The current geopolitical landscape surrounding the relationship between Mexico and the United States offers much for Mexicans to reflect on when considering this film and its possible political implications. One common thread between France and the United States is their shared history of neocolonialism and imperialism, which is deeply rooted in Eurocentric ideologies that often align with white supremacist beliefs. These ideologies position the West as superior to the Global South, upholding a paternalistic approach that asserts dominance over it. This mindset is evident in the creation of this film, and it’s one of the primary reasons many Mexicans are upset. For instance, the film tackles a serious issue but does so in a biased way, failing to acknowledge that this problem isn't exclusive to Mexico. It is a shared responsibility among several countries. A key point, such as the fact that over 70% of the weapons fueling violence in Mexico originate from the United States, is conspicuously absent. Mexico has been unfairly vilified by the media for decades, particularly by Hollywood, which has consistently contributed to an anti-Mexican narrative. Numerous Hollywood films, for example, have utilized sepia-yellow filters to portray Mexico as backward, dirty, inferior, and underdeveloped. Almost all films focused on Mexico seem to dwell on its negative aspects, and this movie is no exception. The film’s lack of nuance in portraying Mexico only deepens the anti-Mexican discourse that stems from a Eurocentric, white supremacist perspective. It is particularly troubling that, in a world dominated by white Western powers, these very nations are the ones celebrating and awarding this film, further entrenching negative stereotypes about Mexico. This film is not only offensive but also deeply insulting to Mexico. The criticism stems from multiple facets, including the film's casting decisions. When asked why there were no Mexican actors in a film set in Mexico, the casting director responded by stating they traveled to Mexico but couldn't find any talented actors. Given that Mexico has millions of residents, this claim feels not only discriminatory but also deeply troubling when considering that the film profits from depicting Mexico's pain and suffering.
@ I think labeling it as "a world dominated by Western powers" is a bit to simple. China is the world's #2 power. Russia is probably #3. India is up there as well. China, Russia and India are far more ethnonationalist than the Western world is generally. I think a large part of the perception that Mexico is "underdeveloped" today comes from the mass migration of people from Mexico to the US due to poverty.
Doubling back on this review cause I do feel like a lot of ppl are dogpiling on this film. Thankful to have a channel like FishJelly to give their own genuine perspectives no matter what others might say/think.
The current geopolitical landscape surrounding the relationship between Mexico and the United States offers much for Mexicans to reflect on when considering this film and its possible political implications. One common thread between France and the United States is their shared history of neocolonialism and imperialism, which is deeply rooted in Eurocentric ideologies that often align with white supremacist beliefs. These ideologies position the West as superior to the Global South, upholding a paternalistic approach that asserts dominance over it. This mindset is evident in the creation of this film, and it’s one of the primary reasons many Mexicans are upset. For instance, the film tackles a serious issue but does so in a biased way, failing to acknowledge that this problem isn't exclusive to Mexico. It is a shared responsibility among several countries. A key point, such as the fact that over 70% of the weapons fueling violence in Mexico originate from the United States, is conspicuously absent. Mexico has been unfairly vilified by the media for decades, particularly by Hollywood, which has consistently contributed to an anti-Mexican narrative. Numerous Hollywood films, for example, have utilized sepia-yellow filters to portray Mexico as backward, dirty, inferior, and underdeveloped. Almost all films focused on Mexico seem to dwell on its negative aspects, and this movie is no exception. The film’s lack of nuance in portraying Mexico only deepens the anti-Mexican discourse that stems from a Eurocentric, white supremacist perspective. It is particularly troubling that, in a world dominated by white Western powers, these very nations are the ones celebrating and awarding this film, further entrenching negative stereotypes about Mexico. This film is not only offensive but also deeply insulting to Mexico. The criticism stems from multiple facets, including the film's casting decisions. When asked why there were no Mexican actors in a film set in Mexico, the casting director responded by stating they traveled to Mexico but couldn't find any talented actors. Given that Mexico has millions of residents, this claim feels not only discriminatory but also deeply troubling when considering that the film profits from depicting Mexico's pain and suffering.
You guys have such perfect timing. I’m traveling on the 29th and I’m petrified of flying so this will really help me relax! I know it wasn’t intentional but thank you guys!
The depiction of Mexico isnt bad. As a Mexican i am not mad at it. The acting itself is good. The story is at least interesting, what gets me is having Zoe be Dominican and no very clearly indicate that she is and is now living in Mexico and working there as a lawyer and it isnt dawning on anyone that is what is happening. There are black people in mexico she could have played a true mexican, by getting the accent right , but i feel like this movie did not make the efford to cast any mexicans as the main characters or give the actors the time to sound and feel mexican. Selena is supposed to be a mexican american women that still cannot speak spanish fluently even after living in mexico for years, just give the girl more time to get it right. The lady playing Epifania is the only mexican actress in the cast and she does an amazing job. I think from the mexican audience she is the only that makes sense in this story. Everything else feels fake. Like a soap opera by way France. The other issue i have with it is that the main character is one of the most violent man turn trans women. The trans part is not the issue, the issue is that i am supposed to believe that a men that has inflicted so much violence and death and was probably one creating many of the death and missing of my country has a sudden chance of heart and now wants to help people find their missing death. The story just didnt give me enough to belive the change. Just didnt.
