I got my PhD in India however it was very hard to find a research based job. I did 2 jobs after my PhD, 1st for a US based organisation run by an Indian, 1st meeting happened at 10 am, second at 8 pm and 3rd at 1:30 am again, this never happened with those working in US. I had to leave the job because of the poor working hours. For the 2nd job the 1st meeting happened at sharp 9 am, and the work continued till 9:30 pm at least every day and even after Saturday being a holiday on the offer letter, almost worked every Saturday till I was there. Finally decided to resign as it was too much for me especially when having worked almost 12-14 hrs everyday for the last two years of my PhD. Now I'm in US , rarely anyone works past 6 pm here besides the work environment is stress-free. No wonder people leave India, money is just an added benefit. Maybe if you are working for someone else India is a bad option, if working for yourself India can be better because the labour is cheap 😅, and on top they now want you to work even on Sundays.
That culture has been there since 60-70’s in Gujarath and no matter how better the state grows, how many jobs comes in things doesn’t change unless the differential between US and India gets small.
Gujju's are not the only one. Just go to South and see the craze of going to USA there. It is insane. No good girl will marry you if she doesn't see a US visa on your passport. The largest Indian communities in the US are mostly from the South, despite all their tall claims of being the most 'educated and advanced and developed' in India.
@@Gajjala-oi4ccBro these are extremely Irrational narrow minded Bigoted People. Tu kitna bhi fact check karle ye nahi sunenge. Inko Bae Gujrat ka FOMO dikhega Kerala ya Punjab ka nahi.
I left India because of the toxic work culture, and rude people everywhere with no sense of acceptable social behavior. And it was my best decision till date.
You are absolutely right. And Indians' behaviour is getting worse. I am from Goa and the situation there is horrible. Goa's environment is destroyed, dirt everywhere, no sense of civics, rude and uncouth behaviour from males, no manners, inappropriate developments, coal, drunkenness, intolerance to Goans' way of life and religion and food, folk from elsewhere in India who have moved to Goa dictating to Goans how to live and who to worship and how to dress, etc etc. No respect for another. For a country which claims to be conservative and clean, the sex trade in Goa is abhorrent and even children have to endure this degrading treatment. When you say no sense of acceptable social behaviour, you are spot on.
So damn true. We Indians have no manners and we cannot even politely respond to a stranger saying Hello, How are you? WTF! In western countries, you can say Hi, How are you to ANYONE and they will smile and respond in a similar way. But we Indians, we behave as if the other person is trying to rob us. Very sad and very disappointing.
@@TheBaywork its because we live in low trust society we don’t trust strangers! Keep a 10 rupee worth stuff on the sidewalk , come after an hour it’s gone forever! Thats the community we have ! 20 % people really want to change the country whereas 80% people pulling it back!
Majority of the people employed in India are in Swiggy, Zepto, Blinkit. Also there are many cases wherein techies quit their job and starting small cafes and restaurants. People are fed up of the toxic work culture. On top of that we have pollution, traffic, rude people, bad roads, expensive schools and unclean environment. There are a bunch of people who are least bothered about spitting on the roads, or driving rash. Horrible.
Sadly, the so called NRIs who claim life is better in India must know - one can keep maids as slaves because there aren't any hourly wages law in India. Also think why are there maids in the first place. Do these maids have maids? So, the creamy layer who can afford to keep maids only crib.
I am a teacher, I’ve worked in India for 17 yrs as economics teacher. Such a negative environment there in schools back in India. Now, I am working as learning assistant in Newzealand, such a peace and actuality addition to my intellect instead of playing survival tricks.
2 choices Pay 30-40% tax get good roads, good police, good social security, job security and work life balance Or Pay 30-40% tax and don't get the things mentioned above. Simple choice
@@LikeDeep-q6w try telling yourself that when you are an enterpreneur. And in my country, that's becoming more difficult by the day. The compliances and taxes are basically designed to take money out of the entrepreneur and into the hands of the corrupt sitting in government offices. Doing business ethically in India is (almost) impossible. India has become too capitalist for its own good. God forbid but a day might come where the country ban and Sue farmers from planting their own seed. And industrial oligarchy is what it(India) has become. A house divided by its own cannot stand.
All the more, any shit job one does in the West one is treated the same way. Even someone on perennial dole aren't second class citizens. One does not have to call anyone sir. Perhaps, the job titles. Still not sir.
1 out of every 7 person in the WHOLE WORLD lives in India. India doesn't have enough resources to go around, even if we were a more successful country. Please, please, just spread across the globe. Good land exist everywhere
I met an illegal immigrant at the airport last year here in the US, and was shocked to hear the kind of struggles she went through to get here. She was from a village near Ahmedabad and she said there was no prospect of a better life and she was willing to risk her life for at least that hope. So it's not just the educated class frustrated by the toxic work culture but the labor class as well. It's a sad reality and laughable to hear politicians saying absurd things so out-of-touch of reality.
She must have voted for Modi and his ilk.. Most hypocrite "nationalists" are here in US and other Western countries... they become hyper nationalists after SURRENDERING their Indian citizenship 😀
I agree, If you are earning $ 175 a month its better to get out of India unless u have assets worth 5cr to 10 cr to begin with then India can be comfortable. Otherwise, it can be a hell hole and be a slave to the system for perpetuity.
