Lily B Hae B- NinNing C+ Monday C+ Winter C Yunjin C Chisa D+ Sullyon D+ Kyujin D+ Miyeon D+ Liz D+ Juria D+ Giselle D+ Karina D (and there are more idols) In addition to the fact that the vocal range is not everything in the vocal, it is also the vocal technique)
@JulianaChong-ti9gd it's there job to dance and sing, but coachella is not about dance bro, and they should sing while dancing, but even in there encores? they are not dancing but their vocals us so freaking ugly
@@Chisahimada hanya disana,di berbagai acara dia bagus bagus saja(bahkan mujin memuji akan bakat dia akmu juga,sekelas penyanyi yang sama hebatnya memujinya dan kamu malah menghinanya?),bahkan saat dia live di weverse dan mengcover lagu lagu dia tetap bagus dia sering cover live bahkan kemarin dia melakukan nya dan vocal nya tetap sangat bagus,di encore dia hanya 2 yang tidak stabil dan bahkan hanya di lagu easy saja karna nada rendah selain di situ tetap dia bagus banget,sudah banyak bukti tidak perlu tutup mata,jangan hanya beberapa kesalahan kamu mengecap nya buruk dia juga manusia jangan dangkal
I'm an NSWER and Yunjin gets the edge because she supports her head voice and can support up to B4 in her mixed, yes Kyujin and Sullyoon have higher stamina, but neither of them have supported the head voice register
@@osamafaisal3716this video is a list of 4th gen idols. The ones you listed are mostly 3rd gen idols. Yes they are better vocalists but that’s not what this video is about
Chisa pulling out the stops with her solo performances of Never Enough, Born This Way, Halo, I'll Never Fall in Love Again, I Have Nothing, Toxic, If I Were a Boy, Keshia Cole's Love, she also sang Believe by Che'nelle in Japanese and sang Yoon Mirae's As Time Goes By in Korean. Nearly a different song for every city on the tour was mindblowing. Juria had a smaller set list but sang songs like Adelle's Hello, Jessie J's Thunder, Ella Mai's Trip, Without You, Utada's Flavor of Life in Japanese and Breathe by Park Hyo Shin in Korean. Fearless bocalists and just got better with every performace. Both should be top 5.
Please, stop thinking about vocal range as one and only criterion for the level of vocal skill. As professional vocalist and vocal teacher I'm so sad to see this mistake again and again. The only thing worse than this is “if a vocalist sings high notes, then she sings WELL”. Gosh... 1. Lily 2. Haewon 3. Ningning (up to this point everything was fine, but then errors started) 4. Sollyun 5. Monday from Weekly 6. Liz from Ive 7. Winter 8. Kyujin 9. Sieun from StayC 10. Miyeon from (G)-IDLE Yunjin good at ACADEMIC vocal. Her pop vocals technique is pretty weak, right now she's just average pop singer, as Hanni from New Jeans. BTW, I can't understand why Hybe didn't use her skills properly. And I'm not sure we can call XG "k-pop"... They are Japanese group.
Jika kamu menilainya hanya karna kesalahan nya kemarin maka itu sangat dangkal,selain di sana dia bagus bagus saja,lihat dia di acara live lain nya babe lee mujin contohnya acara yang sama dengan sullyoon yang di tayangkan
@@Stan_me-thi yes, like how can them all be good in vocal which the lowest is D, i know aespa is better but Nmixx got 6 members and that's crazy to have all of them as great vocalist ❤
To be honest 1 lily(nmixx)mid-high aa 2haewon(nmixx)low aa 3monday(weekly) low-mid a-aa 4ningning(aespa) low a-aa 5winter(aespa) high average 6yuri(soloist/ex izone) mid-high average 7Goeun(purple kiss) mid-high average 8jiwon(fromis-9) mid average 9 yunjin (lesserafim) low-mid average 10sullyoon(nmixx) high weak-average
@@ifoundtheimposter1652 nahhh she can't even support B3 hhhhhhh, and this is a public platform I comment whatever whenever I want, and going by your logic then no one asked for your useless input either 😂
@ifoundtheimposter1652 like my logic says I comment whatever whenever I want and I ain't the one who's bothered by your comment, I just normally commented YOU'RE the one that was bothered by my comment hhhhh
Correct but not correct. Both kariselle are equal atm. Giselle has less materials comparatively to Karina she could be better but as of now due to lack of materials, she is estimated equal to karina.
