When By the Fireplace was recommended to me by the Sephora associate, I was completely baffled when I smelled it wondering who would want to smell like a smoky fireplace!?! But after I went home that day I couldn't stop thinking about the scent. I decided to purchase it during the the Sephora VIB sale and now it's one of my favorite scents!
Jazz Club is polarizing. The people who love it (myself included) really love it. It's so unique and fun, but I can totally see why some people aren't fans.
Just pick up Beach walk, Jazz club, lazy Sunday morning, sailing day, and by the fireplace. They smell pretty good. 3 out of 5 I really like. I only got to where jazz club witch is 🔥 & lasted all day. Great protection!
Your number 1 is great Sebastian, but Whispers in the Library is awesome also. If you test it in store you won't get much out of it and just move to another fragrance, but after about an hour it is a stand-out and hangs in well. If you try hard enough you will get the old paper and stuffy old library vibe. No need to try hard with By The Fireplace though. It's a compliment getter. :)
I love love Whisper in the Library. I also have Jazz Club but does not reach out to it as much as WITL. Just bought Tea Escape too so I can't wait for it to arrive.
i have 5 i absolutely adore !!!!!! By the fireplace, lipstick on, coffee break, bubble bath and springtime in a park.. looking forward beachwalk, sunday lazy morning and sailyngday
I will never be without By The Fireplace. Perfect autumn/winter scent. They’ve now released the matching candles. I can’t wait to pick up the candle version.
By the fireplace smells exactly the same as stronger with you Intensely but just with a smoky vibe! In my opinion! But I do prefer stronger with you Intensely
I got an ad for a 20% discount on fb for these fragrances but my favorite Maison Margiela's so far (coffee break) is not available. I'm considering getting the travel sizes of Whispers in the Library and By The Fireplace because I've been wanting to try them for a while. I just wanted to hear your opinion on them. Thanks for the video!
American Chestnuts trees are severely endangered and some say extinct. I think it was a big tradition, but the disease came through many years back anyways, enjoy you content so much.
It’s said online that Lipstick On is discontinued unfortunately. For me, it has a really nice dry down! Plus, we still eat chestnuts at home, Portuguese’s custom.
I own three of these ( Jazz club coffee break and by the fireplace) and I’ve worn them for years.. I don’t know if I could ever tire of them. Coffee break and jazz club I specifically wear in the fall and by the fireplace is my winter scent. I get tons of compliments on all of them. I use them during the day or in the evening just a great signature scents
Replica line is the vibes I need for winter I have two of the fragrances, by the fireplace and wicked love both smells amazing and projects for over 9hours and more I spray all over my body after shower and it’s cold in Europe so it will sit on my skin and hung me when I go out in the cold 🥶
I know my comment is super late, but coffee break is meant to smell like an actual coffee break (in Stockholm) I read. The smell of the city & your latte pretty much.
I'm such a huge fan of Maison Margiela, not just their fragrances but also their ready to wear clothes. Anyway, I currently have Jazz Club, By the Fireplace, Lazy Sunday Morning, At the Barber's, and Music Festival. Planning to buy Whispers in the Library and really curious about Bubble Bath. I live in Indonesia and the Maison Margiela's Replica fragrances are not easily available here. Anyway, my top 3 would be Jazz Club (smoky, boozy), By the Fireplace (the easiest choice, awesome longevity), and Whispers in the Library (creamy, woody). I just wished they didn't discontinued Tea Escape, a great release.
By the fireplace is my favorite fragrance of all time, it is absolutely wonderful and unique. Jazz club smells nauseating to me personally, and the others mentioned are just okay. Not memorable. But by the fireplace is the perfect combination of unorthodox and familiar in a scent
By the Fireplace is in my top 10 fragrances of all time. The smoke is delicious! I like to layer it with Santal 33 for more staying power. I bought a travel size Coffee Break hoping it would be more coffee bean or brewed coffee but all I really get is the lavender as well. Such a bummer. Currently on my hunt for the best coffee gourmand!
