(HEATED) Yishai Fleisher Vs Palestinian Activist on “Israeli Occupation”
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 1 янв 2024
- Things are tense but conversations continue. Yishai on the Radical Imagination podcast with host James Vrettos.
More from Yishai Fleisher
Website: yishaifleisher.com
Podcast: israelpodcast.buzzsprout.com
Facebook: / yishaifleisher
Twitter: / yishaifleisher
Instagram: / yishaifleisher
RUclips: / yishaifleishertv 
Развлечения
Jewish people didn’t come in 1948 they were always there!!
lol
Exactly.
Yep. Ottoman Sultan even sent a governor to enforce a law to stop property purchases by Jews in 1914. Maybe the Arab plight started in 48 in their opinion. Different for Jews though
why...doss...Palestinian Activist...sucks..iran.nazis.sharmota.ballz??and..hamash.suck.hizala.poop?
just.like.your,nazi.dumb.ass.mom
They hated it when jews fought back@@Randy-lg1qo
That fellow Barack really needs a history lesson. He admits to us that he doesn't know his history but then he says that Jews came to Israel that was a land full of Palestinian people. Secondly go tell that to my father who was born in Jerusalem in 1926 may he rest his soul
In 1946 the Jewish population of Mandatory Palestine owned only 6-7% of the land and constituted 1/3 of the total population - the surviving non-jewish population and their descendants are now displaced to Gaza and the West Bank, one doesn't disprove the other.
Dude , he knows history better than you , it's truth .
All you have to do is look at the demographic history, to see just how quickly the local population was overwhelmed -> displaced, here is the percentage of the total population which was Jewish;
1800: 2.55
1890: 8
1922: 11
1931: 17
1947: 33
Shame on Barack, he doesn't know the history of his country.
@@unom8 during ottoman rule Jews were heavily restricted form purchasing land in Israel... the Ottomans were known to bring foreign Arab workers from Egypt, Syria and the other surrounding countries who they favored with land ownership given the Muslim connection these families constitute a large percentage of the people who now call themselves "Palestinians"... they still retain family names from these countries like Al-Maghrebi (the north African), Al-Suri (the Syrian), Al-Yemini (the Yemenite), Al-Mitzri ( The Egyptian) . I haven't even mentioned here the fact that around 1000 years ago the Arab Caliphate came and colonized the lands (along with the rest of the middle east) and build al Aqsa on top of the Jewish holy temple site. This is the underlying reason why you even have Muslims living in Israel, they are a result of Arab/Muslim colonialism.... These are facts. history doesn't start in 1948, sorry to burst your bubble.
'Palestinians had nothing to do with Hitler ....' -- not true. Google 'Amin al-Husseini', or the 1936 uprising in Palestine.
FACTS!
I’m surprised and disappointed to hear Barack is so clueless about his history and his belonging. The irony is that Jihadists and nazis don’t discriminate against ur beliefs they kill Jews simply because they are Jews! If people like Batak don’t get thru their head, they might learn it hard way one day! Shame on you Barak!
It's such a stupid argument either way.
100%. Al Husseini LIVED in Berlin 1943 - 1945 and Himmler described him as "appearing gleeful" when he directly observed the gassings at Auschwitz ! ! Was also indicted for War Crimes for his part in recruiting and inciting the 13th Waffen SS Division who committed many atrocities in the Balkans.
All of that was AFTER he had led the pogroms against Jews from 1920 -1939 ! !
Check out :
Record of the conversation of the Grand Mufti with the Foreign Minister in Berlin on November 28, 1941
and : Record of the Conversation Between the Führer and the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem on November 28, 1941, in the Presence of Reich Foreign Minister and Minister Grobba in Berlin
* * * * Documents on German Foreign Policy 1918-45, Series D, Vol. XIII, London, 1964, pp. 881
No connection, my ass !
Let's talk about the "right of return", will the Jews ever have "right of return" to the 899/900th of the Arab occupied Middle East? Not that they ever would be safe there, but would the Arab occupied lands ever be pluralistic and tolerant? I doubt it.
What Arab occupied lands in the Middle-East?????
@@jackmason4320 Look on a map. Do you see the "Arabian Peninsula"? Arabs are from here. Countries such as Saudia Arabia, and United Arab Emirates. These are the historic homelands of Arabs. Starting in the 8th century, however, they conquered the Byztantine Empire and the Sassinids and took control of the entire middle east and north Africa. After 1000+ years of ethnic cleansing, the indigenous people in those regions are mostly exterminated and have replaced by Arabs, other than some notable exceptions such as the Druze, Kurds, Copts, Berbers, and yes the Jews. So yes, anytime you see an Arab country not on the Arabian Peninsula, that is technically Arab occupied lands.
the entire area, Arabs swept out of Medina in 640ce, raping, murdering, enslaving and colonizing and conquering@@jackmason4320
Arabs are from Arabia, of course, Mohammed's 1st war crime was the rape, murder and enslavement of the Jews of Medina... history is amazing@@jackmason4320
google: copts, Druze, Jews, kurds, berbers, Phoenicians to name a few peoples the Arabs occupy their lands@@jackmason4320
From an ex lefty,...thank you Yishai!!🙏🏻🤝🏻May the Almighty Bless you!!🙏🏻🙏🏻
😂 shut up Meg
Who's Meg?🙄@@saracen638
🤣🤣🤣
100% with Yishai. Israel has the title deed to the land.
The reason his grand parents were born in Germany is because his ancestors had to flee at some point in history as other nations massacred the Jews and renamed it to palastine to spite the Jews.
How will Batak live in Israel if he refuses to defend it? The people he wants to give it to are instructed to stop him living.
Greetings with love from Kurdistan!! God protect Israel❤🙏
Wow. This Barack lies as soon as he opens his mouth.
Trojanhorse,if you cant love your own people, you cant love others,is sick and without love.God bless
This is possibly the worst moderator i have ever seen, absolutely infuriating
Isn’t he the worst! Interrupts Yishai, screaming at him, stops him talking only to say “ok now talk!”
@@1DaTJo Yishai is a clown.
completely... painful experience.
@@sagamigawaville why? like actually give a few outlined reasons.
@@sagamigawaville he’s awesome. We love him
Terrible moderator
Moderator should shut up and let the guests speak.
Because someone is able to shout loudly doesn’t mean they are right!
