Fountain pens have become my most expensive and fulfilling hobby. My handwriting and writing has improved, but at the cost of a lighter wallet. I blame Gentleman's Gazette for this.
Gordon Hall The pen is very much relevant. My handwriting with a cheap plastic biro is appalling, whereas using a fountain pen or my silver Yard-O-Led ballpoint allows me to write far more neatly
@@Fidgottio I started studying penmanship about 4 years ago. Although I have my preference, I can write equally well whether it be a cheap pencil, ballpoint pen or my way too expensive Nakaya Dorsal Fin 2. It's never about the pen but the penman. 😉
No, if anything Sailor and Mont blanc copied Schaeffer they certainly released the first pen in this style. Sailor may even predate Mont Blanc as the meisterstuck was introduced in 1924 so there is a good chance sailor was producing this style pen certainly around the same time if not before. There is actually no real way of knowing for sure though because most of sailors records were destroyed in the war.
@@aych131 I have two montblancs and while they are great pens they are not head and shoulders above any of the other pens in my collection (a modest 45 pens)
@@adriantwiss600 oh of course, I know they're excellent pens, though the brand does play too much into their pricing. My point was really that he basically said an older model of pen was cigar shaped so it's a montblanc ripoff. Which is obviously untrue
You do know that the "iconic" Meisterstuck shape that you are referring to was actually introduced by Sheaffer with their Balance model? On the other hand, calling Sailor a knock-off when there were also pre-war Japanese pens in a cigar shape is a bit cheap, don't you think?
@@deezem5294 I like expensive pens. My favorites are made by Nimike, and I love both the Maki-e and the Chinkin pens. But they aren't overpriced. It takes decades of effort, and a boatload of talent and skill to make either of these pens. Compared to such pens, every Montblanc is a joke. The high price of Montblanc pens comes solely from the brand name. ANY pen makes could make identical pens for a fraction of the cost.
James Ritchie the original Japanese fountains like the ai made for Japanese calligraphy,will leave mont balnc to dust, ok leave Japanese even the good German fountains will smoke mont blanc
While I'm not a fan of the 1911 and I prefer the Pro Gear flat top I agree with your comment. Sailor is not a knock off of anyone. I would even prefer a Sailor King of Pen over a MB 149 if I was offered either as a gift.
It's a little unfair to say that the 1911 looks like a knockoff MB, when it is known that the MB is based on the earlier Sheaffer's Balance. There are lots of similar designs around, doesn't mean they are knockoffs.
This guy doesn’t know anything about fountain pens. If you see his other videos you’ll see his lack of knowledge. Honestly I feel like his pen videos will lead to people destroying their pens.
C- if that’s the case he shouldn’t be trying to sell things he knows nothing about. Some of the tips he gives in here can wreck people’s pens. He’s also misinforming people willingly..
I own both the Lamy 2000 and Waterman Carene. Both are excellent pens. Also, I've found that both pens do have a very narrow "sweet spot" on the nib but when you do find it, the nib writes exceptionally smooth. In my opinion, the Waterman Carene fits its price range but the Lamy 2000 is excellent value as it may cost $200 but it writes and functions like a $600 pen.
For anyone who is interested in the Vanishing point, it's an excellent pen. I have mine with a fine nib and it writes extremely smoothly. I use mine with the converter which does have a very low volume and only lasts me about two days of light college note taking. Edit: the VP doesn't feel cheap, it has a very nice weight to it. He's just being pretentious. Also the clip doesn't really get in the way.
Agreed. The standard VP is heavier than the Decimo and for smaller hands or those who can’t write with a heavy pen, the Decimo is a great alternative. I don’t have any issues with the clip placement either. I also have a VP and it is great for meetings where I need to take notes. This whole video was off. He could have reviewed the Sailor Pro Gear instead of the 1911 if the design bothered him so much. And to not even mention the differences between European and Japanese nibs in the video was bizarre.
The great thing about the fountain pen hobby is the amount of options that exist at every price range. Here are some further suggestions if you didn't see something you liked in this video: For a more traditional pen: 1) Platinum 3776 2) Pelikan m200 For those who prefer color: 1) Edison Collier 2) Esterbrook Estie For something outside the box: 1) Opus 88 Demonstrator 2) Conklin Crescent Filler 3) Diplomat Aero Personally, I'm a big believer that a pen should fit the personality of the person using it. The abundance of options guarantees that you'll eventually find something that is "you."
@@voltgaming2213 Namiki and Pilot are the same company. Namiki became the luxury brand and Pilot became the daily use office brand. I have an old Namiki Vanishing Point. Later, they decided that the mechanism was more fitting for daily/office use so they move it over to the Pilot side to become teh Pilot Vansishing Point or Capless. Namikis weigh much heavier toward an object d'art than a tool.
i can feel youre not really open minded... anything that deviates from the 149 is described in somewhat of a negative tone. Also, i think one of the key points to the Custom823 is the shutting valve. People either love it or hate it but the people ive talked with who got it say that they got used to unscrewing the back even if they were doubtful at first
so, watching Goulet pens and then watching some hobbyist opinions on fountain pens, rewatching this, I just get a bit of a snobby tone from it. "here's some mid-range pens I wouldn't choose" is what I really got. there are other good pens that are cheaper than the 823 that hold less ink from the pilot that is just as, if not, a little less smooth than the 823. I'm talking about the other pilot customs. I don't think I would mind the 823 but I would most likely use that as a stay-at-home pen because of its cost, the fear of ruining it if I take it out of the house as it drops on concrete, or it being stolen by someone because of how... "bougey" it looks. if you want to have a cheap pen that is gold nibbed (which is what all these pens are) then go for the custom 74 or the platinum century 3776 (a budget sailor 1911). I personally don't own these pens (because I'm 25, poor, working a minimum wage job, and working on my writing etiquette with a Lamy Safari and trying out other inks) but I want to own a gold nib. As a result I researched the past few days and sharing what I know and found out in my education. Gold nibs may be springier and looser, but they don't contact the paper, there is iridium that is on the tip of the nib that contacts the paper. it's the quality of the grind that matters and the ink that is used. please do your research guys before focusing on these sorts of reviews. when you break in a "scratchy nib" it becomes much smoother over time. Asian companies make smaller finer sizes of nibs than all the Western companies. So if you are using a more expensive ink you don't have to worry about using so much per writing session. If you are a southpaw (lefty) like me, you won't have to worry so much about smudging.
A Montblanc is a pen for people who like something with a flashy name. Pit a 146 against the 1911L and Pro Gear and a 145 against the 1911S and Pro Gear slim and I’ll guarantee you most people will take the one with a better nib for half the price.
The Sailor pen is not a copycat.... The "Montblanc classic design" was already classic before the 149. Sailor only takes inspiration from Montblanc's design and prefers to focus on the nib and writing experience. In my opinion Sailor has surpassed Montblanc in some ways, and offer nibs Montblanc cannot even touch ( just google "sailor specialty nibs"!
Also sailor nibs being Japanese, fine nib can be used on normal paper, Mont blanc writes so wet and wide, it is not practical unless you are using 80/90 gsm paper. Not to forget 1/3rd the price of Mont blanc. Sailor realo > Mont blanc 149 for me.
Well, it sounds like you don't ever use Montblanc pens. Whatever else can be said about Montblanc, they still make some of the best nibs in the world. And "specialty" nibs are a joke, even when they come from Sailor. I love Sailor pens, though Namiki makes better Maki-e and Chinkin pens. It takes infinitely more talent to make a Sailor Maki-e that it does to make any Montblanc pen, but when you start talking bad about Montblanc nibs, you jsut don't have a clue. There are many things about Montblanc pens that I really dislike, but every Montblanc pen I've owned, used, tested, or repaired had an absolutely perfect nib and feed. I can't say the same for Sailor. Sailor makes some excellent nibs, but they also allow too many poor nibs to slip through, and occasionally design a nib that just does not work well, especially for the price.
@@jamesaritchie1 I sold my MB Homer after having sent it back to Germany for proper tuning once. The pen skipped all the time and had almost no feedback. It is a good pen and a good brand for rollerball users and heavy-handed status seekers.
@@jamesaritchie1 Ah dunno, I’m still new to the hobby, but I have tried a Mont Blanc, I believe it was an 18 kt nib It felt alright, it was very big, like a Sailor King of Pen, and the nib was smooth enough, reminded me of Diplomat’s nibs, but bouncier But then I saw the price… 1200… Yeah yknow what I’ll stick to my TWSBI GO. And when I’ll upgrade I’ll just go with the Diplomat instead of… This 1200$ Aero
I think the best one is the Pilot custom 823 due to the fact that it has a higher ink capacity 2.2ml and the nib is amazing also it's shape is similar to the Namiki Yukari.
