CJI Chandrachud on ‘old boys club’ and challenges to judiciary | HTLS 2022
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 11 сен 2024
- Speaking at the 20th edition of the Hindustan Times Leadership Summit, 2022, Chief Justice of India DY Chandrachud said that the law should not be used as an instrument of oppression by those who handle it. He added that judges should have the ability to hear unheard voices and unseen faces in the system as this alone can sustain the judicial institutions in the long run. “Entering chambers of senior counsel -- it's an old boys club. How do you gain access to chambers? By tapping your connections and networks. Until we have a democratised and merit-based access to the entry point in the legal profession, we won't have more women,” said the CJI. Watch his full address here.
#dychandrachud #CJI #HTLS #chiefjustice #supremecourt #law #India #Justice #judiciary
Hindustan Times Videos bring you news, views and explainers about current issues in India and across the globe. We’re always excited to report the news as quickly as possible, use new technological tools to reach you better and tell stories with a 360 degree view to give you a better understanding of the world around you.
After listening to our CJI now I have a great hope for India.. thank you Sir for your thoughts for the Judiciary system.
Why should the collegium be not accountable to anyone? Where are the checks and balances you demand from every other institution?
First get your knowledge right ..and then comment
An innocent child 🤩
@@hiheloByby6902 Please enlighten me with your ‘knowledge’.
@@AdvAbdv “Andha Bhakt” of judges/judiciary! Opps..you’re an advocate. You have to butterup! :)
@@pritesh0117 🌞😘
A dynast. The collegium is promoting nepotism in judiciary
These buggers are always preaching here and there, while common people are suffering from judicial lethargy and incompetence.
Thanks you "न्यायमूर्ति"आप सच में न्याय हैं, आपका होना ही न्याय है, बस ये न्याय सभी जरूरतमंद व्यक्तियो को मिले.
First he should allow competitiveness & recruitment in judges, SC is not for selection & should be accountable.
Are yaar ye woke banda, Sara kuch kabad kr dega.
The only thing I like about him is that he will protect ur liberty and fos and foe.
@@rakshit8570 Are bhai tu chup re yaar, Tu chup re itna Faltu mat bola kr angrej
@@rakshit8570 he won't. All judges have double standards!
@@abhisheksumanAS well its true, I am saying he will be one of the better one to protect those rights, not saying he isn't woke, but I have seen many woke judges that converts after becoming CJI.
But until govt dont destroy their collegium system nothing gonna change.
Toh mat sun na jaahil.
Only a highly intelligent person like CJ Chandracaud can make the statements he makes which are mind-blowing. I can listen to him all day without being bored, he is my favourite SC CJ and shall remain so for the foreseeable future.
forget about women...even men's without any godfather in judiciary can't get elevated to bench or get a designation of senior advocate
Such a rich and thought provoking address. There is a reason why he is considered as the finest judge in our country in the recent times.
Fantastic! We, citizens of India, are under the safe custody and leadership of Hon.CJI D. Chandrachud who has dealt with every aspect of the Indian Judiciary. The marginalized, dearth of women justices , weak infrastructure at the rural places, gender equality, challenges of social media in the age of internet and the limitations of the Judiciary. I am reminded of Justice V R Krishna Aiyer's and Justice O Chinnappa Reddy's eloquent speeches and judgements in favour of the oppressed laymen. Salute to your concern for the common man, Sir. Your baritone voice reverberates heralding a new epoch! Thanking "Hindustan Times" for the wonderful leadership summit, - Kumaraguruparan R, Chennai.
Like upsc cse...judges should be recruited through examination in HC,SC.
Actually there is an exam called HJS exclusively for lawyers to be directly recruited as ADJ at the age of 35.....So it somehow expedites their elevation to DJ and eventually as HC justice(when compared to those in lower judiciary through state judiciary exam) ....But to be directly recruited at the HC or SC , unlike any machanism like upsc, you must appear to be expedient to the collegium.....
@Udith Bhaskar Doddapalani do you want judiciary to be Bollywood 2.0?
Woke Liberandu Intellectual people found "patriarchy" everywhere in Indian Culture. But the most patriarchal, misogynistic, women suppressive, bigot, regressive culture which also have in India came by invasion from middle east they don't say a single word against it.
