Pretty Little Liars: Everything We Know About Bethany Young
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 3 окт 2024
- Everything we know about Bethany Young. Her strong link with the DiLaurentis, Hastings and Cavanaugh family leads me to believe her death may be a part of the "Big A" motive! Theory videos to come, just thought this video was needed. Comment your thoughts below, subscribe for more awesome videos and follow us on twitter @PLLheadA
PLL has taught me a lesson : NEVER wear the same outfit in the same day of other girls...trust me you will regret it
Mari Rodriguez _ Never Lie
_ Never kept a dark secrets to yourself because someone will find out
_ Fake your own death to get attention
_ Never go after your friends boyfriends
I know now I will only make my own clothes... no getting buried alive for me lmao.
Bethany's voice on that tape sounds exactly like Sarah's whatt
***** True but I think it's a coincidence
+Becky Clough then maybe bethany and sara are twins
Probably the same person lol
Good doggo Coco dock 👌 doggo forgot
@The.Sisters. _ how do you know this?🤦♂️
I still think its so weird that we have never seen a picture, video, flashback or anything with bethany's face in it, so we have no idea what she looks like.
@Addison Rae Edits what episode
Rosie Love season 6 where "cece drake" told ali everything while being in a room at radley.
@@emilydebridge7145 ohhhhh yea thank you!!!
Rosie Love np!
jason saw melissa and bethany talking, and there was a flashback of her when she was young
The second yellow dress was for Cece/Charlotte. In season 6 ep 10. Cece tells Ali that every time Mrs.D bought clothes for Ali, she bought the same for Charlotte.
maybe ali gave bethany that top because ali knew A wanted to kill her that night. This way maybe A would confuse Bethany for Ali and kill her instead
thank u ! :)
But Ali is a
The only A back then was Mona, so if A wanted somebody dead, that person would've been Mona she's the one who created the game
Cianna Lamontagne Alison is being framed. she is not A.
but i always thought Bethany is A. also Bethany killed mona. i have all the spoilers.
but not who A is.
but i do have a lot of spoilers.
isabella pace How do u have spoilers? where did u get them from
The situation now is too complicated for me to comprehend lol I need to rewatch the whole thing starting from Pilot to clear up my mind
Same here
So. Three people with a yellow top. Alison, Bethany and Cece. I think Cece is A. If not, then I think it's Noel Kahn or Jason. Although I hope it isn't Jason to be honest, he seems really nice. I feel sorry for his struggles with alcohol addiction, and oh did I mention he's super hot :P
It's super coincidental there were three blonde girls that September night walking around the DiLaurentis/Hastings backyard without anyone being like, what the hell is going on? I definitely think Cece could be 'A' aswell! Great theories by the way, and yes Jason is very good looking!
I think the same exact thing, I think CeCe is A too and I got suspicious about Noel Kahn when he wasn't at Mona's funeral, its strange because they used to date and another thing that made me suspicious was when he broke into the Marin house to help Alison.
"A" is an evil closet crossdresser and Alison found out about his secret.
That's how it started.
Ghaltouni lol that's hilarious LOL, I never thought of that one
sydni cockerham I just looked it up, and guess what? It's an actual theory lol.
Noel Khan's father was a crossdresser in the books, but since he's not a major character in the TV show, fans suspect that a one of the male major characters will turn out to be a crossdresser.
10:37 The rock with the blood makes a smiley face. :D
and that voice sound like SARA..that's why I think Sara is really BETHANY
Melissa is Bethany
Awesome job hun! You did such a good job putting this all together with the clips and exact episodes. Please keep them comming!
Thanks so much! I'm so glad you liked the video. More videos to come!
LOVE IT!!! There's one issue that I'm having with the burials though.
If we go with Ali's version of events from 4x24, then she was knocked out from behind, half-way woke up to see her mom burying her (though somehow, kept her eyes closed enough to still appear dead), was pulled out by Mrs. Grunwald, and then Mona found her and advised her to disappear. Meanwhile, someone else (Bethany) is killed in the same way Ali was hit and that's all Ali knows. This story doesn't work for several reasons. One is that Mrs. D would know where she buried Ali. Who buries someone, then allows people to work and dig around that same area? That would be asking for trouble. So she would have buried Ali somewhere else on the property, not at the gazebo. However, since Bethany's body was found there, she would have known it wasn't Ali because that's not where she buried her.