I see what you're saying and I think all of ur criticism is valid. For me, the part of the movie where Rita is convincing the dr to operate on Emilia and perform her sex operation is where the movie tells us the thesis. Rita's argument is: if u help change society then society allows for each individual to grow, and thus causing a domino effect repeating itself. Basically Emilia being able to live the life she never got to live allows her to make choices she would have never thought to take. I guess, I'm more forgiving because to me this movie was supposed to be very theatrical and fantastical, as if it was a fantasy story. My suspension of disbelief really helped me enjoy the movie. Especially being Latino and both of my parents being Mexican I also agree with u that it was very soapy and to me that was very nostalgic and saw it as a cool homage more than a qualm. I do agree they should have casted Mexican actors because Selena's accent was getting to me lol
I came to agree to your last paragraph. But at some point, while watching the movie, something clicked: it's a fantasy, or a fairytale. The movie doesn't need you to believe in a purely causal construction of the characters - just like in one of the last scenes, time inexplicably flows backwards: there is always an element of magic in Audiard's gritty and realistic depiction. The movie, by being partly a musical, demands the viewer to agree to a form of candor or magic. The epiphany (also the name of the woman Emilia dates) that has Emilia doing charity work is for sure stretched. Still, it also participates in the doubt the viewer nourishes towards Emilia: did they really change? what had they become? what are their ulterior motives? can we/should we pardon them? can a clean slate really exist? That is where part of the drama lies. And obviously, some things didn't change, referring to the bitter death of Emilia, while they are raised as a sort of icon, a successful and progressive outcome built on violence... it is problematic and conflictual, and that is what the movie is also about. Additionally, Jacques Audiard's characters tend to be seductive morons. Emilia is one of a kind. Rita is venal. Jessi has been unfaithful... All have their darker sides. You can watch 'a prophet' or 'the beat that my heart skipped' in which you start to root for characters who are morally dubious. But I do agree that if you are looking for an 'authentic' Mexican movie... go watch movies by Mexican directors. Here Mexico is used as a background for a narrative that wants to touch on large, existential questions In the same way, Audiard's 'the sisters brothers' is a disaster and it's hard for cinematographers, no matter their talent, to shoot in culture/language they don't originate from - Wong Kar Wai 'My blueberry night', or Bong Joon Ho 'Okja' being their poorest material are likely not a coincidence.
I very strongly disliked this one but it is legit good to hear a different opinion. I wish more folks who like the film would post reviews cause I'm not even mad, I just want to understand! While this didn't sway me, I respect y'all heavy for your unabashed enjoyment.
I walked into this movie at a film festival with zero idea what it was about - so bizarre - like a transgender musical version of no country for old men. I’m amazed how great of a reception it’s getting because it’s such a huge risk and swing for the filmmakers
It sounds like a really amazing representation of the spectrum of humanity. Someone once said we often misuse the term "humanity" by interpreting it only to mean "good"--which ignores the other aspects of being human.
Is very human watch an ex narco/killer redeeming herself by finding the corpses she killed in the first place. This movie is making fun of the victims of the narco and reinforcing stereotypes, and that's why europeans and americans love it and think is a master piece, they love that, but not, is a portrait of a french who doesn't know anything about México
I just watched this movie and loved it, Zoe was so good, singing, acting, speaking in Spabish. J-lo could never! The only thing is that I wished they would have given Selena’s role to a Mexican actress from Mexico, who actually speaks Spanish.
Saw it last night, it felt like a rich text but I gotta admit I didn’t understand the meaning… is Emilia a metaphor for Mexico? Wish there was more examination of the morality of Emilia getting to start a new life and escape her evil deeds (was there? Maybe I didn’t understand it). The first 30 minutes is phenomenal
I'm a strait dude and I was moved several times by this film; at their core the themes are universal. Even if it wasn't a musical the premise and performances were excellent and would have held up. It's also really cool to see Spanish speaking American actors performing in their native language.
This was a slow to grow on me, I was bored in the beginning then after Emilia’s song explaining herself to Rita, I got goosebumps, and the scene with her daughter saying about missing her papa, 😢 I was then hooked. I have to admit I enjoyed this movie. I give it 4 in half stars ⭐️ too
I saw this film at tiff and I totally love it. All of the elements on paper seem to not work but it does remarkably well. I especially loved Saldana's performance and would love to see her get a Supporting Actress win at the Oscars (even though she and Gascon are co-leads but such is the campaign).
I was blown away by this movie. This is a great review, and I agree with the 4 1/2 star rating, although I would have given it 4 3/4 or even 5 stars. It's refreshing to see a piece of art like this. It really felt like the planets had to align to put together a film this impactful. It's an amalgam of very solid acting, directing, music, choreography, and cinematography. It's incredibly rare and original. By far, the best movie of 2024.
Terrible songs that have no rhythm, lyrics that make no sense, created by chatGPT and poorly translated in Google translator. Topics that in the end lead to nothing. Delicate topics such as drug trafficking and disappearances that are addressed in such a crude, superficial and grotesque way. And the end was a mess, when the people consider Emilia Perez as a saint when she in her past directly or indirectly caused the disappearances and it is not enough to found a non-profit organization, people do not only ask for the location of the remains of their relatives, but justice. Here everything goes unpunished. Do you want me to feel sorry for Emilia? No. She did a lot of damage. This is an insult to a harsh reality of Mexico that is still suffering, drug trafficking is not part of the culture of Mexico, with culture you are proud, I do not think Mexico is proud of that. This film glorifies the drug trafficker even more and minimizes the gender transition in escaping justice, because a repentant person turns himself in to justice.