@@Celestial-c8z he's stronger than karina and kyujin, equal to chisa and juria ig. also bg vocalists are great, wonho from ateez, seungkwan and dk from seventeen, heeseung from enhypen, more..
Ummmm I think you missed 👇 Lia Yeji Chaeryeong Miyeon Liz Ahyeon Rami Anyone who 👍 Please 👍 And also blinks who are waiting for blackpink comeback like 👍
@@Han_orange Yunjin's highest note is significantly lower than Sullyoon's. I'm not a fan of either group-I'm simply an objective observer. Based on various performances, Yunjin's vocal abilities fall short in comparison to Sullyoon's. Watch every dice performance (even the MR removed ones) and look at Sullyoon's high note part. Now look at Yunjin's parts in basically every antifragile song (MR removed) and they still fall short. TLDR: You yappin cuh
@@kiimniyeon4561 Yes, she USED to be a better singer, her technique was not the best but opera singing is indeed very hard and something to admire, but she has had a vocal regression ever since she debuted on le sserafim, it's due to how their company manages them, they don't get proper vocal training so their vocals are slowly declining in technique...
Sullyoon really so good song and nice vocalist😢 Ningning so good alot in song vocalist ningning voice very cool so I don't shock put 3 first centers❤ this is fair for ningning I hope more for sullyoon😢
If you are talking about the best then you forgot to add Wendy and IU. Belle and Rami are just fifth gen and haven't shown us their full potential. The Wendy and IU are way more experienced and better vocalists than them.
If its best female vocalists in kpop- it would be 1. A member of big mama (dont rmbr the name) 2. Luna F(X) 3. Taeyeon SNSD (I may be wrong about taeyeon but luna for sure is the best female vocalist in kpop apart from a member of big mama)
Agree with this 🤭, maybe i consider a little: Minnie, Miyeon, Liz and Lia (they are the only ones in their groups who have a great vocal technique 😗) imo ✨#shoutingisnotsinging 😂
yes ok, she isn't the best at live singing, but she's an opera singer, if u have ears, u would hear her in that clip and tell that she's actually professional like fr-
@user-ul7mm4ru8k that's most definitely just a trick that sounds good to a wide public. After hearing her singing this awful live, I can't believe that her opera-style was legit. She couldn't even sing her own solo songs standing perfectly still with guitar. That's a shame. She's not an opera singer, she was just trained to be one at some point, but in no sense this education was finished.
@@ВасилийБлаженов-ж9еit's all marketing strategy, yunjin make mistakes all the time even when singing standing still in encore stage. Chaewon is better than her and make less pitch mistakes
They are all 5th generation and do you know that their best vocalist is rami which is a D tier vocalist and the weakest here is karina/ Giselle who are both D+ tier vocalists ak a they won't make it
Monday Weeekly Hana,chanelle Fifty-fifty Newjeans danielle,Hani Bessie lapillus Everglow Mia StayC sieun Kof Belle Lia and Yeji Itzy Liz Ive And manymore girly starting world war 4 huhu jwks Havent read the 4th gen thing so belle,hana and chanelle not included 😊
Lets be real all of the NMIXX girls and aespa girls should be here and Yunjin 100% doesnt belong here, not after she showed how poor her vocals are at Coachella
@kpop4lifer-i4v see Coachella was not her only bad performance... many of her Easy and Smart performances were not great either... her vocal abilities have been getting worse and worse and I think it's probably due to a lack of vocal training (idols still have to train once they debut, training never stops)... all of Le Sserafim need better vocal coaches because they are vocally the weakest group of 4th gen
@@ciaranjohnston7983 Wdym bad smart and easy performance? She's the only that sounds good there along with Chaewon 💀. Are you perhaps mistaking her voice Kazuha? The only part she doesn't sound good is the "victory" line for smart but other than that she sounds fine. And there's literally nothing wrong with easy performances, you're just blowing things off the roof.
@Vyro-g12 did you actually listen to Easy... I don't exactly fault the girls for that because that song is way too low for them, but a good singer should be able to a. extend their range and b. sound okay singing a bit outside their range so long as they are using proper techniques... also no way in hell am I going to let you gaslight me into thinking any of them were good singing Smart
@@ciaranjohnston7983 i don't even know much about singing but i ain't stupid enough to say that people should be able to sing out of their range, like wth are you stupid?
