The Kris - A Must Have + History

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 9 сен 2024

Комментарии • 250

  • @OhCrxzeh
    @OhCrxzeh 4 года назад +73

    It‘s so hard to get one of those here in Germany :/ I‘ve been fanboying the Kris-Blades since I first saw one. Greetings to all my Americans, have a blessed, Corona-free time!

    • @ragnarok7498
      @ragnarok7498 4 года назад +4

      you can find both on lamnia.com

    • @The4cp
      @The4cp 4 года назад +2

      You too my friend

    • @deimos4071
      @deimos4071 4 года назад

      BA blades in the UK provided mine and they are the local cold steel franchise. Excellent company and still operating in the lockdown, had them in stock zwei minuten ago. Priced in euros if required. D.

    • @dragonfell5078
      @dragonfell5078 3 года назад +1

      You can find them pretty easily here in Malaysia! XD

    • @anthonycanady4051
      @anthonycanady4051 3 года назад

      Check medievil collectables they have a whole bunch of cool shit

  • @arpioisme
    @arpioisme 4 года назад +30

    For a javanese, the wavy blade is not the definitive design of a keris. A blade must have three aspect to be even considered a keris and not just a keris-like object (which there are many) : 1. The material must be steel ; 2. It has to have a definite, separate gonjo (that guard-like flare actually is separate, but one) ; 3. It has to have a 'condong leleh' (that cant forward) of at least around 5°, but not more than 15°

    • @kevinmorrice
      @kevinmorrice 11 месяцев назад

      this isnt a javanese one, its based on the filipino kris

  • @keithbodnar2937
    @keithbodnar2937 4 года назад +36

    I really like the historical aspects of Luke's presentations of Cold,Steel Edged Weaponry!

  • @mathewrculbertson
    @mathewrculbertson 4 года назад +17

    I own both CS Kris blades. But spyderco actually did a really cool Kris back in the mid 2000s. Keep up the good videos Luke.

  • @GOxHAM
    @GOxHAM 4 года назад +11

    Love these historical stories behind various blades and weapons. Extremely interesting to say the least. Thank you very much for these! They are very fun to watch and educational.

  • @martinsmith3550
    @martinsmith3550 3 года назад +3

    Keris wave shapes like snake… silent and deadly. Kris is not for box opening or unboxing, noisy marital art fighting or so call self defence, but Kris design size and blade material all aim at silently slipping into opponent stomach and pull enemies’ intestine out ; it is designed purely to kill. It is not designed to deter enemies from attacking you or design to just hurt someone, it is designed to kill. When you attack with Keris you need to focus, silently bend your knees so that the blade will cut through the center of the stomach, (belly button) ;
    There was primitive groups (until now) believe amongst South East Asian (Hindu) warriors that you need to consume enemies’ intestine to gain courage, so that the enemies’s spirit be with you and keris designed to take out enemies’ intestine. You might heard some groups fighting happens in South East Asia still uses Keris and they attacked kill the enemies silently at night and then consume their enemies intestine and then drag the remains on the street to scare the enemies families from taking revenge. This still happens.

  • @bobreynolds744
    @bobreynolds744 Год назад +1

    I love my Voyager Kris. Carry it 24-7.

  • @rockd8946
    @rockd8946 3 года назад +2

    Enjoyed very much. The history itself is amazing and you kept to the point… I just picked up the Ti-Lite version. One of the many things I’ve always enjoyed with Lynn’s designs… you said it right- every knife has a function. Thanks for a great history on these.

  • @umarzaidzulkifli8294
    @umarzaidzulkifli8294 4 года назад +4

    Keris is originally from Indonesia & Malaysia

  • @PerfectNormal
    @PerfectNormal Год назад +1

    I love my Ti-lite Kriss 6" Serrated. I loved it so much, I bought a second one.

  • @hezsurnarcissus1460
    @hezsurnarcissus1460 4 года назад +4

    COLD STEEL NEED TO RE-RELEASE THE FIXED NAGA KRIS THAT THEY USED TO MAKE, THING WAS AWESOME

  • @kaizoebara
    @kaizoebara 4 года назад +3

    Linder in Solingen, Germany, still makes flame daggers to this day. As for modern interpretations, Spyderco had a kris model some years back.