Yes, I realised than when he didn't like the Lamy 2000 and if you don't like the 2000 then there is something not right. But he's said it himself, he had a Montblanc collection as a kid so I guess his standards now may not be met by many pens at all!
@@alextaplin7354 MB is low standard imo. Boring overpriced plastic pens with no life in your writing. Only the new calligraphy nib is nice, vintage MB is nice but I prefer a Waterman 52 which is cheaper than a modern MB but is lightyears better
What I like is that you gave your honest opinion about these 5 pens. Even though they didn’t appeal to your taste, you still offered the people who it would benefit most from them, an option.
The Lamy 2000 is a favorite of mine. The mid-century modern design is timeless, the pen is incredibly comfortable and well balanced, writes smooth, and is a great workhorse pen.
I Too like the 2000, at first when I saw it I thought it was a metal felt tip pen XD... then when I wrote with it.... I literally threw away all of my felt tip pens away.... I Wept at that decision...... XD
I think it should be mentioned that, while piston-pens have a greater ink reservoir, they are also much more difficult to clean or service. Unless it's something like a TWSBI (a fine selection of piston-filling, mostly demonstrator pens between $28-$85) that is made to be broken down by the user, most of them need to be sent off to their respective companies to be serviced. This can be irritating when all that is needed is a bit of lubrication or you don't want to actuate the piston-nob repeatedly just to clean it. For ease of cleaning, maintenance, versatility, and price, I tend to favor cartridge/converter-filling pens. Given the cost of the typical Montblanc, I'll stick with my Sailor 1911. And Edison Pen Company.
One of the unspoken things about TWSBI is how the plastic can get weak over time. I used to own a Vac 700 which I bought in late 2015. The plastic around the metal cap ring at the base of the cap had sheared off and I was left with a pen that could not seal itself. Sadly, I had to throw it into the bin 2 months ago.
@@thelongslowgoodbye You bring up an interesting point. While I've never experienced a similar issue, I do know TWSBI did have cracking issues for a time. I've also not had my TWSBIs for as long. I must say there are a number of pen makers who use plastics and acrylics who do not have widespread complaints about how their pens held up to normal use. Your circumstances may have put unusual wear on your pen. That said, for what they offer, the affordability, and great customer service, I have no problem recommending a TWSBI.
I have a Lamy 2000 and enjoy it quite a bit, though it does write on the wet side. I have an extra-fine point and it still produces a smooth line that’s a bit on the wider side for its stated width.
I’ve been collecting pens for 7 or 8 years. I have both the Carene and the lamy 2000. They are two of my favorite pens and one is usually inked. I’ve used the capless/vanishing point and it feels nice. However, for 100-300 don’t overlook vintage! Many pens are available fully restored in that price range, and even sub 100, with lovely nibs and tons of character.
You wont believe this but I still hold my pilot metropolitan over all of them I have some of these great writers yet I for some strange reason Still opt to reach for my Metropolitan!! IF you heard of the writing term "butter on hot glass" this surprisingly does this like the gold nibs if not better that some..... And you can bet you bottom and top dollar on that!
@@mrpilotsapien7705 I have two metropolitans that I use all the time. They work well and are very utilitarian. In my opinion they don’t have the character of a 80 year old sheaffer, or a lamy 2000, or waterman Carene for that matter. They do write well. I usually keeled one inked with red or orange and use it in my classroom.
In order to avoid the likeliness between a Sailor 1911 and a Montblanc, just go with a Sailor in the Professional Gear body. Sailor nibs are among the best in the world, and for smaller pens, way better than Montblancs and a fraction of the price... If you are a conaisseur, you’d rather go with Sailor instead of Montblanc. An ideal mid range would be the Proffesional Gear large, with 21 k nib in the Earth limited edition finish (which is mid brown). Elegant and reliable. A bit more expensive, but still cheaper than equivalent Monblancs, are Sailor’s piston fillers. Their converters carry a very limited amount of ink...
An excellent video. For those who favor a piston filling mechanism, Sailor makes a variation of the 1911 with one. It's called the Realo and is available in burgundy or black with gold or silver trim. While the stated retail is $410.00, I've seen it priced by reputable dealers at just over the $300 limit. The sailor is one of my favorite mid-range fountain pens. It has a very good nib and is a pleasure to write with. And while I agree that some pens for a bit more money can be a lot nicer, a mid-range pen can be useful to have for occasions in which one might prefer not to be carrying one of his finer pens. I bought my Montblanc 146 in 1965 and used it through college, law school and much of my career. I wrote my Bar exam with it. Through the years I acquired other pens (how many is confidential, to protect myself from being ridiculed by my wife), and the 146 went into semi-retirement about 15 years ago. These days I mostly use one of my Pelikan M600s -- I find that size more suitable for carrying around. Thank you for your efforts to maintain/restore a measure of class to our world.
Gosh. I love how personal some people are when it comes to their fountain pen opinions in the comments! BTW, Pelikan > Montblanc. I wait patiently for the hate!
I think pelikan pens are beautiful and I appreciate the fact their smaller models are piston fillers whereas their montblanc counterparts (I'm thinking of the m200 vs 145 respectively) don't offer that until their higher models. I just don't like the toothiness of the pelikan nibs, but it's a personal preference!
A couple of days ago I got a Pelikan Souverän M400 in black and red with a broad nib. I like the design quite a lot and it has been a pleasant writing expirience so far. In Europe it would be right in the middle of that price range. I recently got back into fountain pen writing in part thanks to your videos.
I have to say, I truly love listening to you speak so intentionally and clearly. It is truly unique and enjoyable, but additionally very informative. Thank you!
My lamy 2000 doesn't have that 'sweet spot' issue that everyone says it has, I rotate and move my pens a lot and have never had a problem. In my opinion this is the most perfect pen and every aspect of this pen is well designed. Don't hesitate if you are thinking of buying one. Very iconic design too.
I find this video heavily biased (Not in a good way). If you're going to put in an opinion, don't be so negative about every option you give. It's conflicting and confuses viewers. I find it irritating when you label your video as "Quality Pens", then proceed to call the first pen right off the bat "cheap-looking". If you don't like the pen, but recommend them to others, leave your opinion out.
Ykw😂 If you give something that costs more the guys: ITS THE BEST THING OUT THERE. Something average: NOT MY TASTE. Well, don't expect me to take these chunks in my classes. Need to scribble down lots. Lamy and twsbi does the job way better than anything. At this point I doubt the credibility of any of their videos I've watched.
Back in my elementary school days (about 11 years ago) we actually got a fountain pen from school. Lasted up until 6th grade. Even now it still works great! If you take good care of your pen it can last you very very long.
About the Sailor 1911, you mentioned that it's a bit of a finer line. Of course it is. anybody that knows a bit of fountain pen knows that pens made by pilot, platinum and sailor are finer than the other ones. Basically, a medium from these companies is equivalent to a fine from other companies like Lamy, Faber Castell, Waterman, etc. And calling the Sailor 1911 a knock-off of the Montblanc is basically sating that all pen that have a cigar shape and a black option is a knock-off. That's a bit pretentious
I would love to see a companion video on men’s stationary and calling cards. Why have great fountain pens without the stationary to go with it. Writing is becoming a lost art and I would love to know more about the etiquette of calling cards, thank you notes and stationary for written correspondence. Thanks
My favorite brand is Faber Castell. In my younger days I used their Osmia 883. Today I use the Graf von Faber-Castell Guilloche Black Fountain Pen. Really nice. Thanks to GG. A nice channel. Give me so much fun 😂👍
I have never owned a fountain pen but the idea appeals to me. I think I like the sailor 1911. do you think I should start my fountain pen journey there or something else? thanks
If my experience is useful, and I think that of many others as well, you’ll be happier if you ease into it with under 100 or under 50 dollar pens. You’ll be able to get the hang of it, play around, and figure out what you like before dropping 200-300 bucks on a more expensive pen that might end up not liking. Also, a big part of the fun, and the writing experience, is the ink and the paper you use. You’ll have a blast with cheaper quality pens, ink samples, and a variety of paper. Then you can buy more expensive pens. Also, if you live in a city with a pen show, it’s worth going to one so you can see, touch, and write with the pricier pens.
dont buy the expensive ones yet. my advice. try first the china made jinhao x750 so you can familiarize yourself with how a fountain pen works, maintenance, and common pen issues. you can find alot of videos for this. when it comes to ink. buy first a dye based and or waterbased ink. and stay away from carbon based ink. starter inks you should start to choose from: pilot namiki, parker ink, and lamy ink.