Idk if you can tell, but this is talking about FOURTH (4th) gen. Not 5th gen. Plus this is objective not subjective. And besides rami is NOT better than lily
Rami is weaker than ALL of aespa members hhhhhh, she's babymonster's best vocalist but she's just a D- tier vocalist while karina/Giselle are D+ tier vocalists also Ningning is B- tier vocalist you seriously put her under a D- tier vocalist 😂😂😂😂😂😂 hhhhh bfr
@@lemon3391its not just about support range. Eminem has a wider range than Whitney Houston but does that make him a better singer💀 there's other criterias like Dynamics, Agility, Technique sm more to consider than just support ranges
NOTE :
I DID NOT PUT ALL THE FOURTH GENERATION GROUPS, I PUT A SPECIFIC NUMBER OF THEM
I'VE PUT :
LE SSERAFIM
NEW JEANS
NMIXX
AESPA
GIDLE
ITZY
IVE
XG
-------
THE RANKING :
1. LILY (NMIXX)
2. HAEWON (NMIXX)
3. NINGNING (AESPA)
4. WINTER (AESPA)
5. YUNJIN (LESSERAFIM)
6. SULLYOON (NMIXX)
7. KYUJIN (NMIXX)
8. JURIA (XG)
9. CHISA (XG)
10. KARINA (AESPA)
-----
VOCAL RANGE
1. LILY (B)
2. HAEWON (-B)
3. NINGNING (C+)
4. WINTER (C/C+)
5. YUNJIN (C)
6. SULLYOON (-C)
7. KYUJIN (-C)
8. JURIA (D+)
9. CHISA (D+)
10. KARINA (D+)
Kyujin is D+
Miyeon???
Ningning C+/-B
Karina / Giselle D+/-C
Where's Giselle? She has a better vocal range then Karina.
@@nazokatakramova6284 ok we understood you are a my
Not Lily singing symphony no wayy😭
Also
Slaymixx mentioned 💅
ROMANIAN KPOP STAN? GIRL ME TOO
@Mary.wrixle_1 FINALLYYYYYY ANOTHER ROMANIAN KPOP STAN!!!!!!
XG its jpop
✨✨🐬🐬🌈🌈
Da baaa
kyujin is literally main dancer & lead rapper (same for karina) and she’s here, i’m so proud of my nmixx girls
frr!!
@@heartyi lead vocal too lol
@@yu_jennieafinskaya she's literally no sub position, all of her positions are lead and main
@@j.creamycoffe I know. Main dancer, lead raper, lead vocal
i will forver be an nwser i lve my girlies
LILY IS MY FAVORITE VOCALIST!!
I LOVE HER!!
1•Lily (B)
2•Haewon (B-)
3•NingNing (^C+/B-)
4•Monday (^C+/B-)
5•Winter (^C)
6•Yunjin (C)
7•Sullyoon (C-)
8•Kyujin (^D+/C-)
9•Giselle (^D+/C-)
10•Miyeon (^D+/C-)
What about XG??
I'm pretty sure giselle is still a solid D+
1. Nayeul (B+)
@@AsMaria-ix1ox haha she is tier B
Lily B
Hae B-
NinNing C+
Monday C+
Winter C
Yunjin C
Chisa D+
Sullyon D+
Kyujin D+
Miyeon D+
Liz D+
Juria D+
Giselle D+
Karina D
(and there are more idols)
In addition to the fact that the vocal range is not everything in the vocal, it is also the vocal technique)
Liz should be here
yes
I was looking for this comment
This
She's a D- tier vocalist when karina who's the lowest is D+ tier vocalist
Very debatable
Monday from Weeekly left the chat...
Admin only knows popular groups lmfao
Yes😢
😭
She can't support she's same level as those stayc girls
LILY SINGING SYMPHONY HELPP
bro forget about kepler main vocalist and purplekiss
omg yes purple kisss
Vocal doesn't depend on popularity
There're also another girls with the beautiful voices
Its not popularity, haewon and lily have a powerful voice
@@aeriwzzzthen where is liz, monday, chaehyun..?
@@morii4070Honestly, Liz strains to much and avoids belting
I think it's fair enough,XG is not popular than other groups but they are involved too
@@JayYang-k5q yunjin also strains a lot and it's still here and liz is great at belting
didn't you see yunjin coachella vocals? still kyujin and sullyoon are below her? are you serious?