I think, no matter how things are 'bad' for someone in India, taking the risk of moving abroad illegally is never worth the risk. If the person is caught, things might get really bad and might have to spend time in prison. Also, even if the person does earn some money, after all the person is still illegal and won't be able to enjoy the new money.
High pollution , corruption across , lack of civic sense and utter disrespect for collectivism and inclusivity -these are where governments and people need to pay attention . If we get paid better , live in near zero corruption and pollution free environment and caring for law and collectivism why people will go back ?
When I was flying , spoke with a Man from Gujarat, he mentioned only one person is living in India, rest every one are living abroad, this is the pathetic situation these big mouth corrupted politicians have created and on top of that, they still couldn’t figure out why people are leaving
But the same people are putting them in power, isn't it ? Modi has the biggest support from these people who are no more Indian citizens yet hate minorities in India to the max while living as one in Christian lands.
And yet Indians living abroad, living off the foreign governments good governance and tolerance to their religion, these Indians are supporting from abroad a government in India who is intolerant to minorities, other faiths other than Hinduism. These Indians are financing the present Indian government to promote disharmony and chaos in India while enjoying all privileges in foreign lands. Hypocrisy to the hilt.
They really don't care and the citizens also don't care enough to demand better from the goverment. Indians and Indian politicians HAVE NO SHAME at how horrible India's public image is right now.
Better work life balance, cleaner air, respectful behaviour, lesser corruption, more accountability by senior leaders, safety of women and minorities, dignity of labour, work culture that supports family as an essential part of daily life. Even knowing India is growing economy and an excellent market for businesses, many factors come into play making this decision.
Clean air, better work life balance, importance to mental health, better corporate policies, less mortgage rates. Less toxic work culture 😌from my experience of working in UK and Sweden.
I'm from Chennai india, its hard to live with bribe police, bribe politicians, life is hard for me, its hard to get jobs, Social system is bad, people mindset corrupted already, No honest people live in Chennai, People begging for overseas, this is my own experience and I don't know about others 😢😢
Air quality in places like Delhi and Mumbai is 200 -500+ , the same in countries like US and Canada is in the range of 2-5 or lower. Obviously it is much better outside India.
How do we account for corruption? I have to grease several palms for most important things - from buying land to getting clearances? Law enforcement is poor - if I was wronged by somebody, can I expect justice to be served quickly? Are there enough courts? I have a feeling we know what the answers are. These are fundamental to a healthy country in which I can place my bets on.
India's rapid growth is often overstated-look deeper, and migration trends tell a different story. Comparing India to developed nations is unrealistic; innovation remains minimal, and the 'jugaad' mindset persists. Can you name one globally used product made in India? Even TikTok, created by China, showcases their innovation and global reach. India lacks the environment and mindset for groundbreaking innovation, which raises concerns about its ability to compete globally. This isn't criticism but an attempt to understand why India risks falling behind.
@@NingegotthaWouldn't you blame Kerala’s Communist Government or Punjab's Congress and AAP jaha se sabse Zyada Brain Drain horaha hai? Youth Unemployment in Kerala is as same as Bihar’s i.e 28%. You guys are soo obsessed with bjp that you just conveniently ignore other non performing Governments who are for more than a decade?
@@nikhilbhute07 everyone ! All parties are just reflection of ours ! Literally every party ! Don’t blame parties instead blame ourselves thats ! what I meant They are just reflections of ours And please don’t defend BJP
Pollution, health care system without accountability, poor education, poor taxation laws, unemployment, unsocial working hours are the reasons why people leave India. Tomorrow, if rich industrialists were to fall acutely ill, is there a system that can be held accountable for providing timely health care to them.
The day India has cities that attract non-Indians who would want to come settle here is the day when India would know, it has finally made it and become developed and at par with other rich countries.
India is great for those who have money and fame. It is not that great if you live an average life and hoping to ascend the social status. An average life in developed countries is also not the greatest, there are a lot of problems there too and things can become frustrating especially healthcare which is better in India but comparatively , the quality of life is much better outside India atleast for now for the average people. Another problem is those who have money and status in India want to exploit those who don't and who are below them. When you work outside, your manager is also an employee and you speak with him/her as your colleague on a first name basis, you do not act subservient to them and call them Sir/Madam, that is a colonial mindset and very disrespectful but not in India which is a problem.
The question is pointless as is Rajnath Singh’s remark. Those who decide to go abroad do so after finding that it did not work out in India or that getting education and experience abroad will improve their future prospects in India. The question is irrelevant for them. Their decision is (or was) based on their own experience. The Minister remarks make no difference in that decision. People will continue to go out until existing job, education, or career advancement opportunities in India fall short of their desires and expectation. Anyone else’s opinions, including the minister’s, are irrelevant.
Not to mention male dominance and intolerance. India is a rape and murder country of the world. Recently even a female doctor was raped and murdered while working in the hospital. Where is the law and order in India ? The ministers are busy looting and increasing their bank balances. Look at the calibre of constructions. New roads with cracks, new buildings collapsing, even the new temple is collapsing after spending crores of rupees on building it. Where does all the money go ???
