The WORST beginner plane ever made?? -WLToys XK Piper Cub J3

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 22 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 93

  • @coded_vr3699
    @coded_vr3699 2 года назад +25

    My first plane was a cub beginner plane that surprisingly flew well without any type of rudder, elevator or aileron’s but the wind turned out to be the little planes demise as the wind picked up and flew the plane onto the top of the highest tree in the field

    • @Jays_rcgarage
      @Jays_rcgarage  2 года назад +4

      Lol we have all had the tree landings 😂 bummer you didn’t get it back

    • @ace88205
      @ace88205 Год назад +2

      So no rudder, elevator, or ailerons.... So how'd it fly with no control surfaces? Literally imposssible for a highwing cub unless it had 3 different motors that used torque vectoring maybe. I love the story but it needs to be a least a little believable if your trying to garner true interest in what your saying. Ok son?

    • @kerilueders6188
      @kerilueders6188 Год назад

      Wait how did you fly without aileron and elevator 😅

    • @Jack-cm9ye
      @Jack-cm9ye 9 месяцев назад

      @@ace88205one motor on each side. One speeds up it turns. 100% power it climbs

    • @MohsinKhan-yq9sg
      @MohsinKhan-yq9sg 5 месяцев назад

      Same, my first was a 2 channel cub

  • @crotaflyingsolo4759
    @crotaflyingsolo4759 2 года назад +12

    THE PROBLEM IS ACTUALLY with the Gyro/Stabilization system intermittently giving full left rudder lock and if not high enough to recover will take you DOWN! I've actually tested it on the bench and was able to make it happen!

    • @theoztreecrasher2647
      @theoztreecrasher2647 2 года назад

      Yep, the problems that the Gyro programming on that XK A160 has have been well documented. Lovely looking model but a real steaming flying coprolite!

    • @blackterminal
      @blackterminal Год назад

      Sounds like a replacement stabilizer would help

    • @crotaflyingsolo4759
      @crotaflyingsolo4759 Год назад

      @@blackterminal THE PROBLEM IS ACTUALLY with the Gyro/Stabilization system intermittently giving full left rudder lock defective controller/gyro!

    • @mattbryant420
      @mattbryant420 Год назад +1

      I had the same full rudder lock.
      Should have been a 3 channel.
      I glued the rudder straight,
      Cut horizontal along lowest vane,to isolate the rudder and rear gear,to be able to taxi.
      Made it work,
      Now it flies great!
      But the paint sucks too.

    • @asdaven1
      @asdaven1 4 месяца назад

      On Brian Phillips channel, he moved the position of the servo rod where it attaches to the rudder, watch his review , the linkage comes stock attached to the wrong hole

  • @sawajiri100
    @sawajiri100 2 года назад +19

    WORST *IT BECAUSE YOU FLYING NOT OPEN FIELD* You *Wasted*

    • @dravcicz
      @dravcicz Год назад +1

      Yes that's very good plane

    • @jlrguy2702
      @jlrguy2702 5 месяцев назад

      My thoughts precisely, it's too small an area to fly a plane in, yes you do suck....lol

  • @chickenlifeau
    @chickenlifeau Месяц назад +1

    i have the j3 cub its okay but needs lots of space like you said i also brought the other plane you had in the vidio and is way better with detachable prop

  • @waywardspirit7898
    @waywardspirit7898 Год назад +2

    My wife bought me one of these. I felt so bad for her because she thought she was "doing me a solid". I let her down easy and went and bought a whole new electronics package. Have not messed with it yet but, it is a beautiful little airplane. Once i completely change the electronics it should be fine.

  • @TheBadbrad9
    @TheBadbrad9 Год назад +5

    Thanks, It was interesting, helped me to see I'm not ready for the Cub, need a lot of practice, especially for this old man, lol

    • @fzngagan
      @fzngagan Год назад +1

      Simulators are the way to go...

  • @warmiceUT
    @warmiceUT 2 года назад +8

    This version of XK A160-J3 known to have a problematic algo on the controller board (gyro algorithm).
    As I understand, recently XK released a new version of the controller board as replacement parts, which shall be corrected the gyro algorithm issue

    • @Jays_rcgarage
      @Jays_rcgarage  2 года назад +2

      Awesome, I will definitely get one. I love the way this plane looks. It’s hanging in my garage currently!

