piano is ok, not really for hip hop drums are as basic as you can get, but they’re alright bells are equivalent to having coronavirus, ebola, and ear cancer at the same time
@Mini Yeets well it's the knowledge of music theory that every producter basically has, since most just know chords and harmony. Starting producing with this kind of knowledge is a big advantage compared to people jumping in with no knowledge at all (which is for most the case). It may not be high end music theory but it's a skill a lot of producers lack and a lot of newcomers to music production probably would enjoy having a lot.
1980s: You man, this is the shit. I created this oval looking thing attached to a string. Its called a yoyo In 2017 there'll be flying cars ( also known as helicopters ) 2017: Fidget Spinners are CAWL
Honestly, some of the melodies are quite nice, the beat is much basic, sounds like my first finished track. Seems like you didnt mix anything, which is the most important part of the creation. Yeah, im disapointed that this kind of video reaches the 1M views instead of real beatmakers ones! Sorry for my eng buddies
And it's also okay to say it's the best because it's subjective to that person's opinion and not for everyone else. So technically, it is clickbait because there are really no facts it's the best piano melody
Bruh.. first piano goes hard, but that's it. Them drums on sum Fl studio beginner type shit and that bell melody don't match with the piano melody. Be humble, don't put no title like that.
Not gonna lie, this isn't good, like at all, off key and melody is way too complicated, chords are odd and hard to vibe to. Overall just doesn't work. I'll rate it 4/10
The melody isn't complicated but the rhythm of the melody stays constant (all the notes are the same length) and there's really no good flow to it. I think it's funny how many views that title got this guy because this is something you would create after using FL Studio for like 3 months which isn't a long time.
So it's off key to some, and others here a virbtration oh mixed. harmony. And the creations that come from learning the piano, scale's and chodes. Symphony conductors
Fr tho! I'm sayin bruh, youtube producers be havin they standard set kinda low, this man got 1K likes just for that piano melody, cuz them drums doo doo.
Wow, negative comments... I just watched 15 different melody-videos, and this is the first one I really find interesting (and I like some of it too) - and it is precisely for the reason it is being criticised: breaking the rules. Come on music-theorists, up the game a bit...
sound like santa spending christmas in a trap house
6 лет назад+96
this piano progression is stolen from a Turkish soap/Telenovela. U most probably found a MIDI FILE OF IT. And its movie music so it has no rythm ..its classical...it has only 3 bars ...u should tweak it first. That is why the beat doesnt make sense. You had to restructure the piano first. Add a 4th chord or make the second chord go double or something...
C o a x melody doesnt fit timewise. He just put a beat from begin of the melody . imagine a singer composing lyrics to it . it would be impossible. He needs some music theory. But actually these are just basics. No theory needed for this. Anyway these days every idiot thinks being a producer. Everybody can make beats with a sequencer. It doesnt make u a musician
It's really good, love the use of harmonic minor, but the bells clash with the type of counter point you used on them; try warming up the bell section with a damper, and less is more. The opening melody for the bells is great enough, and the piano cadences are fire. Try to think hip hop, and jazz, you can tell that you're classically influenced theory wise. Learn some jazz theory to balance it out. Sounds like great lofi music 🙂
Guys this isn't bad at all, when talking about HIP-HOP, beats like this are used and with vocals they sound fire. I don't know why I see so many hate comments.
Looking back at this and producing music for 5 years now, I see a lot of mistakes with this beat now, piano is ok definitely doesn’t sound realistic you can try changing the velocities of every note so it sounds more realistic, drums are basic, 808 seems to be all over the place and the first note just doesn’t hit right and doesn’t seem to be following the root notes of the chord progression so it sounds very random, and the bells honestly just doesn’t fit the beat, but still pretty fire in theory
Hey let’s not lie back when we all started we thought every beat we made was a hit single even though they for sure were not lol. This was two years ago this guy would for sure be much better now.
Aye man dont listen too these jerks saying that "the beat isnt good" they dont play real instruments and listen to classical music so they dont know triads and melodies completely right. They arent top musicians they cant say shit, this sounds melodical and i enjoy this beat very much dude keep doing what your doing man
I listen to a lot of different classes /genre of music, including the really melodic classicals from Mozart/Beethoven/Bach. I can confirm that, the beat itself is ok, but: Bells are really out of key, move the bottom notes up 1-2 semitones and the same with the high frequency 808s, then it's better
![Blox Fruits Dragon Rework Update [Full Stream]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EqDAp8udhm0/mqdefault.jpg)
You can buy plugin "Pendora" here tiger-sounds.com/shop/
promo code - "20low"
Your like 2 a years late
@@vel7280 Try four years lmao
I cant tell if he’s being fr?
