly untrue for the other ASoIaF, and KKC.
Given Rothfuss's political beliefs-- or at least what he's happy to shout about-- I think the whole thing was a troll on people-- his fans-- who have disposable income: people who haven't already given all of their money to charity.
He's just another hypocrite who likes to say money "doesn't matter" while he has plenty of it.
Also, I don't think the money was ever real to him. He wanted to go "double or nothing" at one point until his mods talked him out of it I shudder to think what kind of damage he could do to himself in front of a slot machine.
At this point I feel he should just admit he cannot complete it, he should gather his notes and ask Brandon Sanderson, Steven Erikson, or Joe Abercrombie to finish his work so the fans can have closure.
Sanderson is Rothfuss’s opposite. The madman churns out books faster than his publisher can print them 🤣
@@MaiaGothmog Moreso than that - they're opposites in prose, too. Sanderson says he tries to make his prose invisible, and as a result its very basic. makes his books fast reads and easy to read (which is important for a story with ten thousand made up words) but it makes for mediocre prose. Rothfuss has less of that high-fantasy stuff, and his prose is significantly better.
@@stephengrant4841 I think “significantly better” is a very subjective term. Sando does an incredible job with what he’s trying to do. And I prefer a simpler, more fast-paced writing style to “beautiful” prose. Then again, I read mainly for escapism and so I like my stories to move fast. For example, I just read Red Rising and the prose in that book is simply masterful in my opinion. And I think Pierce Brown handles that style better than Sanderson. I write my own stories that way.
@@MaiaGothmog Yeah I wasn't dismissing Sanderson. After all, I said that how he writes works for what he's writing.
Never heard of Steven Erikson, I like Sanderson and Abercrombie though, I have read everything by Abercrombie.
Have to agree. As an author myself, if I promised a chapter, I would release "anything" even if it isn't done and say look, this is something special for you, it may change in the final book....but for now, this is the chapter.
Can't even do that? $1 million? holy shit dude, figure yourself out. Personally I never even got through book 2, but out of curiosity I'm following up on this debacle and I'm stunned.
The Career Killer Chronicle.
Him and RR Martin…. I think they both simply made so much money and got so much praise that it affected their work ethic. They don’t need money, so there’s no financial reason to write another book. And they got so much critical praise that they are afraid to write something that isn’t perfect. I wish them well.
Martin isn't a scammer, what are you talking about?
Why would you think there is no financial gain by releasing the book?
His fans literally paid him over a million dollars to release one chapter. Don’t you think these fans would not buy the book when it’s released 😂
What praise is he getting by doing this?
Great timing, I just started the audiobook for Name of the Wind. Put it off for years because this guy is not reliable. I found a free version somewhere so I'm listening to it before it get's taken down. Get to listen to the book without supporting this scammer at the same time. Win win 👍
Scammer or not, the books are amazing and he deserves the money from them.
I loved the first two books. But it's been a fucking decade since book two came out. At this point in time I assume he will literally never finish book three and the story will never have an ending. Some authors need to realize that perfection isn't worth letting your readers grow into completely different people. Since book 2 released I've completed a master and a PhD, moved to not one but two different countries, and went from being single to married with two kids with one starting school this Fall.
The greatest fantasy of our generation is thinking Patrick Rothfuss is writing the final book 😅
Wish I could write 2 books I could live off of for the rest of my life. Must be nice.
Fine. I won't purchase his works. I will get pirated PDFs of his works. I was excited to order his 2 books if i ever want to read kingkiller chronicles. I'm sorry but his attitude is disappointing.
Pirating so morally superior
epub with an e reader is the only right way (moon reader is good)
i dont understand the reasoning behind him not communicating. Just tell us where the books at in terms of progress. people are already pissed. you cant make fans more angry by just being open.
The reason he isn't honest is probably because there *is* no progress being made. "Sorry guys but I gave up a while ago" is about the worst possible thing he could say.
@gagecole4913 it would be but it would also be better than whatever he is doing now.
After all these years I no longer care whether or not he writes another book
He should have shoved whatever out the door, learned form his mistakes, and started his next series. His first book was really good, but not perfect. Can't get over himself. Writing is not a mystical art, it's sitting there and thinking and getting words on the page as best you can. Afraid to fail = afraid to move.