We are ready to come but can Rajnath Singh guarantee the following- 1. Can he ask people like Jaishankar to call back their children? 2. Can he guarantee education accessibility and employment or are we gonna have lacs of candidates caught in stampede while struggling for only a 1000 odd opportunities? 3. Can he guarantee state of art infrastructure for educational institutes and more govt colleges with equal infra so students have accessibility? 4. Can he give us freedom of expression so professors and students aren’t suspended cz they perform research and find out how the economy is failing? 5. Can he guarantee there is minimal wealth disparity so 50% of population still doesn’t feel poor? 6. Can he guarantee a fair system irrespective of our income? 7. Is he willing to invest more in education than in religious structures? Cz apparently there is so much space for temples but very little for schools and colleges. 8. Can he reduce tax burden on the middle class? 9. Can people protest to voice their discontent and to ask for their rights? 10. Can he stop enforcing his party beliefs on the people and let them live as per their will? We go abroad cz they are providing us all these and more opportunities that we have been demanding in our country. Indian or not our opportunities broaden, our minds broaden, we get newer perspective. Even an authoritarian country like China has a better education system even if rigorous.
I I finished my BA and BEd from Mumbai University and Masters in Rome. Currently working in Australia. I am very content, well paid, even if you work as a Relief Teacher or Contract your Tier go up. I love Goa and would like to work in Goa but I will have to pay without paying you want get a Job specially for Post graduate. And Now we Goa government is selling jobs for Lakhs, not just 1 Lakh but 15-50 Lakhs. I am a person who don't encourage this mal practices. Few months ago some people have been caught so, far no action taken. I am talking for Goa. There is corruption and more people are brought from other states rather then employing locals. The person who said that Indian don't need to go overseas, this shows that he is ignorant or have no knowledge of ground reality or he is blind. You work abroad your rights are protected and if you complaint immediate action is take. In India there is no law no human rights.
I have lived in the UK for the last 3 years. The cost of living is so exorbitantly high and also the salary growth is not amazing. It also depends on at which stage of your life you are moving abroad. When you are young, if you venture out, it makes a lot of sense but when you are a bit matured and unless you get a significant growth in salary, it is not viable. Having said that, the work life balance is so wonderful abroad. Once you are out of office, you don’t really need to worry about getting a call from your boss 😅
The richest man India has more than all 5, he has the power of mobility. He can move around anywhere in the world or have things brought to him on request.
The Truth is no IITian do their Masters Degree and PhD in our country, no Talented Scientist do their PhD in India, it is because our Higher Education System for Science and Technology is very poor compared to USA, Europe, China, Japan,.... Our Talented Labour Force ultimately being continually migrated to USA and Europe because what they deserve, they almost get in those countries but if they stay in our country, they will get almost nothing. I remember once our Government told that they r extending special facilities to Corporates like reduction of Corporate Tax, Tax concession on SEZ, special tax concession on some products to encourage Businesses, if Government don't extend those facilities to our Tycoons, they will be shifted to Europe, Middle East for doing Business. It is assumption of Government for extending facilities to Business Class though we don't know really they will be shifted or not if special privilege is not extended to them. Our Government never got time or scope of thinking whether our Talented Labour Force would stay in our country if special privilege was extended to them or not.
I guess people doing well in India don’t usually comment on such videos. There are only two types of guys commenting - those really struggling in India and want a way to exit and those who were struggling in India and have then moved abroad and are doing better and are looking for validation that they made the right decision.
India is extremely overpopulated and total gdp is low. More must go out and search for opportunities. Look how Europeans are all over America, Australia etc
Any person, irrespective of his/her nationality, must move around the world in search of better opportunities in education, learning, health, employment, business.
Its strange that i see this video today bcos just like other times just yesterday also while talking to.someone i was mentioning that many people can be employed to do.lots of work in India esp clearing unwanted trees and shrubs in unwanted areas, the constructing theme parks or other facilities which provides opps for all ages and then i see ur this video discussion...
@fayedsouza as an entrepreneur and a tech startup i can surely say that the govt has lost the priority of research education and SME focus. Jobs are created by thousands of startups for lakhs of students. India instead of investing on technology has wasted on road builing and burdening people with tolls. This govt has failed in strenthening governance but shifted to cronies who have spoiled the full generations.
If the govt make study about the subject thoroughly, it may help the job seekers , job generators and the govt itself. It is unknown whether govt is having category-wise unemployed population. The remarks of many below this video itself give a fair idea of the situation. Merely making statement that nobody needs to go abroad will not serve any purpose.
Sr citizens are treated well, free transportation and health besides other facilities. Jobs available for all age group and many activities free and many more opportunities in UK.
The widespread corruption in almost each single institute in india sucks.. I am very sure i have to pay to get license to start a business ...people are not honest..honks everywhere, noise is not considered kind of pollution...worst concern is corruption has entered into our DNA....imagine getting renew ur passport in 3 months.. The country i live u can do in an hour. Mere bharat mahan
Family oriented youngsters must not need to go to abroad for the Living. Returning age is 58 to 60 in India so your benefits getting start. Returning age in US is 67 that’s not the age you can enjoy your retirement fund. Recreation Places more in India with proper Climate, US, Canada, UK are Cold Countries you can get Skyey, and National Parks for the Recreation with uncertainty of the weather. Food is totally different. Public transportation in US are not like India.
Lots of comments saying abroad is better, cleaner, etc. Yes, but the gravy train is not going to last forever. Anti-immigration sentiment and white-nationalist political parties are rising everywhere in the West. Violence may increase against Indians in Western countries, and many may be deported. Then what? AAP and the book The Delhi Model by Jasmine Shah addresses most of the governance/infrastructure concerns Faye brings up, but nobody talks about it.