The Platinum 3776 is very similar to the Sailor 1911 and can be had for around 60 on Amazon or Ebay if you buy it from a Japanese reseller. I find the construction more solid than that of the 1911 and the nib selection is quite nice. If you generally are a careful person, I would recommend spending around 100. If, on the contrary, you are clumsier than average, I would not recommend spending over 20. In any case, a fountain pen doesn't do much for your handwriting unless you practice penmanship on your spare time. So I would advise starting your fountain pen journey by finding a book or two on that and practicing with any fountain pen. You can acquire amazing skill with a cheap and nasty supermarket-grade-fountain pen. Expensive pens mostly provide more comfort as materials are nicer to the touch and the pens are made more carefully. They also give you the opportunity to show-off even though nobody cares about your pens and to be more self-confident knowing you demonstrated your ability to spend money.
Another thing to remember if you buy a Japanese pen - most of the nibs are a grade finer than stated. Therefore if you like medium nibs go for a broad in if buying Japanese. A great starter pen is the Lamy Alstar. Its the same as a Safari but with an Aluminium body. Very good steel nib and tough as old boots. Also the triangular section (the bit you hold) makes for a very natural writing position.
I love fountain pens and use them regularly. Working in construction I wear a Pelikan Souverän M605 as my construction site note taking tool. Most guys consider me a bit strange for that, but who cares. I use it with Montblanc Document Blue ink, since this is 100% document prove, meaning the writing remains perfectly ok even if it gets wet. And yes, my notebook, lying around on construction sites regularly, does not look beautiful and gets scratched and dinged regularly. This leads to the general problem with fountain pens, and the reason I cannot really recommend them. Like Raphael I am from Germany and in Germany you cannot use them for signatures. Because 99% of the available fountain pen ink is not document prove and if you sign a legally binding document, be it a business contract or any kind of official document like your tax declaration, it MUST be signed with a document prove pen. Since the person who looks at the signature cannot know if you used a document proved ink or not, he can - and quite often will - reject the document unless you can prove that you have used document ink in your pen. I remember 20 years ago I was sitting in a lecture room during a written 3h test in mathematics when 15 minutes in the test the professor walked the lines and saw one guy using a fountain pen. He told him to get a ball pen or other document prove pen immediately and to first copy everything he had already written on new paper with the „correct“ pen first before he continues to work on the rest of the test. So sadly pens like these are fine for writing a letter - which I do maybe once a year - or to take notes in your personal notebook - which many people today do on their tablets or computers, but it is not suitable for use on any official document. Funny: On German schools up till the 13th grade - which is when you get your final school diploma that allows you to go to a college or university - the use of fountain pens and cursive writing is mandatory in most German states. Or at least was when I was in school until 1997.
This breaks the heart to have read this. I wish All schools would keep writing in.... tech is good but not for everything.....Im old enough to remember simply writing a letter to some one and mailing it off..... not its email......took the enjoyment out of the time put in to communicate with others..... Correct me if I misinterpreted the basis of your story..... that's tough that you need actual proof that you signed with document proof ink..... would they do the same for a finger or stylus written signature from a tablet?..... Wouldn't it be best as to call to confirm you signed the document and it is being sent to them immediately? I could argue this all day..... i'm not a lawyer, but believe me, i can go the distance. As for the Lecture, Do I really need say more!?.... Ill be your attorney... for free... just let me do the talking.... or in this case Ill have a hand written document sent to them in either "Platinum carbon black, "Noodlers black, "D'atramentis document black.....theres more but I can think of them right now.......
Gold nibs are usually bouncier than steel ones, with exceptions, but they are not necessarily smoother. A Diplomat or Faber-Castell steel nib will be as smooth or smoother than any of the nibs in this video. You also did not talk about a benefit of the vacuum filler system of the 823, which is the MUCH larger filling capacity, easily twice that of any other pen in the five spotlighted today.
If you have normal sized hands and write a lot you’d defiantly prefer decimo over capless. More weight=hand fatigue. Also, as others has pointed out, though the design may look similar, Sailor 1911 definitely isn’t a knockoff of MB. Sailor prevails in nib grinding, no other major manufacture does the likes of Sailor’s togi 长刀研 nibs out of factory. Also, MB 149 doesn’t guarantee a pleasant writing experience. It’s mostly the branding that gives you the pride of ownership. I prefer writing with my Lamy2000 and Platinum 3776 over my MB149 all day. Imho, while fountain pens may be part of styling, you really should leave these more in-depth information videos to professionals like GouletPens. I find your videos a little biased.
I work a physical job, although it is on the inside of a retail store, (I stock merchandise), I wanted to know how fancy I could get without risking harm to the clothes I am wearing. (I do wear kneepads as to not damage my slacks/pants. (Do keep in mind that I bend, kneel, stoop down, and stretch many parts of the body often. Dress shoes I can wear everyday, walking all day without wearing out fast would be amazing)
The vanishing points clip is actually something I like. It makes a nice place for my fingers to rest against when gripping the pen. Everyone has their own opinions I hope people take this video as one mans opinions for some of that stuff.
What Ive also discovered is: if your a "writer roller" [your hand tends to roll the pen as you write]; this will definately stop it from rolling in your hand. bitter sweet of a pen but because it is what it designed for a quick note pen, not a memoir first draft pen, Ideal for students and doctors and other quick jot takers alike... (dont know why I put this in.... maybe b/c everyones STILL bashing the ink capacity) (PLAYFULL RANT) WELL, GO BACK TO THE "BIC STIC" IF YOU WANNA WRITE ALOT!!!!! XD
Cigar shape is a classic design for a fountain pen, sailor 1911 is not a copy cat. That's what Mont blanc wants you to believe so that they can charge 3 times more than sailor. If we go by their definition, every sedan car is a copy cat of Benz or BMW car.
I view writing as an essential part of life, life has changed because of writers. Getting a good pen early on in life is an investement. I will be making my first purchase soon & I'm still considering my options.
I like the looks and finish of Waterman Carene ! I’m neither an expert nor a collector, but I own Waterman Hemisphere Fountain and Roller pens and also entry level Sheaffer and Cross pens.
My everyday pen is a Lamy Studio that I put an italic nib on. It fits my hand well, is very classic looking in stainless and the italic nib is just blunt enough to make my handwriting look closer to calligraphy. My backup pen is also a Lamy Studio with a medium nib with a black body. The primary pen is filled with a reddish brown ink while I use dark blue ink in the backup pen. Some documents must be signed in blue, hence the ink choice for the backup pen. These pens do not fit into your video since they are well under $100 but I would not trade them for any other pen.
I wonder if any the other topics this channel covers is as much of a hand grenade as "What is the best fountain pen?", particularly from a Montblanc cultist? I'd suggest a Sailor Professional Gear over a 1911 for a first step up, for example. It projects "classic" and "elegant", but has a more modern shape, so you can show your own style a bit. It just wouldn't make the GG grade because it doesn't look like a Montblanc.
@@mrpilotsapien7705 vintage can be had for cheap aswell, I got my parker 51 for 15 bucks, new breather tube and a clean and adjust and it wrote like new, sadly I sold it a few months ago.
Its not the cheapness and design of the pen its your personal pen that you can grow up with i started with jinhao but i suggest higher prices for those who likes expensive and elegant ones
1. Pilot Vanishing Point Raden 2. Namiki Emperor Maki-e 3. Sailor 1911 or Pro Gear King of Pen Boom. Collection done. That' all you need in this lifetime.
Can't really argue with that. I would personally replace the Namiki Emperor with a urushi pen (maybe a decapod or something) from Platinum, just to complete the big 3 Japanese companies.
I own 3 sailor fountain pens, and they are great. I think they are a little bit small for most people. I recommend picking 1911L if you don't have kids size hand like me.
Recently I purchased my first real fountain pen fro Sailor, pro gear slim, from a collection in 21k gold nib, medium fine. I’m curious how long the ink will last and gain more experience with it. I hope one day to own Mont Blanc foundation pen with gold nib.
If it's a pro gear slim then it has a 14kt gold nib. Also please don't aspire to own a MB because their pen manufacturing process has degraded MASSIVELY. They are now making the bodies via injection moulding and have sold their soul for success. The sailors not only came before the Mont Blanc but are immensely better both in terms of value and in terms of writing experience, and please don't take my word for it. There are many people who are collectors who will attest to this. You can watch the nibsmith video of the Sailor KOP vs MB 149 and also numerous articles online before you arrive at your own conclusion.