I undertand being too depressed or mentally ill to write. I struggle the same so i get it. But setting up fund raisers and getting money from fans for doing nothing at all is a complete different story. Atleast make an effort to give fans what they want.
Bit of a misnomer to call that an "apology". Doesn't an apology require you to actually say "I'm sorry" or "I apologise" or some variation thereof?
Screw him. There’s a whole galaxy of stories made by writers who are CONSISTENT with their work. Read the Hanuvar novels by Howard Andrew Jones. He already released two books in the series and the third one will be out later this year.
I really think he is struggling with this book. I have been a fan for a long time and I remember the wait for the 2nd book and I was so excited when it finally came. But there’s definitely a huge change in him since then. The Pat from 15 years ago would never have done something like that. I don’t know, but I am actually a little afraid of book 3 finally being released because I fear the tone and feel will be so vastly different from books one and two that it will almost ruin it for me.
When I read (and absolutely LOVED) Books 1 and 2 of the series, I had no idea that I may die of old age before the conclusion of the trilogy. Patrick is no scammer, he’s simply one in a long line of tortured artist using their fragile mental health as a crutch. (READ: another whiny Primadonna’s fear of success)
He'll use the excuse of "oh, I didn't scam anybody, that went to charity"as an excuse too
My theory is that the guy is addicted to something, most probably drugs, alcohol or both. I've seen this pattern before
He should release the prologue for book 4 (just copy and paste). I am really looking forward to the "reimagined" version of slow regard
I gave up on waiting for Rothfuss book long time ago. He said once on his blog joking that Steven Erickson sold his soul to the devil and that is why he write so much books so fast (Malazan Series) . Maybe Rothfuss should sell his too...
IMO, it was pretty obvious he wrote a Bast chapter for charity, and he decided he could sell another book if he weaved that new story into The Lightning Tree.
Even still its not that hard to write another chapter to release a novel with no controversy, thus making MORE money instead of releasing a novel after a huge backlash with his own fanbase 😂
@@adoniscreed4031 oh, I'm 100% there with you. Honestly, the idiot could have given everyone half of The Narrow Road between Desires for free, and it would have increased goodwill and boosted sales. The dude is just lazy. I get it. Mental disorders are a b*tch, but if he wanted to get it done he would have.
Sounds like Rothfuss is pulling George RR Martin move. Promise something to your fans, and never deliver.
Dear Patrick Rothfuss: please invite Brandon Sanderson and other authors to a write out adventure! Brainstorming with other Authors might get you out of whatever spot you are stuck in. Or you can even sell them your project so they can finish it! We won’t mind! And you can still be on the credits with a finished storyline
God that ‘apology’ just made me ill when I first saw it. Like man your fans donated over 1 million dollars to your charity that, I guarantee you, wouldn’t have come anywhere near even half of what it made if you didn’t promise a chapter from Doors of Stone. Then you go on with these excuses “Oh it’s not edited the way I want it to be, I want to do a big thing with professional VO’s. Then it turned into a mess.”
Like dude stop using your mental issues as a crutch here, pick a chapter from the book, preferably one that doesn’t need a ton of context from other chapters, and literally copy and paste that to your blog. You can literally say “Hey guys, this is a rough draft of the chapter _It will likely be different in the final manuscript_ but this is it so far. Thank you once again for donating your hard earned money to my charity.” Fans would be over the moon for new kingkiller content in a decade, and they would understand it’s a rough draft of the chapter. The fact it’s been nearly 2 and a half years is making me think he hasn’t written ANYTHING of Doors of Stone.
thanks for covering this! i think about it every month probably, lol. i was gifted the name of the wind a couple christmases ago, but i won't start the series until all this drama is resolved. just say something, dude (rothfuss)!
Respect turned to disappointment turned to resentment turned to anger turned to detestation. 😒
Has anyone else had the thought that he didn't write this series in the first place...
Aaaand there's the conspiracy theorist for the day... Remember: Things are never simple, there's ALWAYS something sinister going on, always a dark secret, always a scheme
I feel like a lot of ppl forgot this was during the pandemic timeframe, which can EASILY change someone's life, let alone their plans. He's a human first and foremost. Those who assume anything about someone who writes so in-depth and layered, are more than likely incorrect.