Quality of higher education as well most importantly primary and secondary education even after so many year of independence is questionable... how we can have a good quality lifestyle, Are we providing equal opportunity of growth to all
I think India is to top heavy meaning tech and blue color heavy. India has the largest population with the majority blue collar manufacturing. India is not capitalizing on their large population as it relates to manufacturing
Pollution + Middle-class ONLY tax w/ 0 benefits + INR depreciation (and no one cares attitude) + Reservation system + (not so important reasons) Traffic, global warming impacts. Please talk about real points !
We r proud of our Space Research Organisation ISRO but truth is there is not much Highly Innovative Scientist in ISRO, I don't know how many IITean r a working in ISRO but truth is ISRO is much behind than NASA and CNSA though a very good number Talented Scientist r working in NASA. Our Chandrayan 3 is a prestigious performance ISRO, it is a great achievement but darkar side is it could not even withstand one Lunar Night whereas YUTU 2 Rover of CNSA is operating on Moon Surface till date since 2019, Curiosity Rover of NASA is operating on Mars Surface since 2012. We achieved but running far behind them. If we get answers of Why?, then only solutions available.
It's not that foging is not done by local bodies but the expenses booking by local bodies on mosquitoes have increased by 5 to 15 times in past 5 year's. 😂😂😂😂
Sorry to say, but what was the conclusion we made here.. Just discussing is not going to make any difference whatsoever.. We all know what is wrong with our country.. We all admit them apart from our ache din wala politicians.. but Is there any way to push our corrupt politicians?? Did we talk on that aspect.. Sorry if I missed that point
1 . Tax system , it sucks 2. Poverty is not an excuse for hygeine 3. If i say something bad about india which is actually bad then i am anti national and what not . Like cmon out tier 1 cities have the largest slum in the country perhaps the continent . You can smell the hygeine as u move through these roads 4. 'Mother ganga " stinks a lot , why treat it ljke god when u cant maintain it that way 5 . Minimal civic sense and ignorant on issues 6. Religious riots and some backward 1800s oriented people in this country begging for hindu rashtra 7. The arrogance the people of this country have stating we are vishwaguru while on the other hand the worlds 5th largest economy has the 80cr people on free ration and some women who live their life on 1500 per month provided in the name of welfare 8. Scam call centres and other tourist realted scammers 9. Toxic work culture and inefficent techies 10. For how long this country will be dependent on it industry dont we have anything else to offer 11. Shit public services , the bus trains and even airports are not well maintained except tjose in tier 1 cities , seeing all the red marks there irritates me.
the quality of research in India is very poor and most of it is copy paste from eearlier research and we do not have benchmarking of defending our research
I got my PhD in India however it was very hard to find a research based job. I did 2 jobs after my PhD, 1st for a US based organisation run by an Indian, 1st meeting happened at 10 am, second at 8 pm and 3rd at 1:30 am again, this never happened with those working in US. I had to leave the job because of the poor working hours. For the 2nd job the 1st meeting happened at sharp 9 am, and the work continued till 9:30 pm at least every day and even after Saturday being a holiday on the offer letter, almost worked every Saturday till I was there. Finally decided to resign as it was too much for me especially when having worked almost 12-14 hrs everyday for the last two years of my PhD. Now I'm in US , rarely anyone works past 6 pm here besides the work environment is stress-free. No wonder people leave India, money is just an added benefit. Maybe if you are working for someone else India is a bad option, if working for yourself India can be better because the labour is cheap 😅, and on top they now want you to work even on Sundays.
How effective per hour were you when working in India and in US?
May be that also need to be told
@@abhiwins123 andh bhakth agaya ! Meeting schedule dekho pehle ! Baad main u can talk about productivity
If Gujju's are leaving India , even illegally, then it's a good indication why Ache Din & Amrit Kaal can only be achieved overseas
If they don't go overseas then who'll fill up Namaste Modi events.
That culture has been there since 60-70’s in Gujarath and no matter how better the state grows, how many jobs comes in things doesn’t change unless the differential between US and India gets small.
Gujju's are not the only one. Just go to South and see the craze of going to USA there. It is insane. No good girl will marry you if she doesn't see a US visa on your passport. The largest Indian communities in the US are mostly from the South, despite all their tall claims of being the most 'educated and advanced and developed' in India.
@@Gajjala-oi4ccBro these are extremely Irrational narrow minded Bigoted People. Tu kitna bhi fact check karle ye nahi sunenge. Inko Bae Gujrat ka FOMO dikhega Kerala ya Punjab ka nahi.
I left India because of the toxic work culture, and rude people everywhere with no sense of acceptable social behavior. And it was my best decision till date.
You are absolutely right. And Indians' behaviour is getting worse. I am from Goa and the situation there is horrible. Goa's environment is destroyed, dirt everywhere, no sense of civics, rude and uncouth behaviour from males, no manners, inappropriate developments, coal, drunkenness, intolerance to Goans' way of life and religion and food, folk from elsewhere in India who have moved to Goa dictating to Goans how to live and who to worship and how to dress, etc etc. No respect for another. For a country which claims to be conservative and clean, the sex trade in Goa is abhorrent and even children have to endure this degrading treatment. When you say no sense of acceptable social behaviour, you are spot on.