In Melissa's version, she sees that Spencer is walking around with a shovel and then she spots a body (Bethany). She then rolls the body directly into an already-dug grave, which Bethany happened to be laying right next to (isn't that convenient?). That would mean that Ali hadn't been buried yet, as the hole wasn't filled in. We know, however, that this happened at the gazebo since that is where the body was recovered from. So from that, would that mean Ali was buried on top of Bethany? I doubt it.
I think a very important thing to remember here is that Ali tells the girls about her mom burying her alive, and the next thing we know, Mrs. D is dead, supposedly out of revenge. However, we'll never hear Mrs. D's side of this from her since she conveniently died right after Ali told her story. So technically, Ali can't be proven a liar on that one. That makes me think that her story is definitely made up.
Side note, this is all so confusing, I now need to take a nap lol
I'm in the works of this theory at the moment! Trying to puzzle together who was buried first and where etc. Feel free to DM on Twitter to help with the theory!
Pretty Little Liars Definitely! I'd love to help out.
MightBeParanoid1 Both girls were buried where the gazebo was being built. There was no more digging, the workers were just going to come and pour the cement the following morning, so it was the perfect place to dispose of a body.
I think the burials went down like this: Ali got out of the grave, so it became more or less empty. Somebody came around and hit Bethany and then Melissa buried her in the spot that Ali had escaped from.
Tom Gill Oh you mean the soon to be grave(s)/ gazebo was already dug up before any bodies were buried! That makes sense!
melissa admitted to burying bethany, thinking it was ali because she was wearing the yellow top. according to jason's memory of that night, melissa was talking to cece and cece was also wearing the yellow top. surely she would have checked to make sure it wasn't cece she was burying?
i get your point but she saw Spencer fighting with Ali which is why she thought she was burring Ali.
wondermus Altough we don't know if Melissa actually buried "Bethany". She didn't say "I buried Bethany young". She said something like "she was a stranger and I buried her alive".
Why is Mrs. Dilherentis having an affair with everyone?
The voice on the tape recorder is IDENTICAL to Sara Harvey's voice. Twins? Both are big A? Quite possibly.
all these theories make my head spin! I'm so tired of guessing, I want to know alrdy!
already
that yellow top traveled quite a mile
Is it just me or does Bethanys voice on that tape sound just like Sarah Harvey
The Voice of Bethany sounds like Saras..
Tut utu Noticed that too ! Did they do it on purpose or is it just a coincidence ? Don't know if they had planned Sara would come back at that point..
Melissa is Bethany
I think Sara Harvey that was pulled out of the dollhouse is Bethany. First of all, the website with the old "missing girl" post about Sara has a picture of a girl that is NOT the one who is pulled out of the dollhouse. So Sara is probably dead and in Bethany's grave. Bethany obviously had a cheating father, so her mom probably ended up dumping the father. "sara" also claimed in episode 6x03 her dad is gone and makes it sound like he wasn't a good person. Another thing I noticed was how Tanner was very obsessed with Bethany's death and pinned it on Spencer without much proof. Maybe Tanner was the mother, after all she is shady and hasn't had a big secret yet. Plus right after "Sara" is found, she takes a leave of absence on the police force so I think she is the blonde girl's mom. Just a guess.
Now I can fuxk with that..that is a good theory.. tanner is CREEPY.!and she look sneaky.. GREAT JOB.
I think Sarah is Bethany because i remember in one of the episodes one of the girls were saying Sara and cece both knew each other in Radley and then hear this "supposedly" Bethany had died but once all the girls got out of the doll house Sara was the last one out wearing the same thing as Alison so maybe cece thought it was Sara that night who she hit on the back of the head with a rock but when she saw it was Alison she got the wrong person but then again Sara was underground for years and years and maybe she killed Charlotte for revenge
Melissa is Bethany
@@emilykossen1997 HELP WHAT
What if Bethany was the one who hit Ali with a rock? She might have wanted to get back at Jessica, it would explain why Jessica didn't speak up about it and why she suddenly lost contact and didn't question it (thinking that Bethany ran away after the murder and perhaps didn't want to contact her) then Ce-Ce found out what happened and hit Bethany wen't to the grave and left her there to go find Ali and then Melissa came alone and... Is this possible?
No. Jessica was covering for the person who hit Ali.
Yeah, what if she was covering for Bethany?
tenika french omg i was thinking the same thing like who else would she cover up for her own sons "Charles and Jason" or Bethany whose father she's having an affair with.. but i don't think Cece hit Bethany maybe its Spencer she did remember blood on her face and hitting someone with a shovel
tenika french sorry but it's cece
Also ali has to have a twin!!!her hair was very very curly at one point of the night. But then when meeting wit Ian it was very straight. The wind couldn't have made the hair change, and why would ali wear a wig? This means maybe bethany and Ali worked together and are the -A team.