Sure could have, but that doesn't free you, him, or me from responsibilities or promises made. Recovery requires doing hard things. Anything except expecting one to do what is right is enabling what is wrong. More so, it's fraud to misrepresent intentions, even with charity, and I'm surprised nobody has sued and that consumer protection hasn't stepped in.
@@schlurrpy9790 Screw him, sure the pandemic was bad sure, but that was 2 years ago, the release of book 2 was 2011 he had 9 years to produce something, but at every corner, instead of writing he was doing charity and going to pax to play DnD and at every moment and at every moment he was abrasive to his own fans, GRR Martin is the same but at least Martin has interviews where he says that writing a chap for him is like giving birth, Rothuss just complain about his own fans.
@@DaviHorner I guess. Yes and no? I want to assume that he has the right thing to do in his mind, ready to go, but Occam's razor suggests otherwise. The simplest answer is he screwed up, and something will not allow him to fix the problem. Nobody else knows what that something is. Is it pride? Is it fear? Ghost writer part ways? Whatever it is, that's his demon to fight. Most would probably help him fight it, if he were willing to be straightforward on what it is. The reactions say it all... He's likely never wanted to fight fans, but it's a hell of a lot easier to ban angry Joe on a forum than it is to admit failure in a public space.
I am truly shocked that people have not sued him at this point. Legit. There's a lot of bosh going around whether or not it was a scam or not. Don't get me wrong, I loved his books, or anything he's written so far. He's one of the best fantasy authors in the 21st century. I think why it's so good is not just that the world is beautiful and full of well developed characters, it's how it is written. It is truly remarkable. But. Since the charity, my respect for him died. He is a jerk to his fans, he's an ass to anyone who asks about the third novel. Because he didn't deliver the chapter, is it considered scamming? I think so. Why has no one come after him for that? I don't know the details but couldn't he go to jail or something scamming people out of that money? I don't think in his heart he's a truly bad person. His behavior has made it hard to believe that sometimes. I don't get it at all. Why wouldn't you want to release it? It'll be good for him, good for the series, good for the fans, and everyone will be better off for it.
It does take time to write a book. It should not be rushed. I am an author myself and have written five books in eight years. I am not saying I'm better than him by doing that. Just making a point. It's unfathomable that it's been 13 YEARS! Jesus man. He's barely breathed about it for like two years, really since 2021. At this point does it even exist? I doubt it.
We all don't need his books.
Surprised he hasn't be sued because not holding up on his side is illegal right?
Btw, he didn't apologise. He's irresponsible, immature, unprofessional, uses his mental health as an excuse, and lazy at this point. Nothing is stopping him from hiring people to do all the non-writing parts that he wants to do for that chapter, but he makes it a clear point "I want to do a, b, and c for it" bruh, hire people for the parts that are not part of your job as a WRITER.
In the past he's been rude af to fans too and AGAIN used his mental health as an excuse. He's just a man child at the end of the day.
I might be a garbage person but when I donated I did it not for charity, I did it to get a piece of my favorite story and that was stolen from all of us.
Lawsuit? Class action lawsuit?
I agree with everything you're saying but Brandon Sanderson was the worst choice of examples when talking about Rothfuss. Sanderson is one of the most prolific authors in the genre, he's like the Stephen King of fantasy. Rothfuss clearly has a more serious mental health issue than I think anyone realizes and his situation isn't anything Sanderson has ever experienced. Sanderson's special release is a whole different thing, he didn't do that because he had gone 13 years without being able to release any books. If Rothfuss did the same, fans would not "love it" like when Sanderson did it. They would be seething because all they want is a new book and it would come off as a money grab.
I feel for Rothfuss more than most because I know how crushing writer's block is. No, clearly he CAN'T write a chapter in a "day, week, or at the most a month" or the book would have been here already, obviously... His problem is that he keeps making promises that he can't keep, as much as I know he wishes he could.
All of his excuses sound like different ways to say he can't handle the pressure and expectations. I sometimes think if the first two books weren't so successful, the third would have been written a decade ago.
I think fans should just quietly back off at this point. The fact he said "when I 'accidentally' Google my name" says a lot. The increasing ire over the years has only served to worsen his mental health. He is not getting the help he needs or he would know not to Google his name but he's doing it and if people want to EVER want to see the book they would do well to just leave it be, don't donate, don't hate, just wait or forget him.
