AMT vs CVT vs TC vs DCT - Automatic Gearboxes Explained | MotorBeam

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 11 дек 2024

Комментарии • 308

  • @pgohil100
    @pgohil100 4 года назад +387

    How many people still prefer driving a manual?

    • @SDBTalks2016
      @SDBTalks2016 4 года назад +9

      Thanks motorbeam.....most awaited video!!

    • @ParthChhabra
      @ParthChhabra 4 года назад +10

      I do prefer manual because it gives kick in the pants feel😄

    • @navdeep_autophile
      @navdeep_autophile 4 года назад +1

      How to join Motorbeam?

    • @pgohil100
      @pgohil100 4 года назад

      Parth Chhabra which car?

    • @navyaprakashm
      @navyaprakashm 4 года назад +1

      What about mecedes Gear boxes?

  • @april7531
    @april7531 4 года назад +52

    I've been driving manual ever since i started driving. This year i switched to DCT, and I ain't going back to manual for my daily commute and long drives.
    The ease and comfort are incomparable.

    • @riteshvs4949
      @riteshvs4949 2 года назад

      What about tc

    • @april7531
      @april7531 2 года назад +2

      @@riteshvs4949 in my opinion TC is best when you are going bumper to bumper traffic, especially when there are many incline road.
      If you do offroading TC is the best in my opinion and experience

    • @Torq123
      @Torq123 Год назад +1

      @@april7531 TC is also smooth the only catch is the fuel efficiency and lack of instant pickup compared to DCT

    • @paris9332
      @paris9332 7 месяцев назад

      signs of getting old 😅

    • @greatexpectation6456
      @greatexpectation6456 6 месяцев назад

      Ok now share us your experience with DCT transmission since my father is considering to buy a car which has DCT and he is skeptical about it's performance.

  • @punarv
    @punarv 4 года назад +13

    I think this was the most awaited video.
    CVT is ultra smooth. Yes, while cruising at higher speeds, it can show up with the rubber band effect. However, it can be repaired easily when compared to a DCT/ DSG.
    The VW Group represents DSG. You won't even realise the shifts easily. It's efficient & gives you a power packed performance. However, as mentioned if it fails, it's a nightmare to get it repaired.
    The video added a lot of things to everyone's knowledge. Thanks a lot for the video. 🤗🙏🙂
    Hope that our dearest MB team is in pink of health.

    • @pgohil100
      @pgohil100 4 года назад +2

      Thanks for the kind words. Yes, CVTs are easier to maintain and they generally don't give issues if you get your car serviced on time. For those who seek performance, DCT or TC is the way to go

    • @pankaj5080
      @pankaj5080 11 месяцев назад

      @@pgohil100 CVT sucks. DCT is best

    • @idsharma103
      @idsharma103 7 месяцев назад

      ​@@pgohil100Hi
      I am using a CVT car since last 4 years.
      It is the smoothest and best one.

  • @MrVijay-te6ob
    @MrVijay-te6ob 4 года назад +75

    Manual transmission is giving the original feel of driving❤️

    • @arun0921
      @arun0921 4 года назад +10

      In city traffic automatic is a bless

    • @suvimoon
      @suvimoon 4 года назад +15

      I the same mindset till I drove an automatic...for daily drives in the city automatic is literally heaven

    • @pandiarajan87
      @pandiarajan87 4 года назад +1

      Manual is waste

    • @PaulBateman69
      @PaulBateman69 3 года назад +2

      Until you drive a decent automatic

    • @aravindt
      @aravindt 3 года назад +2

      That's just perception!!! This is why people are not switching to automatic 😂

  • @secondaccount5421
    @secondaccount5421 4 года назад +11

    CVT for sure best for urban use efficent during traffic in mumbai and other crowded cities.