Ali doesnt have a twin sasha who pkays ali confirmed it and also. Marlene king one of the writers alson confirmed she never xx
Actually, in the book the story is more or less like that! '' Bethany '', whose name is Courtney, is allison's twin sister who she killed and put on her grave. She was already sent to Radley, too. It's more interesting and makes more sense, I really don't know why they changed it for the TV series. Read about Courtney, it's a cool story.
i think it's because those scenes were filmed to different times
omgphew true but I feel like the show is smarter than that
No, they replaced Courtney Dilaurentis with Cece Drake, hence the same initials.
The yellow blouse that CeCe was wearing was different than the blouse Alison was wearing. (It was spaghetti strapped and Alison's straps were thicker). I don't really know if that changes anything but it's something to think about...
jill bean Also Alison's was different when she is changing in her bedroom is a high neck blouse and also when she came back to the barn, but then later is a round neck (when she is talking to Mr. Montgomery for example). I don't know if the winters explained this mistake or if it's a clue that there were 2 Alisons? Does anyone know?
SPOILER ALERT!!!! I'm on the seventh season. I'm sorry but I have a few things in your story.
1. Peter Hastings threatened to tell Ali's dad about the affair with Jessica that produced Jason. That's why Jessica didn't go to the Police about what she witnessed.
2. Cece Drake is A, she was in Radley and was blamed for Marion's death, CeCe is Charles DiLaurentis (Transgender)
3. Bethany not only witnessed Marion's death by while Bethany and Charlotte (Charles) were playing dress up on the roof when Marion came and Bethany pushed her off.
3. Cece Drake threw the rock at Ali thinking it was Bethany
4. Spencer and Jason are half-sibilings
5. THEY ALL GET KIDNAPPED BY A
If Bethany was talking to Melissa, what could they possibly be talking about?
you were right. mrs dilaurentis did get a call about Bethany escaping. but there was another girl. charlotte dilaurentis. or as you may know her, cece drake.
Maybe Sara Harvey is in Ali's grave and Bethany young is Big -A because Marlene gave the biggest hints, she said when we find out who -A is we will feel sympathy for them and -A name starts with 7 letters. B E T H A N Y!
I doubt it, the writers keep saying that we've known A since the very beginning, we barely found out about her
Thats possible. But also Spencers name has seven letters. This is gonna mkae my head spin @.@ lol
Spencer and Melissa's name both have seven letters, but I really want Bethany to be Big -A/End Game because it would make so much sense why she would wanna torture Alison and the liars.
But we've also known Bethany since season one it was just that nobody brung her up.
Carlton Battles It would make sense her punishing Alison, not Aria, Spencer, Hanna, Emily, and at one point Mona. They never even met Bethany let alone negatively effected her life.
The second outfit wasn't for Bethany. It was for Charlotte.
WOOOOoooow you probably took a loooong time to do that !!!!! These facts are AMAZING and it kinda opened my eyes on what's the reason of all this mess !! My only thing to say : BRAVO you're a genius !!!
The dress wasn't for Bethany, it was for CeCe (Charlotte) Bethany just stole them from her
Can't wait for the winter premier of PLL Tomorrow.
Does anyone know what the heck happened to Caleb after he came back from RavensWood??? I've been curious ever since he came back on the show, but there's nothing that gave away what happened, and I feel like that has an important role in the story line...
I believe the series Ravenswood are about Caleb and what he did there. But I've never watched it myself :/
In Ravenswood, Miranda was actually a ghost. They witness supernatural stuff and he gets creeped so he returns home.
I watched the Ravenswood show it was good
Your videos are sooo good!
thank you!
7 years late but I feel like Jessica actually Killed Bethany due to a theory that Bethany is really CeCe Drake and Sarah Harvey is Charles. Jessica hit her in the head thinking Bethany aka CeCe was going to hurt Alison the night she escaped Radley. CeCe did hurt Alison and blackmailed Mrs. D about exposing that Sara Harvey ( the real Charles ) was in Radley along with CeCe who are both her children due to her affair with Peter Hastings. The writers just got tooo creative and obsessed with tricking fans to the point of having to create multiple twins.
Good theory. but the body Mrs. D identified couldn't have been Bethany (assuming she's alive), it would have to be Sarah Harvey. So were there 4 girls wearing the same yellow top that night?! Ali, Bethany, Cece and Sarah. Or else maybe CeCe is Bethany. I don't know; its odd that they all had the same clothes. Also we didn't really see Bethany's face when Mellissa buried her.