    • @jimmydirtnap7803
      @jimmydirtnap7803 2 года назад +2

      Any link to the replacement part? I'm experiencing the same issue. Thx

    • @Jays_rcgarage
      @Jays_rcgarage  2 года назад +1

      @@jimmydirtnap7803 I’m wondering the same, I may reach out to manufacturers

    • @warmiceUT
      @warmiceUT Год назад +1

      Yeah, do need to contact the Wltoys official store.. meanwhile, I also don't have the official link for the replacement control board.. as my replacement board was given by the manufacturer official store after I contacted them.

  • @jamestaylor1614
    @jamestaylor1614 7 месяцев назад +1

    The way you fly the p-51 or whatever it is I can fly the cub just as well and even with the cheap transmitter I can fly inverted. Take undercarriage off and add 8-10 grams to the nose and it will fly great

  • @rcplanetim53
    @rcplanetim53 2 года назад +3

    I have flown all my life, mostly gas, then when the brushless motors and lipo batteries came around I started flying electric and I bought one of these flew it and then threw it away... complete junk. I tried to disconnect the rudder and just fly it 3 channels, but it still slammed itself into the ground.

  • @andreweakin3923
    @andreweakin3923 8 месяцев назад

    Flew mine for so long the batteries went bad before the plane broke. (I am not necessarily a beginner) it's a good plane. It's just not a backyard flyer, and needs a bigger battery for windy days.

  • @tboystoys5682
    @tboystoys5682 Год назад +2

    I had the same experience. Then on throttle up when it does start to fly all the control surfaces stick and puts the plane into a death spiral and crashes. But it’s well constructed it just needs a good flight controller and reconfigure on the servos. 😂. Sad to say company done nothing to help😢

  • @EngineNoise305
    @EngineNoise305 Год назад +1

    Yeah so I got the XK A220 (the p40) and same thing with safe on happens. You can barley turn. When safe is on I guess it really limits the control travel. I got the Eachine/volantex mustang and it flys so good with safe on, I can turn so sharp with it.

    • @Jays_rcgarage
      @Jays_rcgarage  Год назад +1

      I have just about every Volantex Warbird they made... They are amazing !! The F-16 is a little sketchy lol f22 flys way better.

    • @blakejohn8374
      @blakejohn8374 7 месяцев назад

      I also own all the mini warbirds, and the A220 is great to fly in 3G mode 😎 I can knife edge that thing all day inverted flying you name it

  • @tim7402
    @tim7402 Год назад +6

    You totally were unprepared for this airplane. I have one and it was not easy to tame. It loves to tip stall and requires lots of speed to keep flying.
    Your choice of flying site was bad too. Soccer field required not a backyard. I'm a well seasoned RC guy retired here in Thailand,this is definitely NOT a trainer. Looks great but too much for a newbie. I also stay in 6G mode too. Too squirrely in 3D. If your prepared properly and check CG, etc. It looks amazing in the air or just sitting.

  • @jamesrivers9106
    @jamesrivers9106 11 месяцев назад

    My first was the parkzone Cub.. went from that to the Stryker C. then got bored after a while and upgraded my Stryker with a motor that shouldn’t go in it 🤣

  • @lilgreencanoe2936
    @lilgreencanoe2936 9 месяцев назад

    In its out of the box form, this plane will “fly”. Does it fly well? (No) I agree it’s very “meh”. I ended up swapping the crappy motor for the brushless motor that is in the A160 (XKP51), omitted the plastic canopy and made a wing support out of toothpicks to replace that part. With the added power, it is like a completely different plane. So it has potential! I’ve put around 100 flights on mine. It is in fact a 60 dollar airplane so… it’ll fly like one.

  • @ferp420
    @ferp420 8 месяцев назад

    I bought 1 of these never flew before took me about 30 seconds to learn to fly it I've got 3 packs through it let my friend fly it who also never flew before and he had no problems flying it either
    the landing gear took a beating but other than that it hasn't had any issues
    I'm still learning how to land and my driveway is dirt and rocks so it's not exactly smooth

    • @ferp420
      @ferp420 8 месяцев назад

      so far so good

  • @impuls60
    @impuls60 7 месяцев назад

    That Rarebear is a gem for the price!