  • @ummfaizal
    @ummfaizal Год назад +4

    The most magical Kris in Malaysia is Swinging Monkey Kris owned by Sultan of Selangor. In the past the kris belongs to a big monkey that killed 99 people. The monkey later defeated by a local warrior using cork wood that stuck the kris blade. Because of 99 people have been lost their soul through this kris, when it unsheathed, people around it will feel headache.

    • @sleepsire9321
      @sleepsire9321 Год назад

      I honestly cannot tell if you are joking. Please let me know

    • @emieh.4494
      @emieh.4494 Год назад +1

      ​@@sleepsire9321Unfortunately, he's not joking. We Malaysian, especially the old folks are very superstitious. We like to believe in magical, mythical things. It's in our blood I guess.

  • @jorgefernandez6407
    @jorgefernandez6407 2 года назад +1

    I like that Kris Voyager for SURE!!!

  • @picturesfromabove2018
    @picturesfromabove2018 4 года назад +20

    Both knives look great, but what I personally would really like to see is how this blade is sharpened outside of the factory. I know it is not impossible, but I guess it would be not an easy task.

    • @josemariaalipio449
      @josemariaalipio449 4 года назад +4

      Pictures from Above Agreed. I personally prefer their clip points and tantos. For EDC roles, the kris blade shape isn’t the most practical option. I still appreciate Cold Steel taking risks though.

    • @ArtVSMayhem
      @ArtVSMayhem 4 года назад +5

      Use the Spyderco 204 sharpmaker, and then finish up with a strop.

    • @picturesfromabove2018
      @picturesfromabove2018 4 года назад +1

      Oh absolutely, it's good thing that companies don't fall into stagnation and to release every year practically the same 5 or 6 knives.

    • @picturesfromabove2018
      @picturesfromabove2018 4 года назад +1

      Thank you sir.
      When I buy one I'll have your advice into consideration :)

    • @tikkidaddy
      @tikkidaddy 4 года назад +4

      Round and rat tail Fine diamond and ceramic hones and rounded leather strops by eye. Care and precision. It's not a race. The Spyderco TSM can also be used but again...take your time...NO power tools

  • @KungFuTweety1
    @KungFuTweety1 4 года назад +4

    Love how CS pushes the envelope!

  • @y_saputra761
    @y_saputra761 3 года назад +6

    Javanese kris/Indonesian Kris has beautiful and detail design. It may be not Javanese Kris.

  • @yukafidah1
    @yukafidah1 4 года назад +3

    The purpose of the waves are to break the rib cage as the blade enters the chest cavity.

  • @Wideranger
    @Wideranger 4 года назад +2

    Thanks Cold Steel. Love these videos on the history of different blade designs (love the bad ass testing ones too!). Carrying my Vaquero right now, have a number of your great blades.

  • @boogboog8097
    @boogboog8097 3 года назад +2

    Just got a voyager kris, grinds are amazing fit is perfect not a hint of wiggle in the lock.

  • @willc9235
    @willc9235 4 года назад +5

    Got both of them in a couple weeks ago and they are both super fun knives.

    • @andrew-ripley1747
      @andrew-ripley1747 4 года назад +2

      Grape for you, and no, I'm definitely not jelly.

    • @willc9235
      @willc9235 4 года назад

      Okey doke.🗡

  • @gandoleemuhammad8721
    @gandoleemuhammad8721 4 года назад +8

    KERIS FROM INDONESIA !! 🇲🇨

    • @supremesauce2047
      @supremesauce2047 3 года назад +1

      Not gonna lie,but you're too tacky

    • @malay7371
      @malay7371 3 года назад

      Indonesia ditubuhkan pada tahun keberapa ya? Sorry but i am a bit stupid 😶🙄

    • @adilperdana4509
      @adilperdana4509 3 года назад

      @@supremesauce2047 can't argue with that

    • @dasamukha9379
      @dasamukha9379 3 года назад +1

      @@malay7371 indonesia ditubukan tahun 1932 oleh bangsa jawa , bangsa melayu , bangsa bugis , bangsa dayak dan bangsa2 lain di nusantara lewat sumpah pemuda , satu tanah air , satu bahasa dan satu bangsa INDONESIA...

    • @noviannurfakihk
      @noviannurfakihk 3 года назад

      @@malay7371 mau klaim ke?