So their motive is not to be against patriarchy but to spread negativity and attack a single community 🙏
*_"India's biggest enemy not behind the border but inside the border"_*
- No one special said it, me.. Common sense 🤷♂️
It's time for the judiciary to bring social transformation for India to keep up with modern times and ethos.
And that transformation should start with dumping representation of wokes and pseudo - liberals such as Mr. Chandrachud himself from the holy post of CJI..
What about a democratised and merit-based access to the entry point in the Supreme Court judiciary? Absolute hypocrite.
Exactly ! Reformations should start with bringing wokes and pseudo - liberals like Chandrachud down.
Yes CJI, but present model of Caste system introduced during the rule of Mughals and British is not yet eliminated by judiciary or political parties after 1947, in 75 years. There are many issues in judiciary, not only undue delay but political leanings, left / right ideology, corruption , exceeding judicial jurisdiction , dynasty etc
While there are serious issues in democracy, why not resolve the issues within judiciary to start with and let us solve democratic issues after setting our own house in order ?
Good man please kindly spread this message to every corner of the social media spectrum and amongst your circles 🙏 We cannot allow Lies to spread regarding our civilization, culture and traditions.
Caste system introduced during the Mughal rule (1526 onwards -) Ha ha...from where did you learn history?
@@abhiramiramachandran1062 please enlighten me if there is any reference in any vedas or upnishads about present model of caste system
Selection of judges should be transparent .
U know our SC doesn't allow us t communicated in hindi or regional language and we are asking to UN To recognised in Hindi ...
It is not with the SC. Please read the Constitution of India properly.
This guy is the example of .. What's app University Graduate 🤣🤣🤣 I mean.. anything and everything..kuch biii
Beautiful speech may god keep justice chandrachud always blessed 🙏 🙏 very sincere and thought provoking
It's a blessing to have this guy as our CJI when our constitution and society are threatened by all sides.
CJI D Y Chandrachuda sir we need you .
Woke! Product of collegium system
स्वागतार्ह दिशानिर्देश ! धन्यवाद
Great speech , comprehensive explanation and suggestions to improve judiciary. I salute your suggestion Jai hind and Jai bharat
No CJI, CLAT/JEE/NEET are not based on mugging up. CLAT checks for basic math proficiency, you cannot mug it up, Even the GK section is based on whether the candidate reads newspapers or not, nothing is asked beyond that, whether he has the capability to interlink various subjects and make an intelligent guess even if he does not know the answer, negative marking helps here to prevent blind guessing. Similarly the English section checks for verbal ability, since that is the language of the courts. Why don't you just say you want to implement proportional quota and ensure proportional outcomes? Why bend the definition of merit so that the groups who will avail from this redefinition do not feel an inferiority complex for not meeting the standards? Why don't you publish the average cgpas and their correlation with the entrance test scores pre and post this redefinition of merit?(assuming atleast within the college standards remain the same, unlike Tamil Nadu where they had to lower the ceiling so that everyone remain happy)? Entrance exams are not selecting for good people, they select for whether the candidate can meet the rigor of UG and have a fair shot of scoring a 10 pointer, they correlate best with academic success.
Indian entrance examination system is probably the most fair meritorious selection system that you can have with such a large population even after the reservation policy of 70% of the seats. You want to redefine merit , sure go ahead, bring in the letter of recommendation system and extra curricular and other criteria, let us see then what happens to merit and social justice? You think you are too smart by half, but you ain't judge. Probably your own son did not make it to a top indian college for his UG such as an NLU but thanks to your own connections made it abroad for masters, where such connections are more handy and since then you have some complex.
Why not just randomly allot students without any tests, abolish all exams and destroy standardisation, let us see how long your universities and institutions stand. The republic will collapse within a century.
Implement Caste and Gender Quotas in the Officer Entry of the Indian Military as well while you are at it, even that institution needs to collapse if we are gonna go the whole hog on reservation.
Excellent. Of course no test can predict how well the person will perform later in his profession and anyway that is not the intention of entrance test checking for his merit. What wrong is there in taking coaching classes when even few marks matter in intense competitive environment in our country and that is good. Of course some students may not able to afford it but what can be done? Anyway concessions are there for the best but can't afford. Some parents are responsible and ensure that their children study well and some parents are not but that is no excuse to accommodate the less merited.
