@@snatcher420 they turned question into story. Big difference, the fact you see exploration as desecration shows ur mindlessness devotion which isn't what any God wants, God wants FAITH and BELEIF
At least they should have added an explanation about those little agents working for Asriel in the first episode. I´ve tried to avoid the books and wait for conclude this series; but seeing that little people and then one of them following Lyra and Will (and they do not get surprised to see him) that´s was odd for me.
The show does rush through things, but I think it keeps the show moving at a good pace. In the book, the Gallivespians are a little more fun and they ride around on dragonflies rather than having their own wings.
Well I actually was expecting more "weird" beings, since they are supposed to come from many different worlds, I dont think you have to explain each race knowing this
i like how they despatched the decrepid Creator God. No fuss, no intent. It was a more deliberate act in the book- an act or mercy. In this version it was an aside, inconsequential.
No there are angels who were cast out for finding out that "God" (also known as the Authority) is just an angel that lied about created the many worlds, and that Dust is what gives living beings free will and without Dust, organisms would just be hollow shells, which is what the Magesterium (the church) wants, because they believe that Dust is "sin" and without it, people can be easier to control. So no, no devil demons.
This book series has been out for decades now. Cry some more 🙄 your dumb god WILL be mocked until the end of Christianity as we know it, because it deserves to be ridiculed.
And they know they're mocking him and being blasphemous. That's what's so sad about it. I could see if they didn't know b/c when people go through problems in life they could accidentally do that bc of pain or don't know any better, but this is no pain, no ignorance just plain old nastiness and awareness.
@@ericcelestino2170 What I see from this video is a glorification of the spirit of rebellion against God. About the specifics to the Catholic Church, pls explain.
Here's a story within a short story in 1992 by Neil Gaiman... Angels, who were sexless, 'belonged' to their function. In the time of pre-Creation, two angels who were tasked to work on the concept of 'Love', fell in love. Not just platonic love, but physical desire as well. Then they were tasked to work on the concept of 'Death', that led to one inadvertently killing the other. And so the murdering lover was punished by being destroyed, by an angel tasked with Vengeance. Lucifer cried at the wrongness done to his kin, and this was the catalyst to his rebellion.
Calm down. 😭💀 It's a TV show, based on popular Young Adult books. Ya'll complained that Harry Potter promoted witchcraft, and would have a generation of children casting spells, too. You folks constantly underestimate children & young people, and act as if they can't tell the difference between fact & fiction. Plus, who says that your interpretation of "God" is even accurate anyway?? Ya'll worry about the wrong things...
@@KabbalahSherry Underestimate children, are u joking, children are so easily manipulated and this kind of entertainment is turning the children of today away from God, forgive me for not being able to calm down.
@@francesweetman It is not about a knife cutting between worlds. It is a progression from subtle occult references, to 'just fun for kids', to 'God is bad and the devil is our hero'. If you lived in a country where occult practitioners carry out ritual human sacrifice, it wouldn't seem like just harmless fun.
Amazing, isn't it. 2,000 years ago writers described the values and attitudes that would prevail in our time. It has to happen this way, otherwise the scriptures would be wrong. Just make sure you aren't on the losing side.
Hmm... Another movie promoting fallen angels as the good guys and God as the bad one. Such dark times we are living in. Read Revelation in the Bible. Nothing is a coincidence anymore.
Deception and foolishness. The real spirits of light and righteousness laughs at this destestable things done by idolatrous and rebellious children of mankind.
Pure low budget wreckage. I could barely end the first season, during which I slept a lot. I loved the book, and the 2007 Golden Compass was such a promise... Rubbish.
![VICTOR Denmark Open 2024 | An Se Young (KOR) [1] vs. Gregoria Mariska Tunjung (INA) [5] | SF](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Y3QEyCih85s/mqdefault.jpg)
Are you OK, HBO? Promoting His Dark Materials?! I barely see posts about the show on your social media! That’s a miracle!