  • @Tipi_Dan
    @Tipi_Dan 2 года назад +2

    Cold Steel has done a good job creating reproductions of historic blades, and with its innovative designs.
    The true archipelagian Kriss is not a blade that could ever in any way be mass produced.

  • @classifiedagent8807
    @classifiedagent8807 3 года назад +10

    A keris origin from Malaysia, Indonesia, Southern Thailand, Southern Philipines.
    A well made keris can stand on itsself tip down. Go type KERIS BERDIRI in youtube. U will see
    Click on the most top/first video

    • @candrasari6642
      @candrasari6642 3 года назад +3

      Javanese kris (majapahit kris) is your kris anchestors

    • @AyikFariasi
      @AyikFariasi 3 года назад

      @@candrasari6642 ken arok aja udah pake mas...

    • @noorindra5150
      @noorindra5150 3 года назад +4

      Kris was originated from Java before spreading to Nusantara archipelago

    • @EukalyptusBonBon
      @EukalyptusBonBon 3 года назад

      A well made Keris could make a gecko in the wall falling just by pointing the dagger at it.

  • @beardedwolf628
    @beardedwolf628 4 года назад +1

    not gonna lie it's fucking cool
    no idea what a kriss is but it reminds me of a flamberge or a ceremonial dagger
    these curved blades were hard to forge and therefore very treasured

  • @jaayashree3943
    @jaayashree3943 3 года назад +2

    KRIS ORIGIN FROM JAVA INDONESIA.....A MISTICAL WEAPON.

  • @TheSnakeyes2013
    @TheSnakeyes2013 4 года назад

    Excellent Video! Awesome little history lesson on the kris!

  • @bob_moron
    @bob_moron 4 года назад +4

    Is there going to be another production of Mr. Thompson‘s Vaquero Voyager? I desperately need one 😊

  • @NMiller_
    @NMiller_ 4 года назад +2

    I really think the Kriss Vector should have a Kris style bayonet.

    • @andrew-ripley1747
      @andrew-ripley1747 4 года назад +1

      But only if it's at a weird angle to "redirect the stabbing force". :)

  • @isaacrhodes4617
    @isaacrhodes4617 2 года назад

    great vid :) love the historical inspirations behind Cold Steel blades.

  • @julesthurongi1223
    @julesthurongi1223 4 года назад +2

    Thanks Luke!!
    Gonna try to get a Kris Voyager for my Bday!
    Love the design of it!! Also all those humps acting like miniature recurves! 👍

  • @kresna3329
    @kresna3329 3 года назад +1

    Nogososro keris is legend

  • @soulzzplaysgames
    @soulzzplaysgames 4 года назад +1

    Already ordered. Now I'm just over here patiently waiting for the Facon.

    • @j.s.4700
      @j.s.4700 4 года назад

      Facon ..? What it look like

  • @donfierro777
    @donfierro777 2 года назад +1

    Thank You! God bless

  • @patricegarnierlobo25111967
    @patricegarnierlobo25111967 4 года назад +1

    in the past in 80's-90's i bought an automatic italian knife with 20 cm of kriss blade shape!

  • @SilverScarletSpider
    @SilverScarletSpider 4 года назад +1

    I love triple bladed knives. Nothing like it! So much fun!

  • @loti1488
    @loti1488 4 года назад

    Giving love? Hell, you've earned it.

  • @jusufagung
    @jusufagung 3 года назад

    The perfection of the Kris dagger is at the balance. The perfect Kris is at perfect balance that you can make it stand upright at its tip. If it cannot stand up in balance, then it's a bad Kris.

  • @EVENINGWOLF666
    @EVENINGWOLF666 4 года назад +1

    I kind of liked the Naga Kris throwing knife you guys used to make...kind of sad it was discontinued....

  • @KA-jm2cz
    @KA-jm2cz Год назад

    Keris is much more than just "shape of the blade".
    It has almost own culture and presents basically cosmic love.
    Those copy things are just piece of industrial metal (not a music style).

  • @hildolfrdraugadrottin7279
    @hildolfrdraugadrottin7279 4 года назад +1

    I like the designs and the Ti-lite is one of my favorite blades.
    They look really cool and I bet they cut really well too but sharpening one correctly wouldn't be easy.

