@@noagerestrictions3337 no, they shouldve swapped moka and WONHEE. Yunah has decent vocals. Wonhee is mainly just a visual.. She doesn't provide much to the group
@@chenles_defender Yg vocalist have very stable vocals and you are just a blackpink hater btw and if you think yg don't have stable vocalist go search teayang park bom june yoon rosé or bang yedam you will get your answer
@@Shasha-ud7zb Maybe the idols you mentioned are good vocalists, except from Bom, but what about the others? Blackpink and many other YG idols are known for having weak vocals, which proves that you don't need stable vocals to debut under YG.
@@chenles_defender Bro yg recently debuted baby monster like...go search their live singing and what do you mean except bom teayang from bigbang still is considered one of the best vocalist in industry and akmu like girl..? Their vocals are chef kiss and treasure never hesitate to sing live see their mama stag and both ikon and winner is made from survival show go see their performance
I felt wonhee was focusing on dancing rather than singing. They could have skipped dancing part. It just felt like they were trying to avoid singing and hiding their cracked voice by dancing
It was bad. People need to stop denying it. When NewJeans or Unis or Nmixx sing live since their debut, they are so good, so it’s no excuse for these girls. This is the career they chose, so they should be able to sing properly.
I def. agree with Girlgroups having worst live vocals but all the Boygroups of HYBE are freaky amazing .. have you not listening to BOYNEXTDOOR singing live .. also TWS .. as a rookie group .. they're such so damn good ... FROM BTS to TWS all the HYBE Boygroups are amazing @@ClubPuguin
@@kimjeongwon-ll3dh this comment was about lesserafim and ILLIT. we know that therem are very good vocals in BABYMONSTER. lmao. your comment came out of no where.
the funny thing is that they only sing 1-2 lines each and have a rest or breathe in between while just standing still... yet they could not even deliver a proper singing ability.
@@febirizkiana3329and the song is very short clearly made for tiktok with one hookstep no pre chorus they repeat the same lines the ending of the song is so blank like it doesn't have any difficulty part of singing even a E grade singer can sing alone the Japanese members teacher was Sakura i think 😂😂
Thanks to technology (which hybe relies on) that people like these sound good in recorded version and song becomes hit. Don't know how much modulation and other stuff they do for recording, bet they have a whole dedicated team of technician to polish this sound
They sound decent, like friends having fun in a karaoke not like singers or debuted idols, except for moka who sounds like someone that cant sing at all.
Why did they debut moka tho? Is she a main dancer? Iroha is a better dancer, why did they had to make her in the line up? Its not like her visuals r outta of the world or something, her singing is not bad but definitely not idol level, its only her stage presence that's decent but that's not even the bare minimum, its hybes fault to rig the lineup so bad, its not like she doesn't deserve it but i feel she needs more time to improve she needed atleast 3-4 years she would've been a great dancer
If minju were still in yg, she would be in a more loved group than hated.. i was feeling bad while writing this comment.. but its true that hybe should thank yg...
the producer of this song probably made Moka sing like she's squeezing her voice or something..they taught her bad technique..ugh i miss r u next moka so much
Chaewon is an experienced and a passionate idol! So since she had these qualities, she ain't gotta trained fully! That's why her vocals stand out in hybe
Tbh Danielle is uninteresting overall as a singer, I think she’s way too airy and shallow when it comes to her support range too, she just stands out in New jeans along with Hanni since no standout vocalist exists in that group.
Lol.. they didn't even need to belt or dance while doing it and still couldn't pull it off cleanly. Encore used to be fun during Bigbang and Shinee's days when they'll turn it into a mini concert 😂. This group already debuted as professionals. They're not trainees anymore. No excuses.😂
You people are funny. K-pop idols always have been visuals and dance >>> singing. Put all the idols singing 100% raw without any effects including echo, and you will realize that 80% of them can't sing well.
Ask them to go to vocal coach or our ears will be bleeding. Please never invite them unless they have got vocal training. This is really serious. Kpop will be known as the groups of non skill singers. They can't even sound well. Shame on you HYBE. Moka is the worst.
