*-How can the old Hyakkimaru speak?* Both Hyakkimaru have extrasensory perception, what means they perceive information without using the physical senses, it's just that in both it works differently (with some exceptions, like the fact both can "see" without eyes). The original Hyakkimaru doesn't speak, you could say that he talks telepathically and to pretend he's actually speaking he just moves his lips. As far as I remember, this is explained in a different way in the manga xD but that's pretty much it Anyway, I've seen a few comments saying that the new Hyakkimaru doesn't have emotions. Sadness and anger are emotions too, besides he doesn't need to smile to feel happiness, he's just an inexpresive guy for now
Well, when you're born without your 5 senses, you won't have any emotions either. He only really had one goal in life, and that was to kill these demons.
@@oneplumpboi5317 In episode 3, it shows that Hyakkimaru loves his father. Also, in episode 2 you can notice that he's sad in the campfire scene, then he's surprised when Dororo take him by the hand, and in the scene when the villagers lock up both, it seems that Dororo is annoying to him. He has emotions since before, it's just that he doesn't expresses them very often
Really like the 2019 remake that they made Hyakkimaru never talk and flat out hating the sound of his voice because it's too loud, making his screaming bloodbath hit the feels so much harder.
ForemostCrab7 I love the fact that he doesn’t start speaking as soon as he regains his voice and hearing, as I thought it would be at first. It will take some time until he learns how to properly use his senses, which is unexpectedly realistic, and just an overall sign of good writing. This anime is gold.
@@MillyKKitty Well actually it's not, had it been a completely different country where they spoke a different language, it would've been. A child will "automatically" speak their parent's language "by default" if you have a child with parents who speaks 2 differnt language the child will react to both languages, they might focus on learning the "easier" one but as a child, they simply know. So in that, Hyakkimaru immediatly understands them because it is still the same language that his parents use. And like the old dude with the lute says when Hyakkimaru was standing in the rain before he regained his hearing "he is listening to the rain" Or if non of those answers does it for you, you can just stick with the simple answer "for plot conveniance" it's a Very simplified answered but the more sought after for simplistics sake.
@@ForemostCrab7 Hyakkimaru was in a state of complete sensory deprivation for most of his life, he is not going to be able to pick up on his parent's language.
psst in the new version, Hyakkimaru probably saw Mio's soul fading away as she died. Because if you look closely, Take's soul is already gone in Hyakki's vision, because he's already dead. MAPPA did such a good focking job with this readaptation.
Wow! I actually re-watch the scene and just realize that you may be right. Cause when Hyakimaru look at Mio at Dororo, Take's soul is not visible. It was just darkness from where he lies unlike Mio, it somehow looks like dissipitating/fading.
Both sad and strong, only i found the new one Slightly better than the old for only a reason: hyakkimaru. While in the old version he have human interaction and try still to kept control while crying( and his face is more sad than angry), in the new one, he find out that mio died only after hearing her last song, that make him into a storm of pain and rage and you can really feel the pain in his face and his voice while turning into a berseker against those soldiers.
@@filipbabovic8474 why unrealistic, he is a 16 teen but have mind age of a children who is discovering the world, and before mio's death, he had never lost something important for him (when he lost his body he was too young to felt sofference), and the sufference for the lost made him turn into a storm of rage against the ones who killed her, thats a pretty realistic scene for someone in his mental/phisical status.
@@chrisreaves6399 well, the old one is justified because the animations were pretty impressive for the 1969, so would be kinda unfair compare the animations quality after 50 years.
The newer series has more impact, as we spend more time with Mio, his reaction is more animalistic and distraught, and Dororo has to share the experience as well, but I really like how, while slashing the samurai in the older series, the image of Mio is slashed too, it's a good visual metaphor.
It has more impact in the manga. Mio was mute originally and Hyakki came to relate to her even further when he fell in love with her but never being able to listen to her voice.
@@7Blink2 bro a fun fact I was reading the comment upper than your.a bug is going circles in my head,when I was focusing reading the comment and scroll my screen down your profile make me shock I thought the bug was sitting in my screen (no offense) Sorry for bad English
first time he hears was someone crying, first time he screams was the loss of his leg, first time he speaks was the loss of his loved one. We should change the anime's title to Pain and Suffering. Holy, thanks for the 1k likes
Both of them are good, but I see that the new one has showed Hyakkimarus emotions more.. It's like the legend being reborn as a masterpiece. This anime is so good at expressing the emotions back then and now.. Such a good quality and story, a real masterpiece
People here saying "Somehow the new one is slightly better" Somehow? Of course it's fucking better, there's literally a 50 year difference between them.
not just animation the atmosphere the cheesiness of him "speaking" with normal emotions like he is some normal dude and maybe a bit slower "did you guys killed them? eh?"
Can we just appreciate how far ahead of time 1969's version was? Just the mere concept of losing body parts is amazing let alone the plot. Truly worthy of a better readaptation
Even stronger in the manga when Mio was originally mute and Hyakki had a deeper connection with her relating to her disability but still living life to the fullest back in a time when Hyakkimaru thought of himself as weak because of his own disabilities.