@Paulos Padelidis fl studio
como e que cria uma conta da image line por favor mim ajunde
Mans was making 15 yr old producer from atlanta type beats before they even got famous, mad respect
⛓🤣
check me out, im a 14 year old producer, without the atlanta part
@@Prod5D im 12 XD I make like good beats check me out pls
@@Prod5D i was finna say that too lmao, check my page
@@prod.byyaya aight boi
I literally thought this was a “Draw a whale with midi notes” video
Looks more like a hippo to me😂
Beaver?
lmao same
Isn't it?
its a squid
Achievements:
[✓] clickbait title
[✓] 1 million views
[ ] good beat
Amen.
@@miconia oh no
[✓] good beat :D
I clicked on this vid thinking i would watch an dinosaur music drawn thing
it IS everyone's opinion bich, i think you need to get your ears checked out bro...
When you first start producing music and think you have a banger. But in reality, you just have this....
Factss
this is me everytime i make a beat lol, ive only been doing it for a couple of weeks so hopefully ill get better with time
@@itsss_gage4306 oh for sure. I didn't make that good beats until like 5 or 6 months in
we out the hood ma
lmaooo
piano is ok, not really for hip hop
drums are as basic as you can get, but they’re alright
bells are equivalent to having coronavirus, ebola, and ear cancer at the same time
xd
Yuh, piano isn’t bad but he could have muffled it a little bit and lowered the release a little too. Great beat though👍
Cam on men you cant tell your opinion with out desepoint him
lol
This was back in 2016 when we thought stuff like this was good
sounds like my 1st project in fl
hahahahahaha real
Fr dawg
my dude if you started fl studio knowing that kind fo music theory i envy you, the beat maybe ass but the piano chords are good.
Jajaj
@Mini Yeets well it's the knowledge of music theory that every producter basically has, since most just know chords and harmony. Starting producing with this kind of knowledge is a big advantage compared to people jumping in with no knowledge at all (which is for most the case).
It may not be high end music theory but it's a skill a lot of producers lack and a lot of newcomers to music production probably would enjoy having a lot.
Day 51
Draw a whale on fl studio
Mouse
BAND BROTHERS ASSOCIATION nigga it's 2017 get your fuck ass somewhere with that "fl studio producers" shit.
"I bet we will have flying cars in 2017"
*draws a whale on fl studio in 2017*
1980s: You man, this is the shit. I created this oval looking thing attached to a string. Its called a yoyo
In 2017 there'll be flying cars ( also known as helicopters )
2017: Fidget Spinners are CAWL
Looka they don't get it smh
Imagine sayin u got a fye beat but its trash af and gettin roasted by everyone in the comments
Boaaa
My biggest fear
Why so rude? He tried his best
I actually kinda like the idea of the beat but it definitely was executed pretty poorly
@@Mcguigan2 more like why so true? He tried his best
The piano is actually pretty good but the bells and 808 kinda ruined it. If the 808 followed the chords and you got rid of the bells, it’d be lit.
Exactly
the 808 was out of tune with most of the melodies and pads etc.
Finally someone who isn’t calling this guy trash and being reasonable
@@Mcguigan2 be real bro, even wit some changes the beat would still be :/ Considering the title, he is trash.
the piano is not good
This beat make Sharpe look like a god
LMFAOOOO BROOOO
I'm dyinnnn
Broo 🤣🤣🤣
Lmaooooooooooooooooooooo
Lol, I love your profile pic with this comment
*plays the piano once* “best piano melody for rap”
Why is this in my recommended? Anyone with any bit of music theory knowledge is crying while watching this
Thanks omg
*E L I T I S M*
tgi wasnt the only one XD
soundcloud.com/dylan-zhang-6/agonize
no,why?
I have ear cancer when I hear those bells.
Marlies, solo comentas esto porque los demás lo hacen?