Secara support range tier yunjin emang lebih,dia hanya kurang stabil di sana,lain dari sana dia bagus bagus saja
Yunjin c
Sullyoon d+/c-
Actually dancing step can make a people being not stable like unforgiven dance step
@JulianaChong-ti9gd it's there job to dance and sing, but coachella is not about dance bro, and they should sing while dancing, but even in there encores? they are not dancing but their vocals us so freaking ugly
@@Chisahimada hanya disana,di berbagai acara dia bagus bagus saja(bahkan mujin memuji akan bakat dia akmu juga,sekelas penyanyi yang sama hebatnya memujinya dan kamu malah menghinanya?),bahkan saat dia live di weverse dan mengcover lagu lagu dia tetap bagus dia sering cover live bahkan kemarin dia melakukan nya dan vocal nya tetap sangat bagus,di encore dia hanya 2 yang tidak stabil dan bahkan hanya di lagu easy saja karna nada rendah selain di situ tetap dia bagus banget,sudah banyak bukti tidak perlu tutup mata,jangan hanya beberapa kesalahan kamu mengecap nya buruk dia juga manusia jangan dangkal
I'm an NSWER and Yunjin gets the edge because she supports her head voice and can support up to B4 in her mixed, yes Kyujin and Sullyoon have higher stamina, but neither of them have supported the head voice register
I knew you are kidding when you put yunjin above sullyoon
her vocal tier is better and she can also do opera but i see your point
lmao yunjin C- and sullyon D+
@@monstiezžzzzzz never lmao, show me the note she supported
@@monstiezžzzzzzbruh ur saying that shes better than yeonjung, dawon, jihyo, seulgi, kei, hwasa, wheein, seunghee and more of high A or A-AA vocalists
@@osamafaisal3716this video is a list of 4th gen idols. The ones you listed are mostly 3rd gen idols. Yes they are better vocalists but that’s not what this video is about
Liz not being here is a crime
FRR!!!
Agree
Why Liz is D- in Vocal,And the ones there are D+~B
Obessed with Karina's voice >.
Slaymixx queens also liz from I've is pretty good
Not putting Yeji, Chaeryeong,Lia,Miyeon and Liz in here is crime
Miyeon should be here but the others you mentioned are weak
@@shwetapathak9274 Liz is not
@@gamerxarmymultistan Liz and Miyeon sorry
Itzy is not weak,their voices are miracle (no hate,imo)@@shwetapathak9274
@@shwetapathak9274 NO BUT LITERALLY EVERY ITZY BABIES ARE ALL ROUNDER 😭😭
I love Yunjin❤
Ningning is mind-blowing ❤
Girl ok everything i can accept kyujin being lower than yunjin but sullyoon is defo better than yunjin!!
She's defo not. Yunjin is C but sullyoon is D+
@@SkzgidleYunjin is low-mid A. C-/C
@osamafaisal3716 think she's solid C now
@@Skzgidle solid mid A? kinda accurate
@@osamafaisal3716 didn't she improve to C??
Chisa pulling out the stops with her solo performances of Never Enough, Born This Way, Halo, I'll Never Fall in Love Again, I Have Nothing, Toxic, If I Were a Boy, Keshia Cole's Love, she also sang Believe by Che'nelle in Japanese and sang Yoon Mirae's As Time Goes By in Korean. Nearly a different song for every city on the tour was mindblowing. Juria had a smaller set list but sang songs like Adelle's Hello, Jessie J's Thunder, Ella Mai's Trip, Without You, Utada's Flavor of Life in Japanese and Breathe by Park Hyo Shin in Korean. Fearless bocalists and just got better with every performace. Both should be top 5.
Aespa vocalists are amazing❤❤❤winter&ningning
Lily : 🐬🐬🐬🐬🌊🌊🌊🌊✨️✨️✨️✨️🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭
Lilyyyyy❤❤❤❤
Please, stop thinking about vocal range as one and only criterion for the level of vocal skill. As professional vocalist and vocal teacher I'm so sad to see this mistake again and again. The only thing worse than this is “if a vocalist sings high notes, then she sings WELL”. Gosh...