  • @JN24185
    @JN24185 5 месяцев назад

    It’s funny because this is my absolute favorite beginner plane. I guess they’re a bit hit and miss. Iva had mine over a year now. Still flies amazing and so easy to replace parts.

  • @ohiorc5586
    @ohiorc5586 8 месяцев назад

    Your bobber vid with tailheavy was like a blooper of your channel it was great and that a nice wall art plane haha

  • @AliNoor-fy5qb
    @AliNoor-fy5qb 7 месяцев назад

    It’s good for its price I really like it, but it’s hard to fly and takes practice

  • @jordancoleman2402
    @jordancoleman2402 Год назад

    I love the a160, put a spektrum sattalite in it and it fly it with a real radio and it's awesome

    • @Jays_rcgarage
      @Jays_rcgarage  Год назад

      Hmmm, would love do to this. Can you email me the link to what you used ? This plane is hanging in my garage and I love the way it looks. Bud can’t fly it the way it is! My email is jaysrcgarage@gmail.com

    • @jordancoleman2402
      @jordancoleman2402 Год назад

      @@Jays_rcgarage if you own a spektrum radio all you need is a spektrum sattalite. There are two open ports on the main board/Flight controller one marked S-bus thats for fytaba radios and i believe the other one is unmarked and that one is where you plug the spektrum sattalite in. I picked an XK a800 glider this week and was able to do the same thing. Kind of sucks they are great airplanes but the toy grade radios they provide are crap. You could also try to bind to the controller from the airplane that flys well to yellow one

    • @Jays_rcgarage
      @Jays_rcgarage  Год назад +1

      @@jordancoleman2402 amazing, ordering now. Thanks for this info

  • @bobbylapointe2334
    @bobbylapointe2334 5 месяцев назад

    Title of the video could be "worst place to fly for a beginner" small planes fly fast and need good reflex, so for a beginner the best thing is to fly in a place with no trees, with a bigger model and it’s gonna be stressless !
    Your garden is perfect to fly a 3D aerobatic plane or helico but with experience !😉

  • @v8rangee
    @v8rangee 10 месяцев назад +1

    The only thing bad about it was where he flew it and partly his skill. Its not an areobatics plane you need more space to fly it

  • @capnhardway
    @capnhardway 2 года назад +2

    That really doesn't help the people that may not know the ins and outs of model building..

  • @jack-n2n1k
    @jack-n2n1k 9 месяцев назад

    im thinking of replacing the guts of mine because the gyro is so messed up. Whenever i pull up, the rudder turns left. I got it for chritsmas and haven't flown it since a few days after. The two prop mount thingies it came with are broken. Im not sure how to fix it since its my first actual rc plane.

  • @Feeds_Stock
    @Feeds_Stock 7 месяцев назад

    I got that plane for a beginner, and I crashed it, and the rudder connection to the servo wouldn’t work after that and the prop broke :/

  • @manicfour
    @manicfour 2 года назад

    Man did that plane suck. It flew twice perfect. Took many attempts at that too. In the end the airframe did survive undamaged. I broke it down with plans to someday add other electronics to it. Never got around to it. Been maybe two years now. Just hate to throw away such a beautiful airframe.

    • @jordancoleman2402
      @jordancoleman2402 Год назад +2

      If you got one with the first release flight controller they flew like crap but they did revise a few times now and might be worth picking up a new main board on bang good see them going for as low as 17 bucks and makes it a whole new airplane when flying

  • @MXX95TV
    @MXX95TV 2 года назад

    Top Wing planes are the greatest beginner aircraft this whole safe thing came around a few years back if anything it's a hindrance to True skill that's obtained through practice

    • @theoztreecrasher2647
      @theoztreecrasher2647 2 года назад +1

      Yep. If i ever get on a commercial airplane and see that it has an Autopilot installed I scream to get off! Same if the pilot is wearing a fancy Kepi instead of a real leather flying helmet! You can't trust this new-fangled stuff! ;-)

    • @mrfilmer9270
      @mrfilmer9270 Год назад

      @@theoztreecrasher2647 uhm, ok

    • @theoztreecrasher2647
      @theoztreecrasher2647 Год назад

      @@mrfilmer9270 😜😜😊

    • @mrfilmer9270
      @mrfilmer9270 Год назад

      @@theoztreecrasher2647 autopilot was created before you were born so it isn't new

    • @theoztreecrasher2647
      @theoztreecrasher2647 Год назад

      @@mrfilmer9270 Everything manufactured by only the hand of man after the first flood is "new" Brother Filmer! 😉😇

  • @CastroFelix
    @CastroFelix 9 месяцев назад

    Is a beautiful plane sadly a waist of money, had one like this a wile a go the electronics on it are the problem the only way to make this work is by replacing the flight controller/ESC & servos.