  • @manavnagpal3361
    @manavnagpal3361 4 года назад +3

    Going By the way Everything has been explained By Parth
    FOR NOW CVT'S SEEMS TO BE THE BEST AUTOS AT PRESENT TIME FOR EVERYTHING CONSIDERED..COST EFFECTIVENESS,,MILEAGE,GEAR SHIFTS,,ETC ETC ETC..CVT'S IS I VOTE FOR

    • @pgohil100
      @pgohil100 4 года назад

      Depends on the usage honestly. CVTs are smooth but i personally am not a big fan mainly due to the rubberband effect. I love DSGs, the ones with wet-clutches are reliable too

    • @manavnagpal3361
      @manavnagpal3361 4 года назад

      @@pgohil100 me also not a big CVT fan..I love DSG too..I love too drive my freind's jetta..But there maintenance is too costly..and older ones arn't that reliable Parth

  • @SachiPathmajan
    @SachiPathmajan 4 года назад +6

    The Dual Clutch Transmission in the different brands under Volkswagen group have different names.
    Audi calls it S Tronic, Lamborghini calls it LDF(Lamborghini Dopia Frizione ) and Porche calls it PDK(Porsche Doppelkupplungsgetriebe).

  • @kiranbhabal3329
    @kiranbhabal3329 4 года назад +23

    For last 3 years my uncle is driving an automatic transmission car now he struggles to drive my manual transmission car.

  • @yuvrajseth95
    @yuvrajseth95 4 года назад +10

    My choice is DCT coz the shifts are seemless and offers a wonderful performance

  • @suvimoon
    @suvimoon 4 года назад +4

    Well explained...neat and crisp.... automatic nis definitely the way to go in city traffic for sure. Manual is luxury these days as good roads and no traffic are a luxury

  • @arq2898
    @arq2898 4 года назад +29

    Automatic will shift the gears for you. But I am good with a manual
    Because....
    #aatmanirbhar

  • @anirudhsosale9626
    @anirudhsosale9626 4 года назад +5

    AMT is comfortable and cost wise affordable to all !

    • @carzoholics_world
      @carzoholics_world 4 года назад +1

      Agreed , it's best for low budget cause it gives fuel efficiency nearly MT & affordable too...
      Only a disadvantage is that it's very lack & that's why don't give power as we MT gives..

  • @atsonaga5520
    @atsonaga5520 4 года назад +7

    🤔Didn't know about torque converter👍
    Prefer manual because learnt driving in esteem♥️

  • @nandakishoreka7748
    @nandakishoreka7748 4 года назад +1

    I have seen many videos on automatic transmission in youtube,
    but the way motorbeam explained it was very easy and I understood it very clearly. Thnak u🙏💕 for making such a informative content.

    • @pgohil100
      @pgohil100 4 года назад

      Thanks, I'm glad you liked it

  • @deepaksrinivasan8315
    @deepaksrinivasan8315 4 года назад +3

    Picked Dzire 2016 petrol for torque converter, Had astar AT too (not Sluggish AMT) & now having Ameo DSG 1.5 TDI. & DSG is 🔥🔥🔥

  • @d.p.k4902
    @d.p.k4902 4 года назад +6

    Torque converter my favorite

  • @adityamahindrakar4851
    @adityamahindrakar4851 2 года назад +1

    I like the DCT and DSG gearbox as they are the most advanced, provide quick shifts and a good driving feel

  • @navdeep_autophile
    @navdeep_autophile 4 года назад +3

    Very good initiative and effort done by Motorbeam Team.

  • @devanand6753
    @devanand6753 4 года назад +4

    I like to take control of things manually.... Manual gear box🔥🔥💪💪

  • @arunkharat5465
    @arunkharat5465 4 года назад +1

    The information you provide is very important. And I like it very much.

  • @sameermulani9950
    @sameermulani9950 4 года назад

    I just saw a review and got confused between dct and cvt... Motorbeam uploaded this on the right time 😂😂😂

    • @carzoholics_world
      @carzoholics_world 4 года назад

      Only the disadvantage of CVT has that it's can't give you fun like downshifting & rev engine at higher rpm & launch the rocket , otherwise it's the best transmission.
      Yes you can get gears in CVT but it only happens when CVT has been coupled with gears which is very very very rear in cars but it can be seen in motorcycles....

  • @surajgarg7590
    @surajgarg7590 4 года назад +6

    Manual is🔥🔥🔥

  • @susantaguin702
    @susantaguin702 4 года назад +1

    Firstly it is very good information. But I don't like automatics.If have to choose one of the above, DCT / DSG is only option for Me.