@@Anonymous_Gambito she never spoke a word, he never heard her voice. No matter how much she smiled, no matter how happy they were, she never spoke a single word. He never hears her voice. That temple was filled with broken people, she was broken as well, robbed of her voice.
@@Anonymous_Gambito When Hyakkimaru states that he had never heard Mio's voice, it was because she actually didn't talk. Even though Hyakkimaru had no hearing, he could sense the people talking to him via extra-sensory powers. Mio could only communicate with him by saying things with her heart, since he could catch them telepathically.
@@firepitch5113 by your logic, The eva rebuild films are better then 90s tv show because more superior animation animation isn't everything, i would like you to provide more
The way the two versions tell the story and display emotions reflect the times they were made in. They’re equally impactful and emotional, but in different ways. The newer version of this scene is more compelling to me (they’ve done an amazing job remaking this, seriously), but I love how the old one makes my heart feel like it’s sinking, it has such a eerie and quiet despair to it, even if Hyakkimaru isn’t showing his emotion vocally, the imagery says it all.
I don't get how some people in the comments are comparing the two shows without talking into account the 50 year gap between the two animations. Like it came out before the first episode of Dragon Ball Z came out, so give it some slack
I like how the remake shows the emotion and let's it play out rather than telling it like the original, and how Hyakkimaru can never cry in this scene in the remake.
So on top of being fucked up, I forgot about the orphans having missing limbs. Honestly, every single one of these men deserved it! EVEN if they thought Mio was a spy, they were clearly out for blood-these kids were orphans, disabled, and found hope in Mio as sister figure-only to die because, well, the world is cruel. I'm still pissed, and sad, very very sad!=(
I think that the 2019 version is more in line with the personality that hyakkimaru should have, since he was basically a wooden doll since he was a child, the 1969 version seems more human his reactions
Both versions actually rock! Like wow. They're still powerful depending on their time. The new one is more graphic, and the older one seems more dramatic. Love both of them. The new adaptation of Dororo is very, and I'm happy to see that it's keeping the spirit of the old.
The 2019 version seems a lot better. Apart from the obvious expected improvement in animation, Hyiakimmaru's character fits him better. He reacts more like someone who's felt true loss for the first time and acted on instinct rather than some cliche shinobi warrior.
Oh God, the 2019 version always makes me cry. It's done so well. Hyakimaru isn't even used to expressing himself at all yet. But the subtlety in the realization of what happened turning in a bout of acute insanity from the pain and anguish he feels. It's so sad
He identifies as a "he", to which I'm mean he actively says "I'm a man, there's nothing wrong with me" in the manga and gets mad when people call him a "she"
@@mariama.f8314 Its very fucking ironic.. no ignorant of you to mention Tezuka because he literally grow up with disney animation and inspired from it. You weebs disgust me
J0šęph Weeb means someone who loves another’s culture, typically Japanese, over their own and places it on a pedestal. Liking and appreciating anime or any aspect of another culture doesn’t make your a weeb. Bashing your own culture for another and blindly praising it without measuring pros and cons makes you a weeb.
I think the newer one is better to be because it does the job of “show, don’t tell”. We already know based on hyakki’s interactions with Mio and the others how much he adores them, and his screaming instead of just telling us what he’s doing feels a lot more impactful.
the 2019 is better. we can feel how desperate hyakkimaru on losing his first love. plus, dororo consoling hyakkimaru after that breaks our heart. "she didn't lose...". oh god. i shed a tear tbh.
The 2019 one is more deep and has more feeling to it cause he couldnt talk in it and His rage felt more real,also his first word was mio so it makes the scene even better
The 2019 added more storyline and did a great job of making us sympatize the main characters Mio included, while the 1969's version felt like despair and depicted grief instead of rage. The 1969 scene was a bit more scary than the 2019 scene (probably because of the music and it's dark themes) It was a tad more darker than 2019 tbh, but I think both years did a really good job.
I think the thing is that 1969 didn't have animation techniques and easy-of-use as today does. Technological and the overall evolution of anime as an art medium allowed Dororo to get the few bits of edge it was lacking in its original incarnations. I literally got into the franchise today with the remake, but I have mad respect for Tezuka's work, knowing how influential he is as a mangaka. Besides overall new insights in how the story is pulled off - such as making Hyakkimaru completely unaware to the world outside him save for a special vision. It allows for adding in tidbits of character development through metaphors conveyed by his physical improvement, which I find simply genius. Totally hyped to see what the show has in its sleeve for me.
I like the 2019 Dororo scene more. Reasoning? Because the fact that Hyakimaru *could no talk* . All he could do was let out his rage by screaming *because* he had never talked before. It put a lot more emotion into the scene than the 1969 Dororo did. Not to mention the sakuga that went down during the "fight" if you could even call it that since it was really Hyakimaru going sicko mode on those dudes.