I truly hope this show gets more love some day. It’s just been an entire treat.
Really looking forward to the Mulefa. Seedpod claws crossed!
To bad this show turned the Truth into a Lie. They have turned Good into evil and evil into Good. Just as it is written.
@@snatcher420 they turned question into story. Big difference, the fact you see exploration as desecration shows ur mindlessness devotion which isn't what any God wants, God wants FAITH and BELEIF
Really enjoyed this entire series. Great job HBO for seeing this through and making it fun and emotional.
At least they should have added an explanation about those little agents working for Asriel in the first episode. I´ve tried to avoid the books and wait for conclude this series; but seeing that little people and then one of them following Lyra and Will (and they do not get surprised to see him) that´s was odd for me.
That was ridiculous I laughed so hard
The show does rush through things, but I think it keeps the show moving at a good pace. In the book, the Gallivespians are a little more fun and they ride around on dragonflies rather than having their own wings.
@@jasoncraig4320 exactly, the scene where will broke his knife should've been more emotional and exciting
Well I actually was expecting more "weird" beings, since they are supposed to come from many different worlds, I dont think you have to explain each race knowing this
It looks like they got JUST enough $$ to wrap things up.
I had no idea this show would be this good!
Good?! Such blasphemous trash!
I find the least promoted programs are usually one of the best. Cant wait to get into this gem.
I had forgotten how crazy the third book was 😅
I don’t know if you’ve read the Book of Dust trilogy but it gets even crazier 😅
@@lukasmeggs5857 I have actually and it really does...😅
The 'Lady Salmakia'! I had hoped they would developed the Gallivespians a little more
Especially with such a phenomenal actress playing her.
Episode 4 had me weeping😢
great show, supprised it is not promoted more
i like how they despatched the decrepid Creator God. No fuss, no intent. It was a more deliberate act in the book- an act or mercy. In this version it was an aside, inconsequential.
I'm sad that we're not getting the blue hawk and dragonflies the Gallivespians ride in the book...
also how their wings aren't organic
budget issues, more than likely
HBO, please, where is the openning you always post when releasing His Dark Materials?
I was wondering where do these tiny flying soldiers come from?
Agent Salmakia should have said "I look like a pencil"
It’s French.
Wow its out. I had no idea. Gonna watch now
Love this show
I love this show
Aw man, I was hoping to see the dragonflies :C
Soo are we getting more episodes or not 🤔
Is there somewhere other than HBO that I can watch it?
BBC IPLAYER
Metatron: One of the choirs of angels, the are called *watchers* ....guess what they do?
Even angels need companionship. Lol
Im bummed the angels aren't organic buildings of sorts. Being humanoid is so...meh.
Budget, I guess.
Been a long time since I read the books but I thought they were some mass of light and wings. Dissapointing
@@NJRIII they portrayed like that in the show too.
But the budget for the last series clearly wasn't big enough to make that happen for every scene
Have to cathc up, see Mr Eko!
Gallevespians are a bit of a disappointment.
Wait not we in the world of golden compass
Angels dont take human orders
Do Balthamos and Baruch survive in the series?
Spoiler...
No.
@@aylinpatacsil846 Thought so. Doubt if I will watch it
Wow was going to watch this show but seeing this. No thanks.
Why?? 😄 What's got you all turned off??
How good
So is this inspired by the book of Enoch
Yeah alotta similarities
Lots of spoilers for us on BBC
This show coulda been something special
It was.
True!
So it's a show about the devil demons fighting for rulership 🤔
No there are angels who were cast out for finding out that "God" (also known as the Authority) is just an angel that lied about created the many worlds, and that Dust is what gives living beings free will and without Dust, organisms would just be hollow shells, which is what the Magesterium (the church) wants, because they believe that Dust is "sin" and without it, people can be easier to control. So no, no devil demons.
@naexla6372 I meant the story in the bible of lucifer and his followers being kicked out of heaven. The fallen angel who is now the devil
@@naexla6372 you tried explaining but they didn't get it ....
