I don't see any justiciable reasoning behind the judgement. If wife gets 5 crore even after misbehavior and being just a non working wife. Imagine how much a working wife would demand. Trust me in the coming years divorce will become a fashion . Talking about whether the amount paid is FAIR. I don't know. But for me it is fearful.
The guy was earning 20 Lacs in a month. Hence 1 crore in 5 months. Factor in inflation. He got off cheap. And honestly this is tu tu mein mein. Don't know whom to believe.
Marriage is business for the judiciary and advocates. The decision of the Atul Subhash is correct. The only way to close this ATM for the mens. Indian Judiciary is punishing only the men/husbands.
Has wife done anything which takes to earn even 1 lakhs per month? Does she know what it takes to earn Rs 5 crores? And the presenter in this video concludes it as Fair and Balanced solution?
Why is the wife given the privilege to stay unemployed? Encourage idle people giving 5cr? Where is equality? SC has not given any list of factors where alimony can be denied? And now this is to be treated as landmark?
Billionaire dollars question is that the wife doing for living during the 20 years...??!!! Wife doesn't fulfilled matrimonial obligations and other hand she also not stud up financially on her feet during 20 years. !!!!!
Not clear what the reasoning is behind such a high payout. Was the husband extremely wealthy and the wife entitled to a standard of living requiring 5 Cr? Was she helpless, dependant and incapable of earning herself? Was she an aggrieved victim? Who is exploiting whom?Each case has its own facts and circumstances and cannot become a law to be followed blindly.
Interim maintenance abtak kitna diya tha husband ne vo to kahe nahi bataya gya kyunki 18 saal ka son ka kharcha unemployed wife ne to uthaya nahi hoga... 10-12 lacs ka income pe 30% tax lagta hai par fir bhi lump sum 6 crore de diya
For how long has he been earning 10-12 lacs pm? How many years of service remain? Which country does he live in and what are his normal living expenses there? Which country does the wife live in and what are the normal living expenses there?
Look for how long he is earning that doesn't matter at all.... I am a citizen of Vadodara and in our principal family court honorable judge told us that don't consider the past and future earnings I'll only decide on the current salary to award maintenance...... So it's pointless to tell that what was the past earnings and what will be the future earnings also.... Also naming the assets the name of your relatives or suppose your mother or father doesn't exempts you from that cycle .... Because 3-4 days ago my senior took out warrant for the husband who haven't paid 1 lakh to his wife ..... 😅😅 So this is the situation in the family courts ... And to be honest according to me the husbands are to be blamed... Because at the time of marriage the only see the good faces of the wife... And all about her body... And at the time of maintenance every husband shouts.... I by myself have seen many of the wives doing the business of maintenance and Alimony and they have married more than 5 to 6 times...... But yes still court doesn't consider this at all because it's the discretion of the judge in the final .... And believe you me most of the times this insane maintenances and Alimony are awarded by male judges only ... 😅😅😅 So kisko blame karogay ?
If the maintenance awarded if 5 cr than the husband must be having 10-15 cr in his total assets ..... And under the law wife can demand upto 1/3rd and 1/2 nd also sometimes...... I always feel sorry for the husbands but the wife is legally entitled for that money and none of the else in the comment section can tell that she is not entitled. Basically jab shaadi karte ho tab to yeh kuchh dekhte nahin Ho sirf ladki ki shakal aur vagaira dekhte Ho but at the time of maintenance everybody starts shouting...😅😅😅 To be honest according to me if the husband is earning 10 per month than wife is entitled for that .... 😊
I don't see any justiciable reasoning behind the judgement. If wife gets 5 crore even after misbehavior and being just a non working wife. Imagine how much a working wife would demand. Trust me in the coming years divorce will become a fashion .
Talking about whether the amount paid is FAIR. I don't know. But for me it is fearful.
The guy was earning 20 Lacs in a month. Hence 1 crore in 5 months. Factor in inflation. He got off cheap. And honestly this is tu tu mein mein. Don't know whom to believe.
@@aritranaruto 10-12L she said that means 6cr is his 6-7years of hardwork. And the court never ask the wife that y she can't or didn't earn?
It's already a fashion of legalised extortion from Men...
@@aritranarutookay let's say he's earning 1cr a month does mean he need pay based on that.