Who is Sarah
Cheerluv07 Sarah is the other girl that disappeared the same night as alison and her body was never found
Brenda Lopez when happen that?
***** season 3. Sara brought all her friends together too. She was also queen b.
Sorry. Sara's alive
CeCe is Behany's twin Melissa was alking to Beth not CeCe and the blouse on CeCe It's a litle different from the one on Ali
and Aria is not big A we will find out who big A is in the season finale
I agree I think Bethany and CeCe are twins, and CeCe is the one who was in the grave and Bethany is alive and is Big A.
Makela Noble Yeah but I also think that CeCe and Bethany are both alive and Sara harvey is the one in the grave or Toby's mom
and you can hear Bethany's voice it's similar to Cece's
Actutally, that sounds like a great theory, however one thing doesn't make sense: Cece is 8 years older than Ali, so how come the two dresses Ali found when she was a child (one was supposedly for Bethany) were the same size?
***** CeCe is around Jason's age and Melissa they're not 8 years older they're 22 or 24
OK, according to the PLL wiki she's 23. So it's still 5-6 years older than Ali.
16:50 "That top was too revealing" - REALLY?! The top she's wearing at the lunch is more revealing (both in the front, and in the back!) than the yellow top Ali wore that night! XOXO ;)
Ryuiolkas
❤💌📝🎶♥🎵🌟👠❤Bz znznznznznznznznnznzn
ZnzmNMzn.Ajznzmznsk
baqkambdkaaja
Zsmzjs
nskana
Znsks
👠🌟🎵♥📝💌💋❤Vxznbzznnznzbznnssn
mamama
10
46
94
7
A
Bxnznzznznzm
Znzmsms
ZmM.zmzmz
Zmaakamam
Aamamam
Ryuiolkas
Did anyone notice that in 4:55 ali's hair is fully curled and in 7:08 its just wavy? I think that its ali's twin (bethany) in 7:08 pretending to be ali and ali at 4:55. Thats just my opinion....
If Bethany is alive everything makes sense. She's Red Coat, helping Charles who is A because they're close and ran away from Radley together. But who was in the grave then ? Sara Harvey ? Then who's pretending to be Sara ? Bethany .. ?
Pll is confusing Why would Charles put Sara in the dollhouse ?
Bethany is dead, Melissa buried her alive.
But whos in the grave of alison
@@precious3168 Yes, I know that, but according to your theory, if Bethany was alive, someone must have been in Alison's grave and it must have been someone who was in history from the beginning, someone who had a link with A and all the others (sorry for my bad English I am French haha)
@@precious3168 yes in real history, but in your theory where bethany is still alive, who could be in the grave? it could be sara because sara was not used for much in the story except for A
Jessica would give Charlotte the same clothes that she gave Allison. On the night Allison "died" Bethany was at her house wearing the same clothes. Charlotte explains that Bethany was jealous the she got our rights, which was why Bethany was at the the house, to go hurt/kill Jessica. It is most likely that Bethany stole some of Charlotte's clothes.
What if Cece got kicked out of college by Ali because they found out that she lied about her age, possibly to get away from her town were A might've been tormenting her
I think that ali died that night and bethany took her place, she could be alis twin, you guys remember when jason was looking at family albums and ali said it was a good day but it wasnt true at all, i mean by looking at the picture u can guess it was a good day but u had to be there to know it wasnt.
***** I agree that they're not twins but not because of the different men. Nobody ever said that Ms.D was Bethanys mom lol.
Pretty sure the directors said that they arent doing the twin thing in the show. In the books, the explanation was that ali had a twin but its not gonna be that for the show
There is a real problem with Melissa's story. It doesn't match up to Ali's story.
Melissa saw Spencer going after Ali with that shovel. She goes after them, probably first hesitating a bit, and then finds a blond girl in a yellow top, laying next to the grave. She thinks Spencer killed her and buries her to protect her sister.
Ali told the liars she was chased by Spencer, but she convinced her to go to sleep. That happened, and then she walked to her home where her mother was looking out the window. Then Ali got hit, and she realized her mother was burying her.
These story's are conflicting. Melissa was probably looking from the Hastings house, which is located right beside the Dilaurentis house. It probably takes her less than a minute to walk up to the garden of the Dilaurentis house. Which means, that if she left right after she saw Spencer, she would not find a dead body. Melissa would probably see Ali and Spencer talking, or maybe she saw Ali being murdered. That means, Melissa is lying and never burried Bethany. Because Bethany was probably murdered after Ali was saved by Mrs. Grunwald. That would mean that Melissa hesitated at least half an hour befoe going after Spencer to protect her. And that is not quite convincing.