I absolutely love your numbers 1 and 2!! I still remember my first sniff of By the fireplace and it's such a realistic fireplace smell! Roasted chestnuts is a treat indeed!!! 🌰😋
Not to get off subject, but the reason Americans no longer eat chestnuts is that the American Chestnut Tree was nearly completely wiped out from a blight during the early 20th century and has yet to be replanted in any significant number. They were once abundant. That said, I really like By The Fireplace.
I have 3 of the of the fragrances mentioned. I am a big fan of Jazz Club, it's my second fav. BTFP is my fav, with Whispers in the Library in 3rd place.
I personally can't get enough of Jazz club. I own By the Fireplace as well but Jazz club just smells better to me. Do you guys have any suggestions on tobacco and boozy scents for me?
You are killing it with your fragrances videos lately. I love it! I must be the only person on the planet that dislikes By The Fireplace. 😏 It just gives me this bad hair spray smell that I just can’t stomach. I do somewhat enjoy Jazz Club and Lipstick On but they seem to have that underlying note that I can’t put my finger on that I’m just not keen on.
I adore by the Fireplace. I just love that it smells so different from anything that is current. It does have such a gorgeous smoky, sexy chestnut cozy scent. My number one scent for the winter.
By the fireplace and Lune Feline by Atelier des Ors smell a lot alike, I think that Lune Feline is a little bit sweeter. They are both really similar, the same nose behind them, Marie Salamagne.
Whispers in the Library is by far my favorite of the Replica series. But my very favorite MMM fragrance is Soul of the Forest. I can wear that all year.
I really like Jazz Club, but the performance is terrible (on my skin) 1 hour max. But I have started to use it as a layering fragrance best combo to date has been layering with Zaharoff Signature Pour Homme. By The Fireplace is a solid release great performer also
It’s super super long lasting for me. It is possible that you’ve become nose-blind to it - because that’s how Baccarat Rouge 450 is for me , even though I know it’s a beast mode fragrance.
Just picked up jazz club and at the barbershop last week. Jazz club is the best period IMO. By the fireplace is good but too limited on when you can wear it
Whispers in the Library and Across Sands are my favorites from this house. I loved By the Fireplace when I first smelled it, but I find it less unique now after trying more sweet-smoky scents. By the Fireplace reminds me of Commodity’s Velvet except with less of a sweet-sour dimension to it than Velvet has. I prefer By the Fireplace over it.
We had a chestnut tree in the yard when I was a kid and the outer husks are like baby porcupines and will murder your feet and even stick into your shoe soles. Never seen one growing anywhere around here since and that was like almost 30 years ago. BTF is nice. The smoky smell is almost too much but I like it more than JV dark rebels smoky smell.
Am I the only one that thinks By the fireplace is similar to MFK Baccarat Rouge 540? Nothing in the notes suggests they smell alike, but that's what I get.
I LOVE this line and have been acquiring quite a few! Great review! 💞 ...to answer your question I have 4 from this line and By the Fireplace was the 1st purchase ... this is so unique and very time provoking...
hello guys! if you love the margiela vibe you should appreiate "sotoor waaw" by rasasi (this is a cheap one) it reminds me a little bit of whispers in the library , a little bit of by the fireplace (the nutty thing) it's a beautiful one , wearable, slightly spicy and warm ! i need a bottle of jazzclub , and i never smelled coffee break but i m sure i could love it by your description! another great review thank you sebastian!
Smelled Jazz Club at Sephora and it seemed redundant to something I already have...Aramis Special Blend...which you don’t like. Do you get the similarity?
Can you do a top 10 or 20 Xerjoff plz? I am gonna buy 1 before new year, but all of them seem to be fantastic. I am leaning towards Alexandria II and/or Luxor.
@@ThePerfumeGuy she offers a very nice deal from her house, you buy a very inexpensive two reasonably priced set of samples (vanilla set, musc, orange blossom are the choices) and you get a set for free, then you can use the code to get a discount on a future buy. I've done that and it is a great deal.