5cr is Too much , what will happen if he lose his job
Marriage is business for the judiciary and advocates. The decision of the Atul Subhash is correct. The only way to close this ATM for the mens. Indian Judiciary is punishing only the men/husbands.
Are we supposed to feel proud of this judgement 😂 wife couldn’t start working for herself in 20 years? This is not 1960s
Marriage has become a business. Most relationships are materialistic. Stay single stay happy.
Sabse badi baat, khoob gyan diya hai is judgement mein, agle case mein 12 crore diya hai, shaadi vyapaar ban gaya hai
Narrator ke face per khusi toh dekho jara 🌝😏.
Didi tumhare bhi Maan mein ladoo foota🤑🤑
Judiciary has lost it. Time for an unimaginable order of transformation.
Has wife done anything which takes to earn even 1 lakhs per month? Does she know what it takes to earn Rs 5 crores? And the presenter in this video concludes it as Fair and Balanced solution?
Alimony and maintenance has become a day light extortion weapons for married women 😢😢😢😢Legalised by indian law😢😢😢
Why is the wife given the privilege to stay unemployed? Encourage idle people giving 5cr? Where is equality? SC has not given any list of factors where alimony can be denied? And now this is to be treated as landmark?
What if the husband changes his gender in the meantime? Can he now file a case against the Wife?
No, gender before conversion is considered
Billionaire dollars question is that the wife doing for living during the 20 years...??!!!
Wife doesn't fulfilled matrimonial obligations and other hand she also not stud up financially on her feet during 20 years. !!!!!
This is legal extortion and the Court has become extortion Adda.
Not clear what the reasoning is behind such a high payout. Was the husband extremely wealthy and the wife entitled to a standard of living requiring 5 Cr? Was she helpless, dependant and incapable of earning herself? Was she an aggrieved victim? Who is exploiting whom?Each case has its own facts and circumstances and cannot become a law to be followed blindly.
What is the basis for which a major child needs to be catered for?
Shame!! Shame!! Shame!!!
law for women
lawda for men
If he gives 5 cr as alimony , what about his oldage, what he can save for his oldage? Starves to death?
Interim maintenance abtak kitna diya tha husband ne vo to kahe nahi bataya gya kyunki 18 saal ka son ka kharcha unemployed wife ne to uthaya nahi hoga...
10-12 lacs ka income pe 30% tax lagta hai par fir bhi lump sum 6 crore de diya
Exceptional judgements tabhi hote hai jab either or both parties have deep pockets, for commoner is there any exceptional judgements?
For how long has he been earning 10-12 lacs pm? How many years of service remain? Which country does he live in and what are his normal living expenses there? Which country does the wife live in and what are the normal living expenses there?
Look for how long he is earning that doesn't matter at all....
I am a citizen of Vadodara and in our principal family court honorable judge told us that don't consider the past and future earnings I'll only decide on the current salary to award maintenance......
So it's pointless to tell that what was the past earnings and what will be the future earnings also....
Also naming the assets the name of your relatives or suppose your mother or father doesn't exempts you from that cycle ....
Because 3-4 days ago my senior took out warrant for the husband who haven't paid 1 lakh to his wife ..... 😅😅
So this is the situation in the family courts ... And to be honest according to me the husbands are to be blamed...
Because at the time of marriage the only see the good faces of the wife... And all about her body...
And at the time of maintenance every husband shouts....
I by myself have seen many of the wives doing the business of maintenance and Alimony and they have married more than 5 to 6 times...... But yes still court doesn't consider this at all because it's the discretion of the judge in the final ....
And believe you me most of the times this insane maintenances and Alimony are awarded by male judges only ... 😅😅😅 So kisko blame karogay ?
FAIR AND BALANCED SOLUTION
If the maintenance awarded if 5 cr than the husband must be having 10-15 cr in his total assets .....
And under the law wife can demand upto 1/3rd and 1/2 nd also sometimes......
I always feel sorry for the husbands but the wife is legally entitled for that money and none of the else in the comment section can tell that she is not entitled.
Basically jab shaadi karte ho tab to yeh kuchh dekhte nahin Ho sirf ladki ki shakal aur vagaira dekhte Ho but at the time of maintenance everybody starts shouting...😅😅😅
To be honest according to me if the husband is earning 10 per month than wife is entitled for that .... 😊
📌📍
जय हो जशोदा मैया आपकी जय हो
😂
😂