Legit, Dororo reminded me how good anime can be as a form of storytelling. A lot of the recent stuff has been overpowered isekai harem anime with very little depth.
Dororo is a pioneer in the youkai genre and Japanese anime in general, and it just makes me really happy to see interest in this wonderful series revived in the wake of the incredibly well made 2019 version :3 the first adaptation is very much a swashbuckling samurai adventure with demons whereas the remake is a grim representation of humanity, emotions and the actual horrors of the Sengoku era. For those who don't know, Tezuka had to change a lot of things about Dororo in the 60s because people thought it was too dark for its intended audience (young-preteen boys), but the 2019 adaptation clearly was allowed a bit more freedom on that front, because anime isn't just made for kids anymore, and thus was able to bring back some of those darker scenes and show them on screen which just make it amazing and way more appealing to a modern audience. I'm actually writing an essay about this series currently for my Japanese Literature and Arts course and how it's changed over 50 years~
Right? This show influenced so much. This show gave birth to so much anime, like Demon Slayer, Yuyu Hakusho, Berserk, Fullmetal Alchemist, Bleach, Yugioh, Inuyasha... Even Kenshin from Rurouni Kenshin borrowed heavily from Hyakkimaru's design and swordplay.
I was looking for the original japanese VA of Hyakkimaru and i've found out that Nachi Nozawa did his voice, he also did the voice for Alexsander from the Hellsing TV anime version.
Explanation as to why Hyakki can talk in the old one, basically, Jukai taught him how to speak with his stomach. It’s like a weird combination of how it moves, and growls, I read the og manga years a go so I don’t remember the specifics, but the demons didn’t take his stomach so yeah. Plus, in the old one, Mio was from his backstory, we never actually got to meet her personally in the original version.
A mí me rompe el corazón ambas, realmente amo a Mio y fue súper sad cundo la asesinaron, lo que más me gustó es que en la de 2019 es que Mío le canta por última vez y hyakkimaru la abraza diciendo su nombre re sad :'c 😣😭
Wow Mappa brought me a lot of emotions with their choice of adaptation. That's amazing they managed to convey so much yet stay true to the original content. Mappa doing god's work ;w;
This scene is the perfect example of why I like the 2019 version better, it portrays hyakkimaru more animalistic than human because he was robbed of most experience that would make him human, his brain also works more like an animal as well “kill red get body back” as he doesn’t know more because he didn’t have the means to understand.
I like that even though Hyakkimaru doesn't say a word and simply roars with rage as if he'd become a beast made a much bigger impact on me than all the questioning and flashbacks he did in the 1969 version and when he finally did speak only to say Mio's name, it broke my heart. Really. :'(
Both great moments. For me while I think the emotion is a bit stronger in the original (between the change in style and some story changes to alter its impact) there is something truly beautiful in Hyakkimaru’s rage during the original. Particularly the music and the cuts, especially the part where Mio’s image is sliced up.
2:43 in the 2019 version you can see hyakkimaru's face reflected in the blade. I had to slow the video down to .25 playback speed and even then pause and unpause quickly in order to catch it. It's seriously a blink a you'll miss it detail but damn it's awesome
the song for the 1969 version is haunting.... i think if the 2019 version had given a few more episodes for mio and hyakkimaru to fall in love and draw out their relationship more, the death scene could've had that kind of music and dramatic imagery that the 1969 had. but i think the 2019 didn't have music because they wanted to highlight hyakkimaru's screams... ahhh so sad
Hyakkimaru’s reaction in the new adaptation is so much more realistic, and instead of just being overwhelmed with sadness, he sees mio slowly die and gets overwhelmed by rage
Good god they're not even remotely the same guy... I like the new hyaku better as a character, and as a concept. But they're so damn different. Like I see people comparing them and honestly you just can't.
In the new scene, when Hyakkimaru breaks- the way it's animated at 2:16 reminds me of that one scene from Howl's Moving Castle when (I think, i'm not super clear on the details) the head witch lady tries to turn Howl into a monster and he loses some control- he starts screaming like that too. Anyways, broke meh heart.
*-How can the old Hyakkimaru speak?*
Both Hyakkimaru have extrasensory perception, what means they perceive information without using the physical senses, it's just that in both it works differently (with some exceptions, like the fact both can "see" without eyes).
The original Hyakkimaru doesn't speak, you could say that he talks telepathically and to pretend he's actually speaking he just moves his lips. As far as I remember, this is explained in a different way in the manga xD but that's pretty much it
Anyway, I've seen a few comments saying that the new Hyakkimaru doesn't have emotions. Sadness and anger are emotions too, besides he doesn't need to smile to feel happiness, he's just an inexpresive guy for now
Jennihazama his father made him a voice
Well, when you're born without your 5 senses, you won't have any emotions either.
He only really had one goal in life, and that was to kill these demons.
@@oneplumpboi5317 In episode 3, it shows that Hyakkimaru loves his father. Also, in episode 2 you can notice that he's sad in the campfire scene, then he's surprised when Dororo take him by the hand, and in the scene when the villagers lock up both, it seems that Dororo is annoying to him. He has emotions since before, it's just that he doesn't expresses them very often
Let's face it, the original does talk, when you move your mouth and project your words to ears it practically the same as talking
@Ummer Farooq Fight me!
