How an Apology Creates a Turning Point in ‘Women Talking’ | Anatomy of a Scene

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 окт 2024

Комментарии • 53

  • @xyrildanmanuel783
    @xyrildanmanuel783 Год назад +63

    crazy that the whole scene with autje walking towards her mom and jesse buckley breaking down was spontaneous

    • @johnnystob4037
      @johnnystob4037 Год назад +4

      fr! that was the most heartbreaking moment in the film for me

  • @Ring0fSaturn
    @Ring0fSaturn 8 месяцев назад +7

    Wow. This video really helped me to understand the film so much better and to appreciate the heartfelt collaboration of all the actors.

  • @toasted_.coconut
    @toasted_.coconut Год назад +102

    This is the apology I spent the majority of my life wishing I'd hear from my own mother.

    • @zoefang4563
      @zoefang4563 Год назад +2

      This is the apology I wished I would hear from my own dad.

    • @CGMedia2023
      @CGMedia2023 2 месяца назад

      right...

  • @anthonycarlos4146
    @anthonycarlos4146 Год назад +49

    What a wonderful film. Cannot believe that there was spontaneity in this scene. All three actresses moved so elegantly in response to the others performance so well that I for sure thought it was written in. Great stuff!

    • @marcusclark1339
      @marcusclark1339 9 месяцев назад

      its literally mediocre smear piece on men, just a misandrist movie
      ruclips.net/video/3IpKL8FJ5QU/видео.html

  • @lahlem6725
    @lahlem6725 Год назад +24

    Kind of hard seeing somebody get a kind of apology that I never will

    • @megandeytoth448
      @megandeytoth448 Год назад +5

      That makes sense. I am sorry you never got the apology.

    • @marcusclark1339
      @marcusclark1339 9 месяцев назад

      the movie is horrendous
      ruclips.net/video/3IpKL8FJ5QU/видео.html

  • @esinyenetabo2356
    @esinyenetabo2356 Год назад +37

    People should take appology seriously! God hates abuse. Not divorce. Get out of an abusive environment

    • @kwill84
      @kwill84 Год назад +5

      Exactly they even say forgiveness can be misinterpreted as permission

    • @lyndawilliams4570
      @lyndawilliams4570 Год назад +1

      Amen

    • @kimberlyrobinson3992
      @kimberlyrobinson3992 Год назад +3

      Don’t distort the Bible. God hates both divorce and abuse. However, that doesn’t mean a woman should stay in a house where she’s being abused. Either make the man go or go yourself.
      Any man who abuses his wife will face God and have to deal with Him.

  • @liv-bv3pl
    @liv-bv3pl 7 месяцев назад +1

    “Im sorry” 3 times was possibly the most powerful moment in the movie

  • @FilmPepe2024
    @FilmPepe2024 14 дней назад

    I saw this movie with my mom and by the end of it we were both breaking down for different reasons, I was angry and she was sad but we were both broken and sobbing

  • @Aleakwe
    @Aleakwe Год назад +2

    brilliance and moved. i have not experienced DV but know I will never experience a "meaningful apology" from enabling relatives who do not see themselves as emotional abusers, despite everyone knowing the truth, facts and evidence

    • @marcusclark1339
      @marcusclark1339 9 месяцев назад

      ruclips.net/video/3IpKL8FJ5QU/видео.html
      its a mediocre misandrist movie

  • @carmtiff
    @carmtiff 3 месяца назад

    Ww-oooooow. This is on my list of movie to see but I live great character development and genuine human dynamics that occur beyond the dialogue.

  • @mkallai
    @mkallai Год назад +3

    Hi, thanks for these videos! It would be nice if we could watch the "Tár" | Anatomy of a Scene episode here. Are you planning to upload it? Thank you!

  • @hyunvinh
    @hyunvinh Год назад +8

    The meaning full and amazing scene. i love it

  • @cathykemp9146
    @cathykemp9146 Год назад +6

    Absolutely beautiful. Sarah is a goddess!

  • @kingclover1395
    @kingclover1395 9 месяцев назад +9

    This is the most despicable movie I have ever seen. Even my girlfriend thought it was horrible. It should have won 50 Razzie Awards instead of Oscars.

  • @CGMedia2023
    @CGMedia2023 2 месяца назад +2

    levels of misandry that I never thought existed.