I was very surprised at how quickly WITL rocketed up to become by favourite from MM. It's a great one to layer with as well. Add a bit of cinnamon here, a touch of booze there and voila, you're suddenly shouting in the library and get kicked out. 🤣
LOVE this house!! I’ve had at least 5 at one point in my closet. Would always use them up though since I’d have to spritz them repeatedly throughout the day. Not one of the long lasting fragrances unfortunately
I only smelled by the fireplace which is very nice to my opinion. I also smelled jazz club, bad Projection to my opinion there a a lot of boozy tobacco fragrances which are better
Margiela the person has long retired from the brand. He is very reclusive but once was the Hermes creative director. John Galliano is the maison's current creative director. Just a little factoid 😁
🍯🍯🍯 Watch Top 10 Maison Margiela Fragrances Video here: ruclips.net/video/tI1PJMHGHpo/видео.html 🍯🍯🍯
When By the Fireplace was recommended to me by the Sephora associate, I was completely baffled when I smelled it wondering who would want to smell like a smoky fireplace!?! But after I went home that day I couldn't stop thinking about the scent. I decided to purchase it during the the Sephora VIB sale and now it's one of my favorite scents!
Jazz Club is polarizing. The people who love it (myself included) really love it. It's so unique and fun, but I can totally see why some people aren't fans.
I absolutely love By the fireplace!! 🥰 The perfect autumn fragrance and I wear it all the time! 😊
By the Fireplace is fantastic. I was wearing samples and my hairstylist said, “WHAT are you wearing?!” I bought a full sized bottle the next day.
Coffee break on my list, this fall season.
Just pick up Beach walk, Jazz club, lazy Sunday morning, sailing day, and by the fireplace. They smell pretty good. 3 out of 5 I really like. I only got to where jazz club witch is 🔥 & lasted all day. Great protection!
Your number 1 is great Sebastian, but Whispers in the Library is awesome also. If you test it in store you won't get much out of it and just move to another fragrance, but after about an hour it is a stand-out and hangs in well. If you try hard enough you will get the old paper and stuffy old library vibe. No need to try hard with By The Fireplace though. It's a compliment getter. :)
I love love Whisper in the Library. I also have Jazz Club but does not reach out to it as much as WITL. Just bought Tea Escape too so I can't wait for it to arrive.
I enjoy By The Fireplace, Whispers In The Library a lot...
This is a house I always wanted to get into but never did for some reason. Thanks for the recommendations!
i have 5 i absolutely adore !!!!!! By the fireplace, lipstick on, coffee break, bubble bath and springtime in a park.. looking forward beachwalk, sunday lazy morning and sailyngday
My daughter likes Bubble Bath and Whispers in the Library and I like Springtime in the Park and By the Fireplace.
The top three are my absolute favorite. Lipstick On, would be my favorite then By the Fire and Whispers in the Library are tie.
Replica had a perfume called Soul of the Forest that smelled delicious, sadly that one is not longer for sale in the USA.
They need to bring it back! I bought three back up bottles....
I will never be without By The Fireplace. Perfect autumn/winter scent. They’ve now released the matching candles. I can’t wait to pick up the candle version.
Man I love Maison Margiela fragrances, especially By the Fireplace and Soul of the Forest 😍
My favourites as well.
By the fireplace smells exactly the same as stronger with you Intensely but just with a smoky vibe! In my opinion!
But I do prefer stronger with you Intensely
I'm a huge fan of this house. I layer Jazz Club with By the Fireplace and the smell is amazing.
Great list! My favorite is Whispers in the Library.
I absolutely love Coffee Break, but sadly it lasts on me less than 2 hrs.
Same experience, Teresa. Great fragrance, poor longevity...or maybe its just that the heart note is unremarkable?
i mixed it coffee aud by Mancera and smells amazing plus lasts all day long
Same here
Lasts 24 on me
Just scooped up a bottle of by the fireplace, can't wait to wear it fully thus upcoming winter
I got an ad for a 20% discount on fb for these fragrances but my favorite Maison Margiela's so far (coffee break) is not available. I'm considering getting the travel sizes of Whispers in the Library and By The Fireplace because I've been wanting to try them for a while. I just wanted to hear your opinion on them. Thanks for the video!