You have a good point in exposing the western system that kills our merit system by including literary activities, recommendation etc.
Exactly, reg education system also I believe most things are done in correct direction. I am of the belief that existing solution should be criticized with presenting a proposed solution
We have a huge hope for our nation. I am currently in love with our CJI. 🌸
Nepo kid
What a speech!!
Leadership Summit also looks very patriarchal!
Sometime we find even judges strongly rebuking a litigant. or a lawyer or even a govt official or even a government or minister. Often this rebuking expose the judge of his ideology or belief in the personal level. Is such a practice healthy for the common man to repose faith in the judge's impartiality.
Justice system should be upto mathematical correctness , not on biologIcal based miscarriages . Because judges deals with cases of life and death , but astonishing fact is this , sometimes three judges give three different verdicts for same case , is justice system is based upon individual mindset opinion or on law formulas ? Without filling the flaws in justice system only name " justice done " will be a misleading word .
Great sir🙏.. One request.. Make judiciary Non Corrupt and Accountable..
National treasure ... India is great because of such people
My heart ❤❤❤❤
My heart good morning sir thank you sir Jai Hind Jai Hind Jai Bharat l lndian sir Hi sir
In Supreme court how many holidays in a year ❓❓❓
Sab tere jaise pakhala khake nalle thoda hi baithe hain.😀😀😀😀😀
My country is in safe hands, with J Chandrachud as CJI. just hope that results of the changes appear in my lifetime !.
' Stern daughter voice of God O duty how do I honour a rod to check earrings and reprove ' Thank God
If the Supreme Court has trust in the lower courts for them to make independent decisions, without fear or favour, and if the SC is able to support their decisions on appeal, I am sure the SC will not be inundated with many minor cases and issues and will not have to face a backlog of cases. What the SC can do is lay down guidelines for the lower courts to follow on how they can decide cases and appropriate training should be given to them by judges who are selected for this purpose.
These judges are not delivering justice according to constitution but their woke opinions.
🙏🙏
Indian Judiciary is doomed...litigants will suffer more now.
1कानून पारदर्शी बने, निर्णय एक निश्चित अवधि अनुसार बने... बहुत अधिक विलम्ब भी वास्तविकता से दूर करता है....
2सशक़्त संभाषण.... विभिन्न पहलुओं को सटीक अभिव्यक्त किया गया... जय भारत
Great personality ❤
Your perspective is biased and ill informed. How collegium system has broadened the justice?
Member security Council International
Would give speech on
Global Civilisation
And
Its
Evaluation
I am scared of that this woke joker will be at top of our judiciary system
What a man what a cji... Who truly understands the pain of litigants🙏
Everyone understands. It's just that nobody wants to change, all they want is keep talking about this.
For Example: Congress is better in bringing schemes but BJP better in implementation.
Justice chandrachud has assumed office as CJI . As he is a highly qualified person will he bring about this urgent changes in judiciary ? : (Unfortunately he does not know what is happening in his backyard. PLEASE ALLOW Party-in-persons to argue their cases with out the mischief of registry : Asking silly questions, Raising silly defects, sleeping over it for years and finally ensuring dismissal of case by mischief in defects stage itself and that is happening in Supreme Court and the judges are looking the other side !! The judges are colluding with the registry to do that !!)
1. In high courts any appeal on decision of single judge must go to a bench of odd number of judges. If CJ is part of bench other judges on bench should be selected by another judge and not CJ. ( There should not be any even nuumber judges bench at all)
2. Any judgement that does not counter all the points raised in a petition should be automatically considered null and void
3.Any judgement must consider all the evidences presented and not a few selective ones .Otherwise the judgement should be considered null and void
(Points 2 & 3 is already there in judges training manual of UP. A team citizens should monitor a case and ensure compliance. Just like jury but unlike jury system here the citizens should be given a check list .)