  • @HayshishTV
    @HayshishTV 11 месяцев назад +9

    now that film looks like one huge piece of dung

  • @Christianna73
    @Christianna73 Год назад

    Such a good movie ❤

    • @marcusclark1339
      @marcusclark1339 9 месяцев назад

      its not and has no real point
      ruclips.net/video/3IpKL8FJ5QU/видео.html

  • @kurbads74
    @kurbads74 Год назад +2

    Is Lubyanka in charge? Clearly!

  • @13cornstar
    @13cornstar Год назад +3

    I’m just here to make fun of the NYT for Raccoon dog! 😂

  • @Coco61525
    @Coco61525 Год назад +4

    Hey New York Times, how come you don’t talk about the cop that you quietly retracted the story over January 6.🤭💯

  • @MikhailAbbot
    @MikhailAbbot Год назад +2

    Всем Добрый День. Нашему Поколению 50-60 лет, Полезно Было бы Обратиться К Жизненному Опыту... Наших Предшественников из минувших эпох: Чтоб Научиться... Быть Снисходительными... К Людям, Но Требовательны... К Себе. Лишь Только Поступки... Нравственности Созидают... Социум Людей и Мотивируют... Оных Жить По Кодексу... Совести и Чести. Конечно же, Никто Из Нас Не Совершенен. Но Мы Должны Стараться... Достойно Жизни Путь... Пройти. Чтобы Благоразумными Людьми Остаться.

  • @brevedad1
    @brevedad1 Год назад +3

    another point against transactivism

  • @jbagger331
    @jbagger331 Год назад +4

    Fiction, just like everything else NYT produces.

  • @tyrranicalt-rad6164
    @tyrranicalt-rad6164 Год назад +6

    I'd like to hear the male Mennonite opinion of this movie 🤔

    • @elizabethhenning778
      @elizabethhenning778 Год назад +42

      Look everyone, the NotAllMen guy is here 😂

    • @5Xum
      @5Xum Год назад +8

      You can go and ask them in their cell in Bolivia, they aren't going anywhere for a while...

    • @lyndawilliams4570
      @lyndawilliams4570 Год назад +1

      Tryrrant is it?…..that says so much already

    • @jenniek8391
      @jenniek8391 Год назад +2

      Yes, let's hear what the rapists and abusers have to say 🙄

    • @cheesecakeisgross4645
      @cheesecakeisgross4645 8 месяцев назад

      @@elizabethhenning778 Not even that. it's BarelyAnyMen.

  • @atlanta2076
    @atlanta2076 Год назад +4

    When I heard about the title of this movie, I knew I'd rather watch the spiteful Velma-series forwards and backwards. And this scene confirms what I thought. It's so shallow and vapid. Surely it's unacceptable to hit anyone. But no one ever dares posing the question: «What's the last thing she said?». I can't wait for the sequel «Men Not Listening».

    • @kwill84
      @kwill84 Год назад +25

      You clearly didn’t pay attention if you called this film shallow and vapid. This film is one of the best I’ve seen in a long time.

    • @lordofthefemoids9234
      @lordofthefemoids9234 Год назад +35

      Hmmm... the simple title "women talking" invoked such a negative reaction in you. I wonder what kind of person both finds the concept of women talking so angering, and implies that domestic violence can be justified if the woman is being disagreeable 🤔🤔🧐
      By the way, did you know that this movie is based on a real instance of men in a Mennonite community drugging/raping local women and girls in their sleep, that the victim's ages ranged from 3 years old to 65, and that the male dominated church authority did in fact tell the women that it was Satan or ghosts that committed the rapes? I wish that angered you half as much as the title "Women Talking" does.

    • @talb.1805
      @talb.1805 Год назад +7

      Let's consult Wikipedia: en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manitoba_Colony,_Bolivia

    • @talb.1805
      @talb.1805 Год назад

      You're so spiteful and full of hatred that you'd rather stay ignorant rather than learning something. Watch the film. It's not Velma, it's oscar-nominated

    • @falgalhutkinsmarzcal3962
      @falgalhutkinsmarzcal3962 9 месяцев назад +2

      ​@@talb.18058 were guilty, but this movie frames everyone in the community as guilty or involved in a coverup, which is completely contrary to the wiki you linked.

  • @iknowthisone6844
    @iknowthisone6844 9 месяцев назад +2

    i dont understand this video at all, bye

  • @paullowman9131
    @paullowman9131 Год назад +3

    FREE ASSANGE