By the fireplace is my favourite from this house
Received Coffee Break as a sample, was surprised how much I loved it....will be buying a full bottle!
Great!!
Seb you’re about to hit 100K I’ve been watching you since your original channel. I’m happy you got to this milestone. congrats my Armenian brother.
American Chestnuts trees are severely endangered and some say extinct. I think it was a big tradition, but the disease came through many years back anyways, enjoy you content so much.
I wasn't aware they were endangered. Bummer! They are so yummy! :)
It’s said online that Lipstick On is discontinued unfortunately. For me, it has a really nice dry down!
Plus, we still eat chestnuts at home, Portuguese’s custom.
I own three of these ( Jazz club coffee break and by the fireplace) and I’ve worn them for years.. I don’t know if I could ever tire of them. Coffee break and jazz club I specifically wear in the fall and by the fireplace is my winter scent. I get tons of compliments on all of them. I use them during the day or in the evening just a great signature scents
Replica line is the vibes I need for winter I have two of the fragrances, by the fireplace and wicked love both smells amazing and projects for over 9hours and more I spray all over my body after shower and it’s cold in Europe so it will sit on my skin and hung me when I go out in the cold 🥶
I appreciate knowing more than before about this company. I've heard of the last one that you mentioned but I didn't know anything about them.
I know my comment is super late, but coffee break is meant to smell like an actual coffee break (in Stockholm) I read. The smell of the city & your latte pretty much.
I have jazz club and whispers on the library on my coleccion both amazing and unique
Au contraire!....We Italians have chestnuts in the fall and around Christmas time every year!...lol.....Thank you for another great review!
I'm such a huge fan of Maison Margiela, not just their fragrances but also their ready to wear clothes. Anyway, I currently have Jazz Club, By the Fireplace, Lazy Sunday Morning, At the Barber's, and Music Festival. Planning to buy Whispers in the Library and really curious about Bubble Bath. I live in Indonesia and the Maison Margiela's Replica fragrances are not easily available here. Anyway, my top 3 would be Jazz Club (smoky, boozy), By the Fireplace (the easiest choice, awesome longevity), and Whispers in the Library (creamy, woody). I just wished they didn't discontinued Tea Escape, a great release.
Yes HUGE fan of Maison Margiela!
By the fireplace is my favorite fragrance of all time, it is absolutely wonderful and unique.
Jazz club smells nauseating to me personally, and the others mentioned are just okay. Not memorable. But by the fireplace is the perfect combination of unorthodox and familiar in a scent
By the Fireplace is in my top 10 fragrances of all time. The smoke is delicious! I like to layer it with Santal 33 for more staying power. I bought a travel size Coffee Break hoping it would be more coffee bean or brewed coffee but all I really get is the lavender as well. Such a bummer. Currently on my hunt for the best coffee gourmand!
Curious to know your top 10 😁
I absolutely love your numbers 1 and 2!!
I still remember my first sniff of By the fireplace and it's such a realistic fireplace smell!
Roasted chestnuts is a treat indeed!!! 🌰😋
Not to get off subject, but the reason Americans no longer eat chestnuts is that the American Chestnut Tree was nearly completely wiped out from a blight during the early 20th century and has yet to be replanted in any significant number. They were once abundant. That said, I really like By The Fireplace.
Thank you for an insightful review sir. My favorite is, At the barbershop, to me it has that clean powdery scent right after a haircut.
I have 3 of the of the fragrances mentioned. I am a big fan of Jazz Club, it's my second fav. BTFP is my fav, with Whispers in the Library in 3rd place.
Love the jazz club and by the fireplace.. would have loved to try lipstick on but no longer available
I personally can't get enough of Jazz club.
I own By the Fireplace as well but Jazz club just smells better to me.
Do you guys have any suggestions on tobacco and boozy scents for me?