TF HAPPENED WITH MOKA’S VOICE?! She sounds so weird I almost burst out laughing🤣🤣🤣🤣 especially the “boy” part. I think she’s not singing in her natural tone cuz it sounds so forced and strange
i just recently started to get to know illit so that's why i am here at their magnetic 2nd encore win,,and all the people at comment section are so narcissist commenting mean words about this new gg,,as if they can hit a high note as high as Celine Dion,,do you even kow how to sing the way you all are saying that they can't even sing , can't you see that they improved after their1st encore,,if you are confident about your singing talent go and contact hybe and tell them that you want to apply as illit new member or as their vocal coach 🙄
@@catcat04309 so you go to a restaurant and don't expect the chef to be able to cook better than you?? they're singers. they should be able to sing better than the average person.
I feel like Hybe made a bet somewhere down the line that said "We'll debut the groups who can't sing live and they'll be famous. They'll win awards." And some K billionaire was like "You're on." Because what else explains this debuting vocalists who can't sing?
1:48 I watched Xiaojun on Lee Mujin and I can't unhear that vocal cover. Please debut an idol like this that can sing well instead of people who sound like me.
honestly you could argue that they a little sound better than their first encore ( maybe because they weren't crying this time ) , but Minju is still carrying. Vocal training could do them really well , especially Moka. I'm rooting for her to get better. Her voice is super cute and definitely one of my favourites, but with vocal training it could give her a really likeable and unique voice that sounds well enough for future encores. This also goes for every other member. HYBE please get them proper training and don't be so ignorant !!!!
To be honest this one was way better than the first one. I think the people who are so quick to give negative feedback just don’t like the group and will probably always find something negative to say..
Don't remember nmixx, kiss of life and babymonster having the same "flaws". Of course it's fine when voices break or slide from time to time, especially during dancing, but... They're standing. My father is singing better than 3 of them, it's such a cheap excuse for such a rich company. It means you don't have to sing or have any stage presence, you just have to be pretty. It's upsetting of course
It's unfortunate that Minju has to be in this group tbh. She's an amazing singer but because most of the other members are mediocre live, she gets lumped in with them somewhat and instead of her being praised, she gets called "decent". She's not "decent". She's great.
Nah, hell nah. This is bad. This is not idol standard, moreover singer standard, nonetheless artist standard. They still young so I hope they will keep improving themselves and not be so comfortable with this early attention from people
ok i still dont remember mokas voice sounding like that?? i remember it sounding so much better on the show what are they doing to her????? wonhees vocals are disappointing me to no end. after the 5th season performance i thought shed be better than this. i didnt expect her to be good but i certainly didnt expect her to sound bad??? ugh.
Illit has got to be the cutest idol group in a long time. Girl crush has taken over the past decade so it’s really nice seeing a group like ILLIT with their own little cutesy vibe doing so well
Damn if fans will encourage them because they’re pretty then they should have been models not K-pop artists who is supposed to have talent for singing and dancing not rely on auto tune K-pop groups used to go through hell to polish their skills in order to get debuts and their own album..
Actually Moka sounds really good with that stylistic choice when she is in an upper range. Doesn’t go well with low register, me thinks. Still, these girls are getting better at every encore. Hopefully they will be confident enough to not hold back. Also, Hybe needs to give them songs with actual vocal power. This is also a stylistic issue of them, New Jeans went through a lot thanks to that too.
i mean, Yunah and Minju are the best vocals in here (Wonhee had lines where her vocals were good too), the others are mid but doesn't mean to be bullying them because we can't blame them, they just wanted to be Kpop idols but you have to blame the adults
kpop has dwindled down to "They are not THAT bad. Maybe they'll be good next time!" Like I thought we were supposed to be listening to music by professional singers who debuted after choosing their career by their own will.
Как же отвратительно себя ведут люди в комментариях. Зачем писать такие слова, выделять столько желчи. Именно из-за таких людей группы, которые только дебютировали, бросают это дело, и боятся за каждый свой вздох и пук. Есть много примеров, где слышно вокал девочек, и он очень приятный. Огромное количество групп во время сольного выступления не попадали в ноты или звучали ни как в оригинале, но вы решили накинуться на этих малышек. Они хорошо постарались, и им должно быть очень тяжело после дебюта. Отнеситесь с пониманием к людям, которые работают в k-pop индустрии, ведь они так много делают для нас. ILLIT, спасибо вам за Magnetic! ❤
Let's have them sing in Coachella please, they won 5 times already right, that makes them good right? Coachella Coachella 😂 show them the value of that awards in Coachella, Lets gooo.