Cool. I just ordered a mid range Maki-e fountain from japan. It's by a very indie Maki-e artist. It has the iconic 'The Great Wave of Kanagawa'. God bless, Proverbs 31
A year ago I would have suggested to you the Jinhao 159 for $3 literraly right then and there! You could pass for a montblanc to the untrained eye.... I can say this cause I do it.... ppl love how It writes when I give my signature on documents (stub nib and color other than black and blue)..... Them: can you sign off on this sir? Me: certainly Them: Wow! nice lookin writing I like this color! And that pen is fancy! Me: Would you like to write with it? They try it........ Whoa: its heavy!!!!! Dont wanna break you expensive pen!!!! XD
Get a pilot 91, 912 or a falcon. Or the 74 series instead of these. A fountainpen without flex is just an expensive ballpoint (specialty grinds excluded ofc)
As a fountain pen user I enjoyed the video very much. BUT please do not say " very unique". Unique is an adjective that is not quantifiable. It is either unique or not. Critique is left in a constructive vein. Thanks for the video and I will continue to watch your channel.
As of youre request I purchest a Fountan Pen. I got it from a Lokal Woodworker, he uses Fountain Pen Banks and Turns the "Shell" (leck of better Word) out of a combination of Wood and colored Resin. So i have an absolut unique Pice. I realy have to Thank you, without you I wouldn't have taken a shot to Fountain Pens
Good choices for mid-range fountain pens. May I suggest a video on fountain pen inks? Other than the Waterman Carene, I have tried them all and the Sailor 1911 is my favorite. Other less known options are Franklin-Christoph and Edison, both of which write well and fall in this price range.
I second the Edison Pen Company suggestion. I think they're well-made and versatile. Mr. Schneider might take umbrage with the Herald model, though, and call it a "Montblanc knockoff." He may love the brand, but I still consider Montblanc's prices ridiculous. I want something at a more affordable price-point. Inks and papers would be taking us down a whole different rabbit hole. Which is where I am now. Send help.
Hello. I just got my pilot fountain pen yesterday. I prefer blue ink to black ink. Can I just switch to the blue after the black runs out. Or do I need to clean the pen first?
One video on this channel discusses pens under $20. Now this one is for $100-300. Where’s the video showcasing pens between these vastly different price points??
After watching your videos and doing research, I started with a Pilot Metropolitan. I do want a Montblanc Meisterstuck 149 Platinum. And after watching this, I think that when I upgrade, I'll probably just upgrade up to that. But even the Pilot Metropolitan is so much better than the cheaper pens that I've used, so I'm looking forward to the Montblanc. :) I find that I actually like writing by hand again. And as others have said, since I care about it again, my handwriting is getting better / back to what it used to be and I find myself finding excuses / reasons to write notes / letters by hand now.
you my friend have the Fountain pen Virus level one : finding any excuse to write.... well done! I commend you on this (a year later though i'm sure you're far along with the pleasure of a virus) writing Is Validly necessary eye to hand coordination versus the screen.... finger scroll finger scroll scroll tap tap finger scroll.... Where ever you are in your journey; in the words of Brian Goulet and the team: WRITE ON! (NOTE: IM NOT AN EMPLOYEE THE CATCH PHRASE IS JUST BEFITTING TO PUT THERE)
I wouldn’t recommend the Mont Blanc though… A Sailor or even a Diplomat will write just as, if not smoother and better. Also the Metropolitain is fine on it’s own. No need to upgrade if there’s no need to
Correct, yes; the Montblanc is in the front, and the Sailor 1911 is in the back. You'll also see this shot at other points in the video. Thanks for watching! - Preston
Do you have a video on what are the best fountain pens for daily writing? I enjoy the feel of writing with it and am always interested in finding a high quality writing experience. Thank you!
Do you know of a top qual ink that is insoluble? You write with a fountain pen, ink dries, you spill water on it, ink runs. What ink do you recommend if any?
There's just something about this guy's handwriting and the ink combination (Mont Blanc Irish green) that makes me feel like I wanna write. I really want a mont Blanc Irish green I have some pens that will look stunning with it
The Decimo is my daily carry. Pearl white with Rhodium plated trim. I have a Medium 18k nib in mine and have a 1.0 stub nib coming. My desk pen is a 1940s vintage Waterman's 515. 14k gold semi flex nib. Black and gold trim. Made in England.
Literally any pen from the Custom or Custom Heritage lines from pilot > Any waterman IMO. Same with Platinum 3776 line and the Sailor 14 slim line as well as the 21k lines all out compete modern Waterman pens,
@@MrBloopt Don't hold your breath - Mont Blancs are extremely well made and can be visually very lovely but in terms of writing performance they are not a quantum leap above many other quality pens. As I said in another comment its all down to the tuning. I have a 90 year old Wahl Eversharp Doric with a firm 14k nib that and a 40s Mabie Todd Swan that are both sublime writers.
What about Faber Castell or Cross? They have absolutely fabulous pens. I have been writing with fountain pens for years and tried many. I have never found anything as excellent as my Faber Castell with an extra fine nib, and my Century Cross with a fine nib.
Fountain pens have become my most expensive and fulfilling hobby. My handwriting and writing has improved, but at the cost of a lighter wallet. I blame Gentleman's Gazette for this.
Guilty as charged. :) Thanks for watching and commenting!
- Preston
Then you haven't seen Goulet Pen's videos. Guaranteed to decimate your bank account.
Choice of pen is irrelevant to your hand writing. Choose a script that you like and put in the time to practice. That's it.
Gordon Hall The pen is very much relevant. My handwriting with a cheap plastic biro is appalling, whereas using a fountain pen or my silver Yard-O-Led ballpoint allows me to write far more neatly
@@Fidgottio I started studying penmanship about 4 years ago. Although I have my preference, I can write equally well whether it be a cheap pencil, ballpoint pen or my way too expensive Nakaya Dorsal Fin 2. It's never about the pen but the penman. 😉
No, if anything Sailor and Mont blanc copied Schaeffer they certainly released the first pen in this style. Sailor may even predate Mont Blanc as the meisterstuck was introduced in 1924 so there is a good chance sailor was producing this style pen certainly around the same time if not before. There is actually no real way of knowing for sure though because most of sailors records were destroyed in the war.
AMEN!!!!!
Swear that irritated me so much. Another montblanc elitist
@@aych131 I have two montblancs and while they are great pens they are not head and shoulders above any of the other pens in my collection (a modest 45 pens)
@@adriantwiss600 oh of course, I know they're excellent pens, though the brand does play too much into their pricing. My point was really that he basically said an older model of pen was cigar shaped so it's a montblanc ripoff. Which is obviously untrue
@@aych131 I agree with you on both points
You do know that the "iconic" Meisterstuck shape that you are referring to was actually introduced by Sheaffer with their Balance model? On the other hand, calling Sailor a knock-off when there were also pre-war Japanese pens in a cigar shape is a bit cheap, don't you think?
Krzysztof Kołosowski I glad you brought that up. 👍🏻
He just wants everybody to buy the overpriced af montblancs
@@deezem5294 I like expensive pens. My favorites are made by Nimike, and I love both the Maki-e and the Chinkin pens. But they aren't overpriced. It takes decades of effort, and a boatload of talent and skill to make either of these pens.
Compared to such pens, every Montblanc is a joke. The high price of Montblanc pens comes solely from the brand name. ANY pen makes could make identical pens for a fraction of the cost.
James Ritchie the original Japanese fountains like the ai made for Japanese calligraphy,will leave mont balnc to dust, ok leave Japanese even the good German fountains will smoke mont blanc
While I'm not a fan of the 1911 and I prefer the Pro Gear flat top I agree with your comment. Sailor is not a knock off of anyone. I would even prefer a Sailor King of Pen over a MB 149 if I was offered either as a gift.
It's a little unfair to say that the 1911 looks like a knockoff MB, when it is known that the MB is based on the earlier Sheaffer's Balance. There are lots of similar designs around, doesn't mean they are knockoffs.
Qing Tian Xia yea the sailor 1911 looks somewhat like a platinum 3776 so does that make it a knock off of that too?
This guy doesn’t know anything about fountain pens. If you see his other videos you’ll see his lack of knowledge. Honestly I feel like his pen videos will lead to people destroying their pens.
@@potatopewpew4719 Guy is a salesman , not an penthusiast
C- if that’s the case he shouldn’t be trying to sell things he knows nothing about. Some of the tips he gives in here can wreck people’s pens. He’s also misinforming people willingly..
@@antoniosaladin Sailor Promenade looks like 3776 xD :
I heard 1911 and I legit thought you were about to pull out a .45 :D
Haha, I thought this when I first heard of the pen a while ago.
Nah 9m
@@Vlakvarks the 1911 is chambered in .45acp
Best gun ever. :D
That particular pen has closed a lot of deals over the years. Anyway, it's my favourite pistol, even though I'm more of a revolver man myself.