Barak hasn’t lost anything, he’s not part of Am Israel. It’s hilarious that he’s attempting to portray the Arab world as peaceful. Arabs wanted to bring eternal peace? 😂 Oh my goodness, that’s a good one 😂😂😂
All peace comes out of the Middle East 😂
Vanessa...is it possible for you to reflect upon the fact that the mass immigration of Jews into the occupied territories, the aggressions upon a people who were forced from their lands and the continued ethnic cleansing of a region may give rise to some resistance. How can almost an entire people not comprehend what is so clear?
@@richardchurchward4413 is it possible for you to reflect on the suffering millions of other ethnic groups as well? What about the millions of people living under the authoritarian regimes in that region, Iran under ISIS, Afghanistan and the Taliban. Did you watch the day US pulled out of Kabul? 10s of millions of people, that live with little human rights of any kind. It’s funny, people care so little about them but mention the words Israel and Palestine then the whole world has a bleeding heart.
@@christerry1773 sadly your retort does not address the question.
'Don't look here, look there '.
@@richardchurchward4413 weak. such a predictable response.
There were No Palestinian people known by the League of Nations, the United Nations, the Paris Peace Conference, the Bible, the Torah, or the Quran.
There were all different religions, cultures, nationalities, and ethnicities in the land, and most were recent immigrants of the late 1800s, early 1900s.
The Palestinians are a political identity created by the KGB and PLO in 1964. The Palestinians are mostly Arab and Muslim immigrants into the land, the same time Jews returned to the land. The immigration and population records prove this.
Palestinians are; Muslims, Christians, Druze, Samaritans, Bahai, Mandeans, Orthodox, Shiites, Salafis, Sunnis, Syrians, Circassians, Chechins, Bedouins, Fellahins, Bosniaks, Kurds, Turks, Berbers, Slavs, Greeks, Albanians, Arameans, Georgians, Persians, Tartars, Ashiri, Mongols, Sudanese, Armenians, Assyrians, Maronites, Lebanese, Egyptians, Jordanians and more.....
💯🎯💯
Correct the Gaza settlers are economic land squatters😅
Really? ruclips.net/video/_FNtMV2i8-8/видео.html
Haha it was Israeli people colleckit in all this cantrys you spike of. And send to izrael, in experience of Palestinians life and land. Thas a fact.
What did the acronym UNSCOP which decided resolution 181 mean?
A guy like barack does not belong in israel.
And palastinians turned down the peace initiative
1. When was the country of palestine founded, and by whom?
2. What were its borders?
3. What was its capital?
4. What were its major cities?
5. What was the prevalent religion of the “ancient country of palestine?”
6. Name at least one palestinian leader before Arafat.
7. What was the language of the country of palestine?
8. What was the name of its currency?(choose any date in history of a palestinian currency with could be exchanged with another currency)
9 Where the ‘palestinians’ in 1869, when Mark Twain visited the area?
10. The land Judea and Samaria is full of ancient Jewish buildings, tombs,
found artefacts, scrolls, all in hebrew. (been there seen them)
11. Where are historic palestinian scriptures, documentations or scrolls?
12. Where are the historical palestinion buildings, tombs?
13. Name at least one of historic palestian libraries with documentated palestinian literature
You Zionists trying to deny Palestinians existence is disgusting. And it's the reason antisemitism is on the rise around the world. You are plain evil. No other explanation.
Palestinians speak Arabic, and the Arabic language does not have The P sound with a Capital P, so why the hell they named that land Palestine? Doesn't make sense
@@pabloemilioescobargaviria9914 135 years after Christ, Hadrian gave them the Name palestine, because of hatred,the Philister was a enemy of the jews in the past. (Philister came from greek, they have nothing to Do with the arab from today)God bless
@@pabloemilioescobargaviria9914 Filistin is the arabic name it has had for 3 millenia and still does. Palestine is the english name.
@lbs7774 there's no such word palestines, much less fillistines, don't try spouting BS from your ass
Why doesn’t anyone bring up 1920 when the league of nation (the world) voted on the boarders of the mandate of Palestine the Jewish national home…knows as Israel and Jordan today….80% of the Jewish national home was give to Jordan in 1922…..
the Jewish National Home was to be founded in Palestine and not that Palestine as a whole was to be converted into a Jewish National Home.
No the borders of the mandate where not the boarders of the Jewish National home.
The Committee noted that the construction, which restricted considerably the scope of the National Home, was made prior to the confirmation of the Mandate by the Council of the League of Nations and was formally accepted at the time by the Executive of the Zionist Organization
My mother was born on a small farm in Germany. I'm thinking of going back to claim it.
I'm sure nobody will kick you out of Germany of want to unalive all Germans if you did 😢
So half your ethnic group was killed and your hated everywhere you go? Makes sense
He doesn't believe in god? That's nice. Does he believe in history? Archaeology?
Do YOU believe in self-determination of people living in Israel/Palestine?
That’s a false equivalency
@@lucabriatore7891 Palestine is not a thing and never was.
self determination of jewish people exists for sure, enrooted deep in everything both of most ancient and most modern history
@@kkk-yj8re self determination for people who calls themselves Palestinians exists as well. It's a human right, for all humans, even those without a past. The right of self determination is based on where people live since some generations. Actually, Israel's right to self-determination depends on its 80 years of history. Not on the history of ancient Jews, which the Israelis share with the Palestinians whose ancestors converted to christianity or Islam...
Anyway, dude, could you explain us your triple k nickname?
@@lucabriatore7891 yes, but falsestine is shallow fairy tale for weak minded westerners
Such an idealist, he started by stating he is not a historian but yet he starts narrating “history”. He wants to live in Israel (deep connection) and yet sadly his “friends” don’t want him to. Barak needs to wake up if he wants Israel to survive. Things may need to be rethought. But not Baraks way.
who TF is he?
Exactly! His "facts" are lies.
ruclips.net/video/_FNtMV2i8-8/видео.html
Barak is treif, he's a nobody and doesn't even read or follow Torah. Their were Yemeni and Morrocan Jews before the gazan nomadic group straggled into. Barak is a shame to my fellow Torah observant Jews.
Barak is stupid, he was not raised to know Torah and doesn't know the history of my fellow Jews.
Barak's ignorant and anemic thoughts are BS
HE'S EMBARRASSING AS A JEWISH MAN.
@@mworldxyz5631 He is not lying. The religious narrative is mythical thinking not fact.
"im not an historian"
then proceeds to present revisionist history
EXACTLY 👏🏼🎯🎯🎯
ruclips.net/video/_FNtMV2i8-8/видео.html
he is always contradicting himself
The only revisionist history here is the Zionist nationalist history.