His first words being "Mio" ALONE makes the new one far superior
No replies. huh
@@yahia5476 impossible
I smell bots
@@johnvideos6613 Ikr
FOH
I watched the anime but i fort who mio is, could someone tell me?
Really like the 2019 remake that they made Hyakkimaru never talk and flat out hating the sound of his voice because it's too loud, making his screaming bloodbath hit the feels so much harder.
ForemostCrab7 I love the fact that he doesn’t start speaking as soon as he regains his voice and hearing, as I thought it would be at first. It will take some time until he learns how to properly use his senses, which is unexpectedly realistic, and just an overall sign of good writing. This anime is gold.
@@velvet_victor Tho the fact he can understand speech right away is still unrealistic
i like more the remake, not only for the animation.
@@MillyKKitty Well actually it's not, had it been a completely different country where they spoke a different language, it would've been. A child will "automatically" speak their parent's language "by default" if you have a child with parents who speaks 2 differnt language the child will react to both languages, they might focus on learning the "easier" one but as a child, they simply know.
So in that, Hyakkimaru immediatly understands them because it is still the same language that his parents use.
And like the old dude with the lute says when Hyakkimaru was standing in the rain before he regained his hearing "he is listening to the rain"
Or if non of those answers does it for you, you can just stick with the simple answer "for plot conveniance" it's a Very simplified answered but the more sought after for simplistics sake.
@@ForemostCrab7 Hyakkimaru was in a state of complete sensory deprivation for most of his life, he is not going to be able to pick up on his parent's language.
psst
in the new version, Hyakkimaru probably saw Mio's soul fading away as she died. Because if you look closely, Take's soul is already gone in Hyakki's vision, because he's already dead. MAPPA did such a good focking job with this readaptation.
Neat
Wow! I actually re-watch the scene and just realize that you may be right. Cause when Hyakimaru look at Mio at Dororo, Take's soul is not visible. It was just darkness from where he lies unlike Mio, it somehow looks like dissipitating/fading.
If you take into account that one scene where he plucks a flower, you can see it’s life fading away so this makes perfect sense
.... Where's my wallet...?
I think i popped a blood vessel in my head screaming to "kill them" at my pc.
1969: "I killed them to avenge the one I loved"
2019: "AAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH"
Lmao
@R3TR0 30 right that one showed more emotion. I actually cried and felt his pain
I like the " i killed them to avenge the one I loved"
Dont judge me, i started trying to find the first anime, so i could watch it
2019 best version lol
😂
poor mio...she was killed twice
Four times; in the manga, in the original anime, in the videogame and in the new anime.
@@jorgegarralagamartin3071 :,,,(((((
@@jorgegarralagamartin3071 movie too
fled admiral at lest he averaged her
@@ihvdrm i'm glad she's not appearing in Live Action :(
Both sad and strong, only i found the new one Slightly better than the old for only a reason: hyakkimaru.
While in the old version he have human interaction and try still to kept control while crying( and his face is more sad than angry), in the new one, he find out that mio died only after hearing her last song, that make him into a storm of pain and rage and you can really feel the pain in his face and his voice while turning into a berseker against those soldiers.
But it also makes it unrealistic
@@filipbabovic8474 why unrealistic, he is a 16 teen but have mind age of a children who is discovering the world, and before mio's death, he had never lost something important for him (when he lost his body he was too young to felt sofference), and the sufference for the lost made him turn into a storm of rage against the ones who killed her, thats a pretty realistic scene for someone in his mental/phisical status.
How about the fluidity of the newer animation and the lack of color in the old?
@@chrisreaves6399 well, the old one is justified because the animations were pretty impressive for the 1969, so would be kinda unfair compare the animations quality after 50 years.
Plus the blood doesn't sound like squirting syrup
The newer series has more impact, as we spend more time with Mio, his reaction is more animalistic and distraught, and Dororo has to share the experience as well, but I really like how, while slashing the samurai in the older series, the image of Mio is slashed too, it's a good visual metaphor.
Nah man ur just not a crybaby like the normies down there
- i m m o r t a l i s - I agree that effect was really cool
It has more impact in the manga. Mio was mute originally and Hyakki came to relate to her even further when he fell in love with her but never being able to listen to her voice.
@@7Blink2 bro a fun fact
I was reading the comment upper than your.a bug is going circles in my head,when I was focusing reading the comment and scroll my screen down your profile make me shock I thought the bug was sitting in my screen (no offense)
Sorry for bad English
@@mozammelhossain8261 ok?
first time he hears was someone crying, first time he screams was the loss of his leg, first time he speaks was the loss of his loved one.
We should change the anime's title to Pain and Suffering.