I think I loved it in part because I'd heard it started out as a libretto for an opera. The music isn't operatic, but the storytelling and characters are ideal for that art form. Complaints about this film -- not fun and therefore not a good musical -- are probably from viewers who never enjoyed an opera in their lives. In any case, I loved the diverse music, loved the acting, dance, and cinematography. And I was floored more than once by the twists of the story. (In fact, I suggest you listen to this spoilerific review AFTER you check it out.)
I love Zoe Saldana, and I'm loving Selena Gomez in Only Murders in the Building! Excited for this one! I've been looking forward to this ever since your pull quote from Joker!
So imagine that a perosn kills your brother and as an apology he tells you where he buried him plus this is a joke to Mexican culture since the director didn't research anything about the culture before making the movie
Hi, mexican here. This movie is bullshit and an insult for us. Is like someone making a musical about 7/11. Would americans accept that? I don't think so.
@@fishjellyfilmreviewsI don’t know. 7/11s are getting pretty nasty in these parts. Can’t believe this got nominated for best picture though , and how Zoe got nominated for best supporting when she’s a main?
@@fishjellyfilmreviewsbut you understood what the comment meant, you wouldn't have liked it a bit, the film is problematic in a lot of ways but the worst is ridiculing a social problem that hurts a lot of mexicans today, and you didn't answer that
Through fear and intimidation a criminal lawyer is "motivated" to get things done...the language is no barrier, to you both too, which is why its well received, that's good!
From the UK; I watched yesterday afternoon - I love this film. I’m not a great modern musical fan but I enjoyed the film from the start. I thought all the main actors were amazing especially Karla Sofia Gascon; I hope she wins more awards. I thought that this was the best role that I have seen Zoe play; dancing and singing - I was very impressed. I will try and watch again in the cinema and on Netflix 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
LOVED LOVED LOVED this film so much! Saw it first alone and then dragged a dozen friends to see it again so I had someone to talk about it with! Also, first time experiencing your channel and love your dry, cool, and witty takes. You guys have great chemistry! You have a new fan in the ReelOut Queer Film Festival. If you're ever in Kingston, ON Canada at the beginning of February, come say hi!
Imagina hacer una película de Canadá, enalteciendo a un político o personaje histórico corrupto de esa nación, mientras cantan con un "Henglish, henglish, so much Bery gud, zorry" con un acento mezclado entre australiano y alemán. 👌😂
One of the reasons I have an issue with organized religion is you have to ignore common sense and critical thinking to be an obedient follower. In Christianity, you must believe in the Trinity, miracles, Jesus getting resurrected, and all other types of magical thinking. That's a perfect setup to be victimized. You're conditioned into ignoring your gut instincts and provable facts. Religious leaders are placed on a very high pedestal and considered anointed by a perfect God so how dare anyone question their intentions and acts? You're supposed to have faith and trust that God will fix things and protect you when you should be acknowledging the power within yourself and notify the cops. I don't mean to offend anyone. I just believe we shouldn't consider anyone or entity as all good and all-knowing. It creates vulnerability, IMHO.
It’s a shame you feel this way. Surrender and submission to God’s love righteousness majesty et al is part and parcel of salvation. That God’s love is to great to imagine/conceive. Yes humans have mucked this up with needs for power and influence of the world. That not what God wants for His children to flourish, for His creation to glorify Him. There’s plenty of witnesses to Jesus’ life, ministry death and resurrection but for you - I wonder what is greater than you than you love? That you’d surrender all of yourself to? That you’d actually acknowledge your spiritual foundation, seek eternal life…
@ I wish I could believe in all that but my critical thinking brain won't allow it. I practice the golden rule because it's the right thing to do. I don't believe in eternal life. Since our time is limited, I feel we should do our best to be decent people for ourselves, others, and those we leave behind. I would love to believe that when we die, we'll reunite with our dead loved ones and rejoice in Heaven. It would be beautiful to be proven wrong. I'll just have to wait and see. Until then, I'll continue doing my best to do more good in this world than harm. If there is a benevolent god(s), goddess(es), He or She will know my heart regardless.
I think this is one of the more non biased reviews of this film. Most other media don't see the lens of film and just pure trans hate and Mexican gatekeeping.
Late to the party but I finally watched the movie. It’s easily one of the best movies I’ve seen this year. The performances and the cinematography blew me away!!
Your review is the reason I watched it. This movie has gotten SO much hate, I decided to watch a couple RUclips critics that I trust and I’m so glad I watched it. It’s a PERFECT film. I throughly enjoyed it and was happy with how the characters ended. Open-minded film buffs should watch it for themselves.
First of all, this not a documentary about Mexico, Trans people, or Drug Cartels. It is an attempt to get to the bottom of the relationship between the human soul and one's external circumstances. When I studied fine art, I learned that the French impressionist artists were considered untalented and not take seriously by either the public or the art community at large. And ... this is a French movie! To me, the whole plot just grabs at the subconscious archetype evil (Mexican drug lord with power) and asks the question whether the evil is a product of the environment or inherent in the soul. To do this, we are presented with a method of attempting to change that. It makes no attempt to be accurate, in fact, it spits in the face of accurate representation much like the impressionist artists did. What it does explore is the challenges of reprinting one's environment and upbringing. Most of the music is more like rap than song (not typical for a musical). It's very surreal. As a trans women myself who began publicly transitioning later in life, I felt emotionally drawn in to the struggle to let go of the past, while all the while it kept haunting me (like running into the lawyer in London, being susceptible to the kind of anger and rage that ruled so much of his life, etc). It was messy, a bit incoherent, like a dream half remembered. To me a bad movie, is one that I turn off after 15 minutes because I'm bored. I felt engaged through the whole 2+ hours of the film. Nothing quite made sense, yet I think this film will stick with me for a while.