I stopped listening to him as soon as he said "the Jewish people came here in 1948 and established a country"...WTF??? The Jewish people had a country there for over 3000 years.
Barak thinks the Jews "stole" Palestinian land.
Yet he lives in Jaffa, which, historically, is an arab town
more accurately Jaffa and Haifa were mixed. In Haifa the Arab gangs were fighting each other.
he is a true occupier and should self deport back to germany
Arab because they ethnically cleansed it of jews.
As a Protestant-raised mother who converted to Judasim in 1987, bore 2 sons, Abraham & Herschel, I feel a strong connection to a religious Jewish life related to Eretz Israel. Don't distrespect faith.
Really? ruclips.net/video/_FNtMV2i8-8/видео.html
I respect you but I don't think you, being a Jew, have the right to occupy the West bank, to displace Palestinians who live there since centuries and bulldoze their house. What would you think if somebody claim the right to displace you from your homeland because you're not protestant any more? That's the topic, in case you did'nt realize it....
You are demonstrating that you do not respect the fact that Jews have lived exactly in the locations you name for thousands of years, with archeological proof. Islam, ever since its origin in the year 628 (not BC) has been an imperialistic entity. In 1882, when Jews bought land from the Ottoman Turkish landlords, there was not much agriculture or economic activity going on, because drip irrigation had not been invented. The land did not have enough water and was dominated variously by the Jordanians, British and by the Ottomans. The Turkish land owners were tired of paying the taxes to the Ottoman caliph for land that was so unproductive. So they sold it to the Jews for their little villages and kibbutzim. Many Arab workers got wages from these agricultural enterprises in the early years of the 20th century. Then, many Arabs came to work for the British from 1917-1947. They came from Egypt, Jordan (the country Samaria and Judea were formerly inside of) For centuries, Arabs followed the years of rain and left in years of drought traveling north to Lebanon and south to Eygyt. There were a lot of very poor people, renting from rich Arab landlords. The British, knowing they wanted Arab oil, were quite obsequious to the Arabs, and the Arabs realized they needed Western engineering to pump the oil out of the earth. Prior to the British Mandate, the Ottomans banned Jews, made them leave Jerusalem and other very Jewish areas, basically at their whim. I knew a daughter in a Jewish family who were uprooted from their home in Jerusalem in 1914 and starved in Constantinople during WW1. Did you know that Nazareth and Bethlehem were majority Christian towns since early Christianity, and only with Arab control of Bethlehem have so many Christians been killed, forced out, such that Christians are no longer a majority. You may say, well, there are lots of Christians all over the world. Guess what there are lots of Muslims all over the world. No one is trying to wipe them off the face of the Earth. @@lucabriatore7891
@@UteHeggenTranswidowHeals I respect people and individuals, not biased facts that you only can find on Zionist documents whose goal Is not knowing history but building a false and dishonest Zionist narration, made up for justifying what can't be justified. There's no reason, anywhere, anytime, to claim that ancient ruins give to anybody the right of occupying a land. Based on your logic, the Greek could occupy southern Italy, since it's full of Greek ruins. No Greek nationalist ever said that, because it's absolutely absurd, but when it comes to israelis, you know...
People you call Jordanians were the Palestinians. People you call "poor people renting from Arab landlords" were Palestinians. Palestine has never been empty. Moreover you pretend to ignore that Palestinians are the descendants of ancient jews, more than most today's European Jews. You know! You're not the only one who converted to another religion. The inhabitants of Betlehem and Nazareth were Christians because they had abandoned the Jewish religion for christianity. Then, many of them became muslims. If you don't believe me, ask to a random Christian living in Betlehem. He will tell you he's a Palestinian, and he wants Israel out of the West bank. Rightfully.
Do you really think that YOU, as a converted Jew, have more rights on Judea and Samaria, than a muslim or christian Palestinian whose ancestors are buried there?
Don't commit genocide.
In August 1977 Zahir Muhsein, a member of the Executive Committee of the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) and a military commander of the PLO, in an interview with the Dutch newspaper, TROUW, declared the Palestinian people to be a propaganda invention. His exact words were:
*“The Palestinian people does not exist.* The creation of a Palestinian state is only a means for continuing our struggle against the state of Israel for our Arab unity. *In reality today there is no difference between Jordanians, Palestinians, Syrians and Lebanese.* Only for political and tactical reasons do we speak today about the existence of a Palestinian people, since Arab national interests demand that we posit the existence of a distinct ‘Palestinian people’ to oppose Zionism.
He missed an important group. It should have said... "In reality today there is no difference between Jordanians, Palestinians, Syrians, Lebanese and JEWS!"
Now with that said, are you stupid enough to be implying that there were NO "Palestinians" inhabiting that region when the Zionist terrorists arrived? Just because of what someone said? I'd be willing to bet that you left out a buttload of context.
Oh wait... let's see... Mohsen was pro-Syrian and his statements contravened those of the PLO. Mohsen also founded As-Saiqa, a Palestinian Ba'athist political and military faction created and controlled by Syria. Robert Fisk claimed that As-Saiqa, under Mohsen, employed its energies against the PLO, stating that in June 1976 he saw "the PLO in open combat within West Beirut against As-Saiqa, who had attacked Arafat's forces on orders from Damascus."... Hmmmm interesting that you left all that out.
You idiots just love to attempt to, simply, erase a population of people, who had been living in the region for thousands of years, with dumbass comments like "Ummmm... Palestinians don't exist... they are like fairys, leprechauns and unicorns. Doy doy doy." The NAME doesn't f**ing matter. I bet you believe giants once walked the earth, though, and that the election was stolen, the J6 attack was a tourist walkthrough of the Capitol and the Covid vax gives you man-boobs! Ugh I digress... I am surrounded by idiots.
How sad to only exist to oppose Jews ! Maybe that’s the reason Hamas easily took over Gaza from the Palestinians when the Palestinians could have Strength through Peace and Education !!
Just do a DNA test that will solve everything😂 this is what people don't talk about
@@dseason7216 Zionism and Judaism is not the same thing. Self-determination and territory are the issue
You are denying many facts documented in history. I suggest you read Illan Pape. You're basing your beliefs about 75 years of oppressed people on an interview? Come on!
There's a gazan occupation of the Jewish land by the gazans who were given Jewish land, fellow Jews were literally thrown out of their homes for the gazans to occupy.
Nop 😂
Yes
@@sarahhumphreys3980 nop
WTF I literally watched a documentry where the jews are arriving my ships and being welcomed by palestinians 😂
From the river to the sea
Man why does this moderator keep interrupting everything? It's so hard to keep focused on the back and forth.