1. Lily
2. Haewon
3. Ningning
(up to this point everything was fine, but then errors started)
4. Sollyun
5. Monday from Weekly
6. Liz from Ive
7. Winter
8. Kyujin
9. Sieun from StayC
10. Miyeon from (G)-IDLE
Yunjin good at ACADEMIC vocal. Her pop vocals technique is pretty weak, right now she's just average pop singer, as Hanni from New Jeans. BTW, I can't understand why Hybe didn't use her skills properly.
And I'm not sure we can call XG "k-pop"... They are Japanese group.
Jika kamu menilainya hanya karna kesalahan nya kemarin maka itu sangat dangkal,selain di sana dia bagus bagus saja,lihat dia di acara live lain nya babe lee mujin contohnya acara yang sama dengan sullyoon yang di tayangkan
what about pink fantasy yechan?
@@CerealBoxiee she's an amazing vocalist, unfortunately people don't pay much attention to nugu groups no matter how talented they are :/
Karina is much better than Sieun though, are you only counting vocal line.??
@@heartyiwe cant just rank vocal solely by vocal support, sieun has better technique than karina
4 nmixx members ❤
I say all of them are damn good vocalists
@@Stan_me-thireall
@@Stan_me-thi yes, like how can them all be good in vocal which the lowest is D, i know aespa is better but Nmixx got 6 members and that's crazy to have all of them as great vocalist ❤
1.Ningning karina winter windey lily haewon sullyoon
Nmixx is the dark souls of 4th gen.
To be honest
1 lily(nmixx)mid-high aa
2haewon(nmixx)low aa
3monday(weekly) low-mid a-aa
4ningning(aespa) low a-aa
5winter(aespa) high average
6yuri(soloist/ex izone) mid-high average
7Goeun(purple kiss) mid-high average
8jiwon(fromis-9) mid average
9 yunjin (lesserafim) low-mid average
10sullyoon(nmixx) high weak-average
Wjsn debuted in 2016, so they're 3rd gen
@Jyyzzzzz oh that's right , my apologise
Finally right ranking
Ligthsum's Chowon can be in the list too
@ZhouKyulkyung07 oh! Yes i love her tone if i do like top 20 she will be in the list
Ive Liz ,yujin and lesserafim chaewon❤
Chaewonn Le sserafimmm is number one for mee
Liz is so underrated!
She's a D- tier vocalist
@eulalia3468 D/D+, and I don't remember asking?
@@ifoundtheimposter1652 nahhh she can't even support B3 hhhhhhh, and this is a public platform I comment whatever whenever I want, and going by your logic then no one asked for your useless input either 😂
@eulalia3468 exactly if you didn't ask then why did you reply under my comment and going by your logic "I can comment whatever I want"
@ifoundtheimposter1652 like my logic says I comment whatever whenever I want and I ain't the one who's bothered by your comment, I just normally commented YOU'RE the one that was bothered by my comment hhhhh
Top 10 4th gen. Vocalist ❎ Aespa V/s Nmixx compared ✅
Rami is the best❤❤
rami isn't 4th gen she's fifth
She is not the best. Sorry to break it to u
@@NagiReoBL she isn't the best imo but she's really good
@@whyyoucryingx I love Rami too. People are starting to overrate her which is sad to me. She has great potential
@@NagiReoBLit's just your opinion
I heard chisa's vocal first time and I don't even know her😅 and her vocal is so good❤❤
And I knew who would be in top 😅
Omg Nmixx queens❤
purple kiss and kep1er: 🧍
FR
Both weak
@@eulalia3468 LMAO, thats a BIG lie.
@@hiyyihteamo go see their vocals rank and support they are not good
@@eulalia3468 I do, they are literally one of the best vocals groups of 4th gen. Maybe not the first one but pretty better than some idols here.
Giselle is better than Karina in terms of vocals. It's just that she doesn't get vocal parts
don't agree
@lulouise549 it's your opinion but what I said is a fact
@@notyourfollower Wow, the most arrogant egomaniac I've ever met. Your opinion is the truth? I don't know what to say except sigh
finally someone wise!!!
Correct but not correct. Both kariselle are equal atm. Giselle has less materials comparatively to Karina she could be better but as of now due to lack of materials, she is estimated equal to karina.
probably
1. Lily NMIXX
2. Goeun Purple Kiss
3. Haewon NMIXX
4. Monday Weeekly
5. Ningning aespa
6. Chaehyun Kep1er
7. Winter aespa
8. Yunjin Lesserafim
9. Sullyoon Nmixx
10. Kyujin Nmixx
purki mentioned!