  • @DpKris
    @DpKris 4 года назад

    If you are a person with some health problems or major driving occurs in toe to toe traffic automatic is the best especially CVT or DSG, if not go for the manual that's it.

  • @abiyarajan
    @abiyarajan Год назад

    So it's,
    DSG> Superior Shifts
    CVT>
    DCT>
    TC> Better shifts with low FE
    CVT> Good with low fuel efficiency
    iMT> Weird Driving
    AM> Crappy shifts with good Fuel efficiency
    &
    MANUAL - ❤️

  • @johnsoncd9686
    @johnsoncd9686 4 года назад +5

    Torque converter very reliable

  • @iammanas1818
    @iammanas1818 4 года назад +3

    Thanks for explaining this very finely, i need this info.

  • @praveenkumartin
    @praveenkumartin 4 года назад +2

    Thanks for your explaination.. For a long time i was looking for a clear information on automatic gear box and to know which will be better then which. Finally you guys have put the lights on it.

  • @prince1995moh
    @prince1995moh 4 года назад +1

    how do paddle shifters works and which type of automatic gear box are used or can be used with a paddle shifters ?

    • @MotorBeam
      @MotorBeam  4 года назад +2

      CVT, TC and DCT gearboxes come with paddle-shifters. Paddle-shifters allow you to take control of the gears, just like the manual mode in any AT.

  • @ragavendras1367
    @ragavendras1367 4 года назад

    CVT GEAR SYSTEM IS SUPER BROO

  • @chhagandobariya1916
    @chhagandobariya1916 4 года назад +2

    Merc offers which automatic? Plz let me know motorbeam

    • @carzoholics_world
      @carzoholics_world 4 года назад +1

      AT & DCT , moreover it's DCT gearbox is called Speedshift...

  • @aayushbhingare2279
    @aayushbhingare2279 4 года назад +4

    Personally I have two cars, corolla altis and an Innova Crysta, I prefer the manual for hatchbacks and Sedans, but for fortuner , innovas, hexas I prefer automatics. Manuals are absolutely truck like in these cars. Toyota manual gear levers for Crysta and Fortuner send a lot of vibration down your spine.

  • @jaymanik
    @jaymanik Год назад

    Thank you. It was very informative.

  • @asitadkar4976
    @asitadkar4976 4 года назад +4

    Honda:Launches Civic with CVT.
    Me: So, you have chosen death.

  • @pcpraman3219
    @pcpraman3219 4 года назад

    Presentation is very good... keep it up

  • @anjikv2601
    @anjikv2601 4 года назад +1

    My polo my DSG😍

  • @kirkumar77
    @kirkumar77 4 года назад

    Hi...I have a doubt since long, Torque converter an be really called as a gearbox like DCT or CVT or AMT?. With my limited knowledge TC is used as a slip clutch or on CVT it gives you feel of change of gear when gear shift is done manually....its a supporting mechanism for gearbox to smoother the gear change is what I feel....please clear my doubts.

  • @Aaron295555
    @Aaron295555 4 года назад +1

    Manual only give happiness bcoz car under our control 💯

  • @malharraodeshpande2196
    @malharraodeshpande2196 2 года назад

    Please explain creep mode. why car moves forward with speed of 4-6 km. how power of engine is coupled to gear box

  • @manav2914
    @manav2914 6 месяцев назад

    Xuv 700 Automatic has which of these transmission, pls inform.
    N is it good?

  • @lukedasilva418
    @lukedasilva418 4 года назад +1

    I love driving manual cars as the gears can be changed however u want it to, and not how the gearbox wants to. Honestly though, I love cvt gearbox when it comes to at gearbox. I dunno y?

  • @1195rony
    @1195rony 4 года назад +24

    Till all 4 of my limbs are functioning, a manual, always. Period

    • @kalsanglama119
      @kalsanglama119 4 года назад

      Same bro

    • @trvaruntrvarun6376
      @trvaruntrvarun6376 4 года назад +1

      this line reminds me of Thor's dialogue in Age of Ultron.. (?) Thor: "As long as there is breathe.."