4. Any defect raised by registry maybe contested and should be resolved only by a judge this will prevent mischief by registry and now the registry is law unto itself raising silly defects
5.A party in person should be allowed to argue his case without giving any reason and without answering irrelevant questions like why he cannot engage a lawyer ? etc and without undergoing irrelevant procedures made to harass him and to finally drive him out or to force him to accept a lawyer
6. Most important the registrar or secretary general should not be allowed to make any rule without approval from a committee of judges appointed by CJI
7. Also cji should form a committee of judges to do a weekly review of the progress made by the registry. Today registry and secretary general are uncountable. cji should assert his authority over the secretary general.
Lawyers are least concerned about the flaws in the system but are only after collecting their fee.Please note it is not just speedy justice that is required but also high quality, fair judgment that is more important. However today it is totally lacking in judgements of High courts. Litigants wait for years but judges dispose of cases with out even reading the petition. Only option left for litigants is to go on appeal but even there situation is same or worse.
Email it to SC
Judicial overreach in some matters and being wishy-washy in some others is not equitable. Woke judiciary is a big threat to Indian nation as blindly imposing western values on Indian nation is not justice.
🙏💐💐💐💐🙏
So sensible word this man spoke!
Boy no wonder we are still a colonized society and with folks like him (so far removed from the society ) and language which majority of Indians don’t understand - we will continue to be so
Personally, I have high regard for women lawyers and judges in that they take their duties seriously and can be trusted in reaching an appropriate judgement.
Your Lordship..please Take a note of Threat to Security of Subordinate Judicial Officer's ..
Can ordinary citizens read and understand cases easily available through the internet by the courtesy of the judiciary when the lawyers themselves have problems understanding the judgements as there is no finality and is subject to different interpretations and not forgetting legal jargon? The solution is to simplify the law by the court and judges themselves, they should use simple language and avoid complicated language. The lay citizen should be allowed an audience in the lower courts and allowed to present themselves with the court's assistance on the procedures to be followed.
Justice in will woke up in laughable way.
U know Rular has been changed but way of ruling is same in case of judiciary. ...
@@hiheloByby6902 look like something burning go get burnolll...
Recently SC has free gang rape person who were already convicted in rape charges by HC ...
And last how much u are literate can be explain just by ur choice of word
Ishwar aapko sat buddhi de....
*Stop the Summer vacation holidays for courts, it was for Britishers, as they used to sail back to UK as they could not bear Indian summer, now India is a free country and the judges are not British, Indian judges can bear Indian Summer, already their are tons of pending cases*
There is a need to have a time frame within which to dispose of the case.
Though judiciary considers that ‘justice hurried is justice buried,’
it is certain that it takes lightly of the sad plight of the ‘victims.’ Placing
itself in the ‘accused box,’ the Supreme Court of India observes that
‘where the termination is questioned as invalid or illegal, the workman
has to go through the gamut of litigation and his capacity to sustain
himself throughout the protracted litigation is itself such an awesome
factor that he may not survive to see the day when relief is granted.
More so in our system where the law’s proverbial delay has become
stupefying.
You’re accessible to all but it also mean you’re delaying justice for so many. Delayed Justice is NO justice at all!
This man may do more severe damage to a certain community and it's a obvious guess among majority of people in the country. But with 2024 approaching fast, lots of high drama is bound to happen in SC.
What about providing justice in citizens own mother tongue? I have seen so many citizens turned down because they can’t speak English. Simply saying, we are translating judgements is not sufficient.
would be interesting if ralk is limited to reforms and appoiintent of judges and accountabiliyt incluging delcarling thier assets
Very lucid perspective of CJI 👏👏
All accountable Answerable including Country PM n CMs but not Justices. You can’t raise questions coz of contempt of court.
I would be confined to the rights or wrongs no philosophy Logic
harward liberal club yaha bhi aagaya
gaan jal raha hai kya re bhakt mcc anpado ka fauj ho tum aur india ka daag
@@fullvillagefood1299 pehle thoda adhyayan karo ma ke laude tumhari bhaasa se pata chalta hai kitne padhe likhe ho aur liberals ko oppose krnewale ko conservative kaha jaata hai aur mai ek hindu hoon aur har ek hindu jo apne dharm ka paalan krta hai usko bhakt kehte hai
.pehle bhakta ka matlab Jaan le bhsdke
I do not know rights or wrongs but why the things.....?