He's the absolute worst. And in my opinion...he's biased. The time he's allotting to each is very imbalanced.
The Palestinian activist barely got a chance to talk
@@sammytek300 😂🤣😂
@@sammytek300thank goodness for that. Everything that came out of his mouth was gibberish.
Barak . I used to be on your side and was naive, as i was listening to the voice in my heart thinking exactly the way you presenting your view ,I was a western thinker in euphoria of live and let live till I dare to read the charter of the PLO and the Hamas I was naive to think that we can live in harmony and peace, I still have hopes but I dare you to read it too and realize in what part of the world we living in.... Wake up my brother the other side doesn't think off you as you think of them...
He's a delusional naive spineless waste of space.. Just look at him.
You are mistaken. I think Barak's views are the right views. They represent the hope for peace and prosperity.
@@mot9769and they also represent the end of Israel
@@dbucher115 The exact opposite is true.
@@mot9769 a very naive hopes
YISHAI MAKING SENSE OF THE REGIONAL PROBLEM
AND THE ILLOGICAL LEFTIES WHO DONT UNDERSTAND THE
VIOLENT DEPTHS OF HAMAS IRAN AND THEIR BUDDIES
THANK YOU YISHAI
❤ TO ISRAEL FROM AUSTRALIA
Victoria .are you willfully blind to the aggressions of the pre-1948 Jewish militia and the modern day IDF?
Free Palestine from Australia.
It's not just the torah that states the land of israel is the Jewish homeland but states it over and over in the Quran
It is estimated that the phrase "Children of Israel" appears approximately 220 times in the Quran.
1. **Surah Al-Baqarah (2:47)**: This verse acknowledges the special favours bestowed by God upon the Children of Israel.
2. **Surah Al-Isra (17:104)**: This verse states that God said to the Children of Israel that He would gather them together. Some interpret this as a reference to the Jewish return to the Holy Land.
3. **Surah Al-Ma'idah (5:20-21)**: This passage recounts the story of Moses speaking to his people about the holy land God has assigned to them.
The Quran contains several verses that mention the Children of Israel, a term often associated with the Jewish people, and their connection to the land historically known as Israel. These verses are primarily historical and religious in nature, rather than political. Here are some key references:
1. **Surah Al-Baqarah (2:58-59)**: These verses recount the story of the Children of Israel being granted entry into a city, which some scholars interpret as a reference to a city in the Holy Land.
2. **Surah Al-Baqarah (2:83)**: This verse is part of a covenant made with the Children of Israel. While it doesn't specifically mention the land, it's part of the broader narrative involving their history.
3. **Surah Al-A'raf (7:137)**: This verse speaks about the Children of Israel inheriting lands in the east and the west, which some interpret as a reference to the Promised Land.
4. **Surah Yunus (10:93)**: This verse mentions the settlement of the Children of Israel in a dignified place and provided them with good things.
5. **Surah Taha (20:80)**: Here, the Children of Israel are reminded of God’s favors upon them, including their deliverance from the Pharaoh's people.
6. **Surah Al-Isra (17:2-8)**: These verses recount the story of the Children of Israel and mention the destruction and restoration of Jerusalem. The term "the land" is often interpreted by scholars as a reference to the land of Israel.
7. **Surah Al-Dukhan (44:30-32)**: These verses again recount the deliverance of the Children of Israel from the Pharaoh and mention them as the chosen people.
The Quran mentions the Children of Israel in various contexts, including narratives that involve their presence in a land that many scholars interpret as the historical region of Israel.
Key points from the Quran regarding the Children of Israel and the land include:
- **Historical Narratives**: The Quran recounts stories of the prophets and the Children of Israel, often in a context that suggests a connection to the land historically known as Israel or Canaan.
- **Spiritual Significance**: The land is portrayed as significant in the spiritual narratives of the Quran, such as the stories of Prophets Moses and David.
The term "Palestine" does not appear in the Quran. The Quran, written in the 7th century, does not directly name modern geopolitical regions
However, the Quran does include references to the "Holy Land" (Arabic: الأرض المقدسة, Al-Ard Al-Muqaddasa), often in relation to the stories of the Prophets and the Children of Israel.
If "Palestinians" want to make up a history. Then maybe protest for them to change it in the Quran first...
If humanity is to get to peace, then the follow needs to be changed in the Quran:
"Fight them until persecution is no more and religion is all for Allah."
This verse is mentioned to argue that Jihad in Islam is not only defensive but also aims to establish religion solely for Allah.
Quran Chapter 8, Verse 55:
Islamic views on non-believers.
Discussed in the context of the perception of non-believers in Islam.
Quran Chapter 5, Verse 82:
Quran Chapter 9, Verse 5:
"Kill them wherever you find them."
Referred to in the context of Islamic teachings on warfare against non-Muslims.
Q8:60 advises Muslims “to strike terror into (the hearts of) the enemies of Allah and your enemie
Spiritual and moral jihad is generally emphasized in pious and mystical circles. The Hans Wehr Dictionary of Modern Written Arabic defines the term as "fight, battle; jihad, holy war (against the infidels, as a religious duty)."
There are a lot more quotes about how non-believers need to be oppressed. I suggest anyone who wants to understand it, they should look it up and not ask a Muslim what it says becuase its permissible for Muslims to lie to infidels in the Quran...
Mark Twain went to Palestine and made the following remarks: “Palestine is a waste land, only the imagination can grace this barren land with the pomp of circumstance of life. We travel a whole day in the Galilee, we didn’t see a human being”.
Of all the lands there are for dismal scenery, I think Palestine must be the Prince. Renowned Jerusalem itself, the stateliest name of history, has lost its grandeur, and is become a pauper village, the riches of Solomon are no longer there to compel the admiration of visiting Oriental Queens; the wonderful pride of which was the pride and the glory of Israel, is gone…Palestine is desolate and unlovely. And why should it be otherwise?....Palestine is no more of this work-day world. It is sacred to poetry and tradition - it is a dream land (Innocents abroad, Chapter 56)
“Palestine”, Twain avowed, “sits in sackcloth and ashes”. And Jerusalem, “the stateliest name in history” was in reality a small village, so small I could cicle it - all “rags wretchedness, poverty and dirt” in an hour. That storied city, he concluded, was, “mournful and dreary and lifeless” and for the life of him, he would not choose to live there.
I am now paraphrasing, and not quoting Twain verbatim. The only place where I saw people was on the coast. There were Jewish settlements, Jewish people making a living from the land, fishing and so on...............