Giselle and Karina are both in the same place while Giselle is a bit better and and Chisa is above Juria
Giselle is so underrated 😢
Giselle ain’t better than Karina..
@@Faisa_123 she is
@@Chisahimadashe has a pretty vocal tone but range wise karina is better.
Karina is above kyujin
Her lows agility belts
Are better than her
And in lows
And Gisele support head voice upto
C#5
nmixx ateee
Seungmin left the chat!
He’s my favourite!❤️🔥
isn't it obvious that this is girl groups only
@@divevilleno its not..
yes it is, you don't see any men, do you?@H.H84
Boy groups eitherways in vocals arent that strong in 4th gen. Seungmin is weaker than all those in the video.
@@Celestial-c8z he's stronger than karina and kyujin, equal to chisa and juria ig. also bg vocalists are great, wonho from ateez, seungkwan and dk from seventeen, heeseung from enhypen, more..
4th gen is my fav gen in kpop.!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
But, XG isn't even kpop...
it never said kpop, it just said top 10 vocalist
But he mentions that he is from the fourth generation. What would XG be like from the fourth generation without being K-pop? 🤔
@@mamamoofrvr so she might as well add vocalists like ariana grande or Adelle?
What's the name if the song that haewon was singing?
halo - beyoncé
Sullyoon kyujin above yunjin
From the rate yunjin is c and kyujin is d+/c- and sulyoon c-
@@ahmadalbhikarsyabriant8938sullyoon and Kyujin are too shallow to be a C-
Ummmm I think you missed 👇
Lia
Yeji
Chaeryeong
Miyeon
Liz
Ahyeon
Rami
Anyone who 👍
Please 👍
And also blinks who are waiting for blackpink comeback like 👍
Maybe Miyeon and Rami but babymonster is 5th gen and Itzy are too weak to be in the top 10
KOL is gen4th
Baemon is gen5th
Itzy is gen4th
not adding jongho here is a crime
i was surprised too then i realised this is ggs only lmaooo
You can name the song that Kyujin sang? Please
no hate but kyujin should be placed higher than yunjin
Babymonster ruka man her high notes and rami and aheyon 2❤
yh Rika is so underrated and actually very good
Stupid
Monday? Chaehyun ? Sihyeon ?
that’s wrong
1. Nayul B+
2. Lily B-
4. Haewon B-
5. Yechan B-
6. Minseo C+
7. Swan C+
8. Monday C+
9. Ningning C+
10. Sio C
Putting yunjin before sullyoon is a crime ☠️☠️😂😂✨🔥
because she is
You don't even know anything sullyoon is C- and yunjin is C
@@Han_orange Yunjin's highest note is significantly lower than Sullyoon's. I'm not a fan of either group-I'm simply an objective observer. Based on various performances, Yunjin's vocal abilities fall short in comparison to Sullyoon's. Watch every dice performance (even the MR removed ones) and look at Sullyoon's high note part. Now look at Yunjin's parts in basically every antifragile song (MR removed) and they still fall short.
TLDR: You yappin cuh
Technically speaking Yunjin is
Better singer as she have many techniques especially Opera singing
@@kiimniyeon4561 Yes, she USED to be a better singer, her technique was not the best but opera singing is indeed very hard and something to admire, but she has had a vocal regression ever since she debuted on le sserafim, it's due to how their company manages them, they don't get proper vocal training so their vocals are slowly declining in technique...
Sullyoon really so good song and nice vocalist😢
Ningning so good alot in song vocalist ningning voice very cool so I don't shock put 3 first centers❤ this is fair for ningning I hope more for sullyoon😢
Best female Vocalist:
1. Lily
2. Belle
3. Rami
Rami and Belle is not 4th gen! This video about 4th gen 🙂
More like ur favourite female vocalists
@District_911 it's ok I'm talking about best female Vocalist.
If you are talking about the best then you forgot to add Wendy and IU. Belle and Rami are just fifth gen and haven't shown us their full potential. The Wendy and IU are way more experienced and better vocalists than them.
