Sorry for the leaks in 0:45, 2:30 and 2:40, the rest is normal!! If you are new in this channel, subscribe, like and turn on your bell of notifications for you not lose any MR Removed like IVE's that I post! Thanks for watching!!
''Oh perfect sacrifice!'' parts sound really good, especially Leeseo surprised me, and Gaeul sounds loud and clear compared to the members who sing before and after her
@@kimyura2482 ofcourse, but her breath control was ass and so was her technique. her technique is still pretty bad but if she continued down the iz*one path she would’ve lost her vocals for sure
Wonyoung sing all her parts 0:17 1:092:032:40 We know she is great singer since pd48 was 100% live but unconfidence Her highnote is really stable ,she trying sing all her parts even narcissit my gid i love it this is lower part .0:35 She improved day by day Starship should give more lesson on confidence in live performances cause ive members look stressed n unconsitent in live encore or live performances
@@sunookim2127 you should didnt compared jyp ...jyp have aired vocalists n their trainning is different also there is nmixx is only group with stability in their vocals im impressed by raw vocals this is first group 4gen w much confidence in live I know ive re great singers Starship is known for being great company for their amazing vocalists like Sistar hyolyon n wjsn . I wish Starship will being more strict on their vocal live like they should sing all the days .yes they should done like stayc wuth 5 hours trainning vocal . Ive can working more on their live performances for become more stable
Maybe its bcs they are really busy like they are not given time to rest and refresh since debut. Plus there are a lot of advertisement coming. Since they are still rookie, the company think its better to promote promote promote. Means work work work. They dont have enough time to get a lot of classes anymore. I think when they are reaching a year or so they will get more free time and more classes
I'm so proud of Wonyoung, she improve a lot, i think this is her best live vocals since she was in izone, SLAP FOR THOSE HATERS THAT SAY SHE CANT SING! IVE BEST GIRLS
Wonyoung know sing since pd48 was 100% live but she is insecure person n perfectionist also she is teenager also she have much stressed in her life of idol n highschooler Wonyoung is hardworker person n will shine if she give her best in live since she is known perfect idol in korea
@@christiangagemonsanto9105 i don’t think anyone forced her, her voice that she used in izone matched the concepts. like panorama, her high pitched voice matched the concept since panorama had a lot of high pitched vocals
I’m amazed with lesseo’s perfect sacrifice part, Gaeul , Liz, Rei incredible too, Yujin eating cds as always and I think wonyoung need to be more confident because she is capable, fighting IVE🤍
Yujin always doing her work flawlessly She is iconic for that She always shows how good vocalist is and there are not ways of telling she is not! Amazing, the other girls did it very well Really proud
@@danie5233 0:20; 1:09; 2:04; 2:40 go get ur ears checked 🙄. Even leeseo skipped her parts but y'all said nothing, you're just here pretending to be death when wonyoung literally sang everything
실력이란 한 번에 확 늘지는 않지만 이정도면 일레븐 때에 비해 정말 많이 개선했네.. 특히 원영이는 실력도 늘었지만 무대를 대하는 자세가 많이 바꼈다고 봄. 물론 아직 갈 길이 멀지만 비는 파트 거의 없이 해냈고 꾸준히 발전 가능성을 보여주니까 남들이 뭐라뭐라 해도 기대하고 있는 거야. 앞으로 더 발전하고 훗날 누구에게나 인정받을 만큼 프로페셔널해지자. 노력으로 이겨낸 사람은 훗날 더 인정받더라.