You are killing it with your fragrances videos lately. I love it! I must be the only person on the planet that dislikes By The Fireplace. 😏 It just gives me this bad hair spray smell that I just can’t stomach. I do somewhat enjoy Jazz Club and Lipstick On but they seem to have that underlying note that I can’t put my finger on that I’m just not keen on.
Great 📹 and I enjoyed it and I like by the fireplace and I give it a 9 out of 10 and I'm going to try the other fragrances and have a blessed day
I adore by the Fireplace. I just love that it smells so different from anything that is current. It does have such a gorgeous smoky, sexy chestnut cozy scent. My number one scent for the winter.
I love By the Fireplace ❤️
Coffee Break is my favorite
Mine too.. absolutley amazing!
Same
By the fireplace and Lune Feline by Atelier des Ors smell a lot alike, I think that Lune Feline is a little bit sweeter. They are both really similar, the same nose behind them, Marie Salamagne.
I love them both, off course By the fireplace is more affordable but I truly love them both.
I'm absolutely fan of jazz club and I bought BY THE FIREPLACE listening your advise! Tnx!!!!!
Whispers in the Library is by far my favorite of the Replica series. But my very favorite MMM fragrance is Soul of the Forest. I can wear that all year.
I really like Jazz Club, but the performance is terrible (on my skin) 1 hour max. But I have started to use it as a layering fragrance best combo to date has been layering with Zaharoff Signature Pour Homme. By The Fireplace is a solid release great performer also
It’s super super long lasting for me. It is possible that you’ve become nose-blind to it - because that’s how Baccarat Rouge 450 is for me , even though I know it’s a beast mode fragrance.
By the fire place❤ and it lasts for a decent amount of time
By the fireplace is my favourite from this house 🔥🔥
Just picked up jazz club and at the barbershop last week. Jazz club is the best period IMO. By the fireplace is good but too limited on when you can wear it
Not a winter scent, but At the Barber's is a great fougere fragrance.
I bought that for my husband years ago. Love it.
I have Jazz Club, By The FirePlace and Coffee Break
By the fireplace is very good...need to try lipstick on and jazz club
Hey Sebastian! I enjoy a few on your list.....also Across Sands.
Whispers in the Library and Across Sands are my favorites from this house. I loved By the Fireplace when I first smelled it, but I find it less unique now after trying more sweet-smoky scents. By the Fireplace reminds me of Commodity’s Velvet except with less of a sweet-sour dimension to it than Velvet has. I prefer By the Fireplace over it.
I have 6 of them, bougut Jazz lately because of youtube, and I agree with you about it.
We had a chestnut tree in the yard when I was a kid and the outer husks are like baby porcupines and will murder your feet and even stick into your shoe soles. Never seen one growing anywhere around here since and that was like almost 30 years ago. BTF is nice. The smoky smell is almost too much but I like it more than JV dark rebels smoky smell.
Huge Jazz Club fan. :) Love it.
Am I the only one that thinks By the fireplace is similar to MFK Baccarat Rouge 540? Nothing in the notes suggests they smell alike, but that's what I get.
Must be that! I wondered why I didn’t like them two so strongly 😂😂 thanks for pointing this out! 👏
I LOVE this line and have been acquiring quite a few! Great review! 💞 ...to answer your question I have 4 from this line and By the Fireplace was the 1st purchase ... this is so unique and very time provoking...
Would have loved to see Wicked Love in here. Absolutely love the unexpected pimento spicy aspect!
I’m a fan...Tea Escape is next on my “to buy” list.
I love their packaging, as well!
I love Lipstick On and by the fireplace also Commodity’s Velvet is very similar not an exact dupe but very enjoyable as well
Great review once again lipstick on is amazing my favorite the only one I own from the house. Pleasure watching 👍
I smelled many of them but nothing actually caught my attention except for By the fireplace. I’ve been eyeing lipstick on but not sure
Finally you will reach 100K !!! YOU definitely deserve it !