    • @beardedwolf628
      @beardedwolf628 4 года назад +1

      definitely not easy to sharpen, you'd have to follow that curve with a thin belt I reckon

    • @andrew-ripley1747
      @andrew-ripley1747 4 года назад +1

      I'm not great with hand sharpening and I think some guided systems like the the DMT/Lansky/KME clamp-based systems may not sharpen the interior of the curves well (I have trouble with simple recurves on the DMT Aligner). However, any free/partially-guided stone system (bench stone, Sharpmaker, etc.) should work- you can drag the edge along and access the insides of the curves. Hissatsu5 had a video on this recently.

  • @remb9614
    @remb9614 Год назад +1

    I have a voyager kris and it’s not used for anything but self defense. I wouldn’t want to sharpen it lol

  • @asfvck7397
    @asfvck7397 4 года назад +1

    Exceptional Content!

  • @LegionTacticoolCutlery
    @LegionTacticoolCutlery 4 года назад +8

    Whens the Woodman's Sax coming out?

    • @adods9824
      @adods9824 6 месяцев назад

      Out now, the Karve

  • @anamariecarlos-barr5452
    @anamariecarlos-barr5452 4 года назад +1

    Pacific cutlery/ Benchmade did it in the 1980s.

  • @kenmarapese9085
    @kenmarapese9085 4 года назад

    Dig the history, beautiful folders!

  • @Digital2pulse
    @Digital2pulse 2 года назад

    The longest variant of the kris sword is from philippines, we call it Kris too and also Kalis

  • @holyshaman
    @holyshaman 4 года назад +2

    Just take my money already , damnit!!

  • @wross5961
    @wross5961 2 года назад

    looks wicked but the 4 or 5 inch vanquero will bite harder and slice deeper but kris dagger is a more nasty damage used as push dagger and should stay as a fixed dagger since useless as everyday utility use plus it's difficult to sharpen on whetstone unless using a round stone rod.

    • @saifaldin_
      @saifaldin_ Год назад +1

      Traditionally, keris is not sharpened at all.. it’s a stabbing weapon. Most of the time, only the tip is sharp. For everyday tasks, we have other kinds of blades - golok, parang etc.

  • @newvillagefilms
    @newvillagefilms 3 года назад

    With Netflix Trese out, you'd get demand for a kris dagger for collection.

  • @zjoaquin
    @zjoaquin 4 года назад

    Wow very nice, these Cold Steel blades are growing in me.

    • @adods9824
      @adods9824 6 месяцев назад

      On you .. hopefully!. Lol

  • @LDmagnum
    @LDmagnum 4 года назад

    That shirt is kick ass

  • @rosh5924
    @rosh5924 2 года назад

    For the morokris. There's a lot of version depending on the tribe. Northern filipinos relied on the jungle. But the moros in the south preferred the plains. They attack out in the open. Thats why weapons from the south are a bit bigger. They tend to wrap their hands, binding it firmly to the sword.

  • @arrifjoe
    @arrifjoe 3 года назад

    You know? A well made keris can stand on its own

  • @patricegarnierlobo25111967
    @patricegarnierlobo25111967 4 года назад +1

    and i saw a lot off knives with kriss blades make by french soldier in the trench in the ww1

  • @claytonlovendale2021
    @claytonlovendale2021 3 года назад +1

    What I would like to see is a traditional/ modern Filipino Kris sword. Cold Steel rocks. It would definitely be my sword of choice, combined with a companion off hand Kris knife.

    • @atlasflame2510
      @atlasflame2510 3 года назад

      Try maranao kris swrod in the Philippines they create most beautiful kris

  • @CECS1
    @CECS1 8 месяцев назад

    Serrations could be yhe most modern adaptation of Kris inspiration (at least round bread knife serrations)

  • @joeythethrifty
    @joeythethrifty 4 года назад +1

    The Benchmade BM49 was a production kris blade

    • @andrew-ripley1747
      @andrew-ripley1747 4 года назад +1

      The balisong from Face/Off? :)

    • @joeythethrifty
      @joeythethrifty 4 года назад

      @@andrew-ripley1747 that's the one, knockoffs from dhgate only 25 bucks too

  • @nafis6668
    @nafis6668 4 года назад

    That Voyager looks more like a traditional weapon, Badik. Try to look it up guys. Badik comes with wavy blades as well.