Did you respect the decision of trial court in case of Azam Khan? You insulted lower courts by demeaning their judgement
And who's at the leadership summit
One person Shahrukh Khan and one person getting Salman Khan
he must be cji of britain
the language which speaks more than 70% rural indian not able to understand
court is made for whom???????????????????????????????
Feministic judge. All feministic matters
Looking very young and brilliant
Objective proliferation of objects without objections to abjections...???
The Indian judiciary should decide matters before them impartially, on the basis of facts and in accordance with the law, without any restrictions, improper influences, inducements, pressures, threats or interferences, direct or indirect, from any quarter or for any reason. There is a possible threat from the executive trying to wield their power and silence the judiciary and such a threat also exists from the legislative body i.e. the parliament. A balance in power is needed, no individual or group - legislative, executive, or judicial - should have too much power. The judiciary should be able to check the Prime Minster's power when he tries to overstep them or tries to resort to laws when it suits him or his party, otherwise not. The SC judiciary should ensure the rights of ordinary citizens are protected and the fact that the Indian SC is prepared to look at minor cases is a credit to them as this does not happen in the Western democracy where the SC only takes major groundbreaking law proposals or challenges as a criterion before they can intervene.
Lagta hai womania ho gya hai
There is a constant effort to create a perception that the judicial system lacks speed in justice delivery... The collaboration between legislative and executive for self interest in majority of the cases is the main reason for such a delay, coupled with deliberate lack of amenities, workforce and systems for the effective judicial system...
Monologue
Can't ask anything.
The media persons disturbance and the state of Haryana from Bombay Bollywood disturb the whole of Haryana culture
The Other lady who was there was having a son
Supreme court judge must Reed Gita and beda shatra 👍
This Junior Chandra bud gimsrlc us a member of the old boys club in High/ and Supreme Courts in India. His father was also a Supreme Court Chief Justice. What is this Chandra bud Jr talking about? .
Do ladkiyon ka mere pass hisab
Stem70%crk
Per Nagar Nigam chahie donon ko bata raha hai aur nature off work per bata raha hai
There are serious offenses committed on women in this country especially in states like UP with the backing of political class and police. We need law with preferential treatment for women till normalcy is restored.
Serious monitoring is required about enforcement of inheritance laws.Women still are denied their due share.
This patriarchal family set up still need to undergo a drastic evolution even before we start thinking about gender equality.
Has illicit affair with teesta Setalvad
To Jo yah Ladki Ko Nahin pahunchne problem but it was the problem on which FIR was made usko Banaya Gaya Tha Is Tarah Se FIR Tarik se Banaya Gaya Tha profile per
Boring
World health organization Geneva
Would give me
Technology award
World peace would give me
Doctorate in
Education
President of USA
Announced
Arunava Dasgupta
Man of
America
Virginia University
Would give me
Law degree
Bengali baby who was hidden hair with the baby he was not opening that paper
How can you say that Homosexuality is alright. It is completely against the oracles of God Amighty. Is this man greater than God.?
You are Christian?
Independent kha badh desh kha kanoon badhana chahiye tha congress kha rajya mai chorom se milkher chaltha raha farsi logh muslim kho ristha banaya indhira gandhi ji firos se shaadhi khiya asoothran loghom kha dhaaga indhiraji kha gale mai baandha abh badhal gaya wakth hindhu sanathanan rashtre kha barath mitti kha ethihas indian fundemental rights kha constitution se sachayi se banane kha khaam aap loghom kha jameedhari hai har cheej usmai hona chahiye new parliment building mai vo bhi uska undher chahiye seetha rastha road mai sacha histori kithabh mai jai bharath sanathana bharath
Ladies naukar Kuchh kah Nahin Sakte bekar aadami
