Marie Antoinette & Tsarina Alexandra Feodorovna of Russia are so similar in many ways. Both were doomed the moment they became the Consorts of their new countries. If only they were like Catherine the Great & Catherine of Aragon (both teenagers) who integrated themselves to their new countries (Russia & England) and made an effort to win the love of their people.
all mayor all governor wala kayo silbi sa republika ng pilipinas, madami namatay sa gutom, madami nalipasan ng gutom, mga basahan ang mga damit at mga bubuyog ang bahay ng mga mahihirap, bulsa kayo ng bulsa ng pera mga mayor mga governor kakainin ko ang mga utak ninyo mga buhay...
Her marriage was an alliance to keep peace, she didn't have a job. Her husbands duty was to make provisions for the people, job creation, food supplies such as giving grain, seeds, and housing. Each government has learned a valuable lesson from the lack of or failure to govern. MA's cheating is a result of her husband.
She did try to win the favor of the French. They hated her no matter what she did. Even her own husband distrusted her and didn’t defend her from any scrutiny. She was completely alone while also surrounded by a million judging eyes. At the point of Louis gifting her a whole building was when she started to give up and hide from France but even then she sought to do good. They blamed her for everything meanwhile her King could not make a decision to save his life and put France in an economic crisis. The people were starving. If anything it was the Kings fault although I also have sympathy for him for he was just put in this situation that he did not ask for and he knew he wasn’t fit for. They were children used as political puppets by their parents and in the end they were the punching bags of the country. This revolution was nothing but a pointless bloodbath.
I wouldn't say either of them were doomed. Marie Antoinette was amazingly well-liked by the people of Paris when she first arrived, and Russia didn't have a particular problem with Hesse or Alixandra - and these positive relationships might not have lasted forever, but they could have lasted a lot longer if these women were a little more savvy. They both represented countries that would go on to become enemies, and some dislike was inevitable, but they both made some very juvenile, entitled decisions that didn't help their situation.
I recognized the voice from the people's profile videos... Why is it on this channel though? It seems like it's just a complete lift from their channel...
I’m sure things were much different. Royals were probably disconnected from the common folk. She was not prepared but also the riots should have gave them some clue!
If the royals weren't important enough to keep alive, then nobody was safe. What an utter nightmare. Poor Marie Antoinette 👑 She lived in the most gorgeous palace in the world, had everything her heart desired, but still wasn't happy. 7 years without consumation! Everyone watching 👀 couldn't even take a 💩 without someone watching and announcing it!
For you to think your situation is in any way comparable to starving French peasants I truly will never understand how Americans don’t see how privileged they are.
You sound dumb we are already in this direction with Biden. He can’t even give a damn statement he’s a embarrassment to this country. Kamala is a joke, phony and also embarrassment.
"pardon me, monseiur, I did not do it on purpose." I can't even imagine what was going thru her head right then, but somehow this feels like it was an automatic response, she didn't even think about it. This small interaction really does express her entire life.
@@BMJ0877 My comment was in the context of the video and the version of events depicted in it. If you find the video to be factually incorrect or have reasons to question its authenticity then question the uploader instead of randomly attacking me.
Did you not listen to the video? She was a spoiled girl who didn't care to learn her studies, learn the people of France, gambled and wasted away TONS of money of lavish things (which was funded by the taxpayers of France hard earned money!) They continuously spent and spent and ate marvelously without care that their people were literally starving, and paying off HER spending and debts. She was awful!
Bit of a mistake. The aunts were NOT the sisters of Louis XV, they were his daughters and hence the aunts of the Dauphin Louis- Auguste, not his great aunts
So many comments, yet not one expressed sadness or sympathy for the starving mothers and children of France who endured unimaginable suffering, while she lived a life of luxury. The same holds true today-people are captivated by celebrities but show little interest in the struggles of single mothers working two jobs. But I digress.
Wow, you obviously know nothing about the real Marie. You’re so close minded you could only think about certain people you obviously knew nothing about her the fact that she did care about people.😊
you need to read a few books my friend !! and btw this clip was about M.A. and not starving mothers ,,,, I assume by your name you are not educated in European history ?
Stop trying to Virtue Signal. THIS video is about Marie Antoinette. If you care so much about the starving masses during that time then make your own video.
That is largely a myth. 18th century press engaged in a good deal of fake news of people not having more than a "pile of salt" to eat. In truth, French peasants, particularly in the countryside, had liberal access to victuals and were, for the mosy part, staunchly monarchist all along. Food shortages were experienced mostly DURING the revolution in Paris, a situation resulting from poor revolutionary administration and not attributed to the style of life of the king and queen.