But why would Melissa lie? Why would she tell a story that is incriminating her? I think Ali is lying. I think she was never burried at all, which would make Melissa's story convincing. The only people contributing to Ali's story, or were wittnesses, were Mrs D, Mrs Grunwald and Mona. Mrs D was murdered right after Ali told the story, and the Liars never asked Mona if the story Ali told was true. Mrs Grunwald is the only one who could be asked.
On the other hand, this could also be lazy writing, and just a mistake.
I think you might be right! it wouldn't make sense that Bethany was murdered before Ali was burried. Especially because I believe it would be logical if Bethany was the one who hit Ali. Who else would misses D protect? Jason? That seems unlikely to me. But maybe they both tell the truth. What if the girl Melissa burried wasn't Bethany, maybe it was that girl named Sarah, who looked like Ali, but that would make things very complicated.
I think Bethany hit Ali with the stone because she hates her and Mrs D said " what have u done! " because she knows that she hates her and she buried Ali because she didn't want Bethany to get into trouble and after , Spencer killed Bethany thinking it was Ali after Ali told Spencer to go to sleep(confused at that part ?) meanwhile Mrs grundewald got Ali out the grave then they went to hospital. Melissa saw spencer kill Bethany with shovel thinking it was Ali and she didn't want Spencer to get into trouble so she buried "Ali" Bethany where Ali was buried before but Melissa Couldn't Bear To Look At Her Face So She Didn't Know It was Bethany. I don't know where Cece comes into this or sarah?.. I think Cece was the reason Bethany killed Ali Because She Hated Them Both
I have literally no idea what I typed but please comment to tell me if if makes sense.......
The yellow top over three girls is different. Alison and Bethany wore the same yellow top while Cece was totally different.
Sara is Charles - Mary Drake's son/daughter, Mary is Jessica DiLaurentis twin and Cece is Bethany!
no. Cece is Charles and Sara is Bethany
Bethany is the Twin of Spencer Drake.
The second yellow dress was for Charles / CeCe / Charlotte because in 6-10 we find out Charlotte was bought a yellow dress for Christmas
maybe that was Bethany when Mrs D looked out the window at her so amazed ..
I think either Mrs. D hit Bethany in the head or I think Alison did. I believe Mrs. D saw Alison do it and helped her escape town and I think she knew Alison was alive the whole time because right before she died she sent an email minutes before saying that she couldn't protect you anymore, wonder who that could've been.
Mona hit Bethany. Melissa buried her thinking Spencer did it
aria was attacked by a in the brue when a stole monas laptop
I have no idea how this would work but maybe... Ali is the one with the twin??
Mrs. D has child with Scott Montgomery - Charles
Year later - Mrs. D has child with Mr. H - Jason
Few years later - Mrs. D has child with ?Kenneth? - Bethany
Another lady has twins - Ali and Sarah
Here is where it get's a bit crazy....
Bethany and Ali get mixed up at birth. Ali is given to Mrs. D when really she is a twin Sarahs and Bethany is given to Sarah's family. Bethany ends up hurting Sarah (like in Cece's story) and ends up in Radley. Sarah grows up normally without her twin but displays personality traits very similar to Ali. Somewhere along the way Mrs. D discovers she has been given the wrong child and Bethany is her daughter. So she starts visiting her at Radley, but not wanting to upset Ali who she treats as her own daughter and has grown to love keeps this a secret.
Thats a goood Theorie
Do you think the reasons Mrs d told Bethany to call her aunt Jessie is because Mrs d is Marions sister and Bethany pushed Marion when she was on the ruff because she found out they were having an affair and if mrs d and Marion are sisters Marion would be Ali's aunt and Mrs d would be Bethanys aunt.maybe Bethany was talking about Jenna Jenna knew about Ali's twin in the book and maybe Bethany knew who Ali was so she went after her to hurt Mrs d because she was related to Marion so when they were communicating over mail she was pushing to hurt Ali but Ali lied to her about something
mrs dilaurentis's sister is not Marion cavanaugh it's Mary Drake
A is seeking revenge for Mona, Bethany, and Toby's mom, Marion. The drawing weren't drawn by Bethany, a doctor drew them.
I still don't get the part when spencer says she had a affair with Bethany's father? I mean who's Bethany's father?