    • @kingfisher111
      @kingfisher111 3 года назад +2

      Why drive... Ride a bullock cart then... Better... A horse.

    • @1195rony
      @1195rony 3 года назад

      @@trvaruntrvarun6376 hahaha

  • @venkateshhaz1311
    @venkateshhaz1311 4 года назад +2

    Faisal can u upload a video about injections like crdi, Tdi,

    • @arjunprasad1863
      @arjunprasad1863 4 года назад

      It's pretty much the same. Just different names based on manufacturers. These terms are basically used in Diesel engines.
      American cars like ford and Chevrolet use the term TDCI or TCDI respectively which stands for Turbo direct common injection or turbo common direct injection.
      Korean cars like Hyundai use the term CRDI which stands for Common rail direct injection.
      Germans and European cars use the term TDI which stands for Turbo direct injection.
      While there is a minor change in implementation the basic operating method is same in which turbo is directly injected to fuel and thus the car gains faster speeds..

  • @aroonvarma
    @aroonvarma 4 года назад

    Proper job, a very neat video

  • @sanjayan1572
    @sanjayan1572 3 года назад

    Excellent job

  • @AzamAli-ce7tt
    @AzamAli-ce7tt 4 года назад

    AMT is the BEST in both worlds 👍❤👌😎

  • @irsyadhasan3908
    @irsyadhasan3908 4 года назад

    CVT, DCT, AT, and AMT are easy to drive, easy to shift without using clutch. They use computer to shift from one gear to another gear. We need fuel efficiency and performace power.

  • @AT-tw8lf
    @AT-tw8lf 2 года назад

    Thank you for enlightenment.

  • @LaughLoveLifestyle
    @LaughLoveLifestyle 4 года назад +1

    Automatic transmission is the future

  • @RAXITH_playz
    @RAXITH_playz 4 года назад +1

    I prefer diesel manual because of its torque

  • @ujjwalsingh7878
    @ujjwalsingh7878 4 года назад

    It is really helpful, thanks mr. Gohil, 👆👍

  • @NEXUSACHAAR
    @NEXUSACHAAR 4 года назад

    Informative video
    Loved it !!!

  • @7oa178
    @7oa178 9 месяцев назад

    Reading from MotorBeams website 😂

  • @bhishamsaini
    @bhishamsaini 4 года назад

    Is a DCT advisable in city driving conditions? Or is it more suitable for highways or not very crowded cities like Delhi. Does it have heating issues as reported frequently?

  • @aamadmi2890
    @aamadmi2890 4 года назад

    shall i go with Verna Turbo DCT or 1.5L CVT ?

  • @abhijithpayyanattu7606
    @abhijithpayyanattu7606 4 года назад +5

    DCT lover❤️

  • @mukulbakshi5180
    @mukulbakshi5180 4 года назад

    I was planning to buy amaze cvt petrol.. But i frequently go to hill with family 5 members.... I doubt about pulling power and performance of amaze... Pls suggest.

    • @kirkumar77
      @kirkumar77 4 года назад

      I am using CVT since 2 years now, you feel rubberband effect while accelerating, but no issue of feeling less pulling power at all. I dive on highways regularly with packed boot and with family. No issue at all...you can buy CVT without any worry.

  • @kirubashankar7249
    @kirubashankar7249 4 года назад

    For city use an automatic is better whereas in highways and hills the manual is a clear winner !!

  • @Orson990
    @Orson990 4 года назад +2

    Raw feel only comes with manual transmission

  • @evbuddy6678
    @evbuddy6678 4 года назад

    Which is best for rough roads ??? N AT and CVT

  • @shouryadharkaramsetty4370
    @shouryadharkaramsetty4370 4 года назад

    No doubt it's the DSG/DCT isthe best automatic transmission, period..!!

  • @akshaytarade8759
    @akshaytarade8759 4 года назад +6

    i pefer manual, but choosing between automatic .. DSG my choice

    • @muhammedsahal5016
      @muhammedsahal5016 4 года назад

      Dct gives the actual driving feel that a manual gives

  • @aaaaacdhhllmnnv
    @aaaaacdhhllmnnv 4 года назад

    I have a manual 1.2 lr Wagon R(powerful, light and fun to drive), but I'd really love to have a new car with CVT.