The fix:
Ctrl + C,
Ctrl + V,
"still subject to change. Enjoy ya'll"
He didn't apologize, he said "I feel bad." Yeah well good, it's good to feel bad when you do something bad. It shows you're not a psychopath, just a normal bad person.
You do book news very well, Viking. Content like this is sure to help your channel grow. Very tactfully done the way you addressed this author. Watching further, he could have written a decent standalone short story and his fans would have been happy.
Thank you! I really appreciate it!
If you really want to lose faith google, when his charity last filed their reported income. And how much money rothfuss makes renting space to his charity.
I saw it was $6000 a month. That's $72000 a year. Most people could live comfortably with that alone.
He needs to ask Sanderson to finish it. And it will be done by December
Yeah but the prose will be far more prosaic and perfunctory. And when it came to Rothfuss half the appeal at least for me was the music in his words. Book 3's not gonna happen anyway, so moot point.
@@cmp6008 I feel so bamboozeled
Mental health would be an awesome excuse IF he hadn't continued to blog and join "so many other projects" he always refers. And those apologies he posted are a complete mess of excuses. Lost my respect for some time now and if he writes the last book, i will read it but on my terms: i will borrow it from the public library as soon as it is avaiable. I will not give a cent for it although i strongly believe that he will never write it...
Millions of people go to work everyday with mental health issues. He has the luxury to use mental health as an excuse not to work because royalties from his other books and the checks he likely receives for generating donations for Worldbuilders keep him financially salient.
@@jamescaldwell2357 I don't follow this drama closely enough. I know his mom died, but what are his mental health issues that allow him to keep writing other things and participating in so many events, doing some preliminary work on TV shows (even if cancelled) but prevent him from fulfilling the obligation to his fans to f#@king finish his story? Oh, sorry Neil Gaiman.... did I say "obligation?" Yes, I did - perhaps not a legal one, but an ethical one where the story is a trilogy and people invested time and money into the first two. Who would buy the first two books of a trilogy, and invest all that time into reading them, knowing they would not get the conclusion of the story? No one.
He doesn't care about his fans.
The cut down apology at 8:33 with text in it was made by Daniel Greene, think you forgot to credit it.
The credit is in the description of this video but you are right, I should have added it to the video as well!
I have tried to be patient. But holy crap. It’s been 13 years! In a road riddled with broken promises, silence, and blaming the fans that made him what he is. While also streaming on twitch. JFC. At what point are fans allowed to say he’s spitting in their face?
How is this guy a fantasy fan but hasn't read any of these books?
I took KKC off my to-read list sometime around 2018 (it was coming up quickly on it, but I was paring down my list) and told my friends I would read them once DoS got a release date. So I, as a fantasy fan, have not read KKC, and at this rate I might never do so.
I always thought his father wrote them. His father died in 2017 after a 10 year battle with lung cancer and an 8 month fight with leukemia. He just got too sick to finish them. Why let your son publish them? Because at that time Pat was basically a professional student and didnt have any prospects of ever being an adult. If you've know those kinds of people you know what I mean. The charity by the way is a grift. They take the money rake off admin fees and give the leftovers to the actual charity which also takes its cut. Pat even bought a building himself and has the charity pay him 'rent'. Family is employed there as well.
Is there a person who left his life 13 years ago? Maybe he doesn’t know how to write maybe he isn’t actually a writer.
Is there any breakdown for distribution of funds from the charity - who specifically the money is going to and how much? It would also be interesting to know who is authorized to distribute funds on the charity account. In other words, is he in control of how the funds are used?
Why is the possibility that Rothfuss simply found someone else's unfinished manuscript in some attic that was written by his deceased relative, or some-such, is not being discussed? This would explain why he's not written a single chapter as of yet - he has no idea how to write such quality stuff by himself!
Yeah. Even IF he didn't have the chapter he promised to deliver, how hard is it to just make something up and deliver it as he said he would? It wouldn't even have to be a super legitimate chapter. Just give SOMETHING...