U had any tamil manager at any point of time??😂😂
So damn true. We Indians have no manners and we cannot even politely respond to a stranger saying Hello, How are you? WTF! In western countries, you can say Hi, How are you to ANYONE and they will smile and respond in a similar way. But we Indians, we behave as if the other person is trying to rob us. Very sad and very disappointing.
@@TheBaywork its because we live in low trust society we don’t trust strangers! Keep a 10 rupee worth stuff on the sidewalk , come after an hour it’s gone forever!
Thats the community we have ! 20 % people really want to change the country whereas 80% people pulling it back!
Gaddar
Majority of the people employed in India are in Swiggy, Zepto, Blinkit. Also there are many cases wherein techies quit their job and starting small cafes and restaurants. People are fed up of the toxic work culture. On top of that we have pollution, traffic, rude people, bad roads, expensive schools and unclean environment. There are a bunch of people who are least bothered about spitting on the roads, or driving rash. Horrible.
Sadly, the so called NRIs who claim life is better in India must know - one can keep maids as slaves because there aren't any hourly wages law in India. Also think why are there maids in the first place. Do these maids have maids? So, the creamy layer who can afford to keep maids only crib.
I am a teacher, I’ve worked in India for 17 yrs as economics teacher. Such a negative environment there in schools back in India.
Now, I am working as learning assistant in Newzealand, such a peace and actuality addition to my intellect instead of playing survival tricks.
2 choices
Pay 30-40% tax get good roads, good police, good social security, job security and work life balance
Or
Pay 30-40% tax and don't get the things mentioned above.
Simple choice
Correct answer is choice 2 which reflects our current situation
job security is a myth bro
@@LikeDeep-q6w try telling yourself that when you are an enterpreneur. And in my country, that's becoming more difficult by the day. The compliances and taxes are basically designed to take money out of the entrepreneur and into the hands of the corrupt sitting in government offices. Doing business ethically in India is (almost) impossible. India has become too capitalist for its own good. God forbid but a day might come where the country ban and Sue farmers from planting their own seed. And industrial oligarchy is what it(India) has become. A house divided by its own cannot stand.
All the more, any shit job one does in the West one is treated the same way. Even someone on perennial dole aren't second class citizens. One does not have to call anyone sir. Perhaps, the job titles. Still not sir.
1 out of every 7 person in the WHOLE WORLD lives in India.
India doesn't have enough resources to go around, even if we were a more successful country.
Please, please, just spread across the globe. Good land exist everywhere
I met an illegal immigrant at the airport last year here in the US, and was shocked to hear the kind of struggles she went through to get here. She was from a village near Ahmedabad and she said there was no prospect of a better life and she was willing to risk her life for at least that hope. So it's not just the educated class frustrated by the toxic work culture but the labor class as well. It's a sad reality and laughable to hear politicians saying absurd things so out-of-touch of reality.
She must have voted for Modi and his ilk.. Most hypocrite "nationalists" are here in US and other Western countries... they become hyper nationalists after SURRENDERING their Indian citizenship 😀
I don't believe you..this can never happen to someone who's a labharthi of the excellent Gujrat model.
I agree, If you are earning $ 175 a month its better to get out of India unless u have assets worth 5cr to 10 cr to begin with then India can be comfortable. Otherwise, it can be a hell hole and be a slave to the system for perpetuity.
@@7777linpawsGujarati are the most illegal immigrants who travel to US. Check the official data of US.
I think, no matter how things are 'bad' for someone in India, taking the risk of moving abroad illegally is never worth the risk. If the person is caught, things might get really bad and might have to spend time in prison. Also, even if the person does earn some money, after all the person is still illegal and won't be able to enjoy the new money.
High pollution , corruption across , lack of civic sense and utter disrespect for collectivism and inclusivity -these are where governments and people need to pay attention . If we get paid better , live in near zero corruption and pollution free environment and caring for law and collectivism why people will go back ?
Spot on! But add this main point Average life expectancy is very less compared to europe! No value for life if u are poor or middleclass
There are no jobs in India for the youth, even if they have a degree. However, they can work as sweepers abroad without any issue.
True also cleaning washrooms too
When I was flying , spoke with a Man from Gujarat, he mentioned only one person is living in India, rest every one are living abroad, this is the pathetic situation these big mouth corrupted politicians have created and on top of that, they still couldn’t figure out why people are leaving
But the same people are putting them in power, isn't it ? Modi has the biggest support from these people who are no more Indian citizens yet hate minorities in India to the max while living as one in Christian lands.
We need them to be there for the Namaste Modi events, they are fulfilling their national duty..internationally.
But everyone always saying about Gujarat model...
And yet Indians living abroad, living off the foreign governments good governance and tolerance to their religion, these Indians are supporting from abroad a government in India who is intolerant to minorities, other faiths other than Hinduism. These Indians are financing the present Indian government to promote disharmony and chaos in India while enjoying all privileges in foreign lands. Hypocrisy to the hilt.
They really don't care and the citizens also don't care enough to demand better from the goverment.
Indians and Indian politicians HAVE NO SHAME at how horrible India's public image is right now.
Better work life balance, cleaner air, respectful behaviour, lesser corruption, more accountability by senior leaders, safety of women and minorities, dignity of labour, work culture that supports family as an essential part of daily life. Even knowing India is growing economy and an excellent market for businesses, many factors come into play making this decision.