큰 일났네....해외팬도 모카가 노래못하는걸 알고있네.신인걸그룹인데....사쿠라는 노래를 못 불러도 이미 인지도가 있기때문에 별 타격이 없지만 이 아이들은 첫 무대에서부터 이렇게 되면 그 이미지가 그대로 가는데.....해외팬들도 계속 모카에 집중해서 보게 될건데 염소소리가 계속 나오면 모카는 앞으로 활동이 힘들어지지.
I know moka sound a bit bad here.. but pls dont relate sakura here, only put blame on moka is enough, because she's the one singing it. Not sakura. Imagine you being blame on others fault.
![K-EVER KPOP LIVE [VOD]](http://yt3.ggpht.com/3jPmwRJS8D1GfMMqgf7WQ_0H0oVckNBYTOWO0LQ60J9YSc5bhz2ivbfRjBa3IKCanAM52Hr6=s48-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj)
![ILLIT, THE SHOW CHOICE! [THE SHOW 240402]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/sUN8c1TzgVs/mqdefault.jpg)
![ILLIT, THE SHOW CHOICE! [THE SHOW 240402]](/img/tr.png)
![[#2024MAMA] ILLIT - Magnetic + Cherish (My Love) | Mnet 241122](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/IiMSmriHe4I/mqdefault.jpg)
![[ENG SUB] What’s in ILLIT’s bags? (Fire Noodles, Hello Kitty, Keyrings, Glasses, Beanies)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/qxl572HCmek/mqdefault.jpg)
MINJU IS CARRYING HER GROUP!!! they need vocal lessons, singing can't always be covered with autotune
Totally agree with this.
Also wonhee
Dont sleep on iroha they shouldve swapped moka and yunah for chanelle and jiwoo
@@noagerestrictions3337 no, they shouldve swapped moka and WONHEE. Yunah has decent vocals. Wonhee is mainly just a visual.. She doesn't provide much to the group
@@myxxteria yeah youre right. Just frustrated chanelle and jiwoo got robbed off their positions
The fact that the only girl who gets minimum praise is a former YG trainee is a funny joke tbh
Minju?
Yes She was part of baemon before debut , and she said she still friends with baemon@@galixiajudith8267
@@galixiajudith8267yea
@@galixiajudith8267 yes
Even then you can kind of hear the voice is aesthetically modelled after rose's voice so have a semblance of uniqueness
Minju is so stable. As expected from ex yg trainee
yeah because yg is the company with such amazing vocals… 😭
What does YG have to do with stable vocals? Blackpink's main vocalist sings like a sub vocalist who strains her vocalist in every performance.
@@chenles_defender Yg vocalist have very stable vocals and you are just a blackpink hater btw and if you think yg don't have stable vocalist go search teayang park bom june yoon rosé or bang yedam you will get your answer
@@Shasha-ud7zb Maybe the idols you mentioned are good vocalists, except from Bom, but what about the others? Blackpink and many other YG idols are known for having weak vocals, which proves that you don't need stable vocals to debut under YG.
@@chenles_defender Bro yg recently debuted baby monster like...go search their live singing and what do you mean except bom teayang from bigbang still is considered one of the best vocalist in industry and akmu like girl..? Their vocals are chef kiss and treasure never hesitate to sing live see their mama stag and both ikon and winner is made from survival show go see their performance
I felt wonhee was focusing on dancing rather than singing. They could have skipped dancing part. It just felt like they were trying to avoid singing and hiding their cracked voice by dancing
Correct - deflecting bad singing by dancing.
Dancing = Avoiding singing? How is this possible? They originally need to sing and dance at the same time.
Can't agree more here. She focuses on dancing and tries to be cute even though she is not
@@geoharioseno9226being cute is the only reason they put her in the group 😂
oh so she's the one 😭the way she tried to act cute though. I kinda feel bad tbh! TRAIN THESE GIRLS 😭imagine being them! I'd be so nervous!!
Kpop has dwindled down to "it's better than the first time". Haha
They give me confident in my own singing, really. Thank you Illit
Same here ✌🏻
LMAO
😂😂😂😂😂
Their faces tell: “Ok, were singing live again. Were fvcked.”
Hahahaha seriously.