I’m finally watching the film. It’s everything's you gentlemen said it was. Thank you! TBH I thought the drug king pin character was hot. Don’t judge me 😊
When I was 12 my mom took me to the LV on Bloor Street in Toronto. I had my fake LV from kislux on my arm and thought I was cute. The sweet sales ladies let me try on a bag and a pair of heels knowing we were not wealthy and couldn't afford to purchase anything. It as really nice. No one seemed to care I had a fake bag and I felt special. They even gave me a paper shopping bag which I used as a lunch bag for weeks after! :) Who cares if people don't have real ones? I'm 30 now and ironically, although I can afford them I still prefer real people with fake bags than fake people with real bags. Just saying :) (not that everyone who carries a real one is bad or vice versa.) Just means I don't care if people carry fakes.
I'm Mexican born and raised and I loved this film, not because of the Mexico references (good or bad) but because It's such a good story, with good music, that pushes the boundaries of musicals and works pretty well thanks to the amazing performances of the actors! ❤
De que hablas wey es malísima, la película no tienen ningún sentido, los diálogos están todos mal hechos y la trama no tiene ni un perro sentido. This film is nothing more than a product of the ignorance of people who do not know violence and will never know it.
@@gatobuho- if you didn't found sense on it, bueno es tu pedo, la pelicula no era para ti, pero eso no quiere decir que la pelicula es mala, la trama si tiene sentido, y no es un retrato perfecto por que no es una pelicula realista, es una historia, y la historia esta bien contada, con buena musica, buena fotografia, etc.
Very original premise and I enjoyed the film. Meandered a bit in the middle but a satisfying end. I wish it dove a bit deeper into how both Manithias and Emilia can both be parts of the same person. And same with Saldana’s character. Both characters were parts of a shady part of society (drug lord obviously way worse than sketchy lawyer), and think they could’ve gone more into how both of the reconcile with their past actions. I mean Emilia suddenly doing good kind of papers over a deeper look into her character. She never has to truly confront the damage and suffering she's caused. But still a good watch, some decent songs, and Saldana was excellent. Apparently there’s a lot of backlash for this film. Unsurprisingly it’s over-exaggerated and even some criticisms even misunderstanding the film entirely
It's a horrible movie with bad acting, terrible script and horrible sound editing. And I'm not even mentioning how they use drug trafficking and the tragedy of disappearances as an accessory.This movie's a piece of crap.
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
The Cats of 2024.
I have heard nothing good about this film and its depiction of Mexico. It’s not even available in that country! What a joke!
Were we watching the same movie?It’s the worst movie of the year. Zoe Saldana is the best part of this mess.
This movie represent how the world see México.not how México really is.sorry for my poor English.
Yes, this film was made for an American audience, not Mexican for sure.
Your English is better than the Emilia Perez actors' Spanish
The current geopolitical landscape surrounding the relationship between Mexico and the United States offers much for Mexicans to reflect on when considering this film and its possible political implications. One common thread between France and the United States is their shared history of neocolonialism and imperialism, which is deeply rooted in Eurocentric ideologies that often align with white supremacist beliefs. These ideologies position the West as superior to the Global South, upholding a paternalistic approach that asserts dominance over it. This mindset is evident in the creation of this film, and it’s one of the primary reasons many Mexicans are upset.
For instance, the film tackles a serious issue but does so in a biased way, failing to acknowledge that this problem isn't exclusive to Mexico. It is a shared responsibility among several countries. A key point, such as the fact that over 70% of the weapons fueling violence in Mexico originate from the United States, is conspicuously absent. Mexico has been unfairly vilified by the media for decades, particularly by Hollywood, which has consistently contributed to an anti-Mexican narrative. Numerous Hollywood films, for example, have utilized sepia-yellow filters to portray Mexico as backward, dirty, inferior, and underdeveloped. Almost all films focused on Mexico seem to dwell on its negative aspects, and this movie is no exception.
The film’s lack of nuance in portraying Mexico only deepens the anti-Mexican discourse that stems from a Eurocentric, white supremacist perspective. It is particularly troubling that, in a world dominated by white Western powers, these very nations are the ones celebrating and awarding this film, further entrenching negative stereotypes about Mexico.
This film is not only offensive but also deeply insulting to Mexico. The criticism stems from multiple facets, including the film's casting decisions. When asked why there were no Mexican actors in a film set in Mexico, the casting director responded by stating they traveled to Mexico but couldn't find any talented actors. Given that Mexico has millions of residents, this claim feels not only discriminatory but also deeply troubling when considering that the film profits from depicting Mexico's pain and suffering.
@ I think labeling it as "a world dominated by Western powers" is a bit to simple. China is the world's #2 power. Russia is probably #3. India is up there as well. China, Russia and India are far more ethnonationalist than the Western world is generally. I think a large part of the perception that Mexico is "underdeveloped" today comes from the mass migration of people from Mexico to the US due to poverty.