.-.
nice rhyme
@@성이름-q9v5s Lmao
@@Sun_storm la verdad yo siento lo mismo que marlies
Lol
Honestly, some of the melodies are quite nice, the beat is much basic, sounds like my first finished track. Seems like you didnt mix anything, which is the most important part of the creation. Yeah, im disapointed that this kind of video reaches the 1M views instead of real beatmakers ones! Sorry for my eng buddies
Yea :(
Your eng is fine bro
its the clickbait that gets the views
this is ass
Actually not bad, his idea is superb. Ofcourse he can smoothen the rough edges. Hope he did that. This has fire potential no cap
them kicks are like what everybody do when they make there first trap beat
bruh if this yo first trap beat then I'm doing something wrong
when the bells go off key 😍😤😫🔥💯
Daxteralex what?
Jewzy Jesse the bells go out of the key of the song
Daxteralex but do you like it or not the emojis are fuckin with my mind lmao
Jewzy Jesse no i don't like it lol and the emojis are sarcastic
Daxteralex dis shit is ass
Best melody my ass. Sit down be humble bruh
He get rekt
Best piano melody of 1999- Still D.R.E
Ya'll I was just curious what that mess on the piano roll would sound like
ongggg lmao
that is the only reason this has so many views lmao im guilty too
Yeah no need for the off key bells. The melody would honestly be fine without them
And it's also okay to say it's the best because it's subjective to that person's opinion and not for everyone else. So technically, it is clickbait because there are really no facts it's the best piano melody
What makes this the best?
monkfreak72 Yeah....
monkfreak72 the click bait
this is so dooope!
I can trade someone electrax for omnisphere. I also have nexus with about 30 expansions.
Ill trade you omnisphere for nexus with the packs. Working ones!
Bruh.. first piano goes hard, but that's it. Them drums on sum Fl studio beginner type shit and that bell melody don't match with the piano melody. Be humble, don't put no title like that.
NoPlugg Marconi none of the sounds match and the transitions are very weak.
Fr tho...
Yeah I was expecting something like mind blowing after hearing the piano part and was just let down with the 808 and bells
Bells are way too loud
And then there are guys that are actually making dope tracks and dont get recognition like Sad Meal
The comments have me in tears lmao
This melody sounds like my first melody what I have made on my iPad with GarageBand
Not gonna lie, this isn't good, like at all, off key and melody is way too complicated, chords are odd and hard to vibe to. Overall just doesn't work. I'll rate it 4/10
Sonny Jennings I don't see you make these sick beats so what if it'd off beat
The melody isn't complicated but the rhythm of the melody stays constant (all the notes are the same length) and there's really no good flow to it. I think it's funny how many views that title got this guy because this is something you would create after using FL Studio for like 3 months which isn't a long time.
Been producing for 4 years in Abelton and Logic I think I know what I'm doing
even I can do better with 3 hour experience
well i'll be damned, that's a burn if i've ever seen one
Everything starts at 3:10
Jasoh123 oh thank you so much
who came for the strange notes ?
I did I thought it was one of those creative ones but it wasn't LOL thiss is like a sad beat not a good hip hop beat
Nguyên Iglesias u and me
.....
The people in this thread, and many more. I thought the notes in the thumbnail looked like a rat XD
Me
music theory is hard damn
"Trash type beat"
your mom
@@NAPALMATTACK tf💀😂
hahuahuahuaah
Just have a look at his creativity man. You are so dumb
@@NAPALMATTACK that was really bad haha
Starts at 3:09
Don’t thank me later cause those bells gave me a stroke😂
Ur brain can't interbrate the echong of notes in sterero
So it's off key to some, and others here a virbtration oh mixed. harmony. And the creations that come from learning the piano, scale's and chodes. Symphony conductors
Hahahha
Constructive Criticism: Get rid of the bell and the solo drum loop from bars 65.
thank you for your opinion. I will consider it
No prob
I know that. Just in this track I didnt mixing
Random Stranger Forget about it, I just wanted to give out my opinion.
Random Stranger everything. Anything that he wants to say can help.
2:05 lesson learned, make a deformed beaver
I think this is a troll video, why else the thumbnail with the notes looking like a whale and the quality is 144p in 2016? cmon
it's 720p?
Its 720p you prolly just got an android
I have android and its 720p so probs just ur internet and youtube setting to 144p auto
Shoowww
everyone used this mans melody in 2016
2:05 when you just don't know what you're doing and start pressing random notes
Thijs Kranenburg fax half the notes made me angry 😭
Made my day :D
Guys stop being rude he tried his best
@@Mcguigan2 stop being an sjw in RUclips comments 🤣 you ghey af
Sounds like something fit for a horror game ngl
The beginning of the melody made me remember of 'We Are Number One'
Evans Alicea I hear it too😂
Mix ouy nh 1 ban heh ouy 30$ tam wing
your insane XD
Tehmarsh you're
WHo sing we are number one?