  • @bakulmatiyani
    @bakulmatiyani 4 года назад

    does any other manufacturer use the DCT/DSG besides VW , Audi and Skoda?

    • @Kumar-xu1gz
      @Kumar-xu1gz 2 года назад

      Hyundai uses dct

    • @trijit96
      @trijit96 4 месяца назад

      Porsche and lambo

  • @rajashekharkammari9365
    @rajashekharkammari9365 4 года назад +1

    First comment nd first like nd first view also

    • @ahamedrifai8553
      @ahamedrifai8553 4 года назад +1

      What purpose??
      you guys are saying like this..
      1 view
      1 like
      1 comment
      Why ❓❓❓

  • @vimk2915
    @vimk2915 4 года назад

    hi Parth, thank you very much for the detailed explanation. I was planning to purchase the Seltos IVT as IVT is very smooth and I wanted a petrol. However, the torque is very less, and that version offers fewer features. I was wondering if a Diesel Torque converter is recommended. I dont want a DCT because it has heating problems if we dont completely release the brake in bumper to bumper traffic. Does the Torque converter have that issue? would you recommended buying a TC? thank you very much

    • @Letitdiebryan
      @Letitdiebryan 3 года назад

      There’s cars that have a wet dct Solves the heat problem

  • @barbieland9292
    @barbieland9292 4 года назад +1

    4 gear AT or 5 gear AMT which is better..?

    • @joelonney
      @joelonney 3 года назад

      don't choose AMT

  • @ananyachandra8981
    @ananyachandra8981 4 года назад

    Manual Transmission gives the feel of actually driving the car! But in cities with the traffic Automatic transmission comes to rescue. I've driven the Crystra 2.8, If I'm not wrong it is a Torque Converter Unit right?

  • @pcpraman3219
    @pcpraman3219 4 года назад

    Respected sir...i am thinking of buying Datsun Go T option BS4 new car... I can't afford a costly car.. is Datsun Go a good car sir... will there be any major engine problems in the future if I buy it.. kindly reply sir

    • @pgohil100
      @pgohil100 4 года назад

      The GO is a basic car. I don't think you'll be able to get a BS4 model now. You can consider the Alto too

    • @pcpraman3219
      @pcpraman3219 4 года назад

      @@pgohil100 sir in Karnataka the dealers of of BS4 new cars have registered the vehicles in their name.. due to the supreme court order now the new car becomes a second hand if we buy... yes BS4 is available kindly tell me whether Datsun Go is a good car

  • @Storiesbyachu
    @Storiesbyachu 4 года назад

    Manual 💥🔥🔥🔥🔥

  • @samruddhadeshmukh
    @samruddhadeshmukh 4 года назад

    Automatic cars are becoming more popular day by day but I still prefer manual gearbox

  • @ashmeetsandhu558
    @ashmeetsandhu558 4 года назад

    Can you pls explain 6 clutch system of endevour 2.0???

  • @dutta5225
    @dutta5225 4 года назад +6

    I always love to drive the manuals which offers efficiency, performance & reliability.

    • @carzoholics_world
      @carzoholics_world 4 года назад +1

      DCT gives 5% more efficiency & more power than MT...

    • @dutta5225
      @dutta5225 4 года назад

      @@carzoholics_world For 5% I am not going to invest extra ₹1-1.2 lakh. Also DCT are not as reliable as MT or TC.

    • @adarshbhavsar122
      @adarshbhavsar122 4 года назад +1

      @@dutta5225 DSG is reliable. It can run cars to a kilometres of 7-8 lakhs

    • @dutta5225
      @dutta5225 4 года назад

      @@adarshbhavsar122 I have seen many times that cars from VW, BMW, Kia etc. fitted with DCT/DSG have faced many issues. So in India Toyota never gives DCT with their cars. Instead their automatic cars comes with TC or CVT.

    • @Torq123
      @Torq123 Год назад

      Use DCT you will never back back to manual again unless there is any specific need

  • @ssn9072
    @ssn9072 4 года назад

    Which is best among these ???