? they singed very well, you are searching hate where doesn't have it, just moka need vocal lessons
@@frost.entertainment_rpopyou really have a bad taste in Music
@@frost.entertainment_rpopa tone deaf fan hahaha
Why no one give Yunah some credit, I mean she singing decently enough than Moka, Iroha, and Wonhee
It was bad. People need to stop denying it. When NewJeans or Unis or Nmixx sing live since their debut, they are so good, so it’s no excuse for these girls. This is the career they chose, so they should be able to sing properly.
Lsrfm is their senior what do you expect
New jeans isn't good at all, they have easy songs but they are still off key
@@1i2u59 i disagree
@@1i2u59 broo new Jeans are really good singer and there songs are not that easy
njs sing live so bad
HYBE should start looking for a good vocal coach for their female group
Not just their girl groups need it tho....
@@ClubPuguinwhich of their boy groups can’t sing?
So many comments saying sakura is their vocal coach lmfso
@@Lisa-qm5bc literally all of their artists struggle leaving few
I def. agree with Girlgroups having worst live vocals but all the Boygroups of HYBE are freaky amazing .. have you not listening to BOYNEXTDOOR singing live .. also TWS .. as a rookie group .. they're such so damn good ... FROM BTS to TWS all the HYBE Boygroups are amazing @@ClubPuguin
and yet they keep on winning with that kind of voice quality, no wonder we'll get another new kpop group with same formula
Mereka menang karena lagunya saja yang bagus sama pengaruh agensinya😅
What a waste right 😂
Minju is the backbone of ILLIT like Chaewon and Yunjin of Lesserafim.
Ahyeon ,rami, pharita, rora is the best vocal in baby monster
@@kimjeongwon-ll3dh this comment was about lesserafim and ILLIT. we know that therem are very good vocals in BABYMONSTER. lmao. your comment came out of no where.
@@kimjeongwon-ll3dh this video is not about them don't bring baemon here otherwise they will get unnecessary hate from other people
Yunjin ya cayó con sus gallos
@@kimjeongwon-ll3dh who?
the funny thing is that they only sing 1-2 lines each and have a rest or breathe in between while just standing still... yet they could not even deliver a proper singing ability.
Entonces inténtalo tu
No excuse this time
@@galixiajudith8267You are a delusional fan hahaha
@@galixiajudith8267 their the idol????
HYBE should thank YG for training Minju, she is the only decent here
Which one is her?
@@byhs7 the one with the fluffy blue jacket
Everybody is forgetting yunah 😢
Shes okay@@mRtaROtt
Fact...
if you close your eyes it sounds like a bunch of silly high school girls singing unseriously at a karaoke with one person who can actually sing.
Indeed. Only Minju can sing. Moka is just there to ruin the song
@@febirizkiana3329and the song is very short clearly made for tiktok with one hookstep no pre chorus they repeat the same lines the ending of the song is so blank like it doesn't have any difficulty part of singing even a E grade singer can sing alone the Japanese members teacher was Sakura i think 😂😂
@@febirizkiana3329yunah can sing too
That’s exactly what I felt when I watched their encore for the first time.
Minju has good vocals. Iroha and Wonhee have decent vocals. Yunah and moka have bad vocals. They shouldve been swapped for chanelle and jiwoo
Thanks to technology (which hybe relies on) that people like these sound good in recorded version and song becomes hit. Don't know how much modulation and other stuff they do for recording, bet they have a whole dedicated team of technician to polish this sound
They sound decent, like friends having fun in a karaoke not like singers or debuted idols, except for moka who sounds like someone that cant sing at all.
Legit
Why did they debut moka tho? Is she a main dancer? Iroha is a better dancer, why did they had to make her in the line up? Its not like her visuals r outta of the world or something, her singing is not bad but definitely not idol level, its only her stage presence that's decent but that's not even the bare minimum, its hybes fault to rig the lineup so bad, its not like she doesn't deserve it but i feel she needs more time to improve she needed atleast 3-4 years she would've been a great dancer
Everyone is talking about Minju, but Yunah sang well too, she is worth watching! ❤
Minju's voice is so good!!! Never disappointed
If minju were still in yg, she would be in a more loved group than hated.. i was feeling bad while writing this comment.. but its true that hybe should thank yg...
When moka imitating minju singing technique: no no no girl its sounds like goat.
I see why that 6th member left before debut...
Fr
She dodged a bullet
@@jinwwhit5040 did she? i bet all illit members are getting a bunch of money now. we cant say the same about that girl that left.