His ghostwriter died and now he’s lollygagging
Fans are waiting, publishers are waiting. It’s obvious the author is stuck. With the following he has, he’s under incredible pressure to produce a masterpiece, and it has apparently shackled him-for thirteen years and counting. As far as the ‘promised’ chapter, could be that it doesn’t exist, or if it does, maybe he feels like it subceeds everyone’s colossal expectations? In any event, my prediction is that the book will never be published, in his lifetime. I’d gladly be proved wrong. I wouldn’t trade places with Patrick Rothfuss, not even for that mil+ in charity money 😁 George R.R. Martin is in the same boat, his fans are still clamoring for that sixth book, that may or may not ever happen.
I heard that the charity which he set up actually rents there offices from him, so he could be earning from it
Damn I wish this video came out sooner, I wouldn’t have bought his king killer chronicle books last week
It's simple, it's because Rothfuss has no respect for anybody. And if you don't like being constantly lied to, jerked around and taken advantage of, you are just a hater and a terrible person. He doesn't owe his fans anything as he constantly reminds them.
It's such a shame, I really want to read this series but the author's actions are making me put it on hold until he addresses what he's done. :(
Man I never knew about this controversy, I’ve been living under a rock, his first book was amazing but shit that attitude he has is proper foul
The other projects take priority because it brings in more money… my assumption is that the donations went to where they were intended and so to finish the chapter and upload it brings him no income
So, I am going to toss a theory out there... What if he isn't the writer..... Hear me out. What if he was working with the actual writer, convinced them of the difficulties involved in getting published or manipulated it in another way that he would simply publish it under his name. Then, as the books popularity grew, he and said writer had a falling out, leaving him without a means to replicate the work for the last book.
Rothfuss is honestly fascinating. I cant believe he hasnt been able to release book 3 yet. He must have made some world breaking misstakes in the first books that he simply isnt able to solve and still keep his original story going. I wonder what he makes a living off? He cant still be living off the first 2 books surely!
i did read the first 2 books when they appeared. Liked them....but time has passed (12 years) , i've moved on. And i dont really care anymore.
I feel like you're screaming into the void. He's a twitch streamer who used to write. And he's counting his money for each new special edition that is released, and is obviously doing well enough that for whatever reasons he's not writing, he really doesn't have any incentive to write.
Name of the wind was a book i almost dnf. Then, about halfway way through, it just clicked. He writes beautifully. I dont really get this guy and martin. They obviously have talent. If i was them id just release it already. I highly suspect especially in the case of martin, that the book is done. They just got too popular and feel too much pressure. So they go over it again and again and again trying to make sometbing unperfectable ..perfect. Just wrap it up release the damn thing and what will be will be.
You know why? 'Cause the theory that Rothfuss has found someone's unfinished script on some garage sale, or some attic and published it as his own work, hoping he could finish that work of fiction. But he can't. 'Cause it ain't his.
I'll play devil's advocate here.
Some people are extremely sensitive to the opinion of others and writers are often rather sensitive people on the whole. Imagine him writing a few successful books, enjoying the public's admiration, but then this happens.
He wants to make his fans happy, he wants to not "just" release a chapter but make it a special thing but it falls to pieces, fans turn angry & against him at the same time as real life throws some spanners in the works (been there myself, a lot of people seem to never have had real problems in their life since they don't realize how it can mess you up) and suddenly you lose all motivation, all drive.
For a writer that's a death sentence. Writing is not an office job, it's not a "let's crank out 8 hours a day" job. It's not "I'll sit down and type for 8 hours". No, good writing requires creativity, a sharpness of mind, focus, passion, a drive to keep going. Loads of writers get stuck - look at George R R Martin as the most obvious example (and I bet there's similar reasons there too).
I can well see how a fan base that suddenly turned sour, feeling like the Internet is against you and no-one having any sympathy for what you're going through in your private life can kill all of that. And for what? A single chapter. Not a final product, nothing tangible. A TEASER. And instead of the "fans" going "Oh it's fine, just work on the book itself" they turn against him and increase the chance of there never been a third book at ALL now!
As someone who has gone through several years of some very nasty stuff which led to a major burn out, I find it insulting how the Internet treats people. "We paid for something so you owe us now regardless" is such a cold hearted thing to say. Yes, it's true but if you're really a fan and really love something, you do NOT behave in such a toxic way, ESPECIALLY since it was a charity drive.