    • @nafis6668
      @nafis6668 4 года назад

      pusakadunia.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/badik-pusaka-terbaik-sedunia_4.jpg

  • @fatman4792
    @fatman4792 4 года назад +1

    @ cold steel
    You guys considering a full size moro kris

  • @petrusronald5815
    @petrusronald5815 4 года назад

    Wow. You really making it. 2kinds of folding kris. Those would b great

  • @richardhenry1969
    @richardhenry1969 4 года назад

    Great video I'm definitely getting one

  • @olgacherednik2525
    @olgacherednik2525 4 года назад

    I realy like this presenter !!!

  • @78troland
    @78troland 4 года назад

    Very good,thank you!!😊🙏🙏

  • @zaqssb2725
    @zaqssb2725 4 года назад +1

    Javanese kriss👍👍.. Indonesia and malaysia

  • @heimdall8305
    @heimdall8305 11 месяцев назад

    It's a talisman rather than a weapon, some of them are sacred.

  • @channelsepotong2852
    @channelsepotong2852 4 года назад +2

    Kris from java Indonesia

  • @ayahaskara
    @ayahaskara 2 года назад

    I Think you must visit Neka Museum At Ubud - Bali. There a lot of ancient Keris that so beautiful in design.

  • @anthonyp7051
    @anthonyp7051 4 года назад

    Don’t think there’s a more exciting blade style
    When I’m ready I hope there’s one of two I can snag

  • @jasonpettit9984
    @jasonpettit9984 4 года назад +3

    Oh ,,,she is pretty,,Thanks for the toys Lynn...

  • @grenade180
    @grenade180 4 года назад

    Please make more! Im so sad that i cant buy one right now.

  • @eezokk
    @eezokk 2 года назад

    They are still out of stock :/ been looking dor one forever when will u guys be making more

  • @awenxchayoo5614
    @awenxchayoo5614 3 года назад +1

    Kris from indonesia

  • @akhabibhabib6432
    @akhabibhabib6432 Год назад

    That blade to malay history

  • @tomn1026
    @tomn1026 4 года назад +2

    Take the 4max scout & build a recurve blade and then also make 4max scout tanto that would be awesome!!!

  • @sharpsholdier
    @sharpsholdier 3 года назад +1

    Cold Steel, when are you going to give us a fixed blade version....????

  • @isabellam1936
    @isabellam1936 Год назад

    Can you do a video on your new Kris Dagger that just came out?

  • @Atharod
    @Atharod 4 года назад +1

    But this isn't a Kris. A Kris is much more than a flamed blade. Or did you say, that a Flamberg is a giant Kris?

  • @MrOttmandus
    @MrOttmandus 4 года назад +2

    Flamberge swords!!!!! Pleae

  • @Shady36
    @Shady36 2 года назад +2

    Fun fact: the Yakan people, native to the island of Basilan (southern Philippines) used to gift a Kris blade of pure Silver or Gold along with a string of South Sea Pearls to people they deem a "friend to Islam", although often painted as rebels or terrorists by MSM, they were one of the few Moros who argued and fought against the lunacy of ISIS when it was initially preached to their people. Now their waters are being polluted and stripped bare by China's maritime militia.

  • @pashatheharamdestroyer1113
    @pashatheharamdestroyer1113 4 года назад +1

    My country's weapon 😁

  • @ogloc6308
    @ogloc6308 2 года назад

    Indonesians invented some cool knives including the kris and the karambit

  • @PREPFORIT
    @PREPFORIT 4 года назад

    I like them all !

  • @07_defransalvinochristiawa19
    @07_defransalvinochristiawa19 4 года назад +1

    Kris is from Indonesia in Java island not in the Vietnam

    • @blackmanoversized5028
      @blackmanoversized5028 3 года назад

      iya dia kan dah bilang javanese(jawa) cuma itu ada keris vietnam keris kan senjata asli nusantara(indonesia,malaysia,brunei,philipina,thailand,myanmar,vietnam

  • @JETBLACKPRIEST
    @JETBLACKPRIEST 4 года назад +1

    The only thing stopping me from buying one is the steel, why oh why did yall cheap out on one of the sickest folders you've made in a while?!