If its best female vocalists in kpop- it would be
1. A member of big mama (dont rmbr the name)
2. Luna F(X)
3. Taeyeon SNSD
(I may be wrong about taeyeon but luna for sure is the best female vocalist in kpop apart from a member of big mama)
Ive, æspa and nmixx on top
Ive???? Their best vocalist is a D- tier vocalist when karina/Giselle are a D+ tier vocalists hhhhhhhh
My girl Monday should be there 😔
YOU FORGOT YUJIN FROM IVE
Ive liz
She's a D- tier vocalist
@eulalia3468 don't hate she
@@Bangtan57 don't hate her she's my fav ive member
Karina is better than Kyujin 🤦♀️ D+ >> D
Cho Miyeon & Monday😭
Agree with this 🤭, maybe i consider a little: Minnie, Miyeon, Liz and Lia (they are the only ones in their groups who have a great vocal technique 😗) imo ✨#shoutingisnotsinging 😂
Not good enough technically
@Chloé-x5v 7/10
@@Ryuqueen417 what ?
@@Chloé-x5v they are 7/10
@ based on what scale ? What’s 10 ?
Nmixx>>>
I feel that groups like nmixx with amazing vocalist are not quite known
goeun and swan from purplekiss left the chat
finally someone said it
karina’s vocal is.. 😍😍
What about kep1er?
Yes chayeun its good
@@ahmadalbhikarsyabriant8938 yeah she is C
I JUST WANNA BE PART OF YOUR SYMPHONY LOL LILLY
liz? yujin? and yunjin above sully so funny 🤣
Yunjin has better technique she's a C
Ningning vokal 🤭
Yunjin 😂
yes ok, she isn't the best at live singing, but she's an opera singer, if u have ears, u would hear her in that clip and tell that she's actually professional like fr-
@user-ul7mm4ru8k that's most definitely just a trick that sounds good to a wide public. After hearing her singing this awful live, I can't believe that her opera-style was legit. She couldn't even sing her own solo songs standing perfectly still with guitar. That's a shame.
She's not an opera singer, she was just trained to be one at some point, but in no sense this education was finished.
@@ВасилийБлаженов-ж9еit's all marketing strategy, yunjin make mistakes all the time even when singing standing still in encore stage. Chaewon is better than her and make less pitch mistakes
@@AshleyKo-y6freal
Lily>Haewon>>Ningning＞Winter>>Yunjin ＞>Sullyoon
rora babymonster rami babymonster ahyone babymonster pharita babymonstre chiquita babymonster ❤❤❤❤
gen4th
They are form gen 5th
They're 5th gen
They're 5th gen andd u forgot Ruka and Asa
They are all 5th generation and do you know that their best vocalist is rami which is a D tier vocalist and the weakest here is karina/ Giselle who are both D+ tier vocalists ak a they won't make it
Is Ayoen from babymon in the fourth generation
She is not even the second or third vocalist from her group.
Babymon is fifth gen
Monday Weeekly
Hana,chanelle Fifty-fifty
Newjeans danielle,Hani
Bessie lapillus
Everglow Mia
StayC sieun
Kof Belle
Lia and Yeji Itzy
Liz Ive
And manymore girly starting world war 4 huhu jwks
Havent read the 4th gen thing so belle,hana and chanelle not included 😊
Belle is from 5th gen and dani & hanni aren’t in top 10 best vocalists in 4th gen yeji & lia aren’t in top 10 either
Kiof Belle from 5th gen
You mean her top 10?@@FatlindaMetaj
@@kiimniyeon4561 what???
Everyone you mentioned here except monday and belle are weaker than the top 10 in the ops video too (their video is incorrect but yours is even worse)
Lily ❤
Lets be real all of the NMIXX girls and aespa girls should be here and Yunjin 100% doesnt belong here, not after she showed how poor her vocals are at Coachella
Just bcs YUNJIN had one bad performance u think she a bad vocalist like wtf check her solo performances, show singing, produce48 vids
@kpop4lifer-i4v see Coachella was not her only bad performance... many of her Easy and Smart performances were not great either... her vocal abilities have been getting worse and worse and I think it's probably due to a lack of vocal training (idols still have to train once they debut, training never stops)... all of Le Sserafim need better vocal coaches because they are vocally the weakest group of 4th gen
@@ciaranjohnston7983 Wdym bad smart and easy performance? She's the only that sounds good there along with Chaewon 💀. Are you perhaps mistaking her voice Kazuha? The only part she doesn't sound good is the "victory" line for smart but other than that she sounds fine. And there's literally nothing wrong with easy performances, you're just blowing things off the roof.