@@dicu8776 저두용 보컬적인면이 부족한건 뭐 알고있는 사실이지만 솔직히 무대할때 머리 자주만진다 이런걸로 까였는데 ruclips.net/user/shortshK8QAZS7q_E?feature=share 보면 알겠지만 그런것조차 장원영한텐 무대를 잘하기 위한 노력이었음 얼굴도 피지컬도 너무 갓벽해서 딱봤을때 아이돌에 진심 아닌멤버처럼 모르는 사람들 눈엔 보이는지 모르겠지만 오히려 프메도 거의 매일같이 찾아와서 소통하는 아이돌임
@@fruit-tf7bz 솔직히 장원영 정도 비주얼이면 노래실력 좀 부족해도 되는게 그간 아이돌판 아니었나.. 진심 좀 의아함ㅎㅎ; 이런말 하면 또 쿵쾅거리면서 달려와서 아이돌가수는 가수 아니냐면서 지팡이 휘두르는데 아이돌산업에서 그게 현실인데 뭐 어쩌란거임. 원영이 정도 피지컬에 비주얼이면 서브보컬 정도 해도 충분히 1인분 넘어서 2인분 몫 하는거라고 볼 수 있는건데, 뭘 그렇게 바라는게 많은거임 노래 못해서 랩같지도 않은 랩 하고 있는 아이돌이 수백명인 세상에 별 ㅋ
@@longoan9408 well, i think she improved a lot. In the past, she seemed lacks of confidence to let her voice out. And in this era, she tries her best to sing all of her part. And that's definitely an improvement
I'm so proud of wonyoung! She improves so much and sings her parts as much as she could. She used to not sing most of her lines in iz*one and i think its mostly cuz its too high for her. Glad that starship gives her parts that is more of her vocal range, and she trained so much and her hardwork really paid off. 🥺❤️ Also, the other members are also so good eventho they are dancing! Good job, IVE
원영이 진짜 많이 늘었다.. 개인적으로 팬들이 실력 없는 멤버 늘지도 않았는데 많이 늘었다고 난리치는 거 안 좋아하는데 타팬 입장에서도 진짜 많이 는 것 같음ㅠㅜ 일레븐 때 실력이랑 표정가지고 말 많았는데 피드백 빨리 고치는 거 너무 대단하고 멘탈 좋은 듯.. 상처 안 받고 오래 활동했으면 좋겠다 실력 더 쌓으면 진짜 더 대박날 듯..
전 근데 댓글로 피드백은 좋다고 생각하는데 피드백이라는 명목으로 악플 다는 사람들이 많아서 좀 걱정됨... 또..표정 별로다 바꿔라 이런 댓글 달고나서 바뀌면 "ㅣ힣 내가 장원영 표정 바꿨다" 하는 생각 하는 것도 너무 싫음 솔직히 팬 입장에서 표정 전이랑 후랑 크게 신경도 안 쓰고 이쁘기만 한데 지들이 바꿨네 뭐네 내가 댓글 달았더니 좋아졌네 어쨋네 하는 것도 다 억까같고 자의식 과잉같고 그럼.. 갸륵이 뭔 갸륵인데 그냥 이쁘기만 한데.. 그런식으로 댓글 안 달아도 원영이라는 사람은 스스로 발전해 갈 수 있고 그런 의지도 보이는 사람인데 사소한 걸로 욕하고 까는게 너무 보기 싫어요
I hope DIVE will be more protective of Wonyoung. At least that would help her gain more confidence. Some ppl are too ignorant to cyberbully a 13-year-old and just won't give up on hating. And seriously, Starship should cut down her volume of work time.
I think it's pre-recorded. Just like how bang chan of skz explained it. To look like they're singing live but they recorded it before the performance. And I hope people won't come on me for saying this
원영이 진짜 좋아져서 너무 좋다 예전에 솔직히 실력논란은 인정하긴 한데 표정이나 그런 걸로 까는 건 너무 억지였음 원영ㅇ 진짜 대단하긴 함 나이가 어린데도 불구하고 이미 데뷔한 사람들 사이에서도 돋보이는 탑급,, 요즘 데뷔하는 원영이 나이대 여돌들은 어케 데뷔했는지 의문인데 원영이랑 유진인 미쳤음 ㄷㄷ ㅠㅠㅠ 표정연기 스타성 이런 거 타고났음 나이 모르는 상태로 보면 최소 데뷔 3,4년 차 선배로 보임 물론 가수니까 노래 잘해야 하는 건 맞는데 다른 이상한 이유로도 까이니까 안쓰러울 따름.. 그렇게나 심한 욕 먹는데도 바로바로 고치고 진짜 제발 악플 이딴 건 신경 안 써줬음 좋겠음 어린 나이에 안 먹어도 될 욕까지 먹고 아이브 팬 아닌데도 너무하다는 생각임 좋은 것만 보고 나쁜 생각 안 하고 오래오래 활동해줬으면 하는 바람..