They're not singer group,,but dancer group .. only minju can sing..
An idol group MUST be a dancer & singer group.
@@reeahn7605 thing is that their dance isnt good as well
It's always Moka 💀
Moka should be a rapper
moka is sakura lesarafim sister🤣
@@kyunhee_Sakura is her teacher 😂😂😂
which one is moka
can u help me identify moka and iroha rest i know
the producer of this song probably made Moka sing like she's squeezing her voice or something..they taught her bad technique..ugh i miss r u next moka so much
People doing karaoke when they're drunk sound better than most of the Kpop industry lately
Minju had better be a soloist and the rest of them just be back up dancers then.
Minju actually doing better than sone of the senior idols😅
Why hybe is addicted in debuting girls who cant sing. They can skip those girls to only debut chaewon, yunjin, minju, hanni, danielle 🤦♀️
hyein and yuna yoo
@@user-tv4vl9cm8m yes, i think only these 7 qualify to debut
and chaewon wasn't even fully trained by hybe 😂
Chaewon is an experienced and a passionate idol! So since she had these qualities, she ain't gotta trained fully! That's why her vocals stand out in hybe
Tbh Danielle is uninteresting overall as a singer, I think she’s way too airy and shallow when it comes to her support range too, she just stands out in New jeans along with Hanni since no standout vocalist exists in that group.
Lol.. they didn't even need to belt or dance while doing it and still couldn't pull it off cleanly. Encore used to be fun during Bigbang and Shinee's days when they'll turn it into a mini concert 😂. This group already debuted as professionals. They're not trainees anymore. No excuses.😂
What's the point in being idols and can't sing?
Being pretty maybe?
@@rasiqcalid8684 you're right
You people are funny. K-pop idols always have been visuals and dance >>> singing.
Put all the idols singing 100% raw without any effects including echo, and you will realize that 80% of them can't sing well.
@@SuperAvocadoonot all 80% of them are this horrible tho 💀
@@nvt_akh true, just saying that most of them are not professional singer level
They sing better than first time
Better? What?
I will sing better than them fr 😂
they were crying the first time..
@@chosummurphew8214go debut then.
@@YaraPM28 you’re pissed cause you agree too.
Or else why are you up my ass like that lol
@@chosummurphew8214 They actually sound better than first time...
Ask them to go to vocal coach or our ears will be bleeding. Please never invite them unless they have got vocal training. This is really serious. Kpop will be known as the groups of non skill singers. They can't even sound well. Shame on you HYBE. Moka is the worst.
OMGGG I ONLY HAVE VISUALSS!! I CAN'T WAIT TO DEBUT ☺️☺️☺️❤️❤️😝😝😝😝😝😝
Minju and Wonhee rlly carried the song mostly Minju
(Iroah and Yunah 👀👀 was kind of ok)
Moka ummmm
Wonhee was so shaky what are you on if anything yunah did better than her.
are u stupid iroha and yunah were great wonhee idk bro
Agreed
i felt like the ones who were better at singing didn't focus on dancing as much
minju slayeddd
Who keeps voting for them
TF HAPPENED WITH MOKA’S VOICE?! She sounds so weird I almost burst out laughing🤣🤣🤣🤣 especially the “boy” part. I think she’s not singing in her natural tone cuz it sounds so forced and strange
She is definitely the one in most need of vocal training.
Wow I enjoyed today's encore u did well gals and it's more stable than first time
what is moka's position? dance?
Im not sure if their positions are revealed but i think shes like lead dance material
Yunah and minju is so good
Come back to training please… So pitchy
Wonhee looked possessed😂, she's the only one who's focusing on dancing rather than singing..lol😂😂
I swear to god I had to check if I was the only one that saw/thought this 🤣🤣 She’s dancing so hard by herself it’s so cringy and crazy.
@@Mkltrn 😂😂
@@Mkltrnshe clearly having fun cringe?
i just recently started to get to know illit so that's why i am here at their magnetic 2nd encore win,,and all the people at comment section are so narcissist commenting mean words about this new gg,,as if they can hit a high note as high as Celine Dion,,do you even kow how to sing the way you all are saying that they can't even sing , can't you see that they improved after their1st encore,,if you are confident about your singing talent go and contact hybe and tell them that you want to apply as illit new member or as their vocal coach 🙄
You do realize you dont need to be a singer to know someone cant sing, right?