Clean air, better work life balance, importance to mental health, better corporate policies, less mortgage rates. Less toxic work culture 😌from my experience of working in UK and Sweden.
Try germany
I'm from Chennai india, its hard to live with bribe police, bribe politicians, life is hard for me, its hard to get jobs, Social system is bad, people mindset corrupted already, No honest people live in Chennai, People begging for overseas, this is my own experience and I don't know about others 😢😢
All honest peoples are living in gujarat
Air quality in places like Delhi and Mumbai is 200 -500+ , the same in countries like US and Canada is in the range of 2-5 or lower. Obviously it is much better outside India.
I just want to breathe clean air and save my son from the pressure cooker or schooling in India.
Rreason for Rajnath Singh to say, no one needs to abroad to study...if they go, they may realise how much "Danka baj raha hai" actually 😂😂😂
How do we account for corruption? I have to grease several palms for most important things - from buying land to getting clearances? Law enforcement is poor - if I was wronged by somebody, can I expect justice to be served quickly? Are there enough courts?
I have a feeling we know what the answers are. These are fundamental to a healthy country in which I can place my bets on.
India's rapid growth is often overstated-look deeper, and migration trends tell a different story. Comparing India to developed nations is unrealistic; innovation remains minimal, and the 'jugaad' mindset persists. Can you name one globally used product made in India? Even TikTok, created by China, showcases their innovation and global reach. India lacks the environment and mindset for groundbreaking innovation, which raises concerns about its ability to compete globally. This isn't criticism but an attempt to understand why India risks falling behind.
It's not overstated, it's just a made-up thing😅
Call all BJP supporters back who come to shout Moti Moti during the orchestrated events.
Dont blame bjp! Lets blame ourselves to put them in the administration
@@NingegotthaWouldn't you blame Kerala’s Communist Government or Punjab's Congress and AAP jaha se sabse Zyada Brain Drain horaha hai? Youth Unemployment in Kerala is as same as Bihar’s i.e 28%. You guys are soo obsessed with bjp that you just conveniently ignore other non performing Governments who are for more than a decade?
@@nikhilbhute07 everyone ! All parties are just reflection of ours ! Literally every party ! Don’t blame parties instead blame ourselves thats ! what I meant
They are just reflections of ours
And please don’t defend BJP
@ one point here is kerala minimum wage is 800 rs for an unskilled labour! Kerala as a state people are educated and has better civic sense than bihar
Just be patience and a wait a few more years,modi Ji to hai mumkin hai
I would move back if I felt India was a free market economy
It's Adani ambani market even Elon Musk is not spared
Whata are we even worth 😂😂😂
I went abroad for studies, stayed for clean air. In a long term, one has to think about health, well-being and learning environment for our children
Pollution, health care system without accountability, poor education, poor taxation laws, unemployment, unsocial working hours are the reasons why people leave India. Tomorrow, if rich industrialists were to fall acutely ill, is there a system that can be held accountable for providing timely health care to them.
The day India has cities that attract non-Indians who would want to come settle here is the day when India would know, it has finally made it and become developed and at par with other rich countries.
His son is in abroad 😅😅😅
India is great for those who have money and fame. It is not that great if you live an average life and hoping to ascend the social status. An average life in developed countries is also not the greatest, there are a lot of problems there too and things can become frustrating especially healthcare which is better in India but comparatively , the quality of life is much better outside India atleast for now for the average people. Another problem is those who have money and status in India want to exploit those who don't and who are below them. When you work outside, your manager is also an employee and you speak with him/her as your colleague on a first name basis, you do not act subservient to them and call them Sir/Madam, that is a colonial mindset and very disrespectful but not in India which is a problem.
The question is pointless as is Rajnath Singh’s remark. Those who decide to go abroad do so after finding that it did not work out in India or that getting education and experience abroad will improve their future prospects in India. The question is irrelevant for them. Their decision is (or was) based on their own experience. The Minister remarks make no difference in that decision. People will continue to go out until existing job, education, or career advancement opportunities in India fall short of their desires and expectation. Anyone else’s opinions, including the minister’s, are irrelevant.
What about the Narcissistic mindset of people? Narcissism is part of Indian culture
Not to mention male dominance and intolerance. India is a rape and murder country of the world. Recently even a female doctor was raped and murdered while working in the hospital. Where is the law and order in India ? The ministers are busy looting and increasing their bank balances. Look at the calibre of constructions. New roads with cracks, new buildings collapsing, even the new temple is collapsing after spending crores of rupees on building it. Where does all the money go ???
We are ready to come but can Rajnath Singh guarantee the following-
1. Can he ask people like Jaishankar to call back their children?
2. Can he guarantee education accessibility and employment or are we gonna have lacs of candidates caught in stampede while struggling for only a 1000 odd opportunities?
3. Can he guarantee state of art infrastructure for educational institutes and more govt colleges with equal infra so students have accessibility?
4. Can he give us freedom of expression so professors and students aren’t suspended cz they perform research and find out how the economy is failing?
5. Can he guarantee there is minimal wealth disparity so 50% of population still doesn’t feel poor?
6. Can he guarantee a fair system irrespective of our income?
7. Is he willing to invest more in education than in religious structures? Cz apparently there is so much space for temples but very little for schools and colleges.