  • @Flybrei
    @Flybrei 2 года назад

    Nice Cub👍

  • @capnhardway
    @capnhardway 2 года назад

    I think you helped me decide lol

  • @lukeypooky.7729
    @lukeypooky.7729 2 года назад +1

    Hi!!! First I love ur vids

  • @lenjan5111
    @lenjan5111 2 года назад +2

    This thing is so bad, i ended up spraying it with my airsoft ssr 15 aeg mid air.

    • @Jays_rcgarage
      @Jays_rcgarage  2 года назад +1

      Lol I would have loved to see that !

  • @naprelax9076
    @naprelax9076 2 года назад

    It’s so nicee, what’s the best for beginners?

    • @Jays_rcgarage
      @Jays_rcgarage  2 года назад

      The little Rate Bear that’s linked below flys amazing. It’s the second plane I flew in this video. Or any of the Eachine are cheap and great beginner planes !

    • @Fishingaddict760
      @Fishingaddict760 2 года назад

      The best micro plane is the Umx turbo timber hands down the best micro out there

  • @Fishingaddict760
    @Fishingaddict760 2 года назад

    You’re right this one is the worst I’m experienced and fly well…. First flight with this plane I broke it lol

    • @sethturner7089
      @sethturner7089 2 года назад +1

      Mine did the same thing on the nose

  • @sethturner7089
    @sethturner7089 2 года назад

    Is there any way to fix that tip ?

    • @theoztreecrasher2647
      @theoztreecrasher2647 2 года назад +2

      Watch the videos of Ground Control RC on RUclips. He shows how to remove the bad guts and get it flying not too bad. It will never be an excellent flier - it is too heavy for its wing area.

  • @cheythompson740
    @cheythompson740 2 года назад +3

    Was gunna say the plane isn't the issue lol

    • @zanderbrandt1730
      @zanderbrandt1730 2 года назад +4

      It’s both. The board is a known issue (can be mitigated but not avoided) but also this guy is taking off straight into trees before the board has a chance to even lock the rudder and become the failure point. Area is way too small for a beginner. Lots of bad choices here.

  • @User5005.
    @User5005. 2 года назад +1

    What’s the best beginner plane?

    • @Jays_rcgarage
      @Jays_rcgarage  2 года назад

      Currently this Rare Bear in this video is the one I’m flying the most right Niels super easy and durable ! Cheap also!!!

  • @JuneKushner
    @JuneKushner 3 месяца назад +1

    he keeps calling it a cherkee it's a cub

  • @crotaflyingsolo4759
    @crotaflyingsolo4759 4 месяца назад

    That plane needs a lot of space to fly!! Too fast for a small yard!!

  • @itsme_luke
    @itsme_luke 2 года назад

    How do i enter the goveaway?

    • @Jays_rcgarage
      @Jays_rcgarage  2 года назад +1

      Usually just a comment on a video! Keep a lookout for the next one. Probably a week or so

    • @itsme_luke
      @itsme_luke 2 года назад

      @@Jays_rcgarage ok thank you i was a fan of yours on tiktok then i couldnt have it so i was scrolling through shorts and found you i have been watching every video of yours

  • @adammccarthy2157
    @adammccarthy2157 9 месяцев назад

    Mine flies great

  • @Sheikh_tom123
    @Sheikh_tom123 6 месяцев назад

    Daam i messed up i got this and i crashed two times 😢

  • @jaimehaynes428
    @jaimehaynes428 2 года назад

    𝚙𝚛𝚘𝚖𝚘𝚜𝚖 🎶

  • @mikeclabaugh1548
    @mikeclabaugh1548 8 месяцев назад

    Lol. I don't think it's the plane.

  • @gardoniwalter1583
    @gardoniwalter1583 3 месяца назад

    WORST pilot !!!!!!