@h.z.1799 yes ofcourse ,, and I'm just so sick of those judgemental haters , as if they do better in singing.
@@catcat04309 so you go to a restaurant and don't expect the chef to be able to cook better than you??
they're singers. they should be able to sing better than the average person.
When you win and people say you can't sing... prove them wrong but it's obvious tone deaf.
외국팬 여러분 모카빼곤 그런대로 라이브 하는편입니다.한국어도 모르면서 가창력 평가는 좀....가창력을 듣고 싶으면 김범수 나얼 박효신 이수 이런 kpop가수들 노래 많이 들어주세요.ㅋㅋ
I feel like Hybe made a bet somewhere down the line that said "We'll debut the groups who can't sing live and they'll be famous. They'll win awards." And some K billionaire was like "You're on." Because what else explains this debuting vocalists who can't sing?
Minju sing very well!
1:00 hyeonju being like: ok alr lets see how this encore goes
the group who all can sing are standing in the back 😮
I love the song and their performances, but I only really love Minju’s voice. I think Wonhee has potential too, just needs polish
1:48 I watched Xiaojun on Lee Mujin and I can't unhear that vocal cover. Please debut an idol like this that can sing well instead of people who sound like me.
honestly you could argue that they a little sound better than their first encore ( maybe because they weren't crying this time ) , but Minju is still carrying. Vocal training could do them really well , especially Moka. I'm rooting for her to get better. Her voice is super cute and definitely one of my favourites, but with vocal training it could give her a really likeable and unique voice that sounds well enough for future encores. This also goes for every other member. HYBE please get them proper training and don't be so ignorant !!!!
what does everyone mean, they sound so cute and cool, just like in original
Cute and cool?? Thats pure strain and instability
Minju’s voice sounds heavenly, and the other’s vocals are honestly sad… :(
Illit is the best
Love all cool girls
Only iroha and minju can sing well
Iroha?? God damn u may have to check your ears if u call her a good singer
EAR CHECK
@@mastervain1583 i watched her privious live vocals and she can actually sing live in my opinion only moka is messing up with sing
@@JohnDoe-xk9th my ears are good tho --
@@Jungkookforlif oooh nooo, then you're delusional haha
Honestly iroha and yunah arent even that bad but Minju is still carying them
Illit beating Kissof💀
Ikr 💀 how is that possible 💀
They are in proving by time💗💗
To be honest this one was way better than the first one. I think the people who are so quick to give negative feedback just don’t like the group and will probably always find something negative to say..
agreed, I don't even stan this group but isn't it normal for rookies to have flaws?
Don't remember nmixx, kiss of life and babymonster having the same "flaws". Of course it's fine when voices break or slide from time to time, especially during dancing, but... They're standing. My father is singing better than 3 of them, it's such a cheap excuse for such a rich company. It means you don't have to sing or have any stage presence, you just have to be pretty. It's upsetting of course
It's unfortunate that Minju has to be in this group tbh. She's an amazing singer but because most of the other members are mediocre live, she gets lumped in with them somewhat and instead of her being praised, she gets called "decent". She's not "decent". She's great.
Most of them arent really that bad, moka has improved a little bit here, but they really improved in the 3rd one.
Honestly they don’t sound that bad. I’ve heard worse encores. Stop the cap 😂
That hybe.... So people hope more
dude no offense they sang like they went to a karaoke or sumthin, and just minju is the one girl good at singing
Just because you’ve heard way worse encores doesn’t mean idols should stay being bad at vocals. It’s like picking a good one between two trash bags.
WAHAHAHAHAHA bros funny af haha
Nah, hell nah. This is bad. This is not idol standard, moreover singer standard, nonetheless artist standard. They still young so I hope they will keep improving themselves and not be so comfortable with this early attention from people
Congrats Illit for the second win
2:14 singing starts 💀
how did moka debut and not jeemin?
ok i still dont remember mokas voice sounding like that?? i remember it sounding so much better on the show what are they doing to her????? wonhees vocals are disappointing me to no end. after the 5th season performance i thought shed be better than this. i didnt expect her to be good but i certainly didnt expect her to sound bad??? ugh.
A voz delas é muito instável. Dá para ver que ficam a um passo da desafinação
Illit has got to be the cutest idol group in a long time. Girl crush has taken over the past decade so it’s really nice seeing a group like ILLIT with their own little cutesy vibe doing so well
This is what happens when you debut children, who's voices have not even developed yet. How can you be a singer and not even find the note?
wdym, have you heard babymonster’s vocals?