Most excellent post, thank you for posting it.
So true there was no one there
Travel around Jordan and you’ll see it too. Just miles of nothingness.
Travel arround Texas. Also barren land. You can relocate Israel to Texas.
Except your "Allah" promise the land of Israel to the Jews. @@jimmychoo9808
The Ottomans had nothing called Palestine for the 400 years of rule, the land was divided into 3 to 5 Sanjaks (provinces), none called Palestine. The Ottoman Land Registry of to 1858 to 1872 showed that 13% of the land was privately owned.
The British Land Survey of 1945 showed that Palestinian farmers only owned 3.3% of the land. The wealthy absentee Arab land holders (living in Damascus, Cairo, Allepo and other cities) owned 16.5% of the land. The Jews owned 8.6% of the land. And, 70% of the land was State Land, transferred from the Ottomans, to the British, and then to Israel. Israel was was created by almost 80% of non-Arab owned lands!!
Useful and enlightening information! Thank you!!
@@jalemairliha Thanks, am full of such information!!
Do you have a citation for this?
@@arijoseph2282 Nope.
Laughing at your crap
From 1948 to 1967, Jordan controlled Judea and Samaria. Egypt controlled Gaza until 1973.
Has anyone heard of Palestinians or protests about the creation of a Palestinian state.
There has never been a Palestinian people in the history of mankind.
I liked the beginning ("I'm not the historian"), in other words- I haven't bothered to study the subject I'm talking about and I have strong opinions, but I will rely on incorrect historical facts to make my claims. When the facts I rely on turn out to be incorrect, I will turn to emotion, and go into victim mode. Unfortunately, there are several tens of thousands of such Jews in Israel, and the media will find them one by one to present as if there are opposing views among the millions of Jews.
Are you a historian then?
Attack the argument.@@winterishere9828
You open a map of the Middle East and you see Arab countries with a huge area on the continent of Asia and Africa and suddenly you put on glasses and find a small dot on the map. This is the Land of Israel. According to the twisted morality of the nations of the world, this small country that historically and factually belongs to the Jews should donate more territories to the Arabs because 21 countries spanning two continents is not enough for the Arabs. Wonder of wonders.
@indigo2009 Yes for a tiny democracy surrounded by Islamic hatred it’s quite incredible that so much hatred is extended globally to their very existence.
The land Belongs to Israel 🇮🇱
YouClown 🤡
Doesn't make sense hey that their is 22 Arabs states around Israel, almost like that sounds like maybe they shouldn't be there, why would there be a Jewish state squat in the middle east,
In 1946 the Jewish population of Mandatory Palestine owned only 6-7% of the land and constituted 1/3 of the total population - the surviving non-jewish population and their descendants are now displaced to Gaza and the West Bank, arguably they were attacked first.
Scant comfort for the Arabs who were expelled during the Nakba and continue to be ethnically cleansed today. The relevance of the size of Israel compared to surrounding states does NOTHING to address the project of ethnically cleansing being carried out to this day.
Perhaps you can explain at what square kilometrage morality kicks in.
Barack is like a turkey asking for an early Christmas.
This Palestinian activist must to educate himself. He should know that the Jews lived in this land for thousands of years.
Yishai, this is such a public service!
My big question is how barak expects to get the hostages back from hamas. In the beginning he glosses over saying that israel will get the hostages back, except why would hamas just hand them over? In what fairy tale does he live in?
If Hamas (IN GAZA) had not attacked the neighboring cities in Israel, NO ONE in Gaza would've died. The IDF and Israeli army provided notice and showed MUCH grace to gazans so that they could get out of the area, prior to bombing and raiding. The Israeli army has not done war crimes. On the contrary, they have bent over backwards to avoid killing innocent people. Mr Fleisher's commentary is a very accurate representation of facts
And you won’t hear anything about Palestinian people.
Operation protective edge operation cast lead anyone??
you must be kidding right?
kidding about what?
@@nikmenere8456
Barak represents a very small minority in Israel (he admits so himself) and it is a gross misunderstanding to put him to debate Ishai like these are two divergent view points in Israel. It is like putting Osama Ben Ladin to debate Barak Obama to show two different points of view. It is ludicrous.
What a shame he is part of the minority as at least his viewpoint isn’t based on claims from the bible and the situation 2000-3000 years ago. Barak seems to have a reasonable view of the situation that acknowledges the fact that all humans are (or should be) equal
Right, but I hope you realize that here Barack plays the role of Obama. Bin Laden, this time, is the majority...
Barak Obama and Osama Bin Laden don't disagree much about America
@@choyayahyah really....
There is nothing left for debate here. The Jewish people came there, expelled and killed the people, they created a religious national state on someone else's land, which has been doing terrible things to the Palestinians for 75 years, well they bomb Leabanon and Siriya on regular base. And for some reason we are still thinking whether it should be stopped, whether killing is justified, whether killing 100 Palestinian children a day is a "proportionate response". Imagine that the world thought about the Jews the way it thinks about the Palestinians, imagine that my ancestors said in 1945, so wait and see if Adolf responded proportionately, so that's not our business, why should we care, it's bad, but maybe the Germans have no other choice , they also have the right to self-defense when the Jews have already taken their money. All that the Palestinians are going through now, the Jews have survived and that makes this situation particularly disgusting, of course the Crusaders, the Nazis, the Europeans chased the Jews for centuries and the only ones who ever came to their aid and saved them were the Arabs and Muslims they are killing now.
The contradiction throughout Edom is astounding: anaemic is an appropriate word (narrow-minded, limited, are other simple descriptions that come to mind); attachment to the Land of Israel without acknowledgment of the history or faith? ; the friction is ideological, political and spiritual; the friction is, like I may borrow from Yishai himself, the friction is colonial vs indigenous. This is not a 1948 argument. This is a 586BC argument to a 70AD-135CE, and these dates belong to the Israelites. Judea belongs to Eretz Israel. Judea and the Yehudi does not belong to Edom. What is the difference between the Oslo Accord 1993 and 135CE? Nothing. Both events are taunts to the spiritual essence of the Israelites.
👏👏👏 brilliant
Since when are modern nation states determined by spiritual essence? I thought Israel is a democracy not a theocracy.