I really thought wonyoung was going to sound worse. I still think she's a pretty weak vocalist, but she attempted all her notes and although she missed her high note it was not by a large margin enough to say she can't actually hit it. The other girls stellar as always. I knew Yujin had it in her but Lesseo really impressed me with her chorus.
They improved more than last live. They sing more stably. Wonyoung also has a bit improvement but somtimes she skips some parts. Rei didn't skip her lines that is praiseworthy. Liz is main vocal so she has stability but somtimes she also skips her parts like Wonyoung. Yujin ,Gaeul, Leeseo are really stable and did well their lines.
Ok but there are so many groups that can't even sing live or barely do it and here we have IVE with every single member singing at least one of their lines clearly, even with the choreo and all, incredible
![[CLEAN MR Removed] 220107 IVE (아이브) ELEVEN | Live Vocals MR제거](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wkXF7YArU5o/mqdefault.jpg)
![[CLEAN MR Removedㅣ엠알 제거] LE SSERAFIM(르세라핌) _ Fire in the belly @ 240414 Coachella 2024](/img/1.gif)
Sorry for the leaks in 0:45, 2:30 and 2:40, the rest is normal!!
If you are new in this channel, subscribe, like and turn on your bell of notifications for you not lose any MR Removed like IVE's that I post! Thanks for watching!!
We share the same leaks HAHAHAHA
@@karylleonce Oh lol
@@BHKMRRemoved sorry can u do eunbi glitch removed version?
@@xxxn118 I don't think so he's going to make one, considering eunbi is only whispering on her live stages so far
liz is so stable she just need more lines to showcase it more, hoping on their next tittle track she can showcase more of her voice.
she still has the most lines for all of their songs tho,hoping for more lines on title track for their next comeback.
I hope that Gaeul will have a lot of lines
she has a plenty of lines already lol
@@stanme she’s singing like 2 times in love dive
@@creepyinsomnia she has 16 seconds in love dive lol what
1:00 Leeseo did so well😭
and she is 15 ! 😳
she hits it
@이다연 외국에선 만 나이를 사용하니 15세라고 한 것 같아요
@이다연 in other country age, she's 15
@이다연 no she was born in 2007
i know yujin and rei is most stable member but i shocked, gaeul and lee seo sing very well🤩
Liz👀👀👀
also Liz.
Gaeul only has to some a few words not really hard to do
liz?
Gaeul is a catastrophe though
Leeseo’s belt when she says “oh perfect sacrifice “ is literally so clear❤️
How does belting work? I don't know a single thing about vocals...
@@gingerdonalds2708 oh ok- belting is pretty much hitting a high note in a very clear tone while singing in chest voice 😀
@@randy_mp whats chest voice?
@@trsrcafe-yo7gm chest voice is your regular singing voice. It’s very ‘full sounding’ method of singing.
@@randy_mp thankyou!!
Yujin's voice is stable and very nice
2:06 this part, yujin's high note is sooo clear 😭
''Oh perfect sacrifice!'' parts sound really good, especially Leeseo surprised me, and Gaeul sounds loud and clear compared to the members who sing before and after her
와 이서 고음 부분 잘하네..
유진이랑 레이 리즈 가을 넘 잘해..원영이는 더 늘었고
wonyoung literally improved like her voice from iz*one to ive, i love to see her growth as a performer tbh
But sometime we miss izone jang wonyoung voice right
True, I'm so proud of Wonyoung right now. We could really see her improvement. I have a soft spot for Wonyoung's voice now
2:40 Beautiful!wonderful!!!
@@kimyura2482 ofcourse, but her breath control was ass and so was her technique. her technique is still pretty bad but if she continued down the iz*one path she would’ve lost her vocals for sure
@@devsabrat definitely
yujin and rei stable queens & wonyoung improve so much!!