Judiciary Independency in India based on British colonial legislation after Independence temporarily incorporated in constitution superseded preamble of constitution now acceptable to people in democracy ,बाबा साहब का संविधान सुब्रतो राय सहारा घोटाला लाखों भारतीयों के करोडों करोडों services के पैसे भ्रमित गुमराह कर लूटे जजों मन्त्रियों सरकारी अधिकारियों के दलाल सुबरातो राय बाबा अंबेडकर साहिब के अनुयायी हैं ज़ुल्म शौषण भ्रस्टाचार हुड़दंग पत्रकारों की चुपी क्यों?बाबा साहब दलालों पत्रकारों माफिया ग्रुप जजों वकीलों नेताओं सरकारी अधिकारियों के लिए महान है जमीन अवैध क़ब्ज़ा, अवैध निर्माण अवैध खनन अवैध धंधे, अवैध drugs अवैध जुआ अवैध शराब economic crimes corruption करने वालों के लिए है संविधान में ब्रिटिश कॉलोनियल सिस्टम अस्थायी आज़ादी के बाद 75 वर्षों से परिवर्तन सुधार उन्मूलन का प्रावधान नहीं है। ब्रिटिश कॉलोनियल rules of laws उन्मूलन के लिए टिप्पणी करना वर्जित है संसद लोकतांत्रिक कल्याण कारी कानून निर्माण पर बैंड फ़िर ब्रिटिश कॉलोनियल rules of laws संविधान का आवश्यक मौलिक ढांचे जो preamble of constitution के बदले संविधान का आवश्यक मौलिक ढांचे उसे keshvanand Bharti case verdict में वर्जित है। कैसा लोकतंत्र ?Constitution is implicit irresponsible undefined oppressive unchangeable no provisions to abolish British colonialism system temporarily incorporated in constitution, Maximum number of advocates judges patrakars political leaders administrative machineries including judges are agents of British colonialism,
MP MLA MANTRI elevated representatives other than judges followers of alien rules of laws British colonialism legislation temporarily incorporated in constitution are given oath of allegiance to imperial power of imperialistic state rests with imperial crown temporarily incorporated in democracy in India आज़ादी के बाद 60% of
population of India are dalals agents of British colonialism system never raised voices against 5 crore backlog cases and 17-18 lakh people in jail without trial exposed on 10.07.2017 in PIL N0 224 0f 2017 when chief Justice Jagdish Singh Khehar now retired and Justice Dy.Chandra chur now chief Justice condemned frivolous imposing Rs one lakh costs upon petitioner Raj Balam Sharma Advocate Supreme Court demanding abolition of colonialism from India not acceptable to people in democracy
Dr बाबा साहब बलि का बकरा 1950 में जब ब्रिटिश कॉलोनियल rules of laws temporarily incorporated in constitution superseded preamble of constitution Judges are not entitled to appoint judges because Supreme power rests with people and political parties to lay down democratic guidelines outcome of deliberations by collective wisdom of actions and reactions of opinions of intellectual delegates of people representing parliament to enact democratic laws to carry out the wishes of people in democracy, observed by Dr Ambedkar sahib Vivek Debroy adviser of Prime Minister Narendra Modi scrutinized complaints dated 19.07.2017 submitted to Government of India by Raj Balam Sharma Advocate Supreme Court now Government took initiative to remodel abolish British colonialism from India by setting up new constitution 2023.for change of British colonialism legislation incorporated temporarily in constitution
लार्ड माउंट बेटन अंतरिम आज़ाद भारत सरकार वायसराय आज़ादी के बाद अस्थायी unchangeable अपरिवर्तनशील ब्रिटिश कॉलोनियल rules of laws imperial powers of imperialistic state rested with imperial crown temporarily incorporated in constitution superseded preamble of constitution who ever comes in power after election like MP MLA MANTRI including Supreme Court High court judges and products of UPSC are given oath of allegiance to imperial power rejecting overhauling proposal of professor KT Shah member of constitutional drafting committee making Dr Ambedkar sahib scapegoat and no provisions to abolish British colonialism from India,
I will take oath
In the
Year
2027
Nobel Committee chairman
And
This year 23
Nobel Committee would Confered with Noble Prize in science
And
Member International Court of justice
And
International Criminal Court
Peace place
Havue
The Netherland s
Oxford law University
Would give me
Doctorate in law
Royal family
Would
Give me
Lord tittle
Member
IMF
Would
Confered with
Doctorate in Econmy
Asian Constries
Would give me
Best civilian award
Cambridge University
Would give me
Doctorate in Science
Mm
NASA USA
Would give me
Doctorate in Mechanical engineering
MIT
USA
Accepted my
Formula
And
Would give me
Mechanical engineering degree
OSCAR
My
Biopic
By
Universal
Picture
Paramount pictures
Richest studio
In
In the world
meaningless meandering ,