    • @nathandoll.
      @nathandoll. 4 года назад +2

      I asked this on their Instagram and they said the Lynn Thompson Kriss Ti-Lite was more of a "decorative" piece... like wtf? I was wondering the same thing. And for like 100 bucks, I would say 440c is just not it chief... stick with the voyager

    • @JETBLACKPRIEST
      @JETBLACKPRIEST 4 года назад +1

      @@nathandoll. decorative... What the fuck, who knew cold steel was in the business of wall hangers now

    • @davidwooden3878
      @davidwooden3878 4 года назад

      Agreed, I had hoped for one of their better tool steels for this ti-lite, especially at this price tag. I would love to have it for my collection and EDC but I want a better steel and preferably different scales. Could we get it with the aluminum scales? And I'm also not crazy about the green zytel. Can't go wrong with black, ya know?

  • @pmq6645
    @pmq6645 4 года назад +5

    It's origin is from ancient Vietnam, bring it with you when you go into the jungle, and the jungle will starts talking to you.

    • @07_defransalvinochristiawa19
      @07_defransalvinochristiawa19 4 года назад +4

      No its Javanese kriss from Indonesia not from vietnam

    • @fajaradynurcahya5806
      @fajaradynurcahya5806 4 года назад

      keris from indonesia bro....

    • @pmq6645
      @pmq6645 4 года назад +1

      @@fajaradynurcahya5806 yes, the keris is from Indonesia, but the prototype of the kris comes from either Vietnam or India, maybe we did not called it "keris" when we invented it, but we did inspired the Indonesian Keris a lot

    • @AyikFariasi
      @AyikFariasi 3 года назад

      @@pmq6645 in my opinion,.. those years, vietnam still influenced by chinesse weaponry... (bronze)
      If talking about iron or steel,.. either it comes from java or around damascus..
      Just my opinion here, dont be so serious about it or even angry.. :))

  • @muhammadzainalahmad4837
    @muhammadzainalahmad4837 4 года назад +1

    the Javanese , arek Suroboyo Here

  • @agustinusHMPTI
    @agustinusHMPTI 4 года назад +2

    Indonesian legend blade.

  • @iamfuckingyourwaifuandther2743
    @iamfuckingyourwaifuandther2743 4 года назад

    Hope they come out with a serrated version.

  • @vybtom1
    @vybtom1 4 года назад +3

    For anyone who is interested in these Filipino warriors who used the Kris blades:
    ruclips.net/video/faX04-lGziU/видео.html
    (starts at 01:00)

  • @MountaineerSamurai
    @MountaineerSamurai 4 года назад

    Limited Edition Kris my ass🤣😂

  • @KungFuTweety1
    @KungFuTweety1 4 года назад

    Please do a kriss with a thumb plate so we can wave it out the pocket like an ak47 folder!

  • @denmasdedychannel
    @denmasdedychannel 3 года назад +1

    I like keris from java

  • @pietrocardinali9725
    @pietrocardinali9725 4 года назад

    Ottimo video ciao da italia

  • @johnmcdonald8760
    @johnmcdonald8760 2 года назад +1

    5 foot 2

  • @SaifulIkram
    @SaifulIkram 2 года назад

    The Malaccan warrior Hang Tuah, took possession of "Taming Sari" after a duel with the foremost Majapahit (Javanese) warrior.

  • @sharpsholdier
    @sharpsholdier 3 года назад

    just got a limited edition Lynn Thompson ti-lite, serial number is 1964...however, there isn't Lynn's signature on the back of the box. Is this an original or did I get a knock-off counterfeit copy...???

  • @KevinK88
    @KevinK88 4 года назад +1

    Is the bailsong from the movie face/off?

    • @adods9824
      @adods9824 6 месяцев назад

      Yes. Macw by benchmade.

    • @adods9824
      @adods9824 6 месяцев назад

      Benchmade BM49

  • @abdulraafi-alia.arumpac7693
    @abdulraafi-alia.arumpac7693 4 года назад +4

    moro warriors hated to be called "filipino". my grandfather told me if you were labelled or called a filipino back in the old days it means your a traitor. proud muslim/moro warriors will never accept to be branded a follower named after a christian foreign king (king Philip). moro kris were used to fight against spaniards and filipinos ( people who submitted to spanish rule)

  • @sharpsholdier
    @sharpsholdier 4 года назад

    Cold Steel, could you please release a fixed Kriss as well.....????