I own both the Lamy 2000 and Waterman Carene. Both are excellent pens. Also, I've found that both pens do have a very narrow "sweet spot" on the nib but when you do find it, the nib writes exceptionally smooth. In my opinion, the Waterman Carene fits its price range but the Lamy 2000 is excellent value as it may cost $200 but it writes and functions like a $600 pen.
I feel like Raphael is a little biased when it comes to the MB149
Water is wet
For anyone who is interested in the Vanishing point, it's an excellent pen. I have mine with a fine nib and it writes extremely smoothly. I use mine with the converter which does have a very low volume and only lasts me about two days of light college note taking.
Edit: the VP doesn't feel cheap, it has a very nice weight to it. He's just being pretentious. Also the clip doesn't really get in the way.
Agreed. The standard VP is heavier than the Decimo and for smaller hands or those who can’t write with a heavy pen, the Decimo is a great alternative. I don’t have any issues with the clip placement either. I also have a VP and it is great for meetings where I need to take notes. This whole video was off. He could have reviewed the Sailor Pro Gear instead of the 1911 if the design bothered him so much. And to not even mention the differences between European and Japanese nibs in the video was bizarre.
The great thing about the fountain pen hobby is the amount of options that exist at every price range. Here are some further suggestions if you didn't see something you liked in this video:
For a more traditional pen:
1) Platinum 3776
2) Pelikan m200
For those who prefer color:
1) Edison Collier
2) Esterbrook Estie
For something outside the box:
1) Opus 88 Demonstrator
2) Conklin Crescent Filler
3) Diplomat Aero
Personally, I'm a big believer that a pen should fit the personality of the person using it. The abundance of options guarantees that you'll eventually find something that is "you."
Nice list. Thanks!
Diplomat Aero looks interesting. I do also fancy the large aristocratic-ish shape and size of the Faber Castell E-motion
You could also substitute the Platinum 3776 for the Platinum President if you want something a little more rare and special.
And for sheet Opulence a Yard O Led Viceroy Grand.
wonderful list ...thank you !
Pilot/Sailor/Namiki are usually about the writing experience. With the exception of the Namikis, they tend to be understated relative to their peers.
All good but namiki best
@@voltgaming2213
Namiki and Pilot are the same company. Namiki became the luxury brand and Pilot became the daily use office brand.
I have an old Namiki Vanishing Point. Later, they decided that the mechanism was more fitting for daily/office use so they move it over to the Pilot side to become teh Pilot Vansishing Point or Capless. Namikis weigh much heavier toward an object d'art than a tool.
i can feel youre not really open minded... anything that deviates from the 149 is described in somewhat of a negative tone.
Also, i think one of the key points to the Custom823 is the shutting valve. People either love it or hate it but the people ive talked with who got it say that they got used to unscrewing the back even if they were doubtful at first
Funny that I am so used to the 823 now I can't use a regular piston filler. I can't help but keep wanting to turn the end cap once a while.
so, watching Goulet pens and then watching some hobbyist opinions on fountain pens, rewatching this, I just get a bit of a snobby tone from it. "here's some mid-range pens I wouldn't choose" is what I really got. there are other good pens that are cheaper than the 823 that hold less ink from the pilot that is just as, if not, a little less smooth than the 823. I'm talking about the other pilot customs. I don't think I would mind the 823 but I would most likely use that as a stay-at-home pen because of its cost, the fear of ruining it if I take it out of the house as it drops on concrete, or it being stolen by someone because of how... "bougey" it looks. if you want to have a cheap pen that is gold nibbed (which is what all these pens are) then go for the custom 74 or the platinum century 3776 (a budget sailor 1911). I personally don't own these pens (because I'm 25, poor, working a minimum wage job, and working on my writing etiquette with a Lamy Safari and trying out other inks) but I want to own a gold nib. As a result I researched the past few days and sharing what I know and found out in my education. Gold nibs may be springier and looser, but they don't contact the paper, there is iridium that is on the tip of the nib that contacts the paper. it's the quality of the grind that matters and the ink that is used. please do your research guys before focusing on these sorts of reviews. when you break in a "scratchy nib" it becomes much smoother over time. Asian companies make smaller finer sizes of nibs than all the Western companies. So if you are using a more expensive ink you don't have to worry about using so much per writing session. If you are a southpaw (lefty) like me, you won't have to worry so much about smudging.
Exactly! Here are 5 pens I don't like! Lol he can be snobby and then he has to pronounce Montblanc all fancy! Hahaha
Calling Sailor a copycat of a Montblanc is downright fountain pen racism.
A Montblanc is a pen for people who like something with a flashy name. Pit a 146 against the 1911L and Pro Gear and a 145 against the 1911S and Pro Gear slim and I’ll guarantee you most people will take the one with a better nib for half the price.
The Sailor pen is not a copycat....
The "Montblanc classic design" was already classic before the 149.
Sailor only takes inspiration from Montblanc's design and prefers to focus on the nib and writing experience.
In my opinion Sailor has surpassed Montblanc in some ways, and offer nibs Montblanc cannot even touch ( just google "sailor specialty nibs"!
Also sailor nibs being Japanese, fine nib can be used on normal paper, Mont blanc writes so wet and wide, it is not practical unless you are using 80/90 gsm paper. Not to forget 1/3rd the price of Mont blanc. Sailor realo > Mont blanc 149 for me.
Well, it sounds like you don't ever use Montblanc pens. Whatever else can be said about Montblanc, they still make some of the best nibs in the world. And "specialty" nibs are a joke, even when they come from Sailor.
I love Sailor pens, though Namiki makes better Maki-e and Chinkin pens. It takes infinitely more talent to make a Sailor Maki-e that it does to make any Montblanc pen, but when you start talking bad about Montblanc nibs, you jsut don't have a clue.
There are many things about Montblanc pens that I really dislike, but every Montblanc pen I've owned, used, tested, or repaired had an absolutely perfect nib and feed. I can't say the same for Sailor.
Sailor makes some excellent nibs, but they also allow too many poor nibs to slip through, and occasionally design a nib that just does not work well, especially for the price.
@@jamesaritchie1 I sold my MB Homer after having sent it back to Germany for proper tuning once.
The pen skipped all the time and had almost no feedback. It is a good pen and a good brand for rollerball users and heavy-handed status seekers.
@@jamesaritchie1 Ah dunno, I’m still new to the hobby, but I have tried a Mont Blanc, I believe it was an 18 kt nib
It felt alright, it was very big, like a Sailor King of Pen, and the nib was smooth enough, reminded me of Diplomat’s nibs, but bouncier
But then I saw the price… 1200…
Yeah yknow what I’ll stick to my TWSBI GO. And when I’ll upgrade I’ll just go with the Diplomat instead of… This 1200$ Aero
I own all of these pens, except the Carene and can confirm that the real experience is the 1911 with a Zoom nib. It’s an amazing nib.
I think the best one is the Pilot custom 823 due to the fact that it has a higher ink capacity 2.2ml and the nib is amazing also it's shape is similar to the Namiki Yukari.
Before reaching 13:00 I knew this guy would not like any of the pens, except for his specific brand.
Then what happens after?
Yes, I realised than when he didn't like the Lamy 2000 and if you don't like the 2000 then there is something not right. But he's said it himself, he had a Montblanc collection as a kid so I guess his standards now may not be met by many pens at all!
@@alextaplin7354 MB is low standard imo. Boring overpriced plastic pens with no life in your writing.
Only the new calligraphy nib is nice, vintage MB is nice but I prefer a Waterman 52 which is cheaper than a modern MB but is lightyears better
What I like is that you gave your honest opinion about these 5 pens. Even though they didn’t appeal to your taste, you still offered the people who it would benefit most from them, an option.
The Lamy 2000 is a favorite of mine. The mid-century modern design is timeless, the pen is incredibly comfortable and well balanced, writes smooth, and is a great workhorse pen.
I Too like the 2000, at first when I saw it I thought it was a metal felt tip pen XD... then when I wrote with it.... I literally threw away all of my felt tip pens away....
I Wept at that decision...... XD
The 2000 is my daily writer for work and home use. I just ordered a Sailor 1911L in medium so we'll see if that out performs my 2000
I think it should be mentioned that, while piston-pens have a greater ink reservoir, they are also much more difficult to clean or service.
Unless it's something like a TWSBI (a fine selection of piston-filling, mostly demonstrator pens between $28-$85) that is made to be broken down by the user, most of them need to be sent off to their respective companies to be serviced. This can be irritating when all that is needed is a bit of lubrication or you don't want to actuate the piston-nob repeatedly just to clean it.