Entry into force: 3 January 1976, 7-days to the day after my birth on Shabbas, legally-ratified from General Assembly resolution 2200A ICESCR 16 December 1966, Art. 1. All peoples have the right of self-determination. By virtue of that right they freely determine their political status and freely pursue their economic, social and cultural development. By implication and previous Declaration, these rights are 'inalienable'.@@sabinereynaudsf
Under Roman Statute Law, Israel is a Democracy. Under G-d's Law, as it is written in Torah, the Covenant with Yakov Israel accompanied by the survival of the Tribe of Judah has always afforded Israel the option of declaring itself a Theocracy and/or a Monarchy. After all, where does the British Crown receiveth its blessing and anointing oil? Is not England a territory at least in part determined by its spiritual essence - namely, The Church of England?@@sabinereynaudsf
@@sabinereynaudsf I can appreciate what he says about spiritual essence and history even while I'm not religious.
The position I emphasize, though some Zionists might disagree with that emphasis, is that Jewish migrants coming to (or coming back to) this Ottoman and post-Ottoman region of Palestine PURCHASED LAND from whoever were the owners of said land.
Jews paid Turks.
Jews paid Arab landowners. (Al-Husseini tried to put a stop to selling land to Jews under threats of torture & death, except for when he sold land to Jews.)
Jews surely paid some existing Jews who owned land.
Jews bought empty land 10 km from Jaffa to create Tel Aviv.
Jews settled on some un-owned land that nobody wanted because it was swamps or deserts that required _hard work_ and modern technology to make it usable and liveable.
When Jews owned land, but Arabs wanted Islamic rules to trump property rights, and Arabs refused to accept multicultural coexistence with a growing Jewish population, Jews petitioned for TWO states, one for Jews, one for Arabs.
Needless to say, Arabs rejected that too.
“ So then leave already” 😂.
God bless you Yishai Fleisher
There is no question that Yishai Fleisher came out on top in this debate.
He did. Barak should have been more hoonest and say not all western imperialism is bad.
He wiped the floor with him. He made points that I haven’t heard before. He’s right, let’s stop brining western ideas/policies of government to a place that rejects it. We don’t speak the same language. This is Middle East speech. This isn’t US speech.
@@tiffanyh1274 Israel wouldn't exist without US-Jews and US Christian Zionists. Better not forget that!
Meh, I'd wipe the floor with Yishai, his history is missing so much context it is ridiculous. He is certainly no historian and, merely, parrots Zionist propaganda talking points. Goebbels would be proud of the Zionists, they really know how to push, push and push a lie!
I don't think he would against this guy - or that he would even dare to try: Really? ruclips.net/video/_FNtMV2i8-8/видео.html
As one father said, " thanks, Israel and the western media for showing the world who you are and what you do"
Really? ruclips.net/video/_FNtMV2i8-8/видео.html
Yes, a strong nation that will not lie down and die, and make no apologies for defending themselves from those who want to destroy it. When this is over and they've won yet again, they will no doubt still have enemies, but those enemies will think twice about messing with them again.
Some quotes of the Zionist global mafia. They "identify" as "Jews".
“We Jews regard our race as superior to all humanity, and look forward, not to its ultimate union with other races, but to its triumph over them.” (Goldwin Smith, Jewish Professor of Modern History at Oxford University, October, 1981)
"Israel won the war [WW I]; we made it; we thrived on it; we profited from it. It was our supreme revenge on Christianity." - The Jewish Ambassador from Austria to London, Count Mensdorf, 1918.
"Our race (speaking of the Jews) is the Master Race. We are divine gods on this planet. We are as different from the inferior races as they are from insects. In fact, compared to our race, other races are beasts and animals, cattle at best. Other races are considered as human excrement. Our destiny is to rule over the inferior races. Our earthly kingdom will be ruled by our leader with a rod of iron. The masses will lick our feet and serve us as our slaves." - Menachem Begin. (Israeli Prime Minister Menachem Begin in a speech to the Knesset [Israeli Parlament], quoted by Amnon Kapeliouk, from "Begin and the Beasts," New Statesman, June 25, 1982)
@@KathyPrendergast-cu5ciyes, and they will be rightfully convicted from the International Court of Justice.
@@KathyPrendergast-cu5ci. Well said. Israel is fighting a racist backward tribal cult which sadly is supported by the UN
Have there not been Jews all the time, also before 1948?.
Next time get rid of the moderator
Absolute mess and doesn’t know what they are doing
20:26 "two MILLION" is hamas figures.
It took almost a month for Israel in order to determine how many Israelis were murdered.
That's is the example of being ignorant there was jewish presence in eretz Ysrael eventhough in small number since the 1800s. There was not Palestinian people, was arabs and jews .I will like to ask Barak if he wants to invite the so called Palestine that voted for hamas to live side by side with him to see what happens. Is pitiful how some of our brothers still think that way
Such people are biggest enemy of his own brothers,more then enemy from outside,that is sick.God bless
He doesn’t want to see Hebron because he is afraid it will expose his false beliefs.
ruclips.net/video/_FNtMV2i8-8/видео.html
He goes in the west bank to demonstrate the illegal occupation. It's a way to respect the Palestinians, who are the legitimate owners of that land.
The rigidity of your thinking cannot allow you to see that people of conscience have an empathetic view if the plight of the dispossessed.
The oppressor will never be able to observe their amorality impartially.
It is amazing that despite (or in his case, in spite of ) the attack by Jew haters, Barack still keeps the same ‘vision’ . So sad that mental blindness is incurable. Good show, Yishai. I admire your patience.
The Palestinian activist, is right when he says, that he knows nothing about history. The Hamas are Muslim Brotherhood, which are directly connected to Hitler and Nazis. They wanted establish extermination camps in Palestine.
Palestine was part of the Ottoman Empire, where the majority of people were poor, existence level. A few rich people owned the land. Farmers who owned land were in great dept. Jews bought land, not stole it. There are approx. 4000 years of Jewish history. Archeology are finding continuously more evidence of this history. In contrast there is nothing of any Palestinian culture.
Yishai you are amazing m.
Yishai you are on point on every level, liberals/leftists/socialists are beyond naive.
The tragedy is that these morons have the backing of the UN.
I wish it was naïvety that drives the likes of Barack …. Naiveté can be educated…..
unfortunately the leftist mind is simply diseased , similar to the mind of a rabid killer…….
Sadly ,Barak has the motion picture tool in his hand and that can cause a lot of damage.
“We have a regional way of doing things “is weak ,very weak.
Barak does not know his history. The best thing he should do is read his history
This moderator needs tu shut up more and let the guests speak.