Dont be cocky man this really aint best..
rudo králik dude I hope you realize HE MEANT FOR 2016
TMY BigStudios still was shit back then
Clickbait dude 🤷🏽♂️ it’s sad but it works
Everybody say their beat lit
I haven’t stopped crying since this was uploaded.
Did you knew that the future hip hop music sound like this...cuz damn at 2k16 you created a flame which goes trending on 2k20 hats off
i know a whole lot of music theory and this song makes me cringe
Shinkey16 SAME !!!
Shinkey16 dude the fucking bells had me cringing
Shinkey16 Anyone can hear that the bells and 808 are way outa tune. Has nothing to do with music theory. Piano was smooth, rest was shit
Nah fam
it was out of key, not tune. And fl studio just doesnt decide to make something out of tune, it's not a intrument...
The piano part was okay but once the beat dropped , shit was wack
Fr tho! I'm sayin bruh, youtube producers be havin they standard set kinda low, this man got 1K likes just for that piano melody, cuz them drums doo doo.
NoPlugg Marconi because people that dont make beats watch this and think this shit fire ha
That's sad
This is really really mehhhhhhhh
I've seen so much better tbh. No hate tho, this beat is not that bad
simon servida crying at those 808's right now.
This actually sounds good. Why the heck are people hating it ?
I also want to know
this is by far the best beat making channel ever. you need to blow up and get famous!!!!
At 1:41 I thought I had a little hair on my screen
Angelo ._. Lol me too
How is a rapper gonna fit over this
Kid Chronic lol stupid much?
It doesn't have a natural flow to it, it'd be hard to get into it and start rapping freestyle.
Trap not rap
ROBOTO still waiting on the rap you supposedly can make over this
@@roboto9413 creative? Nigga your profile is something people did in 2014, creative my ass.
Wow, negative comments... I just watched 15 different melody-videos, and this is the first one I really find interesting (and I like some of it too) - and it is precisely for the reason it is being criticised: breaking the rules. Come on music-theorists, up the game a bit...
This track is like drinking Orange juice after brushing your teeth.
I think the beat is wack and lacks creativity but the Chords are on point
Wandile Mzimela he did not make up these chords. it must be a midi file because that is a movie theme i know very well.
Ikr
Michael Doebbler no drumkit i kno this tune
Wandile Mzimela i agree beat is weak
Doebbler Beatz lmao
Lester can you please turn that volume down?
CSG Studios 😂
You mean turn it off?
the intro is fire. but the beat is wack
i'm sure his dont made the melody and instead took that from the internet
sound like santa spending christmas in a trap house
this piano progression is stolen from a Turkish soap/Telenovela. U most probably found a MIDI FILE OF IT. And its movie music so it has no rythm ..its classical...it has only 3 bars ...u should tweak it first. That is why the beat doesnt make sense. You had to restructure the piano first. Add a 4th chord or make the second chord go double or something...
Peťo D couldn’t have said it better
C o a x if id had that midifile i would make a masterpiece of it. This guy doesnt have musical ears.
Peťo D or music theory
C o a x melody doesnt fit timewise. He just put a beat from begin of the melody . imagine a singer composing lyrics to it . it would be impossible. He needs some music theory. But actually these are just basics. No theory needed for this. Anyway these days every idiot thinks being a producer. Everybody can make beats with a sequencer. It doesnt make u a musician
Peťo D Yo stay calm Peto
This sounds like some logic shit
Expectation: 3:10
Reality: 3:29
It's really good, love the use of harmonic minor, but the bells clash with the type of counter point you used on them; try warming up the bell section with a damper, and less is more. The opening melody for the bells is great enough, and the piano cadences are fire. Try to think hip hop, and jazz, you can tell that you're classically influenced theory wise. Learn some jazz theory to balance it out. Sounds like great lofi music 🙂
why is this here in my recommended 5 years later...
I’m glad you’re putting your content out there man… at least you’re tryna do something with your life😤💯
Guys this isn't bad at all, when talking about HIP-HOP, beats like this are used and with vocals they sound fire. I don't know why I see so many hate comments.
Lmao i was suprised this beat had 2.4m views.