Doubling back on this review cause I do feel like a lot of ppl are dogpiling on this film. Thankful to have a channel like FishJelly to give their own genuine perspectives no matter what others might say/think.
The current geopolitical landscape surrounding the relationship between Mexico and the United States offers much for Mexicans to reflect on when considering this film and its possible political implications. One common thread between France and the United States is their shared history of neocolonialism and imperialism, which is deeply rooted in Eurocentric ideologies that often align with white supremacist beliefs. These ideologies position the West as superior to the Global South, upholding a paternalistic approach that asserts dominance over it. This mindset is evident in the creation of this film, and it’s one of the primary reasons many Mexicans are upset.
For instance, the film tackles a serious issue but does so in a biased way, failing to acknowledge that this problem isn't exclusive to Mexico. It is a shared responsibility among several countries. A key point, such as the fact that over 70% of the weapons fueling violence in Mexico originate from the United States, is conspicuously absent. Mexico has been unfairly vilified by the media for decades, particularly by Hollywood, which has consistently contributed to an anti-Mexican narrative. Numerous Hollywood films, for example, have utilized sepia-yellow filters to portray Mexico as backward, dirty, inferior, and underdeveloped. Almost all films focused on Mexico seem to dwell on its negative aspects, and this movie is no exception.
The film’s lack of nuance in portraying Mexico only deepens the anti-Mexican discourse that stems from a Eurocentric, white supremacist perspective. It is particularly troubling that, in a world dominated by white Western powers, these very nations are the ones celebrating and awarding this film, further entrenching negative stereotypes about Mexico.
This film is not only offensive but also deeply insulting to Mexico. The criticism stems from multiple facets, including the film's casting decisions. When asked why there were no Mexican actors in a film set in Mexico, the casting director responded by stating they traveled to Mexico but couldn't find any talented actors. Given that Mexico has millions of residents, this claim feels not only discriminatory but also deeply troubling when considering that the film profits from depicting Mexico's pain and suffering.
You guys have such perfect timing. I’m traveling on the 29th and I’m petrified of flying so this will really help me relax! I know it wasn’t intentional but thank you guys!
Been waiting for this review!
The depiction of Mexico isnt bad. As a Mexican i am not mad at it. The acting itself is good. The story is at least interesting, what gets me is having Zoe be Dominican and no very clearly indicate that she is and is now living in Mexico and working there as a lawyer and it isnt dawning on anyone that is what is happening. There are black people in mexico she could have played a true mexican, by getting the accent right , but i feel like this movie did not make the efford to cast any mexicans as the main characters or give the actors the time to sound and feel mexican. Selena is supposed to be a mexican american women that still cannot speak spanish fluently even after living in mexico for years, just give the girl more time to get it right. The lady playing Epifania is the only mexican actress in the cast and she does an amazing job. I think from the mexican audience she is the only that makes sense in this story. Everything else feels fake. Like a soap opera by way France.
The other issue i have with it is that the main character is one of the most violent man turn trans women. The trans part is not the issue, the issue is that i am supposed to believe that a men that has inflicted so much violence and death and was probably one creating many of the death and missing of my country has a sudden chance of heart and now wants to help people find their missing death. The story just didnt give me enough to belive the change. Just didnt.
I see what you're saying and I think all of ur criticism is valid.
For me, the part of the movie where Rita is convincing the dr to operate on Emilia and perform her sex operation is where the movie tells us the thesis.
Rita's argument is: if u help change society then society allows for each individual to grow, and thus causing a domino effect repeating itself. Basically Emilia being able to live the life she never got to live allows her to make choices she would have never thought to take.
I guess, I'm more forgiving because to me this movie was supposed to be very theatrical and fantastical, as if it was a fantasy story. My suspension of disbelief really helped me enjoy the movie. Especially being Latino and both of my parents being Mexican I also agree with u that it was very soapy and to me that was very nostalgic and saw it as a cool homage more than a qualm.
I do agree they should have casted Mexican actors because Selena's accent was getting to me lol
I came to agree to your last paragraph.
But at some point, while watching the movie, something clicked: it's a fantasy, or a fairytale. The movie doesn't need you to believe in a purely causal construction of the characters - just like in one of the last scenes, time inexplicably flows backwards: there is always an element of magic in Audiard's gritty and realistic depiction.
The movie, by being partly a musical, demands the viewer to agree to a form of candor or magic.
The epiphany (also the name of the woman Emilia dates) that has Emilia doing charity work is for sure stretched. Still, it also participates in the doubt the viewer nourishes towards Emilia: did they really change? what had they become? what are their ulterior motives? can we/should we pardon them? can a clean slate really exist?
That is where part of the drama lies. And obviously, some things didn't change, referring to the bitter death of Emilia, while they are raised as a sort of icon, a successful and progressive outcome built on violence... it is problematic and conflictual, and that is what the movie is also about.
Additionally, Jacques Audiard's characters tend to be seductive morons. Emilia is one of a kind. Rita is venal. Jessi has been unfaithful... All have their darker sides.
You can watch 'a prophet' or 'the beat that my heart skipped' in which you start to root for characters who are morally dubious.
But I do agree that if you are looking for an 'authentic' Mexican movie... go watch movies by Mexican directors.