I have to disagree with you about the 3000 year connection as my Hebrew connection is way older and goes to the patriarchs of Abraham Aber and why stop at 2000 years as the greatest Jewish figures in the past thousand years lived in the land of Israel and surrounding region consistently uninterrupted, and I think these points should be brought up more often
So you want to murder Jewish people?
Abraham was a sojourner in the land. He only owned the burial site for Sarah. Israel formally entered the land under Joshua and solidified it under David.
Hi Yosaif. I don't want to dispute those facts. But where exactly does that land us in 2024. What is the morality of seizing power and land from an people who also have indigeneity to the disputed lands.
I celebrate my Irish history in a way which is personal and enriching. We ALL have some connection with our past. There is no sin in that.
Moving from celebration to occupation takes things into an entirely different realm. The Zionist project is an amoral, selfish exercise which is destructive to another people with an equal right to celebrate their identity.
Yishai is 100% correct.
Barak don't know what he's talking about.
He trying too be humanitarian, but he failed big time. 😂
barak living in fantasy land, saying something over and over doesnt make it true... regardless what history says or didnt say, its not gonna change anything today
BOOKS ON A GREEN SCREEN REALLY DOESN'T SCREAM "INTELLECTUAL" 💯💤🤡
when people have nothing smart to comment on what he said then they starting commenting on his video background...
The Palestinian activist sounds confused due to lack of knowledge in bible, history, lack of faith in God. Why his parents came from Germany to Israel ? He should ask himself this question.
I'm about 10 minutes in and I'm not hearing any talk about why the Jewish people ended up in Europe...
It's extremely important and it changes the entire paradigm from this idea that they colonized Israel to more the idea that the Jewish people were coming home after being driven out of Israel to Europe during the crusades and persecutions. It has been a historical and and repeatable history of the Jewish people.
Look at the populations of jews presently throughout the arab countries surrounding Israel and compare them to the population of Arabs in Israel. Although they were always the minority in these these countries surrounding Israel they still had a much more significant presence before they were forced out.
Jewish people have a historical presence in Israel always and have been persecuted throughout most of their history there. In modern times before 1947 I believe 1929 there was the Hebron massacre of Jews by Arabs... genocide in Germany an anti-Semitism throughout the regions of Poland Lithuania and the pogroms in Russia have shown time and time again have led to the existence and re-establishing of a Jewish Homeland for their very survival...
I always wonder what would happen if the canaanites also came for their land since they were the real inhabitants before biblical Israel .(Funny how all of a sudden the Bible has became an historical book?Its full of so many inconsistencies it’s even funny to think that way,You could dig up the whole world for artifacts to justify your claims and still the Bible’s account of history always falls flat when it meets science and rigorous fact checking.
Let that sink in for moment all ye lands.
@@blackimusic I agree that history/ historical facts are enough...
@@blackimusicwhat documentation of history that far should we use then?
Jewish presence in Israel does not need to equate to an ethno-religious state which penalises people who are not of the Jewish faith. Zionism, and the exclusivity which it promotes is the disease which has plagued the disputed territories. The Zionist project has always been about expelling the Arabs and others from the lands claimed as being historically Jewish. Everything bad which has followed is a direct consequence of Zionism.
Zionism gave birth to Hamas.
@@christerry1773 . None. The absurdity of a Zion state being established based upon a presence millennia ago is self-evident. Its a nonsense. A poisonous nonsense.
Jim is a horrible moderator and obviously biased.
And loves his own voice too much. It's honestly unbearable
🇸🇻🇸🇻🇸🇻🇸🇻🇸🇻🇸🇻🇸🇻🇸🇻🇸🇻🇸🇻🇸🇻🇸🇻🇸🇻🇸🇻 free the hostages . Never mind gaza they braught that on themselves .
From Morocco to Pakistan set the people free from islam. Free to choose. Free from retribution. Free to choose through free elections.
Yishai 👍👍👍👍👍
Barak is delusional.. its almost sad.
also him drinking from an I
Yishai had him right. His mind has been colonized by western ideas of "rights". The idea of a secular nation with equal rights for all has never worked in the middle east and it won't work here. It would be nice if that was possible but it's not going to happen in this neighborhood. If you're living in a rough neighborhood, you can't leave your door unlocked.
Right, the timing was perfect, i wonder, was it on purpose !? ))
I got married in Gush Etzion, beautiful place, very nice people and beautiful wineries nearby
“I’m squatting in an area once called Judea”
There is one thing I agreed with Barak. Barak definitely doesn’t know history.
I am not Jewish, but anyone who has read the Bible knows the Kingdom of Israel was established c. 3,500 years ago by King David. And his son Solomon built the first temple. This kingdom was not mediocre, it was a glorious kingom, and dignatries came to tribute to this kindom and the wisdom of Solomon.
Beyond this is the fact that God himself gave this land as an EVERLASTING possession to Abraham and his descendants Isaax and Jacob. Any secular person can attempt to argue the validity of this, and that is because they do not understand that the Judeo-Christian Bible has divine authorship codes which cannot be reproduced by man, and the Heptadic Code (structue) which runs through the entire Hebrew Tanakh and the Greek New Testament.
So Barack (sorry do not know the correct spelling) can believe what he wants and the same goes for the so called 'Palestinians' (Arabs and Egyptians), and the rest of Islam for that matter, because the land belongs to the Jews, and no amount of: war, terror, propaganda, lies, deflection, projection, reality denial, feet stomping, screaming and shouting will prevent it, period!
The Jewish claim to the land is verified: divinely, historically, and legally. For example King David paid Arunah the Jebusite hor the temple mount, which hosts artifacts from the second temple. Why then is it claimed by Islam? That is theft, plan and simple.
There is no geocide taking place in Gaza, there is the collateral damage invoked by jihadists who love to slaughter ('martyer') their own civiluans as fuel for a propaganda dimension of the war aimed at secular humanists who deney God and fall into a devious trap promoted by the koran.
So while claiming secularism, these people who buy into this are but puppets of a depraved Islamic ideology, and they are unaware of it..
You're not a historian. Well, history shows israel is 3000 years old get educated. Jesus lived in israel before Islam. Jew were always there
Jaffa stolen from Palestine
That Barrack livin in Java..
Almost sure he was Abdool 😂
The Palestinians should be grateful that Israel don’t turn Gaza into glass in less than a second.
@@grevisse6757 South Koreans don’t murder North Koreans. Get an education.
Spoken like a true Nazi.
@@SuperKripke and you’re a paedophile. Prove you’re not.
@@SuperKripke Exactly.