Holy, thanks for the 1k likes
I also agree
thats a weird way to spell
re:zero
@@jetzrav4889 lol XD
@@jetzrav4889 oh right... that title was already taken. Excuse my ignorance
or ""Why Must You Hurt Me This Way"
Both of them are good, but I see that the new one has showed Hyakkimarus emotions more.. It's like the legend being reborn as a masterpiece. This anime is so good at expressing the emotions back then and now.. Such a good quality and story, a real masterpiece
They don't call Tezuka "God of manga" for nothing, his works are just amazing n.n
@@Jennihazama he is a real genious
هعهعهعهعهعهعععهعههههه 🙂🙂
@@Jennihazama you mean god of all holy manga and anime?
@I H8 PUPPIES Omg I love ur profile pic sooo much
The 1969's ost with the 2019's animation is just perfect.
I highly agree with you.
Me too
Ikr
I dont like the party is over ost
ishli pogi I love the party is over ost.
Old scene: Water splashing and sword sounds
New scene: *F r e a k i n g G e n o c i d e*
Somewhere between 2:42 and 2:43, you can see Hyakkimaru's face reflected on Samurai's blade (2019 version). That's an amazing detail.
Shams Tahsin Holy... SHIIIIII- YOU'RE RIGHT!!! 😱😱😱
Okay but it lowkey looks terrifying
I refuse to believe it's Hyakkimaru' face, lol xD
You meant 1969 version?
Good eye brother. Missed it when watching.
People here saying "Somehow the new one is slightly better"
Somehow? Of course it's fucking better, there's literally a 50 year difference between them.
Drakonus it’s more of a compliment to the old one because it’s also good for its time
@@Repudiate Fair enough
not just animation the atmosphere the cheesiness of him "speaking" with normal emotions like he is some normal dude and maybe a bit slower "did you guys killed them? eh?"
The new star wars is the worst, even the first star wars (episode IV) is still better than the force awaken or the rise of skywalking
Shut the hell up bro, time does not affect writing and storytelling in any way. And monochrome look just adds more to the historical dramma feel.
Can we just appreciate how far ahead of time 1969's version was? Just the mere concept of losing body parts is amazing let alone the plot. Truly worthy of a better readaptation
and it even got a worthy re-adaptation by mappa
Even stronger in the manga when Mio was originally mute and Hyakki had a deeper connection with her relating to her disability but still living life to the fullest back in a time when Hyakkimaru thought of himself as weak because of his own disabilities.
Wait wait wait a minute! I think I missed that. Where in the manga does it say Mio was mute?
@@Anonymous_Gambito she never spoke a word, he never heard her voice. No matter how much she smiled, no matter how happy they were, she never spoke a single word. He never hears her voice. That temple was filled with broken people, she was broken as well, robbed of her voice.
@@Anonymous_Gambito When Hyakkimaru states that he had never heard Mio's voice, it was because she actually didn't talk. Even though Hyakkimaru had no hearing, he could sense the people talking to him via extra-sensory powers. Mio could only communicate with him by saying things with her heart, since he could catch them telepathically.
people bleed oil in 69
Well, of course, it's Black and White...
If u.s army was there you know what will happen right?
@@NishiroK123 - Whoa really Sherlock?? I DIDN'T KNOW
America be like: " oil?, did you say oil?, i think they need some freedom"
@@CodyT711 dude. Wtf??
Its acurrate.
I'm surprised how gruesome the original 60s one was.
Osamu was ahead of his time.
Doesnt come close to the 2019 one tho😂
Fire Pitch I wonder why?
@@firepitch5113 Just because of the animation? And seriously, don't compare them like that. Old anime has its limit. Both are good in my opinion.
@@miyako1909 yes because of the animation.....why cant i compare animation,im not saying the older version is trash😒
@@firepitch5113 by your logic, The eva rebuild films are better then 90s tv show because more superior animation
animation isn't everything, i would like you to provide more
「未央ー！！」て叫んでいっぱい喋る百鬼丸もいーけど、
個人的には今まで感情がなかった百鬼丸が泣きながら「…み…お…」って抱きしめながらいう方が好き。
ホントに綺麗で切ない恋だと思った
手塚の作品をここまでのものにしたMAPPAに感謝。
Yeah japanese words mang.
蛍来
キャラの性格も今のが好きだし
昔のアニメ・漫画見てみたいけど絵が合わなくて見れないのが残念
今の感じで昔のどろろのアニメみたいに長編でやって欲しかった(´・ω・｀)
[Agrees in Japanese]
Revolver Ocelot mood
The way the two versions tell the story and display emotions reflect the times they were made in. They’re equally impactful and emotional, but in different ways. The newer version of this scene is more compelling to me (they’ve done an amazing job remaking this, seriously), but I love how the old one makes my heart feel like it’s sinking, it has such a eerie and quiet despair to it, even if Hyakkimaru isn’t showing his emotion vocally, the imagery says it all.