The internet can be wonderful and utterly horrible in matter of nanoseconds. This is the exact reason why i dont have any social accounts besides a youtube. For Pat to not just copy/paste text from a screenshot that was leaked years ago with multiple chapters is mind-boggling. Then just say, this isnt a final draft and is subject to changes.
Yes, I understand he wanted to make super awesome with special readers and what not, but quite literally, all his fans wanted was a few pages.
Everyone needs to be a bit nicer, but it doesn't help when you first off don't really make a sincere apology about a massive Goof up.
If the third instalment ever comes out, I will not bother with it. I enjoyed the first 2 books when they first came out but after thirteen years of crickets, the interest is nonexistent on my part. Why reread door-stoppers to reacquaint with the story and reward a disingenuous individual by giving him gas? No thanks.
I’m late to the party, but I have waited for this third book. Here’s an idea screw him copyright everything and let’s creative community to make the book.
I see a lot of comments saying people are straight up done with him for the simple reason that he hasn’t finished the series yet (unrelated to this charity issue)…and I wonder if Stephen King would have gotten this same amount of hate if there’d been social media in all the years between his Dark tower novels.
At this point I don't much care whether he finishes it or not. The material he's produced so far wasn't bad but my own experience reading it was a slowly growing belief that this just wasn't going anywhere. The story just seemed to wander and I lost interest in it. Same thing happened to GRRM and his never concluding story.
I bet he doest have a single chapter of door of stones writen down
I guarantee that Patrick promised the chapter without considering the legal implications with his publisher etc and that’s here the third book is…
Patrick Rothfuss is not an Author, he's a twitch streamer that once wrote a couple of books.
It's almost like Patrick can't move ahead with the final book at all. Something in his head just can't let him do it. Maybe it's just such a big part of his life that he can't bare to be done with it. He doesn't know what his life will be without it. What will be his purpose? The man clearly needs to work on himself first.
Welp, it's sure taking Rothfuss a long ass time to work on himself and he's clearly aware he has problems.
@amandapelland It is what it is, I guess. His antics definitely won't help him. I'd really like to read the last book, but fortunately, there are plenty of other good series to read.
You did a good job with the video. Reading is supposed to build compassion and empathy, an understanding that people can make mistakes, can do bad things, and still be good people. It seems that far too many of Rothfuss' "fans?" will acknowledge and appreciate moral complexity in fiction but not in real life. This is sad.
The real issue with Pat is that it's not that he hasn't written anything it's that he is still benefiting from the idea that he's an active writer. Which demonstrably isn't true so I don't know if he was just honest I don't think he'd get as much hate
At this point he has basically scammed people out of more than $1 million dollars. That million came from fans. Fans who are now realizing that he’s basically walked away with their money without delivering the product they gave the money for. He’s a con man, like so many who have promised and not delivered once the money was in their hands. People have been rooking other people out of their money for hundreds of years. Rothfuss is no different than any other crook at this point. He can’t write ONE chapter, but he can expand a short story and sell it for $26 a pop. He, like other con artists, took advantage of people’s desperation and walked off with a large amount of money going to a charity that he owns, I believe, which means it went into his pocket. Whether he used it for charity or not, I can’t say. But he certainly didn’t write a chapter with it. He’s banking on the continued sympathy and support of good and kind people like yourself, so that he can keep making excuses. He wouldn’t be the first person to take advantage of the kindness and generosity of good people.
Well, that second sentence is clearly an erroneous notion. I’ve been an avid reader for most of my life and people constantly tell me that I lack empathy. LOL
It is tough to reconcile his charity work with his misdeeds. Something does not add up and I feel I cannot reach a real conclusion on the man himself.
Kvothe is a Mary Sue so judge Rothfuss by Kvothe.
Rothfuss is a perfectionist, and is caught in a doom loop. He not the type of person to release what he see as unready. For bad or ill that just how he is. Success only put more pressure on him.
It’s been another 6 months since the video. 3 years since it should be released
I don’t care for the chapter, I just want the book. It’s been far too long. I think he made a mistake by saying at the start he’d made a trilogy and then didn’t deliver on all three books.
I loved the first two books, and recently reread them. But I hate Rothfuss with a passion. Even if Doors of Stones did get released, I fear the book would just be a rushed, poorly written book. Causing me to rather have made the ending up in my mind. Than ruining the story for myself