For ease of cleaning, maintenance, versatility, and price, I tend to favor cartridge/converter-filling pens.
Given the cost of the typical Montblanc, I'll stick with my Sailor 1911. And Edison Pen Company.
I love my TWSBIs! I own a really nice Omas piston filler which required a thin metric wrench to disassemble, once Omas went belly-up.
@@waltski4375 I love the TSWBI price-point, ability to disassemble, and the relative ease of nib-swapping. Depending on pen model, of course.
PenBBS also has piston, button, vacuum and bulk fillers, and all can be disassembled by hand.
One of the unspoken things about TWSBI is how the plastic can get weak over time. I used to own a Vac 700 which I bought in late 2015. The plastic around the metal cap ring at the base of the cap had sheared off and I was left with a pen that could not seal itself. Sadly, I had to throw it into the bin 2 months ago.
@@thelongslowgoodbye You bring up an interesting point. While I've never experienced a similar issue, I do know TWSBI did have cracking issues for a time. I've also not had my TWSBIs for as long.
I must say there are a number of pen makers who use plastics and acrylics who do not have widespread complaints about how their pens held up to normal use. Your circumstances may have put unusual wear on your pen.
That said, for what they offer, the affordability, and great customer service, I have no problem recommending a TWSBI.
Fountain pens? I still use a feather to write my letters, and have them delivered by horseback messenger.
Do you now? A bit like Evelyn Waugh, then.
I thought everyone did.
mine is delivered by an owl
Cheaper than a computer, nicer to receive, less polluting, easier to replace. Technology's overrated.
Or a peageon instead lol
I have a Lamy 2000 and enjoy it quite a bit, though it does write on the wet side. I have an extra-fine point and it still produces a smooth line that’s a bit on the wider side for its stated width.
You can control the wetness to a degree by using a drier ink, like some Pelikan or Kaweco inks.
I’ve been collecting pens for 7 or 8 years.
I have both the Carene and the lamy 2000. They are two of my favorite pens and one is usually inked.
I’ve used the capless/vanishing point and it feels nice.
However, for 100-300 don’t overlook vintage! Many pens are available fully restored in that price range, and even sub 100, with lovely nibs and tons of character.
You wont believe this but I still hold my pilot metropolitan over all of them I have some of these great writers yet I for some strange reason Still opt to reach for my Metropolitan!! IF you heard of the writing term "butter on hot glass" this surprisingly does this like the gold nibs if not better that some.....
And you can bet you bottom and top dollar on that!
@@mrpilotsapien7705 I have two metropolitans that I use all the time. They work well and are very utilitarian. In my opinion they don’t have the character of a 80 year old sheaffer, or a lamy 2000, or waterman Carene for that matter.
They do write well.
I usually keeled one inked with red or orange and use it in my classroom.
In order to avoid the likeliness between a Sailor 1911 and a Montblanc, just go with a Sailor in the Professional Gear body. Sailor nibs are among the best in the world, and for smaller pens, way better than Montblancs and a fraction of the price... If you are a conaisseur, you’d rather go with Sailor instead of Montblanc. An ideal mid range would be the Proffesional Gear large, with 21 k nib in the Earth limited edition finish (which is mid brown). Elegant and reliable. A bit more expensive, but still cheaper than equivalent Monblancs, are Sailor’s piston fillers. Their converters carry a very limited amount of ink...
Big up for Waterman! They have an excellent selection of both mid-range and budget fountain pens.
Absolutely, I own a Carène and its my favourite pen!
An excellent video.
For those who favor a piston filling mechanism, Sailor makes a variation of the 1911 with one. It's called the Realo and is available in burgundy or black with gold or silver trim. While the stated retail is $410.00, I've seen it priced by reputable dealers at just over the $300 limit. The sailor is one of my favorite mid-range fountain pens. It has a very good nib and is a pleasure to write with.
And while I agree that some pens for a bit more money can be a lot nicer, a mid-range pen can be useful to have for occasions in which one might prefer not to be carrying one of his finer pens.
I bought my Montblanc 146 in 1965 and used it through college, law school and much of my career. I wrote my Bar exam with it. Through the years I acquired other pens (how many is confidential, to protect myself from being ridiculed by my wife), and the 146 went into semi-retirement about 15 years ago. These days I mostly use one of my Pelikan M600s -- I find that size more suitable for carrying around.
Thank you for your efforts to maintain/restore a measure of class to our world.
Gosh. I love how personal some people are when it comes to their fountain pen opinions in the comments! BTW, Pelikan > Montblanc. I wait patiently for the hate!
I think pelikan pens are beautiful and I appreciate the fact their smaller models are piston fillers whereas their montblanc counterparts (I'm thinking of the m200 vs 145 respectively) don't offer that until their higher models. I just don't like the toothiness of the pelikan nibs, but it's a personal preference!
Agreed...
A couple of days ago I got a Pelikan Souverän M400 in black and red with a broad nib. I like the design quite a lot and it has been a pleasant writing expirience so far. In Europe it would be right in the middle of that price range. I recently got back into fountain pen writing in part thanks to your videos.
....me......jealous........ PELIKANNNNN!!!!!!!!
I have to say, I truly love listening to you speak so intentionally and clearly. It is truly unique and enjoyable, but additionally very informative. Thank you!
My lamy 2000 doesn't have that 'sweet spot' issue that everyone says it has, I rotate and move my pens a lot and have never had a problem. In my opinion this is the most perfect pen and every aspect of this pen is well designed. Don't hesitate if you are thinking of buying one. Very iconic design too.
This comment might be the straw that breaks the bank's back. Thank you, I look forward to enjoying it 😀
I find this video heavily biased (Not in a good way). If you're going to put in an opinion, don't be so negative about every option you give. It's conflicting and confuses viewers. I find it irritating when you label your video as "Quality Pens", then proceed to call the first pen right off the bat "cheap-looking". If you don't like the pen, but recommend them to others, leave your opinion out.
Ykw😂
If you give something that costs more the guys: ITS THE BEST THING OUT THERE.
Something average: NOT MY TASTE.
Well, don't expect me to take these chunks in my classes. Need to scribble down lots. Lamy and twsbi does the job way better than anything.
At this point I doubt the credibility of any of their videos I've watched.
im a doctor and my prefered pen: Twisbi vac mini, a pen wif adequte reservoir to survive a 36 hour shift.
Back in my elementary school days (about 11 years ago) we actually got a fountain pen from school. Lasted up until 6th grade. Even now it still works great! If you take good care of your pen it can last you very very long.
U forget the platinum 3776..which is the best of the all
I bought one a few months back and I love it!
"best" is subjective
The pencil like scratchiness is pretty nice
@@alexchung736 that's called feedback
I love how smooth how the pilot custom 823/92/74 since they all share the same nib
The Carene not only runs dry, but its cap doesn't keep air out properly, and if you don't use it at least every other day, it'll dry up.
6:29 Lamy 2000's have a platinum-plated gold nib, not stainless steel.
Of the pens mentioned I own an 823 FA custom ground which has become one of my daily user pens together with a 70's 149 and a Visconti Wall Street LE.
About the Sailor 1911, you mentioned that it's a bit of a finer line. Of course it is. anybody that knows a bit of fountain pen knows that pens made by pilot, platinum and sailor are finer than the other ones. Basically, a medium from these companies is equivalent to a fine from other companies like Lamy, Faber Castell, Waterman, etc. And calling the Sailor 1911 a knock-off of the Montblanc is basically sating that all pen that have a cigar shape and a black option is a knock-off. That's a bit pretentious
I would love to see a companion video on men’s stationary and calling cards. Why have great fountain pens without the stationary to go with it. Writing is becoming a lost art and I would love to know more about the etiquette of calling cards, thank you notes and stationary for written correspondence. Thanks
My favorite brand is Faber Castell. In my younger days I used their Osmia 883. Today I use the Graf von Faber-Castell Guilloche Black Fountain Pen. Really nice. Thanks to GG. A nice channel. Give me so much fun 😂👍
What do you think of the better Caran d'ache fountain pens?
I have never owned a fountain pen but the idea appeals to me.
I think I like the sailor 1911.
do you think I should start my fountain pen journey there or something else?
thanks
If my experience is useful, and I think that of many others as well, you’ll be happier if you ease into it with under 100 or under 50 dollar pens. You’ll be able to get the hang of it, play around, and figure out what you like before dropping 200-300 bucks on a more expensive pen that might end up not liking. Also, a big part of the fun, and the writing experience, is the ink and the paper you use. You’ll have a blast with cheaper quality pens, ink samples, and a variety of paper. Then you can buy more expensive pens. Also, if you live in a city with a pen show, it’s worth going to one so you can see, touch, and write with the pricier pens.
dont buy the expensive ones yet. my advice. try first the china made jinhao x750 so you can familiarize yourself with how a fountain pen works, maintenance, and common pen issues.
you can find alot of videos for this.
when it comes to ink. buy first a dye based and or waterbased ink. and stay away from carbon based ink.
starter inks you should start to choose from: pilot namiki, parker ink, and lamy ink.