Here Mexico is used as a background for a narrative that wants to touch on large, existential questions
In the same way, Audiard's 'the sisters brothers' is a disaster and it's hard for cinematographers, no matter their talent, to shoot in culture/language they don't originate from - Wong Kar Wai 'My blueberry night', or Bong Joon Ho 'Okja' being their poorest material are likely not a coincidence.
The director of the film is french
Nothing wrong with Zoe being from DR in MX, yet understand your other observations of the film..
Emilia Pérez es una historia ridícula !!! y es una porquería de 🎞️👎🏽, nada tiene sentido, solo a los ignorantes les gusta está película de💩 .....🤮
The woke disown this movie. The anti-woke hate this movie. I love it!
As a Grace Jones fan...I like the shirt. You should review her documentary that came out. Bloodlight and Bami
What an original plot! I've never heard of anything even close, story wise, sounds like such a gamble and glad it paid off
Are you glad that they have dealt with the victims of disappearances in such a mediocre and simplistic way? THIS IS AN INSULT
@@stalingguzmanzuniga8412 lol
Not a softer side of SEARS!?! 🤣🤣💀 unlocking memories on a tuesday morning haha
I don't get this and feel genuinely bummed out and uneducated. 😂
@@goober1310 Same
I very strongly disliked this one but it is legit good to hear a different opinion. I wish more folks who like the film would post reviews cause I'm not even mad, I just want to understand! While this didn't sway me, I respect y'all heavy for your unabashed enjoyment.
I walked into this movie at a film festival with zero idea what it was about - so bizarre - like a transgender musical version of no country for old men. I’m amazed how great of a reception it’s getting because it’s such a huge risk and swing for the filmmakers
It sounds like a really amazing representation of the spectrum of humanity. Someone once said we often misuse the term "humanity" by interpreting it only to mean "good"--which ignores the other aspects of being human.
Is very human watch an ex narco/killer redeeming herself by finding the corpses she killed in the first place. This movie is making fun of the victims of the narco and reinforcing stereotypes, and that's why europeans and americans love it and think is a master piece, they love that, but not, is a portrait of a french who doesn't know anything about México
Humanity?! Na-r-co!!!??? 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Do you live in Mexico or any part of Latin America? If not, I invite you to find out if these drug traffickers have humanity
Dang. I found this AFTER the Globes. Interesting.
Happy Halloween to you Nick and Joseph! I hope you guys have a fun holiday.
I just watched this movie and loved it, Zoe was so good, singing, acting, speaking in Spabish. J-lo could never! The only thing is that I wished they would have given Selena’s role to a Mexican actress from Mexico, who actually speaks Spanish.
*Again, this is another film I totally would have passed on; but your review is so good! I can't wait to see **#EmiliaPérez**!* 🎬
Isn't it crazy that you have to be not Mexican in order to enjoy this movie about Mexico?
Joseph is literally half Mexican
How many films do the US produce that are based in Italy or France, they use the caricature of a country. This is an artistic interpretation as well.
Saw it last night, it felt like a rich text but I gotta admit I didn’t understand the meaning… is Emilia a metaphor for Mexico? Wish there was more examination of the morality of Emilia getting to start a new life and escape her evil deeds (was there? Maybe I didn’t understand it). The first 30 minutes is phenomenal
I'm a strait dude and I was moved several times by this film; at their core the themes are universal. Even if it wasn't a musical the premise and performances were excellent and would have held up. It's also really cool to see Spanish speaking American actors performing in their native language.
finally saw it, can't wait to watch this video now.
This was a slow to grow on me, I was bored in the beginning then after Emilia’s song explaining herself to Rita, I got goosebumps, and the scene with her daughter saying about missing her papa, 😢 I was then hooked. I have to admit I enjoyed this movie. I give it 4 in half stars ⭐️ too
I saw this film at tiff and I totally love it. All of the elements on paper seem to not work but it does remarkably well. I especially loved Saldana's performance and would love to see her get a Supporting Actress win at the Oscars (even though she and Gascon are co-leads but such is the campaign).
I was blown away by this movie. This is a great review, and I agree with the 4 1/2 star rating, although I would have given it 4 3/4 or even 5 stars. It's refreshing to see a piece of art like this. It really felt like the planets had to align to put together a film this impactful. It's an amalgam of very solid acting, directing, music, choreography, and cinematography. It's incredibly rare and original. By far, the best movie of 2024.
Terrible songs that have no rhythm, lyrics that make no sense, created by chatGPT and poorly translated in Google translator. Topics that in the end lead to nothing. Delicate topics such as drug trafficking and disappearances that are addressed in such a crude, superficial and grotesque way. And the end was a mess, when the people consider Emilia Perez as a saint when she in her past directly or indirectly caused the disappearances and it is not enough to found a non-profit organization, people do not only ask for the location of the remains of their relatives, but justice. Here everything goes unpunished. Do you want me to feel sorry for Emilia? No. She did a lot of damage. This is an insult to a harsh reality of Mexico that is still suffering, drug trafficking is not part of the culture of Mexico, with culture you are proud, I do not think Mexico is proud of that. This film glorifies the drug trafficker even more and minimizes the gender transition in escaping justice, because a repentant person turns himself in to justice.