8. Can he reduce tax burden on the middle class?
9. Can people protest to voice their discontent and to ask for their rights?
10. Can he stop enforcing his party beliefs on the people and let them live as per their will?
We go abroad cz they are providing us all these and more opportunities that we have been demanding in our country. Indian or not our opportunities broaden, our minds broaden, we get newer perspective. Even an authoritarian country like China has a better education system even if rigorous.
I I finished my BA and BEd from Mumbai University and Masters in Rome. Currently working in Australia. I am very content, well paid, even if you work as a Relief Teacher or Contract your Tier go up. I love Goa and would like to work in Goa but I will have to pay without paying you want get a Job specially for Post graduate. And Now we Goa government is selling jobs for Lakhs, not just 1 Lakh but 15-50 Lakhs. I am a person who don't encourage this mal practices. Few months ago some people have been caught so, far no action taken. I am talking for Goa. There is corruption and more people are brought from other states rather then employing locals.
The person who said that Indian don't need to go overseas, this shows that he is ignorant or have no knowledge of ground reality or he is blind.
You work abroad your rights are protected and if you complaint immediate action is take. In India there is no law no human rights.
If there is good opportunity, you should do.
Make all of them politicians like so they can make enough money.Where are the jobs.
The great interest shown and the enthusiastic response evoked indicate the real relevance of the topic of discussion.
Kudos to Ms Faye.
Better ask any young person do they want to go abroad ?
you will get answer easy
Thanks for the work you do Faye!! Good on you!
I have lived in the UK for the last 3 years. The cost of living is so exorbitantly high and also the salary growth is not amazing. It also depends on at which stage of your life you are moving abroad. When you are young, if you venture out, it makes a lot of sense but when you are a bit matured and unless you get a significant growth in salary, it is not viable. Having said that, the work life balance is so wonderful abroad. Once you are out of office, you don’t really need to worry about getting a call from your boss 😅
Last line is imp: That is what is needed... accdg to Mr. Singh!
Awesome work!
Only politicians and their oligarchs can live in India rest of the people have to leave for a better life abroad that is the true reality.
Any Indian, including me will hop on any chance to leave this country and settle somewhere else.
The richest man India has more than all 5, he has the power of mobility. He can move around anywhere in the world or have things brought to him on request.
Great topic to discuss!
The Truth is no IITian do their Masters Degree and PhD in our country, no Talented Scientist do their PhD in India, it is because our Higher Education System for Science and Technology is very poor compared to USA, Europe, China, Japan,....
Our Talented Labour Force ultimately being continually migrated to USA and Europe because what they deserve, they almost get in those countries but if they stay in our country, they will get almost nothing.
I remember once our Government told that they r extending special facilities to Corporates like reduction of Corporate Tax, Tax concession on SEZ, special tax concession on some products to encourage Businesses, if Government don't extend those facilities to our Tycoons, they will be shifted to Europe, Middle East for doing Business.
It is assumption of Government for extending facilities to Business Class though we don't know really they will be shifted or not if special privilege is not extended to them.
Our Government never got time or scope of thinking whether our Talented Labour Force would stay in our country if special privilege was extended to them or not.
I guess people doing well in India don’t usually comment on such videos. There are only two types of guys commenting - those really struggling in India and want a way to exit and those who were struggling in India and have then moved abroad and are doing better and are looking for validation that they made the right decision.
In most Western countries they respect humans and their jobs.
In depth fact based analysis of the job situation and the emigration issue. Thanks
nowadays it's not for jobs but people go abroad for lifestyle.
India is extremely overpopulated and total gdp is low. More must go out and search for opportunities. Look how Europeans are all over America, Australia etc
Indian dream is finding 15000/- per month job if YOU ARE LUCKY.Rajnath Singh is living in his BURJ KHALIFA IVORY TOWER.
Any person, irrespective of his/her nationality, must move around the world in search of better opportunities in education, learning, health, employment, business.
Dignity of job, money, environment, personal safety, that's why people leave India
Its strange that i see this video today bcos just like other times just yesterday also while talking to.someone i was mentioning that many people can be employed to do.lots of work in India esp clearing unwanted trees and shrubs in unwanted areas, the constructing theme parks or other facilities which provides opps for all ages and then i see ur this video discussion...
Thank you for this information
@fayedsouza as an entrepreneur and a tech startup i can surely say that the govt has lost the priority of research education and SME focus. Jobs are created by thousands of startups for lakhs of students. India instead of investing on technology has wasted on road builing and burdening people with tolls. This govt has failed in strenthening governance but shifted to cronies who have spoiled the full generations.
If the govt make study about the subject thoroughly, it may help the job seekers , job generators and the govt itself. It is unknown whether govt is having category-wise unemployed population. The remarks of many below this video itself give a fair idea of the situation. Merely making statement that nobody needs to go abroad will not serve any purpose.
Sr citizens are treated well, free transportation and health besides other facilities. Jobs available for all age group and many activities free and many more opportunities in UK.
As you said pvt sector employees are exploited and after retirement there are no pension apart from EPFO which is very low as against govt job
India need One Tax rule to all Individuals..
Yes , all minister children are returning to take their fathers seat ..