  • @youtubeuser2494
    @youtubeuser2494 4 года назад +2

    Particularly dsg not even dct. .... vw 🔥🔥

  • @ajaym3889
    @ajaym3889 4 года назад

    Manual transmission is fun to drive😎

  • @AkshayNariyani
    @AkshayNariyani 4 года назад +1

    Automatics have really spoiled me and now driving a manual especially in traffic feels like pain in the ass.

  • @GameManual
    @GameManual 4 года назад +1

    DSG is 🔥

  • @mudireddy.akhilreddy4345
    @mudireddy.akhilreddy4345 4 года назад

    Manual transmission the punch power
    MT king of transmissions

  • @naws69
    @naws69 4 года назад +3

    show the real life process of it too. don't just show images.

  • @nawafkannur551
    @nawafkannur551 4 года назад +1

    I always go for a manual car🤗

  • @nishantsharma9163
    @nishantsharma9163 2 года назад

    Kia sonet DCT vs torque converter which one to buy ?

  • @pavanch7738
    @pavanch7738 4 года назад

    DSG is the best. 🙇

  • @uzmafarooqui16
    @uzmafarooqui16 4 года назад

    is ZF tronic transmission a torque converter unit?

    • @akshaydhanorkar
      @akshaydhanorkar 4 года назад +1

      If you mean transmission from ZF...like BMW's which uses ZF 8 speed transmission is a Torque Converter...!

  • @pramathparashar5355
    @pramathparashar5355 3 года назад

    Which one does Innova Crysta have?

  • @saanvi53377
    @saanvi53377 4 года назад

    Good video

  • @akshaysharmaas5652
    @akshaysharmaas5652 9 месяцев назад

    AMT--> Worse
    CVT--> Worst
    DCT-->Better
    TC AMT--> Best

  • @Its_your_Viraa
    @Its_your_Viraa 4 года назад

    BMW m5 or 5 series uses which type of transmission..?

  • @gagankatke1996
    @gagankatke1996 4 года назад

    Manual 👌👌

  • @sajeenaaslam869
    @sajeenaaslam869 4 года назад

    Why did you forget to say brezza on the list of torque convertor?

    • @pgohil100
      @pgohil100 4 года назад

      I haven't forgotten, there are 100s of cars and I can't name each one of them.

    • @sajeenaaslam869
      @sajeenaaslam869 4 года назад

      @@pgohil100 But breezza is the best seller. Then why it's missed?

    • @akshaydhanorkar
      @akshaydhanorkar 4 года назад +1

      Brezza just got a Torque Converter...it had an AMT before...!

  • @tusharkantihansdah
    @tusharkantihansdah 4 года назад +2

    I like amt with a manual clutch..😅

    • @sabyasachiroy7482
      @sabyasachiroy7482 4 года назад

      Then get an amg( sequential manual gearbox) but beware it is quite harsh and use for mostly track days

  • @Shekhar_Lal
    @Shekhar_Lal 4 года назад

    Thanks for detailed information regarding gear box

  • @srijananeja3516
    @srijananeja3516 4 года назад

    But the 8 speed torque converter in the bmw's are fast smooth and offers more fuel efficiency🥵

  • @nalinshanavas778
    @nalinshanavas778 2 года назад

    Which to select? DCT or TC on kia carens

  • @mujahidali8222
    @mujahidali8222 3 года назад

    I am driving manual transmission since ten years if at all I upgrade it will be an Dsg a performance oriented gearbox n seamless driving because of the traffic 🚦

  • @prathameshozarkar
    @prathameshozarkar Месяц назад

    Which one is best?
    AT vs AMT vs CVT vs DSG vs DCT??

  • @drbones333
    @drbones333 4 года назад

    All these people in comment section writing manual is love must be driving on highways daily because manual transmission in a traffic predominant city is a BITCH. and i have driven both, Auto (DCT) any day for me

  • @sakshamsingh360
    @sakshamsingh360 4 года назад

    Osm video sir

  • @admiralgeneralAladeen
    @admiralgeneralAladeen 4 года назад

    DSG all the way.

  • @hishmithvvardhan5809
    @hishmithvvardhan5809 3 года назад

    a drag race would have made evrything complete