I loved Liz's voice in Eleven. Hope to hear more of her next comeback.
no one talks about how stable Liz is, I hope she gets more lines on the next comeback
다들 진짜 잘한다... 피치가 낮은편이라 다들 잘부르는듯
여돌 노래중에 피치가 낮으면서 노래가 세련되고 좋다고 느껴지기 쉽지않은데 이걸 해냄
앞으로도 이런 곡 많이 내줬으면
일레븐은 음역대가 안 맞아서 잘 소화하지 못했는데 러브 투 다이브는 음역대가 멤버 모두한테 맞아서 라이브도 잘하고 잘 어울리는 것 같음!!
love to dive X love dive O
Wonyoung sing all her parts 0:17
1:09 2:03 2:40
We know she is great singer since pd48 was 100% live but unconfidence
Her highnote is really stable ,she trying sing all her parts even narcissit my gid i love it this is lower part .0:35
She improved day by day
Starship should give more lesson on confidence in live performances cause ive members look stressed n unconsitent in live encore or live performances
Yes they just need confidence or they'll end like twice being stressed on encores
@@sunookim2127 you should didnt compared jyp ...jyp have aired vocalists n their trainning is different also there is nmixx is only group with stability in their vocals im impressed by raw vocals this is first group 4gen w much confidence in live
I know ive re great singers
Starship is known for being great company for their amazing vocalists like Sistar hyolyon n wjsn .
I wish Starship will being more strict on their vocal live like they should sing all the days .yes they should done like stayc wuth 5 hours trainning vocal .
Ive can working more on their live performances for become more stable
Maybe its bcs they are really busy like they are not given time to rest and refresh since debut. Plus there are a lot of advertisement coming. Since they are still rookie, the company think its better to promote promote promote. Means work work work. They dont have enough time to get a lot of classes anymore. I think when they are reaching a year or so they will get more free time and more classes
she really is very talented. i’m still not sure why she lip sync in eleven but i’m so glad she sang in ‘Love Dive’ so proud of her
@Lail Jordan we're not comparing we are just saying our predictions i'm not dumb okay
This is good, they have improved a lot, why are there still people who thinks this is weak? They sing live quite well for me.
이서랑 리즈 레이 잘한다 ㄷㄷ 원영이도 엄청 늘었네 대박
Yujin's vocals and highnotes always great, and she even better this era 😍😍
Rei going into Slayei mode and I'm all in for it
아이브 라이브 너무 잘한다ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 진짜 갓벽
woww yujin's high note is so clear
다들 너무 잘한다 ㅠㅠ 이번활동 아무도 아프지 말고 즐겁게 시작해서 즐겁게 끝내자 💗
I'm so proud of Wonyoung, she improve a lot, i think this is her best live vocals since she was in izone, SLAP FOR THOSE HATERS THAT SAY SHE CANT SING! IVE BEST GIRLS
Wonyoung know sing since pd48 was 100% live but she is insecure person n perfectionist also she is teenager also she have much stressed in her life of idol n highschooler
Wonyoung is hardworker person n will shine if she give her best in live since she is known perfect idol in korea
Wonyoung voice in izone is really forced in ive it is not forced it is her natural voice
@@christiangagemonsanto9105 Really? Many people say that her voice in IVE is also fake.
@@christiangagemonsanto9105 i don’t think anyone forced her, her voice that she used in izone matched the concepts. like panorama, her high pitched voice matched the concept since panorama had a lot of high pitched vocals
She can’t
they improved so much, i'm truly happy for them
rei im so proud of u
They all improved their vocals so much especially wonyoung
I’m amazed with lesseo’s perfect sacrifice part, Gaeul , Liz, Rei incredible too, Yujin eating cds as always and I think wonyoung need to be more confident because she is capable, fighting IVE🤍
Yujin always doing her work flawlessly
She is iconic for that
She always shows how good vocalist is and there are not ways of telling she is not!