As a wise xandokay said: "Anyone with any bit of music theory knowledge is crying while watching this"
Sounds exactly like the 1st beat of everybody 😭😭😭
yuuuuup the start was great its crazy how good you finished it!
If this has 2,4 million views I deserve at least 100 million bro wtf
The melodies are dope
M.A Beats you mean the complex chords Right?
i think he means that haha
Michael Doebbler but the chords are great
the piano misses the expectation change up ...its not strong
The bells are trash
4:18 you gotta Amit that transition was pretty sweet
Bruh
LOL no
Nopeski
Bro why u bully me i thought tho that this beat is bout to pop off but then came the bells i was like 💀💀💀💀💀🤣🤣🤣
I love that u can SEE the hook
This hits yo! I fw your beats
Half of you hating couldn't make a beat to save your life, why hate on this dude, he's not that bad.
Looking back at this and producing music for 5 years now, I see a lot of mistakes with this beat now, piano is ok definitely doesn’t sound realistic you can try changing the velocities of every note so it sounds more realistic, drums are basic, 808 seems to be all over the place and the first note just doesn’t hit right and doesn’t seem to be following the root notes of the chord progression so it sounds very random, and the bells honestly just doesn’t fit the beat, but still pretty fire in theory
The bell melody looks like a fish
Love the eerie feel to it, reminds me of Aphex Twin & Radiohead (Kid A era). Just with hip hop beats.
This song had alot of potential, keep it up!!
Had
Achievements:
[✓] clickbait title
[✓] 2 million views
[✓] Fake tags for the video
[ ] good beat
copied
4:15
The background beat and the piano in the background is like drowning fried food in sauce
Just.. NO
I clicked cause the thumbnail looked like a fish
the best? honestly it kinda sux
dannyU2g it's click bait
dannyU2g this shit is trash
TMY BigStudios Bro this is garbage
TMY BigStudios lmao this is some wack shit
show me what you can make other then roblox games
honestly the piano blessed my ears... but then the bells and 808 came in
oh my god. you actually made this? amazing!
oh man those drum sounds make me want to stay off the internet
This kinda sounds like my first ever beat i made 😂🤣
" I need a doctor"?
yup
this man's music theory knowledge surpasses beethoven
ای کسی که مارو بوجود آوروی مرسی بابت داده هات عشقی💎💎♥️♥️♥️♥️💥💎
This actually isnt bad i thought its gonna be shit when I read comments but is actually good better than any of my beats lol :D keep up
What was the point of randomly right panning the hi-hat at 3:36 lol
Один только я понял, что парень из России потому что на бандикаме "Запись"??? хддд
Мне понравился трек, удачи тебе!
Whoever Betrays войс тег с руссским акцентом)
хехе
Кек
Пианино красиво, колокола не
the chord progression gives me very heavy UK drill vibes
Hey let’s not lie back when we all started we thought every beat we made was a hit single even though they for sure were not lol. This was two years ago this guy would for sure be much better now.
That's actually pretty good.
Just mix something next time bruh
The bells started out nice and then just went downhill from there
Did you have a spasm on your computer to create that bell melody? Honestly, I have no clue why the RUclips algorithm is promoting this shit.
Блин, внатуре чётко. Я помню года два-три назад слушал это. До сих пор нравится (хоть и суховато)
Бля, там только мелодия пианино сделано не плохо, хоть и местами накосячил. А остальное было по приколу добавлено и написано)
this guy know how to go viral
Aye man dont listen too these jerks saying that "the beat isnt good" they dont play real instruments and listen to classical music so they dont know triads and melodies completely right. They arent top musicians they cant say shit, this sounds melodical and i enjoy this beat very much dude keep doing what your doing man
Spxtre Beats I agree
Spxtre Beats but there isnt any real instruments being played?
Spxtre Beats What’s wrong with listening to classical music? I listen to it when I’m studying.
We dont need to be musicians to hear cancer ya dumb fuck
I listen to a lot of different classes /genre of music, including the really melodic classicals from Mozart/Beethoven/Bach.
I can confirm that, the beat itself is ok, but:
Bells are really out of key, move the bottom notes up 1-2 semitones and the same with the high frequency 808s, then it's better
It's a fricking dino
when u press alt+r in the piano roll
Lolll
oh lord the bells
What am i listening to? 🤯😱 This is epic!!! 🔥💥👏👏
Giuseppe Garda you’re being sarcastic right?
Well this is the new worst thing I have seen on youtube in 2017.