Thanks Guys I appreciate the advice.
The Platinum 3776 is very similar to the Sailor 1911 and can be had for around 60 on Amazon or Ebay if you buy it from a Japanese reseller. I find the construction more solid than that of the 1911 and the nib selection is quite nice. If you generally are a careful person, I would recommend spending around 100. If, on the contrary, you are clumsier than average, I would not recommend spending over 20.
In any case, a fountain pen doesn't do much for your handwriting unless you practice penmanship on your spare time. So I would advise starting your fountain pen journey by finding a book or two on that and practicing with any fountain pen. You can acquire amazing skill with a cheap and nasty supermarket-grade-fountain pen. Expensive pens mostly provide more comfort as materials are nicer to the touch and the pens are made more carefully. They also give you the opportunity to show-off even though nobody cares about your pens and to be more self-confident knowing you demonstrated your ability to spend money.
Another thing to remember if you buy a Japanese pen - most of the nibs are a grade finer than stated. Therefore if you like medium nibs go for a broad in if buying Japanese. A great starter pen is the Lamy Alstar. Its the same as a Safari but with an Aluminium body. Very good steel nib and tough as old boots. Also the triangular section (the bit you hold) makes for a very natural writing position.
I love fountain pens and use them regularly. Working in construction I wear a Pelikan Souverän M605 as my construction site note taking tool. Most guys consider me a bit strange for that, but who cares. I use it with Montblanc Document Blue ink, since this is 100% document prove, meaning the writing remains perfectly ok even if it gets wet. And yes, my notebook, lying around on construction sites regularly, does not look beautiful and gets scratched and dinged regularly.
This leads to the general problem with fountain pens, and the reason I cannot really recommend them. Like Raphael I am from Germany and in Germany you cannot use them for signatures. Because 99% of the available fountain pen ink is not document prove and if you sign a legally binding document, be it a business contract or any kind of official document like your tax declaration, it MUST be signed with a document prove pen. Since the person who looks at the signature cannot know if you used a document proved ink or not, he can - and quite often will - reject the document unless you can prove that you have used document ink in your pen.
I remember 20 years ago I was sitting in a lecture room during a written 3h test in mathematics when 15 minutes in the test the professor walked the lines and saw one guy using a fountain pen. He told him to get a ball pen or other document prove pen immediately and to first copy everything he had already written on new paper with the „correct“ pen first before he continues to work on the rest of the test.
So sadly pens like these are fine for writing a letter - which I do maybe once a year - or to take notes in your personal notebook - which many people today do on their tablets or computers, but it is not suitable for use on any official document.
Funny: On German schools up till the 13th grade - which is when you get your final school diploma that allows you to go to a college or university - the use of fountain pens and cursive writing is mandatory in most German states. Or at least was when I was in school until 1997.
This breaks the heart to have read this. I wish All schools would keep writing in.... tech is good but not for everything.....Im old enough to remember simply writing a letter to some one and mailing it off..... not its email......took the enjoyment out of the time put in to communicate with others.....
Correct me if I misinterpreted the basis of your story..... that's tough that you need actual proof that you signed with document proof ink..... would they do the same for a finger or stylus written signature from a tablet?..... Wouldn't it be best as to call to confirm you signed the document and it is being sent to them immediately?
I could argue this all day..... i'm not a lawyer, but believe me, i can go the distance.
As for the Lecture, Do I really need say more!?.... Ill be your attorney... for free... just let me do the talking.... or in this case Ill have a hand written document sent to them in either "Platinum carbon black, "Noodlers black, "D'atramentis document black.....theres more but I can think of them right now.......
Gold nibs are usually bouncier than steel ones, with exceptions, but they are not necessarily smoother. A Diplomat or Faber-Castell steel nib will be as smooth or smoother than any of the nibs in this video.
You also did not talk about a benefit of the vacuum filler system of the 823, which is the MUCH larger filling capacity, easily twice that of any other pen in the five spotlighted today.
Glad you spoke on the steel nibs... My pilot metropolitan ($23) is butter on glass smooth better than some of my gold nib pens.....
If you have normal sized hands and write a lot you’d defiantly prefer decimo over capless. More weight=hand fatigue.
Also, as others has pointed out, though the design may look similar, Sailor 1911 definitely isn’t a knockoff of MB.
Sailor prevails in nib grinding, no other major manufacture does the likes of Sailor’s togi 长刀研 nibs out of factory.
Also, MB 149 doesn’t guarantee a pleasant writing experience. It’s mostly the branding that gives you the pride of ownership. I prefer writing with my Lamy2000 and Platinum 3776 over my MB149 all day.
Imho, while fountain pens may be part of styling, you really should leave these more in-depth information videos to professionals like GouletPens. I find your videos a little biased.
I work a physical job, although it is on the inside of a retail store, (I stock merchandise), I wanted to know how fancy I could get without risking harm to the clothes I am wearing. (I do wear kneepads as to not damage my slacks/pants. (Do keep in mind that I bend, kneel, stoop down, and stretch many parts of the body often. Dress shoes I can wear everyday, walking all day without wearing out fast would be amazing)
it is always a delight to watch your videos, I like your elegant and kind style a lot! very instructive as well!
The vanishing points clip is actually something I like. It makes a nice place for my fingers to rest against when gripping the pen. Everyone has their own opinions I hope people take this video as one mans opinions for some of that stuff.
What Ive also discovered is: if your a "writer roller" [your hand tends to roll the pen as you write]; this will definately stop it from rolling in your hand.
bitter sweet of a pen but because it is what it designed for a quick note pen, not a memoir first draft pen, Ideal for students and doctors and other quick jot takers alike... (dont know why I put this in.... maybe b/c everyones STILL bashing the ink capacity)
(PLAYFULL RANT) WELL, GO BACK TO THE "BIC STIC" IF YOU WANNA WRITE ALOT!!!!! XD
Waterman Hemisphere is also decent. It's lightweight, great writer and has a sophisticated and elegant look.
As a pharmacist, I love using my vanishing point at work.
Cigar shape is a classic design for a fountain pen, sailor 1911 is not a copy cat. That's what Mont blanc wants you to believe so that they can charge 3 times more than sailor. If we go by their definition, every sedan car is a copy cat of Benz or BMW car.
I view writing as an essential part of life, life has changed because of writers. Getting a good pen early on in life is an investement. I will be making my first purchase soon & I'm still considering my options.
I like the looks and finish of Waterman Carene ! I’m neither an expert nor a collector, but I own Waterman Hemisphere Fountain and Roller pens and also entry level Sheaffer and Cross pens.
My everyday pen is a Lamy Studio that I put an italic nib on. It fits my hand well, is very classic looking in stainless and the italic nib is just blunt enough to make my handwriting look closer to calligraphy. My backup pen is also a Lamy Studio with a medium nib with a black body. The primary pen is filled with a reddish brown ink while I use dark blue ink in the backup pen. Some documents must be signed in blue, hence the ink choice for the backup pen. These pens do not fit into your video since they are well under $100 but I would not trade them for any other pen.
I COULDNT AGREE WITH YOU MORE! My pilot metropolitan is my main stay I will never leave My weekly rotation!
Im considering getting the waterman but i have a smaller hand, do you think it would still be ok for me?
What type of paper is that and where could I get some?
I own a Waterman Carène and honestly the nib writes as smoothly as any other pen can possibly write, almost no feedback.
I wonder if any the other topics this channel covers is as much of a hand grenade as "What is the best fountain pen?", particularly from a Montblanc cultist? I'd suggest a Sailor Professional Gear over a 1911 for a first step up, for example. It projects "classic" and "elegant", but has a more modern shape, so you can show your own style a bit. It just wouldn't make the GG grade because it doesn't look like a Montblanc.
Awesome video, personly I would choose a vintage pen such as a waterman ideal 54, a parker duofold or a parker 51.
Show off..... just kidding...... Great choices! Vintage is kind of grail to me... Make you not wanna write with them precious suckers....
@@mrpilotsapien7705 vintage can be had for cheap aswell, I got my parker 51 for 15 bucks, new breather tube and a clean and adjust and it wrote like new, sadly I sold it a few months ago.