This film looks interesting. But off topic, Nick's Grace Jones Nightclubbing T-shirt is 🔥! ❤
I stay away from movies like this cause any harsh criticism or any criticism towards it labels you a type of phobic
I think I loved it in part because I'd heard it started out as a libretto for an opera. The music isn't operatic, but the storytelling and characters are ideal for that art form. Complaints about this film -- not fun and therefore not a good musical -- are probably from viewers who never enjoyed an opera in their lives.
In any case, I loved the diverse music, loved the acting, dance, and cinematography. And I was floored more than once by the twists of the story. (In fact, I suggest you listen to this spoilerific review AFTER you check it out.)
I love Zoe Saldana, and I'm loving Selena Gomez in Only Murders in the Building!
Excited for this one! I've been looking forward to this ever since your pull quote from Joker!
So imagine that a perosn kills your brother and as an apology he tells you where he buried him plus this is a joke to Mexican culture since the director didn't research anything about the culture before making the movie
Hi, mexican here.
This movie is bullshit and an insult for us.
Is like someone making a musical about 7/11. Would americans accept that? I don't think so.
I think you mean 9/11.
@@fishjellyfilmreviewsI don’t know. 7/11s are getting pretty nasty in these parts. Can’t believe this got nominated for best picture though , and how Zoe got nominated for best supporting when she’s a main?
@@fishjellyfilmreviewsbut you understood what the comment meant, you wouldn't have liked it a bit, the film is problematic in a lot of ways but the worst is ridiculing a social problem that hurts a lot of mexicans today, and you didn't answer that
Joseph is literally half Mexican
I think a musical centered around Beyoncé’s 7/11 song sounds like a great idea
Thanks for the review. I haven't seen a Jacques Audiard film for a while. Almost forgot about him.
I'm late to the reviews this week, but wow, i can't wait to see this. Usually, musicals can go either way, but this sounds like a winner. Thank you.
Interesting takes.
Thanks for tying up this movie for me!
I found the movie boring as hell. I wanted to love it
Through fear and intimidation a criminal lawyer is "motivated" to get things done...the language is no barrier, to you both too, which is why its well received, that's good!
Okay, after scoring a four and a four and a half I really need to watch!
I'm glad such an important and beautiful film will be streaming for all to see.
Okay 4.5 Stars! I'm even more excited to see it now.
From the UK; I watched yesterday afternoon - I love this film. I’m not a great modern musical fan but I enjoyed the film from the start. I thought all the main actors were amazing especially Karla Sofia Gascon; I hope she wins more awards. I thought that this was the best role that I have seen Zoe play; dancing and singing - I was very impressed. I will try and watch again in the cinema and on Netflix 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
Thank you both!!
I am going to watch this movie on Netflix soon.
Damien Jalet needs more recognition for his choreography, its was mind-blowing in this.
I found the film really engaging. Meaning, I was never bored and I was thoroughly entertained. Continued success!
LOVED LOVED LOVED this film so much! Saw it first alone and then dragged a dozen friends to see it again so I had someone to talk about it with! Also, first time experiencing your channel and love your dry, cool, and witty takes. You guys have great chemistry! You have a new fan in the ReelOut Queer Film Festival. If you're ever in Kingston, ON Canada at the beginning of February, come say hi!
Imagina hacer una película de Canadá, enalteciendo a un político o personaje histórico corrupto de esa nación, mientras cantan con un "Henglish, henglish, so much Bery gud, zorry" con un acento mezclado entre australiano y alemán. 👌😂
This is an insult to all the victims of narco, Americans really don't know what they are talking about
Just walked out of this and I also really enjoyed it
I heard excellent things about it. Won in Cannes and Golden Globes.
One of the reasons I have an issue with organized religion is you have to ignore common sense and critical thinking to be an obedient follower. In Christianity, you must believe in the Trinity, miracles, Jesus getting resurrected, and all other types of magical thinking. That's a perfect setup to be victimized. You're conditioned into ignoring your gut instincts and provable facts. Religious leaders are placed on a very high pedestal and considered anointed by a perfect God so how dare anyone question their intentions and acts? You're supposed to have faith and trust that God will fix things and protect you when you should be acknowledging the power within yourself and notify the cops.
I don't mean to offend anyone. I just believe we shouldn't consider anyone or entity as all good and all-knowing. It creates vulnerability, IMHO.
It’s a shame you feel this way. Surrender and submission to God’s love righteousness majesty et al is part and parcel of salvation. That God’s love is to great to imagine/conceive. Yes humans have mucked this up with needs for power and influence of the world. That not what God wants for His children to flourish, for His creation to glorify Him. There’s plenty of witnesses to Jesus’ life, ministry death and resurrection but for you - I wonder what is greater than you than you love? That you’d surrender all of yourself to? That you’d actually acknowledge your spiritual foundation, seek eternal life…
@ I wish I could believe in all that but my critical thinking brain won't allow it. I practice the golden rule because it's the right thing to do. I don't believe in eternal life. Since our time is limited, I feel we should do our best to be decent people for ourselves, others, and those we leave behind. I would love to believe that when we die, we'll reunite with our dead loved ones and rejoice in Heaven. It would be beautiful to be proven wrong. I'll just have to wait and see. Until then, I'll continue doing my best to do more good in this world than harm. If there is a benevolent god(s), goddess(es), He or She will know my heart regardless.
This film looks like it could be extraordinary, and I can't wait to see it. I haven't been this excited to see a film in a long time!
Great vid
I think this is one of the more non biased reviews of this film. Most other media don't see the lens of film and just pure trans hate and Mexican gatekeeping.