Women in history were constantly used as political pawns they had no say or influence in their own fate. She may have been extravagant in her lifestyle but she did try to help. It wouldn't have mattered what she did to be honest she would have still suffered the same fate.
How did she try to help? She gambled away tons of money. She spent and spent for a lavish life with the decorations, outfits, food and items. All of this was funded by France's tax payers. So what attempt did she make to help the people, and not herself and her lifestyle?
@anthonytroisi6682 if Louis XIV had managr to balance the books in building Versailles, if Louis XV hadn't become stupid as he grew overconfident, and had Louis XVI not funded the American Revolution, all of this would never have come to pass.
I learned in college that this is an enduring myth. 🙂 Jean-Jacques Rousseau attributed these words to "a great princess" without ever naming her directly in his book, "Confessions". I have read conflicting accounts about when this book was written (1765? 1767?) but either way, it was written when Marie Antoinette was still a child. Historians think these words may have been linked to Marie Antionette about 50 years after the French Revolution in attempt turn popular opinion against the extravagant behavior of the upper classes.
It's so sad what happened to her little boy 😢
Marie Antoinette & Tsarina Alexandra Feodorovna of Russia are so similar in many ways. Both were doomed the moment they became the Consorts of their new countries.
If only they were like Catherine the Great & Catherine of Aragon (both teenagers) who integrated themselves to their new countries (Russia & England) and made an effort to win the love of their people.
Rrrrr😊
all mayor all governor wala kayo silbi sa republika ng pilipinas, madami namatay sa gutom, madami nalipasan ng gutom, mga basahan ang mga damit at mga bubuyog ang bahay ng mga mahihirap, bulsa kayo ng bulsa ng pera mga mayor mga governor kakainin ko ang mga utak ninyo mga buhay...
Her marriage was an alliance to keep peace, she didn't have a job. Her husbands duty was to make provisions for the people, job creation, food supplies such as giving grain, seeds, and housing. Each government has learned a valuable lesson from the lack of or failure to govern. MA's cheating is a result of her husband.
She did try to win the favor of the French. They hated her no matter what she did. Even her own husband distrusted her and didn’t defend her from any scrutiny. She was completely alone while also surrounded by a million judging eyes. At the point of Louis gifting her a whole building was when she started to give up and hide from France but even then she sought to do good. They blamed her for everything meanwhile her King could not make a decision to save his life and put France in an economic crisis. The people were starving. If anything it was the Kings fault although I also have sympathy for him for he was just put in this situation that he did not ask for and he knew he wasn’t fit for. They were children used as political puppets by their parents and in the end they were the punching bags of the country. This revolution was nothing but a pointless bloodbath.
I wouldn't say either of them were doomed. Marie Antoinette was amazingly well-liked by the people of Paris when she first arrived, and Russia didn't have a particular problem with Hesse or Alixandra - and these positive relationships might not have lasted forever, but they could have lasted a lot longer if these women were a little more savvy. They both represented countries that would go on to become enemies, and some dislike was inevitable, but they both made some very juvenile, entitled decisions that didn't help their situation.
A new subscriber, Thanks for your work and time ❤
This is a video made by The People Profile channel. This one just stole it.
I recognized the voice from the people's profile videos... Why is it on this channel though? It seems like it's just a complete lift from their channel...
I’m sure things were much different. Royals were probably disconnected from the common folk. She was not prepared but also the riots should have gave them some clue!
She wasn't THAT disconnected lol. Haha, peasant women would scream at her in Versailles "give us an heir"
Nothing new. Politicians today are also disconnected from the masses.
Such a wonderful video! Well presented......
If the royals weren't important enough to keep alive, then nobody was safe. What an utter nightmare. Poor Marie Antoinette 👑 She lived in the most gorgeous palace in the world, had everything her heart desired, but still wasn't happy. 7 years without consumation! Everyone watching 👀 couldn't even take a 💩 without someone watching and announcing it!
In the US, we are heading straight into this direction.
For you to think your situation is in any way comparable to starving French peasants I truly will never understand how Americans don’t see how privileged they are.
You sound dumb we are already in this direction with Biden. He can’t even give a damn statement he’s a embarrassment to this country. Kamala is a joke, phony and also embarrassment.
"pardon me, monseiur, I did not do it on purpose." I can't even imagine what was going thru her head right then, but somehow this feels like it was an automatic response, she didn't even think about it. This small interaction really does express her entire life.