Amazing, the other girls did it very well
Really proud
원래 잘하던 애들이였는데 이번기회에 실력을 보여줘서 좋음 항상 라이브 할때보면 아슬 아슬 했는데 그건 그 팀의 음역대에 안맞게 노래를 들고와서 그렇지.. 지금은 다들 음역대도 맞고 안무도 좋고 스트레스만 안받으면 좋겠음 ㅠㅠ
imo this is already good. considering the song is quite breathy/quiet/whisper-y (which imo is harder to sing) they're pretty stable! especially yujin.
와 진짜 많이 늘었다.. 잘해...
rei
I'm most proud of wonyoung! She's proving something to the sworn of haters she has:(
Rei is so stable
YUJIN OUR MAIN VOCAL MAIN DANCER ACE LEADER DID SO WELL, HER VOCAL IS SUPER STABLE
isn't Liz main vocal and gaeul main dancer?
Yes, they are
@@c.lineofficial Yujin can share the position with them, theres no official statement of main vocal and main dancer
@@jocelynwong1962 right because the kpop fandom wiki changed their positions twice now. I don’t know about the k-profile pages.
wtf she is not ace
I love Yujins Voice so much I’ve been a fan since izone and she has improved so much
Oh they slay specially Yujin and Rei
사람들 아이브한테만 유독 야박함 저정도면 라이브 잘 하는거 맞는데요 ㅋㅋ
그러게욬ㅋㅋ 그냥 트집잡고 까고싶은 사람들 많이 붙은듯 굳이굳이 엠알제거 영상 뜨자마자 찾아와서ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
그니까요… ㄹㅇ 인간들 이쯤이면 팬들보다 더 열심히 빨리 아이브 찾아오는듯요ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ;;;^^
All of them have improved so much!❤️🔥
れいちゃんうますぎる💖
top stable (imo)
1. liz
2. rei
3. gaeul
4. yujin
5. leeseo
6. wonyoung
Ok but I cant hear Wonyoung
@@akusapi5681 u deaf ?
@@laissa9372 WTF💀 I think you are a fan of Ive
@@laissa9372 she singing low literally her mic is always the lowest
@@danie5233 0:20; 1:09; 2:04; 2:40 go get ur ears checked 🙄. Even leeseo skipped her parts but y'all said nothing, you're just here pretending to be death when wonyoung literally sang everything
리즈 레이 유진이 진짜 잘한다ㅜㅜ 원영이는 진짜 많이 늘었구 이서랑 가을이도 안정적인듯
They're all so stable especially Gaeul, Leeseo and Liz
Wonyoung barely sings
@@Watt_1200 Yeah But not like' In Iz*one She sing some of her part even She do her hightnote, i think Shes stable
@@Flyndown.0 she should be a stable singer afterall she has been a trainee and a professional idol aswell
@@Watt_1200 I think She Is stable Just that She Didn't have a confidence to Let her voice out
Nmixx better sorry
실력이란 한 번에 확 늘지는 않지만 이정도면 일레븐 때에 비해 정말 많이 개선했네.. 특히 원영이는 실력도 늘었지만 무대를 대하는 자세가 많이 바꼈다고 봄. 물론 아직 갈 길이 멀지만 비는 파트 거의 없이 해냈고 꾸준히 발전 가능성을 보여주니까 남들이 뭐라뭐라 해도 기대하고 있는 거야. 앞으로 더 발전하고 훗날 누구에게나 인정받을 만큼 프로페셔널해지자. 노력으로 이겨낸 사람은 훗날 더 인정받더라.