Late to the party but I finally watched the movie. It’s easily one of the best movies I’ve seen this year. The performances and the cinematography blew me away!!
😂 pero si es la peor película 🎞️ del año !!!
Back Here After The Golden Globes. 👏
Your review is the reason I watched it. This movie has gotten SO much hate, I decided to watch a couple RUclips critics that I trust and I’m so glad I watched it. It’s a PERFECT film. I throughly enjoyed it and was happy with how the characters ended. Open-minded film buffs should watch it for themselves.
I also loved this movie. I thought this was the type of cinematic experiment Rainer Werner Fassbinder would be making if he was alive.
First of all, this not a documentary about Mexico, Trans people, or Drug Cartels. It is an attempt to get to the bottom of the relationship between the human soul and one's external circumstances. When I studied fine art, I learned that the French impressionist artists were considered untalented and not take seriously by either the public or the art community at large. And ... this is a French movie! To me, the whole plot just grabs at the subconscious archetype evil (Mexican drug lord with power) and asks the question whether the evil is a product of the environment or inherent in the soul. To do this, we are presented with a method of attempting to change that. It makes no attempt to be accurate, in fact, it spits in the face of accurate representation much like the impressionist artists did. What it does explore is the challenges of reprinting one's environment and upbringing. Most of the music is more like rap than song (not typical for a musical). It's very surreal. As a trans women myself who began publicly transitioning later in life, I felt emotionally drawn in to the struggle to let go of the past, while all the while it kept haunting me (like running into the lawyer in London, being susceptible to the kind of anger and rage that ruled so much of his life, etc). It was messy, a bit incoherent, like a dream half remembered. To me a bad movie, is one that I turn off after 15 minutes because I'm bored. I felt engaged through the whole 2+ hours of the film. Nothing quite made sense, yet I think this film will stick with me for a while.
I’m finally watching the film. It’s everything's you gentlemen said it was. Thank you! TBH I thought the drug king pin character was hot. Don’t judge me 😊
This movie was fantastic. Shame it is not being talked about more.
Fantastica ?!!! mis pelotas !!! 😂
I watched it 2x and it’s really beautiful. I will watch it again🤣
totally one ofthe unforgettable movies of 2024...
Im sorry but this movie was really good... alot of people are gonna hate on it but its different and i watched it twice
This movie was very good. I’d rewatch it!
Just watched, insanely entertaining one of a kind story. I loved it
Before watching I didn't know what it was about I just heard it was a musical I loved 😻
When I was 12 my mom took me to the LV on Bloor Street in Toronto. I had my fake LV from kislux on my arm and thought I was cute. The sweet sales ladies let me try on a bag and a pair of heels knowing we were not wealthy and couldn't afford to purchase anything. It as really nice. No one seemed to care I had a fake bag and I felt special. They even gave me a paper shopping bag which I used as a lunch bag for weeks after! :) Who cares if people don't have real ones? I'm 30 now and ironically, although I can afford them I still prefer real people with fake bags than fake people with real bags. Just saying :) (not that everyone who carries a real one is bad or vice versa.) Just means I don't care if people carry fakes.
I'm Mexican born and raised and I loved this film, not because of the Mexico references (good or bad) but because It's such a good story, with good music, that pushes the boundaries of musicals and works pretty well thanks to the amazing performances of the actors! ❤
Real Mexicans, we hate this 😤 basura...
De que hablas wey es malísima, la película no tienen ningún sentido, los diálogos están todos mal hechos y la trama no tiene ni un perro sentido. This film is nothing more than a product of the ignorance of people who do not know violence and will never know it.
@@gatobuho- if you didn't found sense on it, bueno es tu pedo, la pelicula no era para ti, pero eso no quiere decir que la pelicula es mala, la trama si tiene sentido, y no es un retrato perfecto por que no es una pelicula realista, es una historia, y la historia esta bien contada, con buena musica, buena fotografia, etc.
@@oscarmosh bot deleted 🙄🙄🙄
Very original premise and I enjoyed the film. Meandered a bit in the middle but a satisfying end. I wish it dove a bit deeper into how both Manithias and Emilia can both be parts of the same person. And same with Saldana’s character. Both characters were parts of a shady part of society (drug lord obviously way worse than sketchy lawyer), and think they could’ve gone more into how both of the reconcile with their past actions. I mean Emilia suddenly doing good kind of papers over a deeper look into her character. She never has to truly confront the damage and suffering she's caused. But still a good watch, some decent songs, and Saldana was excellent. Apparently there’s a lot of backlash for this film. Unsurprisingly it’s over-exaggerated and even some criticisms even misunderstanding the film entirely
🎁🫶
gay homosexuals? really??
I loved this film. What a great cast!
Phenomenal movie. I'm so sad I didn't check it out last year lol
It's a horrible movie with bad acting, terrible script and horrible sound editing. And I'm not even mentioning how they use drug trafficking and the tragedy of disappearances as an accessory.This movie's a piece of crap.
Fenomenal mis bolas 😂 !!! la película de Emilia Pérez es una 💩 mal hecha horrible 🤮👎🏽
👍🙏💜💜💜💜💜
I loved this movie 😭
This movie was a pleasant joy to experience. The story, the production, the actors…absolutely marvellous 🫀🖤🫀
Finally, you Guys!!!!!!!