This came from The Peoples Profile. I knew that narrators voice sounded familiar 😂😂
She sounds like a normal person who lived in unfortunate circumstances, nothing she did indicates her being evil
Are you serious or just trolling, a normal person? Please do a little research before posting such an inane comment 🙄
@@BMJ0877 My comment was in the context of the video and the version of events depicted in it. If you find the video to be factually incorrect or have reasons to question its authenticity then question the uploader instead of randomly attacking me.
Unfortunate? She was the fkin QUEEN OF FRANCE.
Did you not listen to the video? She was a spoiled girl who didn't care to learn her studies, learn the people of France, gambled and wasted away TONS of money of lavish things (which was funded by the taxpayers of France hard earned money!) They continuously spent and spent and ate marvelously without care that their people were literally starving, and paying off HER spending and debts. She was awful!
Thank you for this presentation.
Excellent
Bit of a mistake. The aunts were NOT the sisters of Louis XV, they were his daughters and hence the aunts of the Dauphin Louis- Auguste, not his great aunts
So many comments, yet not one expressed sadness or sympathy for the starving mothers and children of France who endured unimaginable suffering, while she lived a life of luxury.
The same holds true today-people are captivated by celebrities but show little interest in the struggles of single mothers working two jobs. But I digress.
Wow, you obviously know nothing about the real Marie. You’re so close minded you could only think about certain people you obviously knew nothing about her the fact that she did care about people.😊
you need to read a few books my friend !! and btw this clip was about M.A. and not starving mothers ,,,, I assume by your name you are not educated in European history ?
Stop trying to Virtue Signal. THIS video is about Marie Antoinette. If you care so much about the starving masses during that time then make your own video.
That is largely a myth. 18th century press engaged in a good deal of fake news of people not having more than a "pile of salt" to eat. In truth, French peasants, particularly in the countryside, had liberal access to victuals and were, for the mosy part, staunchly monarchist all along. Food shortages were experienced mostly DURING the revolution in Paris, a situation resulting from poor revolutionary administration and not attributed to the style of life of the king and queen.
@@johnubal2825thank you for giving actual FACTS and not just melodramatic hyperbole.
I was delighted and amazed to learn via 23 and Me that I'm related to Marie Antoinette.
Thank you! Loved it. Many parallels with today’s elites
Veri nice Shayari Jabardast video beautiful views full watch big like
Women in history were constantly used as political pawns they had no say or influence in their own fate. She may have been extravagant in her lifestyle but she did try to help. It wouldn't have mattered what she did to be honest she would have still suffered the same fate.
How did she try to help? She gambled away tons of money. She spent and spent for a lavish life with the decorations, outfits, food and items. All of this was funded by France's tax payers. So what attempt did she make to help the people, and not herself and her lifestyle?
@@Crystal11Skulls did u actually watch the voyage jsjsj
@@jackielove1748 Voyage? You mean the documentary? Yes, I did. If you somehow missed her selfish lifestyle, then you obviously did not watch it.
Beautiful castle timelless historical figures lifes.
So yall just stole this video ?
If this is historically correct I find it very interesting.
She caused her own downfall
It was her husband's grandfather who said "After me, chaos". He knew that the Bourbon's mistakes created the whirlwind Louis XVI would reap.
@anthonytroisi6682 if Louis XIV had managr to balance the books in building Versailles, if Louis XV hadn't become stupid as he grew overconfident, and had Louis XVI not funded the American Revolution, all of this would never have come to pass.
Interesting
Too many commercials
VPN ➡️ 🇦🇱
You can pay to get ad free. Stop complaining
She didn't deserve her death
Just found out im related to her and lois the 16th
representatives of the third estate, National Assembly
Now we have Macron 1er.
Hey y'all 😮
She was cute when she was young yute❤❤❤
Who's here because of Luigi?
No one . Luigi is no hero.
Marie and Louis were just scapecgoats for all of the men who were really running the show...the end!
'If they have no bread let them eat Cake 🎂"-Marie Antoinette
“fake news”- donald trump
I learned in college that this is an enduring myth. 🙂 Jean-Jacques Rousseau attributed these words to "a great princess" without ever naming her directly in his book, "Confessions". I have read conflicting accounts about when this book was written (1765? 1767?) but either way, it was written when Marie Antoinette was still a child.
Historians think these words may have been linked to Marie Antionette about 50 years after the French Revolution in attempt turn popular opinion against the extravagant behavior of the upper classes.
@2020davidabc Oh really, there are more? Well thank you - now I want to look up the others! 🙂
She never said it..
It was a saying at least 50 years before she was born
Marie, will you marry me? You can be "head" of household
Sorry dude, but you're about 240 years too late.
ta
Madame La Guillotine: the real MVP!