First of all Hanna can never be ''A.D'' because she was bought to the dollhouse with the other liars and was also in the truck, and was also kidnapped when she lied about killing Charlotte, so from what I know ''A.D'' really cared about Charlotte and Non of the liars are ''A.D''
Cece hit Ali because she thought Bethany was trying to hurt her family and mistook Ali for Bethany, Bethany killed tobys mom and blamed it on cece who was a ‘boy in a dress with more to lose’
Yeah but i was wondering did they ever mentioned that cece is a Transgender ?
@@vistaxx yes.
I don't know if its just me but does Bethany sound like Melissa
I think that Jason was hallucinating. It doesn't make sense that CeCe would be in a yellow top when Bethany stole her yellow top in order to sneak out of Radley. It couldn't have been Bethany because Melissa referred to her as a stranger that she buried alive. If Jason wasn't hallucinating then Melissa must've been talking to Ali but she didn't mention that in her video so I doubt it.
Cece wasn't wearing the same blouse as Alison and Bethany, it's different but the same colour, when cece was talking to Melissa her top was open at the back, maybe that's the top that Mrs Delorentis was talking about when she said it was too revealing and got ali the other yellow top and Bethany wore the same one as Allison.
Editing on point (y)
What if in the voice recording Bethany isn't talking about Alison but instead talking about Cece when she went to radley pretending to be Alison or it could be Charles ?
You should do a new video with Bethany and Mary Drake.
i dont undrstant
The yellow dress was for Alison and for Cece Drake. Cece Drake is Charles, the brother from Alison. The dress was not for Bethany.
Does anybody else notice that in this scene Bethany sounds a lot like Sara Harvey???
3:13 Was she making that up, because it was a lie right there when she said "it's not my daughter sitting in Radley" cause according to Cece, she is just that
We now know Charlotte isn't actually Jessica's daughter, it's her niece. But, we think Jessica told the story at 3:13 to throw the liars off track from knowing that Charlotte was actually in Radley!
+PLL headA True that, maybe that wasn't even Jessica talking, it was probably Mary.
+PLL headA charlotte is charles (her transgendered son) and the second yellow dress was actually his
I saw a theory where Cece/ Charlotte is actually Bethany Young and Sarah Harvey is really Charles. Cece said Bethany Young had explosive disorder, but so does Cece when she choked Alison when she was trying to runaway from Rosewood again and when she kidnapped the girls and how she punished them. And Sarah Harvey being Charles was because Sarah was always looking out for the girls. Like Sarah wanted to keep the girls safe. In season 6B Sarah Harvey is also visiting a grave the same time Emily is visiting her father's grave, and in a scene it shows Jessica DiLaurentis headstone. When Emily questioned Sarah about what she was doing there she said she had to say goodbye to someone. Why visit Jessica's grave if she never even knew the woman? (It is possible she was put up to it, but seems strange if she was)... I actually think it's a very good theory. Makes more sense because if Cece really did love Alison like she said in season 6, she wouldn't have choked Alison, set her up for Mona's murder and let her get beaten up in jail.
I think first time we ever saw Mary was when Spencer gets back from rehab and she comes up behind her. Maybe it was also Mary when she went to the Hastings about the bridal show event, because Spencer apologized to who we thought was Jessica and "Jessica" told her no apology was necessary and seemed very kind towards Spencer. But then at the bridal show, Jessica (the real one) seemed to not even want to be in the same room with Spencer.
So I don't think it was Mary telling Alison "But it's not my daughter sitting in Radley. It's Cece Drake."
I think it was really Jessica because Cece Drake is really not Charles but knows that Charles was Mary Drake's child. But Cece is so delusional that she truly believes she is Charles. Mona said when Lesli Stone was in Radley, she heard that Charles and Bethany were missing. However, at this time, if Charles transitioned into a female, why would Radley be looking for Charles if Charles is now female at that point in time? ...
It also could be that the person dressed in Ali's look alike clothes, truly was "Charles" and that's who Melissa buried alive but Cece knew too much about Jessica's secrets so instead, somehow or someone blackmailed someone into saying it was Bethany Young in that grave. ???
There are things that don't match up in Cece's confession to Alison back in 6A. But if it ever came out to the girls that Cece truly wasn't Charles, I wouldn't be surprised. Maybe AD has been around this whole time and Cece is doing what AD is telling her to do and be.?? hmm...
There are so many secrets and lies in Rosewood, i can't keep up anymore. O_O
What if Bethany was the one who hit Ali with the rock? And that's why Misses DiLaurentis didn't say anything?