The widespread corruption in almost each single institute in india sucks.. I am very sure i have to pay to get license to start a business ...people are not honest..honks everywhere, noise is not considered kind of pollution...worst concern is corruption has entered into our DNA....imagine getting renew ur passport in 3 months.. The country i live u can do in an hour. Mere bharat mahan
Love and respect Faye
Family oriented youngsters must not need to go to abroad for the Living.
Returning age is 58 to 60 in India so your benefits getting start.
Returning age in US is 67 that’s not the age you can enjoy your retirement fund.
Recreation Places more in India with proper Climate,
US, Canada, UK are Cold Countries you can get Skyey, and National Parks for the Recreation with uncertainty of the weather.
Food is totally different.
Public transportation in US are not like India.
Lots of comments saying abroad is better, cleaner, etc. Yes, but the gravy train is not going to last forever. Anti-immigration sentiment and white-nationalist political parties are rising everywhere in the West. Violence may increase against Indians in Western countries, and many may be deported. Then what?
AAP and the book The Delhi Model by Jasmine Shah addresses most of the governance/infrastructure concerns Faye brings up, but nobody talks about it.
Oh this one is easy… yes!
People go abroad and work there, for better quality of ife in all respect by paying same or less amount of taxes.
Quality of higher education as well most importantly primary and secondary education even after so many year of independence is questionable... how we can have a good quality lifestyle, Are we providing equal opportunity of growth to all
As long as 2 > 1
Mr Rajnath Singh for 1 job there are 20000 persons, people fall of from balconies as seen in Gujrat..
Even after building Ram Mandir Indians are leaving India.......
The hikes went to their CEOs
Rajnath Singh is living 20 years ago
The answer will always be “yes”😅
I think India is to top heavy meaning tech and blue color heavy. India has the largest population with the majority blue collar manufacturing. India is not capitalizing on their large population as it relates to manufacturing
No jobs in india then who will send remittances . Politicians can say anything
I think the Pakora industry is flourishing in Gujarat these days.
Has she covered Atul Shubhash Case?
Pollution + Middle-class ONLY tax w/ 0 benefits + INR depreciation (and no one cares attitude) + Reservation system + (not so important reasons) Traffic, global warming impacts.
Please talk about real points !
Educated and talented should leave to teach people like the L&T CEO a lesson. I would say more but the rulers in India will retaliate.
Dignity of labour at overseas
Family oriented youngsters must not need to go to abroad for the Living.
Thanks for all your good work! 🙂
I don't exactly agree with the assertion that we are respected outside India. Doubtful.
We r proud of our Space Research Organisation ISRO but truth is there is not much Highly Innovative Scientist in ISRO, I don't know how many IITean r a working in ISRO but truth is ISRO is much behind than NASA and CNSA though a very good number Talented Scientist r working in NASA.
Our Chandrayan 3 is a prestigious performance ISRO, it is a great achievement but darkar side is it could not even withstand one Lunar Night whereas YUTU 2 Rover of CNSA is operating on Moon Surface till date since 2019,
Curiosity Rover of NASA is operating on Mars Surface since 2012. We achieved but running far behind them.
If we get answers of Why?, then only solutions available.
We all know where your loyalties lie. Wait for a year or so and you will know why our PM and Defence minister are making these statements.
I get free money abroad . Nobody ever gave me 20-30k for free every 2-3 months in india 😝.
Yes
Super comments are pouring in the comment box nothing else to add.
First get the indian managers and hr attitude right and better for work environment
You cannot change these things without being part of politics.
“yes”
It is pathetic to see even Indians are fighting in Ukraine war. It indicates Govt failures esp through Agniveer program likes.
Government has start Taxing politicians
I am one of them
It's not that foging is not done by local bodies but the expenses booking by local bodies on mosquitoes have increased by 5 to 15 times in past 5 year's.
😂😂😂😂
Sorry to say, but what was the conclusion we made here.. Just discussing is not going to make any difference whatsoever.. We all know what is wrong with our country.. We all admit them apart from our ache din wala politicians.. but Is there any way to push our corrupt politicians?? Did we talk on that aspect.. Sorry if I missed that point
He may be hinting at something else. Rise in racism overseas at indians because of soft target. जान है तो जहान है 😂
1 . Tax system , it sucks
2. Poverty is not an excuse for hygeine
3. If i say something bad about india which is actually bad then i am anti national and what not . Like cmon out tier 1 cities have the largest slum in the country perhaps the continent . You can smell the hygeine as u move through these roads
4. 'Mother ganga " stinks a lot , why treat it ljke god when u cant maintain it that way
5 . Minimal civic sense and ignorant on issues
6. Religious riots and some backward 1800s oriented people in this country begging for hindu rashtra
7. The arrogance the people of this country have stating we are vishwaguru while on the other hand the worlds 5th largest economy has the 80cr people on free ration and some women who live their life on 1500 per month provided in the name of welfare
8. Scam call centres and other tourist realted scammers
9. Toxic work culture and inefficent techies
10. For how long this country will be dependent on it industry dont we have anything else to offer
11. Shit public services , the bus trains and even airports are not well maintained except tjose in tier 1 cities , seeing all the red marks there irritates me.
Why has Rajnath sent his son abroad? Also so many BJP MLAS and MPS send their children abroad also.
the quality of research in India is very poor and most of it is copy paste from eearlier research and we do not have benchmarking of defending our research
Super simple - save more $
Yes stay unemployed here