@Vyro-g12 did you actually listen to Easy... I don't exactly fault the girls for that because that song is way too low for them, but a good singer should be able to a. extend their range and b. sound okay singing a bit outside their range so long as they are using proper techniques... also no way in hell am I going to let you gaslight me into thinking any of them were good singing Smart
@@ciaranjohnston7983 i don't even know much about singing but i ain't stupid enough to say that people should be able to sing out of their range, like wth are you stupid?
I'm happy that you mentioned xg❤❤❤❤
1 Rose Black pink
2 rami Baby monster
3 rora Baby monster
4 Ahyeon Baby monster
5 Nayeon TWice
6 myeon g dle
7 jisso Black pink
8 karina aespa
9 winter aespa
10 yunji le serafim
Blackpink and Twice are 3rd gen.
Babymonster is 5th gen
nmixx y aespa es puro talento
Xg isn’t a kpop group :) they’re a jpop group promoting in Korea
it never said kpop, it just said top 10 vocalist
@@mamamoofrvr they’re obviously talking abt K-pop or a lot of the idols on here wouldn’t be here. It also says 4th gen, a kpop term..
@@Flwrtzu they talk about 4th gen not kpop bro
XG is not jpop group they're a Global Group
Aemixx ate
Nmixx and Aespa slaying really in vocals but where is Giselle her vocals are better than Karina‘s Karina is D+ while Giselle is C-
4th gen❌jyp, sm and hybe🤡✅
Guys xg not a kpop group pls
Rosè 😎😎
rosé is 3rd gen
Still Won't make it here
Xg - not kpop..
In my opinion
1.rami babymonster
2.ningning aespa
3.lily nmixx
4.belle kiof
5.winter aespa
6.rose blackpink
7.chiquita babymonster
8.rora babymonster
9.ahyeon babymonster
10.pharita babymonster
Idk if you can tell, but this is talking about FOURTH (4th) gen. Not 5th gen. Plus this is objective not subjective. And besides rami is NOT better than lily
@@thesanestan Youre right
Rami is weaker than ALL of aespa members hhhhhh, she's babymonster's best vocalist but she's just a D- tier vocalist while karina/Giselle are D+ tier vocalists also Ningning is B- tier vocalist you seriously put her under a D- tier vocalist 😂😂😂😂😂😂 hhhhh bfr
No way yunjin 5
you meant top 10 vocalist in th e4th gen female category right?
cus i was fr waiting for heeseung to pop up..
anyways can u do a bg version too?
Even chaewon
No one can beat ROSÉ 😎😏
Wendy, Solar, Bada, Luna, Tayeon? Lmao blonks are so biased
It's 4th gen and Rosé isn't a God to beat red velvet has better vocals than blackpink
@@Ayu_coreOh really 😝
@@Blink_Army-h2s yes
Bruh placing Chisa and Juria below Kyujing, Sullyoon and Yujin was a crime
Right, chisa supported D5
Is there a boy group version?
- Giselle better Karina
- Kyujin, Sullyoon, Bae, Jiwoo better Than Yunjin
@@Mr.Hervans yes and momo from twice is better than wendy in vocals
Help no💀
@@osamafaisal3716lmao real😭
@@MIDZYwhoONCEfoundanNSWER4KISSY and they are trying so hard to make is as a “fact”
while no one is the same fr
Bae and hanni not being here is a crime
I mean, if you put (G)I-DLE and IVE in the ranking, Miyeon and Liz should be in top 10 😭
Nope
Both are around high weak
@@lemon3391its not just about support range. Eminem has a wider range than Whitney Houston but does that make him a better singer💀 there's other criterias like Dynamics, Agility, Technique sm more to consider than just support ranges
@@jinsoulsfriedhair5067it's not that, they both aren't better than karina.
@@CoconasbaldshinyluminousheadLiz no. Miyeon is definitely better than Karina.
Lily best ❤❤❤❤
Sullyoon is D+ and kyujin is D+ or D and karina is better than her
I'm not sure about kyujin but sullyoon is a solid C-
@@rubyjaneluvbot no
@rubyjaneluvbot yes
@@rubyjaneluvbotno they’re too shallow
Chisa being the best vocalist of XG.....and this has been proven several times, so she is in 8th place