Bethany got hit by someone and it was Bethany's blood on the stone, and Bethany has a red a marked on her face
snoko2 I think Charles hit Ali because in the promos you see a black sleeve and Bethany was wearing the yellow top
Märta Juhlin-Dannfelt it was mona who hit Bethany thinking it was Alison. Cece hit Alison thinking it was Bethany's. watch season 6 episode 10 to know the whole story
Märta Juhlin-Dannfelt it was mona who hit Bethany thinking it was Alison. Cece hit Alison thinking it was Bethany's. watch season 6 episode 10 to know the whole story
snoko2 it also could have been Cece which is why Mrs. D didn't say anything to cover for her bc Cece said " mom wuz the only one who really ever loved me "
Beths drawing could be a trick. They painted the hair yellow so that would be the center of attention. You can see a shadow on the floor, could be a hint?
ok so wait you're telling me that bethany was hit around the time spencer and alison were fighting in the front yard of the dilaurentis house and/or the time spencer walked away with that shovel? that only make's sense from what melissa said in her video.
It was around the time they were fighting
After watching this, I understand why this show was 7 seasons long! Alison had not happen to her in one night than i’ve had in my entire life lol
The other yellow dress was for Charlotte
Here is my theory:The night Ali Disappeared Ms D got a phone call saying that Bethany had escaped Radley that's why she didn't want Ali out that night she told her to call it a night and go to her room..We know someone was watching them from OUTSIDE Bethany knew about her dad and Ms D and that made her mad she also drew pictures of Ms D house in her" SCRAP BOOK"..She also said is it LIKR MOTHER LIKE DAUGHTER she wonder can she trust anybody in that FAMILY (MS,Dand Ali)...so later Ali has a cut on her face and later told Spencer in a dream that it was a girl what If that girl was bethany ...she leaves radley to get her REVENGE LIKE she said on that tape..!Maybe that Bethany and Ali got into again and Ali fought back this time maybe Ali hit Bethany with a rock or a shovel and she thought Bethany was dead so she goes back home..Only to see that her mom looks at her like U didn't listen to me and Bethany Snuck up behind Ali and hit her with the rock..there were 2 types of blood on the rock Ali's and somebody else what if that person was Bethany.. Sara Harvey goes missing around the same time.. Whos to say that Sara want the on that got buried by mistake.. we know ALI GOT PULLED OUT BY MS G and somebody with a RED SLEEEVE pulled Bethany out..Bethany dont wanna go back to Radley She FAKES her death and take on SARA HARVEY Identity.
I think Charles is Bethany's brother, they share the same father. However, Charles' mom is DiLaurentis. This situation makes both families couldn't accept Charles as a true family member. Thus, Charles wants to be Alison or Bethany who have mom and dad to accept and love them, which also explains why there are so many human-sized dolls in Charles' lair. He seeks family's companion and love. Charles grew up with no real parents and friends since his parents think Charles is a danger and a burden, so Charles grew up in the dark, maybe in Radley, and often feels unloved unacceptable, and meaningless. It sort of like a combination of 'The silence of lamb' and 'superman. I mean Charles is like the thrill killer who wanted to be a girl to get mom's love and the penguin man who have to hide in the dark, feeling inferior and can not master him own life. Charles hopes to have the Alison or Bethany had, however, he couldn't. Thus, he tried to torture Alison, Bethany and I guess in the end he tended to kill Alison and Bethany, no those girls, because, it would be so lonely without 'dolls', human-sized, real dolls, to play with him. Basically, a story to satire the irresponsibility of people who have affairs and further abandon the baby that is not expected to be born, the child born out of wedlock.
Am I the only one who thinks that the playback recording of Bethany speaking sounds like Sara Harvey?
this theory is fantastic well done its spot on
Bethany did not witness Marion falling she pushed her because cece was afraid Marion was going to say something to her so she asked Bethany for help and Bethany was talking to Marion and then pushed her
Mona hit Bethany with the rock, Melissa saw Spencer at the wrong moment and thought Spencer hurt Ali, but she didnt. So Melissa buried Bethany alive.
I think Bethany pushed Toby's mom
Alison once spoke of how she felt when she was being buried alive by her Mother in that Fitzgerald theater
Did anyone else notice that when Jason saw Cece when she was talking to Melissa, her yellow tank top was spaghetti strap, which was different than Ali's tank top.
Does anyone know how Bethany looks like?
About what character in the show isn't there any theory? Because that's A. Marlene I. King said that only one fan got it right.