Its not the cheapness and design of the pen its your personal pen that you can grow up with i started with jinhao but i suggest higher prices for those who likes expensive and elegant ones
1. Pilot Vanishing Point Raden
2. Namiki Emperor Maki-e
3. Sailor 1911 or Pro Gear King of Pen
Boom. Collection done. That' all you need in this lifetime.
Can't really argue with that. I would personally replace the Namiki Emperor with a urushi pen (maybe a decapod or something) from Platinum, just to complete the big 3 Japanese companies.
I own 3 sailor fountain pens, and they are great. I think they are a little bit small for most people. I recommend picking 1911L if you don't have kids size hand like me.
Love the green ink, what is it?
Recently I purchased my first real fountain pen fro Sailor, pro gear slim, from a collection in 21k gold nib, medium fine. I’m curious how long the ink will last and gain more experience with it. I hope one day to own Mont Blanc foundation pen with gold nib.
If it's a pro gear slim then it has a 14kt gold nib.
Also please don't aspire to own a MB because their pen manufacturing process has degraded MASSIVELY. They are now making the bodies via injection moulding and have sold their soul for success.
The sailors not only came before the Mont Blanc but are immensely better both in terms of value and in terms of writing experience, and please don't take my word for it. There are many people who are collectors who will attest to this. You can watch the nibsmith video of the Sailor KOP vs MB 149 and also numerous articles online before you arrive at your own conclusion.
@@adityavikramgupta1715 No, mine is 21k nib in MF.
@@TheBohemianStyle Progear SLIM? With the 21kt nib? Impossible. The regular size does have the 21kt, but the slim? 14 only
@@justindesrosiers3145 it was. But now, some special editions of pro gear slim have 21k nib with higher price.
Cool. I just ordered a mid range Maki-e fountain from japan. It's by a very indie Maki-e artist.
It has the iconic 'The Great Wave of Kanagawa'.
God bless, Proverbs 31
one word.... and I speak for all those in the know......JEALOUS!.....in a good way though....... Congrats!
cant afford any of these pens but still watched full video because i love how talk
A year ago I would have suggested to you the Jinhao 159 for $3 literraly right then and there! You could pass for a montblanc to the untrained eye....
I can say this cause I do it.... ppl love how It writes when I give my signature on documents (stub nib and color other than black and blue).....
Them: can you sign off on this sir?
Me: certainly
Them: Wow! nice lookin writing I like this color! And that pen is fancy!
Me: Would you like to write with it?
They try it........ Whoa: its heavy!!!!! Dont wanna break you expensive pen!!!!
XD
Get a pilot 91, 912 or a falcon. Or the 74 series instead of these. A fountainpen without flex is just an expensive ballpoint (specialty grinds excluded ofc)
As a fountain pen user I enjoyed the video very much. BUT please do not say " very unique". Unique is an adjective that is not quantifiable. It is either unique or not. Critique is left in a constructive vein. Thanks for the video and I will continue to watch your channel.
nonsense
What about Sheaffer or Aurora? The vintage Targa and Hastil for example are outstanding pieces, and hold value exceptionally well.
As of youre request I purchest a Fountan Pen.
I got it from a Lokal Woodworker, he uses Fountain Pen Banks and Turns the "Shell" (leck of better Word) out of a combination of Wood and colored Resin.
So i have an absolut unique Pice.
I realy have to Thank you, without you I wouldn't have taken a shot to Fountain Pens
Good choices for mid-range fountain pens. May I suggest a video on fountain pen inks? Other than the Waterman Carene, I have tried them all and the Sailor 1911 is my favorite. Other less known options are Franklin-Christoph and Edison, both of which write well and fall in this price range.
I second the Edison Pen Company suggestion. I think they're well-made and versatile. Mr. Schneider might take umbrage with the Herald model, though, and call it a "Montblanc knockoff."
He may love the brand, but I still consider Montblanc's prices ridiculous. I want something at a more affordable price-point.
Inks and papers would be taking us down a whole different rabbit hole. Which is where I am now. Send help.
We've added the idea to our list. Thanks for the suggestion!
- Preston
I would love a follow up to this for the $300-$600 range!
Fantastic color combination in this video, Sven-Raphael! Bravo!
Hello. I just got my pilot fountain pen yesterday. I prefer blue ink to black ink. Can I just switch to the blue after the black runs out. Or do I need to clean the pen first?
I just realized you started using sweater vests more often
One video on this channel discusses pens under $20. Now this one is for $100-300. Where’s the video showcasing pens between these vastly different price points??
Great job. Well done ❤
And here I am with a $25 Nemosine thinking I was mid-range, now I'm a peasant.
Which one? I like the Singularity.
Nice video, I like the paper and green ink you used. What are they?
That’s a nice green ink you are using. What is it?
I think so it's mont blanc Irish green.
After watching your videos and doing research, I started with a Pilot Metropolitan. I do want a Montblanc Meisterstuck 149 Platinum. And after watching this, I think that when I upgrade, I'll probably just upgrade up to that. But even the Pilot Metropolitan is so much better than the cheaper pens that I've used, so I'm looking forward to the Montblanc. :)
I find that I actually like writing by hand again. And as others have said, since I care about it again, my handwriting is getting better / back to what it used to be and I find myself finding excuses / reasons to write notes / letters by hand now.
you my friend have the Fountain pen Virus level one : finding any excuse to write.... well done! I commend you on this (a year later though i'm sure you're far along with the pleasure of a virus) writing Is Validly necessary eye to hand coordination versus the screen.... finger scroll finger scroll scroll tap tap finger scroll....
Where ever you are in your journey; in the words of Brian Goulet and the team: WRITE ON!
(NOTE: IM NOT AN EMPLOYEE THE CATCH PHRASE IS JUST BEFITTING TO PUT THERE)
I wouldn’t recommend the Mont Blanc though… A Sailor or even a Diplomat will write just as, if not smoother and better. Also the Metropolitain is fine on it’s own. No need to upgrade if there’s no need to
Superb video with very good information. Wish you Sir, A Merry Christmas and A Great New Year ahead. Cheers!!!
At 5:10, the pen in the background in the left screen is not a Meisterstück from Montblanc. It is a Sailor pen.
Correct, yes; the Montblanc is in the front, and the Sailor 1911 is in the back. You'll also see this shot at other points in the video. Thanks for watching!
- Preston
Don't know if it was mentioned before, but the Lamy 2000 is made of makrolon (specifically)
I am a fan of fountain pens since school times. Which fountain pen would you recommend me? I like light weight pens, and medium nibs. Thank you.
Pilot 823
Do you have a video on what are the best fountain pens for daily writing? I enjoy the feel of writing with it and am always interested in finding a high quality writing experience. Thank you!
Do you know of a top qual ink that is insoluble? You write with a fountain pen, ink dries, you spill water on it, ink runs. What ink do you recommend if any?
With all due respect I would like to tell you that the sailor 1911 is older than the montblanc meisterstuck series
Title should be “The best midrange pens that I’m not really a fan of”
There's just something about this guy's handwriting and the ink combination (Mont Blanc Irish green) that makes me feel like I wanna write. I really want a mont Blanc Irish green I have some pens that will look stunning with it
Love your videos.
That Waterman looks kind of like a Parker 51 and a Sheaffer PFM had a baby.
I'd choose Pilot E95S in burgundy color.
The Decimo is my daily carry. Pearl white with Rhodium plated trim.
I have a Medium 18k nib in mine and have a 1.0 stub nib coming.
My desk pen is a 1940s vintage Waterman's 515. 14k gold semi flex nib. Black and gold trim.
Made in England.
Literally any pen from the Custom or Custom Heritage lines from pilot > Any waterman IMO. Same with Platinum 3776 line and the Sailor 14 slim line as well as the 21k lines all out compete modern Waterman pens,
May I ask what is the ink you’re using?
I think he is using mont blanc Irish green.
Have you got a Platinum fountain pens (Japan)? If yes, what do you think about them? Thanks for your videos.
Great video! What do you think of a Parker Sonnet?
It's too small
Evan Loh I’ve only used the one with an 18k nib it was very pleasant.
@@adriantwiss600 I have the 18k nib as well and it write pretty well. "Well" is relative because I have yet to try high end pens like Mont Blanc.
@@MrBloopt Don't hold your breath - Mont Blancs are extremely well made and can be visually very lovely but in terms of writing performance they are not a quantum leap above many other quality pens. As I said in another comment its all down to the tuning. I have a 90 year old Wahl Eversharp Doric with a firm 14k nib that and a 40s Mabie Todd Swan that are both sublime writers.
What about Faber Castell or Cross? They have absolutely fabulous pens. I have been writing with fountain pens for years and tried many. I have never found anything as excellent as my Faber Castell with an extra fine nib, and my Century Cross with a fine nib.