I don't get how some people in the comments are comparing the two shows without talking into account the 50 year gap between the two animations. Like it came out before the first episode of Dragon Ball Z came out, so give it some slack
First time hearing his voice and now im wondering who is the voice actor. 😍
It's Hiroki Suzuki, the same guy that plays him in the stage play
@@Jennihazama yeah also its his first debut role. Same with Dororo's seiyuu it's her first debut role too
Omg! Gonna be one of his fan now. And now im waiting for more. 🤗
Here you are 😍
ruclips.net/video/fUMBfGu26ME/видео.html
@ And to be thinking she's a 13 year old girl... Totally Insanee
My pick would be the new one. I've always preferred the "show, don't tell" method and the 2019 anime does it well
If you notice, even the derp face between 2:15 and 2:16 matches a bit xD
(I'm laughing to keep myself from crying :c Mio...)
Why you videos in my recommendation?
I like how the remake shows the emotion and let's it play out rather than telling it like the original, and how Hyakkimaru can never cry in this scene in the remake.
😂😂😭
Both of em are gold in their own ways but somehow the remake is more appealing
Sabitri Sahu i see the remake put more logic on Hyakkimaru
Mappa
I like the old one better bc he isn't screaming like a little whiny baby
新はどろろがいたからなんぼかカタルシスがあるけど旧は完全孤独で辛いな
Osamu Tezuka... was the best author to ever exist. I love his work. Sad he passed away. But BOY HE IS STILL LIVING TODAY!
Those guys had no chance, that guy is deadly when calma and unestoppable when mad
So on top of being fucked up, I forgot about the orphans having missing limbs. Honestly, every single one of these men deserved it! EVEN if they thought Mio was a spy, they were clearly out for blood-these kids were orphans, disabled, and found hope in Mio as sister figure-only to die because, well, the world is cruel. I'm still pissed, and sad, very very sad!=(
Kids could be also spies
That was common durning those times
Very aware of that.
@Tin Tin I have very confused thoughts from your comment.
@Tin Tin is that some Hindu stuff
I think that the 2019 version is more in line with the personality that hyakkimaru should have, since he was basically a wooden doll since he was a child, the 1969 version seems more human his reactions
As if he had already recovered his whole body
i think dororo is a really refeshing anime in 2019, since too many "isekai" - "isekai" anime.
Yeah right.
@Azrael Malaku I Maut wait no overlord?
wait no tokyo ghoul?
@lunar view Afr7d I think we can agree that konosuba is pretty unique compared to the typical isekai anime
Both of them are good, but I think the recent have more impact :o
旧作版の比較編集ありがとうございます🌟
Both versions actually rock! Like wow. They're still powerful depending on their time. The new one is more graphic, and the older one seems more dramatic. Love both of them. The new adaptation of Dororo is very, and I'm happy to see that it's keeping the spirit of the old.
I didn’t want these feels today
The 2019 version seems a lot better. Apart from the obvious expected improvement in animation, Hyiakimmaru's character fits him better. He reacts more like someone who's felt true loss for the first time and acted on instinct rather than some cliche shinobi warrior.
Oh God, the 2019 version always makes me cry. It's done so well. Hyakimaru isn't even used to expressing himself at all yet. But the subtlety in the realization of what happened turning in a bout of acute insanity from the pain and anguish he feels. It's so sad
作画だけでなく作劇の進化も興味深い。
新で百鬼丸を喋れなくしたことでどろろが百鬼丸の心を代弁する形となったが、これにより百鬼丸の苦しみとどろろとの間にある絆が強調される形になっている。
*HUGS MIO WITH DARN SWORDS IN HAND*
Those are his hands
I mean, there's not much other way of holding her
No one gonna talk about how slick the animation was, and how well done the quick burst of anger was done in the 2019 version
リメイク版も、最高に良いよなぁ…
旧は冨田勲の秀逸なBGMが特に効果的かな、と。
あとは百鬼丸の状態のリアル度が旧と新では違う(旧はテレパシー等でほぼ普通の人と変わらないコミュニケーションが取れている)から感情を言葉に出来ない分ネックはあると思いますね。
新はその分、この先感情や取り戻した感覚がどのように描かれていくのかが楽しみです。
旧版では序盤に未央の話を回想として描いてるけど、新版では旅の途中の出来事として描いてて、なんでかな?って思ったけど、百鬼丸が喋らない代わりにどろろが旧版の百鬼丸の様に表向きな感情を視聴者に伝えるためなんだって思った。旧版のそれなりに一緒にいた描写は百鬼丸の未央への感情がより自然に成り立ってるし、新版は初めて心地よい音に出会ってもっと知りたいと思った矢先に...っていう悲しみがあって、どっちもとても素敵。あと旧版百鬼丸めっちゃイケボ...
旧作の百鬼丸の声は野沢那智さんですね、洋画ではアラン・ドロン、アル・パチーノ、晩年にはブルース・ウィリスの吹き替えで有名でした。
アニメではコブラの声を演じていてスペースコブラの頃の若コブラの声が百鬼丸の声と同じ雰囲気でしたね。
I like that they decided to put Dororo there with Hyakkimaru, making him the one to help him come back to his senses.