솔직히 난 이런 댓글도 웃김... 장원영이 무대를 대하는 자세가 많이 바꼈다? ㅋㅋ 유튜브에서 단편적으로 깔려고 잘라둔 영상만 보고 그렇게 생각하는거겠지 내가 계속 본 장원영은 아이즈원때나 아이브때나 무대하면서 설렁인다고 느낀적은 한번도 없음
@@dicu8776 저두용 보컬적인면이 부족한건 뭐 알고있는 사실이지만 솔직히 무대할때 머리 자주만진다 이런걸로 까였는데 ruclips.net/user/shortshK8QAZS7q_E?feature=share 보면 알겠지만 그런것조차 장원영한텐 무대를 잘하기 위한 노력이었음 얼굴도 피지컬도 너무 갓벽해서 딱봤을때 아이돌에 진심 아닌멤버처럼 모르는 사람들 눈엔 보이는지 모르겠지만 오히려 프메도 거의 매일같이 찾아와서 소통하는 아이돌임
근데 외모가 실력이라 뽑힌애인데 보컬멤버들놔두고 장원영한테 보컬능력으로 왜 지적하는거? 음치인것도아니고 장원영이 노래까지 잘하면 미친거아니냐고 ㅋㅋ 난 다른 그룹들 랩담당 멤버들 랩으로 까이는건 그동안 한번도못본듯 보통 비쥬얼노래안되는멤버 랩많이시켰는데 그건 외우기만하니까 욕도 안먹고 ㅋㅋ 장원영혼자만 너무 가혹한 느낌인데? 뭐만하면 무대태도안좋다 열정없다 이지랄하고 ㅋㅋㅋ 수많은 다른 아이돌들 무대컨디션 들쭉날쭉하는경우가 얼마나많은데
@@dicu8776 도대체 뭘보고 대하는자세가 바꼈다고하는지 ㅋㅋㅋ 관심법으로 속마음도보나? 늘 잘된영상은 안보고 안된영상들만찾아보고 하는말아닌가? ㅋㅋㅋ
@@fruit-tf7bz 솔직히 장원영 정도 비주얼이면 노래실력 좀 부족해도 되는게 그간 아이돌판 아니었나.. 진심 좀 의아함ㅎㅎ;
이런말 하면 또 쿵쾅거리면서 달려와서 아이돌가수는 가수 아니냐면서 지팡이 휘두르는데 아이돌산업에서 그게 현실인데 뭐 어쩌란거임. 원영이 정도 피지컬에 비주얼이면 서브보컬 정도 해도 충분히 1인분 넘어서 2인분 몫 하는거라고 볼 수 있는건데, 뭘 그렇게 바라는게 많은거임 노래 못해서 랩같지도 않은 랩 하고 있는 아이돌이 수백명인 세상에 별 ㅋ
They all did so well 💚
Ive been waiting you for love dive mr removed for so longgg, finally
amazing vocals from yujin and liz, stable vocals from rei, vocal improvement from wonyoung, and gaeul and leeseo are good. all QUEEN
wonyoung improved soo much, i'm so glad that she's becoming more confident in singing live
:)? Oh I don't think WY improved
@@longoan9408 well, i think she improved a lot. In the past, she seemed lacks of confidence to let her voice out. And in this era, she tries her best to sing all of her part. And that's definitely an improvement
@@longoan9408 you re Vietnam, wonyoung changed her technique vocal
@@lavienrosewon8811 yep I'm vietnamese, I just feel her vocal still very weak :) that is my opinion
@@lavienrosewon8811 i’m sorry but what does op being Vietnamese have to do with this conversation?
I'm so proud of wonyoung! She improves so much and sings her parts as much as she could. She used to not sing most of her lines in iz*one and i think its mostly cuz its too high for her. Glad that starship gives her parts that is more of her vocal range, and she trained so much and her hardwork really paid off. 🥺❤️ Also, the other members are also so good eventho they are dancing! Good job, IVE
wonyoung really improved i’m so happy for her. you can tell she’s be practicing.
Liz is so underappreciated :
타팬이면서 지들 좆대로 악플 달았다가 칭찬해 줬다가 하는 거 너무 같잖음 ㅋㅋㅋ 실력 너무 늘었다 ㅠㅠ ㅇㅈㄹ 떠는 거 진짜... 평가 좀 그만하고 꺼져 타팬이면 남의 아이돌 평가질할 시간에 니네 아이돌이나 신경쓰세요
The mr removed you made is one of the best. They are clean and at the same time real👍🏻💞
Gaeul is so stable!