@@jasonjason2789 Well, but as you said it's a story and every story can be tell in many perspectives..
So it's a show about the fact that you'd better read the three books and maybe some milton, blake and the bible, among others.
The deceiver up to his old tricks again I see. 😂😂😂😂
This is a Blasphemy to God in Heaven
Woke nonsense and blasphemous! God will NOT be mocked!
This book series has been out for decades now. Cry some more 🙄 your dumb god WILL be mocked until the end of Christianity as we know it, because it deserves to be ridiculed.
@@astrowiz3544 I weep for you, for by your blasphemy you bring a curse upon yourself. May God have mercy on you.
And they know they're mocking him and being blasphemous. That's what's so sad about it. I could see if they didn't know b/c when people go through problems in life they could accidentally do that bc of pain or don't know any better, but this is no pain, no ignorance just plain old nastiness and awareness.
You guys know this show is a Criticism of the Catholic church, right?
@@ericcelestino2170 What I see from this video is a glorification of the spirit of rebellion against God. About the specifics to the Catholic Church, pls explain.
Why does everything gotta in films now a days just asking
Gotta what?
Never read angels being romanticly linked ever, doesn't sit right at all
Here's a story within a short story in 1992 by Neil Gaiman...
Angels, who were sexless, 'belonged' to their function. In the time of pre-Creation, two angels who were tasked to work on the concept of 'Love', fell in love. Not just platonic love, but physical desire as well. Then they were tasked to work on the concept of 'Death', that led to one inadvertently killing the other. And so the murdering lover was punished by being destroyed, by an angel tasked with Vengeance. Lucifer cried at the wrongness done to his kin, and this was the catalyst to his rebellion.
It can happen, not all the Grigori fell for engaging whit humans
It’s right there in the third book! It’s not even subtle.
This looks interesting but is it blasphemy?? I’m seriously wondering
A movie to brainwash mankind to fight against God when he shows up. Revelation in the Bible said this would happen. Wow.
Calm down. 😭💀 It's a TV show, based on popular Young Adult books. Ya'll complained that Harry Potter promoted witchcraft, and would have a generation of children casting spells, too. You folks constantly underestimate children & young people, and act as if they can't tell the difference between fact & fiction. Plus, who says that your interpretation of "God" is even accurate anyway?? Ya'll worry about the wrong things...
@@KabbalahSherry Underestimate children, are u joking, children are so easily manipulated and this kind of entertainment is turning the children of today away from God, forgive me for not being able to calm down.
Ikr, if any kids watch it they might get ahold of a knife that can cut between worlds and go at a glowing box thing
@@francesweetman It is not about a knife cutting between worlds. It is a progression from subtle occult references, to 'just fun for kids', to 'God is bad and the devil is our hero'. If you lived in a country where occult practitioners carry out ritual human sacrifice, it wouldn't seem like just harmless fun.
Amazing, isn't it. 2,000 years ago writers described the values and attitudes that would prevail in our time. It has to happen this way, otherwise the scriptures would be wrong. Just make sure you aren't on the losing side.
Hmm... Another movie promoting fallen angels as the good guys and God as the bad one. Such dark times we are living in.
Read Revelation in the Bible. Nothing is a coincidence anymore.
Your right. Nothing is a coincidence anymore.
This show turned the Truth into a Lie. They have turned Good into evil and evil into Good. Just as it is written.
Angels are spiritual beings and are tall and powerful and thy have long hair this show is just worthless
Deception and foolishness. The real spirits of light and righteousness laughs at this destestable things done by idolatrous and rebellious children of mankind.
Lyra was the most annoying character on the show.
How so?
Possibly the most satanic show out today.
Yes, you are true
Pure low budget wreckage.
I could barely end the first season, during which I slept a lot.
I loved the book, and the 2007 Golden Compass was such a promise...
Rubbish.