Really? ruclips.net/video/_FNtMV2i8-8/видео.html
So much missing from this argument. First off many Jews were here and this land was not full of Palestinians. There were Arabs here. Most of the land was inhabitable as technology made it habitable. And only 20% of Jews in Israel are from Northern Europe. No mention of Mizrahi Jews… such an empty argument!
No person is an alien in the eyes of the Lord.
The moderator was not great, Yishai you did a great job as always.
It's pretty clear where he stands but he did let Yishai talk.
Narrator is on the side of the palestians.
From the river to the sea 🇮🇱 that's the only flag you'll see. NEVER AGAIN 🇮🇱
Barak said that the Nazis had none affinity with the Arabs living in Palestine during W.W.II. With the Mufti during that time making a pact with Hitler, I do think that can be true
This dude, sounds American...One day, American, next day Israeli....WTF?
Thank you Yishai, for producing and posting this video. I have been following events in the Middle East since 1967, and this is the first time I have heard a left-leaning proPalestinian Israeli, candidly express their reasons for supporting Palestinians and opposing Zionism. Like most of those on the left Barack tends to ignore aspects of history that contradict their narrative. I had assumed like most of those in the proPalestinian camp, Barack would adopt their same talking points, but it was good to hear it first hand. Barack begins by saying, "Fact, the Jewish people came here in 1948". Though this is often repeated and strongly believed by many Palestinians and their supporters worldwide. This is not accurate, Jews have always lived in The Land. Prior to the reestablishment of the State of Israel in 1948, there was a Jewish presence in The Land. Although the Romans destroyed the 2nd Temple in 70 CE, killing & enslaving many Jews, Jewish occupation of The Land continued. In 132 CE. the Romans put down a nationalist movement by Jews to retake control of their land, once again killing and enslaving a large number of Jews. The Romans were successful in maintaining military and sovereign control of the Jewish homeland, but Jews continued to live and maintain their presence in their indigenous homeland. Over the following centuries, The Land of Israel was overtaken by numerous foreign armies, who occupied the Jewish homeland, but there was always a remnant of indigenous Jews who continued to maintain a presence. In time Jews became a minority to the occupiers in their indigenous homeland, but up until 1948 they always maintained a presence in their ancestral homeland. This is a historic fact many opposed to the nation state of Israel intentionally, conveniently, or ignorantly forget to recognize.
The majority of the people in Israel are khazarian converts to Judaism. They have absolutely no historical or bloodline connection to philistine/Palestine. These are colonial settlers from Europe just like the Europeans in south Africa. Stop deluding yourself, we know the true history and not the western propaganda used to justify imperialist colonialism in Palestine.
Can someone answer how Israel occupies its own land? The only possible sovereign of the West Bank and Gaza under International Law is Israel.
*Please answer who the land is occupied from?*
▪︎ The former Ottoman lands?
▪︎ The expired British Mandate lands?
▪︎ The illegally annexed Jordanian land?
▪︎ The colonized Egyptian land in Gaza?
▪︎ The land won by Israel from Jordan and Egypt in a defensive war?
*Explain what land is occupied, and from whom?*
It's occupied from the actual people who lived there before 1948. That were massacred and expelled from it by Jewish terrorists to create a Jewish supremacist state that still goes on. Not a democracy but an ethno religious state.
@@lbs7774
genius-NOT, Land is "occupied" when a state takes over land from another State, people are not occupied!!!
@@lbs7774There were very few people expelled and less massacred. There were 300,000 Arabs that fled after the UN Partition Plan was announced in November 1947, these people were the wealthy and educated that presumed there was a war coming.
*The Institute for Palestine Studies,* an Arab organization based in Beirut stated, *68% of Arabs left their villages without ever seeing a Jewish man with a gun or a soldier.*
Search, *_"How we really became refugees, 13 Palestinians tell their personal stories"_* Mamoud Abbas and 12 others from all over Israel, tell the truth about why and how they left the villages and houses and it wasn't because of the Jews.
The majority fled because of the war that happened when 5 Arab armies with the Arab Irregulars started on the one day old country of Israel.
@@lbs7774 Israel has 2.1 million Arab citizens, 1.8 million Muslim citizens, they also have 10 different denominations of Christians, Samaritans, Druze, Bahai and other religions. As for the local Arab and Muslim countries, there are less than 15,000 Jews total in all the countries combined.
Israel is higher in the Democracy Index than the US, Spain, Italy and most countries. There is no ethno-state at all.
@@shainazion4073You are absolutely disregarding the West Bank were jews are given israeli nationality and the rest are not based on their religion. Israel does not have civil marriage only religious, and jewish religious extremists and orthodox are financed by the state to keep growing in numbers so jews are always a majority. Dissidents of the IDF and people who speak against the genocide Israel is commiting are imprisoned. Genetic studies that would prove palestinians are closer to ancient judeans than ashkenazi jews are prohibited. Israel is NOT I repeat is NOT a democracy. It's a religious ethnostate where some people have rights and some other don't.
Barack is a complete ignoramus. And this “debate” 🙄 was a complete waste of time.
This palestine supporter dont know what he is talking about
He has been trained vary well in a Colonising rhetoric
@mikayelaghatabay5322 what do you mean??
Justifying crimes of colonisation by playing victim and accusing of the other side. Many of their leaders had Palestinian passports because they came as refugees...
Yishai, you should not have used the Palestinian flag for Barak, amazing that his name means "blessing". You should use the Israeli flag with the circle and slash over it.
So the Israeli flag stands for their war criminal government? Or it's the people's flag?
Barak is Lightning, Bracha is blessing. SO it makes sense... :-)
Isn't it amazing how the one guys sounds American, go back to America
I enjoyed listening to this conversation between two very different personalities and very different opinions.
It's funny, but I thought it strange that this religious and tribal guy has so many books, until I saw that it is only a virtual lie 🤣🤣🤣
Yishai thank you for showcasing the truth
And forget international law
@@sunnychandi you never studied this topic it seems
Oh I have and I’m sympathetic and fair towards Jewish people and always have been
The UAE is a perfect example of which a majority of its people have civil rights but not national rights. Emiratie Arabs are a minority in the UAE but are the only ones with national rights. Yet, with its high standard of living, the UAE is a place where most of its majority of non-citizens are happy to live and/or work in. This is similar to what Yishai wants to have in Israel and which the West Bank of Judea and Samaria, Area C has de facto.
The UAE model is the best doable approach for Israel in governing Gaza and Judea and Samaria.
Well done Yishai❤
Thank you Yishai!
Well said Yishai
Really? ruclips.net/video/_FNtMV2i8-8/видео.html