원영님 일레븐 때 보다 많이 늘으셨다 ㅜㅜㅜㅜ 노력하는 모습이 보이니까 계속 찾아 보게 되는 것 같아요 아자뵹뵹
원영이 진짜 많이 늘었다.. 개인적으로 팬들이 실력 없는 멤버 늘지도 않았는데 많이 늘었다고 난리치는 거 안 좋아하는데 타팬 입장에서도 진짜 많이 는 것 같음ㅠㅜ 일레븐 때 실력이랑 표정가지고 말 많았는데 피드백 빨리 고치는 거 너무 대단하고 멘탈 좋은 듯.. 상처 안 받고 오래 활동했으면 좋겠다 실력 더 쌓으면 진짜 더 대박날 듯..
‘타팬’ 입장 = 원래부터 빠순이
@@Gureumi75 아니 빠순이면 뭐 어쩌라고ㅋㅋㅋㅋ지도 아이돌 보고 댓달고 있으면서
전 근데 댓글로 피드백은 좋다고 생각하는데 피드백이라는 명목으로 악플 다는 사람들이 많아서 좀 걱정됨...
또..표정 별로다 바꿔라 이런 댓글 달고나서
바뀌면 "ㅣ힣 내가 장원영 표정 바꿨다" 하는 생각 하는 것도 너무 싫음
솔직히 팬 입장에서 표정 전이랑 후랑 크게 신경도 안 쓰고 이쁘기만 한데 지들이 바꿨네 뭐네 내가 댓글 달았더니 좋아졌네 어쨋네 하는 것도 다 억까같고 자의식 과잉같고 그럼.. 갸륵이 뭔 갸륵인데
그냥 이쁘기만 한데..
그런식으로 댓글 안 달아도 원영이라는 사람은 스스로 발전해 갈 수 있고 그런 의지도 보이는 사람인데
사소한 걸로 욕하고 까는게 너무 보기 싫어요
ㅇㅈ...일반 무대때는 긴장없이 잘하는거 같은데
앵콜 하면 테스트 받는다는 생각때문에 압박? 되어서 더 그러는듯...ㅠㅠ 워뇽이좀 그만 괴롭혔음 좋겠다 진짜
@@빠나나우유-p9h 맹목적으로 장원영 늘었다라고 하는 팬들이 오히려 원영이 죽이는거지
Omg Leeseo’s “Oh perfect sacrifice” part 😮❤
vocals are not ive strongest point
but that's okay because their songs are still good
how did some of them even get to the kpop industry theyre literally below average in vocals
fr
Well ...kpop groups always about visual first
wonyoung slaying throughout the song
Where I can barely hear her.
@@nagmakhan7836 then grow better ears
@@ivebptwicetheholetrinity3466 well I am not hateing her I just can't hear her very clearly.
@@nagmakhan7836 skill issue
@@nagmakhan7836 wonyoung is fine i was talking about you 💀
진짜 원영아 너무 짱이다 멋있고 ..❤️🔥
Wow, their vocals did improve a lot. Slay girls!
The second narcissistic part didn't even utter one word. Most of them are stable though especially the perfect sacrifice part.
i love it when 4th kpop group live singing ❤️ well done ive
Liz's voice is heaven 👏🏻👏🏻
wonyoung is always a great singer, its just she isn't confident with her singing. glad to see that she improved a lot in this stage!
shes really great at singing and dancing, she just needs more confidence
exactly, izone just did dirty to force her singing not in her comfortable range
@@kimseorufaxclarity3251 and? what is ur point here?
i agree she has the talent but needs the confidence. I can see her improving with each comeback tho.
Your Back! yay!
장원영 갓기야ㅜㅜ 어떻게 널 사랑하지 않을 수 있겠니ㅜㅜㅜㅜ
*THE ONLY MR REMOVED I TRUST*
I hope DIVE will be more protective of Wonyoung. At least that would help her gain more confidence. Some ppl are too ignorant to cyberbully a 13-year-old and just won't give up on hating. And seriously, Starship should cut down her volume of work time.
리즈 너무 잘 해 ㅠㅠㅠ 아이브 일레븐 뒤로 보컬 연습 많이 한 것 같아서 너무 감격 ㅠㅠ 더더 흥하는 그룹되면 좋겠어요~~ 아이브 화이팅!!🥰🥰
This is real live?? They really did so well
Yes in their performance too you can ger breath and move their mic
Hear
I think it's pre-recorded. Just like how bang chan of skz explained it. To look like they're singing live but they recorded it before the performance. And I hope people won't come on me for saying this
@@yongbokieswaifu5226 0:58 you can listen to Yujin gasping or something sound . It is definitely live.