🎉
hello guys! if you love the margiela vibe you should appreiate "sotoor waaw" by rasasi (this is a cheap one) it reminds me a little bit of whispers in the library , a little bit of by the fireplace (the nutty thing) it's a beautiful one , wearable, slightly spicy and warm ! i need a bottle of jazzclub , and i never smelled coffee break but i m sure i could love it by your description! another great review thank you sebastian!
Smelled Jazz Club at Sephora and it seemed redundant to something I already have...Aramis Special Blend...which you don’t like. Do you get the similarity?
Can you do a top 10 or 20 Xerjoff plz? I am gonna buy 1 before new year, but all of them seem to be fantastic. I am leaning towards Alexandria II and/or Luxor.
Just have by the Fireplace and Jazz Club. At the complete drydown from by the fireplace I got some vibes of Oud Bouquet by Lancôme. Like that.
I mix jazz club and by the fireplace
Im a fan of Music Festival,By the Fireplace and Jazz club👍 but i want to explore the other ones too👌
Love this video! I can’t find Tea Escape anywhere. I’ve been desperately searching for it for three months😫
Hi I just saw it come up when I did a search online it brought up Sephora but I didn't actually click. Perhaps it's back?
Ohhh I’m excited. Just bought some samples of the Tea escape and By the fire.
Thank you Sebastian, I’m keeping my eyes peeled for it👍🏽
I have 7. Love lipstick on the best, then carnival nights
I enjoy a lot of the replica EDT line although always hope for a little bit more from the EDPs
I have whispers in the library and my boyfriend says it smells like clean diapers 😤.... also I used to have jazz club. I Love them both! 😍
I search ur video about maison martin margiela fragrances thanks for this great video reviews
I'm wondering if you will be doing or have done (couldn't find in a search on your channel) Sylvaine Delacourte fragrances?
Hopefully in the future yes for sure! :)
@@ThePerfumeGuy she offers a very nice deal from her house, you buy a very inexpensive two reasonably priced set of samples (vanilla set, musc, orange blossom are the choices) and you get a set for free, then you can use the code to get a discount on a future buy. I've done that and it is a great deal.
I was very surprised at how quickly WITL rocketed up to become by favourite from MM. It's a great one to layer with as well. Add a bit of cinnamon here, a touch of booze there and voila, you're suddenly shouting in the library and get kicked out. 🤣
Dude I see you commenting everywhere. A hidden hero 😂
@@joelfromqueens 💓
LOVE this house!! I’ve had at least 5 at one point in my closet. Would always use them up though since I’d have to spritz them repeatedly throughout the day. Not one of the long lasting fragrances unfortunately
I'm a fan! interesting house
Heads over to find "The Christmas Song". I love Nat "King" Cole!!
Jazz club I pick up coconut smell. I think I would have liked it better if I didn't smell coconut note.
Coffee Break to me smells very similar to Rochas Man. Anyone else?
Really? I'm gonna try it for sure!
Just become a fan after stumbling across this house at Sephora.
I only smelled by the fireplace which is very nice to my opinion. I also smelled jazz club, bad Projection to my opinion there a a lot of boozy tobacco fragrances which are better
What About Longevity By the Fire Place
Margiela the person has long retired from the brand. He is very reclusive but once was the Hermes creative director. John Galliano is the maison's current creative director.
Just a little factoid 😁
Not knowing why this house keep discontinuing there best fragrances.
Their
@@professionalpookie they’re
@@danieldelgado1237 no it’s their! Not they’re ( they are )
@@siddchops15 oops I meant Theis they is
Sales. They usually don’t make decisions based on nerdy frag community opinions
I''m having a really hard time finding tea escape.
it was discontinued, so you can only get it in decants now
Is there a fake jazzclub ? I bought it and it’s sooo weak
Hello Sebastian make video le labo tabac 28 Review plz
I don’t have it!! 🥲🥲🥲
Oho
My Wish u make video about Le Labo Tabac 28 when u have it
Thanks For Reply Sebastian
I’m a big fan
Soo are they unisex?
Most are! :)