Is it because of the song they are singing or the singers? I do not know if it is good or bad.
The singers aren’t trained well enough so they sound bad
This kind of girl group can only release simple, flat songs like this. They can't even sing an entire line. 😂
Oh my..the live singing. It's undeniable.
Minju be slaying 24/7 on encoree🦋
Damn if fans will encourage them because they’re pretty then they should have been models not K-pop artists who is supposed to have talent for singing and dancing not rely on auto tune K-pop groups used to go through hell to polish their skills in order to get debuts and their own album..
2:45 nasal voice
I'm just asking, is one of the MC is UNIS'S Nana? I know some fans might ask this is a ILLIT encore, but I really want to know if that is Nana.
It is she might have had favoritism helping her but shes very good and decent at singin compared to some illit members and sing live 😍🥰
Yep it’s Nana, she was the MC
Yep it’s Nana, she was mcing
@@AestheticAura16 Thank you for letting me know!
Honestly the mv, music & artist are cute/good. Doesn't really matter anymore bout vocals coz u can only hear it RAW during encore.
They sang way better than the other one and thank god they replaced Yous, Us, Baes & Dash da das with studio version 😭
Actually Moka sounds really good with that stylistic choice when she is in an upper range. Doesn’t go well with low register, me thinks. Still, these girls are getting better at every encore. Hopefully they will be confident enough to not hold back. Also, Hybe needs to give them songs with actual vocal power. This is also a stylistic issue of them, New Jeans went through a lot thanks to that too.
Much better than Lle Serrfn whatever and Twice!!! Goodluck Illit
i mean, Yunah and Minju are the best vocals in here (Wonhee had lines where her vocals were good too), the others are mid but doesn't mean to be bullying them because we can't blame them, they just wanted to be Kpop idols but you have to blame the adults
kpop has dwindled down to "They are not THAT bad. Maybe they'll be good next time!" Like I thought we were supposed to be listening to music by professional singers who debuted after choosing their career by their own will.
Illit's Moka is like Le Sserafim's Sakura
Does minji kinda look like hidden love's FL?
I think all of them r good except moka needs a lil bit more training
Как же отвратительно себя ведут люди в комментариях. Зачем писать такие слова, выделять столько желчи. Именно из-за таких людей группы, которые только дебютировали, бросают это дело, и боятся за каждый свой вздох и пук. Есть много примеров, где слышно вокал девочек, и он очень приятный. Огромное количество групп во время сольного выступления не попадали в ноты или звучали ни как в оригинале, но вы решили накинуться на этих малышек. Они хорошо постарались, и им должно быть очень тяжело после дебюта. Отнеситесь с пониманием к людям, которые работают в k-pop индустрии, ведь они так много делают для нас. ILLIT, спасибо вам за Magnetic! ❤
Have you heard of SNSD?
Let's have them sing in Coachella please, they won 5 times already right, that makes them good right? Coachella Coachella 😂 show them the value of that awards in Coachella, Lets gooo.
큰 일났네....해외팬도 모카가 노래못하는걸 알고있네.신인걸그룹인데....사쿠라는 노래를 못 불러도 이미 인지도가 있기때문에 별 타격이 없지만 이 아이들은 첫 무대에서부터 이렇게 되면 그 이미지가 그대로 가는데.....해외팬들도 계속 모카에 집중해서 보게 될건데 염소소리가 계속 나오면 모카는 앞으로 활동이 힘들어지지.
I know moka sound a bit bad here.. but pls dont relate sakura here, only put blame on moka is enough, because she's the one singing it. Not sakura. Imagine you being blame on others fault.
They actually did good here
Minju’s voice is literally soo pretty
Heard that Minju ex YG trainee, has very good vocals 👍the rest looks like he's just learning to sing
She has Rosé singing style 💅
Es demasiado raro como todos odian a Wonhee cuando al igual que Minju y Yunah, es demasiado estable en el encore, se escucha bien
they sound amazing here
I miss the drunk like you you you from the previous encore.
Why is Moka's speaking voice so much better than her singing voice?
Hybe en serio tiene que invertir en clases de canto, no es posible que tenga estos problemas con sus gg
The ppl that gave illit the award are prob Reggreting their life choices