But not only about the character, is about everything so the character could be even the one people suspect the most, but that person guessed the motives and everything that the rest of us don't.
Lovatic123 lol there are so many theories, it's impossible to figure out who got it right Charles is A, Charles is Bethany, Cece is Bethany, Aria is A and also schizophrenic, I was sure I heard Maya's voice in the last episode where A says "please follow the lighted pathway" when the girls wake up at the dollhouse. But that wouldn't make sense , no one has Maya theories anymore lol. So basically I can't keep up anymore, I give up guessing. All i know is that Cece can't be A cause she was helping Ali in new york and in flashbacks.
melissa's secret it bullshit! she saw spencer and alison and then spencer walking away with the shovel.... AND SUDDENLY THEY FORGET MELISSA AND CECE WERE TALKING TOO THAT NIGHT! what about that one?
Thank you!
but when you said Alisons mom said to pretend she saw one Dres that was because cece not Bethany because in season 6 cece was saying how every time Alison got a outfit she got the same one so you are incorrect
I had a bit of track theory...Don't you think Kate and Bethany sounds similar? They said that A is in season 1 and in MOna's funeral...she tots has the black widow body.
Cece is the only person with a twin and her twin is Courtney Drake. Courtney is the big A.
In 1:20 Bethany has voice like Sara Harvey!
first if all, bethany or cece cant be A because we dident know them in the first episode ! they got introduced around season 3/4 (cant remember) so keep in midn, when your thinking of someone being A, they had to be in the first episode !!
Not really because you don't see who A is in the first episode, so it can be a character that was introduced later on
kirsten smith marlene said that A was in the first episode !! like the very first one. your confusing me >.
angela k That applied to Mona- as the original A, NOT Big A.
CandyxCoatedxBubblez no it did not, she said the main, big A was in the first episode !!! this was recently hun.
angela k Actually Marlene set that straight! You can see it on twitter ;)
I saw the Bethany picture in arias room
how did radley not recognize cece when she tried to sign herself in as Alison if she had been a patient practically her whole life .
That is a good question that I never thought of. Jessica knows a lot more than she lets on.
Because she started out as a boy and only when she was about to get out did she turn up as a girl. By all that time, there could have been new staff members.
No Cece was still in radley when she transitioned they just had a funeral for charles and then she came back as charlotte. I think she got in because she might have put on some weird makeup. (don't lie makeup can make a whole new person).
+Cherie Currie not FUCKING really ? cece said that the night ali went missing bethany dressed in her clothes and sneeked out of radly as cece cuz cece had privilege so yea
Saxon Thompson but she got signed in the first time as Charles and came back as Charlotte, probes didn't have her name in books
8:38 Hanna look so different and cool!
When Spencer And Mona Played The Tape Sounded Like Melissa
Nice work!!
If you look closely, cece's blouse is not identical to Ali's and Bethany's. cece's blouse is spaghetti strap while Ali's and Bethany's blouses aren't.
I think when "Jason" to see Melissa talk "Cece". In fact, he saw "Melissa" pushed the body of "Bethany" in the hole, then the time to go get a shovel, "Jason" is asleep
My theory is that the person who hit Ali with the rock was Bethany when she escaped from Radley to come looking for Mrs Dilaurentis.
Wait, I thought CeCe said that when Mrs. D would buy Ali an outfit, she'd buy CeCe the same one. Cause when Bethany snuck out of radley that night, CeCe said she stole her clothes. And that's why she hit her with the rock, she thought Ali was Bethany. So I'm thinking the other yellow dress was for CeCe, and since Mr. D didnt want anything to do with him, that's why she told Ali to lie. But who knows. There are chunks of this show that still make no sense.
I think Cece and Alli made a plan to catch A. A was supposed to think Cece was Alli so they could trap A, But then Alli went behind Cece's back and invited Bethany to Rosewood, in the yellow top ,so that A would kill Bethany instead of going after Cece. Alli wanted Bethany dead, because she was jealous of the relationship she and her mom had. Only Bethany was the original A who tormented Alli so she "killed" Alli for it. Alli's mom covered it up and then Spencer killed Bethany thinking it was Alli and Melissa burried her
that voice on the recorder is aka Sarah Harvey!! so she is Bethany young and the real Sarah Harvey was in that grave
joshua bosley that's a very good theory and it would make sense 👍🏻👍🏻
Just saw the finale. good theories about Bethany...but No. I love how everything gets confusing before the all reveal of Season 6 Episode 10
gosh...those Bethany Young drawings are scary. I have to sleep with the lights on now