Dororo is a she
He identifies as a "he", to which I'm mean he actively says "I'm a man, there's nothing wrong with me" in the manga and gets mad when people call him a "she"
Yeee...but biologically she is a she. So that's that
@@Fyzzy4life well I prefer to use the pronouns people chose for themselves. So that's that.
@@ayt3877 she
50 yrs ago, Japan was already making animations cooler than almost anything western.
Ahem ahem Disney
@@Themeir
Disney copied a lot from Dororo's author, they followed his traces like dogs so lets not mention them
@@mariama.f8314 Its very fucking ironic.. no ignorant of you to mention Tezuka because he literally grow up with disney animation and inspired from it. You weebs disgust me
@@Themeir calls other people weebs -has a fucking Giorno picture
J0šęph Weeb means someone who loves another’s culture, typically Japanese, over their own and places it on a pedestal. Liking and appreciating anime or any aspect of another culture doesn’t make your a weeb. Bashing your own culture for another and blindly praising it without measuring pros and cons makes you a weeb.
The old version still looks amazing with lots of tone levels and details despite no color.
2019: sad crying, angry voice
1969: sad haunting music
I think the newer one is better to be because it does the job of “show, don’t tell”. We already know based on hyakki’s interactions with Mio and the others how much he adores them, and his screaming instead of just telling us what he’s doing feels a lot more impactful.
the 2019 is better. we can feel how desperate hyakkimaru on losing his first love. plus, dororo consoling hyakkimaru after that breaks our heart. "she didn't lose...". oh god. i shed a tear tbh.
50年前のも神作画だよねw
The 2019 one is more deep and has more feeling to it cause he couldnt talk in it and His rage felt more real,also his first word was mio so it makes the scene even better
1969 0:14 when she says her parents aren’t home
The 2019 added more storyline and did a great job of making us sympatize the main characters Mio included, while the 1969's version felt like despair and depicted grief instead of rage. The 1969 scene was a bit more scary than the 2019 scene (probably because of the music and it's dark themes) It was a tad more darker than 2019 tbh, but I think both years did a really good job.
Extremely well-done and creative video. I especially loved the part where you relied on directional sound for either scenes, please keep up!
I think the thing is that 1969 didn't have animation techniques and easy-of-use as today does. Technological and the overall evolution of anime as an art medium allowed Dororo to get the few bits of edge it was lacking in its original incarnations. I literally got into the franchise today with the remake, but I have mad respect for Tezuka's work, knowing how influential he is as a mangaka. Besides overall new insights in how the story is pulled off - such as making Hyakkimaru completely unaware to the world outside him save for a special vision. It allows for adding in tidbits of character development through metaphors conveyed by his physical improvement, which I find simply genius.
Totally hyped to see what the show has in its sleeve for me.
i have never felt so sad about a character i have known for so little time RIP MIO
MAPPA really did a masterpiece with Dororo, but kudos to the first adaptation, I imagine how tricky was adapt violence like this on the 60s.
Thank you for making this video
Even tho old anime is good Daam man those Japanese are really fantastic
*So. Sad... Mi...o.* 😟😩🤧
😭😭
@@devashrijoshi9079 *Yeah. That too...* 🙀
I wanted to see more from her, not just 2 episodes. :((
I like the 2019 Dororo scene more. Reasoning? Because the fact that Hyakimaru *could no talk* . All he could do was let out his rage by screaming *because* he had never talked before. It put a lot more emotion into the scene than the 1969 Dororo did. Not to mention the sakuga that went down during the "fight" if you could even call it that since it was really Hyakimaru going sicko mode on those dudes.
Legit, Dororo reminded me how good anime can be as a form of storytelling. A lot of the recent stuff has been overpowered isekai harem anime with very little depth.
どっちもよく出来てると思います。by日本人
Dororo is a pioneer in the youkai genre and Japanese anime in general, and it just makes me really happy to see interest in this wonderful series revived in the wake of the incredibly well made 2019 version :3 the first adaptation is very much a swashbuckling samurai adventure with demons whereas the remake is a grim representation of humanity, emotions and the actual horrors of the Sengoku era. For those who don't know, Tezuka had to change a lot of things about Dororo in the 60s because people thought it was too dark for its intended audience (young-preteen boys), but the 2019 adaptation clearly was allowed a bit more freedom on that front, because anime isn't just made for kids anymore, and thus was able to bring back some of those darker scenes and show them on screen which just make it amazing and way more appealing to a modern audience. I'm actually writing an essay about this series currently for my Japanese Literature and Arts course and how it's changed over 50 years~
Right? This show influenced so much.
This show gave birth to so much anime, like Demon Slayer, Yuyu Hakusho, Berserk, Fullmetal Alchemist, Bleach, Yugioh, Inuyasha...
Even Kenshin from Rurouni Kenshin borrowed heavily from Hyakkimaru's design and swordplay.
The old anime is pretty violent. Which surprised me
The original 1969 version hit the feeling of sadness and sorrow spot on. While the new 2019 version hit the feeling of anger more so.