@@yongbokieswaifu5226 How can we tell the difference between the two?
1:00 -여기 이서언니 진짜 잘한다-
Gaeul did really well!!!!!!!!
SO PROUD OF YOU MY BABY
the fact i think yujin was carrying the song since she was actually singing like..
원영이 진짜 좋아져서 너무 좋다 예전에 솔직히 실력논란은 인정하긴 한데 표정이나 그런 걸로 까는 건 너무 억지였음 원영ㅇ 진짜 대단하긴 함 나이가 어린데도 불구하고 이미 데뷔한 사람들 사이에서도 돋보이는 탑급,, 요즘 데뷔하는 원영이 나이대 여돌들은 어케 데뷔했는지 의문인데 원영이랑 유진인 미쳤음 ㄷㄷ ㅠㅠㅠ 표정연기 스타성 이런 거 타고났음 나이 모르는 상태로 보면 최소 데뷔 3,4년 차 선배로 보임 물론 가수니까 노래 잘해야 하는 건 맞는데 다른 이상한 이유로도 까이니까 안쓰러울 따름.. 그렇게나 심한 욕 먹는데도 바로바로 고치고 진짜 제발 악플 이딴 건 신경 안 써줬음 좋겠음 어린 나이에 안 먹어도 될 욕까지 먹고 아이브 팬 아닌데도 너무하다는 생각임 좋은 것만 보고 나쁜 생각 안 하고 오래오래 활동해줬으면 하는 바람..
ANOTHER REASON WHY REI IS MY BIAS 🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩💞
I really thought wonyoung was going to sound worse. I still think she's a pretty weak vocalist, but she attempted all her notes and although she missed her high note it was not by a large margin enough to say she can't actually hit it. The other girls stellar as always. I knew Yujin had it in her but Lesseo really impressed me with her chorus.
She did high note in others stage
Here she was nervous
@@lavienrosewon8811 I am sure. I feel she's been under a lot pressure with going back to MC and everyone hating on her cuz Sakura is about to debut.
@@dividedify wonyoung is next kpop queen no hate toward sakura
Sakura vocal is really weak ...
@@lavienrosewon8811 Love them both, so just hope people can realize there are real human beings, not robots. They feel.
진짜 음역대 무식하게 높일 필요가 없다니까 다 너무 잘함ㅠ..
So pretty IVE
They improved more than last live. They sing more stably. Wonyoung also has a bit improvement but somtimes she skips some parts. Rei didn't skip her lines that is praiseworthy. Liz is main vocal so she has stability but somtimes she also skips her parts like Wonyoung. Yujin ,Gaeul, Leeseo are really stable and did well their lines.
JUST WOW!!!THESE VOCALS ARE AMAZING
Ok but there are so many groups that can't even sing live or barely do it and here we have IVE with every single member singing at least one of their lines clearly, even with the choreo and all, incredible
다 너무 잘해.. ❤
This is amazing, im so proud of the girls
I love the way they still try singing live even if it's not perfect but still I am really happy to see them singing live
Wonyoung did well😍
LIZ VOICE 💗
yujin leeseo rei so stable ❣❣
yujin is the best , but everyone is good singer . I loving this song .
Their live vocals are so good as is they don't know the point of backing track anymore
OMG LEESEO'S "OH PERFECT SACRIFICE" ❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥
yujin and lee seo so stable!!
they all are improving, so happy for them, IVE fighting!
레이 미쳤는데??💗
LIZ LEESEO AND YUJIN AMAZE ME!!
원영이 진짜 많이 늘어서 너무 행복하다…ㅠㅠ
remind me the last time there's an actual breathing sound in any kpop idol's mr removed.. IVE they are literally a breath of fresh air
Stayc run2u.
No hate I was just giving an example of breath during live stages
@@isaswith3837 StayC are real singers since debut, almost live stages every performance.
Liz is very stable ♥️🔥