Holy crap I realized if you wear your head phones while watching one side will play the 2019 and the other will play the 1969 version
ikr so cool
This was so moving, Thank you.
I was looking for the original japanese VA of Hyakkimaru and i've found out that Nachi Nozawa did his voice, he also did the voice for Alexsander from the Hellsing TV anime version.
Am I the only one who is crying in the 1969 part where he reminisces her TwT like even the ist is freaking perfect
Adorei ;-;
Achava que a Mio não morria no original...
O anime de 2019 é incrível!
Explanation as to why Hyakki can talk in the old one, basically, Jukai taught him how to speak with his stomach. It’s like a weird combination of how it moves, and growls, I read the og manga years a go so I don’t remember the specifics, but the demons didn’t take his stomach so yeah.
Plus, in the old one, Mio was from his backstory, we never actually got to meet her personally in the original version.
A mí me rompe el corazón ambas, realmente amo a Mio y fue súper sad cundo la asesinaron, lo que más me gustó es que en la de 2019 es que Mío le canta por última vez y hyakkimaru la abraza diciendo su nombre re sad :'c 😣😭
"Those who should kill are the ones who are prepared to be killed"
-Lelouch
😳 Wow
Wow Mappa brought me a lot of emotions with their choice of adaptation. That's amazing they managed to convey so much yet stay true to the original content.
Mappa doing god's work ;w;
Both are good, but I see Dororo have more scene in the new one
1969 scene is a true classic but 2019 hits the heart.
また40年後に製作して欲しい。どんな絵柄や演出になってるのかな。自分はその時見られるか分からないけど。
This scene is the perfect example of why I like the 2019 version better, it portrays hyakkimaru more animalistic than human because he was robbed of most experience that would make him human, his brain also works more like an animal as well “kill red get body back” as he doesn’t know more because he didn’t have the means to understand.
The remake is awesome! Well done
"Dororo Screech fits with everything " . im just waiting for a video like that
This is the best remake I've ever watched for an anime...
I like that even though Hyakkimaru doesn't say a word and simply roars with rage as if he'd become a beast made a much bigger impact on me than all the questioning and flashbacks he did in the 1969 version and when he finally did speak only to say Mio's name, it broke my heart. Really. :'(
Hyakkimaru rage in the new ver is the most satisfying and saddest thing in this year
旧作との比較ありがとうございます。個人的にやはり旧作のみおの章がぐっときます。間にみおの回想シーン入れて心を揺さぶる辺りたまらないです。
The old version's scenes were all about the atmosphere. This one is a good example
Both great moments. For me while I think the emotion is a bit stronger in the original (between the change in style and some story changes to alter its impact) there is something truly beautiful in Hyakkimaru’s rage during the original. Particularly the music and the cuts, especially the part where Mio’s image is sliced up.
That scene where that crippled kid was running away scared and got slashed haunts me...
Low key i have this theory that he gets like a wish after he kills all the demons and wishes her and the children back
@shadowshinobi06 wow nvm then 😂
@shadowshinobi06 oh ok, so Dororo is a girl. Nothing that surprising, as I had already noticed her chest was a little weird, but this confirms it.
@shadowshinobi06 Btw, I have a question, was one of the parts the demon room, his penis?, That would be hella funny
@@Android25K bruh. Dang it now I am imagining the demon and the penis thing. 😂😂😂
"Hey dont look at me like that, I was incharge of the lust section"
"Oooohhhhhh"
Holy Shh!! I love the scream synchronized in 2:15
The new version of this scene is far more thematic, and also flows far better story-wise.
2:43 in the 2019 version you can see hyakkimaru's face reflected in the blade. I had to slow the video down to .25 playback speed and even then pause and unpause quickly in order to catch it. It's seriously a blink a you'll miss it detail but damn it's awesome
the song for the 1969 version is haunting.... i think if the 2019 version had given a few more episodes for mio and hyakkimaru to fall in love and draw out their relationship more, the death scene could've had that kind of music and dramatic imagery that the 1969 had. but i think the 2019 didn't have music because they wanted to highlight hyakkimaru's screams... ahhh so sad
Me encantan estas comparaciones nuevo suscriptor
Hyakkimaru’s reaction in the new adaptation is so much more realistic, and instead of just being overwhelmed with sadness, he sees mio slowly die and gets overwhelmed by rage
Equally heartbreaking thank you very much.
Good god they're not even remotely the same guy...
I like the new hyaku better as a character, and as a concept.
But they're so damn different. Like I see people comparing them and honestly you just can't.
新しい方が工夫されてますね。
しかし、レスが英語ばかりで手塚作品がこんなに研究されてるとは、驚きです。
I think the older one has the i lost my friend and its really sad feeling, and the newer one is more like absolute unadultured rage.
In the new scene, when Hyakkimaru breaks- the way it's animated at 2:16 reminds me of that one scene from Howl's Moving Castle when (I think, i'm not super clear on the details) the head witch lady tries to turn Howl into a monster and he loses some control- he starts